by debiting certain consignments of military stores from Carron to the Board of Ordnance in London with breakages which had never occurred. These breakages went sometimes to the extent of 23 per cent., and Mr. Henry Stainton delivered to the Board of Ordnance, and received payment for the whole quantity sent, but remitted to Carron only the supposed proceeds of the unbroken goods.
Thus things continued apparently until 1850, when Joseph Dawson died, and William Dawson succeeded to the control at Carron, while Henry Stainton remained as agent in London. Dissension then for the first time broke out between the families of Stainton and Dawson. William Dawson, being manager, called upon Henry Stainton to account for the London fund. Stainton admitted its existence and handed over £96,000 to the Company. He died shortly afterwards, and the Company made a claim on his executors for shortcomings, which was compromised by a payment of the enormous sum of £220,000. For 23 years, according to the narrative of Colonel Maclean, some of them have been vainly endeavouring to get information. A Mr. Romanes in particular used active efforts, but was always defeated. The parties were aware of his aim, and in 1826 Stainton wrote to William Dawson, while sending him a certain account "It may serve to amuse Romanes, and can do no harm in any way." At a later period William Dawson wrote to Stainton that to comply with all Romanes' demands would "cause endless trouble and no little mischief ;" that he had better reduce his balance at the Bank of England, lest it should attract the notice of their "enemies ;" and that a certain sum had been kept back in order that their "greedy partners" (the Shareholders) might not suppose they had so much cash in hand. Sir James Gibson Craig, then law agent of the Company, strenuously advised that Romanes and the others should be furnished with the information desired, and in 1846 he again warned the manager at Carron of the illegality of his proceedings, protesting, at the same time, against one of the shareholders, a Miss Adie, being allowed to sell her stock to the Company in total ignorance of its real value. "The account made up," said Sir James, in a private letter to Dawson, 1846, "does not disclose the state of the Company's affairs, but conceals it. The debts due are over-stated by £130,000. The assets are under-stated to a much larger amount. No one who is not a managing partner, can have the least idea of the value of the stock, and I therefore think it illegal in any managing partner to buy the stock of any one who is not a managing partner." Still these warnings are alleged to have had no effect, and in the following year Colonel Maclean also was induced to part with his interest, and this purchase threatens from the proceedings (taken in 1859) to form a fatal bargain.
On the 24th March, 1860, the Master of the Rolls (in the court of Chancery, London), gave judgment in the case of Stainton v. the Carron Company. It was set forth that from the year 1825 down to the time of his decease in 1851, Henry Stainton had rendered accounts of his receipts and payments to the company as their agent, which were not questioned during his life time; but after his decease they were called in question, and imputations were then made that from the year 1825, when a resolution was passed reducing Stainton's salary as agent very considerably, lie had taken means to re-coup himself by misappropriations of the company's money, and a decree was made under which the accounts of the deceased were made subject to severe investigation. During the course of these proceedings attempts were made to bring matters to an amicable adjustment, and ultimately a compromise of the suit was arrived at, under which the Carron Company received the large sum, as stated above, of £220,000 from Stainton's estate. This compromise met with the sanction of the Master of the Rolls, who had before him in the suit several infant children claiming under Stainton's estate. So far it was supposed that the litigation was set at rest; but at the close of the last year, the defendant again took proceedings in the sessions court of Scotland against Stainton's representatives for a principal sum of £32,092, alleged to have been appropriated by Stainton between the year 1808 and 1822, being a period antecedent to the time in respect of which the accounts were taken under the order of the court. The interest claimed upon this principal sum amounted to not less than £74,653 14s. 8d.. making the present claim of the defendants against Stainton's estate more than £100,000 beyond that which it has already paid. The answer to the claim on the part of the representatives of Stainton is, that it was all contemplated and included in the compromise already sanctioned by the court, and that when the compromise was made the Carron Company knew, or ought to be taken to have known, every circumstance of which they now sought to avail themselves. On the other hand the defendants' counsel contended that the period in respect of which the defendants now asked for accounts was not included in the compromise, and had not been discovered until very recently, and long after the compromise was effected.
His Honour, in giving judgment said, that in his opinion there could be no doubt but that the terms of the compromise which had been agreed upon included the questions now raised, by the Carron Company; but, inasmuch as the compromise was of no long standing, and the accounts taken under it could be scarcely looked upon as closed, the Court would permit the company to re-open the whole matter, so as to take in the transactions previously to the period agreed upon under the compromise, upon the company's bringing into court the sum of about £220,000, which they had been paid under the compromise effected with Stainton's executors, and which was now sought to be so far set aside as to open matters which it had virtually closed. Subject to the conditions thus expressed, the court would not refuse to open the accounts — outside the compromise — but, in doing so, would grant the injunction as prayed for in reference to the proceedings instituted by the company in Scotland as against Henry Stainton's trustees.
NEW CUMNOCK IRON WORKS. — These works are established at New Cumnock, Ayrshire, and were formerly known as the Nithsdale Iron Works. The establishment consists of three blast furnaces lately erected, two blowing engines, condensing and working expansively, with steam cylinders 45 inches diameter, and blowing cylinders 100 inches diameter, 9 feet stroke, capable of blowing seven furnaces, and the requisite other plant and machinery, foundry, workshops, &c., for carrying on the works on a large scale. The furnaces and all the buildings are erected on feued ground, of which there is about 30 acres. There is an abundant supply of Ironstone, Coal, and other minerals in the immediate neighbourhood, for which leases may be arranged on favourable terms with the proprietors. This property, including counting house, dwelling houses for manager and agents, workmen's houses, &c., were advertised for sale at Glasgow, in July, 1859, the upset price being reduced to £15,000; and by a subsequent announcement, the upset price was further reduced to £10,000, and latterly to £5,000. It may be added, that the works, when in operation, were not remunerative to the proprietors; the Iron made was not of first quality, the Coal found in the district is of an inferior description, and the Ironstone not abundant.
THE GARPEL COMPANY. — This company was formed in 1859, subject to the Limited Liability Act, under the direction of Sir John Heron Maxwell, Bart., Lieut. General Byam, John Brady, Esq., M.P., John Mirehouse, Esq., P. C. Gates, Esq., &c.; consulting engineer, John Brown, Esq., Darlington. Capital — £125,000, in shares of £5 each. The minerals taken by the company consists of 6,000 acres, situated in the county of Ayr, on a lease for 30 years from 1857, at the following royalty rents, calculated at 22½ cwt. to the ton :— Hematite Iron Ore, 2s.; calcined Blackband Ironstone, 2s.; calcined clay band, 1s. ; Coal, 6d.; limestone, 6d. ; fire clay, 3d. per ton.
Please Note: These web pages retain the original pagination from the publication