1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
Seaham Colliery Inquest, 20th October 1880 (cont.).
Mr. T. H. M. Stratton recalled:
1,770. (Mr. Wright.) How long have you been manager of this colliery? — Six and a-half years.
1,771. What age are you? — I am twenty-nine next birthday.
1,772. Before you were manager of the colliery, were you employed in this colliery? — No, I came from Pease's colliery. I was manager there two years. Before then, I was six months in Cleveland, and the previous five years at Wearmouth.
1,773. Have you had practical experience not only as manager, but also in the more subordinate parts of the work in collieries? — I have not worked from the ranks, I have been an overman.
1,774. How long? — About three months. Taking duty for a man who was unwell; I was not regularly appointed as overman.
1,775. Have you acted as under viewer? — No.
1,776. You were an overman for three months, and the rest of the time you acted as manager? — Yes.
1,777. In the first place, I want some general information about this colliery; of course we know it is situated in the Durham coal field? — Yes.
1,778. Somewhere about the middle of it, on the coast? — Yes, not quite central, it is north central.
1,779. Not near the outcrops? — No, near the basin.
1,780. Will you give me, if you please, in your own words, a section of the mine from the surface to the sump. What is the depth of the shafts? — The depth of No. 2 shaft, the down cast, is 299 fathoms 2 feet.
1,781. About 300 fathoms? — About.
1,782. And the upcast? — The total depth of the upcast is about 270 fathoms, I should say.
1,783. Is there any part of the workings in which the depth from the surface is materially different from those figures. There might be a mountain in that part of the workings for instance? — The ground rises towards the west, and the seam there rises towards the west.
1,784. There is no material difference? — No, the thickest, I believe, is towards the sea.
1,785. Starting from the surface, what depth is the main coal from the surface? — 218 fathoms.
1,786. What are the strata from the surface to the main coal? — I think the limestone measures occupy about the first 76 fathoms.
1,787. As you go along, mention any seam of coal you pass through in getting down. The first 76 fathoms are limestone — that is very wet is it not? — There is a limestone feeder — a sand feeder upon the bottom of the limestone on the top of the coal measures, a very heavy feeder of water.
1,788. And below that? — Below that you have the coal measures. The first seam is the main coal.
1,789. Which coal measures are there below between the limestone and the main coal? — The ordinary coal measures of the district.
1,790. What is the thickness of the main coal? — Five feet six inches.
1,791. Below that, what is the next seam? — The next is the Maudlin.
1,792. What is the depth below? — Generally speaking, about eleven or twelve fathoms.
1,793. To the west of the trouble? — Yes, both sides are about the same distance.
1,794. Never mind the east side of the trouble for the moment? — The west side.
1,795. What thickness is the Maudlin? — The west side of the trouble about four feet six inches.
1,796. What is the nature of the rock between? — Between the main coal and the Maudlin I have not had any experience. The Maudlin seam has not been worked in my time, to the west of the trouble, but I should presume that it is just the ordinary type — generally speaking a blue metal.
1,797. Does the coal adhere to it? — I have had no experience in that respect; the coal has not been worked west of the trouble in my time. Judging from the east side it would not adhere.
1,798. It is not fiery at all, there is no gas in it? — I have never had a blower off the roof in this seam.
1,799. (The Coroner.) The side that you are working? — I never had any blowers here off the roof.
1,800. (Mr. Wright.) What is the floor of the Maudlin? — It varies considerably. The east side of the floor of the Maudlin is the Maudlin bottom coal, and below there is the main seam. There would be two feet of hard thill.
1,801. That is not far, I suppose? — Not that I am aware of.
1,802. What is the floor and roof of the main coal? — The main coal is a leafy post — a layery post — laminated.
1,803. Is that fiery? — Not that I am aware of.
1,804. And the floor? — It is a sort of inferior kind, of coarse segger.
1,805. That is not fiery? — Not that I know of.
1,806. Below the Maudlin, when you came to the main seam, did you tell me the distance between the two? — The west side.
1,807. (The Coroner.) Are you working the west side? — No, we are not working it.
1,808. Have you worked it? — It has been worked both sides a little, the west is not being worked at all.
1,809. (Mr. Wright.) What is the distance between the Maudlin seam and the low main seam? — About three or four fathoms on the west side — I am not quite certain.
1,810. Can you tell us the nature of the roof and floor of the low main seam? — I have not a notion, we have not worked it.
1,811. How far is it down from the low main seam to the Hutton seam, west of the trouble? — Hutton is 22 or 23 fathoms from the Maudlin; it goes up and down in a peculiar fashion.
1,812. Are there any small seams between, except the low main? — Yes, there is a small seam — about seven fathoms above the Hutton seam.
1,813. What is the roof of the Hutton, west of the trouble? — Post.
1,814. Not fiery? — I have had no blowers from the roof of the Hutton seam on the west side.
1,815. The floor? — First, there is a foot and a half of rubbish; then you get on to a sort of flat clay.
