The main road is arched with brick from the shaft, and it was found necessary to add two yards to the end, so as to widen the way. Three men (Charlton's Shift) were sent in for the purpose of taking off some side stone at six o'clock the previous night. They appear to have worked their shift on the right-hand side going inbye, and left the pit when their shift had ended at two o'clock a.m. They were succeeded by another set of men, who went down at 11 o'clock p.m., viz., Johnson, Luke, and Appleby. It was during this shift that the explosion took place. Johnson and Luke were severely burnt, and Appleby was killed. Luke was known to be in a very precarious state, and it was thought desirable to have some statement from him, as they were using powder that shift. The manager of the colliery, accompanied by a magistrate, the colliery doctor, and myself, went to his house the same night, and questioned him, when he made the following statement :—
Johnson, Appleby, and I were working at the end of the arch in the George Low Main Seam, about 200 yards inbye, south of the shaft, between 40 and 50 yards on the inbye side of the Dale Way End.
We went in at 11 o'clock p.m. on the 1st instant, and relieved Wm. Charlton, R. Bousfield, and Henderson.
Charlton's Shift was the first for some time in that place.
Charlton fired one shot on the right-hand going inbye.
It was a high place where we were working. One of the men in Charlton's Shift had been up to this place to see that it was all right. The baulks were notched in the right side, the place was all right, and baulks were propped at the left side.
We started to drill a hole on the right side near the bottom; the hole slanted inbye (it was a machine hole).
We fired the first shot about two o'clock. Fired another shot after that (second hole was a double-hand hole) on the left-hand side; it was a nearly straight down over hole at the inbye nook of the caunch. Hole drilled about 20 inches deep. Fired with a straw and kitty, by taking the lamp out of the case, and heating a piece of wire through the gauze.
Appleby and I came outbye over when the shot was ready.
Appleby went into the Dale Way End, and I went into the "chest" hole, just beside the boy's rapper. Johnson lighted the shot, then went inbye over. Johnson had got away inbye, after lighting the shot, into his proper position.
I thought I saw a flash of flame before I heard the report of the shot.
The flame that passed me appeared red and filled the whole place.
Did not hear any extra report other than what might be due to firing off a shot. When sitting in the refuge hole, looking towards shaft, the flame seemed to come past me towards the shaft. I was knocked down, and then, although I cannot be sure, I think there was a return of flame from the shaft again. Did not hear any report after the flame passed, and went towards the shaft as I was, partly stunned, but did not lose consciousness.
I left the hole and went to the shaft as soon as I could. I had Johnson's lamp in the hole, which was previously put out, and Johnson had my lamp to light the shot. I never saw my lamp any more, but made for the shaft. I heard one or both of my mates shouting. Men went to the shaft.
The other men told me they had been up to examine the top of the place, so we did not examine the top.
The stone seemed solid at the side, and there were no crevices.
We did not water the place before starting work. The previous shift also had not watered it, and I did not notice much dust. There was the usual current of air at this place. I have passed it frequently.
I declare this to be a true account to the best of my knowledge.
The above was taken down in writing, and afterwards read over to him. To each paragraph he gave his assent, and seemed thoroughly to understand his position; the doctor certified that he was in a conscious state, and understood what he was saying. He died from the effects of burns and shock on the 18th December. Wm. Charlton, who was chargeman in the previous shift, stated at the inquest that he had fired two shots on the right-hand side. Previous to doing so, he examined the space above the top of the arch, which was five feet above the level of the top of the brickwork, but found no gas. He also said he had stowed the open space (about three feet long) up with stone. He further stated that they had used nothing but machine drills that night, and that they had no hand-drilling gear out. A full set of hand-drilling gear was found close to the arch end, and from all appearances it had been used, as the edge of the chisels were blunted, and the corner of one of them was broken off. A hand-drilled shot hole was also found in the left corner, as if recently fired, and exactly in the position described by Luke.
Johnson, who had so far recovered from his injuries as to be able to give evidence on the last day of the inquiry, gave a complete contradiction to Luke's statement. He stated that they only fired one shot on the right-hand side during their shift, and that, about an hour before the explosion. He also stated that they never touched the left-hand side. He admitted that, before firing this shot, he did not examine for as to the top of the place, but on]y reached his lamp to the top of the level of the arch. This would be four or five feet from the roof, as the place was 12 feet high.
The various officials and other witnesses produced by the colliery owners gave it as their opinion that no shot had been fired on the left side that night or immediately preceding the explosion. Mr. George Baker-Forster, a mining expert of considerable experience, who had examined the mine on several occasions, gave it as his opinion that the appearance of the place was inconsistent with the recent firing of a shot, and, having given careful consideration to all the circumstances, he was not able to arrive at any satisfactory conclusion as to the cause of the explosion. From his knowledge of the seams, he did not think it probable that dust would exist in abundance at that point that night, and the fact of Charlton having stowed up the space on the top of the arch would diminish the probability of the existence of dust on the stowing. He was also quite of opinion that it was not possible for gas to be in the neighbourhood with such a strong current of air. There was only one open light at the shaft, and it was not very likely that the explosion would be caused by that light. The lamps were all locked, and there were no matches found in the pit. When asked what else he could suggest to have ignited the gas or dust except this shot, he replied, "That is just what I cannot account for." He believed that the explosion took place at a spot somewhere between the Dale Way End and the '' greaser." The distance between these two points is 65 yards, and the arch end is just half way between them. He thought that the explosion did not take place in any other part of the pit, and could not give any reason for the explosion taking place where it did.
