|
5th June 1926, Page: 358, Column: 1 Spontaneous CombustionFrom paper on "A Resume of Spontaneous Combustion" presented at the March meeting of the Past and Present Mining Students' Association in the Wigan Mining and Technical College, Concluded from page 310. By Wm. Lomax, B.Sc. Practical Considerations. The practical underground conditions which affect the liability of coal seams to spontaneous combustion are :— 1. The method of working. — The method of extracting any particular seam must depend on and be adapted to the existing natural conditions. The method should be such as to allow of the minimum rate of extraction and advance of face, thus minimising the crush on the coal, together with a gradual lowering of the roof in the waste. 2. The leaving of coal pillars. — Pillars of coal are left to support the shafts and also frequently to support the main haulage roads, surface land, etc. Pillars may also be left as barriers between various districts or working places. The coal at the edges of these pillars becomes crushed owing to the pressure of the strata, and it accumulates where it falls. Air may leak to this coal along the edge of the pillar, and if the leakage is not such that the heat produced is carried away as fast as it is generated spontaneous combustion may result. This is found to be the case, especially with shaft pillars. 3. The presence of stumps of coal and timber in the gob. — It is frequently found impossible to avoid leaving small stumps of coal in the waste. Such coal becomes crushed when the roof pressure comes on. Further, these small pillars hinder or prevent the even settlement of the roof. This becomes broken and allows of easy access of air to the crushed coal. Timber in the form of props and bars, stacks, etc., may be left in the waste. Such timber prevents the tightening of the packs, the roof becomes broken and leakage of air results. Timber will ignite at a temperature about 50°C. below the ignition point of coal. This temperature is still considerably lower if the timber has been subjected to dry rot. Hence, timber may be the original source of spontaneous heating in the goaf, which will then be transferred to other carbonaceous material in the goaf. 4. The use of coal, timber, etc., as packing material. — In some mines inferior coal, old timber, carbonaceous shale, etc., may be used to form the packs. Leakage of air will take place very slowly through these packs in circumstances very favourable for the production of spontaneous combustion. 5. The leakage of air. — It has been shown that all cases of spontaneous combustion are due to the leakage of air in such circumstances that the heat produced by the resulting oxidation of carbonaceous substances is not carried away by the air. Hence, the heat accumulates to the point of ignition. The heat produced creates convection currents, which thus bring in further supplies of oxygen to the heating mass. Dr. Haldane has expressed the opinion that it is only necessary to establish a suitable air-current in one direction through a sufficient mass of coal in order to produce spontaneous firing with any variety of coal. This is because of the fact that the heat produced is cumulative, and an initial heating which is insignificant may increase continuously until the ignition point is reached. It must also be remembered that the rate of heat production increases with rise of temperature. Air may percolate into cracks in pillars or through the goaf through a process of "breathing" which is directly affected by changes in the barometric pressure of the air. Also, the quantity of air leaking through obstructed passages, such as a goaf, is directly proportional to the difference in pressure between the two ends, not proportional to the square root of the pressure as is the case with an open airway. Leakage of air is very liable to take place in mines from the main intake to the main return, especially where the distance between the two is not very great. The faces of the intake and return airways should be rendered as airtight as possible and all connections between the two roads should be so provided as to minimise leakage. Much leakage of air occurs in the workings owing to the unsystematic methods of forming the gate road and face packs. The formation of good solid packs is to be recommended for reasons other than to secure good ventilation and prevent leakage. In some of our mines the efficiency of the ventilation, i.e., the ratio between the amount of air reaching the coal face and the amount passing down the downcast shaft, is extremely low. I am of the opinion that inefficient ventilation and the occurrence of gob-fires are interdependent in seams liable to spontaneous combustion. The Detection of Gob-fires. Broadly speaking, there are two methods employed in the detection of underground fires, viz. :— 1. That of the practical miner, in which he makes use of his various senses together with his long practical experience of such work. 2. That based on the accurate, systematic analysis of the air in the neighbourhood of a suspected area. This involves the aid of the skilled mine chemist. Before a fire breaks out underground, due to spontaneous combustion, there are certain definite indications of abnormality in the area. As with most other mining conditions, these indications vary in degree according to the particular circumstances, and each case must be judged on its merits. Generally speaking, the first sign of heating in any area is the deposition of moisture on the floor, roof and sides of the roadways, as a film or in drops. This is due to the moisture being liberated from the heating substance, carried away by the warm air, and then re-deposited on the cool sides of the roadways. "Sweating" is the usual name given to this occurrence. As the heating advances "gob-stink" may be detected due to the evolution of the volatile products from