|
Volume 30 (XXX), 1880-1881, published 1881 The President said, this was an inquiry of very great interest. It was not entirely a new one, because suggestions had been made long since as to the possibility of lightning producing explosions. The question came before a Select Committee of the House of Commons on Accidents in Mines, on the 26th of June, 1835, when evidence was taken upon the point. Mr. George Stephenson, in answers 1705 to 1733, gave his views at great length, and doubted the possibility of gas exploding underground by lightning. Mr. J. Buddle was then examined in answers 2191 to 2211, and said, amongst other evidence; that "the Lawson Main Pit was exploded by the lightning. The pit was upwards of 70 fathoms deep, and was not particularly fiery. The explosion took place at or above the surface. I happened to be near the pit during the thunderstorm. A flash of lightning exploded the gas, and a very heavy explosion immediately ensued. I cannot state the interval between the flash and the gas being perceived to be ignited, but I understood it to be instantaneous. I know a fact, recorded by my father, of the engine pump having acted as a conductor and carried the electric fluid to the bottom of the pit; but I do not know it of my own knowledge. My father saw it." The meeting would be exceedingly glad if any gentleman would be kind enough to favour them with any opinion on the matter, or with any facts which had come before them. Mr. A. L. Steavenson said, he remembered hearing about ten years ago of a circumstance of a similar kind. It was told to him that the boys at the siding about a mile in-bye at the Page Bank Pit had seen lightning running along the rails at the time a heavy thunderstorm raged on the surface ; but it seemed so entirely unlikely that he took very little notice of it at the time and made no inquiry. When he saw the notice of the Committee's report upon the agenda paper, however, the circumstance immediately recurred to him, and he would take the opportunity of trying to get some evidence on the subject. The difficulty which occurred to his mind at the time was, that the lightning should run along the rails and do no harm. Mr. May said, he had had a little experience connected with the action of the electric fluid underground, which might be interesting to the members. In this particular case, at Tanfield, it was stated that the lightning went down the pit and went along the rails or along the rope; but the difficulty was to know what became of it. At Boldon Colliery they fitted up some electric bells about a mile from the shaft, and the electricity could not be got rid of after it had been used for the working of the bells, the bells themselves ceasing to work in consequence. Ultimately they tried to get rid of it by fastening one of the wires to the rails and thus endeavour to take the electricity out-bye again, but to no purpose, until it was discovered that about 200 yards of the way was not fished ; and it was this break in the rails which prevented the bells working. As soon as a small piece of wire was attached on the 200 yards to couple up the lengths that were not fished, the bells went to work at once. Seeing the difficulty of getting rid of the small quantity of electricity required for the bells, he was led to ask how the much larger quantity that went down the Tanfield pit was got rid of. At Harton Colliery, during the late severe storms, the lightning struck some wires which were used for connecting the electric bells at the bottom of the pit with the engine house at the surface, and it passed along into the engine house and fused all the small wires upon a telephone, and so passed to the earth. The lightning did not go down the pit at all, as the resistance through the telephone on the surface in the engine house was very much lighter than that which it would have encountered in having to go down the pit. Professor Herschel said, the question which seemed to be a very important one was, what became of the lightning when it entered a pit ? And it was in a great measure answered by the very excellent paper which they had heard read, and which he thought contained more abundant information on a particular point of a very interesting character than he had met with for some time, or had ever been able to fall in with. The paper showed quite clearly what was the nature of the occurrence which took place in the passage of the fluid and certainly described a clear case of lightning stroke. It had been a matter of deliberation with him for a long time whether accidents of this kind, where injuries were done to instruments, might be produced without the actual stroke of the lightning, by what was called the return stroke. A flash of lightning which took place in the clouds never reached the earth at all. There was a great relief, not only of the strain on the clouds themselves, but of that on the earth which had sympathised with it ; and the rush of the fluid which streamed through the earth might be of such magnitude as to do these injuries. If the water pipes and gas pipes of a town were connected together, by telegraph wire for example, the largeness of the area covered by the water pipes, and that covered