Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Inquests Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Inquests
/   \

1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster

Inquest Report

Seaham Colliery Inquest, 19th October 1880 (cont.).

Mr. George Carr sworn and examined.

629. (Mr. Edge.) You are foreman of No. 1 pit, Hutton seam? — Yes.

630. I think you have occupied that position more than six years? — Yes.

631. Did you go down the pit on the morning of the 7th of September? — Yes.

632. (The Coroner.) Did the explosion occur on the eighth? — Yes.

633. (Mr. Edge.) At what time in the morning did you go down? — Four o'clock.

634. (The Coroner.) Before doing so, what did you do? — I adjusted the barometer at the bank before I went down the pit.

635. What did the barometer register at the surface before you went down? — 27.72.

636. You have your report-book? — Yes.

637. Did you examine the thermometer? — Yes.

638. How did it stand? — At 61.

639. When you got to the bottom of the shaft, did you examine the water-gauge? — Yes.

(The Coroner.) You had better ask him what he did.

640. (Mr. Edge.) When you got to the bottom of the shaft, what did you do? — I examined the water-gauge.

641. What was it standing at? — 1.80.

642. What did you do then? — I went to the overmen's cabin.

643. What did you do there? — I adjusted the barometer.

644. What was it registering? — 30.05.

645. What else did you do? — Then I took the thermometer standing at 64.

646. Did you do anything else in the foremen's cabin? — I examined the deputies' report-book.

647. (The Coroner.) What deputies — what are their names? — I cannot say offhand.

648. How many deputies would there be? (Mr. Edge.) The deputies of which shift? — The back shift deputies.

649. (The Coroner.) You cannot tell the names of the deputies? — Not exactly.

650. Can you tell me any of them? — Yes, I can tell them, but not exactly in the shifts.

651. (Mr. Edge.) What did you do then? — I went into the east and west stables and examined the ponies to see if they were all right.

652. Will you point out where this cabin was? — There (pointing on the plan).

653. (The Coroner.) You understand that plan so as to be able to point it out? — Yes.

654. (Mr. Edge.) Now point out the stables that you say you went into — you went to the west and the east stables, No. 1 pit? — Yes.

655. Where are they? — There (pointing).

656. After you had gone to the stables, what did you do? — I turned back to the overmen's cabin again.

657. (The Coroner.) Where is that? — There (pointing).

658. (Mr. Edge.) What did you do there? — I stayed there until the boys came at five o'clock.

(The Coroner.) Do you think you need to go so minutely into this, seeing it is twenty-fours hours prior to the explosion?

(Mr. Edge.) I propose to call all those overmen deputies who were in the pit during the twenty-four hours preceding the explosion.

(The Coroner.) But not to tell us such matters as these.

658a. Did you see the boys at their work? — Yes.

659. What else did you do after that? — After the boys came, I set them to work.

660. (Mr. Edge.) What did you do after you had set them to work?

661. (The Coroner.) Did you examine the lamps? — Yes, I examined the lamps and locked the lamps.

662. Where did you go? — I went to the far-off way — to this district (pointing).

663. What is that? — The far-off way.

664. (Mr. Edge.) Did you meet any of the shifters? — I met the master shifter.

665. Who is the master shifter whom you met? — Charles Dawson.

666. Did he make any report to you? — He reported to me that the third east was all right.

667. (The Coroner.) Would that be entered in the report-book, or was it only a verbal report to you? — That is what he reported to me by word of mouth when I met him in the pit. It would be in his report-book.

668. (Mr. Edge.) Where did you go after that? — After I left him I went into the far-off way and examined the workings.

669. How did you find the workings in the far-off way? — All right.

670. What did you do then? — After I examined the workings, I came back again and met Michael Spence at the third east-end way.

671. (The Coroner.) Had you any conversation with him? — I reported to him that the far-off way was all right, and that they were going on very well, add then proceeded down to the third east.

672. That would be entered in your report-book? — Yes.

673. (Mr. Edge.) Then I believe you came to the bank about 10 o'clock? — Yes.

674. What was the state of the part that you travelled as regards ventilation? — Good.

675. You made a report — have you the report-book here? — Yes.

676. Do you produce it? — Yes (produced.)

677. Will you refer to the entry? — There it is (pointing), the 7th of September.

678. (The Coroner.) When was that report made out? — On the 7th.

679. As soon as you came home? — Yes.

680. Who was it handed in to? — It was handed in to the under viewer.

681. That would be Mr. Turnbull? — Yes.

682. Down that district did you notice any gas or any symptoms of gas? — In this district, no.

683. On that day? — No, not on that day.

(Mr. Edge.) Will you ask whether the witness went to the pit again before the explosion?

684. (The Coroner.) Were you down the pit again before the explosion took place? — No, I was not.

685. When was the last time that you saw any gas in that district, or have you ever seen any gas in that district? — Yes, I have seen gas coming off the goaf.

686. Is that entered in the report-book? — Yes.

687. Can you refer to it? — It is some time since we have had gas there.

688. Can you refer to it? — I do not think I can exactly.

(Mr. Edge.) How long ago was it?

(Mr. Bell.) Look at the 24th June.

689. (The Coroner.) Take the 13th of August. On the 13th of August you report that the west work is in good order, except that there is gas in Greenbank Place? — Yes.

690. Where is that? — In this district (pointing).

691. Then from the 13th of August up to the 6th of September, when you last made the examination prior to the explosion, have you ever found any gas in that district? — No.

692. Has your attention been called by any of the working men in that district to anything of the sort? — Not during my shift.

