|
16th January 1937, Page: 218, Column: 1 Safety In Coal MinesElectricity in MinesThese notes are based on the evidence and statements at witnesses appearing before the Royal Commission on Safety in Coal Mines. With further reference to the evidence given by Mr. J. A. B. Horsley before the Mines Commission (see page 198), he indicated that the time had about come when a flameproof apparatus should be required to carry an official certificate. Adding that a time interval would have to be allowed to the individual collieries to make the necessary substitutions, he thought that in about five years time in the progressive collieries there would be very little to replace. He meant that in all new installations it has become the practice for collieries to ask for what they call Buxton-certified plant. Oil-immersed switches play an essential and well-recognised part in the colliery electrical installation. They have certified a number of oil-immersed switches as flameproof. So far as he knows collieries are not afraid to put oil-immersed switches in appropriate places. At the present time the oil-immersed switch for certain classes of duty is irreplaceable. Until recently there has been no real demand for flameproof motors of much over 30 to 50 horse-power. There is, however, some' evidence now of such a demand, and manufacturers concerned have devised ways of meeting that demand. The problem, however, is to provide for the dispersal of the heat due to the inevitable losses. They have devised special means of cooling the machines — to put it shortly — and Mr. Horsley is assured that if the demand does arise manufacturers will be able presently to offer motors up to any size likely to be required in collieries. Heat provides the problem. In the smaller motors the flameproof enclosure necessitates complete enclosure, and that involves considerable increase in size and weight for a given output. Manufacturers are devising methods of keeping down size and weight and cost by forced cooling. Of course the motor is not the only constituent. There is the control switchgear. That problem has not been attacked on the same lines as yet, mainly because the necessity has not arisen. As regards flameproof apparatus, he would recommend the amendment of the regulations in due course so as to require its compulsory use within certain areas. The problem is, where is firedamp in dangerous quantity likely to occur? He only suggests as a basis the area for which approved apparatus is required under the General Lighting Regulations, 1934. That is, briefly, within the region of the coal face and in other places to which regulation 132 applies. Asked if, having installed the flameproof apparatus, there is any difficulty in maintaining it so that it remains flameproof, did it deteriorate ? Mr. Horsley answered: That is the crux of the problem. The design of flameproof enclosures is a comparatively simple problem. It has been solved to a very large extent. Keeping it safe is a more difficult matter. The only effective solution, he thinks, is closer supervision not only of the plant but the user of the plant. In reply to a question by Mr. John Walker the witness agreed that it is considered to be too dangerous to introduce electricity into certain mines, and that in those pits the use of compressed air is growing rapidly. As indicated in reply to Mr. Grenfell, the danger lies very largely in defective plant and machinery and short-circuits of cables. As regards the latter point he thought he could say that there has been a very definite improvement in regard to the plug and the cable. A superior type is now being very largely used, which is less likely to be the seat of open sparking, and better and safer cables are coming into general use. The provision of a screen for a cable, however, is an incomplete protection in itself. We are dependent on the automatic isolation in the circuit. In the early stages we rely on the trip switch (to use the popular term) to cut off the current before anything seriously dangerous occurs. That is not an absolute safeguard, but it goes some way to reducing the danger of open sparking. It is vital that the regular supervision at the mine should be fully maintained. Indeed it is the crux of the problem. Mr. Horsley has heard of instances where trip switches have been deliberately put out of action, and he would consider it a very bad offence. It is impossible to design anything in such a way that an ingenious or mischievous person cannot interfere with it. All you can do is to design it so that with reasonable use it will not easily go wrong. He does not like the term fool-proof. It is an unhappy term. His objection to it is that it does not fully describe the purpose which it was intended to cover. In reply to the point raised by His Honour Judge Allsebrook that it was intended to cover a state of affairs when an inexperienced person might use the apparatus and put the apparatus in a condition of danger, he agreed, adding: "For example, it may take the form of a mechanical interlock to prevent a man from getting in contact with, for instance, fuses, so long as the current is on to those fuses. The man, however, can derange the interlock by some means, for instance, by deliberately removing a screw. If you call such a man a fool I will not quarrel with