Returning to the junction of the Narrow Board and Cross-cut haulage roads and proceeding into the latter — For a few yards from the junction disturbance was not observed, skating deals and timbering were not moved. At (49) had been two man-doors in a passage leading into the return. These doors and the brickwork framing were blown in the direction of the return; the bricks, door crooks, and other parts of the doors were found lying about 20 yards in that direction, and amongst timber standing undisturbed. The props in this passage were thickly coated with coal dust on the side opposite to the direction of the blast. At (50) were two canvas doors before the explosion; these doors were blown in-bye. A short distance down the Cross-cut extensive falls of stone had to be passed over, and these falls continued almost to the face. (51) Here sets of full and empty tubs afforded unmistakable evidence of force having traversed them in the direction of the face. The empty tubs were twisted and torn in a most surprising manner. From these tubs, to within about 100 yards of the face, the roof-stone of the Cross-cut haulage road had fallen continuously. Near the face indications of force decreased, and the timber was not displaced. The Right Hand haulage road was much blocked by falls of stone, most of the timber having been blown out. At (52) timber left standing indicated the passage of force in the direction of the face. Balks supported, before the explosion, at both ends by props, had one prop blown out, and the loose end of the balk was forced in-bye. The timber left standing in this road was coated with dust on the side opposite to the direction of the blast. The explosion had not passed to the face of this road.
The return air roads were examined, and it was clear that no explosion had traversed them. They were, in every respect, in their ordinary state, except at points where doors, air crossings, or light stoppings had been blown to them by force passing from the intake.
The evidences of flame were as follows :— One of the surviving workmen at the bottom of the smaller downcast shaft was burnt, but not seriously; his partner was not burnt. These men stated they saw dust burning near the coal-drawing shaft after the explosion. A man at the coal-drawing shaft in the lower level saw sparks. Brattice cloth was found burning, after the descent of explorers, at (8). Men were burnt at (9), (17), (24), and (25), and ponies at the stables near (18). A horsekeeper was burnt in the stables by the side of the Middle North haulage road. On the main haulage road, between the Middle and Low North ways, a fire had burned for some time after the explosion. At (27) two men were burnt. At the face of the Low North way, at F', F'', F''', F'''', men were burnt, and coked dust was observed on the timber, In the travelling way, parallel to the main road, and connecting the Low North and Middle North haulage roads, coked dust was observed on the timber and on the coal. At F' and F'', between (32) and (35), on the main road men were burnt.
A short distance along the Hitch North haulage road, at (34), coked dust was observed on timber next the roof, to which a canvas door had been nailed; it was deposited in the direction of the explosion. At (37) ponies were burnt. At (38) a man was burnt. At (39), in a passage (a cul de sac) driven about 30 yards from and at right angles to the haulage road, were three props near the face. Coked dust was on these props, and on the sides next the face, or sides opposite to the only possible direction of the explosion. At (43) coked dust was observed on a balk, and on the side opposite to the direction of the explosion. At F' and F'', near the face of the Narrow Board haulage road, coked dust was on the sides of the timber, opposite to the direction of the explosion. At F''', props were coated with coked dust all round.
At (49) coked dust was observed on a sheave support and on timber on the sides opposite the direction of the explosion. At F', F'', F''', at the face of the Cross-cut district, coked dust was on the timber and on the floor, and near here a pick handle was charred.
At the time of the explosion there were on the plane of the explosion 42 persons.
There were the following fires and naked lights on the plane of the explosion :— Open lights at the bottom of the smaller downcast, and at the boilers on each side of the downcast shaft. Boiler fires on each side of the downcast shaft. Coal on fire in a flue near the downcast shafts. Each of the workmen, except those at the boilers and shafts, had a safety lamp.
A shot was to be fired at one point only — for the purpose of removing side stone.
Dividing the workmen on the plane of the explosion as before, the survivors were only two, viz., the workmen at the bottom of the smaller downcast shaft. These men stated they had been under no alarm up to the moment of the explosion.
The victims, in the field of the explosion, who had been traversed by force, or flame, or both, were, a lad firing a boiler on the west side of the coal-drawing shaft. He was not burnt, but had been thrown upon the hot and wet ashes at the fire hole, and was scalded. He died five days after the explosion. At the boilers on the east side of the coal-drawing shaft two men were found, one, a fireman, had been engaged at the boilers, and the other, a wagonwayman, had probably been resting near him. Both these men were burnt, and had been subjected to some violence. The fireman was dead when found, the wagonwayman was alive but died within six hours of being brought to the surface. Flame would probably issue from the boiler fires at the fire hole at the time of the explosion, and may have burnt the fireman.
At the Lawson's way end a deputy overman was found at a lamp station, where he was waiting for his men, and where he had been left by the last person who came out of this part of the pit before the explosion. His safety lamp was blown down and was found near him. This official, together with three others, descended some time before the night shift workmen in order to examine the working faces in respect to ventilation; after this examination they repaired to the lamp stations to meet their respective workmen.
At the Middle North way end were found two boys and a deputy overman. The boys were in a recess where they were probably waiting for the night shift men. The deputy overman was at a lamp station waiting for his men. He was buried under a fall of stone.
In the Middle North stables a horsekeeper was found, under a fall of stone, at a point where he was probably engaged in the ordinary course of his work. At the Low North way end, two men were found buried under a fall of stone at the place where they had been working. One of their lamps was blown down and was found near them; the other lamp was not found, it was probably buried under fallen stone.
