|
Tipton Moat Colliery AccidentExtracted from the Annual Mines Inspectors Report for 1876 Report of James P. Baker (page 116) The last of these accidents to which I think it necessary to allude happened at the Tipton Moat Colliery on the 24th August, and resulted in the loss of two lives. This being a very important case, in which several persons were seriously involved, I think it expedient to give the evidence bearing on the question as taken in the first place at the inquiry before the coroner, which resulted in a verdict of manslaughter against four different persons employed at the colliery, with the depositions of two other witnesses, who with myself were also called before the grand jury. The bodies having been identified, and the coroner's jury having themselves examined the machinery, the inquest was adjourned at my suggestion to enable a mechanical engineer to examine and report upon the machinery in question. On the resumption of the inquiry, the following evidence was taken:— Elijah Davis says, — "On January the 6th, 1876, I was appointed the certificated manager of the Tipton Green Colliery Company, at one of whose pits the two men met their deaths. I was appointed by Robert Meek Carter, the chairman of the company. I am not able to give the names of the other directors. The chairman, Mr. Carter, met me at the colliery on the date-of my appointment. Immediately after my appointment, I made an inspection of the whole of the machinery; I considered that upon the whole it was in good working order, and working commenced by pumping water, and that continued up to the day on which the men were killed. My duties are to keep a supervision of the underground workings generally, and I had no immediate control over the machinery. I have visited the colliery from then five days a week. If anything had been wrong with the machinery, I should have known it from the reports. On one or two occasions I have inspected the machinery myself, but I cannot say when I did so last. William Jackson was the chief engineer of the colliery within the meaning of the special rules, appointed by Mr. Carter. On the day the men were killed I was at the engine at 12.45 p.m., and the men were killed a little after five. I considered all to be safe. I cannot say when I saw the break applied before then, but on the day the men were killed I considered it good. It was a condensing engine of about 20 horse-power, and 20-inch cylinder and a four feet nine or five feet stroke. I cannot say at what pressure it worked, but I should say about eight lbs. to the square inch from the larger boiler of the pumping engine. "The engine was used for three different purposes. It had to work the capstan, the sawmill and to raise the men and material up the bye-pit, and for the purpose of doing repairs in the engine pit, and the engine was capable of performing all its functions. The day after the men were killed, I visited the colliery, and as it was dark I could not examine the machinery. I did so the next day. I am of opinion that the block which kept the machiney in gear was either left out of its place or worked out. I considered it safe to work it with the block and the carriage screwed down. The Board of Directors have always supplied all I have asked for the safety of the men. I had no objection to Jackson, and as far as I know he was a proper person to take charge of the engine. His competent man was Joseph Shepperd, and he made his reports regularly, and I have never seen in any of his reports anything to lead me to suppose the engine was in any way unsafe." By Mr. Baker, Inspector of Mines. — "Jackson, to the best of my knowledge, appointed Shepperd, but I don't know that as a certainty." By Mr. Owen, on behalf of Elijah Davis and the Colliery Company. — "I have been down the shaft three or four times. I saw the break put on the Saturday after the men were killed, and it stopped the engine at 16 strokes, although there was a greater weight on than when the men were killed." By Mr. Buller, on behalf of George Price. — "If the break had been applied at the time of the accident, and had acted, the chain would not have run." William Jackson said, "I am an engineer, residing at Moat House, Tipton. I was an assistant to Mr. Hanson, the manager, on the day of the accident, to look after trade and collect accounts. I had to carry out any order that was given by the Inspector Shepperd, who signed the books. Mr. Carter appointed me to inspect the machinery up till last April, when Shepperd took my place, when my responsibility ceased. I always thought the engine safe. Mr. Elijah Davis was certificated manager, and had the power of discharging any of the men." By Mr. Baker. — "It was Shepperd's duty to see that special rule 6 was carried out. Mr. Carter instructed me to appoint Shepperd as colliery engineer, and he entered on his duty about the middle of April. Shepperd provides the tools for the use of the engine-tender. If the block had been put in and the pins screwed down, I don't see how the accident could have happened." By Mr. Rhodes, on behalf of Shepperd. — "Between the time of the men falling down the shaft and their being taken out I was in the engine-house with George Price, and he said the block had got out he believed from a jerk of the