Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Inquests Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Inquests
/   \

1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster

Inquest Report

Seaham Colliery Inquest, 19th October 1880.

The Londonderry Institute, Seaham Harbour, 19th October 1880.

Third Day.

Present:

Mr. CROFTON MAYNARD, Coroner.

Representatives of Home Office — Mr. R. S. WRIGHT, Barrister; Mr. THOMAS BELL, Mr. WILLIS, and Mr. ATKINSON, Government Inspectors.

Representatives of the Marquis of Londonderry — Mr. JOHN EDGE, Barrister; and Mr. H. B. WRIGHT, Solicitor.

Representatives of the National Miners' Association — Mr. ATHERLEY JONES, Barrister; Mr. BOWEY and Mr. MARSHALL, Solicitors.

(The Coroner) in opening the proceedings said I think, as we cannot get either Laverick or the brakes men, we had better have the man who made the plan to prove it, and then we might have Mr. Stratton to explain the plan, and the different systems of working the coal.

Mr. George Bowden sworn and examined.

457. (The Coroner.) What are you? — A surveyor and draughtsman.

458. Where do you live? — Wardley.

459. Where is that? — Three miles this side of Gateshead.

460. Did you yourself make that plan (pointing to the plan)? — I did.

461. What is it a plan of? — It is a plan of the workings of Seaham Colliery.

462. What did you make it from? — I compiled it from the old plans of the colliery — the working plans.

463. And is it a proper representation? — It is.

464. And you do not know anything as to what is below? — I did it from the plans.

465. Not from any survey? — No.

466. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) From whom did you get the working plans? — From Mr. Stratton.

467. He is here, I suppose? — He is.

468. Do you know anything, except what he told you and showed you? — Nothing, except from the plans, and what he told me himself; that is all.

469. (Mr. Jones.) Perhaps you will state what the scale of the plan is? — It is a scale of 25 inches to a mile — 1/25 hundredths. It is the Government scale, 25.344 to the mile, or 1/25 hundredths natural scale.

Mr. Thomas Henry Marshall Stratton sworn and examined.

470. (The Coroner.) What are you? — The colliery manager.

471. Of the whole of these pits? — Of the whole of Seaham Colliery.

472. Which consists of what number of pits? — There are 3 pits — No. 1, No. 2, and No. 3.

472a. Does that plan there represent the whole of the pits? — Not the whole of the workings; only those relating to the explosion.

473. Will you explain to what extent they represent them? — They represent all upon the level — upon the "hanging-on" of the Hutton seam. The coals are drawn upon the level of No. 1 and 3 pits.

474. What portions of the workings are outside of that plan? — The main coal seam is above the level of that "hanging-on."

475. Is anything else excluded from the plan? — No. 2 of the Hutton seam is below the level of that "hanging-on."

476. Then why are they excluded from the plan? — Because those portions underlie the particular portions of that plan. You could not show that portion and all the others on the same plan.

477. Did not we agree, Mr. Jones, that the main coal seam and No. 2 pit were outside the places where the explosion occurred?

(Mr. Edge.) They were not affected by the explosion.

(The Coroner.) The whole of the men were got out of those two places alive?

(Mr. Bowey.) I think that was so.

(Mr. Jones.) I think that is so.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) We may take it subject to anything that may occur hereafter. There was very little evidence taken on the last occasion. I think it would hardly go to show that no other part of the plan would be material. I have seen the transcript of the notes.

(The Coroner.) Now, if that is so, you, Mr. Stratton, can go on to explain what is now before the Court. I certainly said we should require the connections between the different places shown. (A small section was here handed in to the Coroner.)

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) A note cannot be taken, and it is impossible to explain or record what the witness has said in the absence of a vertical section like this.

(Mr. Jones.) We cannot properly prove this plan without having some better guidance.

(Mr. H. S. Wright.) Nothing is intelligible without it.

(Mr. Jones.) Cannot you make a tracing for our use, and that of Mr. Wright, Mr. Edge?

(The Coroner.) You see, Mr. Edge, we want those connecting links as decided at the last inquiry; and if I continue Mr. Stratton's examination without those connecting links, we shall have his examination put twice over.

(Mr. Edge.) I hope it will not be necessary. We have sent up for the tracings, and they will be down soon. If you like, I will examine the witness on the present plan, and by that time you may have tracings.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) We cannot follow it without a tracing.

