|
Birley Colliery AccidentExtracted from the Annual Mines Inspectors Report for 1876 Report of Thomas Evans (page 67) Explosions of Gas. Only one fatal explosion of gas has to be recorded this year. It was attended with a loss of six lives, and took place in June at the Birley Vale Colliery, near Sheffield. Inquests were held by C. S. B. Busby, Esq., coroner, Derbyshire, and by Dossey Weightman, Esq., coroner for the West Riding of Yorkshire. Three of the bodies had been removed into the county of York. The Yorkshire jury returned a verdict of manslaughter against the fireman, "William Clayton," and he was committed for trial at the ensuing Leeds assizes. It appears from the evidence (given in this Report), that an exploring heading had been driven about 90 yards beyond a "fault," to prove the mine. The men engaged in driving this heading used locked safety lamps, and the ventilation was conducted to the end by means of wooden pipes. For the better ventilation of the district where the explosion took place, another communication with the return airway had been completed on the 24th June. William Walker, "the under-viewer," went into the airway on Saturday the 24th June, and reported to the manager that the ventilation had been increased, and suggested that the men should be allowed to use naked lights instead of safety lamps. The manager was satisfied with Walker's report, and told him to use his discretion with reference to the use of lights. Walker did not examine the exploring heading to the far end, but merely went to the entrance of it. Clayton, the deputy, whose duty it was to examine that district of the mine on the Sunday night and Monday morning before the men were allowed to go to their work, did not go into the extreme end of the exploring heading, but was satisfied, as the under-viewer was, that the place was ventilated by a mere examination at the entrance. The colliers in going to their work (carrying naked lights) fired some gas which had accumulated in the heading, and ought to have been found and removed by the fireman. Six persons fell victims to the carelessness of these men. Clayton was tried, on the coroner's inquisition, by Mr. Justice Denman, at Leeds; he pleaded guilty, and was severely reprimanded by the learned judge. In my opinion the manager should have satisfied himself by personal examination that the place had been made safe and properly ventilated before he allowed the use of naked lights. The under-viewer, William Walker, neglected his duty, and was probably more to blame than anyone else. He must have known that a mere glance at the entrance of a long heading was no examination; and, further, he must have known that if gas was given off it would accumulate in this heading. It is difficult to understand why he allowed the men to use naked lights before he had ascertained that the place was safe. If he had used ordinary care this explosion would not have occurred. He paid no attention to the discipline in the mine, but committed acts in direct opposition to the rules laid down for the safety of the mine. In obedience to your instructions, I instituted proceedings against the manager, the under-viewer, William Walker, and against the fireman, Thomas Ward. They were all convicted and fined. Evidence taken by Dossey Weightman, Esq., coroner, on the bodies of Ellis Cooper, Thomas Marples, and George Kelly, three of the men who lost their lives by an explosion of gas, which occurred in the Birley Vale Colliery, belonging to the Sheffield Coal Company, Limited, on the morning of the 26th June 1876. Mr. Mosby was then sworn. He said: I am the certificated manager at the Birley Colliery, which belