1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
Seaham Colliery Inquest, 15th September 1880 (cont.).
Mr. William Cummings examined.
1. (The Coroner.) What are you? — A shifter.
2. When did you go into the pit to work? — Ten o'clock on Tuesday night.
3. That would be the 7th? — The 7th.
4. Where? — High pit, Hutton seam, No. 3.
5. In what locality? — Well, it is south, I think, sir.
6. In the south way? — Yes; it is known as the back of the staple.
7. What number of men were with you? — During the work?
8. Yes? — There were three men working, and two other men.
9. Who were they? — John Mason and George Dixon.
10. What was your work? — Shift work.
11. What was it? — We were lowering the way.
12. Did any fall take place in your locality during your shift? — Not far off.
13. Tell us what you know as to the condition, and everything in the pit during the shift, until the time that the explosion took place? — We were working down the way, and we stopped somewhere about ten minutes past two o'clock to get refreshment; while we were sitting, about twenty minutes past two o'clock, we felt a heavy wind, and small coal flying.
14. From where? — From in-bye over.
15. From where? From the shaft? — From the shaft.
16. What distance were you from the shaft? — About half-a-mile from No. 3; and I had my lamps stuck upon a wooden tub; and I said to the men, "Seize the lamps, for fear any gas come off;" and we seized the lamps and put them under our jackets. John Mason said, "That's a queer fall."
17. Did you hear no sound or anything? — Yes; I heard a report after the wind.
18. Could you tell from where the report came? Could you form any idea? — No; only the sound came in over. I told the men if they wanted to save their lives they must follow me ; and we came to the flat.
19. What flat? — On the south side of No. 3, where the boys put to.
20. The south side flat? — Yes; the south side of the pit. There was a little boy called to me, "Come on, canny man, there is a fall down the bank, and we are almost killed."
21. What bank is that? — This coal lies to the rise, and it was coming down to where the main way is.
22. Is that where the dip is from the Hutton seam to the other? — It is a rise from the old bank, what they call the high bank, the west of it. I told the boy it was a blast in the pit; but he said "Come on and see, we are almost killed." I went with the boy and came to a fall; and I went over the top of the fall, and I remained there as long as a man could remain.
23. Where was the fall? — It was somewhere about thirty or forty yards from what we call the wheel.
24. Is that the out-bye direction, or the in-bye? — The out-bye direction.
25. Was the air pure and clear there? — No, she was very thick.
26. Was that the first time that you found it? — That was the first attempt.
27. Was that the first time that you found the air getting wrong? — No, she was thicker from the place where we were, all the way we were going out. I met two men, and I persuaded them to go back; and they said "This was the way out-bye;" and I told them "If you want to save your lives, take the return; and if we die there, we die through the best escape we have."
28. Did they go with you? — No, sir, not then.
29. Did they eventually go with you? — No.
30. They persisted in going more in-bye? — Yes; more into the stythe. And when we came out further we found a little boy who required further assistance; and there was a man named John Mason who said, "You are the strongest, take him by the hand." I had to retreat back; and I had to put my cap over my mouth before I returned to keep out the stythe. We all persevered until four men and four or five boys went over the fall.
31. That is in to the return? — No; to the shaftward, the main way. I took George Dixon by the hand, and said "George, follow me;" and I expected he was following over the fall; and I said we will have to be where the return is. I know where the return way is, as I had put some wood in that part on Friday night, and we took the prop sides and the wall sides. And Thomas Johnson said "Which turn will you take?" and I said, "The east," and he said, "That will be difficult, for there is a twelve post trouble in that return, and we shall have to travel a good deal in No. 1 return." I said, "Let us take the west return." I expected more men following us ; but when we got there, there were only four of us.
32. You came out by the west return? — Yes.
33. Were you all got out safe? — — Yes.
34. Were you the only ones that got safe out of that seam? — Yes.
35. Was there one explosion, or more than one explosion? — We only heard one heavy brattle.
36. Was it in the seam that you were working in? — Well the report was there.
37. Did you think that the explosion occurred in the seam that you were then in? — We were in a kind of doubt. We were bamboozled.
38. You could not tell that? — No; we could not. When I got far over again. I forgot to tell you that there was a man named Dickinson, who was making very fast into the smoke, and I told him that was the wrong way, and before I got far I heard moans and groans.
