Invention Of The Safety Lamp.
"What fairer triumph, what brighter extension of the empire of science, has marked the annals of philosophy, than this victory over the swart demon of the mine ?" — SURTEES.
Mr. Buddle's improvements had introduced a new order of things in the ventilation and working of collieries, but certain other known sources of danger remained for which no remedial measure had yet been thought of. It is true that the risk attendant upon the use of ventilating furnaces had been materially lessened by the invention of the dumb drift, but no improvement had been effected in the methods employed to light the miners at their work. This continued in the same unsatisfactory position as it had been since the days of the elder Spedding.
If the inflammable gas met with in coal mines were discharged into the workings in equable and determinate quantities, and if the ventilating arrangements were at all times in a state of thorough efficiency, it might be possible, by the introduction and proper distribution of sufficient volumes of atmospheric air, to sweep off the gas as fast as it was produced, and so to maintain the mine in a safe condition. But so far from this being the case, the quantity of gas given off from the goaves, or wastes, varies with the varying pressure of the atmosphere; accumulations of gas are liable to be formed through the temporary neglect of a door, or derangement of a stopping; while danger of a still more formidable character arises from outbursts, or sudden discharges of large volumes of inflammable gas, which occasionally take place unexpectedly in deep mines, and instantly overpower, for the time being, the strongest ventilation. If from any of these causes the atmosphere of the mine has become explosive, it is obvious that the presence of a single lighted candle or lamp is sufficient to give rise to the most disastrous consequences.
In situations where the use of ordinary lights was inadmissible, owing to the presence or fear of inflammable gas, the steel mill continued to be resorted to; and notwithstanding its known insecurity and the poor flickering light which it afforded, and the great cost with which its use was attended, it was still largely employed at many collieries between 1810 and 1815. At Hebburn Colliery, where the ventilation had been deranged by a creep taking place, as many as one hundred of these machines were in daily use.
The first person to entertain the idea of supplying the coal miners with a better and safer light was Dr. Clanny, a medical gentleman residing in Sunderland. His attention was drawn to the subject by the frequency with which explosions took place at collieries in the neighbourhood, and it occurred to him that some arrangement might be devised for insulating the miners' lights so as to prevent them from communicating explosion to the surrounding atmosphere.
Having given much thought to the matter, Dr. Clanny proceeded to put his idea to the test of experiment. His first lamp was constructed about the end of the year 1811. It was a small lamp of strong glass, and shut at the bottom, with the exception of a small opening to admit a tube from the bellows, which he used for throwing in the necessary quantity of air to support the combustion of the candle. He found he could safely insulate the candle in this way, but was told his lamp would never answer, as it was certain to get broken in the mine.
In the course of his experiments, Dr. Clanny tried a lamp insulated by means of valves, but found they would not suit, as the expansive force of an explosion within the lamp threw them open, and allowed a communication to take place with the surrounding atmosphere. At length, in the beginning of the year 1813, he succeeded in constructing a strong form of lamp which was perfectly insulated by the ingenious arrangement of passing the air from the bellows into the lamp through a stratum of water below, while a similar stratum of water above allowed the products of combustion to escape safely at the top. An account of this lamp was communicated by him to the Royal Society, in a paper "On a Steady Light in Coal Mines," read on the 20th of May, 1813.
Dr. Clanny's lamp, however, was useful rather as directing attention to the matter and showing what might be done in the way of providing a greater degree of efficiency and security in the lighting of coal mines. It was highly approved of by many scientific gentlemen, and after various tests had been applied to it to prove its security, it was carried by Dr. Clanny into a dangerous mine at the risk of his life; but the idea was novel, and the lamp being somewhat inconvenient, it did not come into practical use, at least to any extent.
But though Dr. Clanny is entitled to the high merit of being the first to conceive and carry out the idea of constructing an insulated lamp, he did not long remain alone in this department of invention, the attention of many minds being drawn to the subject soon afterwards by a series of occurrences which we shall proceed to narrate.
