Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Inquests Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Inquests
/   \

1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster

Inquest Report

Seaham Colliery Inquest, 20th October 1880 (cont.).

Mr. Joseph Spence called (not sworn).

2,130. (Mr. Wright.) Can you tell us anything about the record of the water-gauge? — Not on that morning.

2,131. When did you last see the book? — The day before.

2,132. The day before the explosion — you cannot at this moment tell us where the book is? — No.

2,133. Or what has become of it? — I cannot.

2,134. (The Coroner.) A search had better be made for it, and then we will hear the result of the search? — Wile would record it at 1 o'clock.

2,135. (Mr. Wright.) In this book? — No; in his book.

(Mr. Wright.) If James Wile is here we had better ask him.

(The Coroner.) We will have his report-book. I remember that Wile's report-book stated the same thing as he has done with his mouth.

Examination of Mr. Stratton continued.

2,136. (Mr. Wright.) Very well, you will let us know, Mr. Stratton, as soon as you have made any search? — Yes, I will make a search at once.

2,137. And try to account for it? — It is this way — the book was kept in a little —

(The Coroner.) Give us the reasons if you cannot find it; then give us the reasons why it is not here.

(The Foreman.) Mr. Wile stated that the gauge was 2 1/10 inches.

(The Coroner.) 2 1/10 inches at 1 o'clock.

2,138. (Mr. Wright.) I know he stated that, but I want to know where the official register is? — The register is kept by the master-wasteman.

2,139. Suppose the figures given by Wile were correct, what inference would you draw from those figures? — Well, I should say that the ventilation was about at its maximum.

2,140. Is there much variation in the water gauge from time to time? — Yes, a good deal.

2,141. Accounted for by what, generally? — Well, it would vary you know; for instance, when the furnaces were being cleaned the water gauge would go back.

2,142. (The Coroner.) When the furnaces are being cleaned the water gauge goes back? — We keep a diagram of the water gauge. It is sent to me every day of the week.

2,143. (Mr. Wright.) Just tell me this. I forgot to ask you what are the diameters of the pits, Nos. 1 and 2? — They are both 14 feet pits.

2,144. And No. 3? — No. 3 is a 14 feet pit.

2,145. Is that after deducting for the shaft timbering, or the gross area? — That is the gross area, of course.

2,146. Then how much is occupied by timbering? — I made a calculation the other day about that. I could very quickly calculate it. I know exactly the amount of superficial area in the pit. But do you care to allow me time to calculate it?

2,147. Certainly; entirely at your leisure. You mean you would do it now? — Yes.

2,148. Would it take long? — Five minutes, perhaps.

2,149. I think we had better get on — where were the cages of the pit at the time of the explosion? — No. 1 pit was what is called wrapped by; No. 2 pit was running in the shaft, the cages were running at the time.

2,150. How are the stables ventilated? — By splits in the main in-take as a rule. We have one stable that is ventilated by the fresh air returning to the current again, a separate spit for each stable.

2,151. (The Coroner.) From the main in-take in the returns? — From the main in-take into the return.

2,152. (Mr. Wright.) What is the size of the No. 1 furnace? — Well, the combined area would be 9 feet by 6 or 7.

2,153. You mean its area on the surface? — Yes; the superficial area of the bars, the bars are 7 or 8 feet long, and there is 9 feet between the brickwork.

2,154. No. 3, what is that? — Precisely similar; 9 feet by 6 feet.

2,155. What is the superficial area? — You may say 63 feet in the case of one pit, and about 54 in the other.

2,156. Can you tell me the quantity of coal that is burnt in 24 hours at the furnaces? — Well, I should think about 10 tons each.

2,157. That is, each of two furnaces? — Each of two furnaces.

2,158. (The Coroner.) How far apart are they? — They would be about 150 yards apart.

2,159. What is the average temperature of the up-cast? — Well, it would run from 190 at the furnace drifts to about 160 at the back — 160 or 170.

2,160. Not more than that? — That is the official registered temperature that we took some years ago for a particular purpose.

2,161. How many years ago was that taken? — In 1875.

2,162. That was taken in reference to the main rate? — Yes, I took it myself.

2,163. (Mr. Wright.) So far as you know, there is no reason to suppose that the temperature has materially altered since it was taken in 1875? — I should not think there would be a deal of difference. It is a sort of thing that is bound to be stationary.

2,164. Are the furnaces the same? — The same — there has not been a thing altered.

2,165. It would partly depend upon the amount of ventilation? — The amount of ventilation has not varied materially in that time, it has increased, but not to an extreme extent.

2,166. How many boilers are there in the pit? — Well, there are four common cylindrical boilers, and two semi-portable boilers of portable engines, tube boilers, multi-tubular boilers.

2,167. Just point out where they are situated? — No. 1 is there (pointing).

2,168. A little south of the down-cast? — No. 2 boiler are those (pointing).

2,169. No. 1 — how far from the shaft? — You may say 30 yards from the south of the down-cast.

2,170. No. 2 boilers are? — Are there.

2,171. About 15 yards from the north down-cast? — More than that; you may say 50 yards or 60.

2,172. Where are the others? — There is one standing there (pointing).

2,173. It is about 150 yards to the north of the up-cast? — And the other one is there (pointing).

2,174. That is about 20 yards to the east of the down-cast? — 15 or 20 yards to the south of the up-cast.

2,175. Are they fed by fresh air or return? — No. 1 boilers are fed by fresh air.

2,176. From the in-take? — Yes.

2,177. Can return air get to them? — No return air can get to them.

2,178. No. 2? — Is fed by return air entirely.

2,179. From each return? — These returns — the Maudlin and No. 2 pit.

2,180. From Harvey? — Yes.

2,181. How much return air passes by No. 2 boiler? — Passes by it? Well, there would be a considerable quantity of wind passing by them.

2,182. How much passes into the furnaces? — Just what it takes to drive them, according to the dampness.

2,183. Show me the place where it is taken, and of the Maudlin for No. 2 boiler? — There is the place (pointing), and it just takes sufficient to drive the boilers.

2,184. By pipe, or how is it brought it? — No, they stand close by a return. They stand in the return off to our side, but to all intents and purposes they are in the return.

2,185. Are the fires naked? — Yes.

2,186. Quite open? — Yes.

2,187. Are there any other fires quite open in any return in the mine? — Yes, the furnaces and boiler are close there.

2,188. It is all, so to speak, one thing? — Yes.

2,189. So that there would be no greater danger with the fires of those boilers than there would be with the fires of the furnaces? — No.

2,190. And you have told me now the numbers of all the boilers? — Yes.

2,191. How much coal is burned at them in the 24 hours? — I think about 14 tons a day at No. 1. I should say about 8 or so at No. 2.

2,192. How often do you clean them? — The furnaces?

2,193. Yes? — Once in 24 hours.

2,194. Were any furnaces cleaned that night? — To the best of my knowledge No. 3 furnace would be cleaned a little after 10 o'clock.

2,195. Just point it out. That is one immediately west of the up-cast? — Yes.

2,196. Was it cleaned that night? — It ought to have been.

2,197. (The Coroner.) To the best of your belief, do you think that No. 3 furnace was cleaned a little after 12 o'clock? — Yes.

(Mr. Jones.) You are speaking of the furnace, I suppose — not the boiler?

(Mr. Bell.) The ventilating furnace.

2,198. (Mr. Wright.) How long does it take to burn down and clean the furnace? — Well, I should think they commence to burn down a little after 10 o'clock. The master wasteman would give this information better than I should.

2,199. Would it take an hour? — I think it would take rather longer to stop and burn down, I do not know.

2,200. Whilst one is being cleaned, is the other driven harder? — No, there is no attempt to drive it harder.

2,201. Then the ventilation is less during the time of the cleaning? — Well, the water-gauge is the less, but whether the ventilation is really less is a matter of considerable doubt I should think. For instance, when the boiler fires are out, the water-gauges are much lower, but it does not affect the ventilation so much. Half-an-inch of water-gauge does not affect the ventilation to any serious or appreciable extent in fact.

2,202. The ventilation would be affected, I suppose, by one of the furnaces being out? — Yes, it is affected, but not so much as you would think.

2,203. Not enough to reduce it from five feet to four feet rate of velocity? — I should say not so much as that decidedly.

2,204. Do you know whether the boiler fires were damped down for the night before the explosion? — The boiler fires of No. 2 pit would probably have been damped down at 5 o'clock.

2,205. In the afternoon? — Yes.

2,206. And of the other pit? — The other pit was damped about 1 o'clock.

2,207. Were there any at work? — They were not damped down at the time of the explosion, as it happened.

2,208. All at work? — No, the men were coming in to get up the steam again. He had his dampers open at the time.

2,209. Does the damping of the boiler fires have any particular effect upon the ventilation of the mine? — Well, I told you before, suppose the pit was idle, and the boiler fires were quite out for 24 hours, it does not affect the ventilation of the colliery to a large extent; it might reduce the ventilation current to 300,000 feet, for instance.

2,210. I meant to ask you just now when one of the ventilating furnaces was out, whether that did not affect the ventilation very much? — I did not understand you to ask that. I meant the boiler fires.

