Seaham Colliery Disaster
Extracted from the Annual Mines Inspectors Report for 1871
Report of James Willis (page 10)
The adjourned inquiry into the circumstances connected with the explosion which
took place at Seaham Colliery on the 25th of October last, was held at the Station Hotel,
Seaham, before Mr. C. Maynard, coroner. Mr. Willis and Mr. Dickinson, Government
Inspectors of Mines, were present. Mr. Philipson, of Newcastle, solicitor, watched the
proceedings on behalf of the owners of the colliery, and Mr. Folkard discharged a similar
duty in the interest of the Durham Miners' Mutual Confident Association. Mr. Crawford,
President, and Mr. Patterson, Agent of the Durham Miners' Association, were present.
A large number of the miners connected with the Seaham Colliery were also present.
The Coroner having read the evidence taken at the last inquiry,
Mr. William Dakers, viewer, was then called. He said, "I wish to correct my former
evidence with reference to a stopping being put in near the stables. The Coroner had
read, 'We put in stoppings to prevent the fire getting to the stables.' I was not near
at the time. The stoppings were put in by the exploring party. I left the workmen at
their request. They urged me several times to leave for the purpose of procuring
more assistance as we were getting on so slowly. The stoppings were put in at ten
o'clock on the Thursday night. There was no possibility of the men being got out
alive after meeting with the afterdamp. In going inbye the afterdamp was standing at
the foot of No. 1 bank, and we thought it impossible for the men to be alive. We drove
the afterdamp back as we drove the air in. (Mr. Dakers here explained, from a plan
which was laid upon the table, that it was impossible for the men to be recovered alive.)
At No. 2 bank head both returns were choked up with afterdamp. I came up, and in
going past the fall I saw the explorers sitting, and they said it was impossible to get
past the first crossing in the north way. The crossing was blown down. There
was afterdamp in the east and west ways. When we got to the stables there was
no person met. I met the men opposite the Seaton shaft. I was then going to
bank for the purpose of consulting with some gentlemen who were in the office.
Before blocking up the mine we had a consultation as to what should be done.
Mr. John Taylor, Mr. L. Wood, Mr. R. F. Matthews, Mr. Hepplewhite, and
Mr. Turnbull, Hetton-le-Hole, were present. I cannot say whether or not any of the men
were present. The resolution to seal up the workings was unanimously come to ; there
was no division.
"The consultation was held about one o'clock on the Thursday, about 13 hours after
the explosion occurred. The workings were sealed up in consequence of what the men
reported. They said they had seen the fire, and they considered the sooner the pit was
closed the better.
The Coroner. "Laws and Dawson reported the extent of the fire.
"After hearing the evidence of the men it was thought the only thing that could be
done was to get the pit sealed, a second explosion being anticipated. At that time we were
under the impression that the explosion had occurred at the other end of the workings.
I went down the pit after this arrangement was come to to mark off the places where the
seals had to be put in. The principal part of the smoke came out of the east return, but I
cannot speak of the west return. The nearest water was at the shaft. The stoppings
were sealed up on Friday night the 27th of October, and they were kept in until the
16th of December. We commenced on the 16th December to open Out the sealed
portion of the mine. I was down the pit in company with Mr. Thompson, underviewer,
and several miners. There were also Mr. Gustard, Mr. Laverick, and Mr. John Dakers.
We went to the south stopping first. At two o'clock we drew the 4-inch plug, when
the gas at once came through. We allowed it to run for some time, and then we took
out the plug of the second stopping, and after the gas had run off we came to take the
plug out of the intake stopping. After the running of the gas had somewhat abated, we
commenced to take down the brickwork. On Monday morning, after the gas had
cleared away, I got to the staple. On Wednesday morning following we examined a
portion of the pit up to the edge of the fall at No. 2 Bank head, where the gas had
sufficiently cleared away. There had not been any alteration of the mine. The returns
were filled with gas. By the time we had got to the North station the bodies of the
men had all been found. After the last body had been taken away I examined the stable
end where the fire had been. The stables are 30 yards in length ; nine bundles of hay
were consumed in the hay board. The coal was burnt 2 feet deep for a distance
of about 13 yards in-bye from the stables. There was a hay-board, and
it was totally burnt out. The stables were not totally burnt ; a hay rack was
burnt further in. There was a chock burnt out from top to bottom. Some mason
work had fallen down. The greatest force of the explosion appeared to be at
No. 2 Bank and at the bottom of the Main Coal staple, and there were no signs
of force on the in-bye side further than 200 yards beyond the stables which were
on fire. From the result of my inspection I had indication of fire into the north
Main Coal where the doors go into the standage. My opinion is that the explosion
took place at the No. 2 Bank head. There are traces of the explosion both in-bye and
out-bye. I saw symptoms of force at the bottom of No. 3 shaft ; this, I think, was a
continuation of the explosion from No. 2 Bank head. I am judging from the way in
which the stuff was blown about, and from the direction of the force of the explosion. I
think there had been a fall at No. 2 Bank head immediately previous to the explosion
which had liberated the gas, which I think had fired upon Spence. This (producing a
lamp) is Spence's lamp. His body was found at the in-bye end of the bank head. His
lamp had been damaged by the explosion, but the threads of the screw at the bottom of
the lamp have not been damaged. My opinion is that the bottom of the lamp had been
screwed off previous to the explosion ; the threads would have been torn if the lamp
bottom had been forced off at the time of the explosion. The gauze of the lamp has not
been found. The roof at No. 2 Bank head was metal stone. There were baulks of
timber supporting the roof from one end to the other. The baulks were 2 feet 6 inches
apart and 8 feet high to the under side. The roof is now 4 feet higher than it was before.
That is the point where I think the explosion took place. There was no damage done
to the furnace. There were no symptoms of an explosion nearer the furnace than 100
yards, and these in the intake. We measure our quantities of air once every fortnight.