you; but that is not the primary function of the interlock. The primary function of the interlock is to warn the man that it is not safe to do it. It is not intended to prevent the fool or the ruffian from getting into mischief. You cannot devise anything, as far as I can tell, which would be proof against anything a man could do to it." Examination of Apparatus. In addition to other matters Mr. Miller examined Mr. Horsley on the question of the examination of apparatus and the fixing of a time limit, as follows :— Q. — Dealing with regulation 131, with reference to the appointment of an electrician, that he shall be responsible for the fulfilment of the following duties, "which shall be carried out by him or by an assistant or assistants duly appointed under paragraph (b) (i) the thorough examination of all apparatus (including the testing of earth conductors and metallic coverings for continuity) as often as may be necessary to prevent danger." Is not that very loose owing to the very large amount of electrical apparatus ? Would you not recommend that a time limit should be fixed? A. — It is very difficult to prescribe a time limit for these different operations, which shall not be absurd in one instance and not sufficient in another. To be on the safe side one would have to prescribe an interval which would be unnecessarily short in certain cases — perhaps in a large number of cases — but in others might not be short enough. I think one must in such matters leave discretion to the individual manager and content oneself with giving them general advice; as is done in the present memorandum on the regulations. Q. — But if, owing to there being no definite time fixed, an accident happens, do you think it should still stand? Have you nothing to suggest to make that stronger than it is, in order that the apparatus shall be examined periodically ? A. — I feel a great difficulty in suggesting any period for those three varieties of test; it could not be made of universal application. Q. — Will you tell us 'why you have difficulty in giving us a reply? Could you give us a particular case why you would not fix a time limit ? A. — I cannot give you from memory any particular colliery, I can only give you imaginary examples. In some collieries a weekly test of the trailing cable should I think be carried out, owing to their local conditions. I mean a detailed test by the electricians, which can only be properly carried out by moving the cable on to the surface. That involves a spare cable. In other collieries a weekly removal to the bank would be a waste of money. Perhaps once a month would suffice. The local conditions vary so enormously. Q. — Would it be very costly to take a cable to the surface and back again? A. — It is not a costly operation but it is a rather troublesome one. The main cost would be in providing the necessary spare cable. Q. — Is it not a fact that quite a number of accidents occurs from damaged trailing cables? A. — A large proportion. Q. — Would it not be well to insist that all trailing cables should be examined every week? A. — I think it is putting it too high to require that all trailing cables should be removed to the surface every week, although I know in some cases that is the practice. I discussed this issue lately at a colliery in Lancashire. They asked me to name a period; I said one week; they held up their hands in horror, because in their experience one week was quite unnecessarily short, under their conditions. Q. — Would it be possible to differentiate between conditions say in a thick seam and a thin seam? A. — Something might be done on those lines, but I do not like to take discretion entirely away from the responsible engineer in such matters. If I were responsible I should strongly object to have all my discretion taken away by Act of Parliament. I would say, "Very well, once a week out it comes, and I do not care what happens to it in between; that is your look-out." Q. — But you know from your experience that many accidents would be prevented if the trailing cable were examined on the surface every week? A. — Some would, undoubtedly. I think periodic removal to the bank of trailing cables is essential, but I am not prepared to say that it should be done at any particular interval for all collieries. Surface and Underground Accident Rates. Directing attention to paragraph 9 in the precis showing that the rate of accidents is very much greater underground than on the surface, Mr. Grenfell had some questions to ask to which Mr. Horsley replied :— Q. — In the last seventeen years the number of killed on the surface has been 39 ? A. — Yes. Q. — And the number of killed underground during that period has been 223? A. — Yes. Q. — So that the use of electricity underground is responsible for six times as many deaths as its use on the surface? A. — Yes. Q. — Is it not the case that the horse-power of electrical energy in use on the surface and underground is almost equal? A. — That is so. Q. — Therefore the deduction we draw is that electricity is six times as dangerous underground as on the surface? A. — I will not dispute that. Q. — There is therefore from these figures sufficient proof to show that the use of electricity underground is accompanied with extraordinary risk? A. — I agree. Q. — Below ground 104 persons