2,211. Then I will ask you now. Supposing one of the ventilating furnaces is out, how does that affect the ventilation? — It depends upon the time it is put out.

2,212. How often are they put out? — They are never put out unless there is a necessity to clean or repair the boiler flues.

2,213. About how often does that necessity occur? — Well, I suppose once in six months.

2,214. Had it occurred just about the time of the explosion? — No.

2,215. Not on the night of the explosion? — Certainly not on the night of the explosion.

2,216. Is there a brattice below the Harvey, or is the pit open below the Harvey seam? — I was just trying to recollect — it is not very long since I went down. I would not like to swear whether there is or not.

2,217. Below it is carried down to the Harvey? — Yes, to the Harvey. Whether it is carried down below or not, I could not say.

2,218. Is it close scaffolded over the Harvey seam? — No, it is not a close scaffold, it is a loose scaffold.

2,219. Is there a close scaffold at No. 1 pit up the Hutton? — No. 1 pit?

2,220. Yes? — Well, I suppose it is close there to prevent anything falling down.

2,221. I think you said you did not know whether the main brattice is carried direct from bank to the Harvey seam? — It is carried direct from bank to the Harvey seam. I am certain, but whether it is carried below that I cannot recollect. It is a place one does not see every day.

2,222. How is the ventilation under? — There is no particular means that I know of. There is no open place at the side where they have a flute to see where the water is, and there is always ventilation going on more particularly with the down-cast.

2,223. But there is nothing to lead or force the air through it? — There is nothing to force it.

(Mr. Wright to Mr. Bell.) I should call that a dumb place under the scaffold, should not you?

(Mr. Bell.) Yes.

(The Witness.) When the water is up there would be nothing; when the water is down, there might be a depth of from 3 to 5 fathoms.

2,224. Would the water be up once a day? — It would be twice a day; it very often floats the scaffold in the morning.

2,225. Do you know when the part below the scaffold was last examined before the explosion? — No; it was cleaned out recently, I would not like to say when.

2,226. Carry your attention, please, to No. 1.

2,227. (Mr. Bell.) When was there anyone down from the No. 1 to the Harvey? — I cannot say that, but there is constant examination every night.

2,228. Do the scaffold-men go down it every night? — No, I do not suppose they go down it every night, but there is everything in — the exhaust pipes, water pipes, and that sort of thing — and they are sure to examine them very closely.

2,229. (Mr. Wright.) Now, please, about the timbering. How is the timbering done in this mine — is it done by the men themselves? — No.

2,230. Done by special timbermen? — By deputies.

2,231. Is there much timber required in these seams? — Yes, a good deal.

2,232. Have there ever been complaints in your time of insufficiency of timber? — Never.

2,233. Are accidents frequent from falls? — Well, I should not say they are, I should say they are rather uncommon, if any, compared to other mines.

2,234. It is not a dangerous mine in that respect? — No, we have had accidents of course.

2,235. Can you tell us about that part of the shaft that you were asked about last, under the scaffold on No. 1 side of No. 1 and 2 pit — whether that is examined with naked lights? — I should think so. They certainly don't use safety lamps there.

2,236. Have you ever known gas to come out of the Busty? — No.

2,237. When the brattices broke there can be no sense in calling it a close pit. The same air goes down No. 1 side as goes down to the Harvey pit.

2,238. Have you ever known gas show itself on the top of the old west? — Which west is that?

(Mr. Wright.) Mr. Bell, will you point out the old west.

2,239. (The Coroner.) If you have given the place a name previously, keep to the old name ; — No. 3 Hutton seam.

2,240. (The Coroner.) Do we know it by another name? — We know it by No. 3 Hutton seam incline.

2,241. (Mr. Wright.) Has gas ever been known to show itself there? — Well, it will show itself at the goaf edges, no doubt, there within recent times.

2,242. Do you remember any mention of it being made as showing there shortly before the explosion? — Certainly not before the explosion.

2,243. How long do you think? — Well, it runs in my mind that I have seen it reported as showing there within six months, but I would not say how long.

2,244. (The Coroner.) Just point it out there will you for me? — This is a district (pointing).

2,245. Where is the point? — Here is the top of the in-take.

2,246. No, no, but the point you are speaking of? — I could not say that.

2,247. You have just seen it at the edge of the goaf? — It has been seen at the goaf edge.

(The Coroner.) There is no particular place.

2,248. (Mr. Wright.) Who would report it? — When the pit was working the deputy would report it.

2,249. Which deputy? — I don't know; the deputies have all changed since then.

2,250. Besides the goafs shown in that plan, the great part of the white stuff ought to be shown as goaf — the whole of the west ought to be shown as goaf? — No.

2,251. Well, all along ought to be goaf? — Down there (pointing).

2,252. The whole way down on the left side of that map ought to be black instead of white? — No, there is the boundary (pointing).

2,253. Then all that is round No. 3 Hutton is goaf? — All round No. 3 Hutton seam is goaf decidedly.

2,254. Completely round? — Completely round.

2,255. Is there any other place where goaf ought to be shown? — No, there is no other place.

2,256. Not in the Maudlin? — There is no broken line as you can see.

2,257. No, I see. Have you ever had any blowers in the mine in your time? — Yes, we have had blowers. There was one in the third east about three years ago. I think it is more than that.

2,258. Since then, have you had any considerable blowers? — We have not had any alarming blowers for about three years, but the third east, ever since we have got into it, has been liable to little lots of blowers. You can see by the appearance of the face — the little hitches. We are always liable to get little bits of gas off those places.

2,259. Just carrying on about the goaf. There is one other question to ask you about that. You never fill your goaf at all, do you? — No.

2,260. You always leave it to fill behind? — Yes.

2,261. As you clear the pillars home? — Yes.

2,262. I think we were told yesterday by somebody that there would be as much as thirty yards behind the working face before the goaf would come down upon the floor? — There may be sometimes, but it is an excessively rare case.

2,263. How often does it fall? — Almost as they draw it.

2,264. As they draw the pillars? — Yes; the goaf is always close to the working face.

2,265. What would be the slant of the roof as it comes down? — It breaks off in the Hutton seam — sometimes perpendicular — and then you take off the coal next the goaf. As a rule, the Hutton seam breaks away with a square break. It may hang sometimes for a distance of forty yards, but it is very rarely the case. I have not seen many of that sort of thing. The whole land weight comes down.

2,266. Comes down solid? — No, not at first, as a rule, only a few feet comes first gradually to goaf closes.

2,267. How much fills at first, enough to fill up from the floor to what height? — Six, or eight, or ten feet.

2,268. Quite to the top above? — Yes.

2,269. Then there is a kind of cavity left over it? — Yes, presumably.

2,270. That you cannot see? — That I cannot see.

2,271. That may be there a long time after the land weight comes down? — You never can tell.

2,272. It is merely a question of gas? — Yes.

2,273. You can tell in a place where there is nothing of these falls, and where the goaf leaves about forty yards interval behind, suppose you sometimes see the land weight coming down slowly? — No, we did not see it.

2,274. Now, I come to the blasting. The blasting stopped in the colliery was it not — some years ago? — Stopped?

2,275. Yes? — Not that I ever heard of.

2,276. (The Coroner.) Was firing coal ever actually stopped? — No, never any more stopped than it ever has been. We never have fired shots in the coal much in my time.

2,277. (Mr. Wright.) You were not here about ten years ago when there was an explosion? — No.

2,278. Attributed to a shot. Tell me what the system of the colliery is with respect to shots? — Well, the system is shortly this: that if shots are required to be fired, the persons who wants to fire makes application to the underviewer, and the underviewer applies to me. If I consider it safe to fire shots, I give him a written leave, and he selects the person, who gives him instructions when and what to do, and how to do it — and shots are fired until the necessity for shots to be fired does not exist.

2,279. Do you examine the place so as to see whether it is safe to fire a shot there? — Oh no, I cannot do that.

2,280. Then what is the object of the underviewer asking for sanction? — Simply that I may know that he is not firing in a place likely to be dangerous. If he asks me to fire a shot in the main in-take where there is a certain quantity of wind passing, I should say it is safe.

2,281. I suppose you ask the underviewer whether he has personally inspected the place? — Well, if it is-on the main in-take it is a place I go to myself very frequently.

2,282. Have you any printed rules connected with the firing of shots? — Yes.

2,283. Are they in the special rules? — In the special rules.

2,284. Have you any other besides what are in the special rules? — No, we give a copy of the special rules — that particular part — to the shot-firers.

2,285. Will you turn to the place about the special rules about the shots? — They are not in these.

2,286. (Mr. Jones.) Will they be in these? — Yes.

2,287. (Mr. Wright.) Then will you kindly give me a copy of the special rules? — Yes, I have them in my keeping. These are additional special rules (producing printed paper). I got them past myself. That will complete it.

2,288. That is the only alteration? — That is the only alteration. They are additional rules.

2,289. Are these special rules made for your colliery, and differ from other rules? — Those are confined to our colliery, at least as far as I know. I got these passed by Mr. Bell.

2,290. About how often in the six months before the explosion do you suppose shots have been fired in the colliery? — Well, shots have been fired constantly in the colliery for years at different points.

