|
2nd September 1933, Page: 52, Column: 1 Some Medical Aspects Of Coal MiningBy S. W. Fisher, B.A., M.D., B.Ch. (H.M. Medical Inspector of Mines).* The old-time tendency to regard coal miners as. a strange and savage race apart has now happily died out. Those who know the miner well realise that he is very much as other men. That miners are tough and hardy is evidenced not only by their ability to cope with their hard work, and the splendid specimens one sees underground, but also by the high standard they reach in the realms of sport, especially boxing and football. Facilities for all games are now afforded by the Miners' Welfare Fund, and good playing fields are a feature of almost every mining centre. Intellectually also the miners hold their own. Every mining community can point to numbers who have obtained good qualifications and positions not only in their own calling, but also in the church, teaching profession, law, medicine, literature — and, of course, politics. In one thing they remain very conservative. The food and drink they consume during their day's work is mainly the same as what their fathers and grandfathers took before them. I think with Professor Collis, that a canteen on the pit surface which could provide a more varied diet, suitable to a certain extent to the type of mine, i.e., whether it is moderate in temperature or rather warm, would be of great benefit, and its fare more appetising than the rather monotonous cold contents of the usual food box. Miners are already showing a great appreciation of the certified milk which is supplied in bottles and drunk through straws, and provided at canteens connected with pithead baths. The increasing popularity of pithead baths is a matter for satisfaction. The brisk warm shower, followed by a cold one, for those who like it, and the subsequent rub down with a towel stimulates the skin, nerves and blood circulation. It cleans away all the sweat and dirt which might be infected by micro-organisms capable of causing boils or other inflammatory conditions of the skin. The clothes the miner wore coming to the pit are dried by the time he finishes work and his chances of catching cold are definitely lessened, while his sense of well-being is increased. There are, however, special complaints to which a miner may be liable, depending in some cases on the type of work he is doing, and in others on the type of mine. I cannot deal with all these conditions in an evening — I shall, however, with your permission mention a few and choose one or two for closer examination. Silicosis. Recent legislation (The Various Industries "Silicosis" Scheme) provides for the payment of compensation if the condition merits the name Silicosis and it applies to partial disablement as well as complete disablement and death. If the workman has been employed in the processes for a period or periods amounting to not less than five years, the disease is deemed to be due to employment in the processes unless the employer proves the contrary. Special types of labour are enumerated in the Scheme (a) Drilling or blasting in stone in any sinking pit or staple pit or in any cross-measure or stone drift or other strait or narrow working in any coal mine, or any handling or moving of stone at the working places where these processes are carried on (b) Operating or assisting in the operation of any power-driven machine used for drilling, cutting, ripping, or breaking stone in any coal mine; any one of which must have been performed if the validity of the claim is to be upheld. It must he understood that not all dusts that are breathed into the lungs are dangerous, at least not to the same degree, so I shall try briefly to describe what happens in the lungs when non-dangerous and dangerous dusts are inhaled. The rise and fall of the chest produces expansion and contraction of the lungs. This action is smooth and rhythmic and is made possible by the elasticity of the lungs and by the fact that it is covered by a double layer of wonderfully fine smooth tissue called the pleura. The root of the lung is the point at which the bronchi, blood vessels and nerves enter and leave the organ. In descriptions of X-ray films of the chest, the root of the lung is often called the hilum. An X-ray photograph of the chest of a healthy young adult brought up in the country would show nothing but the ribs, heart and large blood vessels in a practically clear space. Let us bring him to work in a rather dusty atmosphere, not considered dangerous, and see what happens. The larger dust particles are caught by the upper part of the nose and throat, only the very finest particles finding their way along the smallest bronchioles, to the alveoli. When the dust particles impinge on the alveolar wall, they are taken up by special cells called phagocytes which are derived from the wall of the air-sac (alveolar epithelium). The phagocyte laden with dust may now follow two routes-it may become free in the air-sac, make its way to a bronchiole, and there get helped by the ciliated epithelium. This ciliated epithelium (or simply, cilia) is found in man throughout the whole extent of the air passages and their prolongations, except the uppermost part of the nostrils and a little of the larynx. Cilia consists of very, very minute and fine