1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
Seaham Colliery Inquest, 19th October 1880 (cont.).
Mr. Joseph Spence sworn and examined.
1,584. (The Coroner.) What are you? — A master waste man.
1,585. Where? — At Seaham Colliery.
1,586. What district had you? — The whole of the district — the whole of the mine.
1,587. Do you understand that plan? — Yes.
1,588. Then have you the whole of that to look after? — Yes.
1,589. How long have you been so? — Five years.
1,590. You are the man who came out of the pit at the same time as the last witness? — No.
1,591. Then I have made a mistake. We will postpone the examination of this witness, and have Michael Spence.
Mr. Michael Spence sworn and examined.
1,592. (The Coroner.) Prior to this explosion, whom did you come out of the pit with? — I came out by myself.
1,593. What time did you ride? — Four o'clock.
1,594. You rode out of the pit — you came out of the pit at four o'clock? — Yes.
1,595. Four o'clock on which day? — On the 7th.
1,596. Four o'clock in the afternoon? — Four o'clock in the afternoon.
1,597. Where had you been working — Down the third east.
1,598. What are you? — A back overman.
1,599. Then you came out at four o'clock in the afternoon, and you had been down the third east way? — Yes.
1,600. What did you do during the shift? — I went on to the pit heap at nine o'clock. I registered the barometer at 29.86 and the thermometer at 59. Then I went down the pit and went to the on-setter's cabin and looked at the water gauge, and found it to be 2 3/10 inches; and after that I went to the overman's cabin and registered the underground barometer at 31.7 and the thermometer at 65. Then I went into the main in-take till I came to the third east way end. I met George Carr, the fore overman. I asked him which district he had been in, and he said "The far way;" and I said, "How are things going on there?" and he answered, "All right." I went to the third east and went up the chain bank, and found all right there. I came down, and went through the stone drift, and found all right there also. I next went to the north and west district in the third east, and found gas in green bank swell, caused by a fall, bringing the brattice cloth down. There was nobody working in it. I travelled further round to the south and west, and found all right there. I next came down the inclined bank, and then went out-bye to the third east way end, and I met the night shift boys coming in, and got them set to work, and saw the day shift ones out. I went to the far-off landing to see how things were going on there, and found the boys there all right and things going on right. I came to the overman's cabin. The night shift overman was there, and I told him what districts I had been in, and I told him I had found all right except that place.
1,601. During the whole of that shift, did you find any gas in any portion of the workings, or see any chance of gas during it? — No place but the one.
1,602. What was the ventilation like during the shift, so far as you were concerned? — Something of a regular way — the working way.
1,603. Could you detect any less ventilation than ordinary? — No.
1,604. Was any shot-firing going on while you were in? — Not while I was in.
1,605. You did not hear any? — I never heard any.
1,606. Did you know whether there was to be any shot-firing after you came out? — I could not tell.
1,607. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) There were very numerous reports of gas made to you during July and August? — The reports made of gas to me will be in that report-hook (pointing).
1,608. That is not what I asked you. Did you not have many reports of gas in June, July, and August; they are in your book, I dare say — I am not blaming you for anything? — When I have seen gas I have reported it; and when I was not in the district, I have seen the deputy and asked him about it.
1,609. Nobody has suggested that you did anything wrong. I only asked you, is not it a fact that there are a great many reports of gas in your book for June, July, and August? — Yes.
1,610. A great many? — Yes.
1,611. Are they reports which the deputies have brought to you, or that you have seen yourself? — Yes, I have reported all that I have seen myself.
1,612. Something like almost every day you reported gas? — All the time that that fall has been there — above a week.
1,613. Much more than that. I have got the reports here from June 10th, through July and August, to the 7th September. I do not think I am wrong in saying that you have had two or three reports on an average, at any rate, one report for every day? — Yes; there are places still standing. They are not working every day. Those are standing places.
1,614. Do you understand that plan? — I think I might.
1,615. Just point out whereabouts it was, generally speaking, that the gas reported in your book was found? — About the working face.
1,616. What is the name of that? — The north and west flat (pointing).
1,617. That is on the east side of the mine? — On the east side of the mine.
1,618. Were nearly all the reports in your book in the east and north flats? — Yes.
1,619. Were they blowers, little blowers? — Yes; this is Belcher's flat in-bye (pointing).
1,620. (Mr. Bell.) Which is the chain bank — is it above or below the trouble? — Above the trouble, or between the two troubles.
1,621. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Was Wile over that part of the mine at all where there is so much gas? — He travelled occasionally.
1,622. Would the deputies report it to him the same as to you if he was there? — If they saw the report book they would report him.
1,623. If he had seen their report-book he would have known whether there was gas in it? — Yes.
1,624. Would he be there in the month of June? — I think he should.
1,625. And through the month of July? — I think he should, he travels occasionally.