2,291. That is not the question. How often in the six months before the explosion do you suppose shots have been fired in the colliery? — How often?

2,292. Yes? — Well, I don't understand the question.

2,293. How many shots do you suppose have been fired in the six months? — Well, I could not speak. We fire shots in the main coal seam.

2,294. Is it, or not, a thing that you have no recollection of — the number of shots that are fired? — Certainly not.

2,295. I mean, would it be every day that shots are fired? — Every day in the week shots are fired, except Sunday. In the colliery we have stone drifts going.

2,296. More than one, or two, or three shots every day, do you suppose? — Oh yes, decidedly more. The drift goes 18 hours a day, and they are firing shots.

2,297. The whole time? — The whole time.

2,298. Are they firing in all parts of the pit? — It depends upon circumstances.

2,299. In the Harvey, were you firing shots about that time? — I don't remember of any shots being fired in the Harvey at that time.

2,300. There were no drifts going? — No drifts going.

2,301. Take the No. 1 Hutton. Were any drifts going there about the time of the explosion? — Yes.

2,302. Whereabouts? — There was a drift going on there (pointing).

2,303. That is about No. 3 east?

(The Coroner.) There was no shot fired in No. 1 on the night of the explosion.

(Mr. Wright.) No. 1 third east.

(The Witness.) There was a drift too here, and those men were making their drift ready for work. There were four men in there.

2,304. I thought you said there were none? — In that drift I said there were none.

2,305. Then there may have been shots fired in the No. 1 pit, third east district, on the night of the explosion? — Yes, they went there with the intention to fire them.

2,306. Pass from there to the far-off end — were there any drifts going there? — No.

2,307. No shots could have been fired there that night so far as you know? — None there.

2,308. Pass on, please, towards the shafts between — where does the far-off end go? — There is the far-off way (pointing).

2,309. Had we better call that the far-off corner, or what? The far-off junction, shall we call it? — Yes.

2,310. What is this — a trouble? — Yes.

2,311. What is this called? — The Polka way.

2,312. Between the far-off junction and the Polka way, would there be any shots fired that night? — No.

2,313. Are you positive of that? — Positive of that.

2,314. What makes you so positive? — There was no one there to fire them.

2,315. (The Coroner.) Between the far-off way and the Polka way no permission had been given to fire shots on the night of the explosion? — No; there was no one working there.

2,316. (Mr. Wright.) Between the Polka way and the second west stable would there be any shot fired on the night of the explosion? — No.

2,317. Between the second west stables and the first west stables would there be any? — No.

2,318. Between the first west stables and the shaft, would there be any? — No.

2,319. Between the first west stables and the downcast would there be any? — No.

2,329. Nor in any of the returns in No. 1 pit? — No, I am positive of it.

2,321. Now then, please take No. 3 pit, the Hutton seam. In any part of that pit would there be any shots fired that night? — In the third Hutton seam there were shots fired, about here (pointing.)

2,322. What do you call that — the inclined bottom? — You may call it the main coal landing.

2,323. That is just where the bodies Nos. 19, 5, and 17 are? — Yes.

2,324. In any other place in the, pit were shots fired that night? — Yes; 20 yards from there.

2,326. 20 yards eastward from there? — There was one fired there, and there was one 20 yards this way (indicating.)

2,326. Any others in that pit? — No, not in that pit at all.

2,327. Any down the Hutton seam southward? — No.

2,328. Now take the Maudlin engine plane. Were there any shots fired in the Maudlin that night? — There was a shot fired about here (pointing.)

2,329. In the Maudlin? About how many yards from No. 2 boiler?

(The Coroner.) Is that another shot fired?

2,330. (Mr. Wright.) I think I will put it in this way — on the Maudlin engine plane where the body No. 1 was found? — About 20 yards to the east of the body.

2,331. About 20 yards to the east of the body No. 1? — Yes.

2,332. (Mr. Jones.) How do you fix that — how far from the shaft — cannot we get it that way better? — Well, it is about 150 yards from the shaft; you might say 130; it might be 150.

2,333. (The Coroner.) On the Maudlin engine plane, east of there, No. 1 body was found? — Yes.

2,334. How far? — About 150 yards from the shaft.

2,335. (Mr. Jones.) That would be east of the shaft, I presume? — That is west of the shaft, north and west.

2,336. Of No. 1 shaft? — No. 1 shaft.

2,337. (The Coroner.) A shot was fired — a second shot — is it a second? — Well, a third one according to the way we have been reckoning. We reckoned two on the main coal landing.

2,338. Can you tell which was fired first. I suppose you cannot? — No.

(Mr. Jones.) Would you just mark it on the map? — just point to it.

(Mr. Wright.) We must not mark the shots, I think.

(Mr. Jones.) I only meant to indicate it. I did not mean mark the map.

2,338a. (Mr. Wright.) Any other shots in the Maudlin pit? — That is all I know of.

2,339. So far as you know, none in the East Maudlin? — None that I know of.

2,340. And none in the north Maudlin? — None that I know of.

2,341. As far as you know you have told us of all the places where shots would be fired that night? — So far as I know, I have.

2,342. Would those shots be fired for the purpose of clearing stone drifts and making refuges? — They were all for the purpose of making refuges.

2,343. And all in the in-take? — And all in the intake. No, those down in No. 1 pit were not strictly in the in-take.

2,344. Just point which of them would not be in the in-take? — These two (pointing).

2,345. Those of the No. 1 pit, No. 3 district? — Yes; the wind spits over the top and comes down again.

2,346. But, as regards all the shots in the northern part of No. 1 Hutton and in No. 3 Hutton and in the Maudlin — were they all in the in-take? — All; so far as I know all the shots that I refer to were in the in-take.

2,347. I suppose on other occasions there would be shots fired in the return or about the mines in various points — we need not go into that? — No; extremely rarely — extremely rarely.

2,348. (The Coroner.) Shots in the return are extremely rare? — Extremely rare.

2,349. (Mr. Wright.) Is there any rule against them? — No, no rule at all; there is no rule against shot-firing anywhere. I would refuse the sanction unless the man would do it himself — I would make him do it himself.

2,350. Take the personal responsibility? — Undoubtedly I would; but such a thing has only happened once to my knowledge at this moment.

2,351. (The Coroner.) You would refuse permission except the master waster himself fired — is that correct? — Yes.

2,352. (Mr. Jones.) Himself fired, do you say? — Well, himself superintended it — I do not say fired it.

(The Coroner.) Superintended the firing of it.

2,353. (Mr. Wright.) One of the witnesses on a former occasion, when I was not here, said that he had been told by a man called Hindson, that Hindson had orders not to fire shots or to cease firing shots? — Well, I saw the same statement.

2,354. Can you tell what it refers to? — Not a notion.

2,355. So far as you know, has no change been made in the practice of the mine within the last year or so, about the firing of shots? — No; we have just had the same way of going on.

2,356. You have never seen any reason to think it dangerous to fire shots in this mine? — No; not where we allow it.

2,357. Are you guided at all in your allowing or refusing to allow a shot to be fired by the quantity of dust in the part of the mine? — No; we have not been guided at all that way. We have not taken into account the dust.

2,358. You have never required them to damp the part of the mine in which a shot was going to be fired? — No; I have never given special orders for it.

2,359. Are there any parts of the mine that are specially dusty? — No; I should not say any one place more than another.

2,360. There are some that are specially not dusty, are not there? — Those parts where they are wet are not dusty, of course.

2,361. Take No. 3 south way — take all the main coal staple, that is not wet, is it? — No.

2,362. And it is not dusty? — Just the same as other Hutton seams.

2,363. Are you sure of that? — Quite positive of it.

2,364. Take the second in-take in the No. 1 — that is not dusty, is it? — Well, at one particular part it is wet, but it is dusty just the same way as any other. Any other of the Hutton seams are in the ordinary way.

2,365. Have you seen, since the explosion, three places where shots were fired on the night of the explosion — apparently? — Yes.

2,366. Which were those three? — The three that I have seen that have been fired were this one, —

2,367. That is the one on the north, near No. 1 body? — And this (pointing), and there.

2,368. Two in the No. 3 Hutton. Can you tell whether they had been fired in the usual way, or by the explosion — was there anything to show you? — No; we could not possibly tell that. They have been fired in the usual way, probably, I should think.

2,369. Had the stones been removed at all? — They were not removed at all from what I may call the first one we came to. They had been entirely removed from this one (pointing), and partially removed from that (pointing).

2,370. They had entirely been removed from the shot near the No. 5 body? — No; this one (pointing).

2,371. No. 17. Which is the one from where the stones had been removed? From the easternmost of the two blasts in the No. 3 Hutton, all the stone brought down by the shot had been removed? — Yes; as far as I know.

2,372. From the more western one in the No. 3 Hutton, they had begun to be removed? — I think so; they had the appearance.

2,373. From the blast in the Maudlin engine plane, so far as you could see, they had not begun to be removed? — No.

(Mr. Jones.) Could we have that re-heard; I could not follow that.

(Mr. Wright.) From the easternmost shot of the No. 3 Hutton the stones brought down by the explosion had been entirely cleared way.

