Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
/   \

The explosion, no doubt, took place above the George Hutton Seam and Lady Low Main Level, because it was seen to enter that level from the downcast shaft, and all the indications of its course support that conclusion.

Next above the Lady Low Main, is the Lyons Low Main, where the furnace stands, and all appearances here negative the idea that the explosion began at the furnace. The separation doors were blown from the intake into and past the furnace, and the explosion did not extend into any return air-way in this locality.

The only level above the Lyons Low Main where there were men or lights, was the George Low Main. The point of origin of the explosion evidently lay in this level, at some place between the downcast shaft and the Moorsley Way End, and most probably at the end of the arching.

At and beyond the Moorsley Way End, plan B., there were strong indications that the explosion had passed inward to all the districts in that Beam. It had also passed into the Dale Way or East Main Coal on this level.

At the dynamo engine, close to the bottom of the pit in the George Low Main, was the only naked light in the pit other than the furnace. It was a lantern, and was found hung up in the engine room and uninjured. I do not think it had anything to do with the explosion. I have not seen or heard of anything that would lead me to believe it possible that the explosion began where this lantern was. The only other lights in the pit were the Davy lamps, in tin cases, and the electric incandescent lights.

The only men working between the shaft and the Moorsley Way End were three stonemen, named Johnson, Luke, and Appleby, who were engaged in enlarging the road at the arch end, about 200 yards from the shaft. For this purpose it was necessary for them to use powder. The position in which these men and their lamps were found, and the position of the blasting gear, clearly support the idea that the men were waiting for the explosion of a shot when the pit fired.

A statement was made by one of these men, John Luke, before his death, to the effect that a shot was fired at the arch end at the time of the explosion. This statement was contradicted by Johnson at the inquest. A fuller account of it is given further on.

There were no indications of great force near the arch end. This I have observed to be a characteristic feature at the point of origin of several explosions similar to the present one. The blasting gear was found standing upright against the side of the arch. Sixty or 70 yards further out, an open gate, a rapper table and rapper with bell attached, and doors leading to the return, were not damaged. Two yards beyond the caunch inbye, three tubs were found, one lying on its side and the other two off the rails. These tubs were not broken. A few yards further in, a ladder was standing upright against the east side. A few yards beyond the ladder another tub was lying on its side. One end and one side of this tub was slightly bulged in; one pair of wheels was missing, and the axle of the remaining pair was bent.

From the arch end outward to the shaft, the damage done was trifling, and inward, for a distance of about 80 yards, the force had been comparatively slight. For that distance the timber was little disturbed, but beyond it, it was nearly all blown out, and the roof had fallen.

A chest containing stonemen's gear was found close to the arch end, its original position being 14 yards further outbye from where it was found.

It is well known that in explosions there is a reverse current or force succeeding the explosion, and I attribute the movement of this chest to such secondary force. There were several indications of a reverse force in this explosion, which are quite as difficult to account for as the movement of this chest.

The red lamp which hung at the junction of the Dale and Hall ways also appears to have been blown inward and broken, as the poles were found near the end of the arch.

Starting from the inbye end of the arch where the road was being widened, and going inbye, the course of the explosion is traced to the Hall Way old landing. The timber was blown out after the first 80 yards, and the road much blocked by falls of stone; doors, stoppings, and air-crossings were blown from the intake toward the returns. Beyond the old landing 'the force rapidly diminished and soon ceased. No timber was displaced beyond the top of the stone drift. The seven workmen at or near the face of the workings, were killed by after-damp. Grice and Patterson appear to have been between the doors at the East Side return, loading to the "Little Derby Way." They were burnt, and blown with the doors into the return.

The explosion passed, for a short distance, into the "Dale Way," and two workmen from this district escaped.

In the Moorsley Way the explosion passed with great force to the engine landing, beyond which the signs of force rapidly diminished. The work tools and timber in the face of the juds were undisturbed. At this (the Moorsley) way end was an example of force having acted in the reverse direction to that of the explosion. The drum and spur wheel of a winch were found at a short distance outbye of the place where the winch stood. The Hall Way rapper and its table were also some yards outbye from where they stood. The rapper wire from this rapper only extended inward; at the same time a rapper lever and its guard, used for rapping outbye to the engine, were found some yards inbye of their proper place. and there were other strong indications that the force of the explosion at this point were inward.

In the "Polka" Way the explosion passed to the landing, blowing out the air-crossing and breaking the tubs; beyond the landing the force diminished and ceased before reaching the face.

In the " Derby" Way the explosion passed with great force to the South Derby landing, doing considerable damage to tubs and other gearing; but beyond the landing, the signs of force soon died out, and did not appear to reach the face. Three workmen at a short distance from the landing were killed by the after-damp.

In the East and West Derby Ways the explosion also extended to the landing, but did not reach the face of the workings.

At the Derby West Way end there was another strong and distinct example of force acting in the contrary direction to that in which the explosion had travelled. Parts of the winch which stood near the way end were found at a distance of 11, 13, and 15 yards further outbye from the original position. A chain used as a fence across the way ends was also found eight yards further out. Drum sheaves on the curve were forced some inward and some outward.

Returning to the arch end, and proceeding outbye, the flame had passed to the downcast shaft, burning Johnson, Luke, and Appleby, the three stonemen, and Lawson, the dynamo engine man. It entered the shaft, and passed both. upwards and downwards. Flame was seen issuing from the shaft top, and also coming down and out of the shaft at the Lady Low Main Level. Considerable damage was done to the shaft's fittings.

