On the evidence given at the inquests and from examinations of the mine and inquiry made by myself and the Assistant Inspectors, Mr. J. B. Atkinson and Mr. R. P. W. Oswald, I beg to submit the following report :—
The colliery is owned by the Saint Helen's Colliery and Brick Works Company, Limited. The directors are Mr. P. Wedgewood (Chairman), Mr. H. P. Senhouse, Mr. T. Carey, Mr. W. McGowan, and Mr. A. Helder; Mr. J. G. Mulcaster is secretary to the Company. None of these gentlemen are possessed of a technical knowledge of mining. The resident mining engineer, who is also the certificated manager, is Mr. J. H. Johnson. Mr. J. Davidson was certificated under manager; he was killed by the explosion. The agent's name given on the special rules posted at the mine at the time of the explosion was that of Mr. C. J. Croudace, a mining engineer and a shareholder in the company, living and practising in North Wales and who had lived and practised in Cumberland. Mr. Croudace did not admit that he was agent, but stated he was only consulting mining engineer to the Company. Mr. Joseph Morrison is overman, and a staff of four deputies in the Main seam where the explosion occurred had charge in their shifts of the different districts of the mine.
The colliery was commenced in the year 1877; coal was raised from the Upper or Ten Quarters seam in 1880; the shafts were deepened to the lower or Main seam, coal first being raised from it in September 1882. There are two shafts, 28j½ feet apart, situated about a mile north of the town of Workington and within a furlong of the sea shore. The shafts are both 119 fathoms deep, at which depth the Main seam is cut. The Ten Quarters seam lies at a depth of 85 fathoms, or 34 fathoms above the Main seam. One shaft is 10 feet 8 inches diameter and is downcast for air. It is fitted up with wood guides to the Main seam and coal from the Main seam is raised up it. The other shaft 11 feet 8 inches diameter is upcast for air. It is fitted up with wood guides to the Ten Quarters seam only. Coal is raised from the Ten Quarters seam, and if necessary men can be raised from the Main seam in a kibble. Water collecting in a sump at the bottom of the downcast shaft is drawn to the surface in water tubs. Both the shafts are rather damp. A Guibal fan, 12 feet wide and 36 feet diameter, ordinarily running at the rate of 55 revolutions per minute, exhausts the air from the mine. This fan is placed near the upcast shaft on the surface. Both the Ten Quarters and Main seams are being worked. The workings in the former seam direct from the shafts, are extensive. These workings had no connexion with the cause, and were affected only to a very limited extent by the effects of the explosion. The workings in the Main seam, as well as a small tract of Ten Quarters seam workings, approached from the Main seam across a downcast trouble, are shown on the annexed plan, and it was on this plane that the explosion took place.
The section of the Main seam at the shaft is as follows :—
| | Ft. | ins. | |
| Coal | 1 | 9 | Left on as roof in levels. |
| Slate | 0 | 3 | " " |
| Coal | 1 | 10½ | |
| Metal | 2 | 8 | |
| Coal | 3 | 0 | Bords holed for ventilation |
| Cannel | 0 | 5 | only in this coal |
| Coal | 1 | 7 | |
| Soft thill | 0 | 2 | |
| Thill | 5 | 2 | |
Near the patch of goaf to the west of the shaft level the section is :—
| | Ft. | ins. |
| Top coal | 1 | 8 |
| Black slate | 0 | 6 |
| Coal | 1 | 9 |
| Metal | 1 | 2 |
| Coal | 1 | 7 |
| Black slate | 0 | 1 |
| Spar coal | 0 | 8 |
| Cannel | 0 | 4 |
| Coal | 0 | 1 |
| Stone | 0 | 5 |
| Bottom coal | 0 | 9 |
| Hard thill. | | |
The general section of the seam in Hogg's and Gilmour's brows is as follows :—
| | Ft. | ins. | |
| Coal | 1 | 6 | Left on as roof. |
| Black stone | 0 | 4 | " " |
| Coal | 1 | 9 | |
| Metal | 1 | 3 | |
| Coal | 2 | 8 | |
| Cannel | 0 | 4½ | For a distance of about 370 yards |
| Coal | 0 | 2 | from the engine dip this part of |
| Stone | 0 | 5 | the seam was left on in Hogg's |
| Coal | 0 | 10 | and Gilmour's brows. |
