|
18th October 1941, Page: 113, Column: 1 Drilling Dust ProblemsSouth African Engineers' DiscussionThe solution of "Drilling Dust Problems"* was broached last year by Mr. G. Hildick-Smith, and he returned to the subject in May (1941) at a joint meeting of the South African Institution of Engineers and the Chemical Metallurgical and Mining Society of South Africa. He explained that, as referred to by him, by dust is meant any particles which can be seen on a thermal precipitator slide under the microscope with transmitted light, with 1,000 magnification, after ignition to remove carbon. From a preliminary study it was clear that dust could be produced When a hammer machine-drill Was in operation, in either, or a combination, of three Ways : (1) By the borer bit ; (2) By the atomisation, through the machine-drill release port — of water carrying silica and other particles in suspension ; (3) By the atomisation through the exhaust port of water carrying silica and other particles in suspension. All three possible means require air under pressure as the active predisposing factor, and it was essential to determine the relation between this air factor in all cases and the thermal precipitator dust counts. Appended are extracts from the paper. Mixture Dangerous to Health. Recently there has unfortunately been a tendency in some quarters, in regard to dust investigations, to get away from the main issue of preventing the production of dangerous dust as soon as possible by splitting hairs about the washing of thermal precipitator slides. Any controversy on this subject is clearly a waste of time when all that may be washed off the slides are the crystals of the various salts which are caught entirely due to the atomisation of water, through the release and/or exhaust ports of machine-drills, and air-operated winches, pumps, etc., and this factor Will be entirely eliminated when there is no longer atomisation of water above the critical velocity. In any case it may be that the material represented by that washed off the slides is in itself, or in combination with other matter, represented by that not washed off the slides, dangerous to health. It would seem highly probable that such a mixture regularly inhaled by underground workers is dangerous to health. Work of Machines Compared. It is interesting to note that after the introduction, in a section of a mine, of twelve standard (short-piston) machine drills with 3/8-inch diameter flared water tubes it was reported that these machines were drilling better than the same machines had when fitted with standard 5/32-inch diameter water tubes. The matter was investigated and the water pressures at which the natives were operating their machines with 3/8-inch diameter tubes was taken for comparison with the water pressures of twelve other machines equipped with 5/32-inch diameter tubes and it was found that the machines with 3/8-inch diameter tubes were working with water pressures varying from 3 to 9 lb. per square inch with an average of 6 lb. per square inch, which would cause about 14 pints of water per minute to pass through the water tube, of which about 7 pints per minute would be available for sludging. The machines with 5/32-inch diameter water tubes were being operated with water pressures varying from 11 to 25 lb. per square inch with an average of 16 lb. per square inch, which would cause about 7 pints of water per minute to pass through the water tube of which about 4 pints per minute would be available for sludging. This point is of interest as showing to what extent the natives operating the machine-drills use their judgment in adjusting the quantity of water used. For efficient sludging and hence optimum drilling speed, in rock of an average hardness of that of the mines of the Witwatersrand, at least two pints of water per minute through the borer are required, although this varies somewhat with the angle of dip of the hole being drilled and the hardness of the rock, and in actual practice the native operating the machine sets the water pressure to suit conditions. With regard to the quantity of air passing down the borer it is essential that water tubes must not be damaged, and it will therefore be necessary for the borer shanking to be of such a type, as to prevent, as far as possible, the tube being struck by the borer. The rubber collar shank, for example, especially if used with an external buffer rubber, will be one of the least satisfactory owing to the ease with which the buffer rubber can be compressed, not only when in use with the rigged, but also with the hand-held machine. With the use of the long-piston machine the quantity of air passing down the borer with a fixed clearance between piston and cylinder washer depends on the clearance between the Water tube and the hole in the front end of the piston, unless an internally flared water tube is used, by means of which it is possible to prevent air flow down the borer except in negligible quantities with clearances up to 20/1000-inch. In actual practice at the Nourse Mines machines fitted with 3/8-inch dared tubes have been working satisfactorily. To ensure that a long-piston machine of the 2 5/8-inch diameter cylinder class does not pass air through the release port with a velocity of over 2,000 feet per minute, which may be taken as being quite a safe velocity below which no dangerous quantity of dust with any class of water and no increase in humidity can be produced by atomisation, the following standards of clearances, etc., should be set : 1. Maximum clearance between water tube and piston — 15/1000-inch. 2. Minimum area of release port 1 square inch — the edges of all ports to be rounded. 