On the 25th of May, 1812, an explosion occurred at Brandling Main, or Felling Colliery, near Gateshead-on-Tyne, which was attended with a more appalling loss of life than any like calamity that had ever taken place in the annals of coal-mining. Ninety-two men and boys were destroyed by the blast. This great loss of life was occasioned by the disaster happening at a most inauspicious moment. It is the common custom in the North of England to work the collieries with two shifts or sets of men, and for several reasons it is made a rule that the men of the first shift remain at their working-places until relieved by the arrival of the men of the second shift. Hence, during a short space of time, both sets of men are in the mine at the same moment, and this was unfortunately the case when the above-mentioned explosion took place. Out of one hundred and twenty-one persons who had entered the mine, only thirty-two escaped alive, three of whom died within a few hours after the accident.
The colliery was at this time the property of Messrs. John and William Brandling, Henderson, and Grace, each of whom held a fourth share. It is situated in the parish of Jarrow and Heworth, of which the Rev. J. Hodgson (who afterwards became celebrated as the historian of Northumberland) was the incumbent. As Mr. Hodgson resided at Heworth, this dreadful calamity occurred at his very door, and on him devolved the task of administering the consolations of religion to the bereaved, and of performing the last solemn rites beside the graves of the dead.
Mr. Hodgson was not unacquainted with the details of coal-mining operations. He had lived for a considerable number of years in the Newcastle coal district, and had made frequent descents into the mines. At this time the editors of newspapers avoided publishing accounts of colliery explosions, being afraid of giving offence by doing so. Impressed, however, with the conviction that something further might be done to prevent the recurrence of such calamities, Mr. Hodgson, contrary to the feelings of the coalowners, determined to make the circumstances connected with the Felling explosion as widely known as possible, with the hope of rousing the attention of scientific men to investigate the causes of these accidents, and find some mode of preventing them. To this end, for many weeks he continued to write notices, respecting the accident, to the Newcastle Courant, and also wrote and published a particular account of it and its consequences, accompanied with a plan of the mine and the mode of ventilating it. This publication (the preface of which is dated 4th January, 1813) was widely circulated; and part of it, unknown to Mr. Hodgson, was inserted in Dr. Thomson's Annals of Philosophy for May of the same year.
Among those whose sympathies were excited by the recital of the dangers to which the workers in coal mines were exposed was a Mr. J. J. Wilkinson, a barrister resident in the Temple. During the Long Vacation in 1813 Mr. Wilkinson went to the North of England, and consulted with many of his friends on the matter, which resulted in his determining to call the attention of the public to colliery explosions with a view to the investigation of the whole subject, to see if any remedy could be found. With this object, on the 1st of September, 1813, he published, and sent into Durham and Northumberland, proposals for the establishment of a society for preventing accidents in coal mines. These proposals having come under the notice of the Bishop of Durham, among others, his Lordship wrote to the Rev. Dr. Gray, then Rector of Bishopwearmouth (afterwards Bishop of Bristol), giving him carte blanche to aid in the formation of such a society. A meeting of those interested was accordingly arranged for, and was held at Sunderland on the 1st of October, 1813, when the society was duly instituted and a Committee appointed to carry out the objects contemplated.
In the following month the society issued its first report, which contained a very valuable letter, voluntarily communicated by Mr. Buddle to Sir Ralph Milbanke, the president, in which was given a detailed account of the various systems employed to effect the ventilation of collieries — "the only method we are at present acquainted with," says the writer, "for the prevention of accidents by fire." In concluding his letter, Mr. Buddle expresses his conviction that any further application of mechanical agency would be ineffectual to prevent explosions in mines exposed to excessive discharges of fire-damp, "and therefore," he says, "conclude that the hopes of this society ever seeing its most desirable object accomplished must rest upon the event of some method being discovered of producing such a chemical change upon carburetted hydrogen gas as to render it innoxious as fast as it is discharged, or as it approaches the neighbourhood of lights. In this view of the subject, it is to scientific men only that we must look up for assistance in providing a cheap and effectual remedy."
It was deemed advisable to apply to Sir Humphry Davy, the distinguished chemist and philosopher, and Mr. Wilkinson accordingly called at the Royal Institution, but found that he was absent in Paris. Mr. Wilkinson then posted a letter to Sir Humpbry, but having neglected to pay the foreign postage, it was returned to Mr. Burn, the secretary of the society.