the heating mass. The character of this smell varies as the temperature increases. As described by Graham and Storrow, the smell which is peculiar to all wastes may at first be more pronounced. Then as the high volatile paraffins are given off from the coal, a petrol-like odour may be noted. At higher temperatures the heavier volatile bodies are given off and the smell may have a more oily character until, when the fire stage is reached, a distinctly tarry odour, often with a trace of sulphur, becomes evident. It has also been found that when a gob-fire is under control and the heating is dying down another distinct odour is emitted, this being known as "dead stink." It will thus be seen that the sense of smell is very important in the detection of spontaneous combustion underground. Dr. Haldane has recently stated that, in the detection of gob-fires, there is no scientific instrument to equal the nose. The systematic recording of the changes in temperature in a suspected area may be of some value, together with the relative humidity of the air as indicated by the wet and dry bulb readings of a hygrometer. Experience has shown, however, that such readings cannot always be taken as a reliable indication of the existing conditions with regard to heating. The application of gas analysis to the detection of spontaneous combustion is a comparatively recent departure. The research work done by Messrs. Graham and Storrow and other investigators indicate that, in many cases, heating may be detected by systematic gas analyses before any of the signs previously mentioned are evident. In order to interpret the results of such analyses, it is necessary to understand the change or the vitiation which may take place in the chemical composition of the mine atmosphere. Under normal conditions such changes may be brought about by the evolution of gases from the strata, the burning of lamps, the breathing of men and animals, the decay of timber and oxidation of carbonaceous and other material. The latter factor is the only one which is liable to change to any extent. When air comes into contact with carbonaceous substances oxygen is absorbed and carbon dioxide and carbon monoxide are evolved, together with a little moisture. It is found convenient to represent the vitiations of the atmosphere by the ratio between the amount of oxygen absorbed and the amount of carbon dioxide and carbon monoxide evolved. Normally, this ratio is practically constant, increasing slightly with the age of the wastes in the mine. It has been pointed out that the rate of oxidation of coal increases with the increase of temperature. Experiments have shown, however, that for small increases in temperature above the normal oxidation takes, place without any corresponding evolution of carbon dioxide, though traces of carbon monoxide are given off. As the temperature rises, the rate of oxidation increases but the evolution of carbon dioxide and carbon monoxide proceeds rapidly in proportion to the oxygen absorbed. Hence the ratios
are of great value. The first ratio is normally constant for old goaves. When heating is taking place the ratio will first show a rise above the normal then, as the temperature increases, the value of the ratio will drop. The second ratio is normally constant, but when heating is taking place the value shows a gradual rise. As the amount of carbon monoxide produced is comparatively small its accurate determination has but recently been made possible. Mr. Ivon Graham has devised a method by which 1 part of carbon monoxide in 100,000 parts of air can be determined underground. His subsequent experiments have shown that, by the systematic sampling of the air in a suspected area, a very good idea of the existing conditions can be obtained. Methods of Dealing with Underground Fires. The practical measures employed in suppressing underground fires are numerous and vary in detail according to the existing local conditions. The method must be modified for each seam, and even for separate occurrences in the same seam. It is only possible to generalise in their description. Whenever possible, the most effective method is that employed by the Earl of Wemyss in 1674, namely, to dig the fire out. This is only applicable where the seat of the trouble can be definitely located and reached, the secret of success being speed. In other circumstances the affected area must be quickly sealed off from the admission of air by the erection of dams or stoppings. In the construction of such stoppings brick, cement, ferro concrete, sand soil and clay have been effectively used under varying conditions. A memorandum has recently been published by a special committee appointed by the Institution of Mining Engineers to enquire into the shutting off of gob-fires in gassy seams. After emphasising the danger of explosion owing to the accumulation of firedamp, the report discusses the limits, between which ignition is likely to occur, and the means by which risk may be minimised. The first precaution is the heavy stone-dusting of the affected area and all roads leading to it. If this is done the danger of a serious explosion is considerably reduced. During the construction of the stoppings attention should be paid to certain points. The site must be chosen and the ventilation so modified that pure air is supplied to the outbye side of the stopping, to prevent the spread of an explosion, the destruction of the stopping and the easy access to same after completion. The stoppings should be so constructed that free air passages are left as long as possible to render harmless any gas in the vicinity. These passages should then be quickly sealed up simultaneously on the intake and return sides of the area. After the lapse of a period from one to twenty-four hours after closure — depending on the conditions — the stoppings should be examined, samples of air taken from