Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Inquests Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Inquests
/   \

1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster

Inquest Report

Seaham Colliery Inquest, 19th October 1880 (cont.).

Mr. James Wile called and sworn.

1,354. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Are you one of the two back overmen of No. 1 pit, Hutton seam? — Yes.

1,355. You have been so for eleven years? — Yes.

1,356. When were you last down in the pit, before the explosion? — I went down at 3 o'clock on the afternoon of the 7th.

1,357. When did you come up? — At one o'clock in the morning.

1,357a. Who came up with you? — One of the onsetters. I stopped down till everyone came out, and the on-setter came up too.

1,358. Which of the on-setters was that? — I believe it was Edward Hart.

1,359. During the time that you were down in the mine, what were you doing? — When I went down I went up to the overman's cabin, and I just went to the barometer, and then I went in-bye to the face.

1,360. Which face? — The far-off face.

1,361. Did you go down the main in-take? — I went in by the main in-take.

1,362. Right down to this face? — Yes.

1,363. Right to the goaf? — Yes.

1,364. The big goaf? — Yes.

1,365. When you got there, where did you go? — I examined the workings right round.

1,366. Which way — to the west? Did you examine the workings to the west? — I went down east first, and then I went to the west.

1,367. You went first as far as there (pointing on the plan), 200 or 300 yards? — Yes, and round to the west.

1,368. And then across? — I came back by the in-take again.

1,369. And so to the shaft? — No.

1,370. Where did you go then? — I went down to the third east.

1,371. You went back as far as the joining between the two in-takes, and then you came down to the third east in-take into the third east? — Yes.

1,372. Then did you go all round the third east? — No; I went through what we call the stone drift flat — through the stone drift.

1,373. By here (pointing)? — The workings. I don't understand that thing.

1,374. You went round by the third east? — Yes.

1,375. Tell us in your own language where you went? — I went through the stone drift to the workings. There is a stone drift through the seam. I went through there. There are seven places in there, and I examined them places, and then they were right.

1,376. And after that? — I came back there and went up where we call the endless chain bank to the spout bank.

1,377. Is that near the little goaf? — Yes, it is the whole coal between the troubles.

1,378. That is towards the north side of the workings? — Yes.

1,379. Then from there where did you go? — I came down from there and I went into what we call the north flat.

1,380. Then from there where did you go? — I turned back ; it was getting late, and I turned back to the third east way again to meet the master shifters coming in at 10 o'clock.

1,381. What report did you make to them? — I told the master shifters where I had been, and I told them that all was right.

1,382. Who were these master shifters that you met? — Only one.

1,383. Who is he? — Charles Dawson.

1,384. Was he killed? — Yes.

1,385. So far as you could see when you were going over that part of the mine that you told us about, was it in good order? — Yes.

1,386. You saw no gas anywhere? — Not the least.

1,387. Do you always report gas when you see it yourself? — Yes.

1,388. In your book? — Yes.

1,389. Do you report it when you are told of it? — No, when I see it.

1,390. Only when you see it? — Yes.

1,391. Do you remember when the last report of gas was made by you? — I am sure I do not know.

1,392. Did you ever make any report of gas? — I have not seen any gas since a good while.

1,393. Answer the question. Did you ever make any report of gas? — Not that I am aware of — I might.

1,394. (The Coroner.) How long is it since you found gas? — I am sure I cannot say.

1,395. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) You must try to give us the best answers you can. It is your duty to report gas, and I want you to answer the question when you last reported gas. Was it six months ago? — It might be that — I cannot say.

1,396. You cannot undertake to say that you reported gas within six months before the explosion? — No.

1,397. Is that your answer? — Yes.

1,398. Can you undertake to say you never saw any gas within six months before the explosion? — I have not.

1,399. You think you never saw it? — No.

1,400. Did none of the men ever report gas to you in your district? — No.

1,401. Are we to take it that so far as you know there never was any gas in that part of the mine for six months before the explosion? — I never saw any.

1,402. Nor heard of any? — Nor heard of any.

1,403. Is that your answer? — Yes.

1,404. Did you ever look for any? — Yes.

1,405. Did you ever try for any? — Yes.

1,406. What lamp did you carry with you? — A Davy lamp.

1,407. After you had gone to the far end workings you went back until you went to the intake that goes to the east workings? — Yes.

1,408. What o'clock was it when you started on the intake into the east workings? — It would be 5 o'clock.

1,409. Then you were four or five hours going round the east workings? — Yes, I was down there.

1,410. Did you go round them alone, or was anybody with you? — Myself.

1,411. Alone? — Yes.

1,412. Did you stop any where at all? — Well, yes; I stopped just to see how the work was going on.

1,413. You did not stop for an hour or anything of that sort anywhere? — No.

1,414. Is it your duty when you have visited a part of the mine to put up any marks to show that you have been there? — Yes, I set my name — my initials.