1,816. None of that is firey at all? — I could not say. I have had no knowledge of it.
1,817. Below the Hutton you get in about 27 fathoms to the Harvey? Yes.
1.818. You did not give the thickness of the Hutton? — About 3 feet 3 inches, the west side.
1,819. Twenty seven fathoms to the Harvey. How thick is that? — The Harvey has not been explored to the west of the trouble.
1,820. I suppose you know in the shaft? — About 3 feet 3 inches.
1,821. Is it a firey roof or floor? — The Harvey really was very little worked, and no person can form an idea. There were not more than a hundred yards driven in the Harvey seam.
1,822. Below that is the Busty? — Yes.
1,823. How far below? — 19 fathoms.
1,824. What is the thickness of the Busty? — About 4 feet 6 inches with the bends, but I have not seen it.
1,825. You do not know the nature of the roof or floor? — No, it has never been looked at for many years.
1,826. Are the shafts carried below the Busty? — They may be in the stone below.
1,827. You have never been to the sump? — No, it has been filled up.
1,828. With what? — With rubbish — dirt.
1,829. Above the Busty seam? — Yes.
1,830. How high above the Busty seam? — It varies at times. We draw water, and the water runs into the sump, and it often deposits mud; this gradually accumulates. The greatest depth is about 14 fathoms below the Harvey seam; when the mud accumulates it is not so large.
1,831. You do not know how high above the Busty it is filled up? — We have not been within six fathoms of it.
1,832. Is there a standage? — The shaft itself is a standage.
1,833. You say it is filled with water 14 fathoms below the Harvey? — When it is cleaned out; when the mud fills it up it is not so deep.
1,834. What height does the water stand below the Harvey, generally speaking? — That depends upon how it is pumped.
1,835-6. In the morning, when they start pumping, it is often up to the cage scaffold of the Harvey; then it is pumped down? — Yes, till the pump draws no longer.
1,837. Are there any other water standages in the mine besides that? — Yes.
1,838. Where? — We have a proper water standage in the Hutton seam. We pump from that shaft into the standage.
1,839. (The Coroner.) Which Hutton seam? — No. 3 Hutton seam.
1,840. What is the locality? — Here it is (pointing on the plan).
1,841. (Mr. Wright.) North of No. 1 pit? — North of No. 3 pit particularly.
1,842. What distance from it? — About 180 yards.
1,843. (The Coroner.) From the shaft? — From the shaft.
1,844. (Mr. Wright.) What is the water standage you have last mentioned; what is the character of it? Is it a hole dug in the ground? — The seam has been excavated — the Hutton seam — and we have walled the passage round and arched it, and it forms a place where you run water in and run it out again; we draw it at our convenience; it is done at night time.
1,845. What do you suppose are the cubical contents of that standage? — I have not calculated it, but I should think, roughly, about 2,500 cubic yards — very roughly.
1,846. What have you taken for the sides? — I have taken it to be 13 feet wide, 6 feet high, and about 300 yards long. It is never full, because the level is not sufficient to allow it to roof. It is 300 yards including all the passages.
1,847. Is that generally filled up with water? — When it is full the tail end is back to the end of these passages.
1,848. There is always a large cavity containing air and not containing water? — I should think there is.
1,849. Probably half of the whole cubic capacity? — I do not know what to say about that. When the water is up you cannot get in to examine it very well.
1,850. Did you ever examine it yourself? — Yes.
1,851. Has gas ever been found in either of these standages? — Never.
1,852. While we are on this point — it is rather out of the course — tell me, are there any other cavities or dumb places in any part of the mine that might by possibility become reservoirs of gas; I am not speaking of the goafs? — Well, I should not even call that a dumb place; it is ventilated in a proper manner, the same as the ordinary working; it is a mistake to call it a dumb place.
1,853. Is there a current of air passing through it? — Yes, the same as the other working places.
1,854. Then leave out the word "other." Are there any reservoirs in cavities or dumb places in the mine where the gas could accumulate? — I do not know of any.
1,855. Are there any cavities in the mine at all, so far as you know, whether ventilated or not, except this water standage which you told me of, and except the goafs and the return in-takes and stall-roads? — I do not exactly understand the scope of the question.
1,856. Take such a thing as the stone drift. If I had put the question plainly enough, you would have told me that there were some in the stone drift? — Yes.
1,857. Those are cavities which I have not enumerated; they may be properly ventilated; but are there any others besides those which I have mentioned — the staples, for instance? — They are properly ventilated.
1,858. I am not asking about whether they are ventilated or not; I want to know if any cavities exist? — There are the staples.
1,859. Are there any other cavities in the mine?
1,860. (The Coroner.) Any loftings either stowed or unstowed? — Yes, there may be loftings more or less; that is a thing we do not usually like, but there may be loftings.
1,861. (Mr. Wright.) Where are there any loftings? — I only remember one at this moment.
1,862. Where? — Here (pointing); in the Maudlin seam, by that trouble.