(Mr. Jones.) I am utterly unable to follow it.

(Mr. Edge.) We need not go into the vertical section until the tracings are done.

(Mr. R. S. Wright, referring to the plan at this moment). That plan may be suspended at any point in the air.

(The Coroner.) It is all shown on one level.

(Mr. Stratton.) It is, practically so.

(The Coroner.) But there are connecting links. What I propose is that you should begin from the surface and go to your working pits, taking your connecting links as you go down, and then we will understand the whole thing.

(Mr. Jones.) And that can only be done with a series of plans.

(The Coroner.) That plan and the sectional plan will do. Mr. Stratton might pass the main coal, and go on to the next unless anyone wished the main coal further to be shown, or hereafter it became necessary to do so.

(Mr. Edge.) Do you wish the colliery plans to be sent for?

(The Coroner.) If all parties are agreed I have no objection, although it might be informal, but I should not do so unless all parties were agreed.

(Mr. Edge.) If at any time it becomes material, owing to any question, the colliery plan would be sent for directly. So far as I can see I do not see that it is necessary.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Are the plans at the colliery office?

(Mr. Edge.) Yes, at the colliery.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Would there be any objection to our seeing them?

(Mr. Edge.) None.

(Mr. Jones.) That would be the more satisfactory course.

(Mr. H. B. Wright.) At the last enquiry I offered to do any plans that were necessary, and it was suggested that any plans that the Government Inspector thought it was necessary to make should be done.

(The Coroner.) But with this further stipulation, which I put in myself, that we must have connecting links from the different seams.

(Mr. Willis, referring to vertical plan.) Which that gives you; the more plans we have, the more we will be confused.

(The Coroner.) That is so. My difficulty is with the going on with Mr. Stratton's examination without the connecting links, as he will have to be examined over again, and it will confuse us altogether.

(Mr. Edge.) I think this would enable us to meet your objection.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Yes, if we had half-a-dozen copies.

(Mr. Bell.) The vertical section might be put against the plan of the workings up there.

(The Coroner.) I find a difficulty in seeing that section which Mr. Stratton has placed against the larger plan.

(Mr. Jones.) I cannot make much of that from here. Mr. Edge might undertake to supply us with a reduced scale of the large plan and also copies of the vertical section which he has now put up.

(Mr. Edge.) We can give you a tracing of the copies, but not on the reduced scale.

(Mr. Willis.) It will take too long time to do that.

(Mr. Jones.) Perhaps you have a plan on the reduced scale.

(Mr. Edge.) You have had a large tracing that we are using.

(Mr. Jones.) Yes, we have this large tracing.

(The Coroner to Mr. Stratton.) Tell us what the pit consists of, beginning at the top; and tell us all about the different arrangements which are carried out.

(Mr. Stratton.) There are two shafts, No. 1, and No. 2, and No. 3.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) I would suggest that this proof of Mr. Stratton's should be read, and if we had the necessary plans to elucidate it, that would be satisfactory.

(The Coroner.) Do you see any objection to that course, Mr. Edge or Mr. Jones?

(Mr. Jones.) No, I see no objection to that course. The only thing I think, is, that we shall probably at the end of the rehearsal, be as wise as we were at the beginning.

(Mr. H. B. Wright.) It is a matter that will take some time to get what we want.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) What was done at Risca certainly saved some time. A gentleman who was in the same position as Mr. Stratton, as manager of the mine, brought a written statement of the whole of the management of the mine, which was simply read out, and after that we saw how far it was defective, and cross-examined him as to the defects, and we got him to supply what was desired. That was the plan that was pursued at Risca, and it would probably be the best plan to follow here.

(Mr. Edge.) I propose to do that by the examination of Mr. Stratton.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Would not it be much simpler if the whole thing were read out?

(Mr. Jones.) I take no objection to that course.

(Mr. Edge.) I propose to take Mr. Stratton straight through the proof of his evidence.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Why not read it out?

(Mr. Edge.) I want to ask Mr. Stratton to point out the different places, because otherwise the plan would be unintelligible, and the jury would not understand it.

(Here it was agreed that Mr. Edge should go through the proof of Mr. Stratton's evidence, and the witness then described the various parts mentioned in that statement).

The following is the statement referred to "Thomas Henry Marshall Stratton": "I am the certificated manager of Seaham Colliery, and have occupied that position for 6½ years. Seaham Colliery is one of Lord Londonderry's collieries ; this colliery is worked by 2 shafts, which are known as Nos. 1, 2, and 3 pits. Nos. 1 and 2 pits are entered by the same shaft, which is bratticed in the centre, and the shaft of No. 3 pit is at a distance of about 150 yards to the westward of the shaft of Nos. 1 and 2 pits. The shaft of Nos. 1 and 2 pits is the downcast shaft of the entire colliery, and No. 1 the upcast shaft. The colliery works coal from the following seams : — Main coal, Maudlin, and Hutton. No. 1 pit draws coal from the level of the Hutton seam; the same shaft is sunk to the Harvey seam. The main coal is at a depth of 218 fathoms, the Maudlin being at a depth of 227 fathoms, and the Hutton at a depth of 255 fathoms, and the Harvey at a depth of 281 fathoms. No. 2 pit also works the Hutton seam, but there is a trouble about 150 yards to the north of the shaft, and in consequence of it the coals are drawn from the level of the Harvey seam, and there is a drift from the Harvey seam to the Hutton seam. No. 3 pit shaft is sunk to the level of the Hutton seam. At that level coals are brought or hung from the main coal, Maudlin, and Hutton seams. The main coals are brought down to the level of the Hutton seam by means of a drop staple, situated about 250 yards from the shaft of No. 3 pit. The Maudlin coals are brought up through a drift from the north side of the dip trouble by a drift through the trouble. Hutton seam coals only are drawn at the shafts of the pits Nos. 1 and 2; but at the No. 3 shaft both main, Maudlin, and Hutton seam coals are drawn. I produce a plan on which is shown the workings of the Hutton seam of the No. 1 pit, the Hutton seam of No. 3 pit, and the Maudlin seam and the north main coal seam. Seaham Colliery is ventilated by means of furnaces and boiler fires. We have two furnaces, both situate on the level of the Hutton seam. I produce a section shewing the general arrangement of the furnaces. No. 3 pit furnace is situate close to No. 3 pit shaft; there is a separate staple for the furnace, which reaches 8 fathoms above the main coal seam. This staple is connected with the shaft by means of a slope drift. No. 1 pit furnace is also situated in the Hutton seam, close to No. 1 pit shaft; it has a separate staple, which, reaching to the main coal seam, communicates with No. 3 pit shaft by means of a long smoke drift in the main coal seam. This smoke drift rises abruptly towards the end, and comes into the shaft just opposite the No. 3 pit furnace staple drift. The ventilation is further assisted by means of boiler fires; three of these boilers are situate close to No. 1 pit furnace. Only two of them are usually at work; these are at work commonly about 14 hours a day. The smoke from these boilers goes up to the No. 1 pit furnace staple. No. 1 pit boilers are situate on the opposite side of No. 1 pit shaft, and are about 30 yards distant from the shaft. These are also 3 in number, of which only 2 are usually at work; these boilers are at work about 21 hours a day. The smoke from these boilers goes by a rise drift close past No. 1 pit shaft into the seam, when it goes along a level drift into No. 1 furnace staple. Besides these boilers we have two semi-portable engines; one, called the Maudlin engine, standing about 100 yards from No. 3 pit shaft, the smoke from which goes direct into No. 3 pit furnace staple by means of a smoke drift driven above the Hutton seam. The other portable engine stands close by No. 3 pit shaft; it is called the No. 3 pit Hutton seam engine. Its smoke goes direct into the furnace staple at a level with the furnace. Neither of these latter can be said to assist the ventilation at all. By means of these furnaces and boilers a large ventilating current is produced. The total air current will average from 320,000 to 330,000 cubic feet per minute; this current is divided into a great number of splits; these are measured fortnightly by the master wasteman and recorded in a book kept at the office. I produce ventilation book; the total of the last fortnightly measurement previous to the explosion, 316,579 cubic feet. Of this total quantity 78,620 feet went into No. 1 pit. No. 1 boiler fires, &c., &c., took 14,000 feet of this quantity, leaving 64,620 cubic feet per minute available for ventilating the workings. This total quantity is further split in-bye, as circumstances will direct. The total quantity of air going into No. 2 pit is 87,883 cubic feet per minute; of this quantity 13,243 feet circulates round the Harvey seam, the No. 2 engine house, and returns up the steam drift to No. 1 pit furnace; the remainder, 74,640 feet, goes in-bye, and is available for ventilating the workings. No. 3 pit, Hutton seam, is ventilated from No. 1 pit shaft, the air being taken round a curved drift past the Maudlin engine in the direction of the main coal staple, being shut off No. 3 pit shaft by means of separation doors. There are two main splits in the Hutton seam — the old Hutton seam incline, which has not been at work for 6 months, getting 12,960 feet, and the south way Hutton seam, getting 13,600 feet. The north main coal receives its air off the main intake at a point about 100 yards past the Maudlin engine. This air, amounting to 6,930, works round the water standage and goes into the north main coal, works round the north main coal, and returns up to No. 1 pit furnace. The Maudlin engine also takes about 1,500 feet per minute. In order to keep No. 3 shaft bottom cool, scales and leakage of doors amount to 24,780 feet. These together form a united current of 59,850 feet at a point on the in-bye side of the curve leading from No. 1 shaft and to No. 3 shaft. This current is measured each fortnight at this point. The Maudlin seam obtains its air from No. 1 pit shaft by means of two drifts, one, commonly called the travelling way, leading direct from No. 1 pit shaft; the other, or engine plane, obtaining air from the main current at the inbye end of the curved drift before mentioned; this pit has 45,676 cubic feet per minute going in-bye, which is also subdivided at different points. The air returns to No. 1 pit furnace joining the north main coal and No. 2 Hutton seam air at a point about 120 yards from the furnace. The main coal seam obtains its air from No. 1 pit shaft at the main coal seam; 37,074 cubic feet per minute is the quantity going into the main coal workings; it returns to the No. 3 pit shaft at the main coal. The west Maudlin, a small district at one time worked from the main coal staple, obtains 7,476 feet per minute over and above the current of 37,074. This current, after working round the west Maudlin, returns to No. 3 pit at the Maudlin seam. With the exception of those two currents of 37,074 and 7,476, and of the leakages at the bottom of No. 3 pit shaft, all the air passes up the furnace staple either at No. 1 or No. 3 pits in about equal quantities. On the plan produced the intake is shewn by a blue colour, and the return by a crimson colour."

