Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Inquests Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Inquests
/   \

1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster

Inquest Report

Seaham Colliery Inquest, 13th April 1881 (cont.).

Mr. William Nicholas Atkinson sworn.

8,073. (Mr. Wright.) What are you? — I am Government inspector of mines, and the inspector assisting in the Durham district.

8,074. You assist Mr. Bell? — Yes.

8,075. You were one of the very first persons down the mine after the explosion, unless, perhaps, Mr. Stratton? — Mr. Stratton had been down before.

8,076. I may take it shortly that from that morning almost continuously for many weeks you were in and over every part of the mine that you could get to? — Yes, that is so.

8,077. I think you have been here throughout this inquiry? — Yes.

8,078. So far as you have observed are there any material indications of the direction from which the blast came, and the direction to which it passed, that have been omitted by the witnesses called before us. I do not want to go over the ground again, but if you think there has been anything that has not been stated perhaps you will be kind enough to state it? — The only point was the west incline in No. 3. Everything in this incline from the point 100 almost below the wheel was blown outwards.

8,079. What does that point to? What is the significance of that fact? — I account for it in this way, that when an explosion occurs in a mine of any extent, wherever it occurs the only place at which the expanded air can escape is the shaft.

8,080. The back lash in this case? — Yes.

8,081. I presume the point you make of it is any conflicting indications in the No. 1 Hutton seam with the Polka would be similar in kind to the double indications you find in the No. 3? — Yes.

8,082. Are they similar double indications in the Maudlin? — Yes.

8,083. Far in? — Perhaps 50 yards beyond the eastway end.

8,084. That would be something like 400 yards from the pit? — Yes.

8,085. Were these double indications at all strong in the Maudlin? — The Maudlin is so heavy a coal that there were very few indications in or out that we saw. We saw as many out as in as a matter of fact, although not so strong. With all these three lines on which the explosion extended, taking the shaft as the centre, there were outward indications from them all.

8,086. Taking the shaft as the centre, there was a strong outward indication? — Not a strong outward indication.

8,087. From the centre? — There were outward indications.

8,088. You mean the strongest indications were from the centre towards each of the limbs? — Yes. At the same time, on each of these long legs there were outward indications a certain distance from the shaft

8,089. Will you kindly state what your view is as to where the explosion originated? — Here are these three districts (pointing), and there were evidences of force having gone into each of them: there were also these outward signs. The first conclusion that I came to was that the explosion began within a short distance of the shaft — within 100 yards.

8,090. I think that would rather be what your present judgment is? — Well, I have come to the conclusion that the explosion began on this road between the shafts.

8,091. Between the curve and the Maudlin engine? — Between the curve and the Maudlin engine; and one of the chief reasons I have for that is, that this piece of road (pointing) was not damaged.

8,092. The piece of road between the curve and the Maudlin engine? — Yes.

8,093. That is the piece in which Brown's shot was fired? — Yes. There was nothing damaged excepting things connected with the ropes; the sheaves, the tail tope, rapper rope, they showed certain indications.

8,094. They might have been injured, I suppose, by something being blown away at a considerable distance, so that the rope might have been pulled out of its place by damage occurring 100 yards off? — Certainly. There were several instances of that sort over the pit. Any indication connected with a rope I look upon with great suspicion. I do not think you can conclude because you see an indication caused by a rope or connected with a rope that the force which caused that indication occurred at that place.

8,095. Are you able to fix more precisely the point at which you think the ignitions took place? — Well, having come to the conclusion that it was at that road there was a shot fired immediately before the explosion — immediately before it, or coincident with it — the men were in the position that has been described. They would only retire to such positions after having left the shot.

8,096. Do you think it was Brown's shot, shortly? — Yes.

8,097. Why, in preference to Venner's? Because any explosion which began in this No. 3 pit would necessarily have to pass over this road between the Maudlin engine and the curve; to get into the Maudlin pit and into that No. 1 pit it must pass over that road. Therefore, if it began here and did this immense damage on the west side, I cannot understand how it would pass over that road without damaging it also.