3. Maximum clearances between front cylinder washer and piston 8/1000-inch. 4. Maximum clearance between piston and cylinder 6/1000-inch. It must be remembered that in machines of the 2 5/8-inch diameter class the area of the exhaust port is about 0.70 square inch, and through this passes about 83 cubic feet of air per minute for a standard machine and about 90 cubic feet per minute for a long-piston machine, and therefore the velocity through the exhaust port is about 15,000 feet per minute and 17,000 feet per minute respectively. To prevent a dangerous quantity of dust being produced by atomisation at the exhaust port :— (1) The present arrangement of fixing the water tube should be altered. (2) Care must be taken not to install pipes as air mains which have been previously used for sludge, etc., unless they are first carefully cleaned. (3) Compressed air must be kept dry, by (a) Dehumidifying ; (b) Installation of water blasts of a type that do not pass water into the air mains ; (c) Installation of efficient water traps in air pipe lines. Summary and Conclusions. Following the presentation of details of experiments and tests Mr. Hildick-Smith submitted conclusions as follows :— It is safe to say that hammer machine-drills of the long-piston type can be regularly used in drilling operations without los of drilling speed as compared with the standard (short-piston) machines, and if properly designed they will, in operation with any kind of water, produce only a negigible overall amount of dangerous dust. Placed in a condition in which it will not produce dust a machine drill must of course be kept in that condition when at work. On all mines there is at present a regular system in regard to machine upkeep and repair, the fitting shops being usually equipped with rotation testing apparatus, air meters, etc. It is suggested that in future there should be added a "bottle" testing apparatus. The apparatus should be standardised and every machine-drill tested for quantities of air passing down the borer and out of the release port. If a machine-drill does not conform to the set standard it should be adjusted and made to conform before being returned as ready for work. By this means a check on the various suggested clearance standards would be obtained. The standards necessary to ensure that a hammer machine-drill cannot in operation produce dust in dangerous quantities provided it is not doing so by atomisation through the exhaust port, are that not more than 500 c.c. of air per minute should pass down the borer and that the velocity through the release port should not exceed 2,000 feet per minute. These standards would of course apply equally to the drifter, the 3½-inch diameter cylinder class, as well as the 2 5/8-inch diameter cylinder class of hammer machine-drill. The maintenance of such standards would ensure that a long-piston machine-drill in operation would not produce an overall count of more than about n/c.c, 100 n/c.c. from the borer bit, 50 n/c.c. from the release port and 50 n/c.c. from the release port and 50 n/c.c. from the exhaust port with any class of water, as compared with that of 2,000 n/c.c. and over produced at present by standard (short-piston) machines. It may be worth noting that the 100 n/c.c. from the borer bit could be reduced if 7/32-inch inside diameter flared water tubes were used in preference to standard 5/32-inch diameter water tubes. It would seem that the dust produced from the cutting edge of the borer prior to the introduction of the release port was about equal in quantity to that now produced by the atomisation of mine water through the release port of a standard (short-piston) machine-drill, which in addition disseminates soluble silica in a form in which it can be easily inhaled. If the two types of product are equally toxic this may explain the incidence of silicosis amongst new Rand miners, namely, those who have worked underground on the Rand and in scheduled mines only, since 1st August, 1916. Two methods of dust production, not however directly connected with drilling, are worthy of mention, namely : (1) Dust produced by the atomisation of mine water by water blasts ; (2) Dust produced by atomisation by water sprays. In relation to the critical velocity of atomisation for mine waters, namely, 3,000 feet per minute, the velocities used for water blasts and many water sprays are such as to produce very high degrees of atomisation, and in consequence enormous quantities of dust are thus disseminated in the mine air and in addition humidity is increased. As in future, in so far as drilling operations are concerned, only negligible quantities of dust need be produced the question of size frequencies and the washing of thermal precipitator slides becomes only of academic interest. From the foregoing it is apparent that, for the time being, the best way of solving drilling dust problems is to prohibit the use of the present standard (short-piston) hammer machine-drills and either convert them to, or replace them by long-piston machines, the latter presumably at some future, date being in turn superseded by other and better types of equally dustless machine-drills. Silicosis-producing Oust. In the subsequent discussion which was associated With the vote of thanks to Mr. Hildick-Smith for his paper, Mr. E. H. A. Joseph expressed the view that as to the meaning of "harmful" or "dangerous" dust, it is considered preferable to avoid these terms and to speak of "silicosis-producing" dust, thus defining more precisely what it is that is aimed at determining and eliminating from the air of our mines. It is reasonable to conclude, Mr. Joseph proceeded to say, that it is the rock dust particles that constitute the significant factor in the production of silicosis, and in order to make possible the determination of the number of these particles it is imperative to eliminate the salt-plus-soluble-silica particles from the sample. Acceptance of this conclusion is none the less justified because We know that other substances, acting in conjunction with silica, may modify the effect produced in the lungs ; silica plus some other substance may be more virulent than silica alone, or less so (metallic aluminium, for example), but silica unmixed with other dusts produces silicosis, whereas other dusts, without silica, will not do so. Particulate silica being the essential ingredient in a silicosis-producing dust, Mr. Joseph says it is on these silica particles that