Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
/   \

11. At an early stage of the inquiry it became apparent that the seat of the explosion was to be looked for in the George Low Main Level, and it will be necessary to describe this level more particularly. (See Plans B, and AA.)

From the point where the George Low Main Level leaves the shaft, the main intake is arched over with brick arching. About 520 feet from the shaft there is a road branching off the main intake through a atone drift into the East Main coal. This is called the Dale Way.

The arching, is continued along the main intake a distance of 97 feet 6 inches from this junction. It has been built in lengths from time to time during a considerable number of years, and the stone through which the road is made has, during that time, been removed when necessary by blasting without having caused any explosion. Taking the end of the arch, the height from the floor is 7 feet 4 inches, while the true roof is 12 feet 1 inch. The space between the top of the arch and the true roof is "stowed" with the pieces of stone which had been removed from the sides of the road for the purpose of widening it to receive the arching.

12. Previous to the day on which the explosion occurred, no work had been done at the arching for more than a year.

It had then been decided to continue it again, and for this purpose William Charlton went down in charge of a shift, consisting of himself and two other men, whose work was to remove sufficient stone to enable the arching to be lengthened another 6 feet. Charlton's shift went down on the 1st December at 4 p.m., their time for coming up being about midnight.

They commenced working on the right-hand side, going inbye, and in the ordinary course of their work, Charlton, who held the proper authority for the purpose, fired a shot. Previous to this, and while he was making the timbers in the roof secure, he had been up to the roof and had tested for gas, and had not found any. He did not notice much dust on the timbers or props, or in the neighbourhood where the shot was fired, nor did the men in his shift notice any unusual amount of dust. Charlton was a man of considerable experience, and he did not consider it necessary, and he did not, water the immediate locality of the shot, as it would have been his duty to have done in accordance with the Special Rules in force in the colliery, if the place where the shot had to be fired had had any accumulation of dust, or had been very dry and dusty. It does not appear that there was any unusual cloud of dust raised by the firing of this shot.

13. At 11 p.m. on the 1st December, another shift went down to relieve Charlton. This shift consisted of three men — Johnson, who was in charge, Appleby, and Luke.

It was during their shift that the explosion took place. All three men were injured. Appleby died before he was brought out of the pit; Luke lived for a few days only; and Johnson, although seriously injured, was able to attend and give evidence at the adjourned inquest on the 18th of January.

14. On the afternoon of the day of the explosion Luke made a statement, in the presence of Mr. Corbet, a Justice of the Peace for the county of Durham; Mr. Bell, Her Majesty's Inspector; Mr. Lishman, the manager; and Dr. Adamson. His statement was taken down in writing, but it was not upon oath; and, although Luke was in a dangerous condition, yet he did not recognise, nor, under the doctor's advice, was he made aware of his danger.

The statement was read over to him, and assented to by him, and he was, according to Dr. Adamson's evidence, perfectly clear and coherent at the time he made it.

Inasmuch as anything that Luke had said would have been evidence against him, the statement was read, care being taken that nothing therein should be used in any way against Johnson or anyone else.

The accounts given by Luke and Johnson differ so materially that it is necessary to give them somewhat in detail, as, if Luke be believed, the explosion took place upon the firing of a shot by Johnson at the arch end; while, if Johnson be believed, the explosion took place in some other part of the pit, and at a considerable time after a shot had been fired.

15. Luke says that two shots were fired. The first was a machine-drilled hole on the right-hand side going inbye, and was fired about 2 o'clock the second, a hand-drilled hole on the left-hand side going inbye, and was down nearly on the floor at the spot marked "Caunch End" on the plan.