guide-pulley, and the block was down the flywheel race." By Mr. Owen. — "The break has been put on sometimes a dozen times in a day, and has always answered. I have seen it stop with five ton weight to it. I believe every possible appliance has been made use of for the safety of the men." By Mr. Stokes. — "Shepperd, since April, has made the reports to the certificated manager." By Mr. Buller. — "No one was present when I had the conversation with Price." By Mr. Rhodes. — "If the carriage had been screwed down with one's hands it would have kept the block from jerking out, and I know Price had occasionally taken the block out to fill his cistern while repairs have been going on in the pit, and if he had taken the block out on this occasion it might have caused the accident." Joseph Shepperd, being cautioned by the Coroner said — "I live in Workhouse Lane, Tipton, and am a colliery engineer, and on the day of the accident was in the employ of the Tipton Green Colliery Company. I was engaged by William Jackson about six months ago, I was engaged to look after the engine and the lifts. It was my duty to see that the machinery was all safe, and I had to enter my report daily in the book now produced, and on the day in question I reported all as being safe at 9 a.m. Price was working the engine at the time of the accident. I have believed the engine has always been in safe working order. When I saw the engine at 9 a.m. on the day of the accident the block was in. Price would have to take it out to fill the cistern. If it had been screwed down it could not have come out unless knocked out. When I saw it the pins were screwed down with a spanner. As soon as I heard of the accident I went to the pit. They were preparing to get the men up, which was done the next morning at five-thirty, in my presence. They were quite dead. The break was in order, and stopped the engine. It was the same as when the coroner and jury saw it." By Mr. Baker. — "I did not try the break the morning of the accident, although my reports state that all was safe on the 24th of August." By Mr. Rhodes. — "Price told me he had had the engine out of gear at 12 o'clock to fill up his cistern and that Alfred Smith was there and that he had put the block in again." Godfrey Duffield says, — "I am a field carpenter, residing at Summerhill, Tipton, and work at the colliery, and have been fifteen years, and made the wood-work of the break and from time to time have repaired it. I assisted to bring the dead men up the pit. The Tuesday before the accident I applied the break and it acted. I made the block that has been spoken to. It is made of oak, and has been in use about six months; and that is such a block as is generally used for the purpose." John Wilkes says, — "I am a carpenter at the Moat colliery where the accident happened, and live at Mount Pleasent near Sedgley. I was on the bank when the band began to run. It got faster, and I looked in at the engine house door, and Price said, 'the engine has thrown out of gear.' I said, 'the poor men must be dead' He said, 'I put the break on, and it would not stop it.' I saw the chain snap." John Cash says, — "I am a blacksmith at the Moat Colliery, and live at Lockside, Tipton. On the day of the accident I was about a yard from the engine door and saw the chain run. I saw Price put the break on after the engine had stopped, but the chain kept running. I don't know if the post of the guide pulley had given way." George Price, after being cautioned by the coroner, said, — "I am an engine tender, residing at Ocker Hill, Tipton. On the day of the accident I was in the employ of the Moat Colliery Company, and was working the engine at the time of the accident. During the day at noon the engine was put out of gear by me and Alfred Smith as we wanted water, and he and I put it in gear again at 12.15 p.m. I put the block in the usual way and screwed it down, and all went well until 5 p.m. when the side or guide pulley gave way. There was a jerk and the chain ran down swiftly. I applied the break to stop the engine but it took no effect. I applied the break directly I saw the chain run. The men were about thirty yards from the top. I never applied the break in that way before. I was surprised it did not stop the engine. After the accident I examined the machinery and found it out of gear. I did not see the block. I heard Shepperd found it. I believe the jerk pulled the plug out. Shepperd reported to me that morning that all was safe at 7 a.m. With the tools supplied to me I could not screw down the carriage as the spanner was overstrained. I screwed it down as well as I could. If I had had better tools I could have screwed it tighter. I am not able to read or write. The rules have never been read or explained to me. The carriage could not be screwed down at one end because the pin was bent, but I did not know it till that morning. I stopped the engine before I put the break on. There was no indicator provided to show the position of the skip in the shaft, nor was there any signal provided." William Jackson recalled says, — "I find I gave over making my reports in Jauuary last, and then it was that Shepperd took to it." Alfred Smith says, — "I am an engine tender, residing at Union Street, Tipton. I was at the engine on the day in question at 12.30 p.m. and assisted Price by handing him the spanner. I saw him screw the pin down nearest the pit. The spanner was all right, I saw him put the wedge in, he drove it in with a bar used for that purpose. I only saw Price screw one pin down." Jonah Davies said, — "I am a mechanical engineer, residing at Merridale Road, Wolverhampton, in this county, and, in accordance with instructions received from the coroner, I, on the 31st of August and again on the 2nd day of September instant, carefully inspected and examined the winding engine and machinery at the Moat Colliery, Tipton, at the pit where, on Thursday, the 24th of August last, two sinkers named William Grainger and Job Whitehouse are said to have lost their lives whilst repairing the brickwork lining of the pit-shaft. "I find the machinery is driven by a beam-condensing engine of about 14 horse-power (20-inch steam cylinder 4-feet stroke), and steam is supplied at a pressure of 10 lbs. per square inch from the adjacent boilers belonging to the large pumping-engine. This 14 horse-power engine is used for three different purposes; viz.: — In the first place, as a capstan-engine, working by a series of spur-wheels a large rope barrel, and which is used occasionally for changing the buckets, clacks, and raising or lowering the pump-rods in the usual way necessary to the large pumping-engine, which is situated a few yards in front of the same. "Secondly, as a winding-engine for raising or lowering men and materials in the 'bye-pit' shaft, which is situated in the front at a distance of about 60 feet from the centre of the winding-gear. This gear consists of a 4-feet crown-wheel working into a pinion fixed upon the end of fly-wheel shaft, transmitting power to a second motion-shaft, on the end of which is fixed a 'niche-ring,' on which laps an ordinary flat-link chain working over a pulley on a pit-frame fixed over the bye-pit in the usual way, but as this bye-pit is not in a direct line with the centre of the niche-ring, a turn-pulley working in a frame on a dead centre is provided to guide the chain. "Also on the extreme end of this long shaft is fixed a 7-feet break-wheel, with straps and levers operated by a chain winding on a shaft extending into the engine-house, having a handle and catch convenient for the engine-man to apply the break in case of need. "Thirdly, the power of this engine is further made use of in driving a circular saw in the carpenter's shop adjoining the engine-house by a belt working off the fly-wheel, and from thence on to a 4-feet band-wheel keyed on to a second motion-shaft, and so on to the circular saw. So that when the engine is required to work the capstan rope barrel only the belt that drives the saw must be removed off the run of fly-wheel and the 4-feet crown wheel made to engage with the pinion on the end of the fly-wheel shaft, and at the same time the flat chain must either be taken off the niche-ring altogether, or lapped upon it, and the end properly secured; as this winding-gear shaft acts a second motion-shaft to transmit power through another 2-feet pinion-wheel, which will then gear into the large crown wheel fixed on the capstan rope barrel shaft; and when it is required to work the winding gear only for raising or lowering the men or materials in the bye-pit, the large crown wheel must be drawn out of gear and the capstan rope barrel stand still. I find proper draw-screws and sliding carriages are provided for that purpose; at the same time the belt driving the saw must again be removed off the run of the fly-wheel. To more fully explain this complicated machinery, I have prepared and now produce a drawing or plan marked 'A,' showing the whole of this arrangement; it will be perceived that the winding gear is fixed in front of the pinion (on the end of the fly-wheel shaft), consequently the tendency of the load in the pit and the pull of the flat chain is constantly to draw the crown wheel out of gear with its pinion. "Under these circumstances it was necessary to the safe working of this machinery, especially when raising or lowering men or materials in the bye-pit, that proper, safe, and certain means should have been provided to prevent the 4-feet crown wheel being drawn out of gear with the pinion I have mentioned. But no sufficient mechanical contrivance or screw within the meaning of the Act of Parliament was provided for that purpose in this case, except a piece of hard wood in the shape of a wedge which, was shown to me (see sketch), and was intended to be driven in between the foot of carriage and cast-iron plate fixed on the race-sill; and even if it was-fixed as intended, it was most dangerous and insecure, and liable to work or jar out by the tremor of the machinery, or get displaced by coming in contact with the arms of the 4-feet crown wheel at any time without any warning whatever being given. A sliding carriage should have been provided with a strong screw sufficient at all times to withstand any strain that may have come upon it by the pull of the chain or load or the cog-wheels working themselves out of gear (as they will do if neglected to be made secure), and all sliding carriages for drums or niche-rings should be fixed upon cast-iron sill plates, with a wrought-jron