(The Coroner.) The intakes are coloured blue, and the returns are coloured red on that map? — Yes.

478. You might put in the situation of the goafs? — They are all marked on the plan.

479. Give us the situation of the goafs shortly? — There is a goaf on the west side of No. 1 Rolley Way, but it may be called the Old West goaf, but that might be the term for it.

480. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Is not it called the Gas Goaf? — No; I never heard it called that, it is on the west side of the No. 1 engine plane.

481. (The Coroner.) Give us the situation of the intake, and your return, so far as that goaf is concerned? — The intake goes in a southerly direction into the No. 1 pit.

482. I want the situation of the intakes and returns — the distance from the goaf? — I have a scale from Mr. Corbett.

483. Did you make it yourself? — No; I did not make it myself.

484. (Mr. Edge.) If the witness says, "I now deal with No. 1 Hutton seam pit, it would be better"? — It is 220 yards from the engine plane to the nearest point on No. 1 pit.

485. (The Coroner.) This is the intake? — Yes.

486. How about the return? — The return is an average of 40 yards from that goaf edge at that point.

487. What is between that goaf and the return? — There is another road between that road and the return.

488. What else? — That is all; a pillar of coal between, and another road.

489. Pass on to the next goaf? — This is the next goaf, (pointing to map). It goes by the name of the Polka goaf. It is the nearest point from the No. 1 engine plane, about 120 yards.

490. From the intake, or the return? — From the engine plane — from the intake — the return is between.

491. What distance is your return from the edge of the goaf? — About 44 yards.

492. What extent is the goaf? — About 1,000 square chains, that is, about 100 acres. The Old West goaf is about 23 acres.

493. You go from the No. 1, Hutton seam? — From the same goafs; but there is a goaf in the Hutton seam — the same pit No. 1 — one is called the Old Hitch Way goaf; and the other the Far Off goaf. There will be about 200 acres in the Far Off goaf, and in the Hitch Way Goaf about 135 acres.

494. Is your working place carried up to that goaf? — I am only giving you a rough estimate, you must understand.

495. What is there between this goaf and that working place? — Nothing they are working the goaf — they are laying down the goaf all along the Far Off Way.

496. Let us have that goaf? — There is lying against the same trouble a goaf called the Third East Way goaf; it is not of any great extent; it is about 9 acres.

