1882 Tudhoe Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
Tudhoe Colliery Inquest, Tuesday, May 23rd, 1882.
On the court resuming its sitting, Mr. Edge, addressing the Coroner, said : I propose to call some hewers today, we called some deputies yesterday, and I propose to finish this part of the inquiry by calling some hewers.
THOMAS RAMSHAW said :—
I am a hewer in the Shieldfield district. I was on night shift on the night of the 17th and came to bank about 12 o'clock. I did not see any gas in the pit that night. I did not see anything to make me think that the pit was not perfectly safe. I have been employed at this pit for about 11 or 12 years.
(Mr. Bell.) Is it customary for a hewer to look for gas in his place every day? — There is a man to look for it for me.
Does a hewer take the trouble to examine his place? — I cannot tell that.
Do you remember whether you took the precaution to examine the place for gas that particular night? — The deputy did.
Did you yourself examine the place? — No.
Then there might have been gas and you might not have noticed it? — Yes.
(Mr. Marshall.) We admit all that this witness says, but it amounts to nothing.
(A Juror.) Do you think it right, gentlemen, for the witnesses to be in the room while one is giving evidence.
(The Coroner.) I expect there is only one witness in the room at a time.
(Mr. Edge.) I think all the witnesses are in the room at present.
(The Coroner.) What I said was this, that there might be two in, one under examination, and the other in readiness, so that we might not be delayed.
The Foreman of the Jury said they wished to do their duty, and they did not think it right that the witnesses should hear what each other had to say.
The witnesses were then requested to retire and the enquiry was proceeded with.
(Mr. Edge.) I have a great many more witnesses from this Croxdale and Sunderland Bridge way who were in the pit and came out before the accident. I do not know whether the jury would like to hear them or not.
(The Coroner.) The evidence is simply of a negative character.
(Mr. Edge.) Yes, it is simply the evidence of the last witness repeated, that there was no gas and so forth.
(Mr. Bell.) The last witness says he never looked for it.
(Mr. Bowey.) I do not think you need call any further evidence to show the condition of the pit at that time. What may be inferred from it is another matter.
(Mr. Edge.) I am entirely in the hands of the jury.
The Foreman of the Jury (Mr. Carry.) : The jury think there is no occasion to have any more witnesses like the last one.
(The Coroner.) There seems to be an opinion that we might have a few of them.
(Mr. Bowey.) I should like Sutton and Tindale to be called.
(Mr. Edge.) Sutton is very ill, and I am told he cannot come.
(Mr. Bowey.) And Tindale?
(Mr. Edge.) You have had Tindale. He has been called and has given his evidence.
(Mr. Bowey.) Will you call Dazley, the boy that was with Wallace.
(Mr. Edge.) We have sent for him.
PHILIP DAZLEY said :—
I was helping John Wallace at the engine in the Team Valley. I was down the pit at the time of the accident. I was at the engine. I did not hear anything, but some flame and some cinders came out of the door of the boiler. We saw some after-damp coming in. About 10 minutes after I saw some fire come from the boiler. I found some after-damp coming upon it. I did not hear any report. We got to the bottom of the shaft about two o'clock. There was not very much after-damp. We travelled out on the engine plane. We first met the fire-damp in the siding about 20 yards from the engine. I got to the bottom of the shaft before Tindale or Jones. We found everything was upset at the bottom of the shaft. There was no damage in the neighbourhood of the engine or in the Team Valley, except a baulk out of an overcast about 100 yards from the shaft. In-bye this there was no damage at all.
(Mr. Bowey.) Were you in the East Pit at all? — Yes. I was in the East Pit all the time.
(Mr. Edge.) It is worked from the East Pit.
(Mr. Bowey.) Were you in the Sunderland Bridge way? — No, sir.
You did not go along the Sunderland Bridge way? — Only as far as the engine house.
JOSEPH WOODCOCK said :—
I was a hewer in the Sunderland Bridge night shift, and I have known the pit seven years and upwards. I had been in the Sunderland Bridge district this quarter. I was down the pit immediately before the explosion, I came to bank at 12.15 p.m. The ventilation was very good, and I did not see any gas. I would know gas if I saw it. I did not see anything to make me uneasy or suspect any danger to the pit. I was in my own house when I heard the explosion. I left my work at 10 minutes to 12 o'clock. I travelled right away down the engine plane. I saw Caldwell and Faulkner as I was coming out. They were drilling a hole in the stenton. I did not see anything unusual in the pit that night.
(Mr. Bowey.) What you mean to say is that you did not see any gas where you were working? — No, sir, not the least.
You, as a hewer, did not make any search for gas? — Yes, I did.
Where? — In the place I was working.
Why did you look in your own place? — I make a practice of doing so.
Have you ever found gas in your own place? — No, sir.
Not at any time? — No.
Did you take much notice of Cauldwell and Faulkner? — No, sir, I just passed them by.
