1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
Seaham Colliery Inquest, 15th September 1880.
Seaham Colliery Explosion.
Minutes of Evidence taken at the Coroner's Inquest.
The Londonderry Institute, Seaham Harbour, 15th September 1880.
Second Day.
Present:
Mr. MAYNARD, Coroner;
Mr. BELL, the Government Inspector for Durham;
Mr. WILLIS, the Government Inspector for Northumberland; and
Mr. WILLIAM ATKINSON, Assistant Inspector.
Mr. BOWEY, Mr. MARSHALL, and Mr. FORMAN appeared for the Durham Miners' Association; and
Mr. EMINSON and Mr. H. B. WRIGHT, Solicitor for the Marquis of Londonderry.
The jury having been sworn to inquire into the cause of death of James Brown and others at Seaham Colliery on Wednesday, the 8th of September
(The Coroner) in opening the proceedings, said : — Gentlemen of the jury — it will save some trouble if I announce to you the course of examination which I intend to be pursued to day. We will examine as many of the witnesses, who were brought out alive from the different places where they were working, to tell us what occurred in those localities in the pit during the shift prior to the explosion; and if they can, from what locality, and what direction, the explosion occurred, and whether there was one or more explosions. That is what I propose to do to-day. There were 66 or 67 brought out of the pit. I am bound, if the whole of these 66 say that they have important evidence to give on this matter, to receive their depositions on oath. But I myself would not think it necessary to examine the sixty-six; but if Mr. Wright, or you gentlemen, who appear on behalf of the men, say, "This a witness whom I desire to be examined," I shall examine him.
(Mr. Marshall.) We should not ask such a thing as to have the whole sixty-six examined.
(The Coroner.) Very well. Then for convenience sake I propose, after having consulted Mr. Bell on the matter, that we take the witnesses in this order — the hewers, and that class of men, first; then, having finished with that class, I intend to proceed to the deputies ; and then the overman, the viewers, and the scientific evidence; and close the inquiry with any of the inspectors that wish to be examined, or tender themselves to be examined on the subject.
(Mr. Marshall.) That is not all to day?
(The Coroner.) That is only the course in which I intend to proceed. Now, one word with reference to the examination of witnesses. I think it will be best to take this course : — I will commence by examining the witnesses as far as I choose to go; then the inspectors will follow me. After that the legal gentlemen on both sides ; and then, if any question occurs to any man present, let that question be put through me. If we follow out that from beginning to end, we will make the work as sure as it can be, and as complete and ample as will be necessary.
(Mr. Bell.) I have to inform you, sir, that I wrote to the Home Office, asking that Mr. Willis be allowed to come over and assist me in this inquiry; and I have received the consent of the Home Secretary in the letter which I now hand to you.
(The Coroner.) It simply states that Mr. Willis, inspector of mines, is to assist you and the coroner in the case of the Seaham Colliery explosion on Wednesday next, at nine o'clock; and it is signed A. F. O. Liddell. Well, so far as I am concerned, I am very glad to see you present.
(Mr. H. B. Wright.) I would suggest that this inquiry be commenced by some explanation as to the nature and character of the mine. Mr. Corbett, the chief engineer, is present, and I would suggest that he should give a short explanation of the character of the mine.
(The Coroner.) I was going to say, the first foundation is a plan, if you have it ready, of the whole workings of the mine. If you have that ready that will be the foundation for us to go on with.
(Mr. H. B. Wright.) I believe that Mr. Corbett has prepared the plans of two seams, the Maudlin seam and the Hutton seam of No. 1 pit, and these will be produced. At a further stage of this inquiry plans will be produced of all the seams, if necessary; and such plans as may be suggested in the course of this inquiry as necessary for the jury to understand the entire workings, will also be produced. I think it will be sufficient for the present to produce the plans of the Maudlin seam and the Hutton seam of No. 1, which Mr. Corbett has with him.
(The Coroner.) I understood that the plans of the whole mine were in course of preparation; and although they might not be ready now, they would be at the subsequent adjournment.
(Mr. H. B. Wright.) At a subsequent adjournment any plans may be at your service.
(The Coroner.) Then we must go on with the plans that we can get for the day, and afterwards have the plans properly and thoroughly proved at the adjournment.
(Mr. Bowey.) If we are going to get evidence today as to the explosion, I think we shall require the whole of the tracings. How can we have evidence as to the explosion unless we have the whole of the tracings?
(The Coroner.) I quite agree with you, that we should have a thorough plan of the whole mine.
(Mr. Bell.) There is in course of preparation, on a six-inch scale, a plan so as to place the whole of the workings on one sheet.
(Mr. Bowey.) What occurs to my mind is, that if we are to have the witnesses thoroughly examined to-day, that we should require the whole of the plans, and to examine them in part, and re-examine them after the whole of the plans are produced, would be an awkward course of procedure.
(The Coroner.) Well, the only reason that I did not suggest an adjournment for a month or six weeks was, because I wanted the evidence of those who were brought out alive to be taken as soon as possible, when the whole circumstances were present in their mind. If you choose, we will take a part of the plans as proved, and then take the locality from where the witnesses came from, and take evidence from them of what they know.
(Mr. H. B. Wright.) I quite understood that the only evidence would be the evidence of the survivors; and I remember mentioning that it would be impossible for me to produce any evidence of the colliery officials — that they would be necessarily engaged in an anxious and responsible duty in attending to the explorations and I saw that their presence could not be had. I have, however, prevailed on Mr. Corbett to give some formal evidence, and I suggest that evidence be given to the Coroner. Then, I have tracings of two of the seams of coal, and that will be found sufficient for the purposes of to-day.
(Mr. Bowey.) My difficulty is this, that we shall have to ask certain questions which will be unintelligible without plans.
(Mr. Corbett.) I have a plan of No. 1 and the Maudlin seam.
(Mr. Bell.) You have a tracing of No. 2.
(Mr. Corbett.) Yes, No. 1 and the Maudlin seam are now closed ; but proper plans are being prepared to lay before the jury. They are not ready yet.
(Mr. Atkinson.) I think the six-inch ordnance plan would be of most use now, and quite sufficient.
(The Coroner.) We are going to examine witnesses to-day without plans ; and that is the best way. Is Laverick here?
(A Policeman.) He is not here.
(The Coroner.) Is there any danger of his life? If you press me to do it, I will take the jury to his house, if he is not fit to attend. He was a man who was burnt, and he is now suffering from the effects of the explosion ; and if you wish it we will take his evidence.
(It was agreed that Laverick's evidence should be dispensed with for the day.)