497. Are you working up to it? — We are working to the broken there all along.

498. Close up to it? — Yes.

499. Does that finish No. 1? — Yes; as far as the goafs are concerned.

500. Now, let us get the goafs finished in the Maudlin seam? — This (pointing to the map) is the Old West Way goaf. It is about 22 acres in extent; but north of this goaf here is another goaf; called the Inclined South-side Long Wall.

501. Are you working up to it? — Yes; it is working long wall, and they go through it.

502. Where are your returns and intakes then? — The intake is on the line coloured blue (pointing).

503. At what distance between the returns and the goaf? — In the case of the West Way goaf there is 176 yards between the intake and the goaf.

504. What is between? — Pillars of coal.

505. Is it worked up to the goaf? — Yes; the pillars are worked up to the goaf. These were pillars originally.

506. Now, there is another small goaf down here? — Yes; there is one about six acres of long wall goaf, a little to the north (pointing).

507. How are your returns in the pit? — The returns go off the long wall there (pointing) but the intake is 132 yards.

508. And the return goafs are in the long wall working? — Yes; in this direction on each side (pointing). This is called the Old Way Broken. There is about five acres of it. There is the intake (pointing). The distance from the intake is 140 yards.

509. Where is the return? — The return is between — midway — about 70 yards.

510. (Mr. Bell.) There is one small piece more. Along the wall ; about an acre.

(The Coroner.) Now, I think you had better finish your statement, and go on to what you did.

(Mr. Jones.) Before we go further, I was thinking that the course would be, subject to what your opinion may be, that all the evidence with regard to the accident should be deferred on the part of Mr. Stratton.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) We settled that his statement should be put in.

(Mr. Jones.) I thought it was only to be put in, so far as regards the working of the mine.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) It does not matter, whether it is printed in three pieces or one.

(Mr. Jones.) I thought it should be deferred until after we heard the other witnesses — I mean that Mr. Stratton should be taken last.

(The Coroner.) As to what he did

(Mr. Jones.) As to the explosion.

(Mr. Edge.) I think that would be convenient ; we should then get consecutive evidence. At present Mr. Stratton can only give imperfect evidence as to the state of the Maudlin.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) I do not care the least which way you do it.

(The Coroner.) You have one section of his evidence up to this point; if you do not wish to enter upon that until afterwards, I do not wish to press it.

(Mr. Edge.) I think it would save time to defer it, because, if we go into this part at present, we shall have to call Mr. Stratton hereafter, when the Maudlin has been examined, and then we shall have to go over a great deal of this to refresh, not only our minds, but the minds of the jury.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Of course, when I ask Mr. Stratton questions, I shall have to ask what he knows and thinks about the state of the mine, and the cause of the explosion.

(The Coroner.) I think both Mr. Jones and Mr. Edge are agreed that it would be better to defer this part of the examination.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Very well.

(Mr. Bell.) I thought he was simply going to state how he found the mine when he went down the first thing.

(The Coroner.) Probably, Mr. Wright, you would wish to postpone the examination of Mr. Stratton until to-morrow.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) I really should like it.

(The Coroner.) And the same thing will apply to you, Mr. Jones?

(Mr. Jones.) Yes.

(The Coroner.) I will do the same. I have made some minutes as to some points on which I should like to ask a question or two, but I will defer the thing until we get thoroughly into the mine.

(Mr. Edge.) I think that will be better; it will save time, because hereafter we shall have to go over the ground again.

(Mr. Jones.) I thought it would be better to take the workmen first, and take the officials afterwards.

(The Coroner.) Whom do you propose to call?

(Mr. Jones.) We have not any witnesses whom we shall call, but I suppose some of the workmen will be called by Mr. Edge.

(The Coroner.) At the last hearing, I asked the workmen if there were any of them who wished to give evidence — any of those who were got alive out of the pit. And I ask now, if there are any who wish to give evidence as to the state of the pit before the explosion. If there are, I am willing to take their evidence before I take the official evidence; that is, if you have any who are ready to be examined.

(Mr. Jones.) We have not made up our minds as to the evidence we propose to produce at present, until we hear what course the enquiry takes.

(The Coroner.) My position is simply this, I consider that so far as I and the jury are concerned, we are simply like a sheet of clean paper, upon which you, on either side, are to write your view of the case, and bring everything that either of you may think necessary for us to form a proper judgment as to the locality, and how this explosion took place. I cannot say what witnesses should be put in the box, and what should not.