behind them, and the work completed in a more permanent manner. The report emphasises the need for the effective construction of stoppings so as to prevent leakage. In such circumstances the area shut off would soon contain a large proportion of firedamp above the higher limit of explosibility, thus reducing risk of explosion and also the rate of oxidation of the heating material. It should also be endeavoured to create a slight positive pressure inside the stoppings to minimise leakage of air into the inside. During all operations the use of rescue apparatus is to be highly recommended. Even in a non-fiery mine there is a danger of explosion due to the accumulation of gas from the distillation of the heating coal. Though water has often been used to combat gob-fires, experience has shown that its use is not to be commended unless it can be directly applied to the seat of the trouble. The indiscriminate use of water may intensify rather than extinguish a gob-fire. The use of extinctive gas free from oxygen has been advocated, but this has been found to be of very little use. Where the heating has been located the use of cement, injected into the mass by means of a cement pump, has been found to be very effective. The local repeated reversal of the air-current has also been suggested, though this has never found favour in practice. The Prevention of Underground Fires. The prevention of underground fires in mines liable to spontaneous combustion involves primarily the system of working. This must at all times be adapted to the existing natural conditions, but the aim should be to prevent the accumulation of oxidisable material in circumstances conducive to heating. An examination of the practical conditions favouring underground fires will suggest remedies. The recommendations embodied in the report of the Departmental Committee are:— 1. All timber should be removed from the goaf and the use of timber in the gate-road packs should be limited to the construction of stacks or chocks. 2. Wherever possible the longwall system of working should be adopted. This will, of course, depend upon the natural conditions with regard to the thickness and inclination of the seam and the nature of the roof. The face should be kept as straight as possible and advanced regularly and quickly. In this connection I would point out the advantages of machine mining. The straight faces and general arrangements necessary for systematic machine mining facilitate a good ventilating current with a minimum of resistance, ventilating pressure and consequent leakage through the gob. The rapid advance of the face involves the continual exposure of fresh surfaces of coal to oxidation and cumulative heating is thus reduced. The systematic withdrawal of the back timber and the packing of the waste is an essential feature of the system. The report recommends the adoption of the retreating longwall method in gassy mines. 3. Gate-road packs should be made as wide as possible in relation to the distance between the gates and the thickness of the seam. The packs should be solidly built and well faced. 4. Gate-roads. The number of gate-roads should be reduced to a minimum while at the same time allowing of the quick, regular and complete settlement of the goaf. 5. Panel System. The division of the workings into panels is to be recommended, whether the pillar and stall or the modified longwall method is adopted. The entrance to each panel should be limited to two roadways which should be provided with emergency stoppings for immediate use in the case of fire. 6. All old roads no longer required should be closed with good solid packs. 7. The air-ways should be of such dimensions and the ventilating system so arranged that the necessary amount of air is circulated with a low ventilating pressure. A large quantity of air with a low water-gauge is the ideal, in order to prevent leakage. 8. No small pillars of coal should be left and all inferior or slack coal should be filled out. Hydraulic Stowing. The hydraulic stowing of the wastes is practised extensively on the Continent though its use in this country is, at present, confined to only a few collieries. This system of packing has many advantages which cannot be discussed here. Where it can be applied it is undoubtedly the best method of preventing gob-fires. With the object of ascertaining its possibilities in this country the Departmental Committee enlisted the services of Mr. Seidl, an expert German mining engineer, to inspect and report on various mines where gob-fires are prevalent. His report states that the system would prevent gob-fires but would not affect fires in shaft and roadside pillars unless complete extraction was adopted. He does not consider that the method could be successfully applied to longwall. In many cases the cost of the necessary plant would make its adoption uneconomical. The method would lead to the extraction of much valuable coal which is at present left in the mines, and its advantages make it worthy of every consideration in the future development of the British coalfields. Organisation. — At all collieries subject to gob-fires there should be a special staff engaged solely in combating gob-fires. According to the evidence of various mine managers and engineers efficient organisation has led to a marked improvement of the conditions in various coalfields. The Departmental Committee report expresses the opinion that more is to be hoped for from efficient organisation than from any other source in the work of preventing underground fires. Such organisation can only be based on the accumulated knowledge and experience of the past. The future of British mining will involve the extraction of seams at a much greater depth than at present and, together with other difficulties, the liability to spontaneous combustion will increase.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||