1,863. Is that over the in-take? — Over the in-take.
1,864. What would be the height of that above the floor of the lofting? — It is a good distance.
1,865. It varies from what to what, roughly? — I do not know, I am sure. I should not like to say off-hand.
1,866. Might it be 20 feet high in places? — I could not say so.
1,867. Above 10? — It might be 10.
1,868. When did you last look at it? — Not recently.
1,869. How long ago? — I could not say.
1,870. Do not suppose that I want to pin you? — I am not answering in that way — I do not remember exactly.
1,871. Not in the least? — I have not seen it within a yard.
1,872. About how long would that lofting be? — It may be altogether about twenty yards.
1,873. Not more? — I do not think more.
1,874. About how wide? — It is very narrow.
1,875. Three or four feet? — It is more than that.
1,876. From 5 to 7 feet, perhaps? — It might be about that.
1,877. How is it ventilated? — The air goes up to the top ; it is a deep place.
1,878. There is a place left for it? — Yes, it is a proper place for it, and is properly ventilated.
1,879. Do you know anybody who has examined that lately? — It is the master shifter's business to examine it.
1,880. Which? — He is lost.
1,881. You cannot tell us anybody who examined that? — I should think the overman has examined it very recently, and I should think the under-viewer too.
1,882. Do you recollect what is the nature of the roof above the lofting? — I cannot say that I examined it particularly.
1,883. Did the master shifter report the condition of the lofting in his books? — At the time he used to make a special report, but when we introduced the new form of reports common in this county, they did not mention the loftings particularly; they simply said that everything was safe ; they did not mention the loftings specifically.
1,884. You used to think it necessary to mention them specifically? — At one time.
1,885. When was that change made? — When we got the new reports.
1,886. When? — I should think about three years ago — three or four.
1,887. Since then you have never made any special report of the loftings? — No.
1,888. You cannot recollect that they were ever mentioned in any reports? — No, not by name particularly.
1,880. Can you tell me of any other loftings in the mine? — I do not remember any.
1,890. Distinctly understand that in every question I am not at all confining your attention to what is on that plan, I am talking of the whole colliery. Now, in view of that, have you anything to alter in any previous answer that you have given? — I do not remember all that I have answered.
1,891. I have taken you through the section — I suppose they are the same? — Yes.
1,892. Are there no other veins in any part of the colliery? — No.
1,893. And no water standages? — No.
1,894. I think the only other thing I have asked about is these loftings. Now, where else in the mine — you need not go into detail — where else do you know of any loftings? — I do not know of any more. I may be wrong, but I do not remember any more.
1,895. Now, direct your attention to the stone drift between the Maudlin engine and the shaft — you know what I mean? — No. 3 shaft staple.
1,896. (The Coroner.) Is that the correct description? — There is no stone drift between there.
1,897. The stone drift near No. 3 staple? — There is none there. It is the old Hutton seam, the original road of the colliery.
1,898. (Mr. Wright.) What is the name of the thing I am asking about — No. 3 staple — the furnace staple? — Yes, that is it.
1,899. Tell me the description of that? — It is the Maudlin boiler drift.
1,900. That is a smoke drift? — Yes.
1,901. What is the length of it? — About 100 yards — or more than that — 110.
1,902. What are the dimensions? — I think 4 feet — barrel arched.
1,903. What is that constructed for? — The Maudlin smoke drift — to convey the smoke from the Maudlin engine to the up-cast pit.
1,904. Is it level? — I fancy it is almost a dead level it may rise a little to the up-cast pit.
1,905. What air passes? — The Maudlin air. The air goes through the engine, and the scales from the doors.
1,906. What doors? — There are doors into the drift.
1,907. Of course you cannot recollect what happened in the Hetton Colliery in 1862 in connection with a drift like that? — No.
1,908. You know that something did happen in the Old Hetton Colliery in 1862 in connection with a stone drift like that? — No.
1,909. You know that something did happen in the Old Hetton Colliery that is now part of your colliery in connection with a stone drift of that sort — a flue? — I do not remember that. I do not know. I do not know the circumstances.
(The Coroner.) That would be entering into a very wide question.
(Mr. Wright.) It is the same colliery.
(The Coroner.) No.
1,910. (Mr. Bell.) What is the description of the flues — No. 1 boiler flues? — There are three boilers. Each one of these has a small flue coming away from the damper. These flues combine; they go into one another, and they come into a larger drift.
1,911. At what point do they combine? — It may be, I should think, about ten yards from the nearest damper that all would come together. They rise all the way from the damper to where they join about six inches to the yard.
1,912. To where? — To where they join — when they have all joined together they rise much more rapidly — about one foot to the yard.
1,913. (The Coroner.) To where? — They pass close to the down-cast shaft, then they go back level into No. 3 furnace stable.
1,914. That is a fair description of the boilers and the flue from that? — Yes, they are all barrel arched there too — at least not exactly barrel arched, but they are all arched and floored.
