1, Grafton Road, Whitley, Newcastle-On-Tyne,
20th December 1880.
T. W. Bunning, Esq.
Dear Sir, — Mr. Ryder has been good enough to favour me with a perusal of the accompanying proofs, and I beg leave to offer the following observations thereon :— I have read the evidence and there can be no doubt that the pulleys, the steam pipe, and the signal wire were struck by lightning; and owing to the imperfect fishing of the rails, the charge, whilst in the act of dissipating itself over the various conductors which carried it to earth, experienced so much resistance in its course that heat and sparks were caused, accompanied by slight reports as described by the witnesses. I have no knowledge of the pit in question, but it almost follows that it must be a dry one, and also that the surface must have been dry at the time of the lightning discharge, otherwise the phenomenon would have taken place much more quietly.
Remarking upon Mr. May's observations. It is a law that all circuits must be complete within themselves for a current to flow, hence if the bells would not ring there must have been a break in the circuit, and Mr. May points out where the break was; namely, in the earth connection; for as soon as that was made good by connecting the 200 yards of unfished rails, the bells worked all right. Hence in the Harton pit also, if the earth connections at each end of the wire were perfectly made, there was no path, or a path of such very high resistance, owing to the dryness of the pit, that but a fraction of the current took the course intended for it, and that fraction was insufficient to work the bells. The whole question of the safety of the pit from being struck by lightning appears to depend upon the nature of the earth connections made on the surface. Now, with ordinary telegraph instruments, it is a well-known fact that where the earth is riddled with shafts and underground workings, or is artificially raised, as at the Ballast Hill at North Shields, a good earth connection is not obtainable. I can mention three cases in particular Throckley, West Stanley, and the Ballast Hill at North Shields. At Throckley the "A B C" was fitted with a switch, so that each side of the line could be used independently of the other, but when the switch was turned to say line A, it was found that line B was also getting the message intended for A, what happened was this, owing to the imperfect earth connection, the current had three paths open to it, the one to line A, the other to the earth, and the last to line B, the current dividing inversely as the resistances of the three paths, probably the greater portion going by line A, and smaller portions by the earth and line B; this difficulty was got over by taking care to make the earth connection of large surface.
At West Stanley the wire was frequently being reported faulty and this was finally traced to a defective earth at West Stanley.
At the Ballast Hill, North Shields, the earth wire had to be carried down into the River Tyne, otherwise there was danger of failure of the Time Gun.
Mr. Steavenson's remarks its to the lightning probably striking the pulleys is a most pertinent one, and though the lightning would take every path open to it, the pulleys being so prominent and the rope continuous, that path would probably have the largest share of the charge to dispose of.
With regard to the chimneys at Harton bring protected with lightning conductors and yet the telegraph wires 10 or 12 feet from the ground being struck by lightning, this is probably explained by the fact that the wires in question extend over a large surface of country, and no matter where struck the charge would be felt at Harton.
The practical point is how to prevent lightning discharges entering pits, and being a source of danger, the extent of which is not well understood: obviously, to protect the mouth of the shaft efficiently, lightning conductors should be fixed to all lofty chimneys and buildings in the neighbourhood, the various points upon a building being connected to the main conductor, and this conductor must be continuous and make good earth. To effect the latter, should the surface and pit be dry, it must be taken to some point, no matter how distant, where it good earth can be obtained, and nothing is better than the bed of a stream or the water mains
At most collieries I have observed a reservoir of water, and in many cases a stream of some volume due to pumping operations. and in those cases there can be no difficulty.
Then there is one other point, the conductor or conductors must be tested from time to time so that it may be ascertained that they are intact and making good earth.
I have not specially studied the subject of lightning conductors, but it is a pleasure to comment upon so interesting a topic. — I am, yours truly,
A. W. Heaviside.