39. Now, in that district, how many men were there altogether? — Six coal hewers and six shifters.
40. That was the whole number that were there? — Yes ; and four or five boys — I cannot say whether there were four or five boys.
41. What state of the atmosphere had you when you first went in, and up to the time the explosion occurred? — Up to the time very good. I found no difference in going in. There was no slackness.
42. There was no slackness in the seams so far as you were concerned? — No, not were we were working, sir.
43. That is, according to your idea, you found no want of ventilation in the district in which you were working? — No; perhaps we had more that night because the place had holed.
44. Do you know when that part of the district was last examined? — No; I cannot tell.
45. You cannot tell whether the explosion took place in that locality at all? — No.
46. Can you give us any idea where the explosion took place, or the cause of it? — Well, sir, I could not say what the cause was; and I could not say what took place exactly.
47. Was there anything to arouse your fear before the explosion took place, so far as the district in which you were working was concerned? — No, sir. All that I know is this: Thomas Hindson told me on Monday morning when going in to make refuge holes — that is all that I know.
48. (Mr. Willis.) But what did he tell you? — They were going to make some refuge holes.
49. (The Coroner.) Has there been no complaint of the want of ventilation? — Not where we were.
50. None at all? — None at all; there was good ventilation at that part.
51. (Mr. Bell.) How far were you on the face of the workings? — Somewhere about 80 yards.
52. Is it a whole or broken flat? — It is a barrier taken out, laying between the two pits, and we have to go from the right and left.
53. (The Coroner.) Have you noticed any gas coming off from the goaf? — No, sir; the goaf is quite closed.
54. Are there any extensive removals on the way? — No.
55. (Mr. Bell.) Then you spoke of a place being holed — what place do you mean was holed? — It was a wall driven down. There was a third right end, and this was a second right end; and there was a skirting went along.
56. Did that take the ventilation nearer the face? — Yes.
57. This heavy fall that you speak of is in the rolley way? — Yes; it was not a very heavy fall — something like four feet fall on each side.
58. Did you hear that fall come down? — No; nothing but the crash — I heard nothing but the crash.
59. (The Coroner.) Has there been any talk to your knowledge among the men that gas was coming off anywhere at any point? — No, sir; I have not been much among the men. When I went out they wanted to ask me questions, and they used to bamboozle my mind.
60. I mean before the explosion, and not afterwards — was there any discussion or talk amongst the men the gas was coming away from any point that you know of? — Not that I know of.
61. (Mr. Bell.) The coroner was asking a question about the examination of the pit — are you a master shifter? — No, sir.
62. Whose duty was it to examine the pit in that district? — Anthony Smith — he is lost.
63. Did he examine it? — Well, as far as I know, he generally examines as he goes around.
64. Had you seen him after you went into the pit? — Yes; about twelve o'clock in one district.
65. Did he make any statement to you about the ventilation, or of anything wrong in any shape or way? — No, sir.
66. Do you know whether it is the custom for the master shifter to examine all the places of a night? — Yes; he examines all as he travels — both the returns and the face. I have been with him when he has been going over a heavy fall.
67. How long have you worked there? — About 16 months.
68. (Mr. Willis.) Can you tell us about that fall that you spoke of going over down the hole, down the bank, whether it was covered with dust as you crossed over it? — I did not; it was very dismal there.
69. (Mr. Bell.) Were your lamps still burning? — Yes, very dimly.
70. (Mr. Willis.) You would not think much, then, of course. But is there anything you think now to cause you to imagine that that fall took place after the blast, or before? — Well, no sir. I have gone through that place several times, and never thought anything. It was timbered in.
71. But now that you have settled a bit, do you think that that fall would be caused by the explosion? Was it a likely place? — No, sir.
72. (Mr. Atkinson.) When you got into the west side return, did you get into the upcast shaft without meeting any stythe? — No.
73. When did you next meet the stythe? — It was in the return, because it was not so thick. There was a separation door to the two main doors.
74. (The Coroner.) You met the stythe again in the return — where? In the first commencement of it; but it was not very thick.
75. You said something about a door? — There is a separation door between there and the two main doors. That is at the bottom of the main coal staple.
