Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

26th March 1853, Page: 8, Column: 3

Willington Railway Accident

The Adjourned Inquest

On Wednesday, this inquiry was resumed, when the following witnesses were examined :—

John Laverick stated that he was fireman of No. 104 engine, on the day of the accident. He had printed rules for his government. The train left Tynemouth at four o'clock on the day in question. After leaving Howdon station, the driver eased the steam when they came on to the Willington Bridge. The engine No. 104 had ... the Tynemouth line before, but it was generally used ... on the Berwick line. The speed on the Berwick line might ... at thirty miles an hour: but they did not run at half that speed on the Tynemouth line. The engine has outside cylinders, but it used to run very steadily. He never knew it oscillate, and he had been on it several years. It got off the Berwick line some five years ago. The engine has a plough at the fore part of it, which was about two inches from the rail. On approaching Willington Bridge he saw the man with the flag at the west end of it. The man showed a white flag, and he held it out at arm's length. He did not notice any obstruction on the line as they approached the bridge ; but he saw a great number of workmen about. He could not say which line the men were employed on; and he did not notice any timber lying about. Before leaving Tynemouth station the deceased had no drink ; they had not time to get it. The deceased was quite sober, and he knew him to be a steady, sober man. He had been with him for seven years. On coming off the bridge the deceased made no observations. He did not find any jerk, or that anything was wrong, until the engine left the rail. He was thrown under the tender, and had five or six ribs broken.

By Mr. Haggie — The engine was never called "the jumper." The steam was not set on before they came to the place where the engine got off the line, and at that time he was standing on the tender, and the driver had hold of the regulator of the engine. The engine went off first.

By Mr. Reay, the foreman — The engine had only been down once that day. The engine had been down two or three times in four or five years. They were going about 15 or 16 miles an hour.

By a Juror — They left Tynemouth precisely at four o'clock, but he could not say what time they reached Howdon station. It might be about a quarter past four o'clock.

By a Coroner — He could not give any reason why the engine got off the rail.

By Mr. Dodds — He was standing with his face towards the engine ; and, if anything had got on the rails, especially a hard substance, like a piece of iron, he would have felt it, and in all probability it would have broken some of the springs of the engine. He was not firing the engine at the time it got off; he put some on at Howdon station. Supposing that a joint of the rail had been pushed aside, and presented a point, it would not act as an impediment, as the flange of the wheel would not cause a jerk.

By the Coroner — If a rail adjoining was depressed and the other standing up presenting a point, the engine would have gone over without being thrown off.

William Hudspeth said that he was a plate-layer on the Tynemouth Railway. He recollected the engine, No. 104, running off the line. He was working at the east end of the bridge, raising some of the rails where new ballast had been laid. He could not say that the road-way was much out of order, the inspector, as well as himself, had been over the line that morning. It was his duty, according to the rules, to look over the line twice a day. There was a quantity of timber lying at the west end of the bridge, but it was clear of the line. There were also rails lying, but they were compactly put together on both sides of the line. None of the workmen's tools were lying on the road-way. On the day of the accident the men were repairing the north line of the railway, and they had to take up a great deal of ballast from it. The ballast was laid at different places, but a good deal was laid on the middle of the south line. There was not more than two or three inches of ballast lying between the rails. There had been no new rails put in near the cabin. The rails, 50 lbs weight, were laid on the longitudinal sleepers, and they had flanges at each side for screw bolts. There were none of the bolts out. Where the old bolts would not hold, they drilled fresh holes in the flange and put another bolt in, as they would hold better in fresh timber. In the 65 lb rails there were keys or wedges driven into the chairs, between the rails, to secure them. The keys were all on the outside of the rail on the bridge, except one key which was driven inside of the rail near the middle of the bridge. The keys were about three inches below the rail. If a key, inside of the rail, was nearly level with the surface of the rail, it would be hazardous, but they were cautious as to that not occurring. There was no ballast next the rail that could do any injury. Where the engine ran off there were two rails broken, and it might be about 16 yards from the cabin. The rails were broken in the middle on the longitudinal sleepers, but they were fast at the joints. There were no marks of the wheels upon the side of the rails before the engine got off; neither were there any marks on the ballast until it was completely off. They had a bogie on the line in the forepart of the day, and it had left some marks upon the longitudinal timbers, where the engine got off. The rails were replaced in about on hour after they had been torn off; and the broken rails removed. The timber was little the worse. The railway was in a better state now than when the accident occurred. He could form no opinion as to what occasioned the engine to go off.