(Mr. Jones.) I am not speaking for myself, as far as any witnesses are concerned that I may call, but I did not know whether it was the intention of the colliery, or of yourself, or of Mr. Wright, to call witnesses who were workmen employed in the colliery. In that case I only suggested that before the official evidence was taken, the evidence of the workmen themselves should be taken.

(The Coroner.) A proclamation has been made at the opening of the Court, that if anybody could give evidence touching the matter in question, they should come forth and they would be heard; that is, if there is any person ready on your part, or anyone you wish to call, I am prepared to examine him.

(Mr. Jones.) That is all I can ask. I did not know whether my friend Mr. Edge intended calling any workman; if so, I would ask that he should call the workmen before he calls the officials.

(The Coroner.) That is the plan that was thought best to be laid down at the commencement, and as far as I can adhere to it, I shall do so — and begin from the workmen and go gradually upwards — but you cannot fix a hard line for an investigation of this sort.

(Mr. Jones.) I am glad to hear you say that.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) The best plan, generally, is to get a general notion of the whole arrangement of the colliery, subject to anything that may be filled in afterwards — merely enough in the first instance to understand what is being talked about; then, after that, the evidence of the men can be taken as to what actually happened so far as you can get at it; and then it can be completed by filling in about the management of the mine.

(Mr. Jones.) If Mr. Edge is going to call workmen.

(The Coroner.) This list that I have is a list of overmen and deputies.

(Mr. Edge.) That is all.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Perhaps, as an introduction to the evidence of the overmen, I may ask the manager a few questions as to the general arrangements.

(The Coroner.) Very well.

511. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) The certificated manager of the mines is yourself?

(The Witness.) Yes.

512. Under you, who is the under-viewer? — Mr. George Turnbull.

513. You have the management of the entire mine? — Yes.

514. Not merely what is shown on the plan, but the whole of the mine? — Yes.

515. He, under you, has the management of the whole mine? — Yes.

516. Next under him come the overmen? — Yes.

517. How many overmen are there? — Four.

518. For the whole mine? — Yes.

519. What are their names? — No. 1 pit, George Carr; No. 2, John Miller; No. 3 pit, Hutton seam and main coal, Thomas Weatherall; Maudlin seam, Robert Barlow.

520. Just point out and describe to me, as well as you can, what the district of George Carr is? — George Carr commences on this shaft (pointing), and goes along the blue lines.

521. Along the in-takes? — Along the in-takes at the working places of the far-off way, and down there in the third east district, the district through this trouble; this district around here (pointing).

522. He takes the whole of No. 1 pit, Hutton seam? — Yes, the working place of the in-takes.

523. Does he take anything else besides the Hutton seam? — Nothing else that I know of.

524. John Miller? — He takes No. 2 pit, Hutton seam, which we have not shown here ; it directly underlies this part of the pit; it could not be shown on the same plan.

525. That is the other side of the trouble? — Yes, the north side of the trouble.

526. He takes nothing but the Hutton seam? — Nothing but the Hutton seam No. 2.

527. George Carr is No. 1 Hutton? — Yes.

528. And John Miller No. 2 Hutton? — Yes.

529. Are they both on the same level? — No.

530. Except so far as the trouble? — Yes, except so far as the trouble goes.

531. Then there is Thomas Weatherall? — He is No. 3 pit, Hutton seam; this part of it (pointing).

532. That is on the same level? — Yes, on the same level.

533. He also takes the main coal? — Yes, at the top of this point.

534. A much higher point? — Yes, 35 fathoms higher up.

535. (The Coroner.) Connected by a staple? — Yes, connected by this staple.

536. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Then Barlow takes the Maudlin? — Yes.

537. And nothing else? — Nothing else.

538. On both sides of the Maudlin? — No. The Maudlin on the other side of the trouble is not a working pit; it has not worked for many years.