76. (Mr. Atkinson.) Were the first two doors blown out? — Yes.
77. (Mr. Willis.) Which way? — The wreckage was lying in-bye from what we could discern.
78. (Mr. Atkinson.) Then after passing those two doors, where were the next doors? — We went through the regulator doors, and the regulator doors were locked.
79. They were not blown out? — No, sir; that was right.
80. Then could you pull it down to get through? — No; a man named Robert Wilson took a stone and hit it upon the square head, and I took my lamp rail off and pressed my finger and lamp against it, and gave it a twist, and away it came.
81. You opened the regulator door, and went through? — Yes.
82. Did you close it after going through? — Thomas Johnson was the last man, and he said that he could not close it.
83. He left it open? — Yes.
84. Then after passing the regulator, you came to the two doors that were blown out? — Yes; but we came to the return before that. It came from No. 1; and instead of the wind going up over the stythe was coming down over.
85. It was coming down No. 1? — Yes; it was coming from the furnace instead of going to the furnace. It was then very thick.
86. (Mr. Bell.) When you got to the shaft, were there any men? — One man lying burnt.
87. Was there anything else took place in the return as you were going out — after going through this regulator, did you meet with any falls? — No; we came from where the doors had been, and there was a man lying right where the doors should have been.
88. (The Coroner.) And getting to the shaft, you found a man there lying burnt? — I cannot say that he was burnt.
89. You found a man lying dead? — Yes; that was at the main staple.
90. You found one man at the shaft? — Yes.
91. (Mr. Bell.) Was that Laverick? — Yes.
92. (Mr. Atkinson.) After leaving No. 1 return, what was the next thing that attracted your attention? — There was a fire in the main staple bottom.
93. (The Coroner.) Where was the first dead man that you found? — Where the two doors should have been, on the separation of the main coal staple from the return.
94. You found the first man there? — Not burnt to my knowledge.
95. Was it before that that you came before the fire, or after? — After we got past that.
96. What fire did you find? — It was the seats and the timber afire, right in front of the main coal staple bottom. We got fresh air there.
97. Right at the main coal staple bottom? — Yes.
98. And that was the first time that you saw any fire? — Yes.
99. Had you seen any signs or symptoms of fire? — No; first the smoke.
100. Did you put that fire out? — Yes; but it was a bit before we did it.
101. You did not put it out at that moment? — No; we could not. We sat beside it, and we were determined to put it out.
102. Did you put it out before you left it? — Yes, when we came round. We got fresh air there. We had no water to put it out with.
103. How did you manage? — We beat and rubbed it out. We shifted the two tubs and put them against the door, and one of the tubs had a pair of wheels; and we persevered until the fire went out. There were three of us at the fire — Thomas Johnson, and Robert Wilson, and myself.
104. (Mr. Atkinson.) Did you observe the state of the staple bottom? — Yes, we sat there a considerable time. It was all of a wreck. That was the main coal staple.
105. Does it appear as if the blast had gone up or down? — We suppose it had gone up.
106. (The Coroner.) The main coal staple was a complete wreck? — Yes.
107. And the blast apparently going up, you say? — At least, I think so.
108. The blast was coming up? — According to how the things were lying, it had gone up the staple.
109. (Mr. Atkinson.) Did you observe any air going up or down the staple? — It was coming down very fresh. That was where we were for a certain time; and after we got the fire out we tried for the shaft, about 4 o'clock.
110. Which shaft? — Either three or one, which we could get.
111. You did not try to get up the staple? — No; it was no use trying there.
112. (The Coroner.) Where does that staple lead to? — To the main coal — down into the Hutton seam.
113. (Mr. Atkinson.) Then you left the main coal staple bottom to try to get to the shaft. What next? — Then we had wrecks of timber and tubs on the road.
114. (Mr. Bell.) Which shaft did you try? — Whichever we could get at first. We could not get to No. 1; we had to retreat.
115. (Mr. Atkinson.) For stythe? — Yes, there was a heavy fall.
116. Did you retreat on account of the stythe or the fall? — On account of the stythe.
117. (The Coroner.) You could not get to No. 1? — No, nor No. 3 neither.
118. (Mr. Atkinson.) Where were you stopped by the stythe first — in going to No. 1? — We went to the main coal staple.