By Mr. Turner — There were no new rails near the cabin ; and they had been there fourteen years. There was a crossing made about two months ago, when they started to repair the bridge. He was there when the crossing was put in, and there were 65 lb rails laid there. He did not observe any of the 65 lb rails loose on the day of the accident. There was a chair close to the end of the 65 lb rail, where it joined the lug or flat rail, and there was a sleeper point under that chair which extended to the longitudinal sleepers underneath. They had chairs to fit the 65 lb rails and the lug rails, but the reason they had not put a chair was, that it was not the strongest mode, as they had to cut the flange of the lug rail to make it fit, and consequently it weakened the lug rail. All the chairs on which the 65 lb rails were placed were double pinned. There were some timbers on the middle bridge partly shaken, but it was only the sap of it, the frost having affected it. The engines were not running on the south side of the bridge at present. The longitudinal sleepers were taken up because they were putting them down more substantially. It was to add to the strength of the bridge. The rails were of different lengths, and varied from twelve to fifteen feet; and there would be about nine pins in each rail. They used dogs in the flat rails sometimes.

By Mr. Haggie — The part where the accident took place was under his inspection. The sleepers on the bridge were rather damaged by the frost. The rails were about two inches from the side of the sleepers. He had tried every one of the outside bolts, and there were very few that had not a sufficient hold ; but the bolts at the other side of the rail had a good hold, because they were more in the heart of the timber. Mr. Armstrong, the inspector of the permanent lines often came down. He made no complaint to Mr. Armstrong or anybody else about the bridge. It was the little bogie that made the mark on the ballast. The flange of it was very deep.

By the Foreman — His boundary of inspection was from the mile post west of the cabin to Percy Main. The heavy and lug rails were stronger without chairs. There were double chairs on the line, and they had been in use for six or seven years.

The Jury, at the termination of this witness, adjourned the inquiry for half an hour for refreshment; after which

John Oliver Scott was examined. He stated that he was on the railroad in half an hour after the accident. He particularly noticed the end of the rail which was loose, at the west end of the bridge, and east of the cabin. The rail was on the south line. He put his foot against the rail, and both it and the chair moved. The chair and rail were upon the longitudinal sleepers. He observed no pins outside of the rails ; but he noticed that the pins in the chair were loose. It appeared to him that the chair and rail had been loose for some time, as they moved by the ordinary pressure of his foot, full three-quarters of an inch. He also noticed a rail next to that he had alluded to, to be a different kind of rail, and what was called a lug rail. It was much older than the one that was loose. He could not move it, and it seemed secure. The loose rail was much heavier than the tight one. On leaving the place he thought, from the appearance of the joint, that the accident happened there. There was nothing to indicate that the engine had gone off at that place, but he thought the van had been thrown off there. There was a great quantity of timber, apparently the old sleepers, lying at the south side of the rail, which the van might have come in contact with when thrown off the line, thereby throwing some of the timbers amongst the wheels or the engine or tender. A little further west he noticed a quantity of ballast lying between the rails. The ballast seemed about 9 inches in height in the centre of the line, and above the level of the rail, and sloping down towards the rails. The ballast next to the rails appeared to be beat down by the flange of the wheels to a hard substance, and was on a level with the rails, except where the flange had made an indentation. The air was frosty, and there had some snow fallen, but he could not say whether that would have any effect on the rails. He did not notice any of the rails torn up.

By the Foreman — The end of the heavy chair and rail were loose a short distance from the cabin. He did not see that the end of the lug rail was embedded in the longitudinal sleepers.