(Mr. Jones.) You mean mechanically removed by the men.

(Mr. Wright.) People had taken them away.

2,374. (The Coroner.) According to what you saw after the explosion? — According to what I saw. I am like other folks, I can only judge by appearances.

2,375. (Mr. Wright.) That I suppose would clearly point to the two shots in the No. 3 Hutton having been fired some little time before the explosion? — Yes; I should think it would.

2,376. Would it also point to the one in the Maudlin engine plane in the converse direction? Would it tend to show that the shot had been fired immediately before the explosion? — Well, it might.

2,377. I mean, does it afford any indication? — Yes, it would be a somewhat coincident point of time.

2,378. How long would it be after a shot was fired in the ordinary course of things before the men would begin to clear away the stuff? — It depends very much upon their inclination.

2,379. The men could not leave all the stuff lying about? — It is lying there at this moment.

2,380. Was it a refuge hole? — It was a refuge hole they were making bigger.

2,381. Were the others refuge holes? — Yes, they were; they were doubling the refuge holes each side.

2,382. Is blasting in your judgment absolutely necessary for the purposes of this mine? — Yes, you could not work stone work without blasting.

2,383. Could not; of course it is a question of expense? — I mean to say you could not; you could not work stone without blasting. It is not a question of expense at all.

2,384. What kind of stone is it? — It is hard sandstone.

2,385. New red sandstone? — No, freestone. It is a very hard post sandstone, that is the local term.

2,386. (Mr. Jones.) It is a freestone? — It is not exactly what you call a freestone — it is a sandstone.

(The Coroner.) A bastard freestone.

2,387. (Mr. Wright.) Within three months before the day of the explosion we know that inflammable gas had been found in the mines? — Yes.

2,388. Of course we know that, and I suppose we may take it — (tell me if I am wrong) — that it had issued so freely that it showed a blue cap on the flame of the safety lamp? — Yes, I suppose you might say that.

2,389. Very likely you know the question I am coming to. In the Coal Mines Regulation Act the general rule says, where that is the case, blasting ought only to be used "either in those cases of stone drifts, stone work, and sinking of shafts, in which the ventilation is so managed that the return air from the place where the powder is used passes into the main return air course without passing any place in actual course of working." That is one alternative. I suppose you did not satisfy that alternative? — Not in those cases.

2,390. You did not satisfy the one of the two alternatives alluded to by the Act of Parliament; that is to say, the return air from the place where the powder was used in those cases did not pass into the main return air course without passing some place in actual course of working? — The main intake of course was bound to.

2,391. It passed some place in actual course of working? — Using it in the intake you are bound to.

2,392. Before it got to the main return air shaft? — Yes.

2,393. The other alternative which it remains for you to satisfy, if it was lawful for you to fire the shots, is, "when the persons ordinarily employed in the mine are out of the mine, or, out of the part of the mine where it is used." I think the shifters (you call them) were down when the shots were fired. That is your universal practice? — Yes.

2,394. Well, you take the view, I suppose, that the shifters are not persons ordinarily employed in the mine? — Yes.

2,395. There would be a shift of how many men down at the time these shots were fired? — I think we got it yesterday, 238.

2,396. I think you have been making, or having intended to make, some experiments about the explosion of coal dust. Have you made them yet? — All the experiments that I made were made some time ago.

2,397. Can you tell us shortly whether they tended to show that there was danger in coal dust in the absence of gas. What was the result of them? — Well, the result was communicated to the Mining Institute. It is public property, so far as that goes.

2,398. Could you lend us a copy of it to read; it is very valuable? — I could not.

2,399. Can you tell me shortly, did you come to any conclusion that there was danger from the coal dust in a mine like this? — No, I did not.

2,400. You think there was no danger? — I think there was no danger in it.

2,401. Not even if shots were fired? — Not even if shots were fired.

2,402. I suppose you would admit — if I may use the word without offence — that the coal dust would intensify the effects of explosion of gas? — Well, there is no doubt that coal dust is a very active agent in the case of an actual explosion.

2,403. But you think, in the absence of an explosion of gas, there is no danger in the coal dust? — I should not say coal dust quiescent lying on the ground is any more dangerous than anything else.

2,404. But suppose it is stirred up by anything so as to fill the air with a cloud, and then a shot were fired into it? — I never have tried it, but there is no doubt that coal dust in a cloud is an active agent.

2,405. Will a shot fired in a dusty part of a mine raise the dust in a cloud in the neighbourhood of the shot? — Well, I should doubt it; I never saw it.

2,406. Have you taken any samples of the dust that was left in the mine after the explosion? — No.

2,407. You never had the curiosity to see what state it was in? — Well, it is very difficult to collect in anything like what you might call a state to make an examination of it.

2,408. Any time in the day before the accident you could have picked up bushels of it, could not you? If you had offered 6d. for a bushel, you could have got as much as you liked? — Well, I do not know. The dust in the form of dust is bad to collect. The dust lies in such very imperceptible thicknesses that it is a difficult matter to separate the dust from the rubbish.

2,409. Where there is so much of it you have to water it in places? — We water the ways, but it is not all coal dust, you must understand.

2,410. I did not say it was, Mr. Stratton? — I say that the dust you have there was so thick before the explosion that you might have practically got any quantity of it that you wanted, could not you? — No, I should not say so. It depends upon what you call dust. You might have got a lot of rubbish that had dust in it; you could have got a lot of it.

2,411. You say that there was not much about the mine? — I should not say that there was an extraordinary quantity about the mine.

2,412. I am not asking you an "extraordinary quantity" — I know nothing about that — but was there much dust about the mine — was there a quarter of an inch on the floor? — Certainly not.

(The Coroner.) Coal dust or dust of all kind.

2,413. (Mr. Wright.) We will ask him. Is it dust of all kinds? — Imperceptible films.

2,414. Dust of all kinds? — There is dust about the place, but not a quantity that you would notice specifically, except it might be at particular places.

2,415. And after the explosion nothing occurred to cause you to pay any particular attention to the question of what had become of the dust? — I do not know that there was that much — nothing to draw my attention to it particularly.

2,416. You would, in fact, take no steps to find out whether the character of the dust had been altered after the explosion? — No, I did not. The difficulty of collecting it was the chief difficulty.

2,417. (The Coroner.) About the locality where those three shots were fired. What about the coal dust there prior to the explosion? — Well, there was a little dust.

2,418. There is not any quantity of coal dust in that locality? — I should say not.

2,419. Not where any of those three shots were fired? — I have travelled it hundreds of times, and never noticed much dust there.

2,420. Not where any one of them was fired? — Not where any one of them was fired.

2,421. (Mr. Wright.) Could you see large quantities of fine coal dust going down No. 1 and No. 2 pit? — You could never see it.

2,422. Coming from the screens? — It does come down, but you never can see it.

2,423. It is too fine to be seen? — Yes, imperceptible.

2,424. At the bottom is there always a considerable quantity? — Yes, the further you go from the shaft the less you get it.

2,425. Does not it lie in considerable quantities? — No, not considerable.

2,426. It is cleared away? — I suppose it is.

2,427. Daily? — No, it is never cleared away at all.

2,428. You mean there is no collection of dust at the bottom of the shafts? — I mean to say there is no collection of dust in a shape requiring it to be cleared away.

2,429. (The Coroner.) Do you mean that at the bottom of the shaft there is no such collection of dust as requires to be cleared away? — Never.

Adjourned for a short time.

2,430. (Mr. Wright.) In the mine you use both Clanny, Davy and Jack lamps? — Yes.

2,431. The Clanny for all hewers, and the people employed on the face of the workings? — Yes ; the Clanny is usually for the men, and nearly all men have Clanny's — a greater proportion of them have Clanny's.

2,432. What kind of men have the Davy's? — The shot-firers, for instance, carry Davy's.

2,433. Do the overmen and deputies carry Davy's? — At choice.

2,434. They have their choice between the Clanny or the Davy? — Yes.

2,435. Who carry Jack's? — The greater part of the deputies have Jacks.

2,436. Why should they have Jack's? — Well, the Jack's has only recently been introduced. We gave it to the deputies first.

2,437. As an experiment? — Not so much as that the Jack gives a better light, and the deputy requires it.

2,437a. Is it as safe as the Davy? — Safer.

2,438. And gives a better light? — Yes.

2,439. What are the objections to the Jack? — I have never raised any.

2,440. Then why not use it if it is both safe and gives a better light? — The reason is that boys could not have them. You have a glass round them. You could not give them to a boy who uses a lamp in a more rough manner.

2,441. Supposing that applies to the boys, why not give it to the men if it is both a safer and a better light? — The men use Clanny's.

2,442. Why do not they have Jacks if the Jacks are safer? — I did not say that they were a better light than the Clanny,

2,443. You said that they were safer, and gave a better light than the Davy. You say that they do not give so good a light as the Clanny? — Not so good.

2,444. Why not give the Clanny to the boys? — Because all lamps that have glass about them are not so well adapted. The lamps are more stationary in the case of the men. The putter boy always has the lamp in his hands.

2,445. Why do not you give the deputies Clanny's if the Clanny's are safer and give a better light than the Jacks? — Because it is popularly supposed that a Davy lamp is better than a Clanny.

