Although there were then many accidents from falls of ground there was no mention of support in the Acts of 1855, 1860 and 1872 concerned with safety in coal mines. The 1855 Act, however, did require the establishment of Special Rules at every mine and these Rules generally included one on timbering. Usually, however, props had to be set only where they were considered necessary by the workmen concerned. The Select Committee of 1865/67 was told of a reduction in falls of ground accidents that had resulted from the setting of props at six feet intervals instead of "where necessary". Nevertheless, the Act of 1887 made a general requirement only for the setting of sprags, at intervals of not more than six feet, and though the Act of 1911 required managers to specify, in Support Rules, the intervals between props, bars and chocks, it put no limits on the spacings.
As machine cutting and conveying spread, there was a gradual reduction in the intervals specified between props. However, the accident rate from falls of ground fell only slowly (Figure 1), and in 1941 a special effort to reduce it began, by the appointment of H.M. Inspectors for Special Duties and the setting up in all the coalfields of Committees, representative of all the interested parties.
It became clear that many accidents happened because the supports, though usually strong enough, did not carry load until the roof had lowered too far, often because props penetrated a soft floor. Also many resulted from delay in prop setting, because the man it was mainly to protect did not set it until he had almost finished the work he was doing. The need for better support at places where men worked under recently disturbed ground, such as rippings, became more evident.
Improved support measures were widely adopted and the accident rate began to fall sharply. The better practices were enforced generally by the Coal Mines (Support of Roof and Sides) General Regulations 1947 which were later re-enacted as the Coal and Other Mines (Support) Regulations 1956.
Under the 1947 Regulations, bars had to be set on all faces on which machinery was used and additional supports were required at special places. Thus a pattern of dose systematic support became the general rule. This was an acceptance of the fact that in coal mines in this country, especially now that so many roofs have been damaged by previous working, the hidden slip or break is not a rare hazard but one to be expected and regularly countered. The chief result has been that accidents due to some neglect of support in apparently good conditions have become much less frequent.
When the 1947 Regulations were drawn up, the most common method of production was the hand loading of machine cut coal on to a belt conveyor. About 1950, however, armoured conveyors and machines such as shearer-loaders capable of cutting and loading webs about 2 feet wide were introduced. Any props set on the face side of an armoured conveyor have to be removed for it to be advanced, so that when these power loaders are used, no props, other than temporary props, are set there and the system is known as the "prop-free front". Because of the space occupied by the conveyor and the power loader, the nearest row of supports has to be about 6 feet away from the face for part of the time. Therefore, the system, which had important mining advantages, could not be operated under the 1947 Regulations, which fixed a maximum distance of 3 feet between the front row of props and the face. H.M. Inspectors granted some exemptions from certain provisions of the Regulations for the faces concerned, subject to conditions necessary to maintain safety. These included closer spacing of the props on the general face line and the use of better types of props and bars.
Fortunately, about the same time, hydraulic props were developed in this country. These props could be pre-loaded; they shortened under a fixed load, instead of, like rigid props of wood or steel, tending to penetrate the roof or floor or becoming bent or broken, and were easily released. Friction type props introduced from the Continent had these advantages to some degree. Coupled steel bars, also from the Continent, gave cantilever support to the newly exposed roof, and later there were other developments in bars, such as twin web bars.
The success of power loading depended much on the effectiveness of these new supports. For this reason, and because, unlike rigid props or single piece bars, they might lose their effectiveness without that being evident, arrangements were made for specimens of hydraulic and friction props and of coupled bars to be tested by the Safety in Mines Research Establishment and by the Central Engineering Establishment of the National Coal Board.
These new types of support have made face work safer and easier, and they are still being improved. Nevertheless, care is needed in their maintenance and use. Regular checking of supports is necessary to make sure that any out of order are sent for repair. Hydraulic props should not be hammered and are better kept upright on the face, even when not actually set.
An advantage claimed for the new methods was that men would not need to work under newly exposed roof to the same extent as with hand loading. Unfortunately, however, there have been difficulties in loading the whole of the coal by power, and men have had to cross the conveyor to finish the operation. One of the conditions of exemption required men working on the face side of the conveyor to set temporary props, but investigations of accidents have shown that far too often such props had not been set, nor indeed in some cases were they readily available. A man having to work on the face side of the conveyor in order to clear a few shovelsfull of coal might consider that the time he would take in setting a temporary prop would add to the time he had to be in that position, but experience has shown how necessary it is to protect persons working there. The right remedy lies in loading the whole of the coal by power, and with the use of more scavenger ploughs and various types of ramp plates, progress is now being made to this end. Under the new Regulations an Inspector may object to the continuation of a prop-free front system if he considers that not enough is being done to avoid the need for men to work on the face side of the conveyor.
With the introduction of power loading machines, stables became necessary. This led to areas of roof about 40 feet long and 20 feet wide, usually including a roadhead, supported only on props and bars. In such circumstances, there is a risk of large falls, and a few years ago they were not uncommon. There have since been improvements in support in roadheads and stables; the bars are now set to cross the roof breaks, which are usually parallel with the face, and chocks, or chock-props, which are more secure than props especially in broken ground, are used in addition. The disadvantage, from a roof support aspect, of the extra space needed by the machines has on the whole been met by the use of more and better supports. However, the greater the distance between the pack and the face the greater must be the risk of collapse. Managers must now fix a maximum for this distance in support rules and limit, to seven feet, the face advance, before the packs are extended.
