THURSDAY'S PROCEEDINGS.
Coroner Maynard resumed his enquiry on Thursday morning, when the large school room was again packed to overflowing by a large number of miners from the neighbouring collieries. The same officials were in attendance as at the previous days proceedings.
Mr. Chipchase, examined by Mr. Atherley Jones, said the two bore holes were made respectively on the 1st May and 5th May. The first one was driven in the direction in which they were working, and that direction would not have cut the circle. The second bore hole was a flanking bore hole. It went through the strata which they never would have touched, and would have reached the hitch at a point where they would never have been.
Mr. Atherley Jones: What was the object of the 5th of May bore hole, which passed through strata you never would have opened ? — Witness: To try to find a hitch.
Mr. Atherley Jones :Had not the dampness something to do with the second bore hole being made ? — None whatever.
Joseph Urwin, chargeman in the straight long wall at Cassop, said on the 5th May, the day before the accident, he examined the long wall, and found nothing more than a sup of water in the right hand corner. He examined the place where Bell and Kelly had been working and found no trace of water there, as described in these proceedings. He examined the place again at nine o'clock the same night and again noticed nothing.
Mr. Atherley Jones: How long is it since you first noticed water there ? — Ever since we commenced the long wall, which is about 12 months ago.
Have you noticed more water there later than previously ? — No, sir; about the same.
Have you had to remove any water ? — Yes, we lead it out.
Have you ever had occasion to make a report as to water ? — No, sir.
When did you last lead water from this place ? — On the 2nd May.
Do you lead it more than or less than twice a week ? — Sometimes twice a week.
As time went on and you worked the long wall, did you notice more water ? — No, sir.
Did you ever hear any talk among the men as to water where Bell was working.? — No, sir.
Mr. Stanton: Where did the water come from, you say you lead out ? — It was just bottom water.
Mr. Thomas Bell, late H.M. Inspector of Mines for this district, and at one time in charge of Cassop Colliery for seven or eight years, said he resigned his post there in February, 1858, and some time after was made H.M. Inspector of Mines for 23 years. As to the interview with Mr. Tate as to the Cassop workings, witness gave him plans of main coal and five quarter, which were the only ones he had, and tracings of which he forwarded to the Home Office. He discussed very fully with Mr. Tate as to what should be done as to the working of the Cassop Harvey, so as to keep out of old workings. We had information that the Harvey Seam did not extend more than 100 yards to the west of Cassop pit, and Mr. Tate suggested that a 100 yards barrier would be sufficient. Afterwards witness said to Mr. Tate that as way went up that way, they had better extend the barrier up to the mark at present marked on the plan. Mr. Tate demurred on account of the quantity of coal that would be left. Witness said it did seem a large quantity to leave, but that when they got to the boundary coming back they could take a large slice off within, the line of the ring by working with the ordinary precaution of boring. Mr. Tate agreed, and the line was drawn at a scale of 300 yards.
Mr. Stanton: If you had had charge of Kelloe Colliery instead of Mr. Tate would you have had the slightest hesitation in doing as he had done ?
Mr. Bell : None whatever.
Have you every reason to believe that the assistance you gave him was given with an absolute knowledge of the facts ?
Mr. Bell: Certainly; and I thought we were perfectly safe in drawing the line at 300 yards.
Mr. Atherley Jones: Did you come to the conclusion that the 75 yards drift westward was driven entirely for exploration in the Cassop Harvey ? — Yes, sir.
If you had known that they had continued that drift up to the place at which they have continued it then you would not have made that circle on the plan ? — That would have altered the whole thing altogether.
When you gave that information did you know they were going to open 72 yards of long wall in Kelloe Pit ? — I understood they were going to open the whole district out as long wall.
Did you keep plans of the Cassop main and five-quarter seams ? — Oh, yes.
And before the Act of 1872 there was no statutory obligation, to keep plans ? — There was .not.
The person you would have expected to have the custody of the plans would be the lessee of Cassop Colliery ? — Yes, sir.
Was it usual at that time to work mines without plans ? — No, I never knew of a case.
And therefore in your opinion there must have been a plan of the Cassop Harvey ? — Oh, yes. I have made several attempts to find it, but failed.
Mr. Stanton: Would it be possible if a drift had been driven in for the purpose of exploration that the drift would not have been shown on the plans ? — Oh, yes.
William Armstrong, mining engineer, said in 1868 he was in charge of Cassop Colliery, but it was not part of his duty to be in the Harvey seam. On one occasion Mr. Gustard told him that the Cassop Harvey did not extend more than 65 or 70 yards.
Mr. Stanton: Did Mr. Gustard tell you he had driven a drift for the purpose of exploration in any direction whatever ? — No, he never mentioned any.
Mr. Atherley Jones: Mr. Gustard told you that the workings had not extended more than you say. You wanted to find out what coal had been .removed ?
Mr. Armstrong: No; I wanted to get sections.
William Wood said he was down the Cassop Pit in 1866, and advised them to abandon the Harvey, as they were losing a very large sum of money. As far as he knew the Harvey was never driven to any large extent. This was two years before they abandoned the mine altogether, but he thought they stopped working the Harvey prior to the abandonment of the colliery altogether.
Mr. Stanton: Under the circumstances would you have done the same as Mr. Tate has ? — Yes, sir.
This concluded the evidence for the owners.
William Bell, hewer at East Hetton Pit, said he had been there for 7 years, and had been working in the Harvey seam all the time. He worked at the time of the accident, and some time previously in the long wall workings near the place of the accident. He had been working there for about six weeks, and was on the left hand side of the cross gateway between the main gateway and cross gateway.
Mr. Atherley Jones: Do you remember anything in the coal which attracted your attention ? — I noticed the segger was winding.
What does that show ? — That we are getting near a hole.
Besides being winding, what else did you notice ? — Every piece of coal we broke water ran out.
Was it getting wetter as you went in ? — Yes, every day.
Did you mention to the overman Jackson that the water was coming from the coal ? — I did.
Did you say anything else ? — I asked him where we were going to.
What did he say ? — He said they had a ring on the plan and knew where they were going.
Did you know of the existence of the old Cassop workings ? — I knew we were going near them.
Did you say anything to the overman Jackson on the 5th May ? — I called his attention to the place, and said "this b—— is nearly holed."
What did Jackson reply ? — He put it off and said "Nothing of the kind." My marrow Kelly, when Jackson came back, also drew his attention to the water spouting out of the coal.
What did Jackson say to that ? — He put a chalk mark on the roof.
What did he say ? — He said "Don't touch this coal any more. We will have some bore holes on to-night."
Did you hear Jackson say in his evidence that you had cut too much into the face out of the line of the other men ? — Yes, but It is not true.
Did he say so in the pit ? — No.
Is it true you did cut too much in the face ? — No, it is not.
Did you ever touch the place he marked off ? — No more that shift.
Mr. Stanton: Have you ever been found fault with for working this long wall improperly before ? — No, sir.
How long had you noticed the water coming out of the place ? — About a fortnight.
Did you ever report the place to anyone before the 5th May ? — I asked the overman where he was going to.
Did you consider the place dangerous ? — Of course.
Yet you went back and worked day after day for more than a fortnight ? — Yes.
At the peril of your life ? — Yes.
You know you are stating what is contradicted by all other witnesses ? — Yes, but I did not want to be in the place, and nobody ought to have been in.
As to the bore-holes, don't you know it is a simply ridiculous statement to make, to say that Jackson promised to put a bore-hole in the place ? — It is not a ridiculous statement. It is the truth, and he sent two borers into the place that night.
Were not Mr. Tate and Mr. Chipchase in the pit on the 28th April ? — Yes.
Did you make any complaint to them ? — No, I hadn't time.
Do you know this special rule, "that when a working place became dangerous, a man shall discontinue working in it, and report it to the deputy ? Did you report it ? — No, I did not.
Mr. Stanton: That is you deliberately broke rule 103.
Mr. Atherley Jones : I understand you to, say that you did off and on mention the matter to Jackson for some days before the 5th May ? — Yes, sir.
Stephen Kelly, hewer, at East Hetton Colliery, said he had been there for five years and seven months. He had heard the evidence of the last witness, Bell, and what he said was true. Witness himself called Jackson's attention to the state of the coal on the 5th May about 11.30, and Jackson replied: "That is nothing." He had noticed the water dripping from the coal for a fortnight.
Mr. Stanton: Did you report the presence of water to the deputy or any of the colliery officials ? — No, sir.
Do you consider you were in danger ? — No, sir.
You thought you were quite safe ? — I thought we were safe where we were working.
Therefore you did not care a snuff whether the water came in or not ? — No, I didn't care.
The Coroner at this juncture invited evidence from any other miners present who could give similar testimony to Bell and Kelly, but none came forward.
The Coroner said there were three questions for the jury to answer. First — Did Messrs. Tate and Chipchase to the best of their ability and judgment, in the absence of the Cassop Harvey seam plan, fix the locality of Cassop old workings and adopt what they considered safe and necessary precautions ? Second — Did anything occur up to or upon the 5th May last to suggest or to warn Messrs. Tate and Chipchase that they were then within 40 yards of any old workings ? Third — Was there any suggestion should the jury think fit to unanimously offer as to any new legislation to make the safety and security of the men greater when approaching old workings ?
THE VERDICT.
OFFICIALS EXONERATED FROM ALL BLAME.
The jury, after deliberating, returned the following verdict :— "We find Thomas Hutchinson and nine others accidentally lost their lives by an accidental inrush of water from Cassop Pit to East Hetton. The jury believe that Mr. Tate and Mr. Chipchase did their best to get plans of old workings of Cassop, and used every precaution for the safe working of the colliery. We think there is no blame attaching to them."