2,446. In what respect is it better? — It is supposed that it is easier to see the presence of gas of a small quantity with the Davy than with the Clanny.

2,447. I am not asking about the Clanny, I mean the Jack? — The Jack is simply a Davy, with a certain adaptation.

2,448. (The Coroner.) It is, in fact, an improved Davy? — It is a Davy lamp to all intents and purposes.

2,449. If it is a Davy lamp to all intents and purposes, how does it give more light? — Because you get a light on all sides. The glass is a shield, but you can see through it.

2,450. Then it is not a Davy — it is a Davy substituting glass for wire? — No, it is not. The Davy lamp has a wire shield, and the glass lamp has a tin shield.

2,451. That is the whole difference? — It represents an ordinary Davy so far as the case is concerned.

2,452. There are 900 Clanny's in the colliery? — Yes.

2,453. And about 450 Davy's? — Yes.

2,454. And about 150 Jacks? — Probably there would be. I cannot speak exactly.

2,455. Are the lamps examined every morning in this mine? — Yes.

2,456. Before each shift?

2,456a. (The Coroner.) The lamps are expected to be examined — you cannot say that they are positively? — I may say that the lamps are examined.

2,457. You can speak from your knowledge? — Yes.

2,458. (Mr. Wright.) Before each shift? — Before each person goes in.

2,459. Who examines them? — In the case of the hewers and the boys a deputy examines the lamps.

2,460. And in the case of the other men? — In the case of the lads, very frequently the overman examines their lights.

2,461. Who takes the Clanny's to pieces? — The men take them to pieces.

2,462. Every day? — Every day.

2,463. And put them together again? — The lamps are taken to pieces by the men. Every part is brought to the deputy. The gauze is taken out and the case is taken out, and the two leather washers are taken out, and they are brought to the deputy. The deputy examines each portion of the lamp, and finds that the case is good and the washers are good, and he gives them to the man, and he puts them together again.

2,464. Who sees that the gauze is properly fitted on to the bottom? — The deputy. As soon as the lamp is put together, it is brought back to the deputy, who gives it a further examination, and the bottom of the lamp is screwed on, and the deputy takes it, and he blows the glass both top and bottom.

2,465. Before he blows is the Clanny lighted or not lighted? — Yes, the bottom is always lighted. The man keeps his bottom.

2,466. What does the deputy do in blowing? — He blows his mouth to the gas all the way round, and if he can make any air go between the gauze and the rings — you can tell directly by the flame whether you can or cannot. If he makes any air to pass, he sends the lamp back again.

2,467. To whom? — To the man, and it is taken to pieces again.

2,468. Are the men provided with washers? — Yes.

2,469. Who keeps the washers? — There are two washers for each lamp.

2,470. They are not always used in the lamp? — They are invariably used.

2,471. You always put washers on, whether the lamp is reported defective or not? — When a new lamp is brought to the colliery it is fitted with leather washers.

2,472. Are there any elastic washers. Supposing a lamp is found defective at the junction, what is done? — It is taken to pieces and screwed up against the leather washer at the top and bottom. It is made hermetically tight.

2,478. Can it be made hermetically tight with a leather washer? — Yes.

2,474. How many deputies would there be at each shift examining these lamps? Would all the deputies be employed upon it? — All the deputies examined lamps.

2,475. Would all the deputies examine lamps every day? — Yes, the deputies every day would examine lamps.

2,476. There are about 40 or 50 deputies? — Yes.

2,477. Each deputy would have to examine 18 lamps every day — about 18 Clanny's each? — The whole of those lamps are not in use. They do not examine all the lamps. The deputies examine the coal-hewers' lamps.

2.478. Why not examine all the lamps? — Because it is not convenient.

2,478a. Convenient! What has that to do with it? — There are other men employed.

2,479. Who examines them? — The overmen.

2,480. There are only five overmen? — But there are the back overmen and the master-shifters.

2,481. And only eight back overmen in the mine, and that does not make above sixty to examine them? — Yes, there are more. There are the four overmen and the eight back overmen, eight master-shifters and the master-wasteman.

2,482. Where are the regulations about the examination of the lamps? — They are in the special rules.

2,483. How many lamps is one person supposed to examine in a day? — I don't know that it is fixed upon a number at all. It does not matter how many lamps he has to examine; he examines them until they are safe.

2.484. It might take an hour to examine the lamps? — It might.

2,486. You have no idea how long? — It takes about an hour or forty minutes.

2,486. How many in forty minutes? — 15 or 16 lamps, at the outside, I should say.

2,487. But all the lamps, whether of hewers or anybody else, are examined by an overman, a backoverman, and a master-shifter every day? — Every day by a person properly appointed for the same, undoubtedly.

2,488. Do you happen to know who were stationed about the Polka turn? — Well, I know there was a man found there — a man who was dead.

2,489. Who was he? — Anthony Ramshaw.

2,490. What lamp had he? — A Clanny.

2,491. No open light? — A Clanny lamp — no open light.

2,492. Was his lamp locked? — Yes.

2,493. Was it found locked with his body? — Yes.

2,494. All the lamps are locked before given out? — No, they are locked when examined. They cannot be locked until they are examined.

2,495. But before they are given to the men to take into the mine, they are locked? — No.

2,496. At what place are they locked? — They are locked at the stations.

2,497. There is a station in each district? — Yes.

2,498. And the man carries his lamp unlocked to his own working? — Yes; naked lights are allowed in some places.

2,499. What lights do the horse keepers carry? — Glass lanterns.

2,500. Naked lights? — Yes.

2,501. Everywhere outside the caution boards, the naked lights are used? — They are not all used, but they are allowed.

2,502. Where are the caution boards placed? — Take No. 1 pit first; the far-off caution board is about this point (pointing).

2,503. Would naked lights be allowed beyond there? — Not beyond.

2,504. That is about 400 yards from the far-off end? — More than that.

2,505. It is close to the far-off furnace? — 30 yards off.

2,506. No naked light is allowed further south or east? — No further south, but more east.

2,507. That is the way to No. 3 east (pointing). The next caution board is here; it is at the out-bye end — the east end? — It is "east land."

2,508. Then in No. 3 Hutton? — There is another caution board here (pointing).

2,509. The naked lights are allowed the whole way from the down-cast shaft, as far as the far-off end junction, and, of course, further in; but I am particularly asking about the whole way — about the far-off and the junction. How far are they allowed to go in the No. 3 Hutton, roughly. Are they allowed far up? — The caution board to the west is here (pointing).

2,510. How do you describe that point? — It is at the bottom of the incline landing, about 30 yards west of the pit, No. 5.

2,511. Well, then, Hutton seam, south way; how far is the caution board there? — I am uncertain about that.

2,512. Then about the main coal staple? — Yes, it is along the Hutton seam, south way — about the main coal staple ; the in-bye side of the main coal staple.

2,513. Here is a place called the Hutton seam, southway landing, where there seem to be about a dozen bodies (pointing to plan)? — Yes, 13 bodies.

2,514. Were naked lights allowed at that part? — I think not, but I would not like to be certain.

2,515. The place is close by the main coal staple? — Yes.

2,516. Now take the Maudlin seam? — The Maudlin caution board is at that point (pointing).

2,517. What are the letters there (pointing)? — That is where some men were found.

2,518. Can you read the numbers? — 128 to 133, and 134 to 135.

2,519. And the caution board was about that point? — Yes.

2,520. On the north Maudlin? — The caution-board was in that place to the best of my recollection.

2,521. (The Coroner.) What is the locality where those bodies were found? — The out-bye end of the Maudlin incline bank head, and the caution board was in the east way in the Maudlin seam — the out-bye end of the north landing in the Maudlin.

2,522. (Mr. Wright.) Then naked lights were allowed over nearly the whole of the Maudlin? — Yes, down the waggon-way.

2,523. In fact, over every part of it except the part where the long wall face was? — No, along this point (pointing). All from that point, wherever the air went there were locked lamps.

2,524. Then I will alter the question. Naked lights were allowed in the incline in the east Maudlin until within 200 yards of the end of it? — Well, about 250 yards from the end.

2,525. But not in the returns? — No, not in the returns.

2,526. Naked lights were allowed in the north Maudlin until about 200 yards from the end, but not in the returns? — From the 300 to 350.

2,527. Just tell me this. At the place at the Polka turn where these men were, did not you say naked lights were allowed? — Yes.

2,528. But the man that you found had his lamp locked. Why would that be? — Because he would be on the night shift.

2,529. Are all the lamps locked in the night shift, whether in the intake or returns? — Yes, there is a man at the shaft bottom for that purpose.

2,530. So that the naked lights would be used only in the working shifts? — Yes, that is all.

2,531. Now confine yourself to the night shifts alone. Are there any parts of the colliery at all in which no naked lights were allowed in the night shift? — The only parts in which they would be allowed would be the shaft bottom and the stables.

2,532. The shaft bottom extends how far from the shaft? — Five yards.

2,533. Which stables? — All the stables would have glass lamps, as far as I remember off hand. The in-bye Maudlin would not have naked lights.