At this time so little expectation was entertained that any means could be devised likely to prevent explosions in collieries, that the object of the society was regarded as chimerical and visionary. Amidst much difficulty and discouragement, however, and a perpetual harass by the offer of impracticable schemes, they persevered in their meetings, though their humane efforts were for a considerable period attended with little success.
In the meantime colliery accidents continued to occur from time to time. A second explosion took place at Felling Colliery on the 24th of December, 1813, occasioning the loss of twenty-three lives. In 1814 explosions occurred: at Percy Main Colliery, on the 15th of April, with the loss of four lives; at Hebburn Colliery, on the 12th of August, with the loss of eleven lives; and at Seafield Colliery, on the 9th of September, with the loss of four lives. On the 3rd of May, 1815, the great inundation took place at Heaton Colliery, causing a loss of seventy-five lives; on the 2nd of June, Newbottle Colliery exploded, with the loss of fifty-seven lives; and on the 27th of the same month, Sheriff Hill Colliery exploded, with the loss of eleven lives.
Ever since the occurrence of the first explosion at Felling, accounts of similar accidents which took place were regularly forwarded to, and published in, Dr. Thomson's Annals of Philosophy, and thus the attention of the scientific world was kept alive to the matter. The idea of the practicability of employing insulated lights, which Dr. Clanny had never ceased to advocate, was gradually gaining ground. In his Elements of Chemical Science, published in June, 1815, Mr. Murray, a lecturer on chemistry, proposed the use of an airtight lamp, which was to be supplied with air through a tube extending downwards to the floor of the mine. Lamps on this principle were actually constructed by Mr. Brandling, and Dr. John Murray, of Edinburgh, during the summer or autumn of 1815; but as they presupposed the existence of determinate strata in the air of a mine, which is not the case, they were inapplicable to the purpose intended.
A correspondence regarding insulated lights for miners was also commenced in the Morning Chronicle by Mr. J. H. H. Holmes (author of a treatise on the coal mines of Durham and Northumberland), the first letter being dated 12th July, 1815. Mr. Holmes was desirous to know, from motives of humanity, whether Dr. Clanny's insulated lamp had been in use in any of the collieries where explosions had recently occurred. This led to a series of letters between Dr. Clanny and Mr. Holmes, which were published successively for a number of weeks.
We have seen that the first endeavour of the Sunderland Society to obtain the assistance of Sir Humphry Davy had proved abortive, owing to his absence on the Continent, In the close of the summer of 1815 it was again resolved to apply to him, and a letter was accordingly despatched to London by Dr. Gray, the Chairman of the Committee, who was generally acquainted with Sir Humphry. Dr. Gray's letter followed Sir Humphry into Scotland, whither he had gone on a visit to Lord Somerville, at Melrose. In his reply, dated 3rd August, Sir Humphry expresses the great satisfaction it will give him if his chemical knowledge can be of any use in an inquiry so interesting to humanity, and begs Dr. Gray to assure the Committee of his readiness to cooperate with them in any experiments or investigations on the subject. He offers at the same time to visit the mines, should it be thought desirable for him to do so.
It having been arranged that Sir Humphry should visit the coal district on his way south, he arrived in Newcastle on the 23rd or 24th of August, where he was waited upon at the Turk's Head by Mr. Hodgson, who laid before him all the printed information he knew of respecting the ventilating and lighting of coal mines — Sir Humphry entering at once with ardour into the subject. They then proceeded together to Mr. Buddle's house at Wallsend.
Mr. Hodgson had, among other things, communicated to Sir Humphry a theory which he had been led to form regarding the source of the inflammable gas in coal mines, by some experiments which he had made, viz., that it existed in the coal itself. Little was known then on this subject, though various hypotheses had been suggested. Some thought that it arose from the decomposition of the water in the mines; others from the decomposition of the coal or of the iron pyrites contained it. At Mr. Buddle's house, after much general conversation on the subject of the safe lighting of mines, Sir Humphry took up in his own hand a bucket of fresh coal and said: "With this I will try Mr. Hodgson's experiment on coal gas." Carrying it into Mr. Buddle's dining-room, he asked for a bucket of water, and having put some coal into it, and stirred it round several times that no air might remain, he struck a heavy poker with all his strength on the coal, shattering it into several pieces, whereupon numerous bubbles rose through the water. On this Sir Humphry remarked that Mr. Hodgson's experiments were certainly correct and interesting. The only other point he wished to ascertain, he said, was the minimum of light with which the colliers could see to work. This was exhibited to him by procuring a steel mill and "playing" it in a dark place.
