Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
/   \

I append a report of the proceedings which appeared in the "Durham County Advertiser" on the 3rd September :—

EAST HETTON COLLIERY DISASTER.

CORONER'S ENQUIRY RESUMED.

The concluding stage in the history of the East Hetton Colliery disaster, by which ten men lost their lives on the 6th of May last by the flooding of the Harvey seam, as a result of an irruption of water from the workings of the disused Cassop Colliery, was reached this week, when the coroner's enquiry was resumed by Mr. C. Maynard (H.M. Coroner for the Easington Ward), in the National School-room, Kelloe, on Wednesday morning. Mr. Stanton (of the firm of Stanton and Atkinson, Newcastle), appeared on behalf of the owners (Messrs. Walter Scott, Limited, East Hetton Colliery Co.), whilst Mr. Atherley Jones, Q.C., M.P., instructed by Mr. Isadore Isaacs, of Sunderland, represented the relatives of the deceased and the Durham Miners' Association. Amongst others present at the enquiry were Mr. Donald Bain (H.M. Inspector of Mines,. Durham), Mr. Plummer and Mr. Walker (Assistant Inspectors), Mr. T. Bell (late Chief Inspector of Mines for the district), Messrs. Forman, J. Wilson, M.P., J. Johnson, and T. H. Cann agents for Durham), Mr. W. H. Wood, Coxhoe Hall; Mr. Simon Tate, Trimdon Grange (agent for Messrs. Walter Scott, Limited), and others. Despite the long time that has elapsed, since the date of the disaster, there was still a very great interest taken in the proceedings, and a great number of miners from the neighbouring colliery district were in attendance, the large School-room being packed to the doors.

At the outset, plans were put in of the workings of the pit.

Mr. Murray (Surveyor at the Colliery) said he made a survey of the workings three weeks before the time of the accident.

Mr. Atherley Jones: Was there any indication to you that you were approaching the boundary of the old Cassop Colliery ?

Mr. Murray: We were told by Mr. Tate that the Cassop workings were situated about there.

Mr. Atherley Jones: When did Mr. Tate tell you that the workings in the north part of this Harvey Seam were approaching the direction of the old Cassop workings ?

Mr. Murray: About three years ago.

Thomas Jackson, back overman at the colliery, was called to give a description of the workings before the holing took place. He said he had worked at East Hetton Colliery for the last eleven years, and was last down the pit before the date of the accident on May 5th. He examined the pit in the usual way, and visited the place where the holing took place. Robinson, Marshall, and Speck, were working at the place. He noticed they were "taking into a hole," and withdrew them to get the face straight.

Mr. Stanton: In this place where you withdrew them was there any sign of water ?

Witness: No, sir.

Mr. Stanton: Had you occasion to speak to anyone else there that morning ?

Witness: No, sir.

In answer to the Coroner, witness said he never saw any indication of dampness or leaking about the place.

The Coroner: Did you know you were going towards the Cassop old workings P

Witness: No, sir.

The Coroner: Did you really think it was all whole coal ?

Witness: Yes, sir.

The Coroner: And never saw any cause for alarm or fear ?

Witness: No, sir.

By Mr. Atherley Jones: The seam was generally a dry one. He had never had any experience before of working the "long wall" next to old abandoned workings. He never heard of the Old Cassop workings before the time of the accident, and really thought he was working at solid coal. There were several bore-holes at the place, but he could not say by whose directions they were made. There were two bore-holes. One was commenced about a fortnight before the accident, and witness could not say when the other was begun. He knew what bore-holes were for. They were for the purpose of finding gas or water. He knew of several other bore-holes in that seam, but he could not say whether they were made particularly for the purpose of finding if there was water. The only dampness he noticed was the damp bottom, but only very slight, and this was the case in several parts of the pit. No one had ever complained to witness of the dampness of the coal. Bell was working about ten yards from where the water broke in, but he had never mentioned anything about any dampness of the coal. At 11.30 on the morning of the 5th May he saw Bell working in the face, but he did not say "this b—— is nearly holed." He could swear this. Witness would not have liked to have been there if he had (laughter). He' knew a portion of the coal face was marked off "not to be worked." Witness marked it himself, but did so in order to keep the face straight. Kelly, who also worked at the place, never pointed out to witness that water was spouting out of the face. Witness never told Kelly not to touch the place, and that he would have someone in that same night, and put in a bore-hole. He could swear that on the 5th May, the day before the accident, there was no sign of water in the workings.

Mr. Stanton: You had a son going in to work at the place of the accident the next day ?

Witness: Yes.

Mr. Stanton : And if this alleged conversation had taken place, you would have taken care that he did not go in ?

Witness: Yes, I should have taken very good care.