When this shot was ready for firing, Luke and Appleby went outbye towards the shaft, Appleby going into the Daleway Ends to stop anyone coming out there until the shot had gone off, Luke going to a "refuge" by the boys' rapper for a similar purpose, and Johnson going inbye into what Luke calls his "proper position." Luke says that, on the shot going off, the flame passed him and filled the whole place; it seemed to come past him towards the shaft. He says that he had Johnson's lamp in the refuge with him; that Johnson's lamp had been previously put out, and he had lent Johnson his lamp to fire the shot with. After the explosion he came out of the hole, and went to the shaft. He says Charlton's shift had told them they had examined the roof, and so he had not done so. The stone seemed solid at the sides; no crevices. They did not water the place near the shot, and he did not notice much dust.

16. Johnson, as I have said, gave evidence before the coroner, and he had previously given an account of what took place, on the 6th of December. This account, which was noted down at the time, corresponded with the evidence he gave before the coroner. According to his account only one shot was fired, and that was on the right-hand side going inbye. It was a machine-drilled hole, and was fired about one o'clock, and that, when ready for firing, Luke and Appleby went outbye — he could not say into what positions — and he went inbye about 50 or 60 yards. He says no hand-drilling gear was used. After working up the stone dislodged by the shot, they went, he says, towards the shaft to get their "baits." This was about 20 or 25 minutes to 3 o'clock, 3 being the usual time. He says that Appleby remained behind in the Daleway Ends for a few moments, and that he and Luke went on to the boys' rapper hole, where they sat down to eat their "baits." He had just got his bottle in his hand, and was lifting it to his mouth, when the explosion took place. He either rushed or was thrown out of the hole, and was whirled away, and he knew no more until he was found by a man named Hope. He says he saw no flame, but heard a terrible rush, and smelt a suffocating kind of smell; and he said that this rush came from the shaft and not towards it.

17. In support of Luke's statement there is very nearly the whole mass of evidence given. The locality is fixed by all who have examined the pit, either affirmatively or because they cannot find any other spot in which the indications are consistent with an explosion having taken place. Hand-drilling gear was found standing near the arch end as well as machine gear Luke's lamp was found unlocked, as it might have been had it been used for lighting a shot. It was found at the "greaser," which is a place opposite the grease cabin where the tub wheels run over an automatic greaser. To this place Johnson might well have gone for a refuge. Johnson's lamp, although not definitely traced, is believed to have been found uninjured and locked on a chest which stood near the separation doors, opposite the place where Luke says he had it, at the boys' rapper hole. There is a mark of a shot in the left-hand inbye nook of the "Caunch," where Luke says a shot was fired; but whether that hole was new or old it was not found possible, after the dust and dirt raised by the explosion, to say. Johnson was found in a refuge hole close to the arch end, which would have been an unsafe place for him to have been in had a shot been fired at the arch end. He was in such a position that he might well have been in had he struggled from the greaser towards the shaft after the explosion, and had sunk down where he was found sitting. Had he been whirled, as he said, from the boys' rapper hole, he would have travelled a distance of 158 feet. No bones were broken, nor had he any dislocations; he was burnt.

18. In favour of Johnson's account, it must be said that he gave his evidence clearly, and was subjected to cross-examination, which Luke was not. As regards the finding of Appleby it might be either way. He may have stopped behind in the Dale Way End, as Johnson says, or he may have been there awaiting the going-off of a shot. Appleby was found at the point where the rails from the Dale Way join those of the main intake. He may well have come out of the Dale Way and fallen there.

19. Balancing the probabilities of the one account against the other, it appears to be more reasonable to suppose that when two men have equal opportunities of observing the same occurrence, that man would appear to be the most likely to be correct who gives the greatest number of details consistent one with the other. This points to the account given by Luke being the correct one.

20. It is unnecessary to follow the indications of the explosion through the various seams, as these would only show the seat of the explosion, and that, so far as it can be shown, has been shown already. It is enough to say that the explosion followed the intakes only, and in no case were the return airways injured, except where doors had been blown into them from the intakes, and in these cases there was some rubbish scattered a short distance. They gave no appearance of having been traversed by fire. Along the intakes, however, the blast travelled very long distances, and there were indications of fire a considerable way in many instances.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print