|
2nd January 1937, Page: 198, Column: 1 Safety In Coal MinesElectricity in MinesThese notes are based on the evidence and statements of witnesses appearing before the Royal Commission on Safety in Coal Mines. Qualifications and Duties of Electricians. The Association of Mining Electrical Engineers, which has eleven branches in various mining districts with a membership of about 2,100, was represented before the Mines Commission by Major E. Ivor David, M.I.Mech.E., some of the points in the statement of evidence being :— Members of the electrical staff should be considered as specialists in their particular work. They are required to undergo a special training of a nature not followed by the ordinary workman, and their experience and knowledge is not acquired by others coming under the category of general officials. The experience gained in the working of the regulations as to the installation and use of electricity, embodied in the Coal Mines Act of 1911, shows that there has been a marked improvement in the maintenance of electrical apparatus both above and below ground, even as there has also been a marked improvement in the design and construction of apparatus. Experience has also shown that many boys and youths have been attracted into this branch of mining, but the Association views with concern the increasing difficulty in retaining them in colliery work. It is within their experience that many leave the collieries for more congenial work as soon as an opportunity presents itself. It has to be recognised that such opportunities are plentiful for skilled men in this age — and thus the mining industry loses many good men whose services should be retained. It appears, therefore, to be necessary that some definite steps be taken to improve the conditions by raising the status of the electrician-in-charge and of his assistants. It would appear to be desirable that this improvement in the conditions of employment should be accompanied by defining the duties and statutory responsibilities of the electrician appointed under General Regulation 131. This regulation might be adjusted and extended to provide that an electrician and assistants shall be appointed in writing, to supervise the apparatus, maintain it in safe working order, as far as is reasonably practicable, and examine and test it as often ns may be necessary to prevent danger. In many instances the plant used is required to be certified "flameproof," and it is desirable that the electrician appointed under General Regulation 131 (b), whose duty it is to maintain the plant, should be certificated. In accordance with the present Regulation 131 (b), the manager is required to appoint in writing an electrician who shall be competent for the duties which he is required to perform under General Regulation 131. It is desirable that definite provisions should be established whereby the manager will be able to satisfy himself with regard to the competency of the electrician and his assistants. It appears to be desirable that the person thus appointed should hold a certificate of competency from a Board of Examinations on electricity as applied to mining, or alternatively from an authority approved by the Secretary of State. Suggestions for candidate's qualifications. — (i) He has had at least five years' engineering training, of which three years have been spent at a colliery in practical electrical work, both above and below ground. (ii) He is competent to install, supervise. maintain, examine and test apparatus in use both above and below ground. (iii) He is conversant with the Act, general regulations and the installation and use of electricity in mines. (iv) He is competent to make the essential entries in the log-hook and daily log sheets in the form prescribed by the Board of Trade. Educational authorities in mining areas should be given greater financial assistance to provide the necessary technical education, in order to permit of candidates qualifying for the proposed certificates of competency. As the result of practical and close contact with the subject of mining electrical engineering, the view of the Association is that matters relating to design and testing for reliability can be left with safety to the Mines Department, manufacturers and those responsible for the supervision of the apparatus at the mines. Horse-power of Motors. The Commission also called and examined Mr. J. A. B. Horsley, O.B.E., H.M. Electrical Inspector of Mines, who gave evidence on the use of electricity in mines, the incidence of accidents due to its use, and also the regulations governing its use under the Coal Mines Act. Abstracts are given from the statement submitted by the Inspector as follow :— Beginning with the year 1912, statistical information has been available regarding the use of electricity in mines, by means of annual returns made by each colliery showing the horse-power of electrical motors installed for various purposes. In round figures the total horse-power installed was 511,000 in 1912 and 2,010,000 in 1935. Of these totals 317,000 horse-power in 1912 and 1,057,000 horse-power in 1935, was installed below ground. Coal-cutting machines accounted for 31,000 horse-power in 1912 and 138,000 horse-power in 1935. The horse-power of motors installed for conveyors and loaders was first recorded separately for the year 1926, when it was 8,000, increasing to 47,000 for 1935. Below ground the horse-power per person employed was 0.36 in 1912 and 1.74 in 1935. The horse-power per mine using electricity in 1912 was 222 below ground and 136 above ground, and this had increased to 798 and 720 respectively in 1936. Machine Mining. In 1912 some 20¼ million tons of mineral, or 7.5 per cent. of the total mineral production, were got by machine mining. Of this quantity nearly 12 million tons was due to the use of electricity, and nearly 8½ million tons to the use of compressed air. The corresponding figures for 1935 were 113½ million tons, or 49.5 per cent. of the total output; 80½ million tons being due to electricity and nearly 33 million tons due to compressed air. This does not include 9½ million tons got by the use of light pneumatic picks. In 1935, there were in use 4,635 electrically