1882 Tudhoe Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
Tudhoe Colliery Inquest, Tuesday, May 23rd, 1882 (Cont.).
THOMAS THOMPSON said :—
I am back overman in the West pit. I have been for 12 years employed at the colliery, and I have been 7½ years back overman in the West Pit. I went down at 10 o'clock in the morning of the 17th and came to bank at half past five o'clock in the evening. I had charge of the whole of the West district. The ventilation was good. I went through the different districts of the pit almost every day. I took some of the districts one day and some the other day. The last time I found gas in the West Pit was nearly five or six months ago. I found it on the edge of the goaf in No. 6 way. It was on the straight-in goaf. When I came to bank I thought that the pit was in good working order. I travelled the whole of No. 6 district when I was down. I travelled along the railway, where I found everything all right. The previous day (Sunday) I was in No. 6 district, and I also found it all right. I was also in No. 4 district on Sunday, and found it all right. I was in No. 5 a few days before and found it all right. When I came to bank on the 17th I had not the slightest idea that there was any danger. I first heard of the accident about 1.20 a.m. I have been in the pit since the explosion. I was in No. 6 way when there were some heavy falls. We stopped where the waggons had been caught by the fall. Several men were also found there, James Cairnes, the waggon-way man, and the boy. He was found alongside a tub. He was a little burnt, but very little. I did not see John Burns or Hugh Armstrong. I found Edward Jones Roberts. He was in between the tubs under this big fall. I did not find John Lambton. Cairnes and Roberts were the only two I found. I did not notice whether Roberts was burnt or not. He was found amongst the tubs. There were other falls out-bye of this place. I found Michael Rivers, the younger, and John Cherry. I found Rivers in the old No. 5, on the top of the Alma Bank. I found that they had gone from the new landing that we are making at present. This was at the west side of the return. I found a lamp with him. There was another lamp found at the out-bye end of the landing. This man had died from after-damp, not burns.
(Mr. Bowey.) I think you said you were the last to leave No. 4, Alma Bank, on Sunday? — Yes.
You found no gas there? — No.
Were you right along to the extreme end of the goaf? — Yes.
The extreme end? — Yes.
Have you occasionally found gas coming off that goaf? — Sometimes we have seen a little on the edge of the goaf.
How often? — Not over twice.
Over what period of time? — It will be five or six months since the last was seen.
And before that? — Before that the way was not on, and had not been on for a considerable time.
Do you mean to say you have only seen it once during the last five or six months? — Yes.
This part of the pit you considered perfectly safe on Sunday? — Just so, sir.
(Mr. Edge.) You saw where this pointed to ; you said the door? — Yes.
Was this a single door? — No, it is a double door.
(Mr. Bowey.) It is marked single on the plan. Is it a canvas door?
(Witness.) No, it is not a canvas door.
Do you consider this door is quite ample and sufficient there? — Yes, sir, there.
If anything should happen to injure this door how long will it take to fix in another? — Not very long, a quarter of an hour.
That is to say if you were on the spot? — Yes.
And that would be if you had another door ready to put in? — We could canvas it up in the meantime.
You say there was a caution board or a lamp on the Alma Bank? — Yes.
What kind of lamp is it? — It is a lamp with red glass in it.
An oil lamp? — Yes.
This is not what you call a naked light? — No, it is not naked ; it is in a lantern.
But the air is exposed to it? — Yes.
Do you consider that this Alma Bank was perfectly safe on the Sunday? — Yes, perfectly so.
And you think that this door was quite sufficient for the ventilation of this goaf? — Yes, sir.
Do you consider this goaf at all dangerous? — Not at all.
Do you think it would be safer to have two doors? — Yes, it would certainly be safer.
But you do not think it necessary? — No, one is a regulator and the other is a manhole door.
One is to regulate the wind—how far are they apart? — About 20 yards.
(Mr. Bell.) Was the manhole door open? — No, sir.
(Mr. Bell.) Then what was the use of the regulator if the manhole door was shut? — It was where the wind returned, it would come down the hitch on the Alma side, and the regulator was on the top of the hitch.
Was the manhole a closed door? — A closed door, and closely built up.
Close stopping, then? — Yes.
How would the air get from the regulator? Can you point out the position of the doors on the plan? — (Witness pointed out the position of the doors on the plan.) There was a temporary door on the return.
