Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mine & Quarry Engineering - Main Index
Mine & Quarry Engineering - Subject Index
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Title Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Title
 
 Mine & Quarry Engineering April, 1955 

Advantages

The principal advantage of roof bolting is that a tunnel in bad rock can be driven full face, simply and quickly, without using supports that obstruct the workings. Full advantage can thus be taken of modern methods of mechanisation.

Another important advantage is that no wood is used as constructional material. Considered from this standpoint, not even the steel-arch method is as attractive as it seems at first sight, for the workers usually blast out considerable overbreak in order to avoid secondary blasting when setting the arches. The space between steel and rock is then filled with wood lagging and packing, unless steel lagging is used with gravel blown in behind, this latter being of course an irreproachable method but an expensive one and not often practised. If wooden lagging and packing are used, the timber will be locked up behind the concreted arch and form a separating layer of a rather undesirable material between the rock and the concrete. Wood is bound to decay unless the tunnel is constantly under water, and will cause voids, irregular settling and eventually damage to the concrete lining.

There is no need to compare roof bolting with wooden multiple-piece sets as formerly used in the United States, because the use of wood instead of steel has hardly proved to be cheaper and is technically much inferior. The wooden frame has to be placed on the outside of the theoretical concrete line and this means a big overbreak volume to be filled up with concrete later.

Properly executed roof bolting will inhibit loosening better than any other method, as movements are either completely impeded or stopped immediately they commence. All temporary methods depending on support from below are bound to give way in course of time, and are naturally followed by a deepening of the loosening process. On the contrary, yielding with roof bolting amounts only to a fraction of the deformation the roof suffers with support from below.

A further advantage is that roof bolting is not damaged by fly rock from blasting, whereas other kinds of supporting structures will compel the workers to blast more carefully, which in turn results in a lower daily drivage rate. Finally, roof bolting causes less overbreak as no space need be left for any frames and lagging.

Economy

The economy of the method is best shown by an example: For the New York water tunnel steel lining was first used and then roof bolting under the same geological conditions (see Figs. 12 and 17).6 A direct comparison for this section indicates a saving per running metre of tunnel of 445 kg. of steel, 0.10 cu. m. of wood, 1.50 cu. m. of excavation and concrete, and about 29 working hours. Further savings in costs of administration and equipment are accomplished, shortening the time element. If concrete anchors are used for tunnelling through squeezing rock instead of steel ribs placed close to each other the savings will be still greater.

Geological limits of employment

To illustrate the field in which roof bolting can be successfully used we may refer above to Table I.9

Concrete anchoring can advantageously be employed even if forepoling is necessary for certain cases of the groups 7 to 9; the anchors, placed as an additional measure to the ordinary support, will be mainly responsible for stopping the squeezing. Consequently the ribs may be lighter and set at greater distances without danger of being destroyed. Obviously the rock used for anchoring must be of a type in which a hole can be drilled.

Durability

The durability of roof bolting is limited by the corrosion of the steel. As all steel is bound to corrode rapidly in tunnels it is clear that bolting can only be considered as a temporary construction as long as no additional measures change these conditions. Further, it is also possible that the resistance of the rock will change by chemical or mechanical influences, causing the anchoring to give way, especially when bolting in bad rock.

By grouting the anchors and guniting the surface, the durability of bolting can be very much improved. Further consolidation can be obtained by grouting the surrounding rock. There are different means to grout the bolted construction, as shown in Fig. 18. Either a separate grouting hole has to be drilled for each bolt and a small pipe fixed to the bar to allow the air to escape, or the entrance of the hole is drilled larger in order to allow the grouting pipe to be placed close to the bolt. For instance, the roof of the machine hall of Harspranget in Sweden (span 18 in.) has been consolidated in this way with 5 m. long bolts, grouted in and the surface netted and gunited.

Valuable research work has been made in Sweden also for the purpose of grouted anchors.13 It has been found that the normal grouting method, as described above — especially when used for upward anchors — does not fill the hole entirely, but sometimes leaves uncontrollable voids, which evidently cause a decrease of durability and strength. The degree of filling can be judged from the picture Fig. 21 showing several cores of grouted anchors. For this purpose upright steel pipes have been injected with different mixtures of grout in exactly the same way as holes are treated. After curing and hardening, the pipes have been cut off revealing their cores.14

Two methods in particular should be mentioned here which have been developed very recently for concrete anchoring; both of these avoid these disadvantages and are, moreover, appreciably simpler and faster.