From the first Sir Humphry entertained a sanguine hope of being able to help the miners in their difficulties. Mr. Buddle took the opposite view
"I explained to him," be says, "as well as I was able, the nature of our fiery mines, and that the great desideratum was a light that could be safely used in an explosive mixture. I had not the slightest idea myself of ever seeing such a thing accomplished Just as we were parting he looked at me and said, 'I think I can do something for you.' Thinking it was too much ever to be achieved, I gave him a look of incredulity; at the moment it was beyond my comprehension. However, smiling, he said, 'Do not despair I think I can do something for you in a very short time.' "
From Mr. Buddle's house, Sir Humphry and Mr. Hodgson proceeded to Coaly Hill, to examine a geological phenomenon mentioned by the latter, which Sir Humphry had expressed a strong desire to see. This consisted of an intrusive dyke of whin, or basalt, on the sides of which the coal had been charred for some distance by the heat of the whin when first injected in a molten state.
Having inspected several parts of the dyke with great interest, Sir Humphry and Mr. Hodgson went to Hebburn Hall, where they had been invited by Mr. Ellison (who was a very kind friend of Mr. Hodgson's) to dine and spend the night.
On the following morning Sir Humphry proceeded to Dr. Gray's, at Bishopwearmouth, and in the course of the day, accompanied by Dr. Gray's eldest son, he called at Dr. Clanny's house, being desirous to see Dr. Clanny and his insulated lamp. Dr. Clanny was not at home; neither was he at home when Sir Humphry called a second time on the same day.
Hearing of Sir Humphry's visits on his return home, Dr. Clanny, being much engaged at the time, took the lamp in his carriage, and calling at Dr. Gray's, left it for the inspection of Sir Humphry, who remained at the rectory overnight. On the following morning Sir Humphry had an interview with Dr. Clanny, who had been invited to breakfast at Dr. Gray's, but did not arrive till after the meal was over, when he found Sir Humphry engaged in making some experiments with his lamp.
Leaving Bishopwearmouth, Sir Humphry paid visits to Auckland Castle, Egglestone, Rokeby, and Harwood House, remaining at the latter place till the 29th or 30th of September.
On the 29th of September Sir Humphry wrote to Mr. Hodgson requesting him to send him a quantity of fire-damp from a blower. Six wine-bottles were accordingly filled from a strong blower of gas coming from a dyke in Hebburn Colliery, and were transmitted to Sir Humphry on the 5th of October. In a letter dated 15th October, Sir Humphry acknowledged the receipt of the fire-damp, and announced to Mr. Hodgson that his investigations were progressing well. "My experiments," he says, "are going on successfully, and I hope in a few days to send you an account of them; I am going to be fortunate far beyond my expectations."
The progress of Sir Humphry Davy in the new path of discovery which he had entered upon was as rapid as it was brilliant, and from time to time he communicated the results of his researches to his friends in the north and to the scientific circles in London.
On the 19th of October, in a letter to Mr. Hodgson, he announces an entirely new method of insulating lights. "I have already discovered," he says, "that explosive mixtures of mine-damp will not pass through small apertures or tubes; and that if a lamp or lanthorn be made air-tight on the sides, and furnished with apertures to admit the air, it will not communicate flame to the outward atmosphere."
On the 25th of October, Sir Humphry communicated the progress of his discoveries to the Chemical Club of London.
On the 30th of October he wrote simultaneously to Dr. Gray and Mr. Hodgson, giving an account of his discoveries with considerable detail, and describing three forms of insulated lamps. In these communications he states, among other things, that —
"Atmospherical air, when rendered impure by the combustion of a candle, but in which the candle will still burn, will not explode the gas from the mines; and when a lamp or candle is made to burn in a close vessel, having apertures only above and below, an explosive mixture of gas admitted merely enlarges the light and gradually extinguishes it without explosion. Again, the gas mixed in any proportion with common air I have discovered will not explode in small tubes, the diameter of which is less than one-eighth of an inch, or even a larger tube, if there is a mechanical force urging the gas through the tube."