projections, shall we say, like wonderfully tiny fingers. The projections are alive and move spontaneously to and fro and produce a current in the fluid which covers them. When in motion a cilium is bent quickly over in one direction with a lashing whip-like movement, immediately recovering itself. The action may be ten or more times a second, so that it is difficult to follow the motion with the eye. In the air passages the wave passes upwards and the layer acts somewhat like a conveyor — the cells laden with dust get mixed with catarrh and land on the ever-moving conveyor and are carried upwards towards the mouth, and the healthy young man coughs up phlegm full of dust particles and gets rid of them in this way. The second route is via the lymphatic channels draining into the various lymphatic glands. The simple elimination of the dust by the action of phagocytes and cilia or lymphatics unfortunately does not always take place. Let us now expose our healthy man to the dust which causes silicosis, viz., dust containing a large proportion of free silica (SiO2). The phagocytes of the wall of the air-sac attack the dust particles, but not so eagerly (Haynes), and those which reach the ciliated epithelium are dealt with like those containing non-dangerous dust. But the cells which get into the lympathic system soon lose their mobile properties, owing to the fact that the free silica dissolves and forms a toxic solution, and tend to accumulate. Thus throughout the lungs and beneath the pleura, aggregations of motionless dust cells heap up, disintegrate, and a fibrotic process begins, that is to say, a dot of scar tissue forms and this becomes larger as new dust cells drift up and cluster around the original heap. The centre of this accumulation becomes hard (hyaline), so that the lung becomes closely studded with these hard nodules which show up as spots on an X-ray film. One of these nodules cut across shows a central area of hard fibrosis enclosed in concentric laminae. An X-ray photograph of a patient in this stage of silicosis would show the so-called falling snow picture. As well as these hard discrete foci, fibrous ramifications usually develop in the connective tissue and show up as intertwining arborisations in the radiogram. This arborising fibrosis may exist in conditions other than silicosis. As simple silicosis develops, the number of nodules becomes greater and tends to crowd together and obliterate the lung tissue forming an area of "massive fibrosis" — a section of this still shows the numerous concentric single islets that make up the massive area. The pleura becomes thickened and binds the lungs to the chest wall. So much for the uncomplicated silicosis of the gold miner on the Rand who, during his work, has inhaled only highly siliceous dust, and in these days a comparatively low concentration. The usual end of such a case is that pulmonary tuberculosis supervenes. Let us now consider the coal miner. In what manner is his position different? In two ways :— (a) He is liable to inhale various types of dust. (b) He is exposed to heavily concentrated atmospheres. It is generally agreed that coal dust itself produces a brisk reaction and is copiously eliminated, i.e., a collier may, as we know he does, during his working life, inhale a large quantity with impunity. But he may also, if he uses drills in rock, inhale a great deal of stone dust ranging from soft shale to a sandy clift, and on to a highly siliceous rock like "Greys" or "Pennant." What is likely to happen, and what, in fact, seems to me to be the case, is (1) that a certain amount of free SiO2 is left behind in his lungs, and a fibrosis commences which, as it progresses, interferes more and more with the elimination of all other dusts, with the result that the lung becomes heavily charged-the pleura becomes thick and adherent, and back pressure is exerted on the heart and the patient may die of heart failure without any sign of tuberculosis (2) a lung already fibrosed from other causes, e.g., bronchitis, chronic phthisis, etc., may start the same process. Lastly, one must consider the various dusts. Coal dust, which excites a brisk phagocytosis, is, if taken alone, believed to be harmless. Shale dust, like coal dust, is not only considered harmless, but may even be of service in facilitating the elimination of harmful dusts such as silica; but one should know exactly what the word "shale" connotes. In mines a stone is often known as shale which may contain a high percentage of free silica (between 30 and 60 per cent.). This dust is even sometimes used for stone-dusting in mines. In my opinion a dust such as this is or may be harmful, but, I stress the point, it is called shale although not a true one. Sandstone dust is definitely harmful. Preventive Measures. In order to deal adequately with the prevention of the inhalation of dust, the minute size of the particles that cause harm must be clearly realised. Of all the dust we breathe, only a certain proportion actually reaches the fine air cells or alveoli ; the larger particles are trapped, as I have already explained, in the upper air passages. The first question we have to decide is how are we to know when this dangerous dust is in the air, and secondly how can we tell when the quantity of this dust is dangerous. These