693. None has been reported to you in any way? — No.

694. Have you noticed anything wrong about the west and east stables? — No.

695. Nothing at all? — No.

696. What lamp are you using down that district? — The Clanny and the Davy.

697. To what extent — what number of Clanny and what number of Davy? — I think we have about two hundred and fifty altogether.

698. Two hundred and fifty of which; Clanny or Davy? — Altogether.

699. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) In your district? — Yes.

700. (The Coroner.) What number of Davy and what number of Clanny.? — I think something like one hundred and twenty-five Davys.

701. And how many Clannys? — I think something like one hundred and thirty.

702. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Whereabouts is the water-gauge under ground? — Here (pointing).

703. (The Coroner.) The water-gauge mentioned in your report? — Yes.

704. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Was it at all in-by? — Very little.

705. How much? — Say three or four yards from the shaft.

706. Three or four yards you would say? — Yes; four yards.

707. Do the men appoint examiners of their own in this mine ; you know that they have the power to do it under the Act?

708. (The Coroner.) Do the men go round once a month, or whatever the time is, and examine the work themselves? — Yes.

709. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) They appoint examiners of their own? — Yes.

710. Who were the men's examiners at the time of the explosion? — I cannot say exactly who were the men appointed.

711. Have you ever seen them go round? — Yes.

712. Do you know when they went round last before the explosion? — I cannot state the day exactly.

713. Two or three days before? — I think it would not be long.

714. Within a week?

715. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) You have got the book have not you, in which the men make their report? — No.

716. Who keeps it? — Perhaps Mr. Stratton.

(The Coroner.) You have it, perhaps Mr. Stratton.

(Mr. Stratton.) Yes.

(Mr. Jones.) The men have the book themselves.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Let us have the book.

(Mr. Stratton.) I have it here.

717. Did I understand you to say that you went down at seven o'clock in the morning of the 7th? — Seven o'clock?

718. Yes? — No, four.

(The Coroner.) About twenty-four hours before the explosion.

719. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) When did you come up? — Ten o'clock in the morning.

720. Do you know what this refers to in the overman s book : — "August 7th, examined the points on the east way, where Robert Guy was killed, and found every facility afforded to protect the workmen's lives?" — That does not belong to me.

721. Do you know what it refers to? — No.

722. Where was Robert Guy killed? — It was in the Maudlin seam, somewhere. It is not in the mine at all.

723. That is not the question. Do you know where Robert Guy was killed?

(The Coroner.) It is not in your pit.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Still he might know.

724. There are six hours that you were down in the pit. Did you go over every part of the working faces? — Yes, in this district.

725. In that district only? — Yes.

726. Are there any other working faces besides that one in your district of that mine — in the No. 1 Hutton? — Yes, those (pointing).

727. Did you go round those? — No, not that shift.

728. (Mr. Jones.) What part will you call that — that you did not go to? — This is the third east.

729. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Did the back overman go over that part that you did not visit? — He left me at this point to go round this district.

730. So far as you know, he did go round it? — Well, I expect so.

731. (Mr. Jones.) Which district was that? — The third east.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) The one that Carr did not visit?

732. Which of the back overmen was that? — Michael Spence.

733. Was he killed? — No.

734. Are there any other working places in your district, except the two that you have mentioned? — No.

735. The one that you went over, and the one that Spence went over

736. Will you point out, if you please, on that, exactly the course you took in going through the working place? — In this district.

737. First of all, begin at the overman's cabin, and follow down. You came down the intake, did you — straight down the main intake? — That is the route I took (pointing) — into this point.

738. You came the whole way down the main intake? — Yes.

739. To within about 80 yards of the goaf? — Yes.

740. Then which way did you turn? — In there.

741. You turned eastward? — East.

742. Along the second stall road from the goaf, is that it? — Yes.

743. Till you reached the goaf again? — Yes.

744. At the point where the turn begins? — Yes.

745. Is that it? — That is it.

746. Then you followed up the return, did you? — Yes.

747. How far? — Right round — came right round here to this point.

748. You came down the back? — Yes.

749. That is not the return? — No ; this is the airway that we have round by the goaf.

750. To the westward? — Yes.

751. Keep your stick exactly where you went — the whole way? — This is the way.

752. Following the face all along? — Yes.

753. Those are the working faces? — They are the working faces.

754. Till you got back again to the return, where? — I got back to here (pointing) — came out there, on to the mainway again, then came out by that.

755. Then you did not examine the whole of the working faces? — This is standing at present, this is not working — we are only working up to this point, here.

756. Why is that part standing? — Well, we do not require now to go out.

757. But it is necessary that that part that is standing should be examined every day, is not it? — Yes.

758. For gas, and so on? — We do examine it every day by the deputy — the deputy travels this road every day.

759. Your duty is only to examine the working faces? — My duty is to examine the working faces.

760. Who is the deputy whose duty it would be to examine that part that is standing? — On that day?

761. On that day? — I believe it would be Robert Rochester.

762. Is he alive? — Yes.

763. To the eastward there is a bit of working face that you did not examine? — Yes, I went down there.

764. Oh, you did go down there? — Yes.

765. Then the only actual working face that you did not examine on that part was the bit that is standing? — This is standing.

766. That, Rochester would have to examine? — Yes.

767. When were you last over the eastern part of No. 1, Hutton? — This district?

768. Yes? — The day before I went down into this.

769. On the 6th September? — The 6th September.

770. So far as you know, when you last saw that part of the mine, was it in entirely good order? — Yes.

771. When did you last have occasion to notice any considerable outburst of gas? — We have not had a great quantity of gas. We have had a little matter of gas shown up in this place, here.

772. Do you find the gas issuing ever in this part of the mine, or is it an accumulation of gas? — No.

773. You understand what I mean? — The gas may issue out in a little blower at some particular place; or you may find it standing there like an accumulation? — Something like a blower — that is what we get.