The above communications were not intended to be made public at this stage.
"I consider this at present as a private communication," says Sir Humphry in his letter to Dr. Gray. "I wish you to examine the lamps I have had constructed, before you give any account of my labours to the committee. I have never received so much pleasure from the result of any of my chemical labours; for I trust the cause of humanity will gain something by it."
The letter sent to Mr. Hodgson was copied by several professional men of the neighbourhood on the 2nd of November. [Perhaps Mr. Matthias Dunn, who procured the fire-damp, may have been one of them. He gives an extract from it in his View of the Coal Trade, but by some error has dated the letter 15th instead of 30th October.] Mr. Hodgson tells us that he records this fact merely to show that Sir Humphry's discoveries were known at this time to several persons in the Newcastle district besides himself. He did not imagine that any of the gentlemen who copied his letter made an improper use of it.
In an oration delivered on the 4th of November at the foundation of the college of the Royal Institution, Mr. Butler alluded, in terms of exultation, to the process discovered "within these few weeks" by Sir H. Davy, whereby the fire-damp of coal mines had been absolutely subdued.
On the 9th of November, Sir Humphry read his first paper to the Royal Society relative to the progress of his discoveries. It is entitled, "On the firedamp of coal mines, and on methods of lighting the mines so as to prevent its explosion." As this paper is published in the Philosophical Transactions, it is unnecessary to enter into any account of the innumerable delicate experiments made by Sir Humphry before he succeeded in producing lamps which were at once safe and gave a good light. It may be remarked, however, that the results achieved were arrived at by processes which could only have been pursued by an individual conversant with all the resources of chemical science, and with every appliance at his command, leaving out of view altogether the rare creative genius of Sir Humphry Davy.
We have entered with considerable detail into the dates at which the various announcements of the progress of Sir Humphry Davy's discoveries were made, on account of the claim to priority of invention which was shortly afterwards put forward by Mr. R. W. Brandling on behalf of George Stephenson, who at this time was an engineer at Killingworth Colliery, near Newcastle-on-Tyne. It is perfectly clear that for some time, at all events, Sir Humphry and Mr. Stephenson were devoting their energies simultaneously to the invention of an insulated lamp on entirely different lines. The first occasion on which a rencontre took place between their respective lamps was at a public meeting of the coal-trade held at Newcastle-onTyne on the 10th of November.
It will be remembered that Sir Humphry Davy addressed letters containing an account of his discoveries to Dr. Gray and Mr. Hodgson on the 30th of October, and that these communications were intended to be kept private. Mr. Hodgson, however, having seen a notice of Sir Humphry's labours in the public newspapers, considered it no longer necessary to maintain any reserve, and on his own responsibility attended the above-mentioned meeting and read to the coalowners the communication which he had received. The reading of the paper appeared to excite considerable interest. Mr. Hodgson was not aware at the time that Sir Humphry Davy had any rival in the field, but after he had read the paper, some gentlemen from the neighbourhood of Killingworth, among whom was Mr. R. Lambert, made mention of Mr. Stephenson's lamp, which Mr. Hodgson then heard of for the first time. We shall now, therefore, proceed to endeavour to elucidate the origin and progress of Mr. Stephenson's efforts to invent an insulated lamp.
In the summer of 1815 Mr. Stephenson, in his capacity of engineer, being engaged in setting up some machinery in the Killingworth pit, frequently set fire to a blower of gas which he passed on his way underground to and from his work. He was expostulated with by several pitmen regarding the danger of this proceeding, but excused himself by stating "generally" that he thought he could make it useful to preserve men's lives. Having discovered that, by holding a number of lighted candles on the windward side of the blower, he could extinguish its flame by the "burnt air" proceeding from them, he was led to form a theory on which he thought a safety-lamp might be constructed. It was, "that if a lamp could be made to contain the burnt air above the flame, and to permit the fire-damp to come in below in small quantity, to be burnt as it came in, the burnt air would prevent the passing of explosion upwards, and the velocity of the current from below would also prevent its passing downwards."
