Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

September 1896

Monthly Circular


No. 9.     September.     1896.

 

To The Members.

Gentlemen,

Since I last wrote, the election of General Treasurer has taken place, and as you are aware, Mr. T. H. Cann, has been selected by the county to fill the post. Permit me to point out two things. First, as to the sending of money. Let the Orders be sent in to Mr. J. Johnson, made payable to Mr. T. H. Cann. If this is done, it will save confusion. The second point, I wish to mention, is to ask you to assist the Treasurer in the paying of the money. The most effective way that I know of, and the only way before my mind is, by all the members complying with rule, and to avoid, if possible, running into arrears. It will help the Treasurer — and from experience I know he will need it. It will save friction between him and those who are out of compliance, and will do much to strengthen the Association. Bear this in mind: if the members neglect rule, the Treasurer is bound to carry it out.

Stoppage of Haswell.

I am sorry to have to record a serious addition to the number of our unemployed. This has arisen through the stoppage of Haswell colliery. The reason assigned is, the bad state of trade and the cost of production. We have had many stoppages (and this year has been the most notable), but none more serious than Haswell. It is not merely the stopping of a colliery, which, in itself, is bad enough; but it is the stagnating of a very large district. There is not a colliery upon which depended a larger business community and private property, it has become an immense trading centre, and around it has been gathered a very great number of houses, not built and owned by speculators, but belonging to purely working men.

Those who have known Haswell for twenty-seven-or-eight years will know how the group of houses, known as Haswell Terrace, were built by workmen in many, if not all cases. Some of them building one or two as their means would allow. These were rented on lease to the Colliery Company. The sole and only reason for their being built was the colliery. There was no other source of demand. That done, there was not any cause for their being built, and there is not now any necessity for them, except some neighbouring colliery, such as Ludworth or Thornley, requires them; in which case, those residing in the houses, would have considerable distance to travel, in one instance at least.

Then turn to Haswell Lane, with its long line of business places of various kinds, all engaged in administering to the necessities of the workmen. There is no village where there is more, and, consequently, no place where the consequences of a stop will be more widely and keenly felt. The miner being stopped, means stagnation to these. His removal takes away the impulse and impetus to their being. The steady trade which he supplied will become intermittent and futile. It would be a cheery thing to all, if there were any hopes of the stop being short. There is no doubt the employers would work the colliery if they could. There is one touch of nature, which stamps us all with a common resemblance. If the workmen desires wages, the employer, no less so, will desire profit, which are his wages. No man need, therefore, think a large concern, like Haswell, will be allowed to stand, if it can be worked. The capital sunk in such a colliery must be tremendous, and will not be abandoned lightly and without an effort.

The position in the county made more serious by the stoppage of the colliery, I am dealing with, affords us some grounds for congratulating ourselves in our organised character, and supplies us with a warning. The cause for rejoicing is the willingness and steady determination to try and meet the wants of those of our members, who find themselves in such straitened circumstances. The warning comes to all, who have not, up to the present, provided themselves with such refuge and help, as we, by our united effort, secure. These men have no just or reasonable grounds for complaint. They knew their duty, but they did it not. They neglected, with full knowledge. They cannot murmur at the punishment. There are a few at other collieries who are indifferent to this provision. They may shortly need help. If they did not need such, yet the distress of others appeals to them. Self-preservation is, no doubt, a strong law, but I am proud to say there is another and a higher motive at work in Durham, and men everywhere, with few exceptions, listen to, and abide loyally by its teachings. We have not been deaf to the call of humanity, as the help we have been able to dispense to thousands of men will testify. These are our witnesses, and great as may be, this later addition to our burden, we shall try to bear it.

It is somewhat surprising to find how many people there are ready with advice under these as all circumstances. We are not above taking advice. That would be foolishness of the grossest kind; but we do claim to arrogate to ourselves some right of selection, and we do not think that any one has a right to say, we are weak, because we do not accept, thankfully and readily, every suggestion offered. This a question deserving of consideration, and we have a right to ask it. How is it that such numbers of people think we should be ready, jump when they, Sir, oracle like, open their mouths, as if from their mouths (as in the fairy story) whenever they spoke dropped their diamonds of wisdom and pearls of sound knowledge ? It is the way of the world, however, that men think they can steer their neighbour's boat better than he can himself.