by the gas pipes, might be very different ; and under the attractions of electricity in the clouds, there might be an electricity of one kind accumulated in the large area of the water pipes, and of the other kind accumulated by influence, or induction, on the area of the gas pipes. When the relief takes place in the clouds these two electricities unite themselves on the earth, and the passage through the telegraph circuits which used these earths might be severe and injurious. He had often questioned whether there might be sufficient strength in these return strokes, as they are called, to do these injuries. He doubted it now ; and this history which they had heard especially convinced him that the accidents which occur are really strokes of lightning — of electricities coming from the clouds to the earth. Then the question arose, where does the electricity go to? And the fact just described by Mr. May that the bells would not work at the bottom of a pit because no good earth could be found there, was a fact which he could confirm by experience. He had had to put up bells in this house, and had taken the earth wire to almost every accessible piece of metal-work in the building, and finally even to the lead and gutters of the roof, without being able to find earth sufficient to work the bells, until he tried the water pipes, and in joining the wire up to the water pipes it found good earth. Laboratory electricity, however, differs altogether from lightning electricity; not, as was supposed by Mr. May, in the quantity of the fluid which had to be got rid of, for the difference was just the opposite. In the laboratory there was a great quantity of electricity to be got rid of, but it was of very low tension, and it would not overcome resistance. A passage to the earth that was unsuitable for a bell was quite suitable for a lightning stroke ; and the lightning would spring from wires to the earth, and make its escape where laboratory electricity could not follow. The quantity of lightning electricity was very small; but coupled with its high tension where it passes, it does a work far exceeding what a current of less stress would do, and it would melt the wires which it was able to traverse on account of its intensity or strength; it melted thin wires of great resistance, like those of telephone coils. In a case like this, where a real stroke of lightning had, he believed, come down the steam pipe, and thus descended the shaft to a certain depth, it found there rails spread over a large surface of earth. This probably was a very dry pit, and it might very reasonably be asked how the electricity found its way from these rails? It would not do any harm in passing along the rail, but in jumping across from one to the other, the flash and the heat produced there would be dangerous to a colliery by the risk of firing explosive gases. If a safe earth for the lightning at the bottom of the pit could be insured, there would be no injury from it underground. The facts which were learnt in the present case were, that the lightning on reaching the bottom of the steam pipe, not having any chance of escaping into a sump full of water as might have been the case had the pipe gone to the bottom of the shaft, sprang down to the plates, and from the plates to the rails, and found its way along the tram roads. The pit must have been very dry, for the lightning did not escape to the earth as readily as lightning from a lightning conductor is supposed to do; but having entered the rails, spread along them, seeking the earth at every foot or yard it ran in that way; and the fact, for instance, that at 700 yards from the shaft the sound was heard and no light seen, showed that the lightning had diminished in power by the time it arrived there; it had partly escaped into the earth. 400 and 500 yards from the shaft there was still much left ; but he thought it would be found from the workmen's accounts, who were in the inclined way, that they spoke of considerably less light and less noise appearing between the breaks of the rails than the onsetter and the pusher-out at the bottom of the shaft mentioned, where the character of the flash as it fell upon the plates was like that of a gun, and the lightning struck with a light upon the plates which alarmed them all. There could be no doubt that the lightning did make a great flash just there, and passed on into the rails, and there it diminished its strength as it reached to greater distances. All that was perfectly in harmony with what would be understood from lightning leaking out of the rails as fast as it could all along the earth-way. The rails afforded a tolerable earth for the lightning. He thought it was of importance, however, to learn in such cases what took place above ground. There was a thunderstorm, and a thunderclap was heard at the same time. It would be well to know whether on every such occurrence as this it could be ascertained that a lightning flash was seen at the top of the pit. If this proved to have been the ease, pits were in need of lightning conductors as much and more than ordinary buildings ; just as a powder magazine should be protected by a good lightning conductor, so also should be a pit ; and