questions are answered by the konimeter. There are various types of konimeters, but essentially they are the same. By means of a pump a certain rather small quantity of air is sucked in through a small hole. This air impinges on a glass slide which is covered with a sticky material. Any dust that is in the air sucked in sticks to the slide. The slide is then taken out and by means of a microscope both the number and size of the particles in a given quantity of air can be estimated. The size of dust particles which can actually do harm must be below 10 microns ; the size of particles found in the ash of a silicotic lung. One micron equals one twenty-five thousandth part of an inch. The number considered to be harmful is 300 particles for each cubic centimetre of air if the Kotze konimeter is used with a magnification of 150 diameters. Another thing we must remember is, that dust particles may quite easily be so tiny that even a high-powered microscope will not reveal them. Naturally these ultra-microscopic particles, if they exist, would be the most dangerous, and that is why we want to keep in mind the fact that they may exist. More fine dust is produced by blunt drills than by sharp drills. Knowing all this, the earliest efforts were directed with the object of keeping the dust out of the air, and rather naturally the first thing thought of was water. The early workers thought that by directing a spray or a jet of water against the face of the rock they were wetting the dust, and thus keeping it out of the air. This has long since proved to be incorrect. The fine dust goes straight through the water spray as though it did not exist. The next method was to direct water through the drill as a hole was being bored; the water in this way reaches the end of the hole, and the dust thoroughly mixed up, emerges as a sludge. This is the method at present most employed in South Africa. Its ultimate efficiency depends entirely on whether the dust being dealt with has an affinity for water or not. Where the dust has this affinity, that is to say, mixes freely with water, the method is efficient enough for all practical purposes, but where the dust has no such affinity the method is ineffective. A further drawback to the use of water is, that in a hot mine the atmosphere becomes so humid that it is not healthy for the worker. The method which is now considered to be effective is that of collecting the dust, and this method took definite form when the Hay dust trap was perfected. Other dust traps, all working more or less on the same principle, some efficient, some not efficient, have recently been invented. The efficient ones have been approved for use in mines. Essentially they work in the same way, namely, a jet of compressed air is directed away from the rock towards a bag. This creates a vacuum at the face of the rock, and any dust generated is swept from the rock into the bag. The efficiency of the dust trap then depends on whether the bag is a proper filter or not, that is to say, whether it allows the air to pass and retains the dust. The most recent method for the suppression of dust when rock drilling is by means of what is known as the Pyrene foam appliance. The equipment comprises a light closed steel container having a capacity of about 5 gallons. Into this container is filled a mixture of one part foam-forming concentrate and 99 parts water. The compressed air supply to the container performs two functions (a) it provides the necessary pressure for the discharge of the foam and (b) it aerates the foam solution by means of a special diffuser. The foam discharge is connected to the water inlet valve of a standard water fed drill by means of a length of rubber hose. The foam passes through the drill and completely binds the dust. One gallon of liquid per hour suffices. I am informed that the foam producing medium is saponin extract which is obtained from the barks of certain trees. Respirators worn over the nose and mouth have been made use of by workmen as a primitive method of stopping dust going down their throats, but this is where a realisation of the minute size of the particles is useful. If air can pass freely through the respirator in normal inspiration, the very fine particles of dust are going to pass too, and these, you may remember, are the most dangerous. I have examined carefully many respirators. As yet an efficient one has not been constructed, but research work is still proceeding in the endeavour to evolve a respirator which will be both practicable in use and efficient. Another means of prevention which must never be overlooked is ventilation. Ventilation should always be as brisk as possible while dust is being generated. This also applies to shot-firing, and it must be distinctly understood that it is dangerous for a man to go hack info a heading driven in siliceous material before ventilation has cleared away all the dust floating in the air. So that wherever men work in dangerous rock a dust trap should be provided, and one of the main objects of this lecture is to impress upon those concerned that when a dust trap is provided it should be used. * From lecture before the Armstrong College Mining Society and published in Volume 9 of the Society's JOURNAL.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||