The last measurement prior to the explosion was on the 12th of October, when the
quantity passing the place where Hutchinson's shot was fired was 79,000 feet per minute,
thus afterwards split, viz. : North Main coal, 6,000, Main coal staple, 45,000, and Silksworth
way, 28,000 cubic feet per minute. The 28,000 feet per minute would pass
the scene of the explosion. Gas was reported to me in August 1869. At the Old South
way end there are four pillars where I have seen gas coming off the goaf, but I have not
known it show at this point until the furnace has been out for 24 hours. I have reports
from the two overmen and the master wasteman. They are daily reports. If there is
any gas it is always specially reported to me. The lofting at No. 2 Bank head was
examined by me four or five days previous to the explosion. It was my usual weekly
examination. We have no special orders about examining particular places, but we are
instructed to examine daily any place suspected of containing gas. The lofting is not
a place where gas might be expected to lodge, as there is no coal seam at the top of it,
and it is well ventilated. The lofting is 8 chains from the goaf on the north side, and
10 chains on the south side. There are stoppings on both sides betwixt the intake and
the return air courses, in some cases stone and some brick. So far as I knew, the way
was clear of gas. I can only account for the explosion by a fall having taken place at
No. 2 Bank head and liberated the gas from the roof. I cannot say there was any
necessity for Spence to have his lamp unscrewed, but naked lights are allowed at that
part of the mine. I have no other reason, except that the threads are not injured, for
thinking that Spence's lamp was unscrewed. My opinion is that only one explosion
took place, but it is possible there might be one at the pipe which conveys gas from
the surface to light the bottom of the pit, and which passes the place where Hutchinson
was working. I did not notice what state the gas pipe was in the first time I was down,
as I directed my attention principally to getting in-bye to the men ; the pit was all
broken up where Hutchinson had fired his shot.
By Mr. Willis. "The length of the lofting prior to the explosion was about 125 feet ;
the height above the top of the timber about 3 feet 6 inches ; the width about 18 feet.
I think that the cavity might contain sufficient gas to do the injuries described. The
height after the explosion was 20 feet ; previous to the explosion it was only 16 feet.
The cavity has been there for over 12 years. I made an examination about 10 months
ago when it was quite clear. It was the wasteman's duty to examine it and report to me.
I was aware that open lights were exposed underneath the cavity. We have a similar
lofting further down, where there are sloping spouts to carry air into them, but in the
cavity where the explosion took place there was no such means for ventilation. The
report, in all cases when gas is found, comes direct to me. I have never received any
report of gas having been discovered at the places mentioned. I have not found any
signs of gas about the returns, and I have examined very minutely the furnace and
have not discovered anything. The whole of the returns go past the furnace and are
united about 100 yards before reaching it. Where Hutchinson, who fired the shot, was
working was in the intake near the gas pipe. The size of the gas pipe is 2½ inches
down Nos. 1 and 2 pits, and where the shot was fired 1½ inch. The pressure of gas
to force the air down the pit was equal to 13 inches of water. The ventilating power
was 3 inches. Supposing the gas to have leaked out of the pipe it would have gone
towards the cavity I have spoken of, and also up the north staple. The men had been
alive for some time after the explosion, as they had tried to save themselves from being
suffocated by afterdamp.
By Mr. Dickinson. "Another indication that the men had been alive after the explosion
is that some writing was found on some boards. The decision to close up the pit
was made at two p.m. on Thursday. The masons went down for that purpose that
evening. Dawson, Laws, Strong, and Murray first saw the fire. There was a very great
noise like the cracking of stone, &c. I was in to about 30 yards from the fire, and did
not see anything of it. There was a great quantity of smoke, which was very injurious
to the eyes. The men pressed me to go out of the mine to arrange for getting more air
in. A second attempt was not made to get to the men ; if we had done so we should
have risked other men's lives. The writing on the board records that the men were
alive up to 10 o'clock, and the resolution to seal up the mine was come to three hours
after the time it is now known some of the men were alive. I do not recollect that I
told the viewers before they had decided to close the mine that no gas had been seen
in the pit for a year. The ventilation had entirely ceased, and the fear of gas coming
from the goaves was the principal feature in the decision the viewers arrived at. At that
time we were under the impression that the explosion had taken place in the far-in
workings, and if that had been the case it was impossible for any of the men to be alive.
If a vigorous effort had been made after the hay fire had died out, if it did die out,
I do not think that the coal that would then be on fire could have been put out.
Dawson and Laws reported that they had seen 40 yards of fire. I have examined
the water standage near the shaft for an accumulation of gas, but I found none. I am
quite sure that the explosion at the Bank head caused the whole of the damage.
By Mr. Folkard. "We took the evidence of the men Dawson and Laws before we
determined to close the mine. No one in particular presided at the consultation of viewers.
I am quite certain that it was not before 10 o'clock that we commenced to put in the wall
stoppings. The men were down getting the bricks ready before that time. I did not
see the fire myself. We found a horse and set of tubs near the No. 2 Bank head, and I
came to the conclusion that the driver was there. I set some men to seek for him under
neath the fall, and Spence was found. The boy was afterwards found in another direction.
There was a paraffin lamp at the No. 2 Bank head. It is not known whether the paraffin
lamp was burning at the time of the explosion or not. It should have been put out at
five o'clock that evening.
Cross-examined by Mr. Philipson. "I am of opinion that there has been one fall
before the explosion, and one after. I never heard any complaints from the men respecting
the ventilation of the workings. The viewers were unanimous in sealing up the pit.