The first method uses pipes of Plexiglass, closed at one end. The pipes are filled with mortar and placed in the hole followed by the bolt, the latter being pushed in by hand and eventually helped by the use of a jackhammer. The space in the hole between hole and rock is in this way satisfactorily filled with mortar and broken pieces of Plexiglass.

The other method, called the Perfo, which enjoys increasing popularity, uses perforated steel pipes cut in two longitudinally and filled with plastic mortar. Both parts are then put together, fastened with wire and inserted in the hole. The somewhat smaller bolt is then driven in pneumatically (see Figs. 22 and 23). Practically a complete filling of the hole and excellent strength is obtained in this way. By mixing with the mortar chemical ingredients, to speed up its hardening, such a bolt can take load very shortly after placing.

When deciding to grout the bolts it must be borne in mind that the necessary preparations will have to be done at the same time as the holes are drilled. This additional work may probably delay the progress somewhat.

As yet sufficient' experience has not been gained regarding the life of grouted-bolt supports, but it can be assumed that subsequent elongation of the bars may cause fine cracks in the grout and allow the steel to be attacked by water. Any circulation of water in the bolted region should consequently be prevented by grouting the surrounding rock.

A durable support may be obtained in this way in chemically sound rock, and it may be mentioned that Perfo bolts are accepted as permanent support in the Asswan tunnels; but in decomposed rock, bolting and anchoring must always be considered as a merely temporary construction, and it is doubtless necessary to provide a concrete lining, particularly when dealing with tunnels in the civil-engineering field which are required to last a long time with the least possible maintenance.

In considering the various features of bolting and anchoring it seems that, besides its other advantages, this technique allows a degree of exactness in dealing with the problem of supporting unstable rock that has been unknown hitherto. A very interesting and rewarding field of research work is open for this young and promising technique.

References

1. Beyl, Z. S. "Rock Pressure and Roof Support," Colliery Engineering, September 1945 to October 1946.
2. Boman, I. E. "Tillampningar i U.S.A. av Bergfastning 'med bult '." Tryckluft, No. 3, 1952.
3. Editorial article "Diversion Tunnel Driving Without Liners — Keyhole Dam Wyo." Engineering News Record, May 17, 1951.
4. Grundy, C. F. "Notable Water Tunnel." Water Power, January 1953.
5. Perez, Henry T. "Tunnelling Costs Drop down when Bolts hold up Tunnel Roof." Construction Methods and Equipment, March, 1952.
6. Pierce, J. C. "Pinning up an Aqueduct Roof." Compressed Air Magazine, May 1953.
7. Rabcewicz, L.v. "The Forcacava Hydro-Electric Scheme." Water Power, September, October, November 1953.
8. Stager, Ted. "Underground Mushroom Farm." Compressed Air Magazine, May 1951.
9. Terzaghi, K.v. "Geological Introduction to Tunnelling with Steel Supports," by Proctor & White, The Commercial Shearing Stamping Company, Youngstown, Ohio. 1946.
10. Huber, W. G. "Complex Excavation Pattern cuts out Underground Power House." Civil Engineering, June 1953.
11. Mildendorf H. and Janssen K. "Erfahrungen mit dem Ankerausbau." Gluckauf H. 33/34 1953.
12. Langecker F. "Versuche zur Verankerung der Gebirgsschichten im Liegenden" Gluckauf H. 45/46 1952.
13. Bengt Erdheim och Sten C.A. Bergman "Dragforsok med Bergbultar" Rapport av Kungl. Fortifikationsforvaltningen Befastningsbyran Forsknings- och Forsokssektionen.
14. Tests made by Kungl. Jarnvagsstyrelsen bantekniska byran (Dir. B. Fellenius.)
Note — Figs. 12 and 13 are reproduced from Compressed Air Magazine.

Drawings and Photographs accompanying the article

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

Article reproduced from a copy of the magazine held at National Mining Museum Scotland, Newtongrange, Midlothian.

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 17 Jan 2023

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print