|
The Altham Fatal Explosion.Extracted from the Annual Mines Inspectors Report for 1883 Report of Joseph Dickinson (page 2) The explosion of firedamp, on the 7th November, in the Moorfield pit, Altham Colliery, occasioned the loss of 68 lives and injury to 39 others, the occurence being explainable only by a blower of gas commencing suddenly and firing through the Davy safety lamp (see plan). The evidence and inspection showed that, except at the bottom of the shaft and for relighting at the lamp station in the fresh air, Davy lamps were used exclusively ; that according to the usual practice, the firemen went down the pit at 5 o'clock a.m.; found all right; allowed the men to pass to their places between 6 and 6.30 o'clock, and that at about 8 o'clock, having seen the work in operation, they returned to the shaft, with the intention of going up to breakfast and to enter the report of their inspection in the book; an assistant fireman being left in the pit. The manager also came down the shaft that morning, and after being in No. 1 shaft level, he also returned to the shaft about 8 o'clock. The work was going on apparently as usual, and if any suspicion of danger existed it was not made known. Suddenly a boy from No. 2 level came running down the gig-brow to the shaft and told John Rushton, the fireman for that part of the mine, that, he was wanted, as gas was firing in the lamps on the level. Rushton said some one must have been leaving doors open, and he went up the gig-brow immediately. The manager, Mr. Thomas Macintosh, hearing apparently the word gas, asked what it was and he started off for the No. 2 level, going by the travelling road. Neither of them returned alive. Peter Broadley, the other fireman, also went into his workings to see whether they were affected. Meanwhile men and boys who had either seen gas firing in the lamps, or been warned of its filling the workings, came running to the shaft, some of them without their over clothes, and they anxiously but without clamour asked the hooker-on to send them up. The hooker-on, who had five full tubs in the cage and wanted three more to complete the full load, would not consent, but said afterwards they should go when the empty cage came down. The delay would not have been long had work been going on as usual, but in consequence of the alarm the bringing of tubs was nearly stopped, and about quarter of an hour elapsed before the cage was filled and signalled off. By that time it was about 8.45 o'clock and 33 persons were assembled at the shaft, of whom at least one had asked to be allowed to ride with the full tubs, but was refused, and some had taken a good place ready to step into the empty cage when it came down. The cages had not run far when suddenly a blast of wind and flame came down the gigbrow, sweeping partly into No. 1 level and partly towards the shaft, the latter portion driving before it the crowd of persons there assembled, and passing partly up the shaft and partly into an engine plane beyond. The explosion fastened the cages in the shaft and forced up the landing platform and plates at the top, which stopped ingress and egress that way; but the Moorfield workings were connected by airways and by an engine brow or plane, 1,200 yards in length, with those at Whinney Hill, where one of the pits was downcast and the other upcast, and means of communication remained available that way. The waft was felt at Whinney Hill, and forthwith the head fireman there, William Hope, had his men sent out; and the assistant manager, Mr. James Macintosh, who happened to be there, took steps for the rescue. Having looked first at the state of the return air coming from Moorfield and to see that the ventilating furnaces were in full operation, the latter commenced his way down the engine plane, which he was able to do in fresh air, as the engine plane was ventilated at the upper part by a scale of fresh air from Whinney Hill, and at the lower part by a similar scale of fresh air from Moorfield. After proceeding some distance he met afterdamp which necessitated his returning to Whinney Hill, where, by taking a scale from those workings, he gave a greater pull upon the return air from Moorfield. This alteration being made he went again down the plane and found the air improved so as to admit of his going forward. On arriving about 100 yards from Moorfield he met some of the injured survivors coming out in the dark, and having sent these on their way to be attended to by others who were following him, he arrived safely at the bottom of Moorfield shaft, William Hope coming soon afterwards. They found that the explosion had blown all the lights out, and made great havoc, and that nearly every person there was either dead, or burned, or injured, and that partly by the afterdamp and partly by dense smoke from a roll of smouldering brattice cloth which had taken fire, the survivors there were being suffocated. Having in the fresh air coming down the shaft given lights and sent out such of the survivors as were able to travel to Whinney Hill, they, with the assistance of others who had come, went on with the exploration. One of the double or check doors at the bottom of the engine plane was blown in pieces towards Whinney Hill, but