Let me say, in your name, that well-meant counsel shall not fall upon deaf ears, so far as we are concerned. All that we object to, is advice toned by superiority, and delivered to us in a patronising manner. There is one piece of counsel which it behoves us all (employers and employed alike) to give heed to. We are told to lay aside antagonism, and to cultivate a spirit of mutuality and amicability. These terms are not strange to Durham; neither are the desire for, and endeavour after their spirit a new departure to the parties interested in the trade. It should, however, be borne in mind, that before judgment is pronounced, or condemnation uttered, that that spirit is not limited to large questions, and that it will obtain more freely in them, if it operates in what may be considered small affairs. If we would have conciliation in the questions, which, in their magnitude, strike the public eye, and which in their relation and result affect the public interest, then we must seek to keep all harshness out of matters which are never seen by the outside community. It cannot be gainsaid. It is folly to imagine that it is either wise, or prudent, or safe, to foster (or do anything that will foster) animus, collision, conflict, and antagonism.

Let it be understood, that this lesson only receives suggestion from the present situation. There is no desire to give it a special character. The newspaper that pointed the lesson gave it a wide significance, and here it is used as a "county question," and in that sense it is meant. It does not lose any of its importance in that broad character. In that shape it appeals to all, and enforces this truth. If conciliation be the atmosphere in which trade prospers most — all things being equal — then it behoves us all to practice mutual forbearance in all seasons, and not look upon good or bad times as being advantage grounds used for class-purposes or personal gratification.

The Permanent Relief Fund and the Royalty Owners.

I observe the Committee of our Permanent Relief Fund have been re-opening their Board Room, and that they have taken the opportunity to present a statement, setting forth the position of the fund, and a few of the claims it has on those of the community, outside the miners. The statement is a very important and instructive document, as an account of the relief provided for those whose means of living have been cut off by accident, resulting in injury or death. The progress of the society is a striking instance of what can be done by persistent and patient plodding, and the sums of money collected and expended are indicative of the spirit of self-help, which has wove itself into the minds and life of the Northern miners. The gross sum distributed amongst the widows, orphans, aged miners, and others, amount to £1,291,000.

From this glorious record of poverty lessened, and, consequently, grief assuaged, the Committee turn with justice, with especial emphasis to the Royalty owners of the counties. They point out, that while certain of the employers do still subscribe the usual 20 per cent. on their workmen's contributions ; yet outside this "great number of honourable exceptions," there are some who do not, their subscriptions being withheld owing to the Employers' Liability Act. "None of the Royalty owners subscribe to the Society," say the Committee, and ask pertinently and righteously, — "If these will not contribute directly to the fund, where is the injustice of asking them to do so indirectly through the rates ?"

I opine that you and I are of the same opinion as the Committee. There is no injustice in asking them to support the fund, and there need be no apology for stating that. It is, in my opinion, the very height of selfishness, and puts the climax to the cupidity of the age, for the Royalty owners to receive such a large sum, and recognise no obligation to the miners, nor make no return to them. There can be no more opposite reference made, anent this question, than the following quotation, to which I take the liberty to add a word or two parenthetically:

"The coal-owner invests his capital, and runs his risks of profit (and the miner gives his labour, oft for very low wages, in the midst of great hardship and danger), but the royalty owner has no risks, and is always on the winning side. A contribution to this society, we think, should be a first charge on the wealth arising out of the production of coal in the district, say a reduction from royalty rents."

Let me place, in contrast, the amount of royalties received in the counties covered by the fund, and the amount paid out by it in the shape of benefits to the injured, and the widows and orphans of those who have lost their lives; and the old and worn-out miners, during the 34 years the institution has existed. I have given the gross amount above at a little over one million. What sum have the royalty receivers pocketed in the same time ? I will give you one year, and after making allowance in these later years for the expansion of the mining industry, I would ask you to multiply the sum by the 34 years.

You will be aware that a Royal Commission was appointed to inquire into the question of Royalty rents and Wayleaves. From the report of that Commission, I take the following figures :— The year taken was 1889. The output is not less now than in that year. In Northumberland the output was 8,794,005 tons, Royalty £140,704. In Durham there were 30,307,177 tons, and the Royalty was £597,024. Cumberland and Westmoreland 1,740,737 tons, and the rents £41,705. To these sums we must add the wayleaves, which are — Northumberland £25,000, Durham £97,600, and Cumberland and Westmoreland £2,000. A further addition must be made of the Royalty paid on the iron ore in Cleveland, for the fund includes that district in its membership. Now, Sir I. L. Bell tells us, in his very important book, that the charge upon one ton of pig iron for royalty on coal and ore, is 3/3. Of course, as the coal consumed in the manufacture of a ton of pig iron is included in the produce for Durham, it would be a duplication to say that the royalty on iron ore was 3/3. We must allow for the coal used and the dross abstracted in the making, before we arrive at the correct charge.

A comparison between the disbursements and benefits of the Permanent Relief Fund, and the receipts of the Royalty owner, will not only be instructive, but will prove the justice of the claim made by the former upon the latter. In the 34 years of its existence, the fund has helped distress in the shape of injured and worn-out miners, and widows and orphans, caused by accidents in the mines, whence these Royalties are derived to an amount exceeding one million pounds.

The Royalties and Wayleaves may be ascertained by taking an average sum, making an allowance for the development of trade since 1870, and multiplying it by the 34 years. In 1889 the sum from the counties I have named, leaving out Cleveland, for Royalties and Way-leaves, was in all £904,033. This is exclusive of the rents in Cleveland. If that district be included, and making the allowance I have mentioned above, it will not be an exaggeration to say, there has been received by Royalty and surface owners, at least thirty million during the time the fund has existed.

What advantage has this society, or any kindred society, received from the recipients of that large sum? The Committee say nothing has been paid. Some of the employers have recognised the good objects the fund has in view, and the easement to the rates, which comes to them by its operation; but the Royalty owner is above and outside all obligations. Poor rates are no concern of his, neither is he affected by the mining accidents, with all their sad results, in injured limb, premature old age, or impoverished home. The fund is a standing witness against, and a condemnation of that cupidity and callous indifference. There is a portion of scripture which is put into the mouth of the unjust judge :— "I fear not God, nor regard man," — which fits the Royalty owners. Was the coal placed where it is for their special benefit? Was this peculiar provision of Providence stored up for their partial and sole use ? Should all the citizens not be joint beneficiaries ? If they have no fear on that side, why have they not regard for the men who risk their lives, and out of whose risk comes their income ? Inconvenience, small wage, danger, distress, and death, surrounds the miner. Without him the coal and iron ore would not be got. It is, therefore, a righteous claim, which the Committee of the Permanent Fund makes, when they insist it is the duty of the Royalty owners to give something towards their funds, to enable them to meet their liabilities, and increase, if possible, the benefits they pay. There is nearly a million pounds every year taken from the industry. A small percentage of that would strengthen this most beneficial organisation. It is an unjust; and immoral monopoly of that which should be unmonopolised for that percentage to be longer withheld, and for a full recognition of the claim to be longer disregarded.

J. Wilson.

Durham. — 1896


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Bell, Isaac Lowthian, Sir      Whos Who Page
Cann, Thomas H.    General Treasurer, Durham Miners' Association  Whos Who Page
Johnson, J.    Durham Miners' Association  
Wilson, John    Secretary, Durham Miners' Association  Whos Who Page



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Haswell Colliery  Haswell Colliery
Ludworth Colliery  Ludworth Colliery
Thornley Colliery  Thornley Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
Jan 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Feb 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Mar 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Apr 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
May 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jun 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jul 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Aug 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Sep 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Oct 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Nov 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Dec 1896  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jan 1897  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Feb 1897  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Mar 1897  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Apr 1897  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jan 1914  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Feb 1914  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Aug 1914  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Sep 1914  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Oct 1914  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Nov 1914  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jan 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Feb 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
May 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jun 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jul 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Sep 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Oct 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Nov 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Dec 1915  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jan 1916  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Feb 1916  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Mar 1916  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Apr 1916  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
May 1916  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Dec 1916  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Jan 1917  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)
Feb 1917  Monthly Circular (D.M.A. Monthly Circular)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 23 Feb 2023

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print