119. (The Coroner.) What point were you stopped? — We were stopped between two pits — what is called the curve in going into No. 3.
120. (Mr. Bell.) You met with the stythe at this curve? — Yes, in going to No. 3; and it was coming from the back of the wall, near the Hutton seam staples.
121. (The Coroner.) What distance would it be from where you were stopped by this stythe? — About thirty yards.
122. (Mr. Atkinson.) Just describe the position where the stythe was coming from? — It was coming from the Hutton seam main way end; and it was turned back by the wind going to No. 3.
123. Then you went back to the bottom of the main coal staple? — Yes, and remained until half-past 5 in the morning.
124. And after that? — Then we tried for the shaft again.
125. Did you hear any coals coming down that main coal staple? — Yes; we shouted and jowled up, thinking that somebody would be coming up the shaft.
126. (The Coroner.) Did you get any answer from the jowling? — No.
127. (Mr. Atkinson.) Then after half-past 5 o'clock? — We travelled to No. 3 shaft first; and we got to No. 3 and persevered.
128. And the air was still stythey? — Yes, but not so bad as it was; it was more clear. There was no communication to the shaft. There were three guides, and the rope was gone, and we could not make any communication to anyone. We tried No. 1, as the wind was rather fresh coming from No. 1.
129. Had you seen any more bodies up to this point? — Not then, but afterwards. Then we travelled from No. 3 to No. 1, and then we came to a heavy fall where the Maudlin engine is; and we went over the fall there, and we came to the dead body, and the hand was out towards No. 1, and his clothes were on fire.
130. Did you put that fire out? — Yes; Thomas Johnson and I put that fire out.
131. Did you recognise the man? — We supposed it to be Robert Potter, but we could not say. We took it that Robert Potter would be there at one o'clock, and he is the deputy in No. 3, Hutton seam; but we could not say that it was him, at least I could not. There was a baulk of timber on fire when we got over the fall beside the Maudlin engine, and we put that out and planked it up. We came further down to the Maudlin way and lost the stythe; and it was coming out of the Maudlin way, and standing very thick there. And then we came in contact with the fall.
132. But you got into clearer air? — Yes; we got clearer air there, near the shaft.
133. Did you see a body at the Maudlin way end? — We did not recognise that until the night.
134. You did not find it at that time? — No; we found it afterwards.
135. And then you went on? — Yes; and there was another fall; and we heard a voice underneath where this fall was. There is a hole which comes up from the Harvey, and there were three men sitting there.
136. (The Coroner.) The hole coming from the Harvey? — Yes ; there came from the Harvey these three men.
136a. Did they get out safe? — Yes; there are some here to-day.
137. What then? — They asked us to shine them a light.
138. Were their lights in? — There lights were in; and we could not see until we came to three baulks through a hole.
139. And you got them alight leading to No. 1 pit? — Yes; we handed them a light. And then there was another heavy fall at a place called the Three-way ends, close to the shaft.
140. (The Coroner.) Did you find any bodies there? — Not there. We heard Laverick moaning at the shaft.
141. You had another fall — where? — At Three-way ends — that is, No. 1 shaft.
142. (Mr. Atkinson.) And what then? — I asked Robert Wilson to go over that fall first.
143. (The Coroner.) You heard Laverick moaning? — Yes.
144. Was Laverick burnt too? — Yes.
145. He was the on-setter there? — Yes.
146. Was he on fire when you got to him? — No, sir.
147. (Mr. Atkinson.) Did you follow Wilson over the fall? — Yes, and got to the shaft.
148. (The Coroner.) Did you bring Laverick with you? — No.
149. You got another fall close to, from the one shaft, close to the Three-way ends; and the next thing was that you heard Laverick moaning? — Yes.
150. And you found him alive in a hole which was burning, but he was not there on fire? — We saw no fire.
151. Was there anything else on fire? — Not that I saw.
152. You saw no fire there? — No.
153. (Mr. Atkinson.) Was Laverick lying on or under the seat? — I think he was lying on the seat; but I was not the first one that was at him.
154. Was he conscious? — No; he asked us if we wanted to ride. One of the young men told him that the pit had fired; but he talked about his family, and sometimes he was delirious. He was doting towards four o'clock.