locking-key in addition to the screw arrangement I have mentioned. Had this safety appliance been provided in accordance with Special Rule 6 (see Rules for Colliery Engineers) this lamentable and fatal occurrence would not have happened. "I found also upon close inspection and examination that the holding down bolts securing the carriage to wood sill only went through the wood sill instead of down to a proper fonndation plate below, and it is very questionable whether this carriage foot was secured at all by screwing down at the time or previous to the accident, and what confirms my opinion on this point more than anything else, is, the wretched spanner shown to me, and said to be provided for that purpose, for it neither fitted the nuts nor could the carriage be properly screwed down to the wood sill by it by reason of the nuts being in close contact with the body of the carriage, as witnessed by Mr. J. P. Baker, Her Majesty's Inspector of Mines for this district and myself, on the occasion of our inspection when we requested the engineman to apply the spanner for the purpose it was intended. "There can be no doubt the two men lost their lives in consequence of the cog-wheels coming out of gear, thereby causing a "run," and the flat chain in consequence either broke or became disconnected from the niche-ring, and the result was that the cage or skip, with the two men upon it, violently descended down the bye-pit shaft, a distance of about 200 yards or more, and the chain falling upon them some 30 yards under water. There was no screw or mechanical contrivance or means provided to prevent such a disastrous result, except the wood wedge, and which if it ever was put in its place must have become displaced by the means I have mentioned. "When the engineman discovered the cog-wheels had worked out of gear he naturally applied the break, which on examination I found to be in anything but good working condition, and was therefore powerless to retard the gradually increasing velocity of the descending cage or skip with the two men upon it. "I have given this break and its lever arrangements a most thorough and careful examination, and find it in a very bad and unsafe working condition. I had it put in operation in the presence of Mr. Baker on the day of our inspection, and we were surprised to find how inefficient and powerless it was even to stop the engine alone; it allowed the engine to make from 16 to 18 strokes before it was brought to rest, and if there had been a loaded cage and balance weight on the end of the chain in the bye-pit at the time, it would again have run, and no force that the engineman had at his disposal or command could possibly have prevented it. I then had the engine stopped and the break lever wound up to its utmost gripping power, and discovered that the end of the lever then came in contact with the shaft on which the break-chain laps (and which, as I have before explained, extends into the engine-house), and thus prevented the full force of the break being applied by the man in charge of the engine, and he would naturally think the break would be full on when such was not the case. "It is the duty of the 'colliery engineer' to carefully examine the break and its working parts, and to report daily on the condition of the whole of the machinery under his charge. This should be done in accordance with Rule 3 (see Special Rules to engineers). Had this been done he would have detected the defect, and should at once have taken proper means to put it in safe and efficient working condition. In the place of the wood wedge that was at times driven between the end of carriage and sill plate (and which no doubt caused the accident) he should certainly have substituted in its place a proper, safe, and reliable contrivance within the meaning of the Act of Parliament, as it must have come daily under his notice, and should not have allowed the machinery to work again until a proper screw was fixed, or a sure and certain means taken to prevent the wheels coming out of gear, knowing that the men's lives were entirely dependent upon the safe and secure working of this machinery. "The engine having to be used, as I have stated, for three different purposes, no doubt in some measure led up to the disaster. "The whole of this machinery and engine at the time of my inspection and examination was not in a fit state for men to risk their lives in ascending or descending either the bye-pit or pumping engine shaft. The winding gear was also in a very unsafe condition. There was no indicator to show the position of the cage or skip in the pit shaft. There was no signal bell, and the break and its levers were powerless to prevent a 'run' and sadly out of repair." Henry John Marten, in a report drawn up at the request of the Company, says, "I am a civil engineer, residing at Parkfield House, Wolverhampton, in this county. "I have examined the bye or capsy engine adjoining the Leviathan pumping engine belonging to the Tipton Green Colliery Company, Limited, and find that it is a beam condensing engine of the ordinary type, with a steam cylinder working with about 10 lbs. steam pressure. It has a connecting rod, crank fly-wheel, and fly-wheel shaft of the usual construction. "The engine is used for three purposes, namely, for