Mr. Stanton said he had several other witnesses who would swear the same as Jackson that the pit was perfectly dry, and that there was no sign of water.

Matthew McDonald said he had worked as a hewer in the colliery for 13 years, and had worked up to the 6th May in the Harvey seam. He was working in the back shift in number two gateway on the left hand side of the crossgate. He saw no appearance of dampness there, nor any sign of water. During the whole time he worked there he was never under the impression it was a damp place. There were two sets of men working between witness and Bell and Kelly.

By Mr. Atherley Jones : He never heard that the coal was damp in the direction of where Bell was working. He never heard of the presence of any water, in fact he did not know there was any water there until it came away.

Robert Turton, hewer, said he had worked at the colliery for 33 years, and up to the time of the accident worked within 30 yards of where the water broke in. He was never troubled with water in any form, nor ever heard of the presence of any water there at all. He did see a "sup" of water on the extreme right hand of the gateway, but he could not say where it came from. A tub or two had to be taken out every night.

By the Coroner: Witness never saw anything to cause alarm.

By Mr. Atherley Jones Where he saw the water was at the place where Bell was working. It was damp there six weeks before the accident. It had never been perfectly dry at the right side, but that was the only place where he saw signs of dampness. He never heard of water trickling from the face at the place of the accident.

Mr. Atherley Jones said he was not desirous as far as he was concerned that his friend, Mr. Stanton should multiply evidence to show that the men were not apprehensive of any danger. Nobody supposed for one moment that if there was any apprehension of immediate danger these men would have worked there.

Mr. Stanton That is not my point. My point is that there was no water at all.

Mr. Atherley Jones My point is that there was some indication of dampness, which would give cause for the exercise of great caution. Secondly, which is my other point, that having regard to the proximity of the old abandoned Cassop workings, it was a most unsafe thing, without taking proper precautions by boring, to work a "long wall."

Allan Simpson said he was working back shift in the Cassop district, and saw no trace of any water in any part of the "long wall," except a little on the bottom.

A Juryman You mean you did observe a little water, but not sufficient to report upon.

Witness Yes.

Robinson Marshall, hewer, said he had worked in the East Hetton Colliery for 13 years. He worked one shift in the Cassop "long wall," which wan a back shift, on the 5th May. He worked about 30 yards from Bell, and saw no water there; in fact it was a very dry place. Witness never heard anything of Bell complaining of the presence of water. Witness was hewing, and if any water had appeared he must have seen it.

Benjamin Chipchase said he had been manager of the East Hetton Colliery for nine years. They commenced to work coal in the Cassop district in Jan., 1894. They subsequently worked "long wall," because the coal was so thin that it was impracticable to work it any other way. The thickness of the coal was only 2f t. 8in. Before working in this part of the pit witness had several consultations with Mr. Tate relative to getting all the information they could with reference to the Cassop old workings. It ended in an interview with Mr. Thomas Bell on April 1st, 1895.

Mr. J. Wilson, M.P. : A very appropriate day.

Continuing, witness said they discussed the old Cassop workings, and the result was that a circle was drawn on the prospective plan within which nothing had to be driven without boring. Witness was present when the circle was drawn on the plan, and a memorandum to the above effect endorsed on it. He believed there was fully 200 yards of coal lying between the outer edge of that circle and any old workings. They had never been troubled much with water, and the water in the "long wall" would make about one or two tubs a day. The seam lowered a little at the right hand, and all the water the "long wall" made naturally went to the lowest point, and the right hand was the lowest point in the "long wall." Ever since the "long wall" was commenced there was always a little water gathered at this low corner on the bottom of the seam. He never saw any water coming from the coal itself, and no one ever reported the presence of water sufficient to give them any trouble. As to the bore-holes they were put in with a view of letting them know when they were getting to a "hitch," as they did not want all the face taken off at once. They thought they were getting close to a seven-fathom "trouble," from which a lot of gas would come off, and prevent them working at the face of the coal. There was no idea of water at all when the bore-holes were made. The pit was a dry one, and the bore-hole gave off no water. On the morning of the 6th May, about 3.30, witness received information that some water had "come off" in the Cassop long wall. He immediately went out, and met the overman and deputy (Michael Ross and Thomas Morley), and asked them If any men were left in. They replied that there were some in the left-hand way. Witness went to the pit, and saw that the workings were flooded. Everything possible was done for those In the workings, and the pumps got to work. Since the accident witness had inspected the hole the in-rush of water had made, and found an opening in the face of the coal seven yards long It was about 36 yards from the extreme right end of the "long wall," and close to where Bell and Kelly were working.

At this juncture an adjournment was made for luncheon, Mr. Atherley Jones suggesting that a consultation with those who instructed him might narrow the issues of the case.

