Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

I.M.E. Previous Return to Index Next I.M.E.
/   \

Volume 9 (IX), 1860-1861, published 1861

Richard Forster Matthews, of South Hetton, viewer, said — I am viewer for South Hetton and Murton Collieries. I have been a viewer sixteen years, and have seen four or five colliery explosions, and have been burnt myself. Since this explosion I was down the pit assisting to get out the bodies. Everything was done that could have been done to save the men. I have seen both pits. I believe the explosion took place in the No. 3 boiler flue. I have not the slightest doubt of that. My opinion is, that there had been a quantity of gas given off by the boiler fire, probably about 3000 or 4000 cubic feet, which had lodged in the flue, between the boiler and the crossing of the north rolley-way, and had been ignited at the boiler fire, and at first, I think the explosion had been slight, but sufficient to blow out the crossing into the rolley-way, and then the whole volume of gas became mixed with the requisite amount of fresh air, causing the ignition of the whole, and hence I account for the explosive force from that point being so much greater. I do not think it possible the gas could have accumulated from the workings into the flue. I think it could not have come from any other place than the boiler fire. I was at first rather surprised at this explosion, but am not so when I have considered the matter. It is of an extraordinary description. I have calculated the quantity of gas there might be in the flues, and consider, if as much gunpowder as you can put into a thimble will carry an ounce ball a mile, I see nothing to prevent the quantity of gas there would be in the flues to do all this mischief. At Murton we ventilate the flue by a hole five inches square, between the travelling-way and the smoke flue, to prevent such an occurrence. I believe that is generally done. I never knew, but have heard of one of these flues blowing up before this below ground. That was at the Felling. All the damage may have been done without any fire-damp from the workings. I have been frequently, years before, in this pit, and there was always a quantity of air in it. I am aware my opinion is somewhat different to that of Messrs. Bell and Richardson as to the mixture of fresh air, that is, I think the great force of the explosion did not take place until the crossing at the north way gave way. My reason is, that the boiler and engine which is close bye is not injured at all. The explosion would be a continuous one. I have seen the arch-way at the crossing, but have not measured it. It could not be made strong enough to resist an explosion. I think part of the explosion went through Davison's engine to the stables, but the main portion went along the north and south rolley-ways. The west end of the flue being open would not ease the violence of the explosion at the crossing.

Thomas Emerson Forster, of Newcastle-upon-Tyne, said — I have been an extensive viewer of collieries thirty-eight years. I have been down this pit, and have examined it very minutely, with a view to ascertain where the explosion took place. There can be no doubt that the explosion took place in the flue of Davison's engine boiler. The cause was the damping of the fire with a large quantity of coals, and the damper being too closely put down, the distillation of gas from these coals oozed through underneath the damper, and filled the flues with explosive gas, too little air being allowed to pass to sweep it away as it was made. I think the flue had filled back from the top of the crossing on the north way to the damper, and then tailed back on the boiler fire and ignited; and then the gas between the damper and the boiler fire would back through the firehole doors and would set fire to the south-east stables. The larger portion of gas between the damper and the crossing would ignite at the same time, and the first thing it would do would be to blow down the crossing. It is quite clear the blast had gone in that direction, because the wall of the crossing on the east side of the north rolleyway was blown down, whilst that on the west side was left partially standing. It is quite impossible the gas could have been generated in the inbye workings and afterwards get into the flues. There is no other source, in my opinion, but the boiler fire from which the gas could possibly come. In 1847 I was viewer at the Felling, when we had a similar explosion to this underground. I do not think there was any difference in the nature of the explosions, but that at the Felling caused more damage. The flues there were about the same size as they are here. I built the flues in the East Minor Pit in the year 1826, when I was viewer for Hetton Colliery. I came as viewer to the Hetton Collieries in 1824, and was there until 1831, and I have been frequently down them since that time; and I think it is due to Mr. Daglish to say, that the quantity of air going down, and the distribution of it, does him great credit, and has my unqualified approbation. And I further state, that with that circulation of air in this pit it is impossible that the returns can ever be in a dangerous state. I would have considered the pit perfectly safe with a much less quantity of air. It is quite impossible the explosion can have been caused by gunpowder. If the men were killed at such distances with after-damp it would not surprise me, but I think they were killed by the concussion of the explosion. The effect of the after-damp would extend further than the concussion would kill a man. If the air at the bottom of the pit was going north and south at the rate of eight to ten feet per second before the explosion took place, after the explosion had taken place, and its effects were going on, I have no doubt that the air would then be forced at the rate of from 80 to 100 feet per second, and the consequence would be, the air would rush in and carry the after-damp with it, and so kill the men if then alive. That is the reason there is so much damage done to the rolleyway. The ventilation at the Felling at the time of the explosion there was about 60,000 cubic feet per minute, which would be a larger portion of air in proportion to the workings of the colliery than here. There were goaves in the Felling, but it was quite clear that it was not caused by fire-damp. The engine stood 700 yards from the bottom of the shaft, and the flue was level about 350 yards next the engine, and then rose about two inches to the yard to the upcast shaft — the engine being 600 yards from the upcast and 700 from the downcast. It had no ventilation except what it got from the boiler, which was twenty-eight feet long and six feet diameter. I cannot say, whether it was a wheel or a flash flue, but think the latter. The boiler was lifted out of its seat and all the steam pipes broken, and 100 yards of the flue was blown down. The flue there was two side walls, and there were flags over the top. The travelling-way was between the coal and the flue, but there was a brick wall next the coal on each side. I would suggest one way of preventing these explosions — by putting the fires out. The next is by keeping the damper sufficiently high for the current of air to sweep away the gas as soon as made. And a third, by making an opening in the flue wall from the travelling road beyond the damper, and allowing a sufficient quantity of air to go in and so clear the gas away as made. It is my opinion that the gas could not ignite at the west ventilating furnace, and if it had ignited there, the west side of the crossing would have blown down instead of the east. From the evidence I have heard as to the ventilation previous to the explosion, I think the ventilation was quite sufficient, and that it occurred from circumstances that could not be foreseen. I do not consider the damage done so great as might have been expected, independent of the burning of the stables and the sacrifice of life. The masonry of the crossing I consider perfectly strong enough for its purpose, as it has been there thirty-four years.

