|
4th July 1936, Page: 405, Column: 1 Falls And Accidents In Bord And PillarReport By Messrs. Hudspeth, Phillips And Walker. At the meeting of the North of England Institute of Mining and Mechanical Engineers on 20th June a report was read which had been prepared by Messrs. H. M. Hudspeth, D.S.O., M.C., M.Sc., D. W. Phillips, B.Sc., Ph.D., and Arthur Walker. This was the "Fourth Progress Report of the Support of Workings in Mines Committee of an Investigation into the Causes of Falls, and Accidents Due to Falls, in Bord and Pillar Whole Workings." Extracts from the report are appended :— Forces Induced by Coal Removal. As the coal is removed the roof-strata in the immediate vicinity of a narrow working are subjected to bending, shearing, and compressive forces. Bending of the roof-strata under their own weight results in the development of compressive, tensile, and shearing stresses, the intensities of which increase with the width of the working; and, the greater the bending capacities of the beds above, the greater will be the bending Stresses in the immediate roof. At the face and sides the roof-material is subjected to a shearing force the magnitude of which increases with depth; it is also influenced by the strengths of the coal and/or of the floor, being less the weaker and the more yielding these are. With a decrease in width and the consequent less yielding of the sides the shearing force is increased. From all directions freedom of movement is afforded towards the excavation, and the rocks in the vicinity tend to expand into it; this expansion, from over the solid, results in lateral forces acting along the roof-strata in a manner similar to the forces on a strut. The intensity of these lateral forces increases with depth, but as movement proceeds into the excavation it diminishes, and can only be increased thereafter by an increase in the magnitude of the vertical forces. This is effected by the transmission of the weight of the strata above the excavation to the solid coal, so resulting in an abutment pressure beyond each side of the roadway and in front of the face. The redistribution of weight of the higher measures results in the development of a pressure arch and a somewhat de-stressed zone therein. The beds within the pressure arch deflect slightly and no longer carry the weight of the superincumbent mass of strata. General Effects of Driving, etc. The immediate roof of a narrow roadway may be likened to a plate which bends (troughs) into the excavation; and because of the support afforded across the corners at the face the intensities of the several stresses vary across its width. With the setting of roof supports the bending forces are reduced, and that part of the load carried by the supports is not transmitted to the margins of the excavation. To this extent the shearing forces at the sides and at the face are decreased, but this may be offset by an increase due to the greater proportion of the load of the higher beds there concentrated. As to how a roof-stratum may fail depends upon its capacity to resist the different forces induced. Sandstones are strong in shear and will generally fail in bending; shales, on the other hand are weak — and will generally fail — in shear, in both cases, however, failure may be due to a combination of bending and shear. It is only in the deeper workings — and in particular where the strata are laminated — that lateral stresses may con tribute appreciably to fracturing. A well-laminated shale roof of a very narrow working, where bending is almost negligible, may be "split" by the lateral force acting parallel to the laminations, in which direction a shale is relatively weak in compression. The effect of the transmitted load will depend upon the area over which it is distributed which is less the stronger the coal. In any case the liability of the roof-strata to fracture over the solid is increased, and this liability increases with depth and width of working. The distance over the solid at which the strata may be broken increases with time until stability is attained. In addition to the more local effects, the surrounding area is de-stressed (both vertical and lateral stresses being relieved) to a greater or less degree, both in extent and intensity, depending upon the nature of the coal and the adjacent strata. Also, the release of gas from the coal is associated with its contraction and a wider redistribution of the load. That the floor is an important factor in the general problem is undoubted. Stresses of a nature similar to those in the roof are induced in the floor, and its reaction thereto will affect the roof loading conditions. The development of bord-and-pillar whole workings over a wide enough area gradually results in the whole weight of the strata being carried by the pillars; in other words, the load on the pillars increases to a maximum. During this process further fracturing may occur. Some Observed Phenomena. (a) Conditions in Bords v. Walls. — In previous reports it has been shown that the roofs of walls are usually in a better condition than those of bords of equal width. The difference is very slight at shallow depths, but is especially marked where the roofs are of shale at depths of over 1,000 ft. ; under these conditions it is quite common for the wall roofs to remain unfractured in a mine or district where considerable trouble is experienced with bord roofs. Considering bords and walls of equal width in close proximity, the only variable factor is the direction of the working in relation to the cleat, in consequence of which the sides of a bord (and the face of a wall) are more rigid than the sides of a wall (and the face of a bord). That the direction of a working in relation to the cleat is an important factor affecting roof conditions was confirmed where the cross-cleat was well developed ; in this case there was no difference between the conditions in bords and walls. In yet other circumstances, the winnings (in this case cross-cuts) were fractured, whether driven N.S. or E.W. (b) The Nature of the Reef Fractures. — Three distinct types of fracturing have been observed in shale reefs and they are to some extent associated with depth. In each case all the forces previously considered are acting on the roof, but the predominance of one of these determines the form of the fracture. (c) Fracture Control in Bords. — Details of experiments whereby the fracturing of the shale roofs of bords was controlled were given in the Third Progress Report. The good roof conditions which follow fracture control are a consequence of the further development of the initial fracture which occurs rather than the formation of another; thus the fracture at the side will progress upwards through the immediate roof-stratum which, subjected to the bending force due to its own weight, tends to part from the bed above and relieve itself of some superincumbent load. It has often been observed that the roof condition in a skirting alongside a bord was much better than in the bord itself. A somewhat similar explanation suffices in this case. (d) Pressure Relief. — In the Second Progress Report a method adopted in a seam at a depth of 1,146 ft. to provide relief from weight in certain selected bords was described. It is suggested that the explanation of this "pressure relief" is the same in principle as that given in the case of nicking experiments. The collapse of the shale roof in the pressure-relief bord allows of a greater expansion of the reef-beds towards the bord, and in order to maintain the original vertical pressure on the roof the whole mass of higher strata would have to subside. This is not likely to occur at the boundary of whole workings, and the vertical weight acting on the roof in regions surrounding the pressure-relief bord will become less.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||