Seaham Colliery Disaster
Extracted from the Annual Mines Inspectors Report for 1871
Report of James Willis (page 10)
Seaham Colliery Explosion.
Adjourned Inquest.
Held in the schoolroom, Seaham Colliery, on Thursday, Nov. 16th, 1871, before
Mr. Coroner Maynard and a jury of 15 persons; Mr. Willis, the Government Inspector
of Mines, was present.
The Coroner. "The pit not having been opened out to allow of an examination of the
workings so as to obtain evidence of how the explosion occurred, I intend to take to-day
only the groundwork of the inquiry. The viewer will give some explanations with
regard to the workings of the pit, and we can then examine Hutchinson, the man who
was down the pit at the time the explosion occurred, and then take an adjournment for a
month, by which time the Inspector says the pit will have been examined, and we can
then go straight through with the whole inquiry.
The Inspector. "I don't know that they will be able to examine the workings within a
month. You had better make it six weeks.
The Coroner agreed to this course with the assent of the jury, and then called
William Dakers, who said, "I am resident viewer at Seaham Colliery for the whole of
the pits Nos. 1, 2, and 3. I produce a list of the men lost. I am certain all these men
went down that night before the explosion. I produce a plan of the workings of No. 3
pit, Hutton Seam, Silksworth way. That is the seam and district in which the explosion
occurred. The plan shows Nos. 1 and 2 as the downcast, and No. 3 as the upcast.
It shows the intake for ventilation to the No. 3 pit workings ; this is coloured blue. The
portions marked red are the returns in the same seam and workings. The plan also shows
the goaf worked out. The men still in the pit are in a district 3,000 yards from the
downcast shaft. The explosion took place on the night of Wednesday, the 25th of
October, at 11.30 p.m. I was called out of bed at the time and got down the pit in
20 minutes from the time it occurred. I met first old Hutchinson, who was living and
had just been got out of the pit. Hutchinson's son I found lying 140 yards from the
bottom of the shaft in the intake ; he was dead. I continued along the intake, and when
I came opposite No. 3 shaft, the upcast, I heard a man crying as though he was severely
injured, and I told two men to go away to him at once and get him out. When I went
away from him I went to the crossings in the intake and found them blown out. Then
I proceeded further and found two doors blown out on the north side. Then I came
back to the bottom of the staple on the south side, and found the doors blown out there
into the return. After that I returned and went up No. 1 bank for a short distance, and
there met the afterdamp and could get no further. I then sent some men to bank to get
canvas bratticing out of the store for repairing these crossings and doors. During the
time, I went to the north headways opposite to the No. 3 shaft. The first crossing I
came to was damaged a little. I proceeded further into the next crossing and found it was
not damaged at all. There had been a slight force of explosion past it. After I passed
that point I came to a pair of double doors leading into the standage ; the first door was
blown off, the second was standing none the worse. Then, after that, I came away
back along to the No. 3 pit, and found the whole of the doors blown out between the
upcast and the intake. The tubs standing in the shaft siding at the upcast pit were
blown together. The greatest force of the explosion appeared to have been at the bottom
of the Main Coal staple ; the tubs were more knocked together there. This staple connects
the Main Coal with the Hutton Seam ; there was a portion of the timber in the
staple blown out and lying at the bottom. I then returned into the main intake, and
went two pillars up the No. 1 bank, and there met with afterdamp. I ordered men to
put up temporary stoppings with canvas, and then we went up till we got to the head of
No. 2 bank, where I found a very heavy fall on the rolley way, stone, coals, timber, and
such like. I found some men who had been clearing the road sitting at the bank head.
I asked them if they had tried to get over the fall ; they said they had not as they
thought 'she' had fallen close. One of the men came with me and we got across the
fall. Then we got away up to where we turn north into the Silksworth headways. We
found a pair of doors there that went into the return blown out. There the afterdamp
was standing just on the inbye side of the Silksworth way. I put canvas stoppings in
there, and then it cleared out to the crossing still further on, which was blown out. We
repaired the crossing with canvas, and then got up to the out-bye end of the stables.
The stable stalls are ranged alongside the way, and beyond the stables is a very wide
place, so that with the little air we had we could not beat the afterdamp back. Then,
leaving the men, I went away out-bye to the shaft, and tried to get more air in by
setting a waterfall on. I then returned and still found afterdamp at the stables. We
worked on for a considerable time until we got nearly to the in-bye end of the stables.