155. You had got to the shaft? — Yes; and we made ourselves content waiting near the shaft.
156. (The Coroner.) You were content until they were able to get to you, and then you were rescued? — Yes.
157. How many were there in that seam? — Four.
158. How many altogether — you have told me before? — Six hewers, and six shifters, and four or five boys.
159. That is seventeen? — Yes.
160. And four that you got out? — Yes.
161. And the others came out by the main airways, and they were lost? — Yes.
162. They have been recovered since? — Some have been recovered ; I cannot say all. You will find four men, I think, and those boys not far from one another.
163. (Mr. Willis.) You have got to No. 1 shaft; and you ultimately got out of No. 3? — Yes.
164. And you waited until half-past six in the morning? — We were at the No. 1 until half-past six o'clock at night. We were there all the time.
165. (Mr. Atkinson.) Then you will know how many men were there? — Yes; eight of us altogether.
166. Including Laverick? — Yes; three came from the Harvey, and Laverick was at the shaft-bottom.
167. Did you hear any calling or jowling from the main coal? — Not from the main coal. We heard the men working near the shaft.
168. (The Coroner.) Did you hear any jowling from the seams? — No.
169. (Mr. Atkinson.) Are you sure of that? — I am certain of that.
170. Did not you hear them jowling from No. 1 pit from the main coal? — No; they jowled from the bottom of the Harvey, and we told them to hold their tongues, and we would jowl upwards.
171. You never heard a jowl down? — No.
172. Because there were twenty men at the main coal shaft? — We never heard tell until Hartley said that he had communicated with the main coal men, and that was between two and four o'clock.
173. (The Coroner.) In the afternoon? — Yes.
174. (Mr. Willis.) Who joined you? — Hartley, the master shifter, came to us. We never heard a sound in the shaft.
175. (Mr. Atkinson.) He would be the ninth man in the pit bottom? — He never came over the fall — he never came there.
176. Then about half-past six o'clock, some people came down the pit to you? — Mr. Stratton, and another gentleman from Murton, Mr. Bailes.
177. (Mr. Marshall.) I think you said you never heard a jowl down the main coal staple? — No, sir.
178. (Mr. Bowey.) I think you spoke of Hindson making a refuge hole? — I think he said he was going in at nine o'clock, and he went down at ten.
179. Did he say where that refuge hole was to be made? — Not to me.
180. Do you know where it was? — I cannot say.
181. I thought Hindson told you? — Yes, on Monday morning.
182. Did he tell you where he was going to make this? — No.
183. Did you know where? — No.
184. Have you any knowledge? — No.
185. (The Coroner.) Was it the same seam Hindson and his mates go in different places.
186. (Mr. Bowey.) Have you any knowledge where that refuge hole was to be that Hindson spoke of? — No; I could not say that.
187. (Mr. Willis.) Did you understand that it was an ordinary refuge hole on the engine plane? — He didn't say. He said he was going in at twelve o'clock that night — that was on the Monday morning.
188. (The Coroner.) You don't know what refuge hole? — He merely said it was a refuge hole.
189. What were the names of the other men who were where you were? — Robert Wilson, John Mason, and Thomas Johnson.
190. (Mr. Atkinson.) Have you got the names of the three men coming out of the Harvey? — I have not them. Robert Wilson will, perhaps, tell you them.
The witness withdrew.
191. (The Coroner.) Now, so far as this seam is concerned, we have heard William Cummings; and I am ready to hear the other three — John Mason, Robert Wilson, and Thomas Johnson.
(Mr. Bowey.) I do not wish them to be called at present.
(The Coroner.) If either Mason, Johnson, or Wilson wish to give evidence, I am prepared to examine them.
Mr. William Cummings returned and said — I forgot something I have to tell you. Hindson told me that morning that they objected to firing shots, and that they would be found fault with for firing shots.
192. (The Coroner.) Where? — Not to fire any shots. He said they had been refused to fire any shots where they were working.
193. (Mr. Atkinson.) Hindson told you that they had been refused? — Yes; they had been ordered not to fire them; and they had orders not to fire any more shots until further orders.
194. (The Coroner.) Let us have one of the men that came safe from the Harvey.