the nature of that lightning conductor should, he thought, occupy the attention of mining engineers and students, and of those who are acquainted with electrical science, and particularly of electrical engineers, of whom he hoped there might be some present who would give some information on the subject. The narrative which they had just heard, showed that rails, extensive as they were, and far as they might lead away lightning, are yet scarcely a better earth than short steam pipes, and that although the rails laid down in a pit do conduce to carrying away electricity, they yet retain the flash for long distances. On the other hand this flash might probably be avoided by pointed conductors on the surface, which was the only way in which a lightning flash would ever be effectually prevented. He had thought it might interest the members of the Institute to show them an instrument which he brought from Paris the other day; it was intended to serve as an electric light for the dark places in the pit. It was a gas-vacuum tube, through which a discharge of electricity passing produces a useful light. He would not wish to work by it, and as the sellers of the instrument said to him, he thought it was an instrument for amateurs, and not for practical use ; because there was danger of the electrical spark passing between unprotected portions of the wires connected with the instrument. The instrument, therefore, was one of a dangerous nature; and he thought it should be borne in mind in reference to the use of electricity underground, and especially in very fiery pits, that there was always risk of a spark becoming sufficiently strong in the case of breakages of the circuit to have dangerous effects. The experience of George Stephenson on the subject, viz., that electricity seldom fires gas, and is probably not dangerous on that account, had no doubt a great deal of weight, and he (the Professor) thought it might be true that, as ordinary electric sparks have not nearly the body which a candle flame has, such small electrical sparks as are likely to occur in the bell circuits which are now frequently being put up would not be of any serious risk. But should it come to a question of using electricity for mechanical working underground, he thought the risk of inflammation occurring from the use of the electrical current might be a very serious one. In the examples which the members had had brought before them to-day, the discharges had been of a very much more violent character, and he would like to know how far the experience of telegraph engineers, on their lines where the instruments are sometimes destroyed even where lightning guards are used, led them to think that the destruction was likewise produced by the lightning stroke itself, and whether pointed conductors would avoid the occurrence of this damage ? The President asked, how the steam pipes going down this shaft were supported ? Mr. Pringle — They were supported by wood. (See Plate X.) Professor Herschel said, he had not before thought of the circumstance, but the lightning in this case made its way along C and D, Plate IX., to the open mouth of a drift, and from what had been described it may have passed out of the drift. On that the suggestion was made by Mr. Bunning that the lightning tried to make its way out to the air again. It would, of course, naturally have been expected that it would try to make its way to the earth. But he thought it quite possible that the explanation suggested was true, and that in this case the lightning tried to make its way through the earth by another flash having taken place — one down the pit and one down the drift — the two flashes seeking to join each other through the best conductor they could find, which was along the waggonway. Not enough is known as to where lightning goes after it has struck a conductor, and as to what earths are needed to get rid of it; that was a point upon which the experience of telegraph engineers was wanted. It might be that rails were very poor means for the discharge of the electricity, and that the thill or floor of the seam was often so dry as to be a retentive material, or very bad conductor, as seems in this instance to have been the case. It might, therefore, be a question for the miner to inquire what sort of earth he ought to provide for his lightning conductor, which should be adopted at every pit. Mr. D. P. Morison said, a very curious case occurred near Acomb, Hexham, about six or seven years ago, in an old pit which had been totally disused for two years. It had been sunk, he believed, originally for a lead mine, but they found a small seam of coal; and they had worked a little coal out of that pit and then tried for lead afterwards. When the pit was closed, the wire-rope guides and the ropes were left in the shaft, and two years after the pit had been closed up, in a thunderstorm on a Sunday afternoon, the pit blew up. The cages were sent out of the shaft along with the ropes and other debris. Now, there was no chance whatever of there being any naked light down below, or near the top, which was railed off. The pit was altogether in private grounds; and, according to the account of a man who was walking in a field