1,626. Did you see the gas there in June, July, and August? — Yes.
1,627. Mostly every day? — Not every day.
1,628. Every other day? — I cannot say every other day.
1,629. Two or three times a week? — I have seen it above that wall above a week on end, but no other place.
1,630. (Mr. Bell.) Which is Cleghorn's place? — (The witness indicated the place on plan).
1,631. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) There was a fall somewhere in your district? — In that wall.
1,632. Whereabouts? Was it a fall in the back of the face? — Not far back from the face.
1,633. How long was it? — Nearly 10 yards long.
1,634. And about how wide from face to back? — Two yards wide.
1,635. Had it brought down much of the roof? — There is a lot of big stones.
1,636. Lying on the ground? How many feet thick? — About 2 feet thick, as near as I can guess.
1,637. Was that where gas was coming out? — The brattice cloth was broken down, and next the face a little gas, and it could not be removed until this was put up.
1,638. Had you got the brattice cloth right before the explosion? — No; it was not all away before the explosion.
1,639. Was there much gas? — No.
1,640. Did it increase or get less, do you think? — I would say just a little next the face where the brattice cloth was broken down.
1,641. Was the ventilation, however, good close by there? — Good.
1,642. You did not see any danger from this gas? — No danger; there was nobody working by.
1,643. Was gas in sufficiently large quantities to be dangerous? — No; it was not a big quantity.
1,644. Even supposing they had been using naked lights with that quantity of gas? — If they had been right in the face it would have been dangerous; but it would have to be right in the face to be so.
1,645. Have you been in the mines since the explosion? — No, I have not been much. I have been at the return round watching until this last week.
1,646. Have you got any idea about the direction of the blast? — No; I have not travelled much about the rolley-way.
1,647. Do you recollect coming from the engine shaft southwards into the main in-take in the Hutton? You came to a crossing about 100 yards from the shaft, and then you came to the wheels of No. 1 engine. You recollect those? — Yes; the in-take.
1,648. You remember those 200 yards south of the engine? — I was there last week.
1,649. Did you see those wheels the day before the explosion? — I have seen them running.
1,650. Did you see them at all after? — Not that I took much notice of, because most of the things were removed when I travelled that district.
1,651. Do you know who removed the things? — No.
1,652. You cannot say whether the covering of those wheels was blown in-bye or out-bye? — I cannot.
1,653. (Mr. Jones.) I did not quite understand you to say how long before the explosion this fall took place? — About nine days.
1,654. Before the explosion, you said the brattice had not been got there before that time, but no one was working there, I understood you to say? — Not in the daytime.
1,655. Where the fall had been? — No.
1,656. Were they working at night there? — I never saw anybody working at it.
1,657. You knew that they were working there at night where the fall had been? — Yes.
1,657a. You know whether any extra precautions had been taken? — Yes.
1,658. What were the precautions? — It was both fenced off and a caution board put up as far as they had to go.
1,659. How far were they allowed to go from where the fall was? — The fall was, maybe, a dozen yards within the blast end of the place, or about a chain and a half up.
1,660. And a dozen yards from where the blast was? — Yes; the fall.
1,661. They were between the main air-way and the blast where the fall was. The fall was at the other side of the air-way, to the north of the air-way? — The brattice was as far as they had to go, and as they removed the stone they had to put up the brattice cloth.
1,662. What I meant was, it was the other side of the in-take where the fall was? — It was in the in-take.
1,663. But which side of the in-take? Can you point that out on the plan? — (Witness pointed to the plan.)
1,664. What do you call that place? — Belcher's north flat.
1,665. What I want to know is this — you say the men are allowed to work there in the night, but not in the daytime? — Yes; they could not get on. They could not get the stone in the daytime.
1,666. Look at that map, and put your hand where the fall was exactly. Was it on the right-hand side or the left-hand side of the innermost board? — The right-hand side.
1,667. (Mr. Bell.) Was it the innermost wall, or the innermost stentin? — (Witness indicated on the plan.)
1,668. (Mr. Jones.) Point out the main air-way now — the in-take? — Here is the in-take.
1,699. How far does that go up. Where does it go? — All around by the face.
(Mr. Bell.) The witness is following the air-current round the face of the workings.
1,670. (Mr. Jones.) Follow the main in-take? — It is in behind the brattice. It goes in behind the brattice, and goes out the other way.
1,671. Does it go behind where the fall was, or the front of the fall? — One side of the fall.
1,672. In the south side of the fall? — On the east side of the fall.
1,673. Are there any workings between the fall and it? — No.
1,674. It goes right up to the fall? — Yes.
1,676. Well, then, there is a good current there? — Yes.
1,676. Was it through danger from the gas that the men were forbidden to work there, or what? — No; they could not get on in the day time.
1,677. Why not? — On account of taking the stone out.