Thomas Hutchinson, who was the only survivor from the explosion, was called, and
bore traces of injury received. He said: "I am a stoneman and have worked six years
at Seaham Colliery. I was in the pit when the explosion occurred. At the time of the
explosion I and my son were widening the drift to No. 3 workings. Harrison set me to
work that night. There was no slackness of the ventilation. We were blasting the side
down. We commenced drilling between eight and nine o'clock. In order to prevent the
gas pipe from being broken by the shot we stayed it up so as to keep it out of the way,
and just before lighting the shot I looked up the bank for the purpose of seeing if I could
observe any person coming. I saw the usual gas light near the engine house. My son
lighted a piece of touch. I went out-bye for the purpose of preventing any person from
coming, and my son walked away. I went into the mouth of the new drift, about 30 yards
out of the way of the shot, and the shot and fire both came together. After the explosion
when I was lying I shouted out for my son, but could not hear him, so I made my way
to the shaft. After I had been a short time at the shaft I met with Mr. Thompson and
one of my marrows, and I told them that I believed that the explosion had taken place
from our shot, but I really believe it did not. The gas pipe sometimes leaked and then
we lighted the leaks. We used to report to Harrison when a leakage was observed. We
considered it much better to light the leakage than let it escape into the pure air. The
fire came out-bye. I heard only one report. I cannot say that I was insensible. I felt
stupid like. If there was an explosion after my shot I did not hear it. I think the
report of my shot met the report of the explosion.
By Mr. Willis. "We have frequently broken the gas pipe down, which caused a leak,
and we used to light the leak. We had about 9 or 10 inches of powder in an inch
gauge for the shot. If we had had a moment's notice we could both have saved our lives.
There was no possibility of any gas where we were exploding as there was sufficient air to
drive a windmill. Certainly there was not more than one explosion.
By Mr. Dickinson. "I never made a statement that the gas had fired by my shot but
to Mr. Thompson.
By the Coroner. "The time I was deputy the pit was in a good condition, and during
the whole time that I have been upon the colliery there has been capital ventilation.
Joseph Thompson. "I am under-viewer at Seaham Colliery. I was out of the pit at
the time of the explosion. I heard of it about two minutes afterwards. I went down
immediately.
The witness then gave detailed evidence, agreeing in all important points with that of
Mr. Dakers, relative to the exploration of the mine, until the fire at the stables was
discovered. He then proceeded : "After the sealed portion was opened, I found James
Bowman 600 yards from the shaft. I found Laing 2,700 yards from the shaft. He was
not at all burnt. I found a board which has already been produced. Further in I found
a group of six men. About 200 yards further I found other eight. I fancy that Spence
at the time of the explosion, has had his lamp bottom off. I think the explosion was
caused by gas forcing the stone down, and then igniting at Spence's lamp. I last
examined the lofting on the 28th of April last. I saw no indications of gas at the time.
No gas to my knowledge has been seen in the returns or the intake. The men have
never reported the presence of gas. The stone displaced was of a very hard nature. My
attention was drawn to the place where Hutchinson was working. I did not examine the
place at the time, but I have done so since. The gas pipe is down the pit. It is broken
just where a shot has been fired. I did not notice any old leakage in the pipe. I do
not think the explosion could have taken place at the furnace.
By Mr. Willis. "There was no indication of a fall having taken place previously.
The gas pipe where Hutchinson was working was twisted in two or three places. The
water standage is examined almost every day.
By Mr. Dickinson. "The lofting above the timber the last time I saw it and
measured it was about 6 feet high, which makes its cubical capacity about 8,000 feet.
There was no possibility of any gas accumulating in an old drift at the water standage.
I am of the firm opinion that the explosion took place at No. 2 bank. I met about 20 men
proceeding to bank and all they said to me was 'She is all on fire.' We were then
drawn up the shaft.
By Mr. Willis. "I have never had any complaints about any gas having been found.
By Mr. Folkard. "At the consultation the men, Laws and Dawson, were examined,
and in consequence of what they said we came to the conclusion to seal up that portion
of the pit.
By the Foreman (Dr. Smith). "I did not hear any 'jowling' or signals from the men
beyond the fire.
By the Coroner. "I found one of the boards Mr. Dakers has produced. The writing
on it was 'Nine o'clock. All alive. But Hay died at 7. D. Ballantine.'
Robert Todd. "I am an overman at No. 3 Seaham Pit. My duty is to examine and
see the pit is safe before the men go to work. I was not in the pit when the explosion
took place. I made an examination of the pit on the 25th October at half past 9 o'clock
in the morning, and I found all in proper order. Witness described from the plan of
the workings where he had examined. I was not up to the timber that day. When
I examined the lofting I generally got upon a loaded tub. I never saw the presence or
signs of gas on the lofting. I believe that I made an examination of the lofting four
or five days prior to the explosion. I have never heard any of the men complain. I
found gas on the 15th August 1869 in the west side of the workings. The furnace on
that occasion had been out 24 hours. I never saw any gas near the water standage.
I came out of the pit on the 25th October about five o'clock. I did not detect any gas.
I looked at the pipes and found all right.
By Mr. Folkard. "I could not get to the extreme height of the roof at the lofting
when standing on the top of the tubs. I could touch within three feet with my lamp.
I have been 10 years an overman.
By the Coroner. "I cannot remember any person complaining respecting gas. She is
a very clean pit.
Mr. Willis. "It is hardly a fair question to ask, but have you ever looked for gas ?—
Yes.
William Laws. "I am back overman. At the time this happened I was not in the
pit. I went down the pit immediately and joined the exploring parties and continued
with them until the fire was discovered. I proceeded with Mr. Dakers over the heavy
fall. We could not proceed further in consequence of the afterdamp and smoke. We
tried to get in by driving the afterdamp, and we failed. When I discovered that we
could not proceed further I requested Mr. Dakers to get some more air in, and he did so.