2,534. All the stables except the in-bye Maudlin stables would have naked lights? — Yes, I am not sure about that in-bye, but I think they do not.

2,535. Why should naked lights be allowed in the stables when not allowed in the in-takes? — It is not that they are not allowed in the in-takes, but for convenience and for safety's sake. On the night shift the master shifter looks at the lamps as near the shaft as possible, because he has to shut them, and as a matter of precaution they lock all the lamps. It is not because the lamps are more unsafe, but on that account that I have given. It is not because they are more unsafe in the night than in the day time, but because of the reason I have given.

2,536. Has any gas been seen in the stables? — No.

2,537. Where is the air-compressing engine? — It is at bank.

2,538. Oh, yes, I ought to have put it in this way. What engine does the air-compressing engine work? — Two.

2,539. Where are they? — One stands here (pointing). That is in the in-take of the No. 1 Hutton pit, east side, third east.

2,540. Are naked lights used there at the outside of the caution board? — They would be used; you could see them.

2,541. Where was the other engine? — Further inbye, by the side of the caution board.

2,542. Were naked lights used there? — No, certainly not.

2,543. Now, if you please, we will come to the principal other matter that I have to ask you about. I want you now, Mr. Stratton, to go over the mine on that plan, and tell me what you observed on examining the mine after the explosion. I am not going to ask you to express any opinion as to the cause of the explosion. You understand that? — Yes.

2,543a. Have you been down along the in-take into No. 1 Hutton seam since the explosion? — Yes.

2,544. You went in soon after the explosion? — As soon as I could get.

(The Coroner.) I thought you were going to leave that until we got straight through?

(Mr. Edge.) It would be better to take things right on end.

(Mr. Wright.) We might not coincide as to the reasons. I do not want to ask him his opinion as to the cause of the explosion.

(The Coroner.) If there is any reason to get from Mr. Stratton as to the exploration, I should not say that you should not go on; but if there is such a reason, I agree with Mr. Edge that it should not be taken.

(Mr. Wright.) I will not argue the question with you, sir. I fully concur with your views. The only point is that in dealing with the facts of the explosion the memory is apt to get much fainter as time goes on, and as the points of the case develop themselves, sometimes facts assume a different aspect from what they do before the points of the case fully develop themselves. As regards the facts, I think we should get the early impressions of the witnesses.

(The Coroner.) I agree, but that would apply to all the witnesses.

(Mr. Wright.) I agree with that. I think that the recollection of the witnesses as to the explosion should be first taken.

(The Coroner.) That is the very reason that I got the witnesses together as soon as I could possibly get them.

(Mr. Wright.) You fully appreciate the reason why I wish to take this course?

(The Coroner.) I have the witness's deposition here.

2,545. (Mr. Wright.) I shall not be long with him. (To the witness): Coming down one pit, what was the first thing you saw as the effect of the explosion? — The first thing I took particular notice of was this, that the shaft was damaged — what they call the fencing — the lattice work was damaged.

2,546. That is the down-cast? — Yes ; it was damaged from south to north.

2,547. From south to north? — It was bulged in from south to north.

2,548. What was bulged in? — The iron lattice work was bulged in, and the greater portion of the debris was lying in that direction — from south to north.

2,549. I suppose you yourself went along the intake? — Yes; I have been all over it.

2,550. When you first went down you went along the intake? — Yes. Do you mean that I should go through the statement?

2,551. (The Coroner.) Begin at the top of the shaft? — I found when I was sent for a considerable amount of dust at the top of the pit.

2,552. Coal dust or what? — It might be dust or soot. We did not take much time to consider.

2,553. (Mr. Wright.) Of course, in the pits everything was blown about? — Yes.

2,554. You found the lattice work damaged on both sides? — I afterwards found that. You asked me what I first saw. I saw it blown from south to north.

2,555. Afterwards did you see any reason to come to a different conclusion? — Not a different conclusion, but other things affected the opinion. I found that the shaft was damaged from north to south.

2,556. Did you find any falls along the intake? — Do you wish to go right through my evidence?

(The Coroner.) I think you had better give the account.

(Mr. Wright.) I feel the awkwardness of this.

(The Coroner.) Give the account, and any questions that strike Mr. Wright or myself, we shall put to you.

2,557. (Mr. Wright to witness.) Begin at the bottom of the shaft and go southwards? — The first thing I came to was the tubs in that shaft-siding.

2,558. (The Coroner.) What part is that? — No. 1 shaft.

2,559. What part did you find the tubs first? — That was not the first part that I saw. I am now following Mr. Wright's question No. 1.

2,560. I want you to go down the pit and see the signs of damage, and which direction? — We really came down No. 3 pit.

2,561. Tell us what you did in going down, where you went down, and give us the state and condition of the things?

2,562. (Mr. Wright.) Take the order which the Coroner suggests, and begin with the shaft that you first went down? — We went down No. 3 pit shaft some time in the afternoon of the day of the explosion, and we went down that shaft, and we went along the Maudlin kip, and the other thing we came to was the Maudlin doors. We found those doors had been blown towards No. 3 pit shaft. Then we went through those doors, and we found the large fall just there at the junction close to the doors of the engine shaft. We went past that fall, and we found the road comparatively free, and the first thing that struck me particularly was the fact that we came across a man. That was No. 1.

2,563. (Mr. Wright.) Do you mean a body? — Yes.

2,564. (The Coroner.) Alive or dead? — Dead.

2,565. (Mr. Wright.) Is it marked on the map dead? — Yes.

2,566. (The Coroner.) What was the position? — It was parallel to the road about a foot and a half to the rear.

2,567. I want to know the locality? — About 50 yards from the Maudlin doors.

2.568. (Mr. Jones.) Towards the Maudlin? — Towards the Maudlin; and then we went on to the curve leading to No. 1 pit, and we saw another body.

2,569. (The Coroner.) Now, as you were going along, did you notice the state of the timber and the wreckage, or only the bodies? — There was not much to see there; but at the junction where we found number two body, that is, William Simpson, we found the tail rope shield, and also frames were blown up towards No. 3 pit shaft. Then we went round the curve towards No. 1 pit, and we found a heavy fall at the end of the curve and close to No. 1 pit (pointing to map). And then we went down to look at the furnace — the first thing we did.

2,570. Did you find any wreckage there? — Nothing particular. We went down to the furnace then, and we found the furnace doors blown in towards the furnace.

2,571. (Mr. Edge.) Which furnace? — No. 1 pit furnace.

2,572. (The Coroner.) The doors were blown how? — Towards No. 1 pit furnace.

2,573. Will you point out the direction of that — where they were blown? — They were blown in that direction (pointing). We found the furnace man lying in front of his furnace.

2,574. Was he burnt at all? — He was very much burnt, but he had been removed from where he first was when I got there.

2,575. You did not see him at the point where he was first found? — No. The Harvey men found him, and then we went back to look at No. 2 boilers along the return, and we found No. 2 boiler fires still alight, and nothing the matter with it much.

2,576. Were the boilers damaged at all? — Not that I know of.

2,577. (Mr. Wright.) Had No. 1 furnace been blown out? — Yes; there was no fire. It appeared as if the fire had been blown half out.

2,578. Were the coals blown away? — Yes.

2,579. (The Coroner.) If we get witness through the whole district, I think it would be better? — Then I went so far along the return edge.

2,580. Which direction? — North. I went along the return to where the caution board stands, and I saw the caution board uninjured. The we came back and went over the large fall — the fall in No. 1 shaft.

2,581. That is the fall you have spoken of before? — Yes.

2,582. (Mr. Wright.) Follow it down, showing how you went? — Then we came across another fall near the shaft, and got near the shaft bottom, and found some men there, Laverick among them.

2,583. You spoke of another fall — what position was that fall in? — About 15 yards from the shaft, to the best of my recollection.

2,584. From the shaft to the north of it, in the main or the return? — in the intake. Then we made arrangements to send Laverick out of the mine, and from there we went into No. 1 boiler.

2,585. Will you trace that on the plan? — Yes (tracing it). We then went into No. 1 boiler, and we found a standing fire there.

2,586. (Mr. Jones.) Where is No. 1 boiler? — There (pointing). As soon as I saw the standing fire, I thought of putting it out. We had nothing with us at all. There were only four or five of us — Mr. Lishman, Mr. Atkinson, and Mr. Bailes, and others, and I went back to get some extincteurs sent down.

2,587. You then went to bank again? — Yes; and I took Laverick to bank with me.

2,588. Leaving who? — I left Mr. Lishman, and Mr. Atkinson, and Mr. Bailes.

2,589. You mean the assistant inspector, Mr. Atkinson? — Yes.

2,590. How far on that occasion did you penetrate? — No further in that pit, at the moment; but I went down again very shortly, because the thing was serious.

2,591. Go on. When you got down again what happened? — When I got down again, we went back to the same point were the boilers were.

2,592. And then, further, where did you go to? — I should here explain that at first it was a very anxious and trying time with me, and I was upon my legs for a very long time, and saw a great many things, and the order of them was rather difficult to remember. I had some trouble to put them into the proof of my evidence, and they are all there.

2,593. Are they made from any minutes? — They are taken from records. I went to the bank.

