Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
Index

The Investigation

General

39. Immediately the recovery operations had been completed, H.M. Inspectors of Mines and Quarries, accompanied by representatives of management and workmen, carried out a preliminary inspection of the greater part of the mine, including the explosion area. Shortly afterwards, H.M. Inspectors and scientists of the Safety in Mines Research Establishment (S.M.R.E.) made another inspection of the explosion area only. Neither inspection revealed any obvious point of ignition, igniting agent, or source of the firedamp. Thereupon H.M. Inspectors and scientists, with every possible assistance from the representatives of the interested parties, commenced an extremely detailed investigation, which lasted two months.

The Extent of Flame and Blast

The intake gate

40. Specimens of fibrous material collected in the intake gate were examined microscopically and did not show signs of having been subjected to heat. Although there was a thin layer of explosion dust on the gate conveyor, the dry stone dust on the barriers had not been disturbed.

The face and the stables

41. There were no signs of burning in the intake gate stable, but microscopic examination of specimens collected at points along the face indicated that flame had travelled down the face to within about 30 yards of that stable. On much of that part of the face affected by flame, there were unmistakable signs of coking on the intake sides of the props, an indication that flame had come from the return side. Detonator leads coming from charged shotholes in the return gate stable showed obvious signs of having been exposed to heat. There was little or no sign of violence in either of the stables or on the first 20 yards of the face from the intake; but farther along the face there were signs of some violence, although roof supports had not been disturbed.

The return gate

42. Microscopic examination of fibrous specimens collected from an area between the face ripping and a point 550 yards outbye showed obvious signs of exposure to flame. Beyond this point to the junction with No. 5 District return, specimens had been subject to some heat but had not been carbonised. There were signs of blast near the ripping, but evidence as to direction in this area was not positive. In the length of gate between points 28 yards and 180 yards outbye of the ripping, there were unmistakable signs of blast in the direction of the face. Outbye of this area, although there were a number of small roof cavities and the floor was strewn with fallen stone, backing boards and other debris, there were no indications of blast up to a point about 280 yards from the ripping. There an electric section switch had been moved outbye, presumably by blast. In the next 40 yards of roadway, the damage from blast was the most severe in the whole of the affected area. In this length, a number of badly damaged tubs and bogies were found derailed and smashed near the return wheel of the endless rope haulage. The wheel, the carrying frame and the arch girder supporting it had all been displaced in an outbye direction, but there was no sign of abrasion on the return wheel or its framework. Plates I and II show the damage in this area. For a further 200 yards outbye, signs of damage were much less in evidence, but there had evidently been strong blast some 650 yards from the ripping where a tank had been displaced. From there to the junction with No. 5 District return there were signs of only slight blast.

Summary

43. Nowhere in the area was there any indication of a slow burning of a rich firedamp/air mixture. The results of the examination suggest that blast had affected, in varying degree, nearly 1,000 yards of face and roadway, of which 680 yards had been exposed to flame. These indications are shown graphically on Plan No. 3.

Ventilation

44. Ventilation measurements made shortly after the explosion indicated that the quantity of air leaving the district varied from 14,200 to 15,000 cubic feet per minute. The firedamp content of this air, as measured by a methanometer, was between 0.6 and 0.8 per cent. The colliery records show that before the explosion the quantity of air passing was higher and the percentage of firedamp lower, but the actual make of firedamp was about the same. Excluding that being drawn off by the drainage system, this was about 100 cubic feet per minute.

45. Discarded firedamp drainage holes were sometimes sealed by the insertion of wooden plugs but some had been left unsealed. Six of the unsealed holes in a length of from 321 to 709 yards from the face ripping, were examined for firedamp issuing from them. By using a methanometer and probe, firedamp was found in five of these holes but only one, at 472 yards from the ripping, gave any indication of continuing flow. This was small in quantity but up to 30 per cent. was detected at the mouth of the hole. Relatively high concentrations of firedamp were found in a number of small cavities in the roof of the return gate, but it was estimated that the total volume of pure firedamp in these cavities could not have been more than 50 cubic feet.

46. On 24th March, one of H.M. Inspectors made a ventilation survey in the return gate stable without a brattice sheet in position. By using artificially produced vapour clouds as a tracer medium, he found that only a small proportion of the air leaving the face entered the stable. Here there was very marked recirculation. Using a methanometer with a probe attachment, the inspector found high concentrations of firedamp at a number of points between the roof and the top of the fallen coal, but the total quantity involved was very small. On the same occasion, the inspector, using the same equipment, made determinations of the firedamp content of air in the waste, some of them from points 7 to 8 feet above the seam roof level. In no case was the concentration higher than that in the general body of the air on the face.

47. Although the quantity of air leaving the district immediately after the explosion was found to be substantially less than that recorded from the last statutory measurements made before the explosion, later measurements showed that the quantity had increased to between 16,000 to 17,000 cubic feet per minute, with a firedamp content of 0.4 per cent.

48. Because of the frequency with which men and materials were known to pass through the doors at the Cut-back, and men through the doors at James Bradley's Junction, it was decided to measure the effect of opening these doors on the ventilation of the district. Two tests were carried out, one with the doors at James Bradley's Junction fully open, and the other with the doors at the Cut-back partially open. In the first test, the normal quantity of air reaching the face was reduced by 6,000 cubic feet per minute and, in the second, by 5,000 cubic feet per minute.

Explosives

49. In the course of the investigation, two hessian sacks were found, each containing the same type of Eq.S. explosive in cartridge form. One, near the intake gate ripping, contained 12 pounds and the other, near the return gate ripping, 56 pounds.

50. Along the first 14 yards of the face from the intake gate stable, 10 shotholes had been drilled in the bottom coal. Nine of these had been charged and stemmed, and a single-shot exploder with connected cable was lying between the ninth and tenth holes.

51. In the return gate stable, seven shotholes had been drilled and six of them charged and stemmed. The charged shotholes were disposed in two groups, two near the ribside and four to the left side of the stable. In the short length between the two groups there was a heap of broken coal lying against the face. It was clear from the evidence in the roof and face that at least two shots had been fired in this vicinity. Of the group of four shotholes, the one immediately next to the broken coal and about 12 feet from the face buttock invited particular attention. It was observed that the coal on the loose side of this hole was fractured by innumerable fine cracks. When this coal was removed by hand, a plug of stemming at the front of the hole and three cartridges of Eq.S. explosive were revealed. The latter were impacted together as though they had been subjected to pressure from the back of the hole, and the inner end of the last cartridge was covered by a coating of coal dust 1/8 of an inch thick. The shothole was subsequently found to extend about 12 inches beyond the last cartridge, but this section was empty. A primer cartridge was not found and there was no evidence to suggest that the shot had blown out laterally. Two detonator wires were found in the hole; one reached only as far as the stemming, but the other extended to the inner end of the recovered part of the charge. Nothing unusual was observed in the condition of the remaining five charged holes and they were subsequently fired without incident under the supervision of H.M. Inspectors.

52. A shotfiring cable, without detonator leads attached, extended from the face side of the conveyor, over a roof bar, under the return gate ripping, on to the ripping debris, where the remainder was tied in a hank with one of the leads connected to a single-shot exploder. A shotfiring exploder key was later found in the clothing of Halstead, the shotfirer, whose body was recovered from nearby.

53. A case, subsequently found to contain 31 detonators, was also found in Halstead's clothing. Some of these, with others taken from the colliery magazine, 25 in all, were sent to the Armament Research and Development Establishment, Woolwich, for X-ray examination and test. They were found to be normal in all respects.

54. Explosive from the pit and from the colliery magazine, when tested for behaviour and composition, proved to be normal. Tests for sensitivity to initiation of detonation on some of the explosive referred to in paragraph 51 showed that it had not deteriorated.

Safety Lamps

55. The five flame safety lamps and 53 electric cap lamps (some incomplete) recovered from the district, were sent to S.M.R.E. for test. The flame lamps and 28 of the electric cap lamps were found to be in approved condition, securely locked and in working order. The remainder of the electric cap lamps had each sustained some damage but this was considered to have been caused by the explosion.

Contraband

56. Smoking materials were not found either during the underground investigation or when the effects of the victims were examined on the surface.

Road Dust Samples

57. After the explosion, samples of roadway dust were collected from the roof, sides and floor at six places in the intake gate and 13 in the return gate. Analysis showed that, of the samples taken from the roof and sides in the intake gate, all contained from 80 to 98 per cent, incombustible material, with the exception of one, taken near the face ripping, which contained 59 per cent. The floor samples from the intake gate contained 62 to 97 per cent. incombustible material, except one, again taken near the face ripping, which contained 43 per cent. The samples from the roof and sides in the return gate varied from 69 to 86 per cent, incombustible material and those from the floor 62 to 95 per cent.