1,415. It is your duty to do so, is it not? — Yes.

1,410. At every part you visit? — At any part of the workings. I do not in every place. Sometimes I do and sometimes I do not.

1,417. I am not asking whether you do or do not, but whether it is your duty to do it. Is it your duty to do it or not? — I was never ordered to do it, but I sometimes do it just to show I have been there.

1,418. Do you mean to say that it is not your duty to do it, that you are not bound to do it? — No, I am not saying that.

1,419. Did you put up any marks that night? — No, I did not.

1,420. When did you last put up any marks? — The Sunday morning before.

1,421. Where did you put a mark on the Sunday morning? — Just through that stone drift and up this spout.

1,422. What was the mark you put? — J. W.

1,423. What did that mean — that you had been there? — Yes, and the day of the month.

1,424. Do you know anything about blasting in the mine? Have you ever known of there being blasting in this part of the mine? — No.

1,425. Have you known any blasting in Hutton — No. 1 Hutton? — No.

1,426. Shot-firing? — No.

1,427. Was it prohibited? — No.

1,428. It was allowed, was it not? — At one time it was allowed.

1,429. When was the last shot that you know of fired? — About four years' since.

1,430. How was the stone drift got out — was that done by blasting? — Yes; that was by blasting.

1,431. How long ago? — Perhaps a year or two — I forgot that.

1,432. Is there anything else that you have forgotten? — I think not.

1,433. Are you quite certain — think carefully — that you have never known of gas in the east workings? — No.

1,434. Nor heard of it? — No.

1,435. That night, before the explosion, did you see all the men and boys safely out of the pit? — Yes.

1,436. (The Coroner.) Beyond Charles Dawson, the master shifter, did you see any one — any of the deputies that night? — Yes; I saw the two night shift deputies.

1,437. Who were they? — Thomas Greenwell and William Potts.

1,438. Which shift were those deputies in? — In the ten o'clock shift.

1,439. Was that the back shift or the fore-shift? — They came in with the master shifter.

1,440. Did you see none of the back shift deputies? — I saw one.

1,441. When were Rochester and Weirs in? — Weirs was on the four o'clock shift in the afternoon — he was on the night shift. Rochester was not on the night shift; he came out at five o'clock that night.

1,442. Did you see him after you got into the pit at three o'clock in the afternoon? — I saw him.

1,443. Why did not you tell us about seeing Rochester before? — Nobody asked me.

1,444. I asked you what deputies you saw, and if you had seen anybody else but Dawson; you gave me two other names, but you never mentioned Rochester or Weirs? — I met Rochester when I first went in.

1,445. What passed between you and Rochester? — He said it was all right in the far-off workings.

1,446. Did you see Weirs? — I saw Weirs at nine o'clock at night at the North Flat, and he said the district was all right.

1,447. Which was his district? — The North Flat district.

1,448. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Try and attend to this. You know Spence, do you not? — Yes.

1,449. He is the other back-overman in No. 1? — Yes.

1,450. How can you account for it that the deputies were always making reports of gas to Spence, and never made any to you? — Well, I do not go that district that Spence goes in. I am at the far-off way, and I go down to the third east, to the Stone Drift workings. Spence is on the other side, the north side of the third east.

1,451. Does he never go the same road that you go? — Yes, he goes at times.

1,452. Do you never go the same road that he goes? — Sometimes.

1,453. How often? — Perhaps twice, or once a week.

1,454. Attend carefully. On the days when you go on his ground, do you mean to say you never had any reports of gas made to you? — No.

1,455. You are attending to the questions, I suppose? — Yes.

1,456. And you have never seen any gas? — No.

1,457. Where was it you heard of gas then? — At the Far-off Flat, coming off the goaf.

1,458. That was six months ago? — Yes.

1,459. Did you report it yourself? — Yes.

1,460. In your book? — Yes.

1,461. What was it, a blower, or what? — No — coming off the top off the goaf.

1,461a. How was the tap stopped? — It was off the top of the goaf.

1,462. How was that stopped? does it stop itself, or what? did it exhaust itself? — We put in a brattice to throw the air on to it.

1,463. How long did the gas continue to flow? — It soon went away.

1,464. Had you heard men speak of gas coming out after that? — No.

1,465. You never heard any mention of it? — No.

1,466. Did you ever hear of any gas coming off that goaf at all within the last six months? — No.

1,467. No mention of any gas coming off that goaf? — No.

1,468. How was the air round the goaf? Was there a good current round it? — Very good.

1,469. How was the current got? Was it got by bratticing? — Yes, we bratticed next to the goaf.

1,470. You spoke about powder; have you been using powder, or have you known powder used within the last year or so in men holes, or refuge holes? — Yes, they were using it in that stone drift.