1,678. But I mean the hewers? — The hewers could not get it for the fall.
1,679. But this side of the fall. Did not you see them stop hewing? — No; they were still working in the other place.
1,680. It was only the men who had to rectify the fall who were allowed to work at night? — Yes.
1,681. Did you see the place within nine days — did you see it frequently? — Every day for the nine days.
1,682. And it was blowing out very little gas? — Very little gas.
1,683. And there was a good ventilation? — Good ventilation.
1,684. Do you know whether anybody was working there with lights on the morning of the explosion? — I cannot tell whether anybody was working there or not.
1,685. Had you heard of any falls in the mine shortly before the explosion? — No.
1,686. You never heard of any? — Not that I am aware of.
1,687. Nowhere in the mine? — No.
1,688. When did you last know of any shot-firing in that part of the pit? — I have not seen any shotfiring ever since that stone drift was driven.
1,689. Only since the stone drift was driven. Do you know why shot-firing was forbidden in that part of the pit? — It never was.
1,690. Was it forbidden? — No; they were done their drift.
1,691. But for winning the coal, did not they require shots at all in that part of the pit? — Yes.
1,692. Then why did not they fire shots? — I daresay that they fire shots at night, but not that I was aware of, in making refuge holes.
1,693. You have heard that they fired shots in the night in that part of the No. 1 Hutton? — In the stone drift.
1,694. I mean for the purpose of getting the coal? — No; we never fire shots for coal.
1,695. (Mr. Edge.) How long have you been in this No. 1? — Eight years.
1,696. In that time has any shot been fired in bringing the coal down? — Not that I know of.
1,697. The shots that have been fired have been fired in the stone? — Yes.
1,698. And the last that you heard of, or know of, in No. 1, was in that stone drift? — The last that I know of was in that stone drift.
1,699. You said that they were not allowed to work at the fall, except at night? — They could not get on in the daytime.
1,700. You could not work in the daytime, because you could not remove the stone? — We could not remove the stone, for there were other people working further away.
1,701. When the men were at work at night, it was because that was the proper time for removing the stone, but not because there was any danger in removing the stone? — Certainly not.
1,702. Whenever you see any trace of gas, you report it? — Yes; if it was ever so little.
1,703. And I think I might take it that you report gas many a time in your reports, when there is very little or no danger in the gas? — Wherever it shows gas, we have to report it.
1,704. (The Coroner.) Have you been into that district since this happened? — No.
1,705. You have not? — No.
1,706. (Mr. Jones.) Whenever there is gas, I suppose there is danger in a coal mine? — Well, we report as soon as ever we descry it. There might not be much danger, but it might come to something more, you know.
(The Coroner.) I would like to ask both sides about No. 1, this question; within what distance of No. 1 district is this explosion supposed to have taken place?
(Mr. Willis.) Opinions differ.
(The Coroner.) I just want to see if we are anywhere near the locality.
(Mr. Edge.) It is a very different thing to say until Maudlin is opened up to see where the explosion has occurred.
(The Coroner.) If we have been examining No. 1 district, and that happens to be a couple of miles away from where the explosion took place, we are spending our time. We have only got to-day so far as this, the general management and condition of the mine in No. 1 Hutton.
(Mr. Willis.) Which probably brought about the explosive condition, so that you want all the evidence.
(Mr. Edge.) I propose to put in the report of the master shifter.
(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Did you get his report before his decease?
(Mr. Edge.) We certainly have not got one since.
(Mr. R. S. Wright.) You have not been able to get those of his subordinates since.
(The Coroner.) Who can prove the master shifter's handwriting?
(Mr. Stratton.) I ordered all the report books to be here, and I have just made an inquiry, and find that the master shifter's is not here.
(The Coroner.) Do you want formal proof of it?
(Mr. Jones.) I think we ought to have it formally proved.
(The Coroner.) I quite agree that that is the proper way.
(Mr. Jones.) I would take it subject to the question about formal proof.
(Mr. R. S. Wright.) I won't ask anything to be taken on formal proof.
(The Coroner.) I should like one district to be clear if we can do it, but if we cannot get on I cannot help it. If we could clear up No. 1 district, before we enter another district, that would be the best plan.
(Mr. Jones.) There are some more witnesses from No. 1, and I think it highly desirable that we should exhaust No. 1 before going into another seam.
(Mr. Edge.) I may tell you that it would be a great advantage to the colliery proprietors if all their overmen were not kept down here. If you wish to go on and exhaust No. 1 by calling some of the deputies, we might say that the overmen of No. 3 might not be required until to-morrow. It is placing the officials in difficulties.
(Mr. Jones.) That is a reasonable proposition.
(Mr. Edge.) I have got one deputy. Might we say that the overmen of No. 3 and the Maudlin — those who are alive — might not be called until 2 o'clock to-morrow.
(The Coroner.) Yes, you may take that.