195. (Mr. Bowey.) I should like to put a question to Cummings. (To witness.) Is it the ordinary rule for stone men to fire shots at night? — Yes, where there is no danger. There are rules to go by.
196. When was it that Hindson told you this about being found fault with? — On Monday morning in going home. He said they had not to fire any shots until they got further orders.
197. Was that at the same time that he told you about the refuge hole? — Yes; at the same time.
198. (Mr. Bell.) Did he say that he was found fault with or got orders to discontinue it? — Yes; he said that he had not to fire any more shots until he was ordered.
199. (Mr. Bowey.) To fire no more? — Yes; to fire no more shots until he was ordered.
200. Where has Hindson been working on the Monday morning? — I cannot tell that; I am working in-bye on the face, and Hindson goes about the mainways and sometimes in-bye, according as he needs it. I do not remember Hindson at his work.
201. Did Hindson say from whom he had got the order not to fire shots? — No, sir; not to me.
The witness withdrew.
Mr. William Hartley sworn and examined.
202. (The Coroner.) What are you? — A master shifter.
203. In which seam? — No 2 seam.
204. (Mr. Bell.) No. 2? — What we call the Harvey.
205. It is the Hutton seam hanging on at the Harvey? — Yes; it is the lowest down.
206. (The Coroner.) It is lower down than the Hutton? — It is the lowest down Hutton seam.
207. What shift did you go in? — Ten o'clock on Tuesday night.
208. What did you do, and what portions of the working were you in until the explosion took place? — I was on the east way — and there are two north branches in the east way — and I was in the first north branch, travelling my rounds there, and I found nothing amiss, not in that district. Of course, I made my way to go to the other district — the other north branch — and I went by the return for a near road. This we very often travel; it is much nearer than the main way, and it was during the time that I was in the returns between the two ways that I found the shock.
209. You were coming from which district? — From the first north district to the second north district.
210. You heard nothing? — I heard nothing in particular — just a change in the air. I said to myself, "That is serious." I thought it might be a fall ; but I made my way out to try to ascertain what was the matter — whether it was a fall, or what.
211. To where? — Out-bye towards the shaft. I thought there was a fall — and it was my duty to put it right the next morning — I still proceeded out-bye, where I had some men working on the engine planes in the coal district going down to the first north branch. They were making refuge holes ; but when I came to them they were gone, so I followed outbye.
212. (Mr. Atkinson.) Did you go back to the return? — No; I proceeded out-bye so far, and found them gone.
213. (The Coroner.) Was anything wrong — any damage done? — No; nothing amiss; and I proceeded out-bye; and when I got so far out, nearly to where the overman stands, I met them coming back. I met the stythe.
214. You were driven back by the stythe, I suppose? — Yes; when I came to them, they were retreating from the stythe; as soon as they told me, I said "let us go back here. Here is a return close at hand — a return door close at hand."
215. And you went into it? — Yes; knowing that it was a short cut as near as the main way; and I thought we might get away before the stythe got to us. Well, there are two separation doors above the overman's cabin, and I examined this above the doors, and saw she was going; and I told them to try and get out of the return, knowing it would be worse than the main way. She was mixed with fresh air in the main way; so we proceeded out to No. 1 pit bottom; and when we came there, we came up to this hole that this man was speaking about.
215a. What is the name of that hole? — I do not know. It separates the high pit travelling road.
216. It is between the "Harvey and the Maudlin"? — Yes; beside No. 1 pit bottom. It is what separates the high pit — Maudlin and Hutton seam. It is the road that takes off to the Harvey.
217. And there you joined Cummings? — No, sir; I never saw anyone; I went to where this timber was burning, that the last witness was speaking about. I never saw Brown the first time; and I tried to put the timber out; but the stythe was coming strong and we had to retreat back again to this hole, the four men and I; and when we got there we stopped for the fresh air a bit, and I told them "Things are in a bad figure here, with the explosion. We had better go and try the back of the furnace, and get into the steam drift in the next pit." We proceeded down the steam drift in the west pit. We proceeded down the steam drift, and I noticed in going down the drift there was not a stone turned of any description, and the same way in the No. 2 pit engine; and the paraffin lamps were all hanging and as plain as you might expect them. That was in No. 2 pit engine.