I had not seen fire but I knew that there was fire, as I heard the reports of the breakage
of stone and also felt the heat. We made a canvas frame and carried it in before us.
Strong and Murray had the canvas frame. Strong called my attention to a fire which
extended across the main way. We all left. On going towards the shaft we met
Mr. Hepplewhite, and we reported to him that we had seen fire. He asked if it could
be seen and we told him that it could. He was returning with us for the purpose of
seeing the fire, when he said it was no use running any further risk. This was about
one o'clock on Thursday afternoon. There was no chance of getting the men out.
By Mr. Willis. "There was no possibility of any man getting past the fire alive.
The fire that we saw was from the hay board. It appeared to me that it was coal that
was burning. When I was in the pit I always considered that I was in the safest in
the north of England. I never heard of any complaints by the men.
By Mr. Folkard. "I told Mr. Dakers after the consultation that there was fire, and
a very great quantity of it, right across the main way. I also told Mr. Dakers that
I could see about 20 yards before me.
By Mr. Dickinson. "The reason I took such a fright at the fire was because I knew
there was danger of a second explosion. I would have gone in with any man.
Edward Dawson said : "I am overman of No. 3 pit. I was in the pit at three
o'clock in the morning previous to the explosion, and came out at ten o'clock. I
examined the face. I merely looked at my lamp to see if there was any gas. I did
not examine the lofting at No. 2 bankhead. I have been back overman for eight or
nine years. There have been four or five falls at the bankhead lofting. The last fall
took place about 12 months ago. I examined the lofting whenever a fall took place.
There never was the slightest indication of gas. Occasionally I have put my lamp up
to the baulks, but I never went right up to them. No complaint of gas has ever been
made to me. I was up to the fire. My opinion is that there were 40 yards of fire.
I assisted to put in a canvas brattice. I saw Hepplewhite, Turnbull, and Thompson and
told them what I had seen. I offered to show them the fire, but after we had gone a
few yards Turnbull thought it not right to go. Mr. Thompson agreed with Turnbull
and thought it would be advisable to consult at bank. I sometimes found gas in the
goaf. Sometimes it would take the lamp and sometimes it would not. I never
'booked' having seen any gas in the goaf. I expected the goaves to occasionally give
off gas. The reason we left the fire and never returned was because we had not
sufficient force. We had no means of grappling with the fire. Laws and I considered that
it was impossible to get through the fire. There was 12 feet of space above the timbers
at the lofting. I examined the place with my lamp. I don't think it was possible to
get past the fire or to get it under. I never went back again to see whether it had
abated or increased.
By Mr. Willis. "Mr. Turnbull was acquainted with the pit.
By Mr. Dickinson. "I frequently saw gas in the goaves. Sometimes I found it and
sometimes not. It was not a regular thing that the gas would take the lamp. Some
times it would and sometimes not. I am speaking of the working goaf. I couldn't
say how far from the working face. I cannot say what day I saw gas in the goaf.
It is an unusual thing to find it in the goaf. We take the lamp when we travel. It
is not a thing which would be reported or 'booked' if gas took the lamp. That is
only done when gas is towards the working places.
"Laws and I did not try to deal with the fire because we hadn't plenty of strength.
The 20 men all ran away, and there were only four of us left.
"It was the master wasteman's duty to examine the pit in the water standage.
By Mr. Folkard. "My object in going there at three o'clock was to examine the mine
before the men went to work. I did'nt examine the lofting when I got to the bank
head, but I put my lamp up to the baulks. It is between six and seven feet high. The
extreme height of the lofting above all the timbers is about 12 feet more.
Mr. Dickinson. "You have often seen the gas coming off the goaves, but cannot tell
whether it was 12 months ago, or any time. Have you seen any within a week or a
fortnight, in any place ?
"No, I have looked carefully.
"I thought there were 40 yards of fire. I have been down the pit since it was opened,
and I am satisfied now there were 40 yards of fire. I attended the consultation of
viewers, and told them there were 40 yards. Nobody saw it after we left it. I was
asked if there was fire, and I said 'Yes.' They asked me the length, and I said 40 or
50 yards. The hay was all burnt. The rack was burnt out at the bottom, but some of
the rack was standing. I am of opinion now that the fire was as great as I thought on
the day I reported it.
By Mr. Philipson. "I considered the lofting sufficiently timbered to protect the roof.
There is gas in every goaf. It does not come from the goaf into the returns. We have
plenty of ventilation to keep it all clear if any did come in. When the ventilation ceased
there was nothing to sweep away the gas. That is one of the things to be apprehended
after an explosion, when the ventilation is taken away. At the time I was in-bye with
Laws I could not tell where the explosion had taken place. We could form no opinion
about it. We had no water to apply to the fire. We had no means of grappling with the
fire at all. We could not possibly have done anything to get in to the men. It was
impossible to get through. If anything could have been done it would have been done.
Only two men, Laws and myself, were left at the last at the fire. The other men had all
come away as soon as they saw the fire. We could have done nothing with it ourselves.
The pit is examined by deputies before the men go in. Thomas Strong and Allan
Murray were the two men who were with us at the fire.
Allan Murray. "I was with Laws and Dawson when they came upon the fire. We
had a canvas to protect us from the afterdamp. We got about 12 yards from a body
of fire. It seemed to be a very large fire. I think it was useless to attempt to put the
fire out, because it was so bright and seemed so large.
Thomas Strong said : "I was in the pit after the explosion. We were forced back by
afterdamp and smoke, and then came upon the fire. I saw the fire and called the
attention of Dawson and Laws to it. The men who were with Dawson, Laws, Murray,
and myself left us. I think it was impossible to have put the fire out without loss of
life. If we had put more air on the fire, it would have got larger.
William Taylor said : "I have been a miner 35 years, and am now employed in
repairing the doors and waggon ways. I have been frequently in the lofting at No. 2
bank head. I used my safety lamp. I always put the lamp to the top of the lofting to
see if it was clear of gas. I never saw any indications of gas. The height I got with
the lamp was about five or six feet. The last time I was in the lofting was in September.
It was all right at that time. The place was cool, and the air circulated freely. I never
heard any of the men complain of the ventilation.
By Mr. Willis. "I had charge of the lofting. I had to keep it clean. I know the
other lofting in the out-bye side. I looked after both of them. It was the overman's
duty to attend to the ventilation of the pit. A 'sconce' had been put into the lofting
in the out-bye side, but it was not through any fear of gas accumulating.
By Mr. Dickinson. "There was always a good current of air. I do not know where
the gas which caused the explosion came from. Todd, the overman, ordered me to keep
the lofting clear. It was the overman's duty to examine the lofting. I have frequently
seen Todd examine it ; he went on the top. I can solemnly swear that I have seen Todd
on the top of the lofting since last April.
Mr. Folkard. "I always examined this place when I was in it. I always put my lamp
to the top and examined it for gas. The air circulated freely. I was not always with
Todd when he examined the place.
The Coroner said : "the witness was not to be depended upon, for it was evident he
said anything that was put into his mouth.
Mr. Folkard said that "having made that plain he would not ask him any more
questions.
By Mr. Philipson. "It was my duty to attend to the lofting. I always went to the
top, but never found any gas. Todd may have been a hundred times at the place for
anything I know.
William Armstrong said : "I am a mining engineer, and live at Pelaw House. I was
not present until the pit was walled in ; but I have been in and examined it thoroughly
since it was reopened. I saw the gas pipe which had been destroyed, and the place at
which the shot was fired ; the break in the gas pipe being 20 yards from the shot. I
then came to the north way end, and saw abundant evidence of great force, and some
few evidences of fire. I then came to the Main Coal staple, and found it disarranged.
The blast had evidently got room for expansion and gone up the pit. In no one instance
could I observe the stone stoppings destroyed. They were pushed over, but no perforation
had been made. I then came up to a crossing at No. 2 bank, which had been blown
out, and there were plenty of indications of the blast having gone out-bye. At the
crossing there was a high recess, which had been occasioned by a trouble running across,
and the cross-timbers were there intact. The roof then came down to the level of the
seam, and shortly afterwards we came on the second fall, which extended to the wheel of
the incline, which was heavily timbered. We then passed on to the stables, and immediately
we passed the incline wheel there was plenty of evidence that the blast had
passed in-bye. At the stables the brattice wall had been destroyed and carried in-bye.
In the hay board I found a truss of hay unconsumed, and ashes of hay that had been
consumed. A 'cog' on the opposite side of the way had been burnt down. In the
in-bye side of the hay board there were evident signs of fire. The fire must have been
intense, as the coal was coked a considerable distance into the seam. Beyond this was a
hay-rack 10 or 15 yards long, and it was partly consumed; the hay totally so, and the
timber on the opposite side had evidently been on fire. There were no signs of fire or blast
or injury beyond the caution board. It had exhausted itself there and passed into the
return. I was quite satisfied that the seat of the explosion was at the fall at No. 2 bankhead.
At the out-bye side there had been a very considerable fall of stone. The frames
of the stone there were five or six feet thick, but much less on the in-bye side. The
timber had been placed in the wall side at short intervals. There seemed to be no mode
of ventilation except the stopping of the tubs on the bank head, and this would throw
the air up and so ventilate the top. The only way I can account for the explosion is
that a large quantity of gas has been lying behind a layer of stone, and so forced the
stone and timber away, and found its way into the air-way. The initial force of gas is
very large, and the force would immediately mix with its complement of air. The
master shifter was found near, and it is immaterial whether his lamp was open or shut.
If it was open the gas would explode, and if not the gas would burst through the lamp.
No Davy lamp can resist more than eight feet a second pressure. My impression is that
there has been no collection of gas in the lofting. I think it is impossible to ascertain
the initial velocity of gas. I did not examine the crossings 300 yards from the shaft,
near the water standage. I think it is impossible any explosion could occur where
Hutchinson fired his shot ; and I am therefore brought to the conclusion that it was
caused by the pent-up gas forcing the stone down. I found no symptoms of fire at No. 2
bank-head. I think the explosion and the firing of Hutchinson's shot was merely a
curious coincidence. Supposing there had been an accumulation of gas in the lofting,
and a depression of the barometer took place, the gas would have come down towards
the lamp. I heard Taylor's description of the mode of cleaning the loft, and I consider
his examination good enough.
By Mr. Willis and Mr. Dickinson. "I hold that the pressure of gas would force the fall.
Some of the frames of stone which had fallen at the bank head were five or six feet thick.
I do not believe there could be any accumulation of gas at the lofting to cause an explosion,
because the tubs always stood under it before going down the incline, and would
force the fresh air through it very frequently. I have known many instances in my
practice of these outbursts of gas. The initial force of gas has not been determined, but
it is very large, and when mixed with air highly explosive. We have evidence that the
master shifter (Spence) was found a short way above the fall, and whether his lamp was
open or shut was immaterial. If open there would be a light for the gas to fire at; if shut
it would be burst open by the pressure of the gas. There would be an enormous expansion
of gas, for 100 cubic yards of gas would be immediately expanded to 28,000 cubic
yards of highly expansive air to find an outlet, in-bye, and out-bye. I account for the
scorching of timber at the more distant points by the theory that particles of fiery coal
dust would be carried along by the blast with velocity, and deposited at various points.