This theory he communicated to Mr. Nicholas Wood "about or before the month of August." No steps, however, were taken to carry out the idea till the beginning of the month of October, at which time a plan was made by Mr. Wood from Mr. Stephenson's directions; and the lamp was ordered from Mr. Hogg, a tinman in Newcastle, "most probably as early as the 2nd, but certainly before the 7th of October." It was at first intended to supply air to the lamp through a tube in the bottom ¼ of an inch in diameter, but on its being represented by Mr. Hogg that it probably would not burn, the tube was made an inch in diameter, and a slide was attached in order to lessen it if necessary. At the same time a glass for the lamp was ordered at the Northumberland Glass-House. It was conical in shape and open at the top.
The lamp was completed and delivered to Mr. Stephenson on the 21st of October, and on the evening of the same day was tried at the blower in Killingworth Colliery. It was found that when the slide was so far shut that the lamp burnt "but feebly" in good air, when exposed to the current of the blower, "within a few inches of the mouth," the flame of the lamp increased in size, and then went out, without communicating explosion to the gas outside; but when in this condition, the lamp was easily put out by motion.
Mr. Stephenson's biographer has constructed a "pretty story" about the trial of this lamp, in which he states, with considerable emphasis, that the very first experiment with it was made by Mr. Stephenson in the mine at the risk of his own life. Mr. Wood, however, who was present, explains that the danger was not quite so great as represented by Mr. Smiles. "At most," he says, "an explosion might have burnt the hands of the operator, but would not extend a few feet from the blower."
Whatever was proved by the trials to which the lamp was put, it was found that the tube and slide arrangement was a failure. If it was safe at all, it was only when the flame of the lamp was reduced to such a degree as to be practically valueless, as it could not bear being carried about. It was consequently determined to make alterations; and, as Mr. Stephenson conceived that the cause of the lamp going out (when moved quickly, he says) was owing to the "burnt air" hanging about the flame, he determined to apply three smaller tubes instead of one large one, and to place them round the flame and point them towards it, in order to dispel this air. The lamp was accordingly forthwith intrusted to a Mr. Matthews, a tinman in Newcastle, who made the alterations; but they were of such a trivial description that the transaction was not entered in his books, and no particulars were preserved by him either of the date or of the size of the tubes. They are stated, however, to have been made of such a size as the experiments with the slide had determined to be the dimensions of safety — the safety, we presume, ascribed to "the velocity of the current from below."
The altered lamp was delivered to Mr. Stephenson on the 4th of November, and tried in Killingworth Colliery on the same day. The accounts of the trial are somewhat laconic. Mr. Stephenson says it was "found safe." Mr. Wood tells us that it was "found to burn better than the other, but still not well; still, however, the explosion did not pass downwards." The overman states that Stephenson thought, and he agreed with him, "that the altered lamp burnt better than the former;" also that the lamp was tried in a "very foul" place, and the effect was the same as before; the flame increased and then went out.
Whether the tests which were applied to the altered lamp can be regarded as conclusive evidence of its safety is perhaps questionable. It is scarcely probable that either Mr. Stephenson or his companions knew at this time that pure fire-damp extinguishes lights, or were acquainted with the proportions of gas and air which form the most explosive mixture. Again, was the lamp proof against passing explosion upwards? However this may be, there appears to have been a general consensus of opinion as to its deficient burning powers. Even Mr. Stephenson was disappointed with it. "It did not entirely answer my expectations," he says; nor is this surprising, inasmuch as, according to his theory, his lamp was to burn among fire-damp, whereas it did exactly the reverse.
This lamp was never exhibited outside of Killingworth, but two subsequent sets of experiments were made with it there which are worthy of note. We are told that "on the 17th of November it was tried at Killingworth office, with inflammable air, before Richard Lambert, Esq.; and on the 24th of November before R. W. Brandling, Esq., C. J. Brandling, Esq., and Mr. Murray;" but that at the latter date Mr. Stephenson had a new lamp in the hands of the manufacturer.