near the pit, the flash of lightning and the blowing up of the cage were simultaneous. Professor Herschel said, he had not heard of the case, but should think there would be many such, and that the ironwork which was laid and left down a pit might afford an excellent earth for the lightning and prove a great attraction for it ; and he should think that rails carefully fished over a large area might be the best earth which could possibly be used for providing lightning conductors with. Mr. A. L. Steavenson thought it natural to suppose that the lightning would strike the pulleys, which are the most prominent object at the pit head, and then run down the rope into the pit, much more likely than to follow the steam pipes. The President said, there was only this objection to that supposition, and that was, if the lightning did strike the pulleys, instead of going down the shaft it would go down to the engine house and get relief there. Professor Herschel — Except for the attraction of the rails underground. The President — Yes; but it would take the shortest way where there was less difficulty in passing to the earth, which would be through the means of the engine house to the earth rather than going down the shaft to the earth. Professor Herschel — The earth alone is not a good recipient. Mr. Morison said, he would like to ask Professor Herschel whether lightning could light up gas underground unless it was in a thoroughly explosive condition? Professor Herschel said, it would have to be highly inflammable. In the laboratory they found that electricity did not succeed in exploding mixtures which were only approximately inflammable. Sparks from lightning would be more intense than sparks given off in small experiments, and on that account they would very probably be more dangerous. A Member said it had been mentioned that the Risca explosion occurred at about the same time, and there was a good deal of speculation as to whether that explosion was caused by electricity. As all life underground was destroyed, there was no evidence to show what did happen there; but the workings were very dry and dusty, and the result of the inquiry was, that the explosion had occurred in-bye, and that there had been an accumulation of gas, but there was no evidence to show how that gas had been exploded. Mr. Ryder said, it had been mentioned that there were some traces of the lightning flash upon X at the daylight drift, Plate IX.; he would like to know of what character these traces were, and whether there was any damage done? Mr. J. B. Simpson said, with respect to this question, there was no definite evidence as to its having gone out there. Some of the witnesses said there was a mark, on the side of the drift which might have been caused by the lightning, but the Committee had no other evidence. The President said, he would like to know whether any of the foreign engineers had made any statement as to their experience, or whether any member had any knowledge of anything having appeared in the Transactions of any of the Foreign Societies upon the subject? Mr. Morison said that both in Belgium and Germany, as a rule, they had lightning conductors on the top of the pulleys. Mr. Simpson asked whether that might not be to save the surface buildings, and not to prevent the lightning going down the shaft ? The surface buildings in Belgium were very large. Mr. Morison said, the conductors might not be put up to prevent the lightning going down the shaft, but would still have that effect. Mr. Bunning said, he had noticed that the use of lightning conductors abroad was very much more general than in England. Mr. Morison — It is very much more general. Mr. May said, that at Harton Colliery, where they had two or three chimneys, and very high houses round about, they had them protected by lightning conductors; yet still the electric fluid struck the wires which are only about 10 or 12 feet from the ground. The President said, the matter had now been very fairly discussed, and he hoped it would receive the attention of those gentlemen who were more conversant with electrical matters than many of the members, and that they would endeavour to let it be known whether there was any possibility of an accident happening from an explosion of gas by lightning passing underground, and if so, whether the danger could be met by finding earth, as Professor Herschel had put it, without the lightning going in-bye. Perhaps this subject might receive consideration, and the members would be very glad to hear of it if any gentleman arrived at any satisfactory proposition. The Secretary said that an electric signal apparatus for use at pits was now being exhibited at Messrs. Mills and Co.'s, Forth Banks, and those gentlemen would be very happy to exhibit it to any member of the Institute who liked to go round and see it at the close of the meeting.
The President moved a vote of thanks to the Committee of Investigation for the most interesting paper they had given, and also to Mr. Kendall for his paper. Mr. Steavenson had great pleasure in seconding the motion. The votes of thanks were then carried by acclamation, and the meeting terminated.
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||