Even if the mode of examination in the pit were lax I hold there is no other way in which
this explosion could have been caused than that which I have described. With 78,000
feet of air going past, it was not possible that the pit could have fired at Hutchinson's
shot, and I do not think that shot could have forced out sufficient gas to cause an
explosion. It was an outburst of gas which caused the Jarrow explosion in 1830, and that
is the first instance of the kind I have experienced. As to the fire I do not think that in
the absence of water it was possible to put it out. By carrying in air past the fire they
would only have driven in the gas and killed the men the sooner.
By Mr. Folkard. "It would not be possible to get the men out. The explorers might
well be alarmed at the fire. The whole pit was saturated with gas. They did right to
turn back from the fire. Once, as an explorer, I was placed in a similar position myself.
We came up to a blaze of fire, and I can assure you that I was not more than three
minutes in getting out of the place. It would be a case of extreme hazard, and the
witness who has said that he had no fear does not, in my opinion, possess a man's feelings.
He must have had fear under such circumstances. I think the lofting ought to have been
examined once a fortnight. The mere holding up of a lamp in the lofting would have
been sufficient to detect the presence of gas.
Matthew Ranson said: "I am a stoneman. In the January of 1871 I worked at the
lofting where there had been a fall. Temporary timber was at first put in, but in the
February following permanent timbering was put in. The baulks were 12 by 14 inches
square. We continued to work at the lofting till April, and during that time we generally
worked with a naked light. Occasionally we used a paraffin lamp.
By Mr. Willis. "I never saw any gas ; a good current of air passed through the top
of the timbering. When the tubs were there the current was rather stronger.
John Dunn said : "I am a coal miner and work in No. 3 pit. After the explosion
I went to the pit and asked Mr. Thompson to allow me to go down. Five or six other
men went down with me. We went to the drift of No. 2, but we could see nothing but
the broken gas pipe. We could not remain in the pit on account of the stythe. I never
heard of any complaint about the ventilation. My father was one of the men who was
killed. I did not wish to search further for my father, because I could not get in-bye.
I think that all was done that could be done. I have never heard the men complain of
the ventilation of No. 3 pit ; there was always plenty of air where I was.
William Hepplewhite said : "I am a gamekeeper. I went down the pit on the day
the bodies were found. I saw that the stables had been on fire. I saw a piece of hay
and three pokes of corn in the hay board. I also saw a prop which had not been burnt
through. I went further in and saw all the bodies. I saw that two doors had been
opened to let the after-damp go down there. I found my father's body behind a door
away from the flat. A tin of grease was close beside him. The small opening round the
door had been filled up to prevent the after-damp getting into the place. My father was
in the Downs explosion, but came round by the returns and so escaped. I believe the
watches had stopped at 10 minutes to 6. A figure "6" was chalked close to the hands
of one of the bodies. I found no writing whatever where my father lay. I believe the
men had lived for a considerable time after the explosion, as the way where they were
found was much trodden down. There were also seats in the wall side, where the men
had been sitting. The coal was burnt a little at the in-bye and out-bye side of the stables.
I do not know anything more relative to the explosion.
Mr. Smith. "Are you satisfied that all was done that was possible to save your father?
No. I would rather have seen a second attempt made to get to the men. I heard the
men say that morning that they were afraid to go into the pit.
Mr. Willis. "Are you a pitman ? I was until I was 16 years of age. I am now
a gamewatcher. Supposing the fire could have been got out do you think the men
would have been recovered alive ? Yes. How do you arrive at that conclusion ?
Because the men had lived so long. You may suppose they had lived for a week, but
are you of opinion, knowing that there was fire-damp and smoke in the returns, that the
men, supposing the fire had been overcome, could have been got out alive ? My opinion
is that the fire could have been got out ; the smoke had gone through the open doors.
By Mr. Smith. "The whole of the men had their clothes on.
By Mr. Willis. "My father had two or three lamps beside him, and I believe he was the
last man alive. I have not given my opinion about the likelihood of getting out the men
without considering the ventilation.
By Mr. Folkard. "I know this pit ; there was a cistern of water close to the seat of the
fire. The water was close opposite the fire ; it was on the right hand side of the hay
board.
Mr. Folkard. "Did you see the boards produced by Mr. Dakers ? I did not. All I saw
was the figure 6* written on a piece of slate lying opposite one of the men's hands. I saw
several of the men's watches ; the last one stopped at 10 minutes to six o'clock. I think
that watch belonged to Bousfield.
Mr. Willis. "The watches do not indicate much.
By Mr. Folkard. "At the time I worked in the pit Mr. Burns was viewer. I frequently
saw Mr. Burns examine the bank head. I never saw any gas at the place. I do not
know whether Mr. Burns ever found any, but I was only a young lad at the time, and
the officials never let us know anything about the gas.
Mr. Philipson. "You saw the two doors standing open with your own eyes ? No, I
did not, but their position was described to me by men who have lost their friends in a
similar way to these men.
Robert Todd, who stated that he desired to make an explanation with regard to the
evidence of the witness Taylor, was recalled. He said : "I think my evidence with regard
to the lofting has been misunderstood. Really there was no lofting at No. 2 bank head,
because the timbering at that place consisted of baulks of wood ; there was not a close
lofting ; there was a passage between the timber and the roof, there was a space of three
feet between each baulk, and there was plenty of room for the air to go through. I
properly examined the place once a fortnight. Taylor has stated that he has frequently
seen me at the lofting, but he (Taylor) has only once met me there in his life. We
worked on different shifts. I went on to the timbering once a fortnight, and whenever I
found any dust upon it I gave instructions to Taylor to keep it clear. I never told
him to examine the place for gas. If there had been any accumulation of gas I could
have seen it from the top of the timbering. I put my lamp right to the roof of the
place.
George Turnbull said : "I was down in the pit on the day before the explosion. I
examined all the ways near the water standage. I did not find the slightest symptoms
of gas. I do not make daily examinations of the standage. I examine it twice or thrice
a week.