218. (Mr. Bell.) Were the lamps burning? — No; they were put out by the brakesman, at 5 o'clock at night. I shouted over to No. 1 pit, but I got no answer. There was a fall and it looked dangerous. I knew the on-setter to be about there, but I got no answer from him. I would not go over; and I thought I would try and get over into the low pit to see after the men that were down; and I went down No. 2 engine, where things were quite pleasant; and I looked to the pit bottom, and she was quite closed. We tried to communicate with some one.
219. But you could not from the wreckage in the shaft? — Yes.
220. Where did you first find wreckage? — On our own road out.
221. Was that before joining Cummings? — Before that, I think. We were there before Cummings.
222. Did you find any damage done before reaching the point where you joined Cummings? — There were falls just in entering on our own section, the separation doors were taken out beside the furnace.
223. Was there no sign of fire? — No, only this timber on fire at the High pit.
224. That was after you go to where Cummings was? — No; that is before we knew about Cummings.
225. About the point that you met Cummings? — Not far from it. Just below the Maudlin engine house. Then I took them into No. 2. engine, and had a look at the shaft, and saw no prospect of any rescue for us there ; and I hovered for a time until a lot of the men came out; and there were three men that Cummings spoke about coming out of the Harvey, that he held a light over the hole for. They were trying to get out of the High pit shaft, but I do not know whether they did; but they went over the fall to No. 1. pit bottom. That is where Laverick was out; and I waited until the men came, and we had fresh air, and there was no fear then. When they came out I put one man in charge of them, time I was travelling No. 1. pit; and I told them how to proceed ; and accordingly I went away again. The next time I went up those men who had before had gone to No. 1. pit bottom, and had fallen in with Cummings, and those other men in the seam. I asked about No. 1. pit; and they said that she was closed, and a wreckage the same as our own; and they told me there was a man there burnt. After proceeding to get into the High pit again, I went into the return way where she was still coming out strong; and I could not say whether that was before I got to the High pit or afterwards. I travelled between the Harvey engine and the high pit all the day, just looking after the pit's ventilation, and trying to get the men right down below ; and looking for a rescue as soon as possible. This Jim Brown, who was the fireman, I went to him, and I put the fire out but I don't know whether Cummings or I was at him first.
226. (The Coroner.) How many men were there in your district in the Harvey? — Forty three with the on-setter and putters.
227. How many men saved? — All of them.
228. Then as far as the explosion was concerned, your district was not its locality? — No, there was nothing amiss in our pit.
229. Did you form an opinion as to the locality of the explosion? — I could not say. I have thought different things, first one thing and then another, according to the direction of the timber that was blown. It came both ways.
230. Where is the place that you found it came both ways? — I thought the timber was both ways.
231. Where was that? — At the Hutton seam. That is, No. 1 pit bottom, when I came through this hole where Cummings joined us.
232. The hole that Cummings speaks of? — Yes.
233. And that was the first time that you saw any strong signs of an explosion having taken place? — Yes.
234. Forty-three men were in your district, who all got out safe? — Yes ; there was one a little hurt.
235. But there was no burning, they got out alive, and no scorching to hurt them? — Yes.
236. (Mr. Atkinson.) Does the forty-three include yourself? — Yes.
237. (The Coroner.) Then it must have been some other part of the mine than where you and the forty-three were where the explosion took place? — Quite.
238. Has there been any complaint about the ventilation of the mine? — No.
239. There was no complaint amongst the men, or any dissatisfaction with the way in which the air was supplied to that district? — I have never heard of any.
240. (Mr. Bell.) What number of men had you under your charge that night? — I had forty — at least thirty-nine and myself.
241. Where the forty-three all shifters, or coal hewers? — Two fitters, and an on-setter; and the others were shifters, and check drawers, and stone men.
242. Before you set them to work, did you examine the different places where they had to go to? — The man that is in before me, the deputy — he goes round the pit late on; and he will examine the workings before I go along with the men.
243. Is it any part of your duty to examine the pit? — It is my duty to examine the pit as we go around.
244. Had the deputy examined and reported to you before you were put in charge? — Yes, and reported to the back overman, and entered it in the book as all being right.