the other door which opened by sliding into a recess, where it happened to be for the passage of tubs at the time of the explosion, was uninjured. This sliding door the survivors had closed partially, with the intention of sending air into the inner workings for persons who might be alive there, and allowing some scalage to escape and clear away the afterdamp from among themselves, and to clear the engine plane for a way of escape. This door the rescuers had to open temporarily a little more to clear away the afterdamp from about the shaft and then they placed it as before. Hearing cries for help in No. 1 level they proceeded there, and among about 10 who were dead they brought out some who were alive but injured and nearly suffocated, and also two men who had felt only a puff in the far end of the dip workings and who worked on until the afterdamp came. They then penetrated up the gig-brow, where fresh air was taking, but only to find there all dead; and that the stoppings were all blown out and the air going by the nearest courses to the upcast. They put in a few tarpaulin screens which sent air and enabled them to go forward a little, but to find only a number of dead, including the manager, who had been leading out about a dozen persons before the gas became lighted. The partial closing of the slide door at the bottom of the engine plane probably kept alive some of those who were saved from No. 1 level by the rescuers, but had anything been on fire among the firedamp as at the shaft the sending of this air forward might have occasioned recurring explosions. Such is the uncertainty whether what is done on these occasions may tend to advantage or disadvantage. Up to this time the exploration had been made from Whinney Hill, but at about four o'clock in the afternoon Moorfield shaft was repaired sufficiently for one of the cages to be worked. Mr. Martin arrived about this time and joined the explorers. A telegram summoned me from the Home Office, where I was, and I arrived early in the ensuing morning. I found on my arrival that most of those forming the first shift had left exhausted about 10 o'clock at night, and that on the way one of them, Mr. J. F. Seddon, a mining engineer, had been thrown out of a conveyance and killed; and that the second shift were coming out. Having looked about I saw the platform and landing plates were still in disorder, but leaving this to Mr. Macalpine, who was attending to general matters, I joined the third shift of explorers, Mr. Martin, who had been on the afternoon shift, and Mr. P. W. Pickup, who had been on the previous shift, joining this shift. The broken tubs had been cast on one side in the gig-brow and one line of tramway relaid for the passage of tubs and riding sledges, sledges being requisite for quick travelling in the low workings. Bricksetters had commenced rebuilding the stoppings at the side of the gig-brow, and new air doors were being prepared. Steady progress was made in dislodging the gas, which was now pure firedamp, by bratticing air forward and putting tarpaulin screens in the openings. The return air containing the dislodged firedamp, having to pass through the fires of the ventilating furnaces, was a cause of some anxiety lest it might reach the fires in an explosive state ; but it was watched at an air door where fresh air was available for solution at a proper mixing distance from the fires. Advancing in this way, the firedamp further in became difficult to move, and stood like a wall, until stoppings had been rebuilt part of the way into No. 2 level and doors reset at the gig-brow which brought more pressure, but the gas instead of all moving into the return on the rise, backed out against the intake in the level, and passing the person placed in front for testing with the Davy lamp came back upon us and filled the Davys with flame, causing all to retire. A cessation of two hours was arranged, to allow the air time to act upon the gas, during which time the furnaces were visited, and the expediency of continuing them lighted was discussed and decided in the affirmative. By Friday, the second day after the explosion, the main source of the firedamp was discovered. The roof had fallen in two places at a small fault, and at the innermost of these falls gas was issuing with a noise like steam rushing through water. The issue was more than the air could dilute, and whilst the exploration was being proceeded with elsewhere, it had to be left uncleared. Another issue, but of a comparatively small quantity, was gurgling out from the same fault in the floor of a cut-through a little further out, and it was remarkable that in this cut-through the brick and mortar stopping remained standing, whilst the stoppings in all the other cut-throughs were blown out. On Saturday, the third morning after the explosion, I and William Hope visited the far end of No. 2 level, accompanied by Mr. John Higson, who had been called in professionally by the owner. We tried to clear the gas from the main blower, but the issue was too strong for the air, and we could not approach the place where it was issuing except in the dark, in doing which I as a precaution against suffocation held my breath. The small blower was cleared by giving vent through the stopping, but the issue of gas from the large one so fouled the return air in the part of the workings where the remainder of the bodies lay, that fresh air had to be scaled off in order that they might be recovered. In these explorations the working of exhausted persons, shift after shift, except say one to show what had been done, was avoided, and by Sunday, the fourth morning, the last of the bodies was reached and brought out, after which the ventilation was restored to its usual courses so far as the blower would admit. The inquest was held by Mr. Henry J. Robinson, Coroner for Lancashire, which I attended. There were also present Mr. J. S. Martin, Inspector of Mines ; Mr John Higson Mining Engineer; with Mr. Robert A. Edgar, Solicitor, of Manchester, for the owner of the colliery; Mr. Arthur Morley, M.P., Barrister-at-law, instructed by the Solicitor to the Treasury. After several sittings, and the close scrutiny which almost invariably ensues where the public are interested, the jury on the 22nd November returned their verdict, that of the 68 dead 43 were burned, 6 burned only, 18 suffocated, one drowned in the sump, and that the explosion was caused by a sudden blower of gas, but they could not fix where the gas was lighted. The details of the evidence having been reported in the local newspapers, and sent by me to the Home Office at the time, need not be repeated here. The correctness of the verdict as to the sudden blower of gas did not admit of any doubt, inasmuch as it was actively giving off gas and making noise enough to satisfy the most sceptical during the entire sitting of the jury. To this I can now add, that it was three weeks after the explosion before any decrease could be noticed. At the end of one month the outside of the fall could be examined carefully. In five weeks the noise and gas continued slackening gradually. In two months the loud noise had ceased, and the gas became diluted at a short distance from the point of issue. In four months, on the 10th March, when I last visited it, gas was humming off, and lodging in the guttered cavity, which could then be examined and seen to extend about 4 yards high above the coal. The "board," or place in which the blower occurred, on being cut into beyond the fall showed, according to the account given to me by the miner who made the cutting, that on the floor at the face of the place, was the miner's shovel, with chalk figures upon it, partly obliterated, but showing apparently that the fireman had been there on the morning of the explosion, and had left the safety mark before the commencement of the fall and the blower. In this "board" no person was at work on the morning of the explosion, but on the previous evening a collier, named David Broadley, was working there, and from his account he had driven across the small fault, and before leaving he noticed that the place was making some gas, but without the extraordinary noise such as ensued afterwards, and that as a precaution to prevent roof falling, he set a timber coupling across the place to keep the roof secure at the outer side of the fault. His not being at work next morning was not, as he affirmed, in any way connected with gas. At the outside of this "board" all the workings were coated thickly with dust, but the inner workings were left clean, and the bratticing at the face of the levels was left standing. So many of those who could have given information being killed, it was not ascertained when the fall in the board further out than that in which the blower occurred took place. It may therefore be said that if it had fallen previous to the explosion the ventilation would not have been obstructed, as another air course up the inner of the two adjoining slants was open. The manager, it is stated, was in the habit of going down the pit about 6.30 o'clock, in the last cage in which the miners descended, and on the morning of the explosion he was a little later than usual, and it might be 7 o'clock before he went down, and from what the hooker-on and the fireman state he went straight along No. 1 level, and it was on his return that he heard of the alarm in No. 2 level. There is no reason to suppose that he saw anything of gas, or did anything special that morning. The boy, William Swales, who brought the alarm of gas to the shaft, escaped with his life, but with a burning. He had been along No. 2 level as far as the slants three times that morning. There was no gas then, but when going in for the fourth tub of coal he, on arriving at the bottom of the inner slant, was told of gas, and on looking he saw a drawer or waggoner coming through the sheet with gas firing in his lamp, and that it speedily blazed in his own, filling it and then going down. Tim Yates, who came, said his place was filling with gas, and he was running about telling the men to come out. John Mann came and said gas fired in his lamp and he could not put it out. About ten or a dozen persons were soon at the bottom of the outer end; some of them made for the shaft as quickly as possible and some went to warn others. Stephen Clough came down the end in the dark and gave Swales a ride out on his sledge. Having gone about 100 yards outwards on the level they met the assistant fireman, T. H. Macintosh, who told them to hold on a minute, and on trying his lamp it showed a little gas at first, and then the gas, which besides going in the return airway above was driving out against the scale of fresh air with which the level at this part was ventilated, began jumping up in his lamp. The assistant fireman remained and was lost. Swales went on to the shaft and gave the alarm there. He had worked in this part of the mine nearly the whole time since the gig-brow was commenced, and said it was unusual to find gas, and that he never knew gas like this. Under the circumstances the hooker-on at the shaft made apparently a mistake in delaying the ascent of the large number of men and boys who came there and might have escaped uninjured. In his justification it should, however, be named that it was not usual for persons to leave the pit so early, that he did not think there was danger, and what danger existed he himself shared, that he was among the severely injured, that the alarm which existed in rushing out apparently subsided somewhat when the persons had arrived at the shaft, and that even the boy who first brought the alarm went with Rushton as far as the top of the gig-brow to fetch his clothes, which took him about five minutes, after which, however, on his return to the shaft he took up a favourable position to step into the first empty cage. The occurrence of the blower was in some respects remarkable. No pillars had been removed to disturb the overlying strata, and the fault from which it issued had been cut across in adjoining places on the rise and dip. The mountain mine series in which it occurred is not usually very fiery, although it is so in exceptional instances in this coalfield. A similar blower was met with eight or 10 years ago in the Whinney Hill working at this colliery. But whether the present blower came from a coal 18 yards above the gannister bed which was being worked or from the Upper Mountain or Old Robin bed 55 yards above the gannister bed may not be quite certain. Probably it was from the Upper Mountain and strata adjoining. A bore hole which has been put down in the mine since the explosion shows that there is a thin coal 4½ yards below the gannister bed, but only a moderate quantity of gas has been found; a borehole has also been made upwards to the thin coal 18 yards above the gannister, but it has proved little if any gas. Large issues have, however, been met with from the Upper Mountain series. It was from the Upper Mountain mine and strata in the same neighbourhood that, when the Hapton Valley shafts were being sunk, the extraordinary quantity of firedamp issued into the Whin's pit on the outcrop, 1,600 yards on the rise, causing gas to pour out simultaneously from the level mouth and the air pit as described in my report at the time. It was also in the same strata, some years afterwards, in sinking the Moorhead air shaft at Dunkenhalgh Colliery about half a mile from Whinney Hill, that the shots had to be fired by running red hot rings down a wire ; and in December last, at Duckworth Hall pumping pit, in the same neighbourhood and strata, an explosion occurred as a candle was being lowered to test for black damp where no firedamp had been met with for seven years, and the only explainable cause for its appearance was the filling up six months previously of an old shaft in which the Upper or Robin coal had been worked. It is some amelioration in a calamity of this kind to know that by the colliery fund, largely supplemented by public subscription, those left unprovided for have been placed beyond the reach of want. Also that the occurrence will be profited by in the taking of precautions for the future, both as regards the Davy lamp, through which the gas fired apparently, and in some other respects unconnected with the explosion. Davy lamps were forthwith superseded by others on the Marsaut principle, which give more than double the light, and are found to be safe in explosive currents. The "boards," or intermediate workings, are not now being driven until wanted for working back the pillars. Cut-throughs are being made at shorter distances apart when required, by which the total length of bratticing, stated at the inquest as having been 1,000 yards, but found afterwards about half that length, will be considerably reduced. A ventilating fan supersedes the furnaces, and technicalities are being attended to. The conduct shown by all concerned in this explosion, although only such as happens commonly on such occasions, is yet deserving of mention. The great discipline shown by the crowd of men and boys who had rushed from the gas without their over clothes, obeying the order of the hooker-on at the shaft; the assistant fireman when he saw the gas coming staying to send his men out; the fireman at the shaft on being told of the gas going to assist; the other fireman who went from the shaft to see if his workings were safe; the manager who followed to the danger; the promptitude of the assistant manager, and the fireman at Whinney Hill in going to the rescue; and the speed with which the wreck and gas were dealt with, and the bodies cleared out by the fourth morning.
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||