It may be observed, however, that since the date of the foregoing document, many of the collieries have changed ownership; almost all have materially extended their power of production by increasing the number of pits, and by improved and more extended machinery; the amount of capital invested has therefore been increased in proportion; and numerous other collieries in the same districts, which will be more particularly alluded to hereafter, have been opened out upon an extensive scale, encouraged by the formation of public railways, docks, the introduction of steam colliers, &c.
The following evidence bearing upon the subject now under notice, was adduced before a Committee of the House of Commons in 1857 :— Mr. Matthews, an extensive Iron and Coal Master, said, "It has happened to me to know a good deal of the collieries in South Staffordshire, because I have not only been engaged in working them, but I have very frequently acted as umpire and arbitrator; and I have found a great many cases in which not only no profit was made, but a very grievous loss was sustained. Upon the whole, they have been profitable, but of course many instances have occurred in which large amounts of money have been expended on collieries which have turned out to be wholly unproductive."
Mr. T. J. Taylor, of Earsdon, mining engineer, and interested in Coal mines, speaking of Northumberland and Durham, says that mining has certainly not been a profitable undertaking. He had made calculations; "I particularly recollect making one with the late Mr. Buddle, one of the most eminent mining engineers in the North of England. After making allowance for interest and the redemption of the capital, the profit that was realised out of mining transactions did not come to more than 4 or 5 per cent., or somewhere between 4 and 5 per cent. on the capital embarked. There are so many circumstances, and so great a risk, that as a question of comparative risk between Coal mining and other mining, there seems to be some false impression abroad. At one time, when Coal mines were very accessible, the risk was much less than it is now. We have been obliged to sink to great depths; 200 fathoms sometimes. The Wearmouth Colliery is 275 fathoms deep; and besides that, there are difficulties that often occur. The Seaton Delaval Colliery, Northumberland, where a capital of £200,000 has been embarked, and when they sunk to where the Coal was expected, it was unfortunately found not to be there, at least it was found to be so thin as not to be of much value. That colliery has been at work 18 years, and I believe the lessees have scarcely had the satisfaction of getting a dividend yet. In the Haswell Colliery, county of Durham, in which some of my family are concerned, we have sand beneath the surface; that sand cost between £30,000 and £40,000, and they were obliged to abandon it at last. At the colliery at Murton, the same sand was got through by the mere force of engine power, to the extent of 1,400 horses, employed in getting through the sand, and the amount of capital embarked in the mine has been so great, that I am afraid to mention it — it amounted to somewhere about £300,000"
Mr. Dobson, a mining engineer in Glamorganshire, thus expresses his opinion upon the general result of milling operations in South Wales:— "If you take the whole mining operations of South Wales into account, including the Iron works, I think that they form a very poor investment indeed. The trade is kept up in this way: in all descriptions of mining there are great prizes to be gained, and so long as that is the case, you will have great numbers of people embarking in it, and investing their capital in it, in the hope of gaining a prize; but for every prize that is gained there are great numbers of losses; many people have spent very large sums in mining operations without any return; some very important works have been established in South Wales, which have passed out of the hands of the original proprietors through failure, and the present proprietors have taken them up at merely a nominal amount."
Mr. Pease, of Darlington, an extensive Coal owner and Iron master, in reply to the Question, in 1857, — "Taking your Iron mines, have they not been much more profitable than Coal mines ?" replied, "No; we have recently had a fair trial in both. I do not know which is better; we have had a terrible time; mining has been a very unproductive source of enterprise; but that has not been the case for the last four or five years."
Mr. Thomas Powell, an owner of fourteen collieries in South Wales; was opening out two more large ones, on one of which he had spent £50,000; worked more Coal than any other person in South Wales; his daily shipments were, in 1857, upwards of 2,000 tons. Did not think the Coal trade so good as the Iron trade; "Look at the rich men that are in the Iron trade, worth millions of money. I know more than one gentleman worth two millions, who has made his fortune by the Iron trade; and there are many others; I need not name the parties, but it is well known that there are many men who have made very large fortunes in the Iron trade, more than is the case with the Coal trade a good deal." "Still there has been a little money made in the Coal trade ?" "I do not deny that I have made a little. My friends were not born before me; I had nobody who ever gave me a farthing; I began the world with very little. I have now been forty-eight years in the Coal trade, and I must have made very bad use of my time if I had not made a little." "Take the proprietors of Iron mines and the proprietors of Coal mines — do you think, upon the whole, that the proprietors of Iron mines have made more money than the proprietors of Coal mines ?" "Yes. If a man can make £100,000 in the Coal trade, he is a very ingenious and clever fellow; whereas I know two or three Iron masters who have made millions in the Iron trade."
Mr. L. W. Llewellin, mineral agent, South Wales, said that an enormous amount of capital had been sunk within the last few years in the parish of Trevethan, in which the Iron working district around Pontypool is situated. "I think I may venture to say, that the capital has been absolutely sunk; I do not say invested, but lost in Iron-making speculations; in that parish I should say that as much as £1,500,000 has been sunk. In this district Iron making has not been a profitable speculation — I do not know a single Iron work in that parish that has ever paid; not one. In this parish, the Abersychan Ironworks, belonging to the British Iron Co., had expended upon those works and in connexion with them, more than £400,000; the works themselves must have cost more than £300,000. The speculation turned out very disastrous for the proprietors, and the consequence was, that they proposed surrendering the property to their lessors; and the lessors (I acting as their agent), made every effort to induce parties to come forward and take those works; and I induced the Ebbw Vale Co., by reducing the galeage from 1s. to 5½d., to take those works, and the obligations as far as regarded the fixed rent of £2,000 a year, on condition that they had the works given to them for nothing. They had the plant and every thing in working condition, which cost £300,000, given to them as a bonus for taking this work at 5½d., a ton galeage." "I believe that, taking the districts generally, Iron making has been a losing trade. There are examples, such as Sir John Guest, and some of the old proprietors, by whom very large fortunes have been realised; but I know that nearly
Please Note: These web pages retain the original pagination from the publication