1,915. Is that a full description of what is required?
1,916. (Mr. Bell.) What is the sectional area? — The sectional area of each of the flues, to the best, of my recollection, is 18 inches by three feet high. Each single one is that; the main one (I may be wrong) is, I think, 4 feet arched.
1,917. Is it barrel? — Not quite barrel, it is a little sloped — I should think 4 feet 6 inches in diameter.
1,918. (Mr. Wright.) Suppose the fires to these boilers were damped down a great deal the gas would be given off into the flues? — It would not, I should think, go into the flues if damped down tight, the gas would not go into the flues.
1,919. As it is damped in practice that is not very tight? — If there was a draught through the timber, the gas would not fill it.
1,920. You say there is no gas from the boilers under ordinary circumstances coming into the flues? — Yes.
1,921. Or from any other source into the flues? — No.
1,922. Passing back for a moment to the stone drift that I asked you about before, could not gas accumulate in that by any possibility? — No, I should say it is utterly impossible; it is arched from one end to the other — properly arched; the only entrances to it are from the fresh air current.
1,923. You say that there is gas neither from the damped fires nor from anything else? — Those fires are never damped; they are raked out every night; I do not think it is possible that there could be any accumulation; the only two openings are from the fresh air current; one is through the chimney, and the other through the scales of the doors I spoke of.
1,924. You know the Maudlin engine fire is raked out? — Every night.
1,925. (The Coroner.) It is extinguished every night — is that so? — Yes, you cannot damp a portable engine.
1,926. (Mr. Wright.) Is there not a great deal of the Harvey that is dumb? — In what sense?
1,927. Without any ventilation? — There is a small portion of the Harvey workings being worked; they have a very large ventilation indeed.
1,928. Is there no part that is neither ventilated nor worked? — The old coal is neither ventilated nor worked — the working places.
1,929. (The Coroner.) Suppose gas was going off from that seam — where would it go? — It would only go to those working places.
1,930. Where would it go? — Up the same drift.
1,931. Which? — This (pointing).
1,932. No. 2 steam drift? — Yes.
1,933. If the gas did come from the Harvey it would come up there? — Yes.
1,934. Which? — The Harvey seam drift.
1,935. (Mr. Wright.) I have departed from my line of examination to complete all about the cavities, or water standages, or dumb places in the mine. I will now pass on to the general description. What you have told me hitherto has applied to the west side of the trouble? — Yes.
1,936. The trouble extends the whole way across the colliery, does it not? — The whole distance we have explored.
1,937. And the effect of the trouble is, if I understand it, that on the east side all the veins are found at a considerably lower level? — Yes.
1,938. Generally speaking? — Yes, at a very considerable lower level.
1,939. The main coal seam is sunk, how far on the east side of the trouble? — They are all sunk alike.
1,940. The main coal (taking one by one) — is that sunk 25 fathoms? — The part where we have explored at the north side of the trouble, or the east as you term it — at that point it is sunk 105 feet.
1,941. How many fathoms? — Nearly seventeen.
1,942. Then the Maudlin — is that sunk about the same quantity? — Just the same, at the same point.
1,943. The low main, as I understand, instead of sinking away like the others, just stops where it is, and gets into the Maudlin join? — Not for a long distance ; at the trouble they are all the same distance apart.
1,944. How far is it from the trouble where the Maudlin and the low main unite? — They will not be together completely for about half-a-mile.
1,945. I believe they are both of them a great deal thicker on the north-east side of the trouble than on the west side? — The low main is about the same; the Maudlin seam is a little thicker.
1,946. Then where they meet — what is the total thickness of the two? — About 10 feet.
1,947. Is the whole of that 10 feet worked? — No.
1,948. Which do you leave, the floor or the roof? — We leave the low main and the Maudlin bottom coal, we work the bottom seam simply.
1,949. Leave the bottom of the Maudlin and the whole of the low main as a floor? — Yes.
1,950. The Hutton, I suppose, is dropped about 17 or 18 fathoms also? — The same.
1,951. And the Harvey the same? — And the Harvey the same.
1,952. Do the strata dip much in this mine? — The general dip is from west to east.
1,953. Is it considerable? — It is very variable, like all dips. I think, taking the general average, you might say the dip from west to east was 1½ inches to the yard — about 1 in 24.
1,954. Do you suppose that it anywhere greatly exceeds that for any distance? — Yes; a great deal in some places. I have known the dip from west to east more than that.
1,955. How much more? — The greatest dip coming east that I have known would be about four inches.
1,956. Does that extend any considerable distance? — It would extend, it may be, from 100 yards; then it might be flat, and so on.
1,957. About the coal in these seams. What is the general character of the coal — is it fiery coal? — Yes, I suppose you would term it fiery; all the east country mines are termed fiery.
1,958. It is the same as the well-known coal everywhere south of the Tyne? — Yes, the same as other seams in collieries in the neighbourhood.