The system of working is to form in the first instance pillars as shown on the plan, the removal of which as a second operation had been only recently commenced at the four points where goaf is shown. The general dip of the seam is to the south-west at the rate of 5 inches per yard. This inclination, however, varied locally. The field of coal is intersected by large dislocations, and is subject to the coal being nipped out. The levels or ends running nearly north end south, as well as all the haulage and some of the air ways, are driven 8 or 9 feet wide. Coal is left as a roof in these roads in order to obviate the use of timber; their general height is from 5 to 6 feet. The bords are 24 feet wide, but are driven narrow next the level on to which the coal is led, and, where the communication with another level is required for ventilation only, are often driven in the upper part of the seam only as well as narrow. The air ventilating the workings on the plane of the explosion descended the downcast shaft to the Main seam, where it was divided into 7 splits, the course of which can be understood by reference to the plan. It will be observed that the air ventilating the incline district and that passing down the engine dip had for some distance two intake air passages. The last monthly measurement of air made before the explosion was recorded in a book as follows :—
| Main Seam, 28 March 1888. |
| North brow and Ten Quarters | 7,310 | cubic feet per minute. |
| Incline | 6,480 | " " |
| East side of shaft level | 4,500 | " " |
| West side of shaft level | 5,130 | " " |
| East side of engine dip | 8,600 | " " |
| West side of engine dip | 3,830 | " " |
| Stables | 1,320 | " " |
| Total | 37,170 | " " |
All these splits were regulated by ordinary regulating doors or openings in the frame-work of large doors on haulage roads. The haulage of the coal to the shaft is effected by horses or ponies, by a self-acting incline, and by an engine worked by compressed air piped down the downcast shaft from the surface. The air engine hauls the coal up the engine dip by means of a rope in trains of from 6 to 14 tubs at the rate of 6 miles per hour; the empty tubs run into the mine by. gravitation, taking the rope with them. There are landings at the bottom of the engine dip and at four intermediate points. The inclination of the engine dip is about 3 inches per yard. From the bottom of the engine dip Hogg's and Gilmour's brows rise at the rate of about 2½ inches per yard, until near the face, where they commence to dip. The coal was led down these brows by horses. Part of the coal from the places next Hogg's brow was brought out to the engine dip by the return air way through the nip out. The dip parallel to the engine dip is used as a travelling way for men and horses for its whole length. The bord parallel to the incline is similarly used. The ordinary or coal-working shift in the Main seam and adjacent track of Ten Quarters seam comprised 160 persons. There is only one shift of hewers, work commencing about 6 a.m. and ending about 2 p.m. About 200 tons of coal was raised daily from the Main seam and adjacent tract of Ten Quarters seam. From the coal and adjacent strata of the Main seam when first exposed gas issues freely, and where the coal is moist the issue is accompanied by a hissing noise known as singing. The mine was worked with locked safety lamps, except in the vicinity of the downcast shaft, where naked lights were allowed. The lamp cabin is near the downcast shaft, and here safety lamps were examined and lighted. The vicinity of the downcast shaft was lighted by electric glow lamps. The workings are generally dry and dusty. At the extreme end of the shaft level some workings are wet. It was stated at the inquests, and confirmed afterwards by examination, that both Hogg's and Gilmour's brows were wet for 60 yards from the face, and it was further stated at the inquest that 150 gallons of water in the 24 hours was removed in tubs from these places. There is some dampness at one or two other points. With these exceptions the passages are dry. For some days before the explosion Gilmour's brow had not been occupied, and no water had been led out of it during that time.