What transpired at Killingworth office on the 17th of November we do not know; it is possible that neither Sir Humphry Davy, nor his lamps with apertures above and below, were ever mentioned. Neither do we know whether the notice of Sir Humphry Davy's discoveries which appeared in the Newcastle Chronicle on the 18th of November was seen by Mr. Stephenson. One thing, however, appears to be pretty certain, and that is that at this particular juncture a new light burst in upon Mr. Stephenson, and that he instantly set about constructing a new lamp, which differed in several essential particulars from his three-tube lamp. The plan of the new lamp was not drawn by Mr. Wood, but by a "Mr. Henry Smith, clerk to Robert Watson, plumber in Newcastle." It was ordered on the 19th or 20th of November, and was made and delivered to Mr. Stephenson in a few days.
In the new lamp the air was admitted through a series of apertures below, and it escaped through apertures above. This lamp was tried in the Killingworth Mine on the 30th of November, "and found to be perfectly safe and to burn extremely well." On the 5th of December it was exhibited and experimented upon, with fire-damp, before a general meeting of the Literary and Philosophical Society of Newcastle-on-Tyne. We are told that at this meeting Mr. Wood attempted to explain the rationale of the lamp, but was unable to do so; whereupon Mr. Stephenson stepped forward and described it "down to its minutest details." The account given by a gentleman who was present at the meeting (Mr. J. H. H. Holmes) is somewhat different —
"Mr. Stephenson," he says, "undoubtedly claims great merit if the invention produced was from his own genius. The principle of this lamp is its being supplied with air through small perforations at the bottom, which, when in pure atmospheric air, enables the light to burn something similar to the radiance of a rushlight. In regard to this lantern having been tried in a mine six weeks previous to its appearance at the meeting, I must express some doubts, as it certainly did not wear the appearance of so old a practitioner, and as Mr. Stephenson appeared totally ignorant of the manner in which the air and gases operated upon the light. Nothing was heard or said of it previous to the private meeting before spoken of (held on the 28th of November), which was exclusively for the purpose of taking into consideration the methods of lighting collieries."
There is a lamp now in the possession of the Literary and Philosophical Society of Newcastle-on-Tyne, which is stated to be the identical lamp exhibited at the above meeting. If it be so, it is not in the same condition as it then was; e.g., the lamp exhibited had a conical glass, and no trimmer: the lamp now in the possession of the society has a cylindrical glass, and the Davy trimmer.
After what has been already stated, it seems unnecessary to enter into the question of priority of invention. It must be evident, we imagine, that in every particular Mr. Stephenson was anticipated by Sir Humphry Davy; while any improvements subsequently made, based upon the chemical discoveries of Davy, however ingenious and useful they may be, cannot be regarded as original inventions.
The discovery which Sir Humphry Davy had made, that explosion would not pass through small apertures and tubes; was only a stepping-stone to still higher achievements; and before the close of the year 1815 he gave to the world the wire-gauze lamp. This was the last, the most splendid, the crowning triumph of his labours — the "metallic tissue, permeable to light and air, and impermeable to flame."
The first "Davy lamps" — as the gauze lamps were named after their illustrious inventor — were sent to the North of England in the beginning of January, 1816, and, after a few preliminary experiments, were tried in Hebburn Colliery by Mr. Matthias Dunn and the Rev. J. Hodgson, with the most excellent results.
By no one was the invention more eagerly welcomed than by Mr. Buddle; no one was a better judge of its inestimable value. "I first tried it," he says, "in an explosive mixture on the surface, and then took it into a mine; and, to my astonishment and delight, it is impossible for me to express my feelings at the time when I first suspended the lamp in the mine, and saw it red-hot; if it had been a monster destroyed, I could not have felt more exultation than I did. I said to those around me, 'We have at last subdued this monster.'"
A few months later Sir Humphry Davy accompanied Mr. Buddle into some of the fiery mines of the north to see his lamp in actual use. "Sir Humphry was delighted," says Mr. Buddle, "and I was overwhelmed with feelings of gratitude to that great genius which had produced it."
Mr. Buddle remonstrated with Sir Humphry for not securing the invention by a patent, from which he might have derived an income of five or ten thousand a year. "The reply of this great and noble-minded man," he says, was "'No, my good friend, I never thought of such a thing; my sole object was to serve the cause of humanity; and if I have succeeded, I am amply rewarded in the gratifying reflection of having done so."