At the face of the Low North nine men were found; some of them had moved a few yards from the places where they had been working, leaving their lamps, which had been extinguished and were found hanging in their working places; these men were burnt but not mutilated.
In the undisturbed length of the main road were five men (including a deputy overman at a lamp station) who had moved up to 9 yards after the explosion; the position of these men will be more particularly described.
On the Narrow Board haulage road two men were found at the place where they had been working; their lamps were blown down. On the Right Hand haulage road a deputy overman was found buried under a fall of stone; he had probably been coming out to meet his men after an examination of the working face.
The victims outside the field of the explosion were the two explorers, who perished from after-damp in the return air road near the shaft, having descended after the explosion. Eight workmen and the master shifter, or official in charge of the pit, at the face of the Middle North had been traversed by a gust of air, which had extinguished their lamps, but they had not been injured or burnt by the explosion. They had, with one exception, moved out in the dark about 200 yards, leaving their lamps, before being struck down by after-damp.
Four workmen in the Hitch North had been traversed by no force or flame, nor had their lamps been extinguished; they were found on the Hitch North haulage road with their lamps. They had left their working places and had moved a considerable distance after the explosion. The oil of some of their lamps was exhausted.
There was no evidence that up to the moment of the explosion any alarm had been felt by workmen in any part of the pit. Any movement that had taken place was such as would probably occur after the explosion.
It will be noted that the four deputy overmen are assumed to have examined the parts of the pit under their charge previous to the entry of the night shift workmen. Had they, during their examination, found anything defective they would probably not have been where they were found.
In fixing the point of origin, it is necessary to consider all the places where there was a light or flame of any kind. These were — all the workmen, each of whom had a lamp, and two of them were using gunpowder; the boiler fires and the coal on fire in a flue at the shafts.
Near the shafts, as shown on Plan 1, are two roads only (through the troubles east of the shafts) into the district affected by the explosion. One of these roads, the return air way, was unaffected by the explosion, and all indications of direction showed that the explosion had passed to the shafts by the other road, the main intake; any light or flame about the shafts may, therefore, be dismissed as an origin of the explosion. The next light, passing in-bye, was the safety lamp of a deputy overman, at the Lawson's way end; he had clearly been traversed by the explosion passing to the shaft. The next lights were a group of three, the safety lamps of the deputy overman and two lads at the Middle North way end. The explosion clearly passed them going to the shaft. The horsekeeper, the master shifter, and eight workmen in the Middle North had each a safety lamp. The horsekeeper was buried under a fall of stone caused by the explosion passing into the Middle North off the main road; lie could not, therefore, be selected as a point of origin. The master shifter and the eight workmen in the Middle North had not been traversed by any explosion; they were none of them burnt, nor was there any burning near them ; they had, with one exception, moved some distance after the explosion, which was arrested, passing to them in two directions, viz :— by the stables on the Middle North haulage road, and by the return air road between the Low North and Middle North, The next lights passing in-bye on the main road were the safety lamps of two shifters at the Low North way end. These men had been traversed by great force, and they were burnt. A force, coming from in-bye, had struck tubs as described within three or four yards of them. They were exposed to the full force of the explosion, and were buried under stone which fell on them at the point where they were working. There was no reason for selecting the lights of these men as points of origin. The next lights were the safety lamps of the workmen in the Low North way, nine in number. The explosion had clearly passed up the Low North haulage road to these men, and flame had extended to the face, as evidenced by the burning of the men, and by coked dust on the timber. It was quite clear that the explosion had passed to the face of the Low North way, off the main way, both by the full and empty way of the Low North, and beyond the junction of the full and empty way, by the single road constituting the Low North haulage road. Passing in-bye, over the undisturbed portion of the main road, four men were working in the Hitch North, into which no explosion had passed. These four men were not burned or injured in any way, and had moved out some distance with their lamps after the explosion and had perished from after-damp. They cannot be selected as points of origin. Two shifters on the Narrow Board haulage road had safety lamps, and had been traversed by the force of the explosion, the explosion having evidently passed in-bye to them.
A deputy overman on the Right Hand haulage road was traversed by the explosion and buried under a fall of stone. The explosion passed in-bye to him, and his safety lamp cannot be selected as the point of origin.
There remain now for consideration the five men in the undisturbed portion of the main road.
It will be noticed that this portion of the main road is, where it crosses the ten yard dip trouble, one of three roads only. These three passages connect the two portions of the mine, that lying to the east and that lying to the west of the trouble. It was clear, from examination of the two return staples or pits up the leader of the trouble, that no explosion had traversed them, and the doors in the stenton in the centre of the undisturbed portion of the main road at (33) had been blown to the return on the north side. Doors leading to the return on the south side, situated in a passage a short distance down the Cross-cut haulage road at (49), had also been blown to that return. The middle of these three passages across the trouble, or the main intake and haulage road is, therefore, the connecting link. In this road the dust showed that some movement of the air had taken place along its entire length, and burning was proved in the centre of it.
The fact of this length of road escaping damage was a very striking feature, considering the great damage done on each side of it, and that it was clearly the route over which the explosion, causing the damage on each side, had passed.
The only probable hypothesis appeared to be, that the explosion had started in this undisturbed section, and developed energy, in some manner, as it passed in-bye and out-bye.
It did not appear possible, that an explosion, producing the effects observed, could pass over one of the most confined parts of the pit (in 70 yards of which there were no side openings whatever), and do so little damage, except under special conditions.
The indications of direction of force confirmed the view that the origin of the explosion lay here.