X. — Recommendations
(51) Because of the scarcity of concrete evidence I must again emphasise that my findings are largely a matter of opinion. In this particular case due regard was paid to many of the following recommendations but I have included them in order to draw attention to items which, obvious though they may appear when read in the calm atmosphere of everyday life, may well be overlooked in the stress of an actual re-opening operation.
(1) Planning of Re-opening Operations
All phases of work involved in re-opening a district which has been sealed off following a fire, and in restoring conditions to normal, should be covered by a detailed plan, drawn up in consultation with all interested parties. This plan should not be varied materially, except as may be necessary to deal with an emergency, without fresh consultation with those parties. The scheme should provide for the appointment of one senior official to be in charge of all operations on each shift, and for the provision of ample supplies of necessary materials and apparatus such as tools, canvas brattice, materials for temporary stoppings, etc.
(2) Timing of Re-opening Operations
Great care is needed in deciding when to attempt to re-open a district which has been sealed off because of fire. A period of longer than six months may well be necessary to allow heated material, particularly coal, to cool down sufficiently. Firedamp will be present in large quantities and in order to ensure that its concentration does not fall into the explosive range it is necessary to consider whether to attempt to recover the whole of the affected area in one stage, or whether to proceed in several stages.
(3) Restoration of the Ventilation
This must always be treated as a matter of the greatest urgency. As far as possible, accumulations of inflammable gas should be removed as a "plug" and not diluted with fresh air until they are well clear of any ground which may have been affected by the fire. All possible sources of ignition in the path of the gas must be eliminated. The possibility of an exploration by a team wearing self-contained breathing apparatus and operating through an air lock, should be considered before any attempt is made to restore the ventilation. Steps should be taken to ensure that electric power cannot be supplied to cables or signalling apparatus in the affected part of the mine until the ventilation has been completely restored.
(4) Sampling the Atmosphere
The scheme referred to in paragraph (1) above should include the provision of suitable laboratory equipment on the surface at the mine for the analyses of air samples, in particular for estimating percentage concentrations of carbon monoxide to four places of decimals. It should also include the specification of points where air samples should be taken at fixed intervals, bearing in mind that the most significant results will be obtained by taking samples near to any possible, or suspected, site of heating, and that separate spot samples should be taken at different points in the cross section of a roadway in which only a small quantity of air is flowing. The results of the analyses of these samples should be plotted at the earliest possible moment on a graph, in such a way that the percentages of the different gases at any time are plainly indicated. These graphs should be kept constantly available to the manager and the senior officials. Where air samples are collected by men wearing breathing apparatus they should be instructed how to avoid contamination with gas exhausted from the relief valve of their apparatus. In every case where carbon monoxide is found in measureable quantity, and where the oxygen deficiency can be reliably determined their ratio should be calculated and shown on the graph.
(5) Safeguarding of Personnel during Re-opening Operations
A physical examination of the district should be made as the fresh air first advances, and no one should be allowed to work without breathing apparatus in a return airway until the whole area is clear of accumulations of gas. The number of men working underground at any time should be kept down to the absolute minimum. Where a rescue brigade is used underground as support for workmen it should remain in some place, not too far away from where the work is proceeding, but under sufficient cover as will make it unlikely that the rescue men would be seriously affected should an explosion occur. Consideration should be given to the possibility of providing "self-rescuers", i.e., small gas masks which give protection to the wearer against carbon monoxide, for all persons engaged underground in re-opening operations where there is any risk of explosion.
A copy of this report was kindly donated by
West Cumbria Mines Research.