8,098. In other words, how it could pass Brown's shot without leaving any marks on the timbers thereabouts? — Yes. There had evidently been no blast of any importance whatever passing in either direction over this road between the Maudlin engine and the curve.

8,099. The same observation, it seems to me, would also be an objection to the theory that the explosion came out of No. 1? — Exactly the same difficulty occurs. If the explosion began in No. 1 pit, this road between the curve and the Maudlin engine is the only road by which that could be passed.

8,100. It must pass that road? — It must pass that road.

8,101. It would be the only place left untouched? — One solitary length.

8,102. Left untouched? — Eighty yards or 100 yards long perfectly undamaged by an explosion which did immense damage on both sides of it.

8,103. How do you get the gas? — That is the difficulty: I cannot get it.

8,104. But how do you? — I cannot. As soon as you begin to look for the gas you are lost in a sea of supposition. There were falls of stone on this side, but I do not suppose any gas came from any falls.

8,105. Are you able to offer any explanation at all as to what the material was that caused the explosion? — If it is possible that coal-dust would cause such an explosion, there is at once an explanation of the whole catastrophe ; if it is not possible for coal-dust alone, without gas, to cause the explosion, I cannot explain it.

8,106. Are you able to account for even the 2 or 2½ per cent. of gas that Professor Abel has spoken of? — No. It is only a question of degree. If I can account for 2½, by the same means I can account for 10.

8,107. Is that quite so? — If it comes off from a fall of stone, and it is supposed there were 2½ per cent., I would also suppose that there might be 10 per cent.

8,108. I may take it, in your judgment, no specific declaration has yet been given of how the necessary quantity of gas to work the coal-dust theory has been found in that part of the mine? — No.

8,109. (The Coroner.) Is this a fair explanation: "Point of ignition Brown's shot overcharge dust in fine state catching fire carried along by the current meeting small quantity of gas"? — No ; I do not think any small quantity of gas was going to carry the fire over the extent.

8,110. "Small coal inflamed at the point of ignition "? — Where does the gas come from?

8,111. Professor Abel puts it 2½ per cent. not detectable by ordinary observation? — Where is it to come from. I can no more account for 2½ than for 10.

8,112. (Mr. Wright.) If there was 10 per cent. there of course you would find it by the ordinary caps and tests? — Yes.

8,113. If there was two per cent, there you would not find it by the ordinary caps and tests? — No.

8,114. Why do you say the two things are at all comparable? I should say if you could account for two you could account for ten? — The difficulty is where it came from.

8,115. (The Coroner.) Is there a total absence of gas in the pit? — Certainly not.

8,116. (Mr. Wright.) You are not prepared to say that there may not be two per cent. of gas in every part of this pit at all times? — I do not believe there is.

8,117. Have you any reason for saying that there is not? — It would not be certain.

8,118 Have you any reason for saying there is not? — If there is it must be in the air when it comes along the shaft.

8,119. That is not the question. I want to know whether there is any reason for saying that there is not throughout a colliery of this kind that quantity of gas? — Very good reason indeed.

8,120. What reason? — Because the air comes from the surface of the earth, and there is not two per cent. of gas in the air on the surface of the earth.

8,121. That would involve that there is no fouling of air at all in a mine. First tell me where was Ramshaw's lamp found? — I never saw his lamp in the pit.

8,122. There has been some difference of opinion as to whether it was close to the fall? — I know Ramshaw was 200 yards from the in-bye side of the fall.

8,123. The fall was out-bye of the trouble? — The fall was about here (pointing).

8,124. Not so far out-bye? — I think 70 yards on the in-bye side of the junction of the travelling road and the engine plane.

8,125. Then Ramshaw's body was how far in-bye of that? — I think about 200 yards.

8,126. Can you tell me on the theory you adopted that the explosion came into the No. 1 — on the theory that the explosion came from Brown's shot into the No. 1, how do you account for the fact that it produced hardly any effect at all on the No. 1 travelling road? — There are two roads which it naturally would go along, namely, No. 1 main intake and No. 1 travelling-road.