Then you had a straight run up to this goaf from one door? — Yes.
And then the south side? — There was a straight run up there also.
How can the two doors be closed? — The air worked round.
(Mr. Bell.) It could not if the door was shut. How does the air get through the door?
(Mr. Edge.) Was there no scale on the door in the intake? — Yes, there was.
How many bricks were out? — Three or four.
Then this is how the air got out? — Yes.
(Mr. Bell.) Then the three or four bricks out there would ventilate this goaf right and left? — Yes.
(Mr. Bowey.) Let me understand. You say there were three or four bricks out of the doorway in the intake and by that means the air got in? — Yes.
And then there is another door in the return? — Yes, the regulator door.
Is this the one you call the manhole? — Yes, it is.
The other was shut? — Yes.
Then how did the wind get there? — It was not closely shut, there was a scale on the door.
How large? — Well, perhaps six or eight inches.
(Mr. Morley.) And in each passage there was a single door? — Yes.
There was a door in the Alma way? No. 4 leading into the return? — Yes.
What sort of door? — It is a lock door, a single door.
(Mr. Morley.) You speak of a door between the intake and the return? — Yes.
From the intake at the south side of the waggon way, and out-bye from the caution board? — Yes.
From the two crossings out-bye from the caution board? — Yes, but they are not now in use.
Where was this door you are now speaking about by these crossings? — In the in-bye side of both of them.
(Mr. Bowey.) There is only one marked on the plan.
(Mr. Bell.) There is not a holing for the door.
(Mr. Morley.) Travelling out along the intake way out-bye, how far have you to go before you come to where the door was locked? — About 60 yards on the out-bye side of the caution board.
Would this not be just where the crossing is? — Somewhere there.
(Mr. Bell.) Was this crossing down, or just standing? — Standing, but not in use.
Does the door open into the crossing to go into the ways? — Yes.
(Mr. Morley.) And is this the crossing you came to on coming out-bye from the caution board? — Yes.
What sort of door is this? — It is a single door, and locked.
(Mr. Morley.) Supposing anything was to happen to the waggon-way door you speak of by the caution board, or to the door into the return crossing, would not the air get into the return, and there would not be much passing into the further end of the Alma way into the goaf edge, or into old No. 5. The air would be carried off? — Yes.
And it would allow of an accumulation of gas? — It might.
If there was an accumulation of gas, there would be nothing to prevent it? — No.
You speak of a lamp being found opposite Cherry and Rivers. Was it a safety lamp? — Yes.
And the other lamp? — It was a "Clanny" lamp.
Where was it found? — On the landing.
Where had they been working? — On the in-bye side of the landing.
How is it they got from there to where they were found? — They might back their way in.
You mean right away round the whole distance of the intake? — No, sir, they were not far into the return.
Do you imagine that they had gone to the end of the intake, and then round by the return? — No.
Was there not a stopping? — There was not a stopping in there. It was the main intake.
You found the bodies on the west side of the return? — Yes.
I want to know how they got to this point across the return from the intake? — They did not get to the return.
They had to cross the return? — No, sir, they did not cross the return.
They must have. Were they found 22 yards from the main intake, and between the main intake and the return? — Yes.
(Mr. Bowey.) Then he is wrong, or the plan is wrong.
(Mr. Morley.) Where was it that you found the bodies? — At the in-bye end of the landing, and it was just 22 yards above this that the bodies were found.
(Mr. Edge.) Now look here (referring to the plan). Here is the caution board. Come here and show us where the bodies were, and how they got there. Do you understand the plan? — No, sir.
Then I will point out the place. Can you tell us whether the men were found to the south of the return or west of the return, or between the return and the intake? — They were found between the return and the intake.
Was there a stopping there? — No, there was no stopping.
What was there? Do you know? Was there a return in the west side of old No. 5 rolley way? — Yes.
How far was it from the rolley way? — You had better not look at the plan for it only confuses you.
(Mr. Bell.) Can you tell us if there was a head-way driven to the west side of the main rolley-way going north? — Yes.
Then when you turn to the left-hand where the men were found did you cross the headway? — No, sir.
Then how could it be 22 yards? — Before you got to the men you must cross the back headway according to the plan.
(Mr. Bowey.) Did you find Rivers and Cherry? — Yes.
