Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
Items for sale
Items for Sale
e-Books
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

E-Book Prev Page Return to Index Next Page E-Book
/   \

Chapter XIV.

Various Methods Of Dealing With Inflammable Gas. — The Diluting System, The Neutralizing System, The Firing System, The Draining System.

During the years 1805-6 a number of disastrous colliery explosions occurred in close succession in various parts of the kingdom. In the North of England, Hebburn Colliery exploded on the 21st of October, 1805, occasioning a loss of thirty-five lives; Oxclose Colliery on the 28th of November following, with the loss of thirty-eight lives; and Killingworth Colliery on the 28th of March, 1806, with the loss of ten lives. Other explosions occurred in 1806, viz., two at Mostyn, in North Wales, by which thirty-six men perished; another at St. Helens, in Lancashire, with the loss of sixteen lives; and another at Whitehaven, with the loss of eleven lives. The frequent repetition of these calamities led to the proposal of several new schemes for dealing with the noxious gases, and particularly with the fire-damp, of coal mines.

Two methods of combating the inflammable gas have already been referred to, and were now in use in different parts of the kingdom. The first of these, consisting in the introduction of a ventilating current sufficiently ample to reduce the gas below the point of ignition and sweep it out of the mine as quickly as it was produced, has been termed the diluting system. The second method, practised where the ventilation alone was inadequate to remove the gas, consisted in kindling and exploding it at intervals sufficiently short to prevent large accumulations from being formed, and was known as the firing system.

Near the close of the year 1805 a new scheme was brought under the notice of the owners and agents of the collieries in the North of England by Dr. Trotter, a physician resident in Newcastle-on-Tyne. The attention of this gentleman was drawn to the subject, he tells us, in connection with the explosion at Hebburn Colliery. When on a visit to a sick friend he happened to pass the churchyard at Jarrow, at the time that thirty-two pitmen, victims of this explosion, were being interred there. The solemnity of the scene, and the fact that the unfortunate men had left twenty-five widows and eighty-one orphans to bewail their loss, so impressed him as to induce him to prepare and issue a pamphlet addressed to the coal-owners and agents, entitled A Proposal for Destroying the Fire and Choak Damps of Coal Mines.

In this pamphlet Dr. Trotter suggested a scheme for depriving fire-damp of its explosive properties by a process of fumigation, to be performed by means of oxygenated muriatic gas — a neutralizing system it may be termed. But though the proposal does credit to his humanity, and proved of service in leading to a discussion of the subject, the scheme was open to a number of fatal objections. These were urged with much force by two writers who undertook to reply to Dr. Trotter's proposal, viz., Dr. Dewar, physician to the Manchester Infirmary, and an anonymous writer who styles himself "A Friend to Rational Schemes of Improvement," both of whom display a knowledge of chemistry, and of the interior economy of coal mines, superior to that possessed by Dr. Trotter. The chief objections urged against the proposed scheme were, that the gases resulting from the fumigation would be extremely deleterious, and that the cost of the process, assuming the possibility of carrying it out in practice, would be so enormous as to put its employment altogether out of the question.

Dr. Trotter's able critics offered some valuable suggestions of their own for the consideration of the owners and agents of coal mines. Dr. Dewar proposed the employment of steam, instead of fire, for rarefying the air at the mouth of the upcast shaft in the case of the ventilation of old workings, where explosion might be apprehended at a ventilating furnace. "Let the air from the shaft," he says, "pass through a tall cylinder of tinned iron. Let this be contained within an other cylinder sufficiently large to leave a considerable vacant space between the two, and let this space be accurately closed in all directions, with only two openings, one for admitting the steam from a boiler, and the other for allowing the condensed water to escape. It is hardly necessary to observe that the external cylinder must be surrounded with baked clay, brick, or some other slow-conducting substance, to prevent a superfluous expenditure of heat. This mode of ventilation would be slower than that in common use, but it would evidently be much more safe in the cases here referred to. Would it not be equally certain in its effect? and (where the price of fuel is no object) would it not be sufficiently economical ?"

A suggestion of still greater value emanated from Dr. Trotter's second critic, "A Friend to Rational Schemes of Improvement." This writer proposed an improved arrangement of the underground ventilation, so as to dispense with the numerous doors required to guide the air current. The inconvenience arising from the use of doors, he states, "might probably be obviated by dividing the mine into a greater number of independent systems of ventilation, so disposed that each waggon-road shall form part of an air-course, and shall not intersect any air-course. This measure must of course be attended with some expense in making partitions, &c.; but this would be of no great amount, and would be cheaply purchased, when it is considered that it would insure the lives of numbers of persons who may now be brought into danger by the trifling circumstance of inadvertently leaving open a door."

Shortly after the date when the above pregnant suggestion was published (1806), the plan of adopting independent systems of ventilation was actually carried out in practice, and was found to be productive of immense benefit in many ways; indeed, it has been aptly termed the true secret of mine ventilation. The introduction of this improvement, however, will be referred to hereafter.

Contemporaneously with Dr. Trotter's proposal to employ chemical agents to destroy the noxious gases, a new scheme for dealing with the inflammable gas was devised by a Mr. James Ryan. We are unable to state how Ryan was employed in his earlier years, but in 1800 he was engaged as a mineral surveyor under the Grand Canal Company in Ireland. In 1804 we find him employed to examine and report upon Mostyn and some other collieries in North Wales; and in the following year he invented and patented an improved method of boring, whereby cores could be obtained, and the quality of the strata pierced be ascertained with more certainty than formerly. He also proposed to employ his apparatus for boring out shafts several feet in diameter, which might be used for pumping or ventilating mines.