245. What were you men doing chiefly that night? — Lowering away, and timbering.
246. Was there any necessity for the use of gunpowder that night? — No.
247. Had you any in the pit? — Not near our men.
248. What was Hindson doing? — I don't know anything about Hindson.
249. Is Hindson one of your men? — No.
250. (The Coroner.) What are your instructions as to shot-firing? — First of all, we must have correspondence from the overman and manager as well.
251. (Mr. Bell.) Were there any men making refuge holes in your shift? — Yes, in our pit there were the first four men that I fell in with, were making refuge holes, but they were using no powder.
252. You say you were not using powder? — No.
253. Before you got to that hole you speak of; in what direction did the blast appear to have travelled? — I thought it might have come from No. 1.
254. Had it gone in-bye or out-bye? — It came inbye. The stythe was going in as we met it.
255. (The Coroner.) I have not got your instructions as to shot-firing. I want to know what instructions you have as to shot-firing? — Our instructions are that we are to examine all places round about, and see that they are safe and free from gas.
256. Before firing the shot? — Yes.
257. What else? You said some licence from somebody or other was required? — We are to have leave from the masters.
258. (Mr. Bell.) Is that in writing? — Well, the overman corresponds with me.
259. Have you a written authority to use gunpowder? — Yes ; after this.
260. (The Coroner.) From the overman? — Yes.
261. And not to fire unless the overman authorizes you to do so?
262. (Mr. Bowey.) You say you are not to fire shots without the overman authorizes you to do so. But that is "after this?" — No, sir.
263. What did you mean by the words "after this?"
(The Coroner.) After the examination.
264. (Mr. Bowey.) You said we are to have leave after this? — I did not mean that. We always have to have leave.
265 You said the words "after this." What did you mean by that? You said we are to have leave; and we are to have correspondence between the viewer, overman, and deputy? — "After this" — after we have had a correspondence with the overman about something.
266. Did you mean that you got an order after you confer with the overman? — Yes; after a consultation with the overman. We have not been in the habit of getting it in writing.
267. You mean "after this" you are to take it in writing? — No; I don't mean that.
268. (Mr. Bell.) I understood him to say that "after this" correspondence with the overman he got his certificate to use powder. — Yes.
269. (Mr. Bowey.) Verbally? — (No answer.)
270. Have you ever received any order? — Not from the overman.
271. From anybody? — (No answer.)
272. (Mr. H. B. Wright.) Is this before the shotfiring you communicate with the overman? — Yes.
273. And when you said "after this" you meant after the communication from the overman to the under-viewer? — Yes; we are then allowed to fire shots.
274. (The Coroner.) Have you printed forms? — Yes; shot-firing forms.
275. (Mr. Atkinson.) Was the stythe coming in both the intake and the return as you came out of the pit? — No; it was going in the intake and through the return door, and it has not got down. We got out before it came door.
276. But you came out by the intake at the last? — No; we came out by the return through No. 1 after I went through the return door.
277. (Mr. Bowey.) Have you got any instructions as to shot-firing since this occurred? — No, sir.
278. Have you had any talk with the overman or deputy overman about shot-firing? — No.
279. Nor with anyone? — No.
280. Not since the explosion? — No.
(The Coroner.) I do not wish to take anything for granted in this inquiry. But forty-seven or forty-three were in this section of the mine, and they all got out alive; and this witness seems to say that, so far as that portion of the pit was concerned, nothing occurred whereby life was lost. I do not propose to examine any more witnesses from that portion of the pit unless you think it necessary.
(Mr. Bowey.) I do not see any necessity.
(The Coroner.) It only clears up the point as to whether anything went wrong. From what this witness says nothing has gone wrong. I think we had better try the Maudlin, if anyone was got alive from the Maudlin seam.
(Mr. Wright.) The only men are the four men who came out alive from the Hutton seam.
(The Coroner.) We have examined Cummings of that section, and Hartley of the next section. Is there a third section in which any man came out alive?
(Mr. H. B. Wright.) There is the main coal.
(Mr. Bell.) Is there no one from No. 1 Hutton.
(Mr. H. B. Wright.) No, I think not. The only men in No. 1 and No. 3 were the four men, and Laverick the on-setter.
(The Coroner.) Of course Laverick is not in a fit state to be examined to-day.
(Mr. H. B. Wright.) He is very ill.
The witness withdrew.