Richard Heckels, of Bunker Hill Colliery, viewer to the Earl of Durham and others, said — I have been a viewer twenty-two years, and have had charge of extensive collieries. I was down this pit on the morning after the explosion, and every means were used to save the lives of the men in the pit. I have been down the pit, and through the flues, and have examined them four or five times, as well as the neighbourhood of the shaft. The explosion had taken place in the flues at Davison's engine fire, from an accumulation of gas from the fire to the crossing at the north rolleyway, which was generated from the coals put on the furnace fire in damping it, and which got into the flues underneath and at the sides of the damper. I think, whilst it was accumulating, it would fill like a balloon, and tail back through or at the sides of the damper. It would ignite, and pass quietly on underneath, just behind the damper, and explode the gas inside the flue. I think it is barely possible for the gas to have been set on fire at the west ventilating furnaces. The gas could not have accumulated from the workings of the pit, or any other source, to be brought into the flue, than that I have named. With this ventilation there might have been gas in the goaves, but not any in the workings. I have not known of any explosion of this nature before; but since this explosion I have heard of that at the Felling, but know nothing of it of my own knowledge. The ventilation was amply sufficient for the safety of the men. I would have considered it safe with half the ventilation. I consider it the best ventilated pit I have ever seen. I know the Hetton Collieries well, having served my time there as a viewer for four years, up to August, 1838. It is possible that it may often have been near an explosion during this length of time, and yet not happen. An explosion of this sort requires a certain combination of circumstances, at a certain time, to cause it, all the circumstances meeting together at the same moment of time.

George William Southern, of Chilton Moor, viewer to the Marchioness of Londonderry, said — I have been a viewer fifteen years, and have had the management of extensive collieries. I have been down the Minor Pits, and have particularly examined them. My opinion is, the explosion took place in the flue of No. 3 boiler. There can be no doubt about it. The cause I believe to have been gas in the flue, from the boiler end to the north way crossing. It could not accumulate there from any of the workings of the pit, but had done so from the damping of the fire, the gas being generated from the coals used for that purpose. The gas had tailed back from the flue to the back of the boiler fire, and there ignited, and then communicated underneath the damper with the gas lodged between that point and the crossing; and having blown out the crossing, and then meeting with a strong current of fresh air, caused the explosion to be more violent, and to spread both north and south, and cause the damage done and the loss of life which has been described. I have had a good deal of experience with underground boilers, and it is usual to damp them. Before this explosion took place, I would not have feared damping the fires. This explosion has altered my opinion as to the probability of an explosion. I now think it more probable that it might occur again. I do not think it necessary for the fires to be put out to prevent an explosion. I would think a door from the travelling way into the flue, in connection with the damper, could be constructed so as to let in a supply of fresh air when the fire was damped, so that the damper could not be put down without the door opening at the same time. I have flues underground in my management, but we have not ventilated them. It has not been general in the trade in this district to do so. I would only consider it necessary to ventilate them when the damper was down. If the damper had been high enough to let in a current of air to carry off the gas as made, this explosion would not have occurred. I would not have expected the fireman to have left it further open than was sufficient to carry off the smoke. The raising of the damper, more than sufficient to take off the smoke, would blow up the fire, and make it burn brighter. The act of cooling down the flues by the admission of fresh air might reduce the temperature in the flue, and make it more liable to explosion by that means than the other.

Edward Sinclair said — I live at Durham, and have been a viewer upwards of twenty-two years, and have had the management of extensive collieries, both in this district and in South Wales, and have seen and investigated many colliery explosions, and was down the pit when an explosion at Springwell took place, when thirty-seven men were killed, I think in the year 1838. I was down the Minor Pit on Saturday morning, and examined the parts. I think the explosion took place in the flue between Davison's engine boiler and the crossing in the north way, from gas collected in the flue between the damper and the crossing; and, I think, when the boiler fire was damped down it would then be similar to an ordinary gas retort, and a constant distillation of the gases, from the coal and coke composing the fire, would be collecting in the fine behind the damper. I imagine it tailed back, either below or at the sides of the damper, and had ignited at the boiler fire, communicating that flame to the gas in the flues, and producing the explosion. I agree with some of the previous witnesses that the explosive force of the gas would be very much increased when the crossing over the north way was blown out, and I think there was quite sufficient force to cause the damage I have seen. I have never known an instance where the boiler flues were ventilated, but do not think there would be any danger in doing so. The air in the flue would be rarefied. By the sudden introduction of cold air, you might damage your flues, but not cause such an explosion as this. But it is, I think, very easy to warm the air by passing it over the boiler, before admitting it to the flues. It is usual, both in this district and Wales and Scotland to damp the fires, and not to ventilate them. I do not know a flue ventilated in any other way than this was. I was down this pit previous to the explosion (about three years ago), and I considered it was then one of the best ventilated pits within my knowledge.

Matthias Dunn, of Newcastle-upon-Tyne, mine inspector from the Tyne to the Tweed, the northern district, said — I attend for Mr. Atkinson, the inspector of this district, in consequence of his illness. I have been fifty years a viewer. I have been down the East Minor Pit once since the explosion, and have examined it. The explosion took place near to the damper in the flues, from gas accumulated there, generated from coal used in damping the boiler fire, which had tailed back from the flue underneath the damper, and become fired at the back part of the boiler fire, or had formed an explosive current all the way to the west ventilating furnaces, and there taken fire. The gas could not have accumulated in the flue from the workings of the pit. I was viewer of Hetton Colliery, in 1832, and this engine and boiler was then working in the same manner as at the time of the explosion, and I considered it perfectly safe. I do not think any thing could have been done by the parties in charge of this pit to avoid this explosion. I consider this is similar to the explosions of boilers which are so difficult to understand, and cannot satisfactorily be accounted for. I consider it a very peculiar case, and there must have been a peculiar combination of circumstances to have produced it. So that if the flues were erected again in the same way as previous to this explosion, a similar one might not take place for very many years, or it might take place next week. Ventilation of the flues, I consider, desirable, and, I think, it could be done with advantage so as to prevent such an explosion occurring again.

Joseph Dickenson, of Pendleton, near Manchester, mine inspector for the Manchester district, said — At the request of Mr. Atkinson, who is too ill to attend to the matter himself and by the direction of the Home Secretary, I have attended this enquiry. I have been down the East and West Minor Pits, and have particularly examined them, and have no doubt there has been an explosion in the flue of Davison's boiler, at the part spoken to by the witnesses, between the boiler fire and the north crossing. I cannot say that I have clearly made my mind up from what cause the explosion took place. If it has been from gas in that flue, and in the quantity described, it has been gas of a more violently explosive kind than any I have hitherto met with in coal mines. I have officially investigated upwards of a dozen explosions, and upwards of one hundred killing less than ten persons, and have never met with a case where the gas has been of so explosive a character as it seems to have been in this case, that is judging from the small quantity of gas which we have been able to trace out. Unless it was in a larger quantity than what that portion of the flue would contain, it could not be ordinary fire-damp. This is the only explosion I ever investigated without coming to a conclusion satisfactory to my own mind. I do not think there is the slightest blame to attach to the viewer, or any party connected with the pit for this explosion; for although every witness we could get has been examined and sifted, we have not been able to find that there was any ordinary fire-damp. I feel quite sure that if the explosion was in the flue, it could not have its full supply of air, and on knocking the crossing down, it got its requisite quantity from the intake, and a further explosion took place, and then it went right along the level.

The examination of Mr. Dickenson completed the evidence, and the Jury returned the following

Verdict — "That the said John Greaves and twenty-one other persons, on the twentieth day of December, now last past, came to their deaths, in the East and West Minor Pits, Hetton Colliery, in the parish ward and county aforesaid, by an explosion of inflammable gas, accumulated in the flue leading from the boiler fire of Davison's engine to the upcast shaft, which gas was not generated in the workings of the said pits."

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print