By the Coroner — Where the heavy end of the rails joined together he did not observe any marks of the engine going off. It occurred to him, from the marks he saw, that the engine, or some of the carriages, had been off the rail for some distance.

George Beck stated that he was a colliery engineer, and had the charge of all the machinery and railways belonging Willington Colliery. He remembered the day of the accident, and was at the place about ten minutes after it happened. He saw the train going along the line, and, according to his judgment, it was proceeding rather quickly. When he first saw the train it was at the east end of the bridge, and on turning about he heard something like "hush," as if steam was escaping. He saw the steam rising at the other side of the embankment, and part of the train running without the engine. He ran to the spot, and observed that the passengers had left the carriages and were running towards where the engine was lying. The first thing he saw after that was the fireman carried along the line. He next went to the place where he thought the engine had got off the line, and it appeared to him that it had got off within a few feet of where there was a crossing plate or rail. He examined the chairs at that place, and found several had only one pin in instead of two ; and the double stands with four holes had only two instead of four pins, and they were rather small for the holes, and did not fill the metal. There was another chair opposite the crossing a little further on, the wood of which was decayed, and water was rising out of the pin-hole. He put his foot upon it, when it worked up and down a quarter of an inch. A little further on the line was all broken up with the engine going across the rails.

By the Coroner — The carriages, after being freed from the engine, were forced forward on the line about 200 yards from where it was broken up. The wheels of the first carriage next to the van were off the rails, and had run along the side of them. That would act as a drag upon the train. Without the train had attained a considerable velocity, the carriages would not have gone so far along the line.

By the Foreman — Then were no marks at the chair found loose and where the rail was working into the timber to show that the engine had got off the line there, He was quite certain that the train was going more than fifteen miles an hour to cause the carriages to run along so far after the engine went over the embankment. He calculated the engine was going about 28 miles an hour. He saw the broken rails, but did not examine them. He saw the trains pass daily.

By Mr. Haggie — He thought if the rails now used on the line were properly fastened on the timber, they were equal to carry a heavy engine at thirty miles an hour. They were strong enough to carry an engine 22 tons weight.

By Mr. Turner — He did not consider that the loose rail was safe for the trains to pass over. He walked along the line about an hour after the accident, and observed several pins out on the bridge.

By the Foreman — The long rail and the heavy one in joining would have been made much stronger if placed on a chair. A double chair was much safer than that which fixed the rails in question.

By Mr. Hann — From the loose state in which the pins were, it was not safe to run a train at the speed the train was going at.

By Mr. Dodds — The pins were out on the line on which the accident happened. He thought the bogie could not make the impression on the ballast without being heavily loaded. The mark was before they came to the loose rail at the crossing.