were killed, and 520 injured, by electric shock or arc-burns. Why should so many people be killed from shock underground, and such a very small proportion be killed on the surface from the same cause? A. — Because the conditions are so very different above and below ground. There are more Opportunities underground to obtain shocks than on the surface. Comparatively few men employed upon the surface have anything directly to do with the electrical installation. Q. — It is because the men are more closely in contact with the exposed parts of machines? A. — With the working parts of machinery and cables. Q. — If cables are properly maintained there should be no risk of short-circuit and shock? A. — Not so long as they are in perfect order. Q. — Do not these figures point to the fact that these cables and connections are not kept in perfect order, and indeed that their condition is very much worse underground than on the surface? A. — I think broadly speaking that is true. Q. — Do you think this Commission can make any recommendations for the better protection of men who have to work in the presence of electric cables and in the presence of machinery with possible live connections ? A. — I have already suggested in answer to similar questions that I think the risk can be reduced by closer attention to the plant and to the personnel. Q. — Is anything being done to instruct the men in the nature of electricity and the nature of the risk they undergo when working in the presence of electricity? A. — I do not think anything has been done systematically in that direction. Q. — Do you think it should be done? A. — I think it would be useful. Q. — If men work near cables charged with a voltage of say 500 or 1,000 or 3,000, contact with a bare cable means instantaneous death, does it not? A. — You have placed the voltage too high. The limit for coal face machinery is 650 volts. That may be fatal, but not necessarily so. Q. — But it generally is? A. — The proportion is roughly that given in paragraph 9 — 104 killed and 520 not killed. Q. — That includes the lower voltages too? A. — Yes. Q. — If all the voltages were at a figure of 500 or 600 you would expect a higher proportion of deaths than this? A. — The largest proportion of horse-power of motors used underground is in the region of 500 volts. Some of those accidents are at much higher voltages — a small proportion of them 2,000, 3,000 and 11,000 volts. Q. — Death can occur when the voltage is as low as 200, can it not? A. — Yes, or even lower. Q. — So that men who work with electrical current anywhere should be made acquainted with the risks they run and the means by which they can obviate those risks? A. — I think they might usefully be instructed in the proper way to handle the plant they have to use. Q. — A new kind of knowledge has to be acquired by the miner to replace some of the old knowledge which he gained when he was responsible for production work with the ordinary tools? A. — Yes. Q. — There is a new technique which must be carried to the miner as well as to the officials of the mine? A. — Yes. Summary of Recommendations. In the course of a long examination by Mr. Forster Brown the recommendations were summarised as under :— Q. — May I summarise your recommendations in this way: As far as ignition from signalling bells is concerned, you would recommend the strengthening of the existing regulations? A. — I think it might be made specific so as to require the use of certified signalling systems throughout safety-lamp mines. Q. — You would also recommend regulations regarding the transmission lines at the surface ? A. — Yes. Q. — Apart from that, to minimise shock you would recommend that trailing cables should be screened and governed by switchgear containing all proper protective devices? A. — Yes. Q. — You would further recommend that all plant and equipment should comply with the British Standards specification? A. — Yes. Q. — You would further recommend that flameproof apparatus should be installed in certain parts of certain mines? A. — Yes. Q. — If those recommendations were carried out at once it would, as I think you have already admitted, impose a tremendous financial burden upon the industry if the existing plant had to be replaced by those things? A. — Undoubtedly. Q. — Would you consider it reasonable, having that in mind, that if these recommendations from you on these lines were implemented by the Commission, they would apply in the first instance to new equipment, and secondly, that an adequate period of time should be given in other cases for the new things to be installed to replace the old ones A. — Yes, I would agree on both those points. As regards electricians Mr. Horsley's recommendation is that ultimately there should be a statutory examination carrying a first grade and second grade certificate, service certificates being issued meanwhile to all the existing staff until they got a generation who passed the examination for the certificates. He would not suggest certification for anybody but the electrician and his assistants, appointed under the terms of Regulation 131 (c). He was not suggesting certificates for linesmen, armature winders, apprentices, and so on, — only for those who have responsible statutory duties.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||