1,959. Is not the coal especially dusty? — No more so than in the neighbouring colliery.
1,960. Which of the seams are dusty — is the Maudlin dusty as well as the Hutton? — The Maudlin, I should say, is not so dusty as the Hutton seam.
1,961. Are they both very dry? — Yes, they are very dry seams.
1,962. Which is the most dry? — I would not like to say. I should think off and on they are about alike.
1,963. They are both extremely dry, are they not? — Very dry where there is no water.
1,964. In the absence of water they are extremely dry and make a great deal of dust, do they not? — Yes, I suppose you may say they do.
1,965. Are there any streaks of soft coal in these veins? — They are all termed soft coal seams.
1,966. Are there none of especially soft coal? — No, they are all soft coal seams that are worked here.
1,967. Is there much creep in the mine — much working of the roof and floor? — Creep is a technical term; we have no creep at all, the pits heave a little.
1,968. But no creep? — No creep.
1,969. Do the floors work up much? — Yes, they do; with a hard roof and a soft bottom, the floor does work up.
1,970. In the first day's evidence several men stated that they were occupied in lowering the roads; that would be, I suppose, because the floors have been raised by the pressure? — Yes.
1,971. Has that to be done to any great extent? — It depends upon the different places; sometimes it has to be done a very great deal.
1,972. What parts of the mine work most in that way? — There is no general rule for any particular part. Sometimes the district of the pit begins to heave very much, and then it may steady again for months, and there will be little difference; then it may come on again in the same way; it is according to the varying conditions of each part of the mine.
1,973. (The Coroner.) Do the lower seams or the higher seams upheave most? — The Hutton seams heave the most.
1,974. (Mr. Wright.) The floor heaves the most in the Hutton seam? — Yes.
1,975. You take away all the coal in working the Hutton? — Yes.
1,976. And in working the Maudlin you take away all the coal except the bottom Maudlin and the low main? — That is, where the two are together.
1,977. You do not work the main coal at all now? — Yes.
1,978. Not the Harvey? — Not the Harvey.
1,979. Before the explosion, was there any part of the mine in which the floor was rising particularly, or any other working taking place? — Not to which my special attention was directed, I rather fancy not. The pits have stood remarkably well as far as we have seen since the explosion.
1,980. (The Coroner.) Before the explosion you had no special upheaving reported to you? — Not particularly.
1,981. Had you any? — No; they did not report little things to me. The master shifter would report to the overman. It is not a matter that they would specially talk to me about.
1,982. (Mr. Wright.) There was nothing important enough for your attention to be called to it? — No.
1,983. Not within six months before the accident? — About the heaving?
1,984. Or moving in any part of the mine — in any part whatever, not merely what is on that plan? — No; I cannot say that my attention was ever particularly directed to it.
1,985. Now, give me a description of the way in which the mine is laid out. First of all, taking the same plane that is shown on that plan — that is the Hutton seam and the Maudlin — are there any workings on that level of the colliery besides what are shown on that plan? — None whatever on that level.
1,986. Neither on the Hutton seam at any level? — No.
1,987. Nor on the Maudlin seam at any level? — No.
1,988. Take the main coal seam — this does not show any of the workings of the main coal? — It shows a little bit of the north main.
1,989. Is the main coal worked from the same shafts as are shown on that plan? — That main coal was worked from this shaft (pointing).
1,990. At the time of the explosion? — No.
1,991. I am asking about the time of the explosion? — There was no main coal worked there — not for 15 years.
1,992. Where was the main coal worked then? — Over here (pointing).
1,993. Over No. 3 Hutton? — Yes.
1,994. And extending how far? — About the same distance that you see here — you could cover the workings with your hand.
1,995. Over No. 3 Hutton and that goaf? — Yes, somewhere there.
1,996. What shaft was that worked from? — The air was got from No. 2 pit shaft.
1,997. Will you point to the shaft? — The air was got from here (pointing) and the coals were dropped down from the staples.
1,998. Into No. 3 Hutton? — Yes.
1,999. Is that the only working of the main coal which was going on at the time of the explosion? — Yes.
2,000. I am not talking of this plan? — The whole of the colliery.
2,001. Was the low main worked anywhere else? — There has been no low main working at all.
2,002. Then with the exception of that small bit of the main coal seam, that plan does not show the whole of workings of the colliery at the time of the explosion? — Except the workings of the No. 2 pit.
2,003. Where are they? — It is a very extensive concern. The roads lie under this (pointing).
2,004. Point out No. 2? — That is No. 2 pit (pointing), the downcast.
2,005. Worked from the same shaft? — Yes, it covers the same area as the Maudlin seam, but extends much further east and west.
2,006. What seam is that? — The Hutton seam.
2,007. It is worked under the Maudlin? — Under the Maudlin.
2,008. It is much more extensive than that, and if it was drawn on that piece of paper it would extend beyond its boundaries? — Yes, it would more than cover that Maudlin seam.