On resuming, Mr. Atherley Jones said as a result of the conference with Mr. J. Wilson, Mr. Plummer, and others, he should be able to limit his cross-examination of Mr. Chipchase to some considerable extent. It was not the intention on their part to suggest there was any criminal negligence on the part of either Mr. Chipchase or Mr. Tate. Their position resolved itself entirely into this. They suggested that in view of certain indications of the presence of water, probably a greater precaution should have been taken. Secondly, in view of the knowledge that was possessed of the old Cassop workings, it was a dangerous thing to work the long wall without taking the precautions which were prescribed by the Act. It was on this point he should question the witness.

Mr. Chipchase was then subjected to a severe cross-examination by Mr. Atherley Jones.

Mr. Atherley Jones: Merely for the information of the jury, you, under the rules, are responsible for the management and control of the colliery, and the direction of the officers and servants ? — Yes, sir.

When you came to the colliery you were aware that the old Cassop Colliery adjoined so far as its royalties were concerned the East Hetton Colliery ? — Yes, sir.

You were also aware that the old Cassop Colliery had been abandoned because it was drowned out ? — I think it was abandoned because it was not profitable to work it.

The Coroner said as far as he remembered they took away the route by which they conveyed, their coal. They were compelled to take away their level-crossing, and could not find any other means of conveyance.

Mr. Atherley Jones: And you were aware that the Cassop Colliery was a flooded colliery ? — Yes, sir.

And you were also aware that Mr. Bell, late H.M. Inspector of Mines, had been manager at that colliery ? — Yes, sir.

Can you tell me approximately when it was that the Cassop Colliery was abandoned ? — I think it was In the seventies, but can't say for sure.

It was abandoned, I think, when Mr. Bell was manager ? — No, it was some little time after Mr. Bell ceased to be manager.

At the East Hetton Colliery there are three seams worked, one of which is the Harvey ? — Yes, sir.

And the same seams were worked in the old abandoned Cassop Colliery ? — Yes, sir.

During the time Mr. Bell was manager of the Cassop Colliery the Harvey Seam was not being worked ? — I believe not, sir.

Mr. Bell: It was not then sunk to.

Mr. Atherley Jones: When you had this conference with Mr. Bell did you know that the Harvey Seam in the Cassop Colliery had been sunk to, or were you under the impression that it had not been sunk to ? — We knew it had been sunk.

Then I may take it that if the Cassop Harvey Seam had not been sunk to you might, as far as the Harvey Seam is concerned, have gone right up almost to the locality of the Cassop shaft? — Yes, sir.

Then Mr. Bell knew, and it was common ground between you, that the shaft at Cassop had been sunk down to the Harvey seam, and that some working had been done ? — Yes, sir.

Did you consult with Mr. Bell as to what extent the Cassop Harvey had been worked ? — I did, and be told me that it had not been worked to a very large extent.

The East Hetton workings crossed the boundary of the Cassop Harvey and went into the workings ? — No, not into the workings, but Into the royalty.

Did Mr. Bell tell you how far the Cassop Company had worked into that boundary? — Yes, he thought they had not worked very far.

Did he tell you his grounds for thinking they had not worked far ? — No, except from the information we got from other people, and by letters.

Beyond the letters was there any information you or Mr. Bell possessed as to the extent of the Cassop workings ? — We got certain information from old Dawson, of Cassop.

Do you know whether any plans were kept of. the workings in the Cassop Harvey ? — I never heard tell of any.

Then I may take it that you were quite In the dark as to the Cassop workings in the Harvey seam ? — As far as our information went they were worked very little. Our Idea was that had they been worked to any extent there would have been plans, and as we could not get plans we came to the conclusion they had not been worked..

Do you know whether Cassop Colliery was abandoned before the Mines Act of 1872 ? — I think it was.

And I may take it that prior to the Act coming into force, there was no obligation on the part of a Colliery Company to keep plans ? — That is so.

An official here stated for the information of those present that the Cassop Colliery was wound up in 1868.

Then I may take it that the circle referred to on the prospective plan was drawn by Mr. Bell, on the assumption that the Cassop Harvey had not been worked very far ? — Yes, sir.

And you understood you could work up to the circumference of that circle without boring ? — Yes, air.

Why was not the circle described on the working plan as well ? — Because both plans are to the same scale, and we compared them repeatedly.

There was one return which would have gone into the limits of the circle if it had been continued further, and you stopped it ? — Yes sir.

It seems to me if you had gone on with this "long wall" you must have struck the circle ? — Oh, no. A Juryman: The jury feel sure it would have cleared it.