1,471. (The Coroner.) Which stone drift is that? — Down the third east.

1,472. You forgot to mention that? — Yes.

1,473. These refuge holes were made in that drift, going through the third east? — Through that drift.

1,474. They were made in the drift? — Yes.

1,475. (Mr. Jones.) How long ago was that? — Perhaps a year or more.

1,476. Have you known of any refuge holes being made since then? — I have not.

1,477. You are not sure? — No.

1,478. You never heard of any being made? — No.

1,479. Have you never heard of any shot firing in No. 1 Hutton, within the last year? — Not beyond that stone drift.

1,480. Not beyond the stone drift? — And the refuge holes in the stone drift.

1,481. You heard of no shot firing in the workings? — No.

1,482. Do you know why they stopped the shotfiring? — I do not.

1,483. Have you never heard why? — No.

1,484. Was there an order given that there should be no shot firing? — Not to me.

1,485. How was it that the shot firing was discontinued?

1,486. (The Coroner.) Do you know that it has been discontinued by an order? — Not to my knowledge.

1,487. It is only because it has not been necessary to do it? — Yes.

1,488. (Mr. Jones.) Is that so? — Yes.

1,489. Have you ever noticed any variation in the current in the intake? Have you noticed a current sometimes stronger at one time than another? — No, not particularly.

1,490. Have you not sometimes found that the current is stronger in the mine at one time than another? — That is when the barometer rises.

1,491. Before the accident, can you tell us how the current was then? was it a slack current? — It was very good.

1,492. Was it somewhat slacker? — No, I think it was a good average current.

1,493. Had you noticed any change in the current the evening you went down? You went down at four o'clock, did you not? — Three o'clock.

1,494. Had you noticed any difference between the time when you first went down, and afterwards when you came up? — No.

1,495. Not at all? — No.

1,496. Have you heard any mention made of any difference? — No.

1,497. Have you any idea as to the rate the current was going? Was it blowing much dust as you came along? — I cannot say.

1,498. Not much? — No.

1,499. It always moves a little, I suppose? — I cannot say.

1,500. You know what I mean; the coal dust always moves a little, does it not? — When the trucks are coming out-bye, the coal is just flying off the top.

1,501. When the trains are coming up? — Yes.

1,502. What I mean is this: you have noticed coal dust, I suppose, flying with the current, have you not? — No, if there was anything disturbing to make it fly, but not for the wind to take it.

1,503. (The Coroner.) Would not an explosion disturb it? — Well, it might.

1,504. (Mr. Edge.) Except when the trucks are coming down out of the coal, do you notice any dust flying in the intake? — No.

1,505. You left at 1 o'clock in the morning? — Yes.

1,506. (The Coroner.) You say that in going back the travelling ways, you considered the ventilation as good as when you went down at the commencement of the shift? — Yes.

1,507. You noticed nothing to make you think there was anything wrong? — Nothing.

1,508. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) You have been exploring? — Yes.

1,509. You have been down the pit since the explosion? — Yes.

1,510. What direction do you think the blast came from? — I think it went in bye-over into pit No. 1.

1,511. From the Maudlin? — Yes.

1,512. Or from No. 3 — which? — I think it came from that side — No. 3 side.

1,513. Can you tell at all, whether it came from Maudlin or No. 3 Hutton? — I cannot tell that.

1,514. Tell us shortly, what makes you think it came in-bye from that side? — Because all the tail-sheaves we took for the tail rope to run on the large wheels, were all running in bye-over.

1,515. You had seen them before the explosion? — Yes.

1,516. And then after the explosion, did you see them again lying further in-bye? — Yes.

1,517. How far in-bye? — Perhaps two or three yards.

1,518. Did you notice anything else? — Not particular.

1,519. Beginning with the shaft itself, that was the first thing you noticed to show the direction which the blast came from — the tail-sheaves? — Yes.

1,520. How near the blast did you notice the tail-sheaves had been blown in-bye? — When I saw them there, I saw they had been blown in-bye.

1,521. Which was the nearest of them to the shaft that you noticed? — At the top of the bank head I went through the stables — the high stables, on to the main intake, and I saw the wheels then.

1,522. That would be No. 1 engine main turned wheel? — Yes.

1,523. Was it blown in two or three yards there? — Yes.

1,524. On the out-bye side was there anything blown? — They were lying in all directions, some in-bye and some out-bye.

1,525. On the out-bye side of the same engine, No. 1 engine-wheel, were they blown out-bye at all? — There was some blowing in-bye and some out-bye.

1,526. (The Coroner.) That is on the out-bye side? — Yes.

1,527. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) On the out-bye side of the engine wheel? — Yes.

1,528. Following in by from the No. 1 engine wheel did you see anything else blown in-bye except the tail-sheaves? — No, not particularly I think.

1,529. Any tubs? — No, I did not see any tubs.