At this time I was compelled to leave them and go to bank to a consultation which was
being held in the colliery office. I had not seen any fire, but I had every reason to
think there was fire from the warmth of the mine. At the consultation it was considered
advisable to try more waterfall in the shaft in order to get a better ventilation. I came
away from the office and put more waterfall on. On reaching the bottom of the pit I
met the men I had left in, coming out-bye as fast as they could come, and they told me
she was all on fire together a little beyond the stable ends. That was in the forenoon
some time ; I think it was about twelve o'clock. There would be 20 or 30 men at that
time. There was no means of getting in-bye any other way. There is only one intake
and two returns ; the intake is the likeliest place to get in. I went through into the
returns, which was full of afterdamp the same as the intake ; the afterdamp we were
forcing out of the intake was coming out of the returns ; the furnace was not injured at
all. I had previously sent a man to put the furnace fire out after the accident occurred.
After I met the men we came to bank again. I took the men with me to the colliery
office to make a statement as to seeing the fire. After it was proved that the fire was
there it was considered better to seal the mine up. Dawson and Laws were the two
men in charge at the time ; they are the back-overmen. There was no viewer there at
the moment the fire was seen, and no viewer went up afterwards. As to the extent of
the fire, they told me it was on fire at three or four different places ; there was no water
near to apply to the fire. I waited a considerable time longer than I should have waited
that morning, expecting to see some fire at the stable end. I thought if there was a fire
and it was not extensive, we might have put it out. The men were very frightened as
soon as they saw the fire, and when they forced the air into it the flame broke out ; as
soon as they saw that they retreated at once. These workings are more than fifty
fathoms above the level of the shaft ; there was no one in after that. They put a canvas
stopping right across the place to prevent the air getting into it, and then retreated back
to the shaft ; this was 2,000 yards from the bottom of the downcast shaft.
"The existence of the fire was brought before the viewers in consultation at the
colliery office, and they decided that no time should be lost, and that the place should
be sealed up at once for fear of a second explosion. And the fear of a second explosion
determined us from losing any time in getting the place sealed. We could not ascertain
the extent of the fire without carrying fresh air in, and it was thought not advisable to
do that.
"I now produce the ventilation book. We have the different pits, and the quantity
of air going into the district. The north Main Coal is the first split. There is the total
quantity in No. 3 pit. This was taken on the 12th of October ; it is measured once a
fortnight. There is a general measurement of the air. There is not any other measurement
made during the fortnight, unless there is some cause or some suspicion that all
is not right. We have no daily register further than the water gauge, we get that
daily.
The Coroner. "Shall we go into that ?
The Inspector. "At the next examination you will have precisely the same means of
ascertaining the state of the ventilation.
The Coroner. "I think we would get a clearer light after the examination of the pit
where the explosion took place ; after that has been made, possibly we would not need to
go into some evidence we might otherwise take now.
The Inspector. "I think it would tend to make it a more satisfactory examination
altogether if you could wait until the pit has been opened out. It is quite possible there
may be some very clear cause for the explosion.
The Coroner. "And this evidence may prove to be not important.
The Inspector. "It would be much better to leave it for the present.
Mr. Dakers. "We did not rid the fall or clear the rolley way up to the fall ; there
was very little on the rolley way. There were two doors knocked out between that fall
and the upcast shaft in the north side. There was a crossing blown out at the outbye
end of the fall. I did not find one of the brick stoppings blown out. There was the
most damage done at the very wide place where the timber was blown down. The body
of Spence was found at the inbye end of the fall, or the top of the No. 2 bank. There
was a horse at the inbye end of the fall ; he had been coming outbye with a loaded set.
When we saw this we suspected the driver must be there. I set men to rid, but they
could not find the driver. They found Spence ; he was burnt ; his lamp was not found.
There was one lamp, we think it was Hutchinson's ; the top was blown off it ; no doubt
it was blown to pieces by the force of the explosion.
The Coroner. "Now, gentlemen, I think we will leave Mr. Dakers alone until the
adjournment, unless the jury wish to ask him any further questions.
The Inspector. "Mr. Dakers will have to give more evidence at the adjournment.
The Coroner. "Can we examine Hutchinson?
Mr. Dakers. "At his own house ; he cannot attend the inquest, yet as far as I know
he is out of danger, though his throat is still affected.
The Foreman. "I understand from the doctor that he is quite out of danger.
The Police Superintendent. "There would not be room for the jury in his house.
The Inspector. "His evidence will be important, I believe ; it is necessary that we
should have it.
The Coroner. "Has his deposition been taken ?
Mr. Eminson. "No ; it was not thought necessary to take it, because he was
considered to be quite out of danger.
The Coroner. "If there is no fear of the man it will be better to wait for his evidence
till the adjournment."
The inquest was then adjourned till Thursday January 18th, 1872, the jury to meet
at the Station Hotel at Seaham Harbour at 9 a.m. on that day.