774. You never find accumulations of gas that have collected in the hole of the roof, or anything of that sort? — No — just blowers.

775. What do you do when you are told that a little blower like that is so near? — We have to hide there to get rid of it as soon as possible.

776. Put up a sheet, or something? — Yes.

777. That is always reported? — Yes.

778. You have never known that omitted to be reported? — No, never.

779. Whether it was a small one or a large one? — I always report it if it is ever so little.

780. Where do the blowers come from generally? What part of the mine? — They principally come out of the roof.

781. Just point out on the plan there where you last saw a blower — the last time you saw one before the explosion? — There (pointing).

782. That is not near a working face at all? — Yes.

783. There is a working face there, is there? — Yes, it was there, the last one we had. That was the last blower.

(The Coroner.) That is the one that you have entered in your report book, is it?

784. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Whose working place was that? — At that time, when it was working, it would be Surtees Cleghorn.

785. Show me the entry of that in your book? — I suppose it will be in this book. It will perhaps be in the book before?

786. Well, let us have the book before.

787. (The Coroner.) Which is that — which book? — It would be in my own book.

788. This is your own book? — But the old. This is the new book that I commenced since.

789. But I thought you said that was the last time you had seen gas? — The last time — a blower.

790. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) What date would that be? — It was a good bit ago.

791. What month? — It is nearly three months ago.

792. July or August. Would it be the 10th July; — I cannot say exactly the date since I saw the blower in that case.

793. Is that gas coming off in a blower, in S. Cleghorn's place — Belcher's flat? Is that it? — That would be it.

794. And the deputies names are Chapman, Alexander, and Foster? — That is the place.

795. I see at the same place on the 10th another blower came off — at the very same place. On the 12th three more came off at the very same place. All the same day, is not it, all July?

(The Coroner.) It is the same blower — one which appears, and then they get rid of it entirely.

796. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) I see; then it lasted till the 20th? — Yes.

797. Where else, in your district, have blowers come off in the last six months? — We have had none particular.

798. Have you had to brush away the gas, or get rid of it with sheets at any other place besides where the blowers came? — No.

799. Have there been any accumulations of gas in your district at all in the last six months? — No.

800. (The Coroner.) When was the last time you saw any gas in it? — The last time.

801. Yes, when was the last time you saw any gas in your district? — Well, it would be reported if I have seen it. I cannot say exactly.

802. Can you give us any idea of about the time? — No.

803. Give me an idea how long it is since you saw any prior to this explosion.

804. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) This appears to be the last according to your book — "August 13th, west workings in good order, except gas in Greenbank's places" Yes

805. Would that be the last that you noticed? — That is the last that I noticed, that I am aware of.

806. Was that the last that was reported to you, or the last that you noticed yourself, do you mean? — The last I noticed myself.

807. Then you do not enter in this book any gas that is reported to you, unless you go and see it? — Just what I see myself.

808. Suppose the men told you that they had found gas, and had got rid of it, so that when you went there you could not see it yourself, would you put it in this book? — No.

809. In whose book would that appear? — It just depends upon the man that found it.

810. If the deputy found it, he would report it in the deputy's report book, even though he had got rid of it immediately? — Yes.

811. Suppose one of the men found a little gas somewhere, and managed to get rid of it before he told the deputy, would the deputy then put it in his book? — Well I do not think that.

812. The deputy would only put it in his book if he saw it himself? — That would be the only way I think.

813. And you would only put it in your book, if you saw it yourself? — Yes.

814. So that any gas that was got rid of by the men, without being seen either by you or by the deputy, probably would not be in the books at all? — If they happen to fall in with it that way, they send for a deputy directly.

815. They do not try to get rid of it at first? — Not that I am aware of.

816. I see sometimes you put in the reports what the deputies tell you. — "June 24th., Deputies report gas in Dunn's south wall."

(The Coroner.) But let us have the deputies' report; that is only an extract.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) It is quite enough for my purpose.

(The Coroner.) If that extract is correct.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) It is perfectly regular.

817. I use this merely to recall it to your recollection. This might be correct, I suppose. "Deputies report gas in Dunn's south wall and Smith's waste, appeared last night, but it is all right to-day"? — Yes, that is all right.

818. (The Coroner.) What did you do in that case, as soon as the deputy reported that gas to you? — He would put it in his report book — the deputy's report book.

819. As soon as that came to your knowledge, did you do anything yourself? — Not when it was right.

820. And you would depend upon the deputy's report, that it had been put right? — Yes.

821. You would not go to see yourself? — Well, I generally do go; if it is my day for that district, I do so.

822. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Is the whole of the seam of coal got out in this district, the whole of the Hutton seam — the whole thickness? — Yes.

823. The rock comes flat down on the floor? — Yes.

824. So that the goaf is quite filled up? — Yes.

825. Have you ever known any gas come off from the goaf? — Oh, yes; we get gas from all sides.

826. When was the last time you had known of gas coming from the goaf? — From this district?

827. Yes, the south district — the far-off district? — Well, I think it is three months since I have known anything come off that goaf.

828. How did it come off? In a blower? — Well, I think it would.

829. Did you see it? — Yes.

830. Was it much gas? — No, a little.

831. What is the rate of the ventilation along the face of the workings there, at the far off? — Along this district?

832. Yes; about how many feet per second? — Well, we have 18,000 into this district altogether.

833. In what length of time? 18,000 feet a minute? — Yes.

834. It must be thousand feet, must not it? Eighteen thousand? — Eighteen thousand.

835. You said eighteen hundred? — Yes; eighteen thousand.

836. Eighteen thousand cubic feet a minute. What is about the average area of the air-way that that passes along? — It would be something like six or seven.