we must concentrate in the elimination of silicosis. We cannot discriminate between free silica and other insoluble mineral particles in the sample, but if the soluble particles (often overwhelming in number) can be removed, the remaining insoluble particles will provide a very reliable index of the number of silicosis-producing particles present in the air in any particular mine or mining field where the composition of the air-borne dust remains fairly constant. Voluntary Adoption Suggested. Tests so far conducted by the Miners' Phthisis Prevention Committee do not show that the overall dust (rock dust particles) produced by a long piston machine is materially lower than that produced by a short piston machine, though the former may produce less atomisation. There appears, consequently, to be insufficient justification at present for the compulsory introduction of long pistons, but the reduction in humidity claimed for long piston machines might induce the industry to adopt them voluntarily in its own interests. Such a step, together with others contributing to the elimination of all avoidable additions of moisture to the air, may come to be regarded as a necessary preliminary to the serious consideration of any proposals for the adoption of dry or drier mining at extreme depths. The method of reducing dust counts to an air flow of 1,000 c.f.m. is an excellent means of affording direct comparisons between similar tests, but it must be borne in mind that a machine drilling without ventilation will produce about ten times as much dust as that shown by the formula in its own exhaust air. Silica and Coal-dust Mixtures. Dr. F. W. Simson, of the South African Institute for Medical Research, pointed out that dust production as a result of air passing down the drill steel has been recognised as a danger for many years, but dissemination by atomised water is a more recent suspect. In regard to atomisation, he says we must not lose sight of the fact that the mine water used in these drilling operations contains in addition to mineral particles, organic matter, bacteria and moulds in suspension and various salts and some silica in solution, and that these may assist or be concerned in the changes which occur in the lungs. Mine water is not a clean sample of water, and is certainly not a desirable substance to be inhaled into the lungs. Regarding the effect of silica when mixed with coal and haematite dust and with aluminium dust Dr. Simson said it was believed at one time that no serious disability resulted from inhalation of these dusts. It is now known that serious fibrosis may occur following inhalation of either. Further, fibrosis has been shown to occur, after inhalation of coal dust, even in instances in which the percentage of silica is very low. The speaker and Dr. Strachan carried out a series of experiments with a mixture of airborne mine dust and coal dust. The mixture given to each animal consisted of 100 mg. of mine dust and 100 mg. of soft coal dust (Witbank). At the end of twelve months very advanced silicosis had developed in these animals. On the other hand 100 mg. of the mine dust injected into each of another series of animals gave rise only to slight silicosis. This experiment is not exactly comparable to the one with orthoelose and quartzite but the result is very suggestive. From the results of available data haematite dust appears to act in a similar manner to coal dust in so far as regards degree of silicosis. Most Dangerous Dusts. Dr. L. G. Irvine also contributed to the discussion, saying it has been recognised throughout that the most dangerous dusts produced underground are blasting dust and drilling dust. Blasting dust and blasting fumes undoubtedly contributed to the high incidence of silicosis amongst rock drill developers in the earlier years of the industry. But the strict regulation of blasting times, and the application of an extended interval for ventilation after blasting, have provided means for avoiding exposure to blasting dust. There remains drilling dust. In the last report of the Medical Bureau Dr. Irvine published some data regarding the relative incidence of silicosis amongst machine miners and non-machine miners, covering a period of twelve years up to July, 1938. The figures show in the latter years of this period a very marked reduction in incidence, in both classes, and of a practically equal proportion in each. Amongst miners who have worked underground for durations not exceeding six years, the incidence of silicosis has never been high in either class, and is now practically negligible in each. Amongst miners working from the seventh to the twelfth year of underground service the reduction during the past six years has been marked ; and in the last three years up to 1938 there was no significant difference between the two classes in those durations of service. But amongst miners having durations of from the thirteenth to the eighteenth year of underground work the incidence of silicosis amongst those who have spent more than half their time on machines still remains more than three times as high as amongst those who have never worked on machines. The Significant Period. And this period of over twelve years' work is the significant period ; since in both classes it is from the twelfth year that the significant progressive rise in the incidence of silicosis begins. Dr. Irvine has heard it suggested that this is probably due to the presence of older pre-1916 miners. As Mr. Hildick-Smith recommends the practical ideal should be, in the present knowledge of the problem, to eliminate all dust whether from the borer bit or conveyed in atomised water, not only because of dust alone, but because the contribution of atomised water, whether from rock drills or water blasts or sprays, is a very definite factor in increasing the humidity of mine air, and as all know, the combination of high temperatures with high humidity is the main problem to be met in deeper mining. * See this journal, page 85, No. 6, Vol. 51.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||