2,009. What is the general description by which you call those workings? How ought one to describe them? — No. 2 pit, Hutton seam. It is locally known as the Harvey ; the men all call it the Harvey.
2,010. Then we had better call it the Harvey? — The men will know it by that name.
2,010a. Is that worked at a lower level than anything shewn on the plan? — Yes.
2,011. And is that worked by the drift communicating with the old Harvey seam? — Yes.
2,012. The old Harvey seam west of the trouble, and lifted from there — is that the case? — Yes; drawn from the downcast to the surface.
(Mr. Wright.) I suppose I may take it there is no question as to the Harvey.
(The Coroner.) I should think it was agreed that nothing happened in the Harvey.
(Mr. Jones.) I think that is so. As far as I am concerned I have no desire that Mr. Wright should pursue this.
2,013. (Mr. Wright.) I must get on the notes shortly — the arrangement of your names on the plan. First of all, take the No. 1 Hutton seam shown there — that line is to the south of the shaft? — Yes.
2,014. South and south-east of the shaft? — Yes.
2,015. The drifts were originally driven to the far-off end? — Yes.
2,016. To the further part of the goaf — is that so — Yes.
2,017. And then worked back, first of all, in what way? — It was worked in the bords first, and then on the drums.
2,018. Carried forward on the bords? — Brought back in the broken.
2,019. That is, removing the pillars? — Yes.
2,020. So that you left the goaf behind you? — Yes.
2,021. You are still, I suppose, working back the broken? — Yes; retreating.
2,022. That large goaf is gradually extending itself and closing in? — Yes.
2,023. What is the length at present of the main in-take, from the down-cast to the far-off end at the south? You have all these things on paper I suppose? — No; I was not aware they would be wanted.
2,024. Be good enough, if I am not asking too much, to give us a list on paper (it will save trouble) the lengths of all the returns and all the in-takes throughout the mine? — Yes; I could easily have done that if I had known it.
2,025. Yon will do it to-morrow? — Yes.
2,026. And also, if you please, the sectional area of the returns and in-takes at a distance of, say, 100 yards? — I could give that by to-morrow, and have to be measured.
(The Coroner.) I suppose you will want a general average?
(Mr. Wright.) No; that is exactly what we do not want.
(The Coroner.) The average — pointing out special places where there is any appreciable reduction.
2,027. (Mr. Wright.) Yes; because of course when there is a reduction it alters the current. I will write out what I want and then you can furnish it before we meet again. At present I will ask generally, what would the length of the in-take to the far-off end be — about a mile? — About a mile and a quarter.
2,028. Then take a branch in-take that goes to the east part — No. 3 east you call that? — Yes.
2,029. If the in-take goes to No. 3 east, that would be from the down-cast shaft about two and a half miles? — Oh, no; about two and a half miles to the furthest working place. I know that; I measured it the other day.
2,030. It is further if you follow the in-take from the downcast? — To the furthest working place there is it is about two and a half miles.
2,031. The Maudlin — is that longer? — No; it is a tolerably straight road — it might be a little longer.
2,032. It is about the same? — About the same.
2,033. Then, on the Maudlin in-take the length would be a mile? — About a mile and a half.
2,034. And the return about the same? — About the same.
2,035. Then No.3 Hutton — half-a-mile? — More, say three quarters of a mile from the down-cast shaft to one district — and to here (pointing), it would perhaps be half-a-mile.
2,036. In the Harvey, what would be the length of the in-take, roughly ; — About the farthest off place, it would be, I should think, about a mile and a half.
2,037. And the return about the same, or rather more? — Yes.
2,038. Here are only two shafts for the whole of the colliery, including the Harvey? — Including the Harvey.
2,039. There are five districts in the mine I understand; first, there is No. 1 Hutton and the third east? — Yes.
2,040. That is one district? — That is one district.
2,041. The No.3 Hutton forms another district? — Yes.
2,042. And the Maudlin forms a third district? — Yes.
2,043. The Harvey forms a fourth district? — Yes.
2,044. Then there are only four districts in the mine? — If you include the main coal.
2,045. That is being worked, is it? — Yes, we have what we call five pits.
2,046. That is what you call them, instead of districts? — Yes.
2,047. Then we had better call Harvey the fifth pit, and the main coal the fourth pit, I suppose? — It does not make much matter which we call it.
(Mr. Jones.) Well ; do we take that so — for the sake of reference I mean, that is all?
(Mr. Wright.) We must call them by names I am sure, or we shall get into confusion — different people will get different numbers.
2,048. Then will you give us, if you please, that paper at your leisure — full particulars of the lengths of in-takes, ret urns, and working faces, in each pit? — I must put them down.
2,049. Do not trouble about them now, we will write it out for you. I will indicate it on the notes — lengths of the in-takes, returns and working faces, you can give us those, I suppose? — Yes; the total distance the air has to travel.
2,050. In each district; and the length of working faces in each pit; and the number of persons — men and boys, employed in each pit; and the number of horses? — You want it divided into each separate district.