8,126a. Why did it produce so much effect in the main intake and hardly any in the travelling road? — If you will allow me I will include two other roads. This travelling road in No. 1 pit was not damaged except at the ends ; it was evident the explosion had not passed over it; it had shot into each end, but it had not passed along it. The same remark applies to the second intake in the Maudlin. The explosion had come down the engine plane and down the intake; both these intakes took the same air that comes along the engine plane. The explosion did not go into the south way of No 3 pit beyond the crossings.

8,127. You say, although you may not be able to account for it in the No. 1, still, similar difficulties occur in the Maudlin and in No. 3? — Yes, and the only reason I can find which will apply equally to all these three roads — not to take one reason for one and another for the rest — is, that these three roads were comparatively free from coal-dust.

8,128. Was that so, as a matter of fact? — As a matter of fact, that is so.

8,129. The travelling road in each case? — The travelling road in each case, and the south way in No. 3 pit.

8,130. Why were they comparatively free of dust? — There are no coals passing along them; there is no source from which the dust can come on to them, and the floor is a stone floor: the dust that is made is chiefly stone-dust. This road, as a matter of fact, is comparatively free from coal dust; the dust is not black, it is grey.

8,131. I believe you yourself have made some experiments on coal-dust — Yes.

8,132. At high velocities? — Yes.

8,133. You have found that the effects which you could not get with imperfect apparatus at low velocities you were able to get with high velocities? — Yes.

8,134. Thereby confirming Professor Abel's results? — Yes. The results of the experiments were small at low velocities, but at high velocities they were increased to such an extent that so far as the apparatus allowed they were complete — so far as the apparatus permitted they carried the flame as far as possible.

8,135. Had you made any observations as to the hygrometrical or other atmospherical conditions of the mine before the explosion? — I got some hygrometrical observations kept at the Londonderry offices. I found the air some time before the explosion had been drier than usual ; it was drier than usual on the night of the explosion. The temperature was rather lower than in the pit, and consequently, the air when it got down the pit would be in a condition to receive moisture, and it would have a drying effect, so that everything in the pit, perhaps, would be a little drier than usual, and the air itself would be drier; but this pit is a very dry pit as compared with other pits, even in ordinary circumstances. There was a series of hygrometrical observations taken by the commissioners on the coal question in 1869 in 23 pits.

8,136. We will not go into any other pits? — Out of 23 pits in which the observations were made the Seaham pit was the driest.

8,137. Were these observations extending over considerable periods of time, or was it the result of one isolated experiment? — I do not remember.

8,138. After the explosion, did you notice any apparent peculiarity in the after-damp that would point to its having arisen from any peculiar cause? — I was going to describe the after-damp. My preconceived notions of after-damp were changed altogether.

8,139. It does not matter about preconceived notions so much as from your experience. You had seen after-damp before? — I do not think I ever did see any after-damp previously.

8,140. Tell us what you did observe about the afterdamp here? — I observed that the lights burned very brightly in it; it had apparently no effect on the lights, but it had a very obnoxious effect on the explorers.

8,141. What sort of effect? — It turned me giddy: I fancied it made me excited and affected my eyesight.

8,142 To what did you attribute the peculiar phenomena? — I think it might be explained by the presence of carbonic oxide in the after-damp.

8,143. Supposing it was due to carbonic oxide, to what would you attribute the carbonic oxide? — It would be produced by the combustion of coal-dust.

8,144. In your judgment you think there was sufficient peculiarity to point to the fact that the afterdamp had been affected in its composition by the combustion of coal-dust? — By the combustion of coal dust certainly.

8,145. (Mr. Edge.) You say no blast of any importance passed round the curve? — Not round the curve; there was nothing in the curve; there was no timber in it ; there was nothing to show whether the blast had passed over it or not. As far as I remember, I do not think there was a single prop or baulk or piece of timber, or anything to show that the blast had passed that way.

8,146. There was serious damage done in the neighbourhood of the Polka doors? — Yes.

8,147. Can you account for there being such serious damage at the Polka doors on your supposition that the explosion occurred so far off as you say? — There was damage far further than the Polka doors.

8,148. Can you account for there being serious damage in the Polka doors in-bye some distance by the supposition that the explosion occurred by Brown's shot? — Yes; I suppose there had been a blast of fire passing right down this No. 1 engine plane, past the Polka doors, and that did the damage.