No sooner had the immense value of the Davy lamp become manifest, than the coal-owners determined to present Sir Humphry with a substantial token of their admiration and gratitude. To this Mr. R. W. Brandling demurred, bringing forward the claims of Mr. Stephenson, and requesting that an investigation should first be made to ascertain who was the real inventor. This proposal was submitted to a meeting of the coal-owners and negatived. The same meeting, however, voted one hundred guineas to Mr. Stephenson, as an acknowledgment of his labours in the same direction.
The presentation to Sir Humphry Davy was made at a dinner held at the Queen's Head, Newcastle, on the 25th of September, 1817, Mr. J. G. Lambton presiding. It consisted of a service of plate worth £2,500.
Mr. Stephenson's friends, being dissatisfied, commenced a subscription on his behalf. The amount collected, added to the previous sum voted by the coalowners, reached the handsome total of about £800. This, together with a silver tankard, was presented to Mr. Stephenson by Mr. Brandling, at a public dinner held in the Assembly Rooms, Newcastle, in January, 1818.
The claims of Dr. Clanny were long overlooked. He received the gold and silver medals of the Society of Arts; but it was not till as late as 1846 that steps were taken to procure for him some public acknowledgment of his labours in the cause of humanity in connection with colliery explosions. An appeal having been made on his behalf, a purse of gold was collected, which together with a silver salver, was presented to him at the Athenaeum, Sunderland, on the 3rd of February, 1848.
The invention of the safety-lamp was regarded by Dr. Gray as a sufficient reason for dissolving the Sunderland Society for the Prevention of Accidents in Mines.
The share which the Rev. J. Hodgson had had in the steps which led to the invention of the safety-lamp was no small one. It was he who, braving the displeasure of the affluent Brandlings, had vividly portrayed and laid before the public eye, in his little pamphlet on the Felling explosion, the awful spectacle presented by a colliery devastated by "whirlwinds of tempestuous fire," and aroused the attention of the humane to the perils to which the workers in fiery mines were exposed. The assistance he had given in forwarding the invention afforded him some solace even in his last illness.
Sir Humphry Davy in after life always dwelt with peculiar satisfaction and delight upon the invention of his safety-lamp. "I value it," he used to say, "more than anything I ever did. It was the result of a great deal of investigation and labour; but, if my directions be only attended to, it will save the lives of thousands of poor labourers. I never was more affected than by a written address which I received from the working colliers, when I was in the North, thanking me, in behalf of themselves and their families, for the preservation of their lives." He used also to exhibit to his friends with great delight the service of plate which had been presented to him.
Not only has the safety-lamp been instrumental in saving thousands of lives, but it has also enabled untold millions of tons of coal to be rescued from the bowels of the earth, which without its aid would have been irrevocably lost. It rendered possible the entire removal of the pillars of coal, great part of which was formerly left underground in fiery mines. It led to the re-opening of many collieries which had been abandoned after having been worked out as far as was practicable by means of candles and steel mills. Walker Colliery, which had been abandoned in 1811, was re-opened in 1818 by the aid of the Davy lamp, and has continued working to this day. Great part of the formerly relinquished workings in Wallsend, Willington, Percy Main, Hebburn, Jarrow, Elswick, Benwell, &c., as well as several collieries on the river Wear, were recovered and resumed work by its aid.
The introduction of the safety-lamp did not put an end to colliery explosions; though few indeed are traceable to it, notwithstanding the many thousands of wire-gauze lamps, of various forms, which subsequently came into daily use. Difficulties there are even with its aid; but, in the case of deep mining, what vastly greater, what insuperable difficulties would have existed, had science not armed the miners with the wonderful insulated lamp, which warns them of the presence of their invisible enemy, and protects them from its power.
The dates cited in the above narrative can, we think, be established beyond the possibility of controversy. It is perhaps almost unnecessary to remark that both Dr. Clanny and Mr. Stephenson subsequently adopted the Davy wire gauze in their lamps, but for which vital improvement they would long since have been laid aside.