1,530. There is nothing else you can tell us? — No.

1,531. Did you see any hay blown about? — Yes, hay was blown about.

1,532. Which way? — Both ways, some in-bye and some out-bye.

1,533. (Mr. Edge.) Where were these wheels that you saw, how near to No. 1 shaft? — Perhaps 500 or 600 yards.

1,534. Do you know where the wheels came from? — They were what we call tail-sheaves.

1,535. There are a great many of these in the pit, are there not? — Yes.

1,536. How could you tell, when you saw one of these wheels after the accident, whether it had been blown in-bye or out-bye? — Where a large wheel is upon a long pole, if it is blown all the way, the top part will fly the way it is being blown.

1,537. There are some hundreds of these wheels in the intake? — A great many.

1,538. What I what to know is this: when you saw any one particular wheel, how did you know the way it had been blown, in-bye or out-bye? — Because the heads were lying in-bye over.

1,539. That is the only reason, because their heads were lying in-bye over? — Yes.

1,540. From that you assume they were blown in-bye? — Yes.

1,541. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) And from the distance ; you said they had been blown two or three yards? — Yes.

1,542. What distance is there between one wheel and another? — When they were standing upright.

1,543. Yes? — About eight or ten yards.

1,544. Then, either they must have been blown two yards distance in-bye, or eight yards if blown outbye? — Yes.

1,545. In your judgment is it more likely they were blown two or three yards in-bye than eight yards out-bye? — Yes.

1,546. (A Juror.) Are those sheaves fixed upon uprights? — Yes.

1,547. And the uprights would be leaning in-bye? — Yes.

1,548. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Was the big wheel blown in by the turned wheel or its cover, No. 1 engine? — That wheel never stirred, but the main rope wheel was blown in-bye. The wheel at the further end was blown in.

1,549. (Mr. Edge.) Whereabouts was that? — It is at the third east-way end.

1,550. Did Weirs make any report to you that night? You told us you met him about nine o'clock? — Yes, he told me all was right.

1,551. When you went down the shaft did you examine any barometer or thermometer? — Yes.

1,552. Where? — At the cabin.

1,553. How did you find the barometer? — It was 31.10.

1,554. And the thermometer? — It was 66.

1,555. And the water-gauge? — 2.1.

1,556. Did you enter this in your report book? — Yes.

1,557. Is it here? — Yes.

1,557a. When you were returning did you examine the barometer then? — Yes.

1,558. About what time was it when you examined it? — About twelve o'clock at night.

1,559. (The Coroner.) Not in going out at one o'clock? — Yes; I examined both in going out and coming in.

1,560. (Mr. Edge.) How was the barometer then? — Standing in the same way.

1,561. It registered the same as when going down? — Yes.

1,562. How was the thermometer at that time? — 66.

1,563. Standing at 66? — The same way.

1,564. (Mr. Jones.) You are speaking of down the pit? — Yes.

1,565. (The Coroner.) Which do you enter in the book? — The one below.

1,566. Which do you enter in the book, the examination in going in or coming out, because there is only one entry in the book? — I entered the one in coming out when I came out, but they were both standing at one.

1,567. Then if I understand they were at one point, or there would have been two entries? — Yes, I would have had to make a difference.

1,568. (Mr. Edge.) I understand that your local district was not exactly the same as Spence's? — No.

1,569. Occasionally you travelled Spence's district about once a week? — Yes.

1,570. I suppose you had nothing to do with any reports that had been made to Spence? — We used to see each other.

1,571. Only to confer? — Yes.

1,572. Whenever you noticed gas did you always report it? — Yes.

1,573. How was the ventilation that night when you left the pit? — Very good.

1,574. Since the accident you have been in that district; have you been in the other districts of the pit? — Yes; I have been in the third east and the third flats since the explosion.

1,575. You have not been in the Maudlin or No. 3 Hutton? — No.

1,576. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Just let us be sure. In going from the No. 1 engine and making south towards No. 1 Hutton, first of all you come to a crossing about one hundred yards off, and then another hundred you come to the engine wheels of No. 1 engine? — Yes.

1,577. Coming southwards from the No. 1 shaft you come first of all to a crossing some one hundred yards south of the shaft, and then about another hundred yards the two engine wheels of No. 1 engine? Yes.

1,578. What I want you to answer is, which way were those two wheels blown if blown at all? — They were not blown at all.

1,579. Was anything over them? — The covering was on them.

1,580. Was that blown either way? — The middle of the way was blown up, but I cannot say which way the covering was blown.

1,581. You could not say whether it was in-bye or out-bye? — Yes.

1,582. If you saw it after the explosion you must know which way it was blown? — There were so many things lying about I could not see exactly.

1,583. Was there at that place anything that you could see which in your opinion was blown in-bye and not out-bye? — Not just there.

The witness withdrew.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print