Where was the hole they were drilling? — On the left-hand side of the waggon way.
Left-hand side in going in, right-hand side going out-bye? — Yes.
In what direction was the hole pointed? — Going towards the West Pit.
Was it pointed towards the door? — Yes, sir, it was.
How far from the doors was it? — I could not say.
What do you think? Was it three yards from the door? — I think so from what I have seen since.
When did you go down after the explosion? — On Wednesday night, at half-past nine o'clock.
What pit did you go into? — The East Pit.
Did you go to explore? — No, sir.
What for? — To carry lime.
Were you in the return at all? — No, sir.
Where did you take the lime? — To the mason's for the stoppings.
Were you in the Stenton where the shot was fired? — No, sir.
Did you see it that night? — No, sir, I did not see it.
When did you first see it? — Not till the week following.
What did you then see? Was there any stone fallen? Had the shot brought any down? — Yes, sir.
Had it brought the door down? — No, sir, the door was standing.
How near was the stone off the door? — I did not go to examine it.
I did not ask you that. I asked you how near was the stone lying off the door? — I think about three yards, from what I could see.
Had none of the stone been removed? — No, sir.
How do you know that none of the stone had been removed? — From the position in which it lay.
Did the stone come from the roof? — Yes, sir.
And came from the roof close to where the doors had been? — Close to the door, sir.
Did you see where the shot had been made? — No, sir ; I did not examine it.
But the shot was pointed towards the roof, immediately over the door? — Yes, sir.
How far was the end of the shot the outer end from the door? — It would not be more than four yards.
Do you know how far the shot would extend inward? How far would the drill hole extend inward? — I cannot say.
Was there much of the stone down? — No, sir.
Was there some yards of stone down? — Maybe one yard.
Did you measure it? — No, sir.
(A Juror.) Did you ever know a shot being fired there before? — No, sir.
You did not consider it dangerous? — Not in the least.
Has there been any shot fired there before? — No, I never knew of any.
You, as a hewer, were satisfied to fire a shot there without any fear or doubt? — Yes, sir.
Woodcock, do you mean to say that you consider that a shot that would bring down the doors between the main intake and the return was a safe shot to fire? — Yes.
(Mr. Edge.) You have been asked by Mr. Bowey as to which way the shot was pointing. You say over the doors. Are you speaking of the inside of the jumper hole or the outside of the jumper hole? Which way was the jumper hole made? Was it made by driving it towards the door or driving it towards the intake? — Towards the intake.
He does not understand it. Was it drilled towards the door? — Yes, towards the door.
How were the men that were drilling the hole standing? Was the back of the hole towards the door or intake? — The back of the hole was towards the door.
(Mr. Morley.) When did you first examine the place afterwards? — I have not examined it yet.
You saw the stone lying? — Yes.
This was a week afterwards. Did the shot bring down the stone as far as the door or not? — No.
How far from the door was the furthest point of stone? — About three yards.
(Mr. Bell.) Is this three yards from the door that was, or three yards from the door there now? — Three yards from the door that was there before.
Is there anything to show where the door was before? — No, sir.
Then how do you know? — I have seen it when I passed.
But you did not examine it particularly, did you? — No, sir.
ROBERT TAIT said :—
I am a hewer in the Croxdale way backshift. I have known the pit 12 years, and have been engaged in it six years in succession. I came to bank at five o'clock at night on the 17th April. There was no night shift in the Croxdale way. I did not see any signs of gas in the place where I was working, not the least, and as far as I know the pit was perfectly safe when I left it. I know gas if I see it, and I did not see any in the Croxdale way.
(Mr. Bell.) Did you look for gas that day? — No, I did not look for it that day.
Then there might have been some for anything you know? — Not where I was working, for I would have seen it.
Never saw it ; you might not look.
(Witness.) It is not my duty to do so ; it is another man's duty.
(The Coroner.) It is your duty to look after you own safety.
(Mr. Bell.) We need not have any more of this kind of evidence.
(Mr. Edge.) We have had one from each of the different districts, Sunderland Bridge, Croxdale, Coldstream, and Team Valley.
(Mr. Bowey.) What is the use of calling a miner to say there is no gas.
(Mr. Edge.) We have called the deputies, and now we have the evidence of the men who were working there. I will call one witness from Coldstream, and then we will be done with it.
WILLIAM MATTHEWS said :—
I was a hewer in the Coldstream backshift. I came to bank on the night of the 17th. There is not a night shift in the Coldstream way. I have been employed at this pit for about nine years. The pit was all right when I left it, and I never saw anything of any gas.
(Mr. Bowey.) But did you look for any? — No, I did not look for any.
(Mr. Edge to the Coroner.) Now, sir, I have dealt with this pit and these different working places. I propose now to go into the West Pit and deal with the West Pit district. I will call the deputies and the overmen and some of the hewers from each of the districts. Assuming that the jury are satisfied, I am now going to give evidence as to the condition of the West Pit on the day of the accident.