539. Who takes the low main? — The same thing applies to it ; it has not been a working pit for many years.

540. On neither side of the trouble? — On neither side of the trouble.

541. Under the overman, I suppose, is the backoverman? — Yes.

542. Have you only one? — We have eight backovermen.

543. Who are under Carr? — Michael Spence and James Wile.

544. Who are under Miller? — William Murray and James Rochester.

545. Who are under Weatherall? — William Scrafton and Edward Harold.

546. Who are under Barlow? — John Greenwell and William Draper.

547. Are all the four overmen alive? — Yes.

548. All that belonged to the mine at the time of the explosion? — They are all alive.

549. Are all the eight back-overmen alive? — Yes.

550. None of them were down the pit at the time? — No; it was in the night shift.

551. Who is the master wasteman? — Joseph Spence.

552. Is there only one master wasteman? — One for the whole colliery.

553. And one master shifter? — No, four master shifters.

554. Who are they? — No. 1 pit was Charles Dawson.

555. No. 1 Hutton seam? — Yes.

556. He is killed, is he? — Yes.

557. Killed in the explosion? — Yes.

558. No. 2 pit — No. 2 Hutton? — William Hartley; he is here.

559. No. 3 pit, Hutton seam main coal? — Anthony Smith.

560. Is he alive? — No, he is dead.

561. He was killed in the explosion? — Yes.

562. No. 4? — Walter Murray; he was also killed.

563. (Mr. Bell.) That is in Maudlin? — Yes.

564. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) How many deputy overmen have you? — Fourteen in No. 1 pit.

565. In No. 2? — In No. 2 we have 12.

566. In No. 3 pit how many? — In No. 3 pit, Hutton seam, four.

567. Only four? — That is all, and in the main coal we have four. There are 14 in the Maudlin seam.

568. When the Court meets again, can you give us a list of the names? — Yes. I may be wrong in the numbers, but I have given them according to my recollection, and I think it is correct.

569. I suppose several of the deputy overmen were killed? — A considerable number were.

570. Perhaps you can furnish us with a list of names showing those who belonged to the pit immediately before the explosion, and showing which were killed in each district? — Yes.

571. (The Coroner.) You mean the officials?

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) The deputy overmen.

(The Witness.) I can tell the names of the killed now.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) There is a considerable number; there would be fifty names, and it would take a long time. I think we ought to examine all the officials that have hitherto been mentioned.

(The Coroner.) I am prepared to examine any man who is called to be examined.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) It would be a very short examination in most cases. — "What part did you go over, and was it in good order"? — It ought to be formally proved.

(The Coroner.) Yes.

572. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) (To Witness.) Below the deputies I suppose in your colliery ; you have no other class of men. Have you fireman? — No.

573. They would be the same as the deputy overmen? — Yes.

574. You have an engineer? — Yes.

575. And an engineman, a brakesman? — Yes.

576. (The Coroner.) You might want the brakesman. Who had charge of the boilers in the engine below? — The engineer.

577. And below him? — The engine-wright and the engine man below him again.

578. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Who is the engineer? — Wilkinson Rowell.

579. How many enginemen and brakesmen are there below? — There are two enginemen in No. 1 pit; in No. 2 pit there is one.

580. You need not trouble about that. By to-morrow you can give us a list of the brakesmen and enginemen.

(The Coroner.) And stating who are alive and who are dead.

581. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Dividing them into the four districts? — There was a pumping engineman — do you require him?

582. Yes. You can suggest the name of anybody who is likely to be able to give information, arranging the names in the four districts which you have given us; it would be convenient to keep the same classification of districts.

(The Coroner.) You will probably be able to cover the whole ground by the reports being put in.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Very likely.

(The Coroner.) The reports, if properly kept, will be lodged, and on their production we shall see what they are.

583. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Very likely. At present I am simply trying to find out what ground there is to cover. At present we will treat the colliery as consisting of four districts: No. 1 Hutton and No. 2 Hutton on the north side of the trouble; No. 3 Hutton seam main coal; No. 4, Maudlin. You can give the names of the enginemen and brakesmen in each district. There were some in each district? — Yes.

584. And some of them were killed I suppose? — One of them is killed I believe.

585. There was no actual engineman killed? — You will understand there were no coals being drawn up at the time, and there was no engineman at the time on the ground. There was a pumping engineman.

586. Was he one of those that came up alive? — The pumping engineman was killed.

587. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) What o'clock did the explosion happen? — I did not hear it. I believe it was exactly at half-past two o'clock.

(The Coroner.) Are we not travelling off the ground?

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) No, I think you will see we are not.

(The Witness.) They called me exactly at 2.30 by my own watch.

588. 2.30 a.m.? — Yes.