2,594. Are there any memoranda of what you saw yourself? — They are all from memoranda, and I can speak for their accuracy.

2,595. Cannot you tell us now? — It would puzzle me, and I should make some clerical errors, which might give the appearance of not speaking the truth.

2,596. You might have the memoranda to go on with? — I have not them.

(Mr. Wright.) If the witness says that all that he recollects is in that proof, it is all there.

(Mr. Jones.) This reference to the proof will assist his memory.

(Mr. Wright.) I am quite certain, in fact, we are all perfectly certain that you (addressing witness) will not tell us anything that you believe to be incorrect but I agree with Mr. Coroner, if that is all that it is to come to, that if the witness's evidence would be a simple repetition of what appears in his proof, it is no use to go into it.

(Mr. Jones.) Except the reference to the proof; combined with the question, would assist his memory.

(Mr. Wright.) If that is substantially what is in the proof, I do not know for my purpose that I want anything more.

(The Coroner.) I do not know what your purpose is. I prefer to have a witness examined from word of mouth.

(Mr. Wright.) So do I.

(The Witness.) But you must make some allowance for me. I am not going on an ordinary time.

(The Coroner.) I can go with you there, Mr. Stratton, because I remember a gentleman telling me that he remembered nothing as to the state of affairs down the pit, in consequence of the tremendous disaster that had occurred.

(The Witness.) I am perfectly certain that all that is in that proof of my evidence is correct.

2,597. But I would rather have your examination on memoranda made at the time? — I made none at the time; I had not time to write or do anything else.

(Mr. Bell.) There was a report from the cabin every hour?

(The Witness.) For the first twenty-four hours there was no record at all. We had not got the thing into a system then.

(The Coroner.) Continue your evidence.

(The Witness.) I went down with the fire extincteurs, and I went to the bank with Laverick.

2,598. (The Coroner.) You took Laverick up? — Yes, when I went for the extincteurs.

2,599. You remained in the mine until three o'clock in the morning? — Yes.

2,600. During the time you traversed the workings in the neighbourhood of the bottom of the shaft, you saw other men lying dead? You say (reading), "The men were engaged in putting out the fires (which were both at No. 1 boiler-house and No. 1 engine-house, and No. 1 staple), by means of extincteurs and hand-pumps, and whilst so engaged, you examined the workings as far as you could for the after-damp." I want to know those portions of the workings, can you tell me the direction? Tell us what you found, so as to give the direction after the explosion came there? — That has been all acquired after those days.

2,601. Cannot you tell us how you found things lying along the way? — The first two days you could not get far.

2,602. As far as you could? — I could tell you so far. I remember going in towards No. 1 engine-room, when they were putting the fire out and going up the road. The first thing I fell in with was the body of James Dotchin.

2,603. Could you speak as to whether he was burnt or not? — I could not, he was blown to pieces.

2,604. Can you point out the point where that was? — Here (pointing). This is No. 1 pit; it is south of the shaft of the No. 1 pit.

2,605. In the returns? — In the in-takes — the waggon-way. He was in the far end of the No. 1 shaft sign.

2,606. All blown to pieces? — Yes; about 30 yards further in-bye there was a pony and a set of empty tubs that he was bringing up to the bank, and I presume that he was with his pony.

2,607. Do you mean that the explosion carried him the distance between where you found the pony and where he himself was found? — That is what I conclude.

2,608. That is a different thing from "the conclusion." You conclude, from the position you found him and the pony in, that he had been blown in that direction? — Yes; the pony was jammed sideways against the tubs, and I concluded that he was blown from his natural place, which would be beside his pony.

2,609. Go on? — We went further in-bye until we came to the first overcast in the road. That was this one (pointing); and we found the overcast completely blown out, and the trucks were blown right and left — a very large number of them were blown in that direction north, and the greater part of the trucks were 15 or 20 yards north of the overcast.

2,610. Did you go further in? — I came into the engine-house, and at that time, when I got into the second door, they had drawn a canvass brattice, and it forced the air into the engine-house. I was not further up at that time.

(The Coroner.) Have we got him as far as we want him, Mr. Wright, up to the present time?

(Mr. Wright.) I confess that they are not much use. Mr. Stratton says he quite honestly thinks that he cannot go on beyond what he stated in his proof.

2,611. (The Coroner.) His proof does not go as far as I should like. The way I read it, it has reference more to clearing the place and getting it into order, and getting the fires out? — The proof stops short of anything further than the first day.

2,612. Begging your pardon, I want an account of the wreckage, but here in your proof you give only what you did to extinguish fires and put things right again. I will rend it (reading). "The men were engaged in explorations, and came across in No. 1 stables fire, which they put out by means of the "extincteurs." This relates only to what took place after the explosion. This is not what you want. This has nothing to do with what was the cause of the explosion, but what they did to get it right again?

2,613. (Mr. Wright.) I will just take No. 3 Hutton seam, and the witness will answer as shortly as he can conveniently what were the principal indications that he has noticed at any time as to whether the blast went into or out of the south Hutton seam. It went into the south Hutton seam? — It went into the south Hutton seam, I would conclude, because these two overcasts are blown out.

2,614. The only two overcasts going in? — There is one there as well, but these two were blown out.

2,615. The two overcasts at the point where the 13 bodies were found? — They were blown out, and beyond a small fall about 20 yards up southwards, and beyond that there is no further damage done.

2,616. That is the principal cause which makes you think that the blast came into the south Hutton seam? — And the fact that live men got out there.

2,617. Now, as regards No. 3 Hutton seam incline, what are the indications, as you have seen them? — That incline wheel is blown 30 yards west — a large heavy body built in masonry.

2,618. That was blown in? — Yes.

2,619. Was there any turning at the end? — None whatever.

2,620. The western end? — None whatever.

(The Coroner.) We are doing what we said we could not do — we are getting to the cause of the explosion.

(Mr. Wright.) I have done with one district; I will go through the others quite as fast.

(The Coroner.) Do not go into the cause of the explosion.

2,621. (Mr. Wright.) What are the main indications as to going in or out of the Maudlin seam? — The main indication is that a piece of 134 yards of arching in the Maudlin seam was knocked down, and in that arching five tail rope shields spiked to the wall, and three of those were left in and two were blown out.

2,622. Out-bye? — No; they were blown in-bye, because they were found in the north side in the corresponding holes where the spikes had been.

2,623. (The Coroner.) They were not blown in towards the Maudlin seam? — Yes; they were blown in 5 yards each — the two that were not. The remaining three were inclined over as if the spikes had received a shock.

2,624. (Mr. Wright.) Is there any other principal indications as to which way the blast went into or out of the Maudlin seam? — The roof had all fallen and made it a little guide, and the blast had stopped at the inclined landing.

2,625. There were two men along there? — Yes.

2,626. And in the east Maudlin were there any principal indications? — So far as I could judge from the direction of the timber, I should say that the timber had gone in. I think they were very slight.

2,627. Without asking anything about the cause of the explosion, the substance of what you have told us comes to this — that, in your judgment, the direction of the blast was into each one of these three districts? — Which three?

2,628. The Maudlin, the third Hutton, and the No. 1 Hutton? — I did not say that.

2,629. That is not the fair conclusion from your evidence. As regards the Maudlin and No. 3, you say yes? — Yes.

2,630. And as regards one part of No. 1, you say the indications were ---? — You have not asked me about that.

2,631. No, I have not. What are the principal indications as regards No. 1 Hutton? — Do you mean going right through?

2,632. Give us all that you have seen — the principal indications as to where the blast went into? — Do you mean me to give indications opening from the shafts?

2,633. Every principal indication beginning at the shaft? — I shall commence again. I found that the fencing — the lattice work — of the shaft was blown out, and, as I said, the principal portion of the debris and the principal portion of the timber looked as if it had been blown in that direction, and I came to here (pointing), and I said that I assumed that Dotchin had been with his pony, and he was 20 or 25 yards out-bye away from his pony; and then we came to this overcast, and that over-cast was blown out.

2,634. And the first over-cast was blown out? — Yes; and the main body of those bricks was on the north side of the over-cast.

2,635. In the in-take? — Yes, some great distance off. At this point, about 30 yards from the overcast (pointing), we began to find hay, and this hay kept in all the way. There is a junction of the in-takes all the way to where the stables are, and the lying hay came in there (pointing), and we know that the hay-board was there.

2,636. What is a hay-board? — A place where the hay is kept, and it appeared to me to be blown in that direction, and it was also blown inwards about 90 yards.

2,637. One moment. Is there only one hay-board in all those stables? — Only one hay-board for all those stables.

2,638. No hay-board for those stables (pointing)? — The west stables — the hay-board is in the middle, and that hay was untouched by the fire or anything else. The hay was there always. This hay (pointing) was all burnt.

2,639. There was hay all between the two sets of stables? — There was hay all the way there (pointing).

2,640. All the way from the first crossing? — From the first crossing to here (pointing).

2,641. And was there none of this southwards to the second station? — Not an atom of hay.

2,642. (The Coroner.) Give us the further damage? — Well, I could not, without going minutely into it. The general impression was that the blast had come outwards.

2,643. (Mr. Wright.) From which point directly? — Not any that I can be certain about.