driving the saw-mill, for driving the capsy drum, and for driving niche-ring shaft for drawing up and letting down the cage in the air or bye-pit. "The engine actuates the saw-mill by a direct action strap driven from the fly-wheel, and it actuates the niche-ring shaft and capsy-drum by means of a train of pinion and crown wheels of various dimensions. "A break is also attached to the niche-ring shaft, which is brought into operation by means of a lever and chain fastened upon a shaft which terminates with a handle under the control of the engineer in the engine-house. "When the saw-mill is in operation the other portions of the machinery are thrown out of gear, and when the latter are required the saw-mill is stopped, and they are thrown into gear. "For the purpose of throwing the machinery into and but of gear the end of the niche-ring shaft next the fly-wheel is provided with what is termed 'a travelling carriage' that is, that a cast-iron carriage in which the end of the niche-ring shaft revolves is constructed so that it can slide or travel backwards and forwards over a space of about three inches. When the 'carriage' is pushed towards the engine, the teeth of the actuating wheels interlock each other so as to transmit the motion generated by the engine, and when on the carriage is pulled away from the engine, the teeth of the actuating wheels are drawn just sufficiently apart so as not to touch one another. "Also when the niche-ring shaft only is required to be used the wheel driving the capsy drum is pulled back and out of gear, the end of the drum shaft next the niche-rings being provided for that purpose with a travelling carriage and set screw. "It is of course very important that when the travelling carriage attached to the end of the niche-ring shaft is pushed in one direction or pulled into another, it should remain firmly in its intended position. "There is no danger when the carriage is in its "out of gear" position of its returning to its "in gear" position, but when the carriage is in the "in gear" position it has a tendency if unchecked to work into the "out of gear" position, as the pull of the machinery is in a direction to pull the carriage out of gear. "To provide against this tendency of the "travelling carriage" to travel to the "out of gear" position, it is first held securely into its place by two screw bolts provided for that purpose, and is further secured by a stout hard wooden wedge or chock inserted between the end of the carriage and the end of a cast-iron sill securely fastened to the engine house wall, so that before the wheels can come out of gear, the wooden wedge must be forced out of its place, and the travelling carriage, although held down by strong screws, would have to creep a distance of between two and three inches. "The mechanical arrangements although old fashioned, are such as have proved efficient during the last fifteen years, during which time I understand there has been no accident, and they may therefore be considered as reasonably safe and trustworthy for the purpose contemplated. "I understand that the break has been in constant use during the time named, and that it had on all previous occasions answered its purpose in a satisfactory manner. There was nothing to indicate that the engine was other than in its usual safe working condition in every part on the day of the accident, and the head engineer manifested his full confidence in all the mechanical arrangements by himself descending the pit on the morning of that day in company with the head sinker, and with a full knowledge of the engine, and of what it had been accustomed safely to perform up to that time. I should have had no hesitation in having done so myself. "The accident could only have happened from one of three causes ; namely, either — "1st. From the chock or wedge not having been placed in position or bringing the wheels into gear; "2nd. From its having been pulled or pushed out of position from malicious motives; or "3rd. From its having become displaced by some extraordinary jar or derangement of the machinery. "With regard to the first point I consider that the evidence of Price and Smith is conclusive that the "chock" was carefully placed in its usual position about 12.30 p.m., when also the carriage bolts were securely fastened down. Also that they were all secure up to 3.15, when they were last seen by Price prior to the accident. "With regard to the second point there is no evidence to show that so far as this particular matter is concerned there was anybody actuated by malicious feeling, although this is not the case I understand with regard to some other portions of the machinery connected with the leviathan pumping engine, sometime previously to the accident. "It is difficult to account for the wedge moving out of its place, as I am informed that it had never done so on any former occasion. Price considered that it may have jarred out of its place by the side pulley between the niche ring and the bye pit becoming displaced, but I am disposed to consider that the displacement of the side pulley was a consequence and not the cause of the accident. "It is possible that between 3.15 and the time of the accident the "chock" may have been jarred or have travelled towards the niche