837. Does that vary very much? — No, not much.

838. No chokes anywhere? — No, not much of that.

839. Does the roof fall very much in this mine? — No.

840. A safe roof? — Yes.

841. Is there any difficulty with the timbering? — No.

842. Do you stow the goaf here in this part? Do you fill it up at all? — No, the bottom heaves, and she falls herself.

843. Falls close behind? — Yes.

844. Is the timbering very heavy? — No.

845. How much open space is there behind the colliers before the roof comes down? — Oh, there is sometimes forty yards, and sometimes only ten or twenty. It just depends upon how much she comes away. Sometimes she comes away very rapid. Sometimes she stands a considerable time.

846. Have you ever known gas come off either of the other goafs in your district? — What, this?

847. Yes? — No, never.

848. (The Coroner.) Have you ever known gas penetrate the return? — No.

849. Have you met it ever in the return? — No.

850. Have you come across it in the returns? — No, not here; not at all.

851. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Have you ever had complaints made to you of ventilation in your district? — No.

852. Have you ever made any complaints? — No.

853. Do you examine the returns? — No, I do not frequently make an examination of them.

854. You simply come down the main intake, as I understand you? — Yes.

855. Do you come down that intake also? (pointing) — This one?

856. The Western one? — No.

857. The travelling way — did you come down here? — Not that day, we did not. I go that way betimes just to see that all is right in that way.

858. (The Coroner.) You mean the return? — No; the second travelling way.

859. Who does examine the returns? — The master wasteman.

860. The master wasteman and nobody else? — Yes.

861. Who would examine these returns? — The master wasteman.

862. Who would examine that? — I examined that.

863. You did examine that? — Round about this when I take this district.

864. Who is the master wasteman? — Joseph Spence.

865. You did examine that return, did you? — Yes.

866. That is the way you came back, I suppose? — But not on that day.

867. Is not it your duty to examine it? — No.

868. I only put the question generally. As far as you know the returns, have you ever found them foul with gas? — Never.

869. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) "Travel from time to time the main returns, in order to make myself acquainted ---" About how often did you examine the main return? — Once in twelve months.

870. What condition is that in at present? — Good.

870a. Are these pillars of coal standing? — Yes.

871. With the stall reads through them? — Yes.

872. Are any of these stall roads closed up? — Well, there may be some of the back pillars.

873. Are most of those open? — Yes.

874. The whole way round? — Yes.

875. Is there ventilation through them? — Yes.

876. How is the ventilation carried through those? — By these roads. We have scales on purpose to scale these back pillars.

877. Does anybody ever go over all these roads? — By the back pillars?

878. Yes, by the back pillars? — We cannot do that very well.

879. Why not? — They are part of them fallen.

880. Part of them fallen? — Yes.

881. Then it is impossible to get ready ventilation through them? — Well, the wind works through them.

882. But it cannot work through them very perfectly? — No.

883. Suppose there was gas collected, we will say there, in the middle of those old pillars, come out of the coal there, that would gradually fill the whole place, I suppose? — No, it would come away on to the return here.

884. How would she be forced on to the return? — The scales that are left upon these stavings are filled up to the returns. It would never get to this place at all.

885. At what point would it get into the return? — Here (pointing).

886. At the south east corner? — Of the third east way.

887. Have you ever made any examination of the returns here, to see if there was gas coming from those old pillars? — Oh, yes, many times here.

888. Did you ever find any? — No, never.

889. What do the arrows show along that third east way?

(The Coroner.) Perhaps, Mr. Stratton, you will say what the arrows mean.

(Mr. Stratton.) The arrows just show that wind goes through those roads. The wind just goes through.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) And where there are no arrows, are we to take it that no air goes?

(The Coroner.) So far as Mr. Stratton knows, no air goes along outside. Is that so?

(The Witness.) The bulk of the wind goes round this way.

(Mr. Stratton.) I was only referring to the goafs in my statement.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Yes, but I am asking Mr. Carr now about what those arrows are?

(Mr. Stratton.) He is not responsible for the arrows.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) But your answer is correct, is it, that those arrows show where the air comes along?

(Mr. Stratton.) Yes, through those goafs.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) I do not mean those on the goaf.

(Mr. Stratton.) Those arrows merely show the general direction of the air current. They do not show anything particular at all. The general air current comes along in that direction.

890. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Suppose there was gas there ; I suppose it would spread itself in every direction? — Yes.

891. Then you say it is got rid of, because whenever it gets to the circumference of the circle, in whatever direction it is met by an air current, which sweeps it away and brings it into this return at the southeast point? — Yes.

892. That is your answer? — Yes.

893. And you say you never found gas in the return at that point? — Yes.

893a. Is your district entirely separated from all the other districts of the mine? — Yes.

894. Separate ventilation? — Yes.

895. By a separate intake? — Yes.

896. And a separate return? — Yes.

897. Is it an entirely separate panel of the mine? — Yes.

898. Suppose the explosion occurred in your district, the No. 1 Hutton seam, could that communicate with the Maudlin? — No.

899. No? — By the vacant place round there.

900. By breaking a place? — By the vacant place betwixt the shafts.

901. There is a communication? — Yes.

902. Then they are not separate panels? — No.

903. (The Coroner.) What do they call the communication between the Maudlin seam and yours? — The way to No. 3 pit.

904. Staple, or what? — No, it is the main road.

905. A travelling road? — Yes.

906. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Then there is nothing at all to prevent an explosion which began in your district spreading in the Maudlin seam, and nothing to prevent an explosion which began in the Maudlin seam spreading into your district? — It might injure both.

907. Is there any communication between your district and any other district besides the Maudlin? — A way to No. 3 pit, there is.

908. Into No. 3? — Yes, a way from No. 1 pit.

909. Is there any into No. 2? — No.

910. Impossible for the explosion to get into No. 2 from yours? — Not if it takes the shaft with it.

911. Could the explosion get into No. 2 from the Maudlin? — Well, not well, I think.

912. Have you been over the mine since the explosion happened? — No, not all over.

913. Over your own district? — Not all over.

914. Which part? You have been over the southeast part next the far off? — The far off way.

915. Have you been able to form any opinion as to where the explosion first occurred in the mine? — No.

916. None whatever; not even whether it first occurred in your own district? — No.

917. Was there an explosion in your judgment in your own district? I do not say whether it was the first or the second? — No.

918. You think there was no explosion there? — I think not.

919. No explosion at all, you think — in no part of your district? — No.

920. Then it must have come from the Maudlin, I suppose? — I am not going to say where it came from.

920a. If it did not come from your district, where else could it have come from so as to come into your district? Could it have come from No. 2 district? — No, it would not have come from No. 2 very well.

921. Where could it have come from? I am not asking you to say which one it came from ; but mention all the parts from some one of which you think it might have come into your district? — Well, I am not prepared to answer that.

922. It is a question easy to answer — that you must answer; because the mine is composed of certain districts; from some of them it could have come to yours, and from some it could not. I am not asking you the fact? — I think she has come from the Maudlin side.

923. From the Maudlin side, you think? — Yes, but I cannot tell what part.

924. You cannot tell what seam? — No.

925. (The Coroner.) Have you formed any opinion as to where it did come from? — No, none at all.

926. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) You have expressed the opinion that it probably did come from the Maudlin side. From what vein in the mine you express no opinion? — I cannot tell.

927. Suppose it came from the Maudlin side, how could it have got into your district — along what way? — This way (pointing).

928. Can you trace it from the Maudlin side a little closer? — Well, as far as I can — into the No. 1 pit.

929. It would have to get into No. 1 pit, I suppose, to come into yours? — Yes; it would come this way, along this way (pointing).

930. Are there no indications of doors blown down, and that sort of thing? Were there any indications of doors blown away, or anything of that sort in your district? — Yes, there were doors blown away.

931. Which direction were they blown — towards the far-off, or away from the far-off?

932. (The Coroner.) Were you one of the exploring party? — No.

933. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Which way were they blown — towards the far-off, or away from the far-off? — They were blown towards the far-off.

934. Is that the case all along? — Yes.

935. Were there any doors blown away from this part (pointing)? — No.

936. Just tell us shortly what is your reason for saying — what are your grounds for saying — that there was no explosion in your district? — Well, my opinion is that according to the indications shown she has come in, however.

937. (The Coroner.) There is no sign that the explosion ever came out? — No.

938. All the signs are that the explosion came in? — Yes.

939. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Do you mean that it has come in the whole of the way into your district? — Well, I think so.

940. Whereabouts are the indications that you speak of? Where do the indications of its coming into your district begin? — It begins there (pointing).

941. What is the one there? What is the indication there? — Of course the indications there were the tubs blown.

942. That is the first indication ; and those indications continue throughout the whole of your district? — Yes, as far as I can tell.

943. As far as you have been. No one has been over this part, as I understand — the eastward part? — No.

944. Just attend to this. We have your books. From June 24th to August 15th, there are only three reports of gas in your book, by yourself? — Yes.

945. During the same time pretty nearly — from June 10th to August 15th — Spence ; he was your back overman, was not he? — Yes.

946. He makes dozens of reports of gas; but when we come to the next man after him — when we come to Wile — he makes no reports at all. Can you account for that — no reports of gas at all? — Because Wile is very seldom in this district.

947. And the district he is in? — He is in that one (pointing).

948. Wile is in your district ; and what is the district that Spence is in? — Spence is generally in this — the third east.

949. (The Coroner.) Then you say that the reason is that Wile's district has been comparatively cleaner than Spence's district? — Yes.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) That is the answer.

950. (Mr. Jones.) I have only to ask you a few questions. How long does it take you to go through all the workings in your district? — What, south-east and far-off.

951. Yes, the whole of your district? — It would take me a good bit.

952. I am only asking you approximately. It would take you several days, I suppose? — Eight hours nearly.

953. To go through all the workings? — Yes.

953a. Of the whole district? — Yes.

954. I suppose, as a matter of fact, you never go through more than a small portion on each occasion? — Oh, no. This district is only a small portion to do — the far-off.

955. Yes; but you have the superintendence of the whole of the Hutton? — Yes.

956. The No. 1 Hutton, is not it? — Yes.

957. Well, I am asking you how long will it take you to go through all the working of No. 1 Hutton? — Well, eight hours.

958. Eight hours? — Yes; I never have done it — not to go through all.

959. How often do you make an inspection? How often do you go over the working? — Every day, a portion.

960. Every day you go over a portion? — Yes.

961. And how long an interval will there be between your having gone over any particular portion, from the first? — Well, it is travelled every day, a portion of the pit.

962. Yes, I know; but how long will you leave a portion unvisited — take it the longest? — The longest will not be over eight hours.

963. You do not understand my question, perhaps. How long an interval elapses from your having examined any particular part of the district? — Before it is examined again?

964. Before it is examined again? — Well, I think nearly eight hours.

965. By yourself, understand? — By myself — all?

966. Yes, I am asking you as to your examination? — Well, the biggest portion of this I see every day.

967. Well, of any portion. How long a time will elapse from the examination of that portion to its next examination by you? Will a week pass? — No.