(The Coroner.) Point us out on the plan, and then afterwards give us the description of the points at which you found things coming in either way.

(Mr. Wright.) I can shorten it, I think. From what the witness has said, taking the Polka way, which is marked here on the map (pointing) — from there all the indications are, in your judgment, that it went in-bye?

2,644. (The Coroner.) And up to the Polka way all out-bye. Is that correct? — There are out-bye indications from the Polka way.

2,645. (Mr. Wright.) Between the Polka way and the second west stables, how were the indications? — They were outwards.

2,646. All of them? — I saw none inwards, and I saw some outwards.

2,647. In your judgment, where would be the dividing line of the indications? — Somewhere about the Polka way.

(Mr. Jones.) I would like to ask whether the proof referred to of the witnesses' evidence is proposed to be put in as evidence.

(The Coroner.) Which?

(Mr. Jones.) What the witness has referred to.

(The Coroner.) No.

2,648. (Mr. Wright.) Did I understand you that you do not profess to give us all that that you know, but only the main indications? — Yes.

2,649. It is only fair to say that you may not be accused afterwards.

2,650. (The Coroner.) The main directions as far as the Polka pit is concerned, were outwards from that point? — To a great extent they were inward.

(Mr. Wright.) Now as to whether the bodies were burnt in the mine.

(The Coroner.) I want witnesses to prove where bodies were burnt, and where they were killed by after-damp. Is there any difference between you two?

(Mr. Edge.) Not the slightest.

(Mr. Jones.) I should suggest that the chart should be made out showing the difference.

(Mr. Edge.) I think Mr. Stratton has marked them.

(The Witness.) No, I have not marked them. I will give it as far as I am able to give it.

2,651. (Mr. Bell.) You said some of the men? — Yes.

2,652. (Mr. Wright.) You say men's bodies burned, is this so far as you know. "Hunter, John, brakesman?" — He was burned there (indicating).

2,653. How is he numbered in that map? — 25.

(Mr. Jones.) Could we not take them in the different districts?

(Mr. Wright.) Then, "Stenton, horse-keeper."

(The Coroner.) If Mr. Stratton points out the burnt ones, it would be better.

2,654. (Mr. Wright.) Then, "Weires, John, deputy; one Hutton?" — These are all men who were blown to pieces.

(Mr. Jones.) I should say burnt or injured.

(Mr. Wright.) I am not asking him anything about injured, but about burning. Stenton and Alexander were 8, 9, and 10.

2,655. (The Coroner.) Were 8, 9, and 10 burned? — I cannot tell. They were much damaged indeed; there were few cases that you could tell by looking at them.

2,656. (The Coroner.) Point out the positions? — Hunter was burnt, and Brown was burnt, and those were the only two men burned.

2,657. (Mr. Bell.) Give the numbers on the plan corresponding with the name? — John Hunter, 25.

2,658. (The Coroner.) Who was the next man? — Brown is the only man personally that I know of.

2,659. You only know of those two. Give me the position of those two? — The one at No. 1 furnace, and the other the Maudlin engine plane. The first named I saw.

2,660. Do you know where Hindson was? — There is some difficulty about Hindson.

2,661. You believe there was some mistake about it. You cannot say, therefore, whether he was burnt? — I am morally certain he was burnt.

2,662. Do you know Mr. Hindson? — That requires some explanation. I am afraid there was a mistake in the identification.

2,663. Then of course you cannot say where he was found? — I am morally certain.

2,664. Where was he supposed to be found? — Here (pointing) No. 23. Since that time we found the face of the watch of the man that was there, and we now know that it belonged to Thomas Lowdy. The two men were similar enough to be taken for one another in a state of mutilation.

2,665. Whoever it was, was that man burnt? — Not that I know of.

2,666. Where was Lowdy supposed to be originally? — Here (pointing); and at that point we found a portion of Hyde's snuff-box.

2,667. That is where the 13 men were — Hutton seam south-way? — Yes.

2,668. In what state were the remaining 12 men? — They were killed by the after-damp.

2,669. The thirteenth man, whoever he was, was much damaged? — He must have been much damaged.

2,670. (The Coroner.) Where were those twelve men, do you know — where would they be at work at the time of the explosion? — Up in the face.

2,671. Where would Hindson be? — Hindson was working here (pointing) but his tool was just here (pointing).

2,672. Who is the other man you mistook him for? — Lowdy was a deputy. He had written his report, and he should have been going in-bye — that is where I should expect to find him too.

(The Coroner.) That makes it clear.

(Mr. Jones.) Do you propose to carry Mr. Stratton's evidence any further.

(Mr. Wright.) Mr. Bell may have a question to ask.

(Mr. Bell.) I should like to know who the men were, that were burnt.

(Witness.) I only know of two positively.

(Mr. Wright.) John Hunter and James Brown.

(Witness.) Those are the only two that I know of.

(The Coroner.) If you get the position of the burnt men, will it matter about the names.

(Mr. Bell.) It does not matter so much about the names. I think it would be safer to divide them, showing whether they were in the blast or not.

2,673. (Mr. Wright.) Can you distinguish them? — Yes, I think I can do that.

2,674. (The Coroner.) Some of the men were killed by fire, and some were killed by the shock, and some by the after-damp? — I can tell you off-hand.

2,675. We want the positions of these men? — I can tell the positions within a trifle.

2,676. Will you prepare a little chart? — Yes.

2,677. It will save time if you will let us have it to-morrow morning? — Yes.

2,678. (Mr. Edge.) I presume you were in bed, when you were called to the pit on this morning of the 8th of September? — Yes.

2,679. Which pit did you go to? — No. 1 pit.

2,680. You found the cages fast? — Yes.

2,681. Did you try No. 2 shaft? — Yes.

2,682. The cage was fast there? — Yes.

2,683. The rapper ropes were broken? — All broken apparently.

2,684. Then you sent for Mr. Gorbett? — Yes.

2,685. The principal viewer? — Yes.

2,686. Then you went to No. 3 pit? — Yes.

2,687. And you sent for the enginemen? — Yes.

2,688. Did you bring the cage of No. 3 pit to bank? — Yes.

2,689. And you found that the guide attached to the cage was broken? — Yes.

2,690. Then you went back to Nos. 1 and 2 shafts to get a jack engine ready? — Yes.

2,691. What was the first descent which you made? — I went down on the jack engine.

2,692. You and Copeland? — Yes.

2,693. You went down about half way, and then you returned, and got two other men, who went down with you? — Yes.

2,694. You got to the main coal from the shaft by that means? — Yes.

2,695. You got off the main coal, and there you found some men standing about? — Yes.

2,696. Did you and Weatherall go down the shaft then below the main coal? — We went as far as we could.

2,697. In the loop? — In the loop.

2,698. Did you find the shaft blocked? — I found it blocked.

2,699. Between the main coal and the Hutton seam? — Yes, it was blocked.

2,700. Did you call out? — Yes, we called repeatedly.

2,701. And you got no reply? — We got no reply.

2,702. About what o'clock in the morning was it when you went down the shaft? — I think it was about six the first time.

2,703. After that you and Mr. Atkinson, the assistant Government inspector, and Mr. Leechman, and Mr. Baylis descended No. 2 pit? — Yes.

2,704. The same morning? — The same morning.

2,705. You got down to the main coal No. 2? — Yes.

2,706. Did you go on as far as the main coal staple? — Yes.

2,707. Did you find the staple all knocked to pieces? — Yes, completely.

2,708. Did you subsequently make your way to No. 3 shaft? — Yes.

2,709. Then you returned to No. 2 and went up to bank? — Yes.

2,710. Did you get a kibble fixed in No. 3? — Yes, we made arrangements for it then.

2,711. Did you go down in the kibble to the Hutton seam, No. 3 pit? — We went to No. 1 pit first, and then to No. 3.

2,712. Subsequently you came up and then went down No. 3? — Yes.

2,713. You found some men at the bottom of the shaft? — Yes.

2,714. Generally you found that there were fires going on in the bottom of the pit, which you had to extinguish? — Yes, I had to extinguish them.

2,715. Three fires, I think; and during the whole of that Wednesday, from the time you were called up to what time were you engaged in going down the pit and exploring? — There was very little exploring done till the fires went out.

2,716. What time were you engaged below doing your best to stop the fires and to save life? — I was there till three o'clock on Thursday morning.

2,717. You went down No. 1 about six o'clock in the morning on Wednesday, and from that time till three o'clock on Thursday morning you were constantly engaged about the shafts below? — Off and on; I was doing nothing else.

2,718. Did you and the volunteers who assisted you do everything in your power to save the lives of the men below? — We did.

(Mr. Wright.) If it will save trouble, we shall all express the conviction that Mr. Stratton did everything that skill and devotion could possibly suggest.

(Mr. Jones.) I can only echo what has fallen from Mr. Wright. I scarcely think it necessary, so far as Mr. Edge is concerned, for him to say another word. On behalf of the men, I am in a position to say that for the energy, industry, and kindly sympathy of Mr. Stratton through out the arduous duties he had to perform, there can be but one expression, and that is of gratification, pleasure, and gratitude. (Applause in Court.)

The witness withdrew.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print