With Mr. Johnson? — Yes.
(Mr. Bowey.) We had better have Mr. Johnson here to say whether the plan is correct or not.
(Mr. Edge to Mr. Johnson.) You were with Thompson when the younger Rivers was found. Where was he found? — 22 yards from the rolley way to the west.
Is it where they are marked on the plan? — Yes.
Can you tell us how they got to this place? — Well, this was an old rolley way which had not been used for some years. They would walk right through. They were working at the end of the landing.
This door Thompson refers to is only a regulating door made of deals about 1¼ inches thick, frames 4½ by 3 feet, and 14 inch brickwork? — Yes.
(Mr. Bell.) It is a single door. It is what you call a Welsh double door.
(Mr. Willis.) As a matter of fact, did the ventilation work? — Yes, it was quite free from after-damp, and there was no gas to be seen.
(Mr. Bell.) Was this crossing in old No. 5 in use? — No, it was not in use.
Then the regulator would catch it? — I suppose we may take it that the plan is not strictly correct.
(Mr. Edge.) I am afraid it is not strictly correct.
(Mr. Bell to Mr. Thompson.) How long before the accident were you along the north end of the goaf? — I cannot tell exactly, but a few days before the accident.
Did you ever find any gas in this north goaf edge? — Never in that district.
Did you travel the workings, or rather the ways about the regulator in the west goaf? — Yes.
When were you round there last? — It would be a week or two.
Whose duty is it to travel the ways? — The master wasteman.
Have you ever found gas in the high end? — No, never.
Have you a travelling road right round in the west to the east? — Yes.
And have you ever found gas in there? — Never.
(Mr. Morley.) How did you get to the goaf edge at the top of the Alma Bank? — I went straight away to it along the intake.
(Mr. Bell.) There was a door on the main waggon-way. Was it locked? — It was not locked.
(Mr. Morley.) The door where the bricks were out is not a locked door? — No, sir.
(Mr. Bell.) Then how was it fastened? — Oh, it is just closed.
Then there is not a sneck or a catch to it? — No.
It is simply put to? — Yes.
Which way does it open? — Out-bye over against the current.
Would it not be possible for a fall to come from the edge of the goaf and throw this door back? — It might.
Have you ever known a door being thrown open by a fall? — Yes.
By drawing a jud? — No, sir, I cannot say I have.
What would be the effect upon the ventilation if the door was left open? — They would get more air in No. 4 district.
Where would the air be taken from? — There is a regulator on the return.
If in case that door should be left open it would not take much air from the other places.
Then the main door would be no use? — It is only a temporary regulator, sir.
There is another door. Could not the air get through that? — Yes.
Then the air might get into the return? — It might do so.
Do not you think a district rising as this is rising would be likely to take the whole of the air if this door was left open? — Well, sir, it would not take it all ; it could not.
There was a lantern at the caution board. Whose duty was it to look after it? — The deputy.
What had he to do with it at night? — He puts it out.
And leaves it hanging there? — Sometimes it is left hanging, and sometimes he take it and puts it in his chest.
Was it his duty to oil this lamp? — Yes.
Have you seen it? Has it been found? — It has not been found.
Was the lamp in the chest? — The chest has been broken. We could not say whether it was inside or not.
Might the lamp not have been left burning some night? — I think the deputies would always put it out.
Was the deputy's chest blown all to pieces? — Yes.
Where were his work tools? — They were inside.
Have they been found? — Yes.
Are there any falls about there? — Yes.
If this lamp had been in the box it would have been found at the same time as the work tools. Would he not put the lamp in? — He would leave it outside. It would be standing upon his chest.
It might be lighted there by anyone else? — There would be nobody in after the deputy came out.
Were there two men found there? — They cannot get in after the deputy leaves.
Were they allowed to carry keys? — No.
Are you quite sure? — I am not quite sure.
(Mr. Morley.) Who was the deputy in charge that night? — Ralph White.
(Mr. Bowey.) When would the deputy come out? — About 12 o'clock at night.
(Mr. Edge.) It was the duty of the deputy to put this lamp out? — Yes, deputies generally put the lamp on the chest.
Has a search been made for this lamp? — Not yet ; we have only got in to get the tubs out.
Are there some heavy falls? — Yes, and we have not yet cleared them away.