968. Will three or four days? — No.

969. Well, tell me as nearly as you can? — Eighteen or twenty hours, maybe.

970. You spoke about the gas coming off in a blower from the goaf — what makes you conclude it was a blower? I think you said this goaf — down at the bottom here. You had seen gas come off; you say it was from a blower? — Well, I cannot say rightly what it comes from.

971. Might it not as well be gas coming off from the accumulation in the goaf? — Well, it might be.

972. It might be, just as well? — Yes.

973. What is between the return air-way and the goaf — the returns and the goaf? Take that bottom goaf? — What is there between?

974. What is between? — I do not understand.

975. Are there any workings between the return air-way and the goaf? — Oh, yes.

976. There are workings between? — Yes.

977. Then I may take it that there is no air-way sweeping the goaf? — Yes.

978. Not at the edges of the goaf? — Yes.

979. But you have the air-way between? — There is an air-way goes round the goaf and sweeps the goaf, out of the way of the workings, altogether clear of the workings.

980. Are there any workings between the air-way that sweeps the goaf and the goaf itself? — There is not.

981. Will you point out there where the last workings are next the goaf — how near to the goaf the workings run? — There is the workings (pointing.)

982. Now, where is the air-way? — There is the air-way comes there, round about by that.

983. Can you go all round there? — Yes.

984. Point out all round? — To that point.

985. Point out the workings first, and then point out the air-way as you go round? — The workings are there; and this is the air-way. It comes right round there, and the working is there; and we come here with the air-way. She works herself out up by the main air-way into the return here.

986. Are there any workings there at the upper part between the air-way and the goaf? — No; not at present.

987. Then what is that that is there? — This is the goaf here.

988. Yes, I know — but next the goaf? — This?

989. Yes; it is not? — It is not working at the present.

990. Pillars have been left? — Yes.

991. How long is it since they were worked? — About six months.

992. This air-way runs in front of them, does it? — In here.

993. Well, show me, next, those parts that are not working — where is the air-way there? — It would be alongside this goaf, and works into this return.

994. Are there pillars left, then, in the part that is unworked? — In here.

995. Yes? — Yes.

996. Will you go to the other goaf, and will you tell me there (you see the large goaf) will you tell me there whether there are any workings between the air-ways — the return air-ways? — No; there is not.

997. Now, in any part of any of those goafs — are there no workings between the goaf and the air-way? — No.

998. You are quite sure of that? — Sure of that.

999. That the goaf is immediately swept by the airway? — Yes.

999a. Will you come down lower, please, towards the largest goaf, and you see there is a part there which is not marked — there is no plan on it. What is that? There are no workings above the goaf, next to the goaf; that space — what is that, where there are no marks there? What does that consist of? — This here? (pointing.)

1,000. Will you take the blank space in between the goaf and the workings? — This here?

(The Coroner.) No; between the goaf and the workings.

1,001. (Mr. Jones.) What is that? — That is a barrier left between this goaf and this main way.

1,002. What does it consist of? — Coal.

1,003. A large piece of whole coal? — Yes.

1,004. Will you show me where the air-way is — is that red the intake? — That is the air-way.

1,005. That is the return, I mean? — Yes; and that (pointing) is the intake.

1,006. What is that on the other side of the return — this side of the return? — This one?

1,007. No ; the lower — what are those; are those working? — Yes; these pillars have been worked, and the wind comes round this way. There is an air-way round here.

1,008. Is the air-way marked there? — No; it is not marked, but it comes round this way.

1,009. Are you quite sure of that? — Certain of it.

1,010. Where does that join the main air-way? — There (pointing).

1,011. Then show me how it travels? — It comes away there.

1,012. Yes, I see that. I want the air-way at the limit of the workings? — It goes in here and comes round there.

1,013. Show me how it travels? — Do you see that (pointing)?

1,014. Yes. Now, come up more this way to your left — what is that? — That is the main air-way.

1,015. Yes; but below that — is there an air-way there? — No.

1,016. No air-way there? — No.

1,017. Then those are workings? — Those places are stoved there.

1,018. Those are workings there? — No working place there.

1,019. What is that? — Just the hole round the pillars left.

1,020. Then it has been worked out? — No; it has not been worked out.

1,021. But you have worked bores, have not you, there? — Yes.

1,022. Then leaving the pillars standing? — Leaving the pillars standing.

1,023. There is no air-way between them and the wall, is there? — Yes.

1,024. I understood you to say not? — The wind works round them.

1,025. How does the wind work round them? — It comes away round there.

1,026. Where does it come from? — From this airway.

1,027. But there is no air-way running round? — No main air-way.

1,028. Then it is merely to say that it is the wind that comes off from the air-way. When you spoke about other goafs — do you mean to say that the same thing applies there? — Yes.

1,029. Then there is no air that sweeps along there? — Along here.

1,030. There is no sweep? — No.

1,031. Let me understand you. Is there a sweep round by the goafs? — Yes.

1,032. Are there any workings between the goaf and the sweep anywhere in any of the goafs? — No. I do not understand your sweep.

1,033. Do you understand me? — I do not understand your sweep.

1,034. Well, I mean, of course, a sweeping current of air? — A current of air?

1,035. Sweeping. You know what sweeping is? — There is no working places betwixt the current of air and the return.

1,036. Let me put it to you another way, perhaps you will more clearly understand it. Are all your returns on the edge of the goaf? — Yes.

1,037. On the edge of the goaf? — Yes, that is where the air-way is — it is upon the edge of the goaf.

1,038. The air ways are upon the edge of the goaf? — Yes.

1,039. And in no case are there workings on the edge of the goaf? — Yes.

1,040. Are you certain of that? — Sure of it.

