Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

24th April 1926, Page: 310, Column: 1

Spontaneous Combustion

By Wm. Lomax, B.Sc.

From paper on "A Resume of Spontaneous Combustion" presented at the March meeting of the Past and Present Mining Students' Association in the Wigan Mining and Technical College.

Early Record of Fires.

The subject of spontaneous combustion covers a very wide field, and to treat it in all its aspects would require not one but a series of lectures. In this paper I have attempted to collect and summarise the available up-to-date knowledge of the question in the hope that it will serve as a basis for further investigation. Reference to underground fires is to be found in the earliest records of mining operations. Dud Dudley, in his "Metallum Martis," written in 1665, cites various instances and relates some interesting observations. In the memoirs of David, 2nd Earl of Wemyss, who was an important mining engineer, occurs the following interesting passage, dated 1877 :—

"There is one thing I must acquaint my posterity with, which is, that when my father left working of the main coal in 1616, he left it standing in water drowned at Methil Hill, and, when I began to work it in anno 1666, it did take in fire at the crop so put it out by stopping all passages I had made for drying it, and smothered it out at that time. But in anno 1674 the wastes which I had wrought myself did take fire that I lighted a candle on the whole coal wall upon which I, finding it burning, was sore put to what to do, in end, I caused all the coal bearers take their creels on their backs and I stood beside till I did see them carry out the small coal burning, and in 24 hours' time I got it put out totally, and then I stopped it up from all the air I could, and so it stands to this day, dammed up with clay and redd.

"This being done, I consulted with the colliers the reason of this fire, first in my father's waste and then in my own, and we found it for certain truth that, whenever water shall stand for a long time, if ye dry that place and it were 20 years after this time, it will take in fire. Therefore, no water must stand in any wastes of that coal."

From these early times the annals of mining operations contain numerous records of spontaneous combustion underground together with the results of investigations into its causes and prevention.

Though much interesting knowledge has come to light, there is still a great conflict of opinion as to the factors producing the self-heating of coal, and experiments are still being carried out by many eminent scientists. On the practical side the accumulated experience of past engineers has given us some very definite conclusions on which to base our future efforts in the detection and prevention of underground fires. While it is impossible to reproduce mining conditions in the laboratory it is equally impracticable to completely ascertain the behaviour of coal underground. Therefore, to understand this problem, we must combine the mine with the laboratory and correlate the results of the chemical analysis, treatment and observation of coal with the actual practical observations underground.

The grave importance and danger of underground fires was brought forcibly to the front by the occurrence of the Jamage Pit and Cadeby Main Colliery explosions in 1911 and 1912 respectively. These explosions were the results of the ignition of gas evolved from underground fires and resulted in heavy loss of life. In 1912 a Departmental Committee was formed to enquire into the circumstances in which spontaneous combustion occurs in coal mines, its causes and the means of preventing it or of dealing with it when it has arisen. Two reports were issued, one in 1918, after which the work was interrupted by the War, and the final report in 1921. Many of the deductions and recommendations of the Committee are embodied in the present Coal Mines Regulations relating to seams liable to spontaneous combustion.

Occurrence and Causes.

The occurrence of underground fires due to spontaneous combustion has not been limited to any particular coalfield or to any one class of mine. Though spontaneous heating has been known to occur in thick seams and thin seams, shallow mines and deep mines and in damp mines and dry mines, it has been found that, in each coalfield, there are certain seams which are particularly liable to take fire. The study of these seams is thus of prime importance. Underground fires have been known to take place: (a) In the unworked coal which is left in pillars for the support of the main roads, surface buildings, etc. Owing to the action of crush, cracks or fissures are formed in the pillars, often in a direction parallel to the sides of the pillars, and it is in these cracks that the fires occur. (b) In the gob or waste, in small stumps of coal which have been left, in the material forming the packs or in other accumulations of carbonaceous material, especially when the roof is composed of inferior coal. (c) In the coal alongside faults. Such coal is often of a very friable nature and of inferior quality, and leakage of air is also liable to occur along the fault plane.

There can be no doubt that spontaneous combustion is due to the absorption of oxygen by the coal under such conditions that the heat produced in the consequent oxidation cannot be dissipated. Dr. Haldane expressed the opinion, and Mr. Winmill proved experimentally that, given suitable conditions, any quality of coal or other carbonaceous substance can be made to take fire if supplied with air.

Physical and Chemical Structure.

In attempting to determine the causes of self-heating resulting in underground fires we must consider: (1) Those factors for which there is a purely scientific explanation involving the physical and chemical structure of the coal seams. (2) Those circumstances which have their origin in the natural conditions in which the coal exists or which are produced by the subsequent method of working the coal, or, in other words, we must determine which of the coal constituents are most readily oxidisable together with the practical conditions which render the absorption of oxygen possible.

Causes from a scientific point of view :—

1. The physical and chemical structure. — Until recently the nature of the structure of coal seams and the materials from which they have been formed was but imperfectly understood. Dr. Marie Stopes has distinguished four banded constituents in bituminous coal, namely, fusain, durain, clarain and vitrain. Subsequent experiments have proved that the bright bands vitrain and clarain are more liable to spontaneous combustion than durain. The action of fusain is uncertain. The conclusions of Dr. Wheeler and Dr. Stopes are that it is improbable that fusain plays a very important part in determining the actual ignition after self-heating has begun. It is probable that the rapid absorption of oxygen by fusain at low temperatures will increase the evolution of beat and thus cause the more readily oxidisable vitrain to react more rapidly with the oxygen. Thus the juncture of the fusain and vitrain is important. A striking factor about fusain is its porosity, which is due to the very fine state of division in which it exists. This porosity allows of a ready access of the air to the more oxidisable constituents of the coal and offers a large area for surface oxidation.