By Mr. Folkard. "The overman could have gone and seen the stoppings if he liked.
I do not know whether he ever did, but he could go to any part of the pit. It is
my duty to examine the stoppings referred to by Mr. Dickinson, but I do not know if it
is likely that the overman would do what it was my duty to do.
Michael Kennedy said : "I am a stoneman. At the time of the explosion we were
working in the new No. 1 pit. I heard an explosion, and I said to my companions,
'There is Hutchinson's shot gone ! ' Shortly afterwards there was a great rush of wind,
and I was thrown down. After I came to myself I groped about and felt a tub.
By Mr. Willis. "There was only one rush of air. We did not feel anything after the
first report, but we lost the fresh air after the rush of wind ; the rush of wind went in
the opposite direction to the ordinary ventilation ; it afterwards came right and took a
'suck,' and then ceased. We heard a distinct report before the explosion, and both my
marrow and myself said, 'There is Hutchinson's shot gone off.' We just had time to
say these words. I cannot tell how the fire came there, but I cannot see how the pit
would have fired at Hutchinson's shot, because there was no gas where he was working.
John Peart said : "I am a coal miner. I was with the last witness when the explosion
took place. About half-past eleven o'clock I heard the report of Hutchinson's shot, and
shortly afterwards felt the wind a little. About four or five minutes afterwards a second
explosion occurred. Altogether I heard two explosions after Hutchinson's shot ; there
was a distinct sound of a second explosion in the workings. I said to Kennedy, 'She's
fired at Hutchinson's shot.' Almost immediately afterwards I felt the first explosion.
By Mr. Willis. "I do not think a minute would elapse between hearing the report of
Hutchinson's shot and the second explosion. I had just time to say, 'She's fired ;' the
first was a heavy explosion, but the second was not so severe. I know that between
four and five minutes is a long time, but I think that time would elapse between the first
and second explosion in the workings.
By Mr. Folkard. "It is my firm opinion that the gas fired at Hutchinson's shot. I
have seen the standage, but not since the explosion.
The Coroner at this stage of the proceedings asked if any of the hewers wished to be
examined.
Robert Straughair came forward and said : "I am a coal miner and have worked in
No. 3 pit for the past two years. I have worked in many pits in my time, and I have
repeatedly made the observation that I never worked in a better ventilated pit in my life.
My son was killed by the explosion, but I am of opinion that the fire could have been
overcome with a little perseverance. I was not one of the exploring party. I was down
the pit on the day the men were got out. I was also on the spot shortly after the
explosion, and went down to the main coal, but I was not opposite the bank head on that
day. Men were allowed to go down till the standing fire was discovered. After that time
men were prevented from going down. I know that a fire always takes up some of the
air, but in this case I think the ventilation, if an effort had been made to get through the
fire, would not have been much interfered with. I think the men might have been got
out if a little perseverance had been used.
Mr. E. F. Boyd, viewer, described the appearance which the pit presented on his
examination of the workings after they had been re-opened, and gave evidence in
confirmation of Mr. Armstrong's view of the cause of the explosion : "He believed there
had been at first a small fall of stone, and Spence had sent the boy in-bye for assistance ;
then a further fall had taken place and liberated the gas, which had ignited either from
his own lamp or the paraffin lamp ; the explosion could not have taken place where
Hutchinson's shot had fired, because if there had been any accumulation of gas there, it
would have fired at the naked light by which Hutchinson fired his shot ; he believed the
explosion had taken place after the fall ; he considered it impossible that the men could
be alive ; the fact that one man died at seven o'clock led him to believe that the others
had not lived many hours after that ; there could not be that much difference in the
men's constitutions.
By the Coroner. "I have examined the place where Hutchinson fired his shot ; from
all I could see I have no reason to conclude that there was any gas at that place ; the
current of the air was very strong. I think Kennedy must have been under a delusion.
He must have confounded Hutchinson's shot with one of the explosions.
By Mr. Willis. "I think the explosion took place after the stone fell, because the
edges of the stone were covered with dust and dirt. It is freestone, and dust would not
have clung to it unless there had been some great disturbing force.
By Mr. Dickinson. "I examined the gas pipe and saw that it was broken. I do not
think it is possible for gas to have escaped from the pipe in a sufficient quantity to
account for the explosion.
By Mr. Folkard. "I approved of what had been done by the viewers. The men
simply repeated the statements they have given in evidence at this enquiry. I have
heard their evidence, and think there is nothing but what is reasonable in it. An
explosion might have taken place at any moment. We have many instances of a second
explosion having taken place ; the latest is the Oaks. He would be a bold man who
would go down a pit where there was a standing fire.
Mr. R. F. Matthews, viewer, "agreed with the previous witnesses as to the cause of
the explosion, which could not have occurred in the standage ; he had satisfied himself
upon that point by an examination.
"He was one of the viewers at the consultation, and they came to the conclusion it
would be a waste of life to make further efforts to get past the fire ; from all that they
knew now he thought they would only have killed the men the sooner by forcing the
smoke and afterdamp upon them. They had not died of starvation but would be suffocated
by the afterdamp.
The Coroner. "Is there any part of the evidence of Mr. Armstrong or Mr. Boyd
that you differ from ?
"There is only one thing I would add. If the gas pipe had been broken by Hutchinson's
shot, and the gas had taken fire, I think it would have burnt itself out in the ordinary
way. I feel quite certain that the explosion took place at No. 2 bank head.
Mr. John Taylor, of Ryhope, agreed with the other engineers who had been examined
as to the cause of the explosion. He was on the pit heap about half-past twelve on the
Thursday and saw the men come to bank and report the existence of fire ; they were in
a very excited state when they came up. At the consultation at the office they heard
what the two overmen had to say, and concluded that if the fire was allowed to go on a
tremendous explosion might occur. They did not ask for volunteers to go down the pit
at all, the men seemed to be panic-stricken. He believed if they had taken more air
into the fire there would have been another explosion, and lives would have been lost.