Mr. John Daglish, a mining engineer of over 40 years' standing, and formerly chief manager of the Hetton Collieries, corroborated Mr. Forster's evidence. He also could not throw any light upon the immediate cause of the explosion. From all the appearances of the indications, he was quite clear that the explosion did not take place in any of the working places or in any of the other seams or parts of the pit. The preponderance of the evidence was directed to the spot where the shot was fired.
In conclusion, I have to state that I have frequently and carefully examined the pit, and have heard all the evidence. I quite agree with the witnesses as to the indications of the blast, and am of opinion that shot firing had been carried on, as described by Luke in his statement; also that the explosion took place at Johnson's shot, at the inbye end of the arch, which is about midway between the limits given by Mr. Forster, viz., the Dale Way End and the "greaser."
Everything points to the correctness of Luke's statement. He and Appleby came outbye to guard the Dale Way, and Main Way, and prevent anyone passing while shot firing was going on. Johnson being chargeman, lighted the shot, and went inbye, apparently to the refuge at the "greaser." The lamp belonging to Luke was found there uninjured, the outer case only being unlocked, as was customary and necessary when wanted for firing a shot. The lamps found with Luke and Appleby were both properly locked. Johnson's lamp (previously put out) was found where Luke sat down in the boy's rapper hole. Appleby had his own lamp. Johnson was found in a refuge hole, within a few yards of the shot, about an hour after, but he had evidently crept along to that place after the explosion, when making his way to the shaft, and had sat down in the refuge hole for shelter. He was badly burnt, and had left the lamp behind, as it would be put out. Had the lamp been blown from where Johnson was to where it was found, about 30 yards, it would have been badly damaged. The hand drilling gear was found still standing, against the side of the arch wall, and was blunted, as if having been used. There was also some stone lying, as if it had been blown off the side by a shot. The hand drilled hole as described by Luke, in the left-hand corner of the place, is visible to this day, and everything, in my opinion, points to his statement being trustworthy.
All the evidence goes to show that there was no other naked light in the pit at this level at the time, except the lamp at the dynamo engine at the shaft, and I quite agree with Mr. Forster that that lamp could not have caused the explosion. This seems to dispose of all the naked lights, especially in the vicinity of the arch, and unless there had been a shot fired, I cannot conceive it possible for the explosion to have taken place there.
I am not prepared to go so far as to say that the explosion was caused by the ignition of coal dust alone, but it is well known that the combustion of coal dust will extend and intensify an explosion. And this being a shaft siding or landing for the engine set of tubs, it was a likely place for large quantities of coal dust to be deposited.
The difficulty with me has been how to account for the presence of gas at that point. In a sandstone or rock roof, such as overlies the Low Main Seam throughout the district, cracks or fissures are frequently met with, and it will be seen from the plan that the mine is very much cut up with faults, which appear to intersect each other in the vicinity of the shafts and this landing. The roof is therefore likely to be unusually broken at this point and consequently more liable to give off gas.
Shot firing having been carried on at the in-bye end of the arching, during that night, after a cessation of many years, it is difficult to say what effect the concussion caused by these shots may have had on the fractures or fissures in the roof and sides of the way at this point.
It may also be observed, that there is a large area of goaf which makes gas in the Hutton Seam, underneath and only a short distance from the point where the explosion took place. There is also a large goaf in the Moorsley Way in the Low Main Seam at the "George Level," and it will be seen by a reference to the plans, that dislocations or fault slips are running in the direction from these goafs towards the arching; and the breaking of the strata, caused by the formation of these goafs would tend to open the "leaders" of the fault slips, and thus allow gas to escape and find its, way through the fissures on to the main road, notwithstanding the fact that there was a return air way on each side of it, and to be imperceptibly lodged on the top of the arch where it would be sheltered from the ventilating current.
Assuming this to be the case, we have the explosive mixture of gas and coal dust, and as the shot, mentioned by Luke, was pointing in a sloping direction towards the open space above the arch, and might possibly have been an over-charged one, the flame would fly direct into this space, where gas might be lodged, and ignite it, and with the disturbance of dust caused by the shot going off, and the workmen moving about, this would be sufficient, in my opinion, to account for the explosion taking place at the point indicated.
The jury, after a consultation in private for about two hours, returned the following verdict :—
"That, Ralph Fishburn and others met their death by an explosion in the George Low Main Seam, Elemore Colliery, on the morning of December 2nd, 1886; that the said explosion occurred between the Dale Way End and the "greaser," but what caused the ignition there is not sufficient evidence to show."
The coroner asked, "Do you make any presentment on the subject of shot firing ?"
A juror, " No, not at all."
The proceedings then terminated.
I am informed by the manager, that since this explosion took place the use of gunpowder has been discontinued at all the collieries belonging to the Hetton Coal Company; and that where blasting is necessary, they are using gelatine dynamite, in water cartridges, the charge being fired by electricity.