On the physical structure of coal the microscopical researches of Mr. J. R. Lomax have been very valuable, He has distinguished small bodies which he terms "globulites" which are extremely liable to weathering. The same material also exists in the form of strings or threads of partly pyritised woody fibre associated with finely divided iron pyrites, and Mr. Lomax suggests that these bodies are the source of the initial heating. This substance is often found present in the dirt bands in the seams liable to spontaneous combustion, and is very readily oxidised. It disintegrates the surrounding coal and dirt to form a coarse powder mixed with fine crystals of ferrous sulphate. This process is accompanied by the evolution of much heat. The texture of the coal is important. A soft, friable coal is more porous and offers a much larger surface for oxidation.

2. Bacterial Action. — It has been suggested that bacterial action plays an important part in the initial stages of the self-heating of coal. The conclusion of the Departmental Committee based on the results of various experiments, was that bacterial action plays no important part in even the initial stages of the self-heating of coal.

3. Effect of the oxygen content. — A chemical analysis of various seams has shown that the liability to spontaneous combustion increases with the percentage of oxygen in the coal. There is still no conclusive explanation of this fact. It is probably due to the higher oxygen constituents being of the cellulosic variety which are more liable to oxidation, though there is still some difference of opinion on that point. Mr. Winmill has also shown that coals of high oxygen content are most porous and are also more friable.

4. The presence of moisture. — It has been proved that the presence of moisture plays an important part in spontaneous combustion. A seam with high moisture content is much more liable to self-heating than a dry seam, though no satisfactory explanation has been advanced why it should be so. Wet seams are probably more porous than dry ones.

5. Effect of pyrites. — It was for a long time considered that iron pyrites was the most important cause of the self-heating of coal. It has been shown that pyrites which, as large crystals, had withstood weathering for some considerable time, was readily oxidised when the crystals were crushed. The conclusion of the Departmental Committee was that some small amount of heat may be developed by the oxidation of an amorphous form of marcasite, but as pyrites is present in such small amounts in coal compared with the coal substance proper, which is a bad conductor of heat, the effect of this heat is negligible. The chief part played by pyrites is as a disintegrating agent breaking up the coal, thus rendering It more porous and exposing a greater surface to oxidation.

6. Absorption of oxygen by the coal substance. — By far the most important source of heat-production in coal seams is the absorption of oxygen by the coal substance itself. Most solid bodies have the property of attracting oxygen from the atmosphere and of surface absorption. This physical or mechanical process may be accompanied by the production of a little heat which will still further increase the surface absorption of oxygen. This oxygen is extremely chemically active and enters into combination with the coal constituents. The action is very rapid at first and then gradually decreases and is accompanied by the production of much heat. Hence, there must be in coal some constituente which are very liable to oxidation. Dr. Haldane, in his evidence before the Departmental Committee, stated that finely divided coal exposed in the mine quickly becomes inert to oxidation, but that the Interior of lump coal is unaffected and, if the coal is crushed after a considerable time, the same process of absorption and chemical combination of oxygen takes place. He also stated that the rate of absorption was directly proportional to the pressure. It was discovered some years ago by Dr. Bedson that pyridine has the property of dissolving a portion of the coal substance. This portion consists of the resinic bodies in the coal leaving behind the cellulosic bodies which have a much higher oxygen content. As the result of many experiments it has been established that the cellulosic compounds, unaffected by pyridine, are the more oxidisable constituents of the coal.

The conclusion of the Departmental Committee, which was practically a quotation from the evidence of Dr. Wheeler, was that "Though coal absorbs oxygen and nitrogen in a physical sense as well as in a chemical sense, the absorption, In so far as heating effects are concerned, is a chemical and not a physical process; that the chemical process is mainly one of attachment of oxygen to molecules of high carbon content, but that, subsidiary to this, and playing an important part In determining the actual spontaneous ignition of coal, is a chemical interaction between the oxygen thus loosely held by the carbon-like molecules and other atoms in these molecules or other portions of the coal conglomerate."

Other natural physical conditions which affect the liability to spontaneous combustion are :—

1. The thickness of the seam. — Other things being equal, the liability to self-heating increases with the thickness of the seam.

2. The depth of the seam. — Generally speaking, the greater the depth, the greater the liability to spontaneous combustion. This is probably due to the heavier roof pressure causing increased crush on the pillars, and also to the natural temperature of the strata at a greater depth.

3. The nature of the roof. — In some coal seams the roof is of a friable nature and may consist of coal or carbonaceous shale. The presence of cracks or fissures which form in the roof allows of the free percolation of air. Moreover, when the roof breaks down in the waste, it becomes crushed under such conditions that it is extremely liable to oxidation. It has been found that some carbonaceous shales associated with coal seams are extremely liable to spontaneous combustion, and in some cases underground fires have been directly traceable to their presence in the mine.

4. The nature of the strata. — Presence of faults, folds, etc., geological disturbances resulting in the formation of faults, folds, etc., alter the nature of the coal in the immediate vicinity and render it friable and of a very porous and inferior nature. Further, the roof in the neighbourhood of a fault is usually of broken nature which allows of the percolation of air.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Bedson, Peter Phillips, Dr.      Whos Who Page
Dudley, Dud      
Haldane, John Scott, Dr.      Whos Who Page
Lomax, J. R.      
Lomax, William      
Stopes, Marie C., Dr.      
Wemyss, Earl of      
Wheeler, Richard Vernon, Dr.      Whos Who Page
Winmill, —      



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
24 Apr 1926  Spontaneous Combustion (The Science and Art of Mining)
05 Jun 1926  Spontaneous Combustion (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print