Mr. T. E. Harrison stated that he was manager of the York, Newcastle and Berwick Railway, and that the Tynemouth branch formed a portion of it. It came under his direction in 1845, at which time it was a line new to him, but he considered it in a good working state. The line was first made in 1839. The line was made on longitudinal timbers, and he paid a great deal of attention to repairs and put it as the other systems in use. He found that there were two sections of the line — one through the Heaton cutting about 200 yards in length, and another near to North Shields, about the same length, which had for a period of four years being worked without any cross ties at all. A considerable number were put in, but that fact especially called his attention to the subject. He never discontinued entirely the use of the ties, but, from experience, he had no hesitation in stating that when a line was laid on longitudinal timbers, the line being straight, the embankments being consolidated, and the ballast sound, he might remark, that a great part of the North Shields line was perfectly safe without ties. He referred to that particularly as a contrary impression prevailed, and he would ask them to compare it with a line composed of stone blocks. They had lines laid on stone blocks, where the speed was constantly from between fifty to sixty miles an hour. He took portions of the London and North Western, the Grand Junction, the Lancaster and Carlisle, and many others. In a stone block road no ties were used ; and the only danger which could arise would be from the line getting out of gauge gradually, or by any sudden action. Experience proved that the tendency to get out of gauge was not one-tenth part as great on longitudinal lines as on a block line. A very ordinary attention of the workmen would keep it in order. With regard to any sudden action to throw it out of gauge, he tried to place as many men as he could get together, without being able to spring the timbers more than the eighth of an inch, and they would see that that must be the case, from every timber being scraped under the adjoining one, when the whole formed one continuous piece of timber. He believed that no safer line could be made than one on longitudinal timbers. With regard to the Willington viaduct, as also the Ouseburn viaduct, these were both examined regularly twice every year. The soundness of the timber was tested by holes being bored into various places. All the ironwork was also examined, and the screws tightened up — and he knew of no case in which any timbers showed the same perfect soundness throughout as they did. Not having been the engineer to the structure, he thought it only due to the person who was so to make that statement. He examined, in October last, several portions of the line, and particularly the road-way over the Willington viaduct. He reported to the directors that he thought the construction of it might be much improved, and he received their instructions at once to carry out the plan since adopted. The north line was hardly finished when the weather prevented them going on, or both would have been done some time since. One of the objects of the plan carried out, was to remedy the fact of the rail being placed out of the centre of the timber, which was referred to by Capt. Wynne in his evidence, and which he (the witness) pointed out to him. Since the period of his taking possession of the Tynemouth line they had carried upwards of ten millions of passengers without any fatal accident to anyone, except from acts of their own ; (he referred to the case of a drunken person jumping out of the train while in motion, with no accident of any consequence to any individual passenger.) Although they carried four millions of passengers per year over the whole of their lines, they had not had one fatal case of accident connected with passengers since he took the management of it. A question was asked, as to the cause of an accident to an engine beyond the Howdon station, and he found that it occurred by a side crank, of the engine breaking, the side rod failing down, and the end of it sticking into the timber threw the engine off. He examined the crank after the accident, and he found a slight defect in the iron, which could not be previously detected. On the 2nd of March, as soon as he heard of the accident at Willington, he took an engine from the station and got to the place about 5 or 10 minutes after 5 o'clock. There were several gentlemen there, among whom was Mr. Weatherhead, of Berwick, who had been there some time before him. He (the witness) went with Mr. W. and examined several points, which that gentleman called attention to, as those which he considered caused the accident. He (witness) had a plan prepared, which showed the position of the line at the place of the accident, and the marks which were made by the engine and tender. [Mr. H. then put the plan in for the inspection of the jury, and entered into a long explanation of it, with the view of showing the probability as to how the accident occurred.] Mr. Harrison afterwards said that the fact of there being holes in the longitudinal rails, without pins in them, was no evidence of the deficiency of the pins, because the practice was to make fresh holes. A question was asked as to whether a pin might be drawn out by the finger ? that might be the case, but there were fresh ones put in by the side of them, or upon the rail. Capt. Wynne had tested where it was alleged that there were only two pins where there ought to have been four, by getting men with pinchers, and they were unable to move the rail. He could give no opinion as to the cause of the accident.

By the Coroner — He gave orders for the cross ties to be put in, in October last.

By Mr. Haggie> — When he took possession of the line a time was mentioned to re-lay the whole of the line. He made a report, but he could not state the time fixed to do so, but he might add that the longitudinal timbers generally were sound, and showed no symptoms of decay. The rails had proved themselves to be of excellent quality, and might last for many years yet with perfect safety. He should prefer those rails at 50 lb to the yard to any rails which they had got for the last few years, although of considerably greater weight.

The Coroner here intimated that it was getting late, and as other witnesses had to be examined, he must adjourn the inquest once more.

After a brief consultation with the jury, the inquest Was adjourned until Thursday next.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Armstrong, —    Railway Inspector  
Beck, George    Colliery Engineer  
Dodds, —      
Dodds, —      
Haggie, R. H.      
Hann, —      
Harrison, Thomas Elliott    Manager  Whos Who Page
Hudspeth, William    Plate Layer  
Laverick, John    Fireman  
Reay, —    Jury Foreman  
Scott, John Oliver      
Stephenson, William    Engine Driver  Deceased 
Turner, —      
Weatherhead, —    Coroner  
Wynne, —, Captain    Railway Inspector  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Willington Colliery (NBL)  Willington Colliery (NBL)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print