Having in the course of his professional duties acquired a knowledge of the properties of the gases met with in coal mines, Ryan projected a new scheme for clearing the mines of fire-damp. This gas, on account of its light specific gravity, tending always to flow upwards and collect in the higher parts of the workings, he proposed to employ a series of small passages, or gas drifts, so arranged as to collect and draw off the gas at the highest level. His system may be termed the draining system.

For some time Ryan was unable to obtain an opportunity of putting his scheme into practice. In 1806 he visited the scenes of the various explosions in the west, at Mostyn, St. Helens, and Whitehaven, but his proposals were rejected. In the same year he also visited Newcastle-on-Tyne, and had many conversations with Mr. Buddle on the subject of mine ventilation, in consequence of which he delivered a course of lectures at Newcastle; but he failed to induce any colliery to adopt his system, and was forced to return home without having obtained a trial of his scheme in any pit. In the following year (1807) he proceeded to London and waited upon Sir John Sinclair, the liberal-minded President of the Board of Agriculture, who highly approved of his plans, and introduced him to the Honourable Washington Shirley, through whose influence he at last succeeded in obtaining an opportunity of applying his system in some of the mines in South Staffordshire.

Ryan's system of ventilation was peculiarly suited to the South Staffordshire mines. The method of working pursued in this county was of a unique type, having its origin in the exceptional conditions under which the coal existed and the character of the coal itself. The seam of coal most extensively worked, viz., the Thick Coal, was of extraordinary thickness, as much as thirty or forty feet; while the small coal, or slack, which was produced in working and was invariably left underground, was remark ably subject to spontaneous combustion, or "breeding fire," as it was termed by the miners, The coal being comparatively shallow, and a large quantity obtainable from a small area, the workings were never carried to any great distance from the shafts; and the arrangement of the workings was specially designed to check the spread of the underground fires which were of such frequent occurrence. This was effected by dividing the area to be worked into a number of large chambers surrounded on all sides by fire ribs, or barriers of solid coal, through which no openings were made save only such as were essentially necessary for the extraction of the coal and the passage of air, and these were effectually stopped up and the whole chamber dammed off as soon as all the coal that could be got from it had been obtained.

To reduce still further the risk of premature ignition of the slack, the working of the coal was carried on with a minimum of ventilation; and inasmuch as the air current from the downcast pit was brought by means of a passage termed the "air-head" into the upper part of the chamber, and the quantity of air introduced was insufficient to dilute and sweep away the fire-damp, recourse was regularly had to the firing process to dissipate the collections of inflammable gas in the upper parts of the chambers.

The firing process as practised in Staffordshire, being essential to the method of working and ventilating pursued, was conducted upon a regular system. During the operation of exploding the gas, all the workmen, save those actually engaged — the firemen as they were termed — -were withdrawn from the mine. The pit stables were employed by the firemen as their base of operations, and were strongly barricaded for the purpose. From this point a copper wire — the firing line — was led to the part of the mine where the accumulation of gas existed. Approaching as near to the place of danger as was consistent with their own safety, the firemen raised the wire aloft by means of a long pole (or series of poles fitting each other like a fishing-rod), and provided with a small sheave or wheel at the extremity for carrying the line. Having fixed the pole in the required position, and secured to the end of the line on the floor of the mine a lighted candle weighted with a piece of lead to keep it steady, the firemen retired to the stable, where, pulling in the wire through a crevice, they elevated the lighted candle at the other end and so exploded the gas. If by any accidental circumstance the candle had become extinguished, and the explosion did not take place, the firemen were sometimes left in a state of the greatest suspense, and being afraid to sally out, remained pent up for a length of time imprisoned in their own stronghold.

In many instances the above dangerous operation had to be repeated several times in a day. Thus at the Netherton pits belonging to Lord Dudley, between the years 1798 and 1808, the firing of the gas was regularly practised three times a day, viz, at four o'clock in the morning, at noon, and at seven in the evening.

Such was the condition of mine ventilation in South Staffordshire when Ryan came into the district at the close of the year 1808. Having been intrusted with the management of one of the most fiery mines, he proceeded to put his ideas to a practical test, and by a few alterations which he made, succeeded in clearing the mine from fire-damp, and putting the workings into a safe state, in the short space of twenty days. This he effected chiefly by a rearrangement of the ventilating current, connecting the air-heads, or passages in the higher parts of the coal, with the upcast instead of the downcast pit, and thus employing them to draw off the gas, instead of blowing in air among it as formerly. In this way the light specific gravity of the fire-damp, which had previously been a source of difficulty, was made to aid in the escape of the gas.

That the introduction of Ryan's system was productive of great benefit to the South Staffordshire mines cannot be disputed. It threw a new light on the subject of ventilation, and led to the general adoption of top-heads, or passages in the upper portion of the Thick Coal for draining off the gas. This alteration rendered the use of the firing-line unnecessary, inasmuch as accumulations of gas could no longer take place. Like other innovators and improvers, however, Ryan was not without detractors and rivals.

But though the draining system proved of great service under the peculiar circumstances attending the working of the Staffordshire Thick Coal, it was less applicable in the case of thin coal lying in a level or undulating position, where the workings were carried over extensive areas, and fire-damp was met with in great quantities, and where no natural difficulty prevented the introduction of large volumes of air into the mines. Hence it is not surprising to find that while Ryan's system was highly esteemed by many intelligent persons in the midland districts, his schemes were regarded with complete apathy by the viewers of the North of England, who universally adhered to the diluting system of ventilation. A few years later (1815) he attempted to introduce his system into the north, but without success. His labours in the cause of the better ventilation of mines were duly appreciated by the London Society of Arts, who, in the year 1816, presented him with their gold medal and one hundred guineas: and the value of his suggestions has been acknowledged by later investigators, both in this country and on the Continent, to a greater extent than was accorded to him by some of his contemporaries in the mining world.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page
mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print