2,051. Yes; so far as it is divided in practice, and the quantity of air? — What I mean to say is — you do not want to add together the total working faces in No. 1 pit.
2,052. No; that is no use? — You want to get each portion of air — the distance it travels.
2,053. Yes, that is it. There would only be about three or four different working faces I suppose in No. 1 district? — Well, there are several splits. There is a split here (pointing).
(The Coroner.) That is, as to the pits upon that plan.
(Mr. Wright). And the Harvey; because it is perfectly true the ventilation had nothing to do with the explosion directly but is necessary to see that the whole quantity of ventilation is properly divided, because it is one unit.
2,054. Now as to the mode of working, Mr. Stratton — I see you had some long wall, some time? — We had it in the Maudlin seam.
2,055. The most of your mine was working on pillar and stall? — Yes.
2,056. What kind of pillar and stall? — It is just the ordinary north country road — board and pillar. We drive the board in ; it forms a square pillar, or nearly so.
2,057. What size pillars? — We leave 40 yards. The places are driven 44 yards centre to centre.
2,058. What is the width of the stall roads? — Four yards.
2,059. You do not do any of it double stall? — No.
2,060. Is the system of long wall being extended in the colliery? — No; it will not be used anywhere else but the Maudlin seam.
2,061. Is it unsuited for this locality in your judgment? — Well, not so much that as that the board and pillar is better suited.
2,062. It is not the fashion of the district merely. You think the board and pillar is better suited? — Yes.
2,063. Why — will you tell me? — Each pit requires a different system, and when you find a system works satisfactorily you do not care to alter it.
2,064. This pit does not seem to have been laid out upon any system at all. It is a mixture of a dozen different systems? — No, it is not.
2,065. It has been laid out by different managers? Yes; but there is only one system.
2,066. At present? — No, the whole time.
2,067. But as far as laying out, one man seems to have started with one idea and another with another? — I should not say so. It has been conducted upon a very regular principle.
2,068. All through? — All through, I should say.
2,069. The pit comprises the Old Hetton, does not it? — The Seaton Colliery belongs to the Seaton owners, but it was not a part of Hetton.
2,070. The present down-cast belongs to Hetton? — No, the upcast.
2,071. North Hetton? — North Hetton.
2,072. And the present up-cast to whom? — The present down-cast belonged to the late Marquis of Londonderry.
2,073. And then when it was necessary to take two shafts for each colliery, they used the two collieries together? — I fancy they were connected before the two collieries were put together — before they were one owner.
2,074. About how many people were employed in that working face? — Well, we employed about 16 men a shift here, and there would be the boys, the putters, drivers, and so on. There might be 30 men and boys as a rule.
2,075. Why do you say that the board and pillar system is better suited for this kind of mine than the long wall? — Well, I take it that long walls are better when there is a softish roof and a hard bottom. In the case of the Hutton seam we have a very hard roof and a very soft bottom.
2,076. So that it would not come down quick enough, or what? — You would find that the roof would be hanging. It would give way together, or else the bottom would heave, and cause a deal of trouble in your gateways.
2,077. (The Coroner.) Does it in any way affect the safety of the mine? — Not a jot.
2,078. Does it so far as the ventilation is concerned? — Not an atom.
2,079. (Mr. Wright.) However, in this mine you say that sufficient ventilation of the working faces can be got by this board and pillar system? — Yes.
2,080. In these seams? — Yes.
2,081. What is your output of the whole colliery, including the Harvey? — Well, its runs over 500,000 tons a year.
2,082. That would be about 2,500 tons on an ordinary working day? — Well, we have got so far as that upon an average, but we did not do it at the time of the explosion.
2,083. What were you doing then? — Not more than 2,000 tons a day.
2,084. How many colliers would there be when you were doing the 2,500 tons? — I should think that the total number of hands would be about 1,500.
2,085. How many of those would be colliers? — Hewers?
2,086. Hewers? — We had at the time of the explosion about 480 hewers.
2,087. Including the Harvey? — Including the Harvey.
2,088. I think you told me yesterday that you work the mine in three working shifts daily? — Yes, a certain portion of the mine in three shifts.
2,089. How many hours in the 24 are the working faces standing without any hewing going on? — The regular shift of hewers leaves the place at 11 o'clock, and the fore shift comes in at half-past 5 in the morning; so that it stands six and a half hours.
2,090. After the first shift ends and before the second shift begins the next morning — during that time what is being done in the working faces? — Well, of course, the shifters go in them.
2,001. And do repairs? — Do repairs.
2,092. Now for your ventilation, Mr. Stratton — that is all done by furnaces? — Yes.
2,092. You prefer those to fans, do you? — You could not possibly raise the ventilation by a fan.
2,094. Through such a length of working? — You could not get the quantity of air by any known fan that has ever been erected.
2,095. Have you got your list of the measurements of air for the last three months before the explosion? — Yes, the book is down here.