After examining the pit and ascertaining the extent of the fire, he was still of the
same opinion that it could not have been extinguished ; he would not have ventured to
such a place himself, and would not have asked anyone else to go. He would not
have asked any set of men to go in, because if anything had occurred to them he would
have felt himself morally guilty of murder. He would not have undertaken the responsibility
of risking men's lives in such an enterprise. He was check viewer on behalf of
Mr. Gregson in that part of the pit, and therefore his interest was against that of Earl
Vane in the matter. He was convinced that the explosion had taken place at the point
already indicated, in consequence of an outburst of gas. He did not think there would
be any collection of gas in the lofting, but would have such a place narrowly examined.
If gas had accumulated, there would have been an explosion before at the paraffin lamp.
Mr. Lindsay Wood was next called, and gave evidence corroborating the view of the
other engineers as to the cause of the explosion. He was present at the consultation in
the office, and the decision to seal up the pit was the only way to save the mine. He
was satisfied there could not be anyone living in the pit. The after-damp was excessively
strong in both returns. He had not heard before of any outburst of gas in this pit. It
was not uncommon in adjoining collieries.
Mr. Wood was questioned by Mr. Dickinson as to the possibility of Hutchinson's shot
having drawn a sufficient quantity of gas from the drift and standage in the immediate
neighbourhood to cause the explosion, Mr. Dickinson adding that they had it in evidence
that this place had not been examined on the day of the explosion. Mr. Wood held that
the accident could not have occurred in this way, and adhered to the theory he had
already given expression to. The indications they had found in the workings as to the
course the blast had followed were consistent with his theory, and if the explosion had
happened in any other way the indications would have been quite different.
Mr. T. E. Forster also gave corroborative evidence, adding that in his opinion the
stone roof at the bank head had got weakened, so that the pent up gas had burst
out. After the consultation he was quite satisfied that the resolution to seal up the pit
was correct, and he might say that Mr. Willis coincided with him. He believed that
more air would have caused the fire to increase so rapidly that they could not have
overtaken it. He once worked on with a similar fire six weeks, but failed to get it
extinguished, and had to close up the pit after all. He would not like to have asked
any man to have ventured through the fire.
The Coroner asked if either of the inspectors wished to be examined.
Mr. Willis did not ask to be examined, but if the jury were desirous to hear him he
was ready to give his opinion.
A juryman expressed a wish to hear the evidence of Mr. Willis.
Mr. Willis was accordingly sworn, and said he had examined the pit on more than
one occasion since the explosion, and from the indications he had seen he agreed with the
evidence given by the mining engineers that day. He believed the explosion came from
the spot they had indicated, and did not think it possible for a large accumulation of gas
to take place in the lofting, nor did he think if the gas pipes had been broken for a length
of time before Hutchinson's shot was fired that gas would have collected in a sufficient
amount to cause such an explosion. Moreover, it must be remembered that 78,000 feet
of air per minute were passing this point (Hutchinson's place), divided into four splits,
and if the pipe being broken would have rendered this air explosive, it would have
exploded in all the four districts into which it went, and not alone in the Silksworth way,
and there was not the slightest trace of explosion in any other part of the pit. He
confessed it was difficult to find an adequate cause for the outburst of gas, and yet it
was the only conclusion he could come to that there had been such an outburst. He
found it difficult to account for the quantity of gas, for it was not in evidence that the
seam or strata had been subject to such outbursts before, although it has frequently
occurred in adjoining collieries.
With regard to the fire and the scaling up, he got to the office at 4 o'clock on the
Thursday, after Mr. Taylor had left, and found the gentlemen who had given evidence
to-day, together with Mr. Hepplewhite and Mr. Turnbull, who had been in the pit.
He heard all about it and heard what the viewers had decided, and expressed his concurrence
in the view they had taken, after having also examined Dawson and Laws on
the subject and questioned Mr. Turnbull as to the surroundings of those stables. Nothing
that could have been done from the outer end would have tended in the direction of
saving the men's lives. On the contrary it would have tended to shorten their lives.
By Mr. Folkard. "He would have been disposed to have examined the lofting more
frequently than once a fortnight, but if the pit had been his, he would not have had any such
thing there. He would have put arches in place of timber. His more frequent examinations
would not have been with the view of finding gas, but to see to the safety of the
roof, and the prevention of falls. He did not think any gas could have collected there,
as it was not a close lofting, and was very well ventilated.
The Coroner then asked the jury to retire to another room to consider their verdict,
and in doing so said they had given such great attention to the evidence that it was
unnecessary for him to recapitulate it. He would only call their attention to two things :
first, the examination of the lofting and timber at No. 2 bank ; and secondly, as to the
sealing up of the pit. If in their verdict they would give an expression of opinion on
these two points it would be more satisfactory.
The jury then retired at half-past five o'clock, and returned in half an hour with a
verdict in writing, which the foreman, Mr. Smith, read as follows :— "The jury are
unanimously of opinion that the deceased met their deaths accidentally from an explosion
caused by an outburst of gas from the roof of No. 2 bank head of No. 3 pit. We are
of opinion that there has been no negligence in the examination of the lofting or timbered
cavity where the fall of stone occurred, inasmuch as there never has been the slightest
appearance of the presence of gas in that place and the ventilation was found to be
perfect. After hearing the evidence of so many eminent and experienced mining
engineers as to the propriety of closing up the pit, we are of opinion that it was the only
safe means to pursue."
The proceedings then terminated.
* This has since been explained. The searchers had instructions to chalk or otherwise mark a number near
to each body when found ; thus the figure 6 indicated that the remains near it were those of the sixth body
found during that "shift."