driven coal-cutting machines and 2,837 driven by compressed air. Conveyors and Loaders. Full particulars in regard to the use of conveyors and loaders, including the tonnage dealt with, were first made available for the year 1930, but information as to the number of machines driven by electricity and by compressed air, respectively, is available from the year 1929, in which year there were 1,617 machines driven by electricity, and 1,956 driven by compressed air which, together, dealt with some 37,000,000 tons of mineral. For 1935 these numbers had increased to 3,892 and 2,940 respectively, while the tonnage dealt with amounted to 95,600,000. Of this total tonnage approximately 56,000,000 tons was dealt with by electrical machines, and 38,400,000 tons by compressed. air machines, the balance, amounting to some 1,200,000 tons, being dealt with by electricity and compressed-air machines together. Incidence of Accidents. All accidents due to the use of electricity which cause any personal injury whatever, are reportable forthwith and also all accidents resulting in the ignition of firedamp or of coal dust and all cases of fire below ground, even where no personal injury or disablement is caused, are similarly reportable. It results. that in many of the non-fatal electric shock accidents, which are included in the data to be submitted in this evidence, the nature of the personal injury suffered was very slight. Nevertheless, these slight accidents cannot be ignored because there is sometimes but little in the circumstances, other than the result, to distinguish them from serious or even fatal instances of electric shock. During the 17 years from 1919 to 1935 inclusive the number of persons killed and injured either directly or indirectly due to the use of electricity amounted to 39 killed and 286 injured above ground and 223 killed and 666 injured below ground, the gross totals being 262 killed and 952 injured, an annual average of 15 killed and 56 injured. Below ground 104 persons were killed and 520 injured by electric shock or arc burns; 107 were killed and 108 injured by ignitions of firedamp, including 33 killed and seven injured in ignitions due to unsafe signalling bells; eight were killed and ten injured as a result of fire arising from electrical defects ; four were killed and 28 injured in other ways. During the period of 17 years from 1919 to 1935, inclusive, there were, in all, 825 non-fatal accidents due to the use of electricity, above and below ground. The annual average is, therefore, just over 48. While electric shock is by far the commonest cause of accident, the ignition of firedamp is not unnaturally regarded as the dominant risk in the use of electricity in mines. Nevertheless, over the period of 17 years, from 1919 to 1935, inclusive, out of a total of 233 instances of the ignition of firedamp from various causes, except ignition by naked lights which accounted for 866 instances in the same period, 41 were due to the use of electric power, 35 to matches or smoking, 26 to flame safety-lamps damaged or illegally opened, and 79 to shot-firing, eight due to underground fires, with a balance of 44 due to miscellaneous, or unknown causes. Notwithstanding the great increase in the use of electricity both above and below ground and, in particular, the rapid increase in the number of electrically driven coal-cutting machines and conveyers, the number of electrical accidents has shown no comparable increase. There is a tendency for non-fatal electric shock accidents below ground to increase with the increase in coal face machinery, but the ignitions of firedamp due to electricity do not exhibit this tendency. With steady improvement in design towards greater safety, aided by better understanding in application, it may reasonably be hoped that the increasing use of electricity will be accompanied by a decreasing hazard in its employment. This desirable result has actually been attained above ground. Regulations Governing Use of Electricity. The general regulations as to the installation and use of electricity below ground, which are now in force, were made by Order dated 10th July, 1913. These regulations with appropriate amendment were applied to apparatus above ground by Order dated 28th July, 1920. In the Coal Mines General Regulations (Lighting), 1934, dated 1st June, 1934, Part II. extended the area within which lighting otherwise than by means of safety-lamps could be used, and varied the previous requirements in regard to electric lighting supplied from the mains, or fed from a self-contained source of power. The Electricity Regulations of 1913 may be said to have achieved their purpose of reducing the risk of accident by improving the quality of construction of apparatus and by raising the standard of supervision and maintenance, as judged by the favourable accident record. By way of illustration, it may be noted that for the five years from 1907 to 1911, inclusive, there were 59 deaths from electric shock below ground, an average of 118, whereas, in the succeeding 24 years, the number was 148, an average of 62. Excluding the years 1921 and 1926, the average for this latter period of 22 years becomes 66. In view of the state of the art at that time, those regulations were deliberately drafted in somewhat general terms, so as to permit latitude in interpretation. This elasticity has not proved a disadvantage, for it has made it comparatively easy to keep practice abreast of improvements in technique, and to meet new requirements in the industry, by administrative action. Nevertheless, the time is approaching when it will be convenient to remodel the regulations, so as to bring them into line with the best present day practice. Suggestions for Amendment. — Without going into detail, it may be suggested that amendment of the regulations should be directed to (i) greater stringency in the requirements for the automatic. protection of circuits, (ii) insistence on the use of metallic screens for flexible cables employed with coal-cutters and conveyers, and (iii) the compulsory use of approved apparatus, i.e., certified flameproof apparatus, within certain areas.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||