Mr. Atherley Jones said he was not suggesting Mr. Chipchase was under the impression that they were approaching danger, otherwise they would have stopped. The only thing he suggested was that they might have taken greater precaution. He would draw their attention to section 49, rule 13, of the Coal Mines Regulation Act, which laid down that "where a place was likely to contain a dangerous accumulation of water, the working approaching that place should not at any point within 40 yards of that place exceed 8 feet in width — (and he would remind them that they were working 72 yards) — and there should be constantly kept a sufficient distance not less than 5 yards in advance at least one bore-hole near the centre of the working and sufficient flanking bore-holes on each side." Had that rule been adhered to, Mr. Atherley Jones continued, the lamentable accident of May last would not have occurred.

Continuing his cross-examination, Mr. Atherley Jones asked but for their being under the impression from the information they possessed that the old workings were far away they would have pursued the course laid down in the Act. — Mr. Chipchase: Of course.

Don't you think that in view of the fact that you were uncertain as to the exact locality of the Cassop old working, it was very un wise to open 72 yards of "long wall ?" — No, not on the information we had.

Don't you think from the uncertitude of the information, and not judging by subsequent events, it would have been much wiser for you to have adopted the course prescribed by the Act ? — If we did that we should always be boring.

Don't you consider there being no plans of the Cassop workings and no information that it was, to say the least, a hazardous thing to drive 72 yards of "long wall" instead of the 8 feet prescribed by the Act ? — The very fact of the absence of plans was a confirmation that the workings were not extensively worked.

Did you tell Mr. Bell you were working 72 yards of "long wall ?" — We told him we were going to work on the "long wall" principle.

And up to that time you had been working there on the "board and pillar system ?" — Yes, sir.

Of course it is a more profitable way of working coal by the "long wall ?" — Yes, for thin seams.

Cross-examined as to the bore holes, witness said there were two made, one on the 28th April, and one on the 5th May, and they were put in because they were coming close to the "seven fathom trouble."

Mr. Atherley Jones: You thought as long as you did not cross the circle marked on the plan that you could work freely ? — Yes, I thought we had 200 yards of solid coal.

Supposing Mr. Bell had not given you that circle, what would you have done ? — Very likely we should have gone a good deal nigher.

Well you would not as a matter of fact, because you would have been annihilated before.

But for the circle where would you have stopped ? — We might have gone within 200 yards of the Cassop shaft.

Mr. Stanton: Assuming you bad not worked the "long wall," but worked "board and pillar," what then ? — We should have holed sooner.

Therefore, working the "long wall" had nothing to do with the accident ? — Nothing whatever.

You work "long wall" in other parts of the pit ? — Yes, it depends upon the thickness of the coal.

By Mr. Bain: The Cassop shaft was distant about 350 yards from the holing.

Mr. Simon Tate, head mining engineer and agent to the Colliery Company, said they commenced to work the Cassop royalty in 1894. Before he commenced to work he made every effort to obtain information as to the extent of the workings in the Cassop Pit. He wrote Mr. Daglish. Mr. H. Wood, Mr. Ramsay, Mr. Armstrong, Mr. Hamilton, Sir Lindsay Wood, Mr. Gustard, and the Home Office. He could not discover any plans, and this supported his supposition that none existed. He had several interviews with Mr. Bell, and discussed the matter fully. On one occasion in 1894, Mr. Bell wrote him that in the Cassop Pit in the Harvey seam the workings extended on the north side 120 yards, on the east 155 yards, and on the west 75 yards. There were no figures as to the south. The circle was made as a result of a conversation with Mr. Bell, 300 yards from the Cassop shaft. The bore-holes were put in for fear of gas coming off the "trouble," and thus not allowing the face to be worked. Witness went round the place the day before the accident, and received no complaint from any of the men as to the presence of water.

Mr. Atherley Jones: Did you rely entirely on the information of Mr. Bell as to the old workings ? — If it had not been for what Mr. Bell told me, I should have gone within the radius of the circle.

Asked if he had information on the matter from anyone else, witness said Mr. White, viewer at Cassop, told him the Harvey seam at Cassop was very little worked, and Mr. Armstrong gave him similar information.

Mr. Atherley Jones: Can you tell me of any other colliery near an abandoned pit where they are working the "long wall ?" — Yes; I think you will find there are some.

Near an old pit, of which there are no plans ? — I can't say that.

No, and I don't think you can either with or without plans. Surely, if you are approaching abandoned workings where you are likely to be near a dangerous accumulation of water, the smaller opening you make in that direction the better ? — Yes; but this is different.

Mr. Atherley Jones : It has not turned out so in this instance, and I suggest you have made an unfortunate mistake.

Mr. Tate: I think not, sir.

The enquiry was then adjourned until the following morning.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print