The use of the better, readily withdrawable supports spaced closely at the waste edge has made it possible in many cases to change from a system of strip packing to caving the roof in the waste. Strip packs have proved valuable in roof control and they are often still necessary, either generally or locally, for example in faulted ground. Since many accidents have happened to men building packs, it follows that successful caving by the use of better face supports should lead to improved safety.
Powered supports, which are defined in the Regulations as supports advanced and set by mechanical energy, were developed for use on prop-free front faces. Their large areas of contact with the roof and floor have proved a big advantage and they can be set with a high pre-load, though the amount of pre-load should be decided with the strength of the roof in mind. They can also be advanced quickly enough to keep pace with the power loader travelling along the face. One disadvantage is that locally, though briefly, the whole of the support is taken away from the roof; another is that with some systems the support of the newly exposed roof is delayed. Types of powered support in which part of the support is advanced promptly behind the power loader whilst the rest remains set are being designed. Another step forward is in the development of various means of operating powered supports remotely, and these allow the operator to be clear of the support being disturbed.
The Regulations permit the general use on prop-free fronts (faces on which persons do not work on the face side of the conveyor otherwise than occasionally or for short periods) of types of powered support that have been approved by the Minister. The maximum intervals between them vary with the types of support and are specified in the approvals. Because some types of powered support are wider at the back than at the front, the intervals are measured between support centres and not, as with props, between sides. The intervals have been fixed partly in the light of experience gained under the exemptions, but a main consideration has been to limit the width of the roof unsupported whilst a powered support is being moved forward.
A disadvantage of the prop-free front system is that it is not suited to conditions where the roof should be supported promptly with props that do not have to be taken out for the conveyor to be advanced. If conditions should require it, the propfree front system with hand set props can be adapted so that bars can be set promptly with a row of props close to the face, the bars being supported by other props whilst the conveyor is advanced. This is not possible where powered supports are used, but with some systems, there is enough space between adjacent powered supports for supplementary props and bars to be set when necessary, either to prevent the waste breaking forward or to catch the newly exposed roof, and extension bars on the canopies are another way of supporting the roof close behind the loading machine. It is desirable that support rules should show how such difficulties should be tackled and what should be done should a powered support become ineffective.
In very bad ground, however, it may be necessary to disconnect the armoured conveyor and work the coal by hand until satisfactory roof conditions have been established beyond the troubled area. Many accidents have occurred because a prop-free front was persisted with after conditions had become unsuitable.
Figure 1 shows that the reduction in the numbers of fatal accidents from falls of ground continued after the coming into force of the 1947 Regulations, though, particularly m recent years, this has been partly due to the reduction in the numbers of men working below ground. On power loaded faces, the rates of accident per man shift worked have been slightly greater than those on hand loaded faces; that is, the risk of a fall of ground accident to the individual working on a power loaded face has, so far, been slightly greater than that to one working on a hand loaded face. However, because fewer men work on a power loaded face than on a hand loaded face producing the same quantity of coal, power loading has led to some reduction in the total numbers injured.
An analysis of 50 occurrences involving fatal accidents to persons on prop-free fronts showed that 14 were due to falls in the fully supported part of the face working, 11 of these happening where the roof was badly broken before the fall causing the accident occurred. Six took place near the waste edge where some supports had been removed, In the other 30 cases, the fall was between the front row of props and the face. This indicates that on prop-free fronts the supports on the general face line are usually adequate, for they have rarely failed unless their effectiveness has been reduced by existing cavities. Because of the closely spaced easily withdrawable supports at the waste edge, there is much less risk to persons working there. The position close to the face is not yet satisfactory. More should be done to avoid men having to work in this area and to provide earlier support to the newly exposed roof.
The prop-free front system with power loading has increased the importance and changed the character of the support work. Once, support setting was a minor part of the day's work; now on many faces it occupies most of the working time. Formerly, a man worked for the whole shift on the same length of the face and got to "know" the roof above him; as he got down the coal, he would set supports in its place, and both coal getting and support setting were under his control. Now, men travel across the face supporting behind a power loader moving into fresh ground. The speed of coal getting is no longer controlled by the man who sets the supports; nevertheless, the two operations must be kept in step. The need for correct timing to ensure proper support extends beyond the actual power loading operation. Strip packs must be advanced at the right time, not delayed but not built prematurely, for then they obstruct the travelling road through the face. The stable and the ripping operations must be kept in proper relationship to each other and to the face work. Moreover, the effectiveness of the supports is influenced in ways other than timing by other aspects of face work; for example, the resistance of the supports often depends on whether the power loader has been kept at the right cutting horizon.
Mechanized mining is team work, and keeping the roof in a safe condition depends on all doing their jobs, in the right sequence, to the best of their ability. The team includes everyone working on the face, those responsible for the supply and maintenance of the supports, management and indeed, manufacturers.