1,041. In no part of that No. 1 Hutton? — No.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) I do not think he understands you. Of course there are workings that come right up to the face of the goaf.

(Mr. Jones.) There are workings?

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Yes. Of course these workings here come right up to the goaf. He did not mean to deny that there were workings that come right on to the face. All he means is that air is carried round the face of them.

1,042. (Mr. Jones.) But you mean that the air comes right round to the face of the workings? — Yes.

1,043. On the goaf? — Yes.

1,044. What sort of state is the mine in — is it dry or damp? — The mine?

1,045. Yes? — Well, we have had wet in there, but this is dry.

1,046. Will you show me how much of the workings there you describe as dry? — This district is all dry; and a portion of that (pointing.)

1,047. Yes, very well. Now higher up? — A portion of that is dry.

1,048. A portion of that is dry? — Yes. We have had wet here.

1,049. And on the other side there — the other side of the goaf going up the other way? — Oh, it is all dry.

1,050. Then there is only a very small part that is wet — that is damp? — A very small part.

1,051. And which is the part of the third east? — The third east.

1,052. Now, will you come from the shaft, please, straight in and show me how far it is dry — coming in from the shaft — how far it is dry? — (pointing.) It is dry in that district, and it is dry away down here, and it is wet there.

1,053. (The Coroner.) You mean it is dry in from the shaft till you come to this point? — Yes.

1,054. (Mr. Jones.) Did you go over the pit after the explosion? — No.

1,055. Over that part? — This part.

1,056. No, over any of the No. 1 Hutton? — This part.

1,057. You have been since the explosion? — Yes.

1,058. In what state did you find the pit then — dry? — Yes.

1,059. After the explosion? — This portion here.

1,060. Did you find any portion that was damp? — That portion we have been to there ; there is water there.

1,061. You went down No. 3 east-way? — Yes.

1,062. Show me where you went there (the witness pointed to the plan). How far did you go and find it dry there? — To that point.

1,063. All the way to that point you found it dry? — Yes.

1,064. How far did you find the force of the explosion extend when you went down? — I think it would be somewhere about this point.

1,065. (The Coroner.) The state of the pit had not been altered before you saw it? — Not down there.

1,066. (Mr. Jones.) It extended to where you say? — There.

1,067. I believe no men were burnt in that part of the pit, were they? — Not that I am aware of.

1,068. You saw many of the men? — Well, I did not see them all.

(The Coroner.) I want evidence Mr. Jones, as to what portion of the pits the men were burnt in, and what part they died from after-damp. We will have to know that.

(Mr. Jones.) He does not know.

1,069. You say it is dry. Do you find there is a good deal of dust — accumulation of dust — in the pit? — Well, not much; there is now since the explosion.

1,070. Since the explosion — yes; but prior to the explosion there was a good deal of fine coal dust about, was there not? — No.

1,071. Well, there was some? — There was some.

1,072. There must necessarily be some, I suppose? — Yes.

1,073. In a dry pit? — There was not much.

1,074. And I believe you never watered the coal dust, did you? — Yes.

1,075. You watered it? — Yes.

1,076. For what reason did you water it? — To keep it wet.

1,077. How often did you water it? — Twice or thrice a week.

1,078. Twice or thrice a week? — Yes.

1,079. In what part? — This road.

1,080. That road? — Yes.

1,081. That would be the in-take? — Yes.

1,082. Then you would not water any other part but the in-take? — Yes, I have done these two. No; no other part but the in-take. It lays the dust, and it makes it much cooler and fresher.

1,083. Twice or thrice a week? — Yes.

1,084. What would be the normal temperature there? — I could not say.

1,085. Sixty? — The temperature?

1,086. Yes; by the thermometer. What was the reading? — Oh, 64.

1,087. Was it a variable temperature in the pit? — Yes, it was very good that day.

1,088. I mean, did it change much — the temperature? — Yes, it changes.

1,089. What are the variations that you read in the temperature. I suppose there were more variations in the in-take than there would be in any other part? — Well, it works from 56, we may say, upwards to 60.

1,090. 56 up to 60? — Yes; I cannot say exactly to a point or two.

1,091. Are you speaking of the in-take now, when you say 56 to 60? — The in-take.

1,092. And you never knew it go below 56? — No, not in my mind at present.

1,093. (The Coroner.) You are not limiting yourself to the point that you examined? You are expressing your opinion generally — not as to any particular point? — No.

1,094. Generally, or which? — Yes.

1,095. That, is, generally?

1,096. (Mr. Jones.) You are speaking generally of the in-take? — Yes.

1,097. Can you give me any idea of the temperature in the workings? I suppose that would be a more fixed temperature? — I cannot give you that.

1,098. Would it be of a higher temperature in the workings than it was in the in-take? I suppose it would be, would not it? — Yes.

1,099. Would it approach 70 in the workings? Was it a warm pit, that part? — I cannot say what it would be exactly.

1,100. You never heard? — No.

1,101. But it is considerably higher than what it is in the in-take? — Yes, it would be high.

1,102. I do not know whether my friend, Mr. Wright, asked you, but can you tell me what the velocity of the air travelling down the intake is? — That is on the main way.

1,103. On the main way? — Something like 64,000, I think.

(The Coroner.) You are speaking of the quantity?

1,104. (Mr. Jones.) I am asking you the speed. Can you tell me the speed — the rapidity at which the air travels? Do you know how many feet it will travel in a second? — Well, I cannot say exactly.

1,105. Perhaps I had better not ask you that, but ask somebody else. But can you give me an approximation at all?

(The Coroner.) You will get it better from the scientific witnesses, I think — Mr. Stratton or somebody.

1,106. (Mr. Jones.) I believe there is a strong current. You can tell me that. Is there not a very strong current? — Yes, a strong current.