The level immediately below the George Low Main is the Lyon's Low Main, or Furnace, Level. Here the explosion blew the separation doors to the furnace, and killed the furnace man. It did not extend beyond the furnace into the return air-ways, but passed along the intake air-road into the Lyons Low Main. In this district the explosion not only extended along the intakes, but also traversed the workings and back pillars.

The next lower plain of workings is where the George Hutton Seam and Lady Low Main are entered at the same level from the shaft.

The explosion did not extend into the George Hutton Seam. Two men escaped from this part, and the rapper man, who was in his cabin, close to the shaft, also escaped. Two men, Henry Buckingham and Frank Straughan, stated to me that they heard a loud report, immediately followed by a rush of flame down the shaft. They were so injured by burning that they have since died.

The explosion passed into the Lady Low Main by the "Littlebank," which is an intake, and, up to the time of the explosion, was the haulage road in use. It did not pass along the new shaft siding and stone drift, but extended by way of the "Littlebank" to the landing in the Lady Low Main, and then ceased. Six workmen from beyond here escaped by the return air-way.

From the downcast shaft, two roads enter the Lady Hutton Seam workings, which are on the lowest level. The upper road leaves the shaft at a place called "Allen's Hole," anti joins the lower road, which leaves the bottom of the shaft at a point 140 yards from the shaft. The explosion passed out of the shaft at "Allen's Hole," along the upper road to the engine plane, and so to the face of the workings in the Lady Hutton Seam, killing seven men at or near their working places. Tubs and timber near the place here appeared to have been blown in contrary directions. From the direction in which tubs and timber were blown in the shaft siding, it would appear probable that the explosion passed both inbye and outbye from the junction of "Allen's Drift" with the engine plane. A horsekeeper was killed in the Lady Hutton Seam stables by burning, or by the after-damp, or the two combined.

The aggregate length of main intake air-ways which were traversed by the explosion exceed 3,500 yards, and it will be observed that the course of the explosion is always traced along the intake air-roads, and never along the returns. It has traversed those parts of the pit least likely to contain gas. No disturbance was observed in any of the returns, except at points where doors, stoppings, or crossings had bee blown into them from the intake. At many points, things which could easily have been moved were not disturbed, and there were few falls of stone in the returns, except at places where the blast had gained access from the intakes.

All the gas originally produced in the mine is conveyed away by the return air-roads, but they are free from dust. It appears quite impossible to account for the extension of this explosion into the different seams which it penetrated, on the assumption that such extension was due to the presence of fire-damp. The only way of doing so would be to assume that gas was mixed with the air descending the shaft, and, even if such an occurrence was conceived to be possible, it would not account for all the phenomena observed, because, in such a case, the explosion would have penetrated the roads in the Main Coal Seam above, and the George Hutton Seam below the place at which it commenced, but this was not so. It was an old road where the explosion originated, driven many years ago, and, passing the place where the shot was fired, was a current of more than 37,000 cubic feet of air per minute direct from the downcast shaft. I have examined the high place above the arch for gas both before and after the ventilation was restored; and once, when the barometer was as low as 27.5 inches, no trace of fire-damp could be detected. The air is not altogether stagnant in the high part, the current rising beyond the arch end, and at such an angle as to impinge on the roof about four yards from it; that is to say, it rises from the end of the brickwork at such an angle that it would strike the roof about four yards from the end of the arch. The main intake airways of the George Low Main are very dry. Hydrometrical observations made at the end of the arch show a difference of from 5° to 6° between the wet and dry bulbs of the thermometer. The working faces and the inner portions of the return airways in this seam are generally damp. It is not a very dusty seam, and it was only on those roads where the conditions were favourable to the formation of coal dust deposits that such were found. These roads are the engine planes. All the coal worked is led at a high speed against the air current on these roads. Dust is blown off the tubs, and will accumulate on the timber, roof, and sides, as well as on the bottom. The explosion was confined to such roads in the George Low Main. The Low Main at this colliery is not a fiery seam. It produces more carbonic acid gas than fire-damp. The Hutton Seam is much dryer and dustier than the Low Main. In it the explosion extended to the face along roads which had been engine planes, beyond where the pillars were being worked off.

The Hutton Seam produces a considerable amount of fire-damp, which is usually observed at the Goaf Edge.

The latest reports of the officials, and the evidence of the survivors, reveal no unusual source of danger. The victims of the explosion appear to have been employed up to the last moment at their ordinary work. Those who were killed by the force or flame of the explosion were found at their working places. Those who had been beyond the limit to which the explosion extended, had left their working places, taking their lamps and clothing with them; they had been killed by the after-damp, some time after the explosion. There was nothing out of the common in the meteorological conditions prevailing at the time of the explosion; the barometer was not unusually low. It was freezing on the surface, and a low temperature is favourable to the ventilation and to drying the dust. The air, in descending the shaft and entering the mine, rises in temperature, and its drying power increases, thus rendering the coal dust more mobile and inflammable. The downcast shaft at Elemore was dry, and the air would not become saturated with moisture in its descent, as is sometimes the case where the shaft is wet. The presence of steam pipes in the shaft would also help to raise the temperature of the air.

There was no dispute or difference of opinion as to indications and direction of the force of the blast, and the inquiry turned almost entirely on the point as to the firing of a shot at the end of the arching, about 200 yards from the downcast shaft, in the George Low Main Seam.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print