589. How many shifts have you in the mine? — Three shifts.

590. From when to when? — From 4.30 a.m., to 11.30 p.m. That is the whole time embracing the three shifts.

591. What are they? — The first is 4 o'clock a.m. to 11.30 a.m.

592. What is the second? — From 10 a.m. to 5.30 p.m.

593. And what is the third? — From 4 p.m. to 11.30 p.m.

594. (Mr. Edge.) What is the name of these shifts? — The fore shift, the back shift, and the night shift.

595. (Mr. Jones.) The fore shift is that beginning at 4.30 a.m.? — Yes.

596. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Are they all coal shifts? — Yes.

597. In all parts of the mine? — In all parts of the mine in question. No. 2 pit is not a double shift; No. 2 pit has only two shifts of men.

598. At the time of the explosion there was no shift down? — No, not a regular order of shift.

599. What was there down at the time of the explosion? — The shifters.

600. Would that be what is called in some places a repairing shift? — Yes.

601. What time would they go down? — Ten o'clock.

602. Ten o'clock p.m.? — Yes.

603. When do they come up? — Six a.m.

604. Is there a separate gang of shifters for each of these four districts? — Yes.

605. How many were down in the colliery altogether at 2 o'clock that morning? — There were 164 lost.

606. 67 came out alive? — That would be about 230. I cannot say off hand.

607. You think about 230 went down? — Yes.

608. And about 67 came up? — Yes.

609. Less than 70 were saved? — Less than 70 were saved.

610. What part of the mine did these 67 who were saved come from? — They came from the main coal seam.

611. In what way were the others distributed — those that were killed — about equally in the Maudlin, Hutton, and Harvey? — No, not quite equally. There were about 65 in No. 1, I think.

612. In No. 2, how many? — There were about 76 in the Maudlin — that is No. 4.

613. (The Coroner.) Are you speaking of your own knowledge? — Just from the number of people that I have got out of the pits. I do not speak from personal knowledge. I did not know the men — I did not see them go down.

614. In No. 2, about how many were there? — Those were saved — there would be about 43 saved.

616. All were saved in No. 2? — Yes.

616. Then in No. 3? — In No. 3, Hutton seam, there were about 23 lost altogether.

617. Were any saved in No 3? — There were four saved.

618. In the main coal they were all saved? — Yes — 19.

619. The seat of the explosion was in Nos. 1, 3, and 4? — Yes.

620. They were the parts supposed, at any rate, to be affected by the explosion? — Yes.

621. As regards No. 3, there were four persons who were actually down at the time of the explosion? — Yes.

622. As regards No. 1, is there any person alive who was down at the time of the explosion? — The onset of Laverick belongs to No. 1.

623. He is the only person? — Yes.

624. Is there any person alive who was down in No. 4? — No.

625. So that there are only five survivors of those who were in the affected parts? — That is all.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Three or four of them were examined the last time.

(The Coroner.) Yes, I think so.

626. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) So that in order to get an account of the state of the mine as late as possible before the explosion, we shall have to call men from the night shift who came up at 11.30 p.m.? — Yes.

627. From Nos. 1 and 4, at any rate? — Yes.

(Mr. Bell.) Six witnesses altogether were examined before.

628. (Mr. R. S. Wright.) Are there any still in the neighbourhood — do you know any number of men who came up from the Maudlin at 11.30 before the explosion? — I should think there would be a very large number.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) Now, I think I know where we are as regards witnesses. I think we had better call some of the overmen now, or you can begin at the bottom.

(The Coroner.) Are there any men to be examined? If so, I will take them. I would rather begin at the bottom and go up.

(Mr. Jones.) Perhaps you (Mr. Wright) will call some of the men who have been mentioned.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) I cannot make up my mind until I have had an opportunity of consulting Mr. Bell and the Coroner. I do not interfere with the course of the witnesses to-day.

(The Coroner.) I have here a list of the only witnesses that are ready to be examined — Turnbull, the underviewer, Spence, the waste man, and a few more of that class.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) To-morrow I shall probably ask the Coroner (with the concurrence of Mr. Bell and Mr. Willis) to call a considerable number of these men on my own responsibility; but at present I have had no opportunity of consulting Mr. Bell upon the course that should be taken. We only met this morning, and I am unable to give any assistance. But if there is nothing else to do I am quite ready to take Mr. Stratton through the general arrangements of the place.

(Mr. Edge.) The over-men can speak as to the general condition of the pit on the 7th. I think we might dispose of them at once.

(Mr. R. S. Wright.) By all means.

(Mr. Jones.) Very well, I assent.

The witness withdrew.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print