8,149. Why should not the blast of fire have gone the other way and done damage by the Maudlin engine? — It did.

8,150. Assuming the possibility of explosion at the Polka doors, why should not the blast have gone outbye, then in-bye along towards the Maudlin engine, and done damage there? — I do not understand.

8,151. If a blast that had originated at the place you suggest was capable of doing the damage at the Polka doors, why should not a blast originating at the Polka doors do the damage you saw at the Maudlin engine? — Because the blast would have to pass over this curve and the Maudlin engine ; and if it passed over that it did so without damaging it in any way whatever.

8,152. On the other hand, the blast you suggest that went in-bye to No. 1 must have passed over the same ground? — No, that is just the difference. It started there, and it had not gained any strength or any explosive force until it got 40 or 50 yards away from where it was ignited.

8,153. There are difficulties in localising the seat of the explosion? — Very great difficulties.

8,154. By way of illustration, I will take you up into No. 3, the Old Hutton incline. May I take it that at the foot of the incline the indications are rather out-bye? — They were the outward indications down the western incline continued past the Maudlin wheel.

8,155. There are indications out-by there, and when you go further along the Old Hutton incline you come across the wheel blown 35 yards in-bye? — Yes.

8,156. No matter where you go there are indications? — There are indications, but there are greater objections to many other points than there are to these in my opinion.

8,157. (Mr. A. Jones.) Did you notice Simpson's body? — Yes.

8,158. Did you notice in what direction that was lying? — It was lying just at the junction of the curve on the Maudlin engine plane on the north side of the road.

8,159. In which direction was his head? — In-bye.

8,160. In-bye where? — In-bye of the Maudlin engine at the junction of the road, but he was on the Maudlin side.

8,161. Did you notice whether there was a sheave lying there? — Yes.

8,162. Was his head against the sheave and broken? — His head was broken.

8,163. Did you notice whether it was lying against the sheave? — I cannot remember the exact position of his head with regard to the sheave.

(The Coroner.) After the strong evidence Mr. Atkinson has given as to where he says the ignition point of explosion was, do you think this is material?

8,164 (Mr. A. Jones.) Certainly, it is only adding thereto. It does not carry it much further. I understood you to say there were no indications of force between Brown's body and the Maudlin engine? — There are no indications of damage between the west end of the curve. In saying the Maudlin engine, I put it too far — there is no other point to get hold of; the damage really commenced about here (pointing to the plan.)

8,165. (Mr. Wright.) How many yards to the east of the Maudlin? — Twenty yards, perhaps.

8,166. (Mr. A. Jones.) Going beyond the Maudlin engine again, you come to indications? — At the Maudlin engine ; the Maudlin engine was all broken up.

8,167. I did not quite understand how you accounted for the absence of these indications; was there nothing for it to expend its force on? — I suppose the explosion had not gathered force enough to blow the timber out.

8,168. It did get its force as it proceeded? — As it proceeded.

8,169. Did you see the cistern lying in the neighbourhood of Venner's shot — some vessel — I call it a cistern, because that is the name which is provided to me? — I do not remember.

8,170. A large tub, or anything of that kind? — No.

8,171. In the middle of the way, going down from Venner's shot towards the Maudlin engine? — No, I do not remember having seen such a thing. If you will allow me to say this, in my own mind I have an explanation of the reason which has caused several persons to fix upon this point near the main coal staple as the seat of the explosion. There were certain indications there, as Mr. Forman pointed out, in both directions. I observed the covers of the sheaves — one blown eastward, and the next we come to was blown westward. I explain that in this way. This outward force, or back lash as it has been called, coming down the west incline passes the end of this road, and it caused the outward appearances right down to the up-cast shaft; the back lash coming down the west incline rushed right away to the upcast shaft. It caused the indications of force to the east and then the in-going blast into the causeway and up the incline would cause the indications of force to the west.

The witness withdrew.

(The Coroner.) Do you propose calling anybody else, Mr. Jones?

(Mr. A. Jones.) No.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print