Electrical Apparatus

58. H.M. Electrical Inspector made a visual examination in situ of all the electrical apparatus in the district. As this failed to reveal any electrical defect, he had certain of the apparatus removed from the mine for more detailed examination and test. At the surface, the main supply cable and joint boxes were subjected to high voltage insulation tests; the joint boxes were also stripped, but no defects were found. The main switchgear and other items of electrical equipment were examined at the S.M.R.E. but there was no evidence of heavy arcing from electrical fault within any of the enclosures. A section switch, five gate-end panels and a drilling machine were twice subjected to the standard flameproof test and proved to be in safe working order.

59. The S.M.R.E. also tested, for intrinsic safety, a signalling transformer, six signalling bells and one magneto telephone, all of which conformed to their approval specifications. Two single-shot exploders, although showing signs of long use, were proved to be in good condition and their shotfiring efficiency unimpaired; they also satisfied intrinsic safety tests. Two twin core, plastic covered tinned copper wire cables, associated in use with the exploders, were found to be in good condition.

Mechanical Apparatus

60. H.M. Inspector of Mechanical Engineering examined all mechanical apparatus in the district. He paid particular attention to the return end drive of the face conveyor but found nothing to suggest that frictional heating had occurred. During his examination of the direct rope haulage system in the return gate, the inspector observed that the rope had been run out to within 35 yards of the endless haulage return wheel. The rope was attached to the first link of a three-link chain. A second length of rope some 50 feet long was threaded through the last link of the chain, tied with two half hitches which appeared to have been subjected to strain, and laid out along the road as an extension of the first rope. At the outbye end of the extension rope was a capel not completely fixed. The only vehicles seen in the return gate were damaged tubs and bogies near the return wheel.

Frictional Heat

61. The Union Seam contains intrusions of rock roughly spherical in shape, in which there are inclusions of iron pyrites, sometimes associated with quartz. They are known locally as 'bobbers' and ignitions of firedamp in the undercut at the colliery have been attributed to coal cutter picks striking them. Because of this, a number of those found cast aside in the return gate were subjected by S.M.R.E. to rubbing and impact tests in an atmosphere containing 7 per cent. of methane, but no ignition occurred. The shale overlying the seam was recognised as being too soft to produce incendive sparking.

62. Because it was known that smears left by contact of aluminium alloys with rusty steel could, from subsequent blows, produce a thermite type reaction giving rise to a flash capable of igniting firedamp, S.M.R.E. tested a portable electric drilling machine and a fire hose nozzle both made from light alloy, and recovered from the return gate near the face. It was found that, while both items were capable of producing dangerous smears, there was no evidence that they had in fact done so. A search was made for such smears in the return gate but none was found.

63. In a length of the return gate from 192 to 307 yards outbye of the ripping, 18 metal foil wrappings of a type used for confectionery and chewing tobacco were found. Nearly all the specimens were damaged by what appeared to be normal usage but two had holes, the edges of which, when examined microscopically, were found to be thin and torn, with the appearance of having been fused (see Plate III). When pieces from each of the specimens were submitted to glancing blows with the foil resting on rusty steel in an explosive firedamp/air mixture, ignitions were obtained with all but two of the specimens, one of which was too small to handle (see Plate IV). These foil wrappings, which are generally of aluminium, usually have paper backing, sometimes waxed; where this backing was retained ignition could not be obtained.

64. The two specimens which had signs of fusion when picked up, were found at points 302 yards and 307 yards, respectively, from the return gate ripping. The signs of fusion on these specimens were very similar to the signs on the pieces of foil which had given incendive flashes when tested.

Strata Control

65. Strata control in the district was good and none of the features observed before or after the explosion was indicative of unusual roof movement. The roof breaks observed at the face by the afternoon and night shift deputies were not accompanied by marked displacement, and were not unusual. The deputies described the wastes as behaving normally. Both intake and return gate rippings contained some bed separation, but firedamp was not found to be coming from these points after the explosion. The small cavities in both gates were attributed either to normal deterioration of the backing boards before the explosion or, in the case of the return gate, to explosion violence.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page


mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z