Report
to
The Right Honourable The Secretary of State for The Home Department
on
The circumstances attending an Explosion which occurred at the Elemore Colliery, on the 2nd of December 1886;
by
Haden Corser, Esquire,
Barrister at Law
1. On Thursday the 2nd of December 1886, at 2.55 a.m., an explosion took place at the Elemore Colliery, near Hetton, in the county of Durham, causing the death of 28 persons. The adjourned inquest upon the bodies of the deceased persons was held at Hetton by Mr. Crofton Maynard, Coroner, on the 20th, the 21st, and the 22nd of December 1886, and was continued on the 18th and 19th of January 1887, when it was finally concluded.
The adjourned inquest was attended by Mr. Thomas Bell and Mr. James Willis, Her Majesty's Inspectors of Mines; Mr. W. N. Atkinson and Mr. John Plummer, Assistant Inspectors; by Mr. W. Crawford, M.P., Mr. John Wilson, Mr. W. Patterson, Mr. John Forman, on behalf of the Durham Miners' Association; by Mr. Lambton, on behalf of the Durham Enginemen's Association; by Mr. Edward Cowries and Mr. Robert Rowland, on behalf of the Miners' National Union. The proprietors of the colliery were represented by Mr. Cooper (Phillipson, Cooper, and Gorger, Newcastle-upon-Tyne). Mr. Etherley Jones, instructed by Mr. Forrest, Durham, appeared for Miners' National Union. I watched the proceedings on behalf of the Secretary of State.
2. At the close of the inquiry the jury gave the following verdict in writing :—
"That Ralph Fishburn and others met their death by an explosion in the George Low Main Seam, Elemore Colliery, on the morning of December 2nd, 1886. That the said explosion occurred between the Dale Way End and the Greaser, but what caused the ignition there is not sufficient evidence to show."
It had been left to the jury to make any presentment they thought fit upon the subject of shot-firing. In reply to the coroner they stated that they had no presentment to make.
3. The colliery is owned by the "Hetton Coal Company." The agent for the colliery is Mr. Lindsay Wood, and Mr. Thomas Lehman is the certificated manager.
Accompanying this Report will be found plans of the workings so far as are necessary to render it intelligible.
4. The colliery is worked by means of two shafts. The downcast shaft is divided into two by a 3-inch wooden brattice, and called respectively the George Shaft and the Lady Shaft, and is sunk to the depth of 142 fathoms. The upcast shaft is called the Isabella Shaft, and is sunk to the depth of 129 fathoms. The diameter of the downcast shaft is 13 feet and that of the upcast 9 feet. (See Plan A.)
Coals are drawn by the downcast shaft only, the upcast being used solely for ventilation. At the top of the latter, however, a kibble is kept in readiness for use, and it was by this that the exploring party descended after the explosion.
5. The ventilation of the pit is effected by means of a furnace, which is placed on the Lyons Low Main Level. The quantities of air passing various parts of the workings are shown upon the annexed plans.
6. The lamp in use in the colliery is the "Davy," fitted in a tin case with a circular glass, and known as the "Tin-can Davy." The electric light is used at the shaft bottoms and shaft sidings, the dynamo being driven by an engine placed a few yards from the shaft on the George Low Main Level There was only one naked light in the pit at the time of the explosion, and that was a glass lantern which the man in charge of the engine had, and he was at or near the engine-house at the time of the explosion.
7. At the time of the explosion 41 men and boys were in the pit, and of these 28 were either killed at the time or have since died of their injuries. They were engaged in various parts of the pit, and the effects of the explosion were felt by them, more or less, upon every level.
8. With regard to the kind of coal, the seams vary. The Hutton seam is a very dusty seam. In the Low Main Seams the coal is extremely hard, and hence produces comparatively little dust, and these seams were described generally as damp.
9. As regards gas, it may be said that the colliery is not a "gassy" one. No blowers had been met with, nor had any complaints been made of gas in the working places. Gas had occasionally been seen on the edges of the "goaves," but this only occasionally, and when found was speedily removed.
10. A barometer, thermometer, and water-gauge are kept in the office at the colliery, and a barometer and thermometer outside the office and at each level in the pit, which are open to inspection by the men, and are regularly registered by the officials on descending and ascending. The following are the readings taken for the days immediately preceding the explosion :—
| 29th November | 1 a.m., 29.48; | 1 p.m., 29.30. |
| 30th November | 1 a.m., 29.30; | 1 p.m., 29.45. |
| 1st December | 1 a.m., 29.57; | 1 p.m., 29.60. |
| 2nd December | 1 a.m., 29.55. | |
The explosion, it will be remembered, occurred at 2.55 on the morning of December 2nd. There had been a slight depression of two-and-a-half tenths previous to the last reading, but the barometer had risen to the same level again. The temperature of the George Low Main was about 56 or 57, and that of the Lady Hutton, the lowest seam of all, about 64 or 65.