2,096. Perhaps you will give us — I will ask you for it — I will put it down for you — a list showing the quantities of air, and the distribution among the different parts of the mine. I will just get one or two general figures. About how much is the total air sent through the mine — sent down the down-cast? — I should say about 320,000 feet on an average. It is not measured in the up-cast; it is measured at the in-takes.
2,097. Not measured at the up-cast as well? — It is measured at the up-cast as well — one measurement.
2,098. (Mr. Jones.) May I ask you the quantity of air — the total quantity?
(Mr. Wright.) Including Harvey? — Well, you might say 320,000 feet on average per minute.
2,099. (The Coroner.) Mr. Stratton said in his evidence yesterday the total air.
(Mr. Wright.) That is including Harvey? — Yes; including everything — the whole of the air.
2,100. And where is this measured? — It is measured at each in-take.
2,101. Every in-take is measured. That is the in-take of each pit, is it? — Yes.
2,102. Measured anywhere else besides there? — It is measured one measurement — at the up-cast as a rule.
2,103. That of course measures the whole air that comes out of the mine? — Yes.
2,104. There is not a separate measurement of the return in each pit? — No.
2,105. Only of the in-take for each pit? — Only of the in-take for each pit.
2,106. And the water gauge is at the bottom of the up-cast? — The one we use — what you may call the official water gauge, is over the No. 1 boiler flues.
2,107. That is near the up-cast? — No; it is near the down-cast.
2,108. That is the official water gauge? — Yes. The same water gauge goes to the bottom of the pit, and it is the one that the on-setters record every hour.
2,109. Were there others? — We have different others. There is one at my house, one at the underviewer's house, and there is one at the office.
2,110. You conduct the current? — No; it is not a current — merely a lead pipe with another opening into it, and you can attach any number of water gauges.
2,110a. Are they self-registering any of them? — We have not one self-registering. The one that is recorded is at the pit bottom. The on-setter records it every hour.
2,111. Would not it be very desirable that you should have a self-registering water-gauge? — Well, I do not think it is usual.
2,112. What is the last record of the pressure immediately before the explosion. Can you tell me? — Well, it would be recorded at two o'clock, I have no doubt, but I do not think the water-gauge book has been found; at least, I never heard of it. The onsetter was Laverick.
2,113. Do you mean to say that you have not caused any search to be made for the water-gauge book? — I have not particularly.
2,114. This is a very important part of the inquiry. Has no one suggested to you that a search should be made? — No; it has not been suggested; and I have not suggested it myself either, but I dare say it is partially destroyed. It is probably not entirely destroyed. It would be in the cabin still
2,115. What cabin? — Where Laverick was.
2,116. At the bottom of the downcast? — Yes.
2,117. Is there anybody here who can tell us? — I should not think so. If it had been found, I should have heard of it.
2,118. Was the cabin destroyed? — No.
2,119. Not burnt? — No, not burnt at all.
(The Coroner.) Laverick was got out of it. He would be the best man to know it.
(Mr. Wright.) Laverick could have no right to take that book away from the cabin.
(The Coroner.) He is the man that was burnt and taken out insensible.
(Mr. Wright.) Mr. Edge, can you furnish us with that book?
(Mr. Edge.) I do not know anything about it.
2,120. (The Coroner.) You can make search for it? — I can make search for it, but I cannot guarantee to find it.
2,121. (Mr. Wright.) What person would have a right to take it away? — No person whatever has a right to take it away.
2,122. How are we to find out what the official records of the condition of the water-gauge were at 2 o'clock, immediately preceding the explosion, and for some time before that? — Well, if you do not find the book, and nobody happened to look at it at the bank, you would not be able to find out. The master wasteman was up at that hour, and he might know; but there is no particular reason why he should know.
2,123. The matter would be open to extremely serious observation if the water-gauge would not be forthcoming; Laverick could have no authority to take it away? — At the time of the explosion you would have other things to think of.
2,124. But you have had plenty of time since then? — But since then there have been plenty of people in the cabin.
2,125. Nobody would steal the water-gauge book? — Perhaps not; I do not think anything should be imputed.
(The Coroner.) We might make any remarks that we thought proper after they came back and say they cannot find it.
(Mr. Wright.) I am not imputing anything to you Mr. Stratton; I am pointing the extreme importance of its being found.
2,126. You cannot give us any information, I understand, at present, as to what the condition of the water-guage was? — You might ask Joseph Spence; he is in the room.
2,127. Thank you; we will call him presently. Can you give us yourself any information as to what the pressure on the water-gauge was immediately before the explosion? — No; I was asleep at the time.
2,128. Do you mean to say that this never occurred to you as a matter about which you should have informed yourself? — No, I cannot say that it has.
2,129. It would be a very important thing to know, would it not, while it would assist to throw some light on ventilation at the time? — There is no doubt. It was this way — no one ever dreamt of the ventilation being wrong, because when I went to the down-cast pit the ventilation at that time and for many hours was all right.