1,107. And I suppose it blows the coal dust a good deal, does not it? — Yes.

1,108. (Mr. Edge.) I have only one or two questions to ask. My friend, Mr. Jones, was speaking of the workings, and asking you about the kinds of air. You said there was the in-take air round each place where a man is working in the mine? — A current of air in each in-take.

1,109. Yes? — Where the man is working.

1,110. Yes? — Yes, there is a portion of wind going round where the man is working in the mine.

1,111. (The Coroner.) Carried in by bratticing, is it? — Yes, carried in by bratticing in the whole places and in the broken places it is carried round by the airway.

1,112. (Mr. Edge.) There is no place where a man is actually working in your division of the mine in which there is not this current of air? — No.

(Mr. Jones.) There must be.

(Mr. Edge.) I did not know what my friend meant by it.

1,113. (The Coroner.) I just want to ask you one question. You were asked about visiting the working places. Do either you or the back over-man visit every working place each day, or do you leave some of them unvisited? — Each day there is every one examined.

1,114. They are all visited by you or the back overman? — Yes.

1,115. And that is never omitted? — Never omitted.

1,116. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Just one or two words about the indications that you say you have seen about the explosion coming into your district. One was a tub. What happened to that? — The tub was blown in over.

1,117. What was the indication that you saw of the same thing? — Part of the covering belonging to the back wheel was taken in.

1,118. The big wheel? — Yes.

1,119. That was carried in? — Yes.

1,120. Far? — Well, nearly 20 yards or 25 yards.

1,121. Where was the wheel?

(Mr. Edge.) Mr. Wright, will you ask Mr. Carr whether he saw this himself.

(The Coroner.) That ought to be put, no doubt.

1,122. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) But I am asking him at this moment where was the wheel? — There.

1,123. Did you see the tub on the ground that you say had been blown in? — Yes.

1,124. Did you see it yourself? — Yes.

1,125. More in-bye than it used to be? — Yes.

1,126. Did you see the covering of the wheel yourself? — Yes.

1,127. Did you see it lying more in-bye? — Yes.

1,128. How much more? — About 20 yards in-bye.

1,129. How do you describe the place where the wheel was? — Right at the engine-house.

1,130. (Mr. Bell.) The engine-house is a little off the road, is not it? — The engine-house is there (pointing.)

1,131. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) It is the turn wheel? — Yes.

1,132. Just point out exactly where you saw the covering lying? — The cover was lying just beyond that point.

(The Coroner.) Can you tell the number of pillars?

1,133. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Beyond the entrance to the staples? — Yes.

1,134. (Mr. Bell.) Was it the in-bye side of the entrance of the east and west stables? — Yes.

1,135. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) How much in-bye? — Nearly 20 yards.

1,136. On the main intake? — Yes.

1,137. What was the next indication that you saw yourself? — Well, I did not notice anything particular.

1,138. Only those two things? — Yes.

1,139. Was there anything burnt in your part of the mine. Were the timbers burnt? — No.

1,140. Not on either side? — No.

1,141. Was there any timber blown outside? — Yes, there was a timber blown out of place.

1,142. Was that in-bye? — Well, there were indications of being blown in-bye.

1,143. Any bricks blown out? — Yes.

1,144. In-bye? — Yes.

1,145. Were there any tramcars blown off? — Yes.

1,146. Which direction did you see them? — In-bye.

1,147. More in-bye than out? — I cannot be certain of that.

1,148. Did you see any hay blown about? — Yes.

1,149. Where did that come from? — I think it came from the stables.

1,150. Just point out where you saw it lying? — I saw some lying the out-bye side of the stables.

1,151. Any on the in-bye side of the stables? — I think there was more in-bye than out-bye.

1,152. More? — Yes, I think there was.

1,153. Did you see the wheel the day before the explosion? — Yes.

1,154. Was it in its right place? — Yes.

1,155. Was the covering over it then? — Yes.

1,156. You saw it yourself? — Yes.

1,157. Did you see the tub on the day before the explosion? — Well, I cannot say that I saw that tub.

1,158. You saw it after? — Yes.

1,159. But you are not sure whether you saw it before?

1,160. (Mr. Edge.) Have you any means of telling where that hay came from? — Well, I know no other place than the stables.

1,161. There are two sets of stables in the pit, are there not? — Well, I think it would be from the east or west side.

1,162. I am not asking you what you think; I am asking you if there are two sets? — Yes.

1,163. Well, the tub that you have spoken of — where had you seen that last? — The tub?

1,164. Yes; where had you seen that before the explosion? — The tub?

1,165. Yes; I thought that you mentioned a tub that was blown in? — Yes, the tub that I see used to stand at the high stables.

1,106. When had you seen it last there? — I saw it there on the 6th.

1,167. On the 6th August? — Yes; I saw a water tub — one that stood there.

1,168. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) The 6th September you mean. Which do you mean — the 6th August or the 6th September? — The 6th September.

1,169. (Mr. Edge.) Do you know whether the hay in the west stable was burnt? — No, the hay in the west stables was not burnt.

1,170. The east stables I should have put to you. Do you know whether the hay in the east stables was burnt? — The hay was burnt in the east stables.

1,171. When did you go down there last? — Well, I cannot say exactly what time it would be, but it was that night some time.

1,172. You mean the night of the 8th? — Yes.

1,173. (Mr. Jones.) Where are the east stables? Point out the east stables? — The east and west stables?

1,174. Did I understand you to say that the hay was burnt there? — In the east stables.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) You are pointing to the wrong ones.

1,175. (Mr. Jones.) Nearly on the in-take? — Yes.

Adjourned for a short time.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print