ring shaft driving wheel, and that it might have been tilted out of its place by the arm of the driving wheel and thrown into the wheel race, where it was ultimately found. "The "chock" would only have to travel a distance of about three quarters of an inch out of its place to be caught by the arms of the driving wheel. "The "chock" might have been tilted out of its place sometime before the accident happened, as the travelling carriage being securely screwed down it would only gradually creep out of gear, but the moment it did so the accident which took place would happen. "It should be remarked that for some time prior to August the 24th the weather had been extremely dry and hot, and this may have caused the chock to shrink or otherwise not to be so tight fitting as usual. "I consider that Price did all he could under the circumstances; as soon as he became aware of what had happened he stopped the engine and applied the break. These operations would necessarily take a few seconds, perhaps from 10 to 15 seconds, aud then unfortunately the chain would be running down the pit with such velocity that the break would not bite. "I consider that a "chock" is superior to a screw for the purpose of keeping the wheels in gear in the precise circumstances of this case. Screws are apt to strip their threads where partially worn, whereas a wooden chock must be crushed before it can give away. There is no evidence that the wedge in question has been crushed. Wooden wedges are used in the most critical set as preferable to any other description of distance piece, when subject to heavy jars and strains, as for instance, for keys for railway chairs where they are subject to the jars and strain of heavy locomotives and trains passing over them at high speed, and where this description of fastening is gradually superseding all others. "Looking at all the circumstances of the case, I consider that every reasonable precaution has been taken to insure the safety of the men working in the bye-pit."
The following witnesses did not give evidence before the coroner's jury. They, however, were called before the grand jury at the Staffordshire Assizes : — John Baker says: "I am what is termed the competent man for underground working, and act under the instructions of the prisoner Davies. "Davies was the certificated manager of the colliery called the Tipton Green Colliery. It was formerly called the Tipton Moat Colliery. "Davies always gave instructions and acted as manager. "The prisoner Jackson was the head engineer; I always looked upon him as such, and applied to him for and received all orders from him as the head engineer. "When Jackson was absent Shepperd acted as engineer, and I applied to him for all orders as such. "Price was the engine tender. "I know the rules produced, they are the rules of the colliery. I have seen them posted in the engine house, offices, and about the colliery. "On the day of the accident, I saw both Jackson and Shepperd at the colliery. "On the morning of the accident, about nine o'clock, I went to the engine house and saw the engine out of gear. I asked Price why it was out of gear. He answered that he was obliged to throw it out of gear to fill the cistern. I told him to be very careful or there would be an accident, and that it would never do to be putting it in and out of gear when the men were working in the pit. "The deceased were then in the act of repairing the shaft, and were suspended by a hanging scaffold. "I afterwards saw Davies and Jackson, and told them that the engine was being put in and out of gear by Price, and that unless more care was taken there would be an accident." Mr. Joseph Hanson says: "I was secretary and agent to the Tipton Green Colliery Company, who were owners of the Tipton Moat Colliery at the time of the accident. Davies was the certificated manager of the Tipton Moat Colliery at the time of the accident. Jackson was the head colliery engineer, there was no entry in the books of his appointment. Price was the engine tender. "Shepperd was the under-colliery engineer, and acted under Jackson. "I was appointed in June, and commenced my duties on the 1st of July, and from that period until after the accident all the prisoners acted in the above capacity. "A copy of the special rules now produced is a copy of the certified and published rules of the colliery. I have seen them all published and posted about the colliery. I was at the pit a few minutes after the accident, and saw both the deceased immediately after they were drawn out of the pit dead." After a very long inquiry extending from two o'clock p.m. until nearly midnight, the jury returned a verdict of manslaughter against the manager, the colliery engineer, the competent person, and the engine-man. They were committed for trial at the next March Assizes, but admitted to bail. The bill or bills of indictment were therefore submitted to the grand jury at Stafford on the 3rd of this month, and after calling all the witnesses for the prosecution, were ignored. Such a result, considering all the circumstances of the case, was most unsatisfactory. Proceedings have, however, by your authority been taken against the persons liable for the recovery of the penalties for their respective violations of the law, which are still pending. The following is a report which I myself drew up for the purpose of the inquiry : "I am Her Majesty's Chief Inspector of Mines for this Inspection District, and I have to state that, I visited the colliery on the 26th, and found that the accident had been brought about through the disconnection of the drum-shaft of the winding-engine. At the time of the accident, two men, sinkers, were ascending the bye-pit shaft, and it is stated that when within about 30 yards of the top or mouth of the shaft the winding machinery flew out of gear or became gradually detached from the engine itself, which allowed the winding drum to reverse, and thus run the men and materials back to the scaffold through which they were dashed into several fathoms of water, the chain running out snapped at the drum, and followed them, under which their bodies were afterwards found. "The cause of the accident was therefore rendered clear, but how the machinery became detached is not so easily made out. "On the Monday following I again visited the scene of the accident with the Coroner and Jury, and pointed out the cause which led to the accident, and also the defective parts of the machinery. "On the Thursday following I met Mr. Jonah Davies, Mechanical Engineer, the gentleman appointed by the Coroner to make a report thereon. We made a careful examination of the engine and its machinery, and having heard his report and evidence at the inquest, I, for the most part fully agree with all he says, and so stated before the Coroner and Jury at the close of the inquiry. "The cog-wheels of the machinery were kept in gear by a wooden block or wedge, which was found after the accident on the fly-wheel race. "The engine tender asserts that when the drum shaft was put in gear the wedge was fixed in its place, but, owing to a bent pin, and an improper spanner he could not screw the drum-carriage firmly down to the sill. "The fact of the men and materials having been lowered, and safely raised to within 30 yards of the top, certainly goes a long way to show that the block or wedge was in its place up to that time, unless the position of the chain coil on the drum shaft, and the additional carriage thereunder and near the coil, kept it in gear, which position certainly favors this view. Or the wedge might have been gradually moved vertically or laterally by the vibration and tremor of the drum shaft and its carriage owing to the insecure condition of the carriage itself. A slight movement laterally would bring it into contact with the arms of the crown-wheel of the drum-shaft, which in revolving might easily lift or tilt the wedge out of its place, and thus allow the cog-wheels to creep or slip out of gear. "I found that the engine made about 16 strokes before the brake brought it to a stand, therefore it could not, in my opinion, be regarded as adequate. From disuse and apparent neglect the brake was in a very bad state of repair. If the brake was applied when the engineman says it was, instantly, he ought, to say the least, if he could not stop the revolving machinery, to have so reduced the velocity as to have prevented the consequences which followed, otherwise its application is of no value. It may be added, that the condition of the brake did not show any particular indication of having been subjected to much strain. Seeing, however, that the brake brought the engine under full steam to a stand in 16 strokes, I incline to the belief that its application was too late, and the increasing momentum gained by each revolution of the drum, brought it to a pitch of velocity, which, considering the shortness of the run of the machinery, makes it very difficult to say what amount of brake power, if any, would have prevented the accident. "The brake, however, was not in my opinion, in a condition consistent with the law. "The competent person "Shepperd" does not appear to have made his examination, and to have finished it in accordance with either the general or special rules, his daughter having made out and signed the report. "The engine tender, so called, is required to do certain things under Special Rule 8 upon discovering any serious defect. This he seems to have neglected. "The colliery engineer (Jackson) comes under Special Rules 3 and 6 also, Special Rule 6 says the colliery engineer "shall see that such machinery is provided with a screw, or other sufficient mechanical contrivance to keep it in gear," &c. After the word "screw" the rule is silent as to what the sufficient, &c, shall be. No doubt the wedge or block had previously and for several years, when in use, proved sufficient. Therefore, it is a matter of opinion as to what the contrivance is, so long as it proves sufficient. It was not one of the best arrangements I ever saw, nevertheless, such as it was, provided the work had been properly done, i.e., the drum carriage firmly screwed to the sill, and the slot-holes of the carriage blocked, such an accident is practically impossible, especially with what is called a connecting plate attached to the gland-pins of the fly-wheel and drum carriages. "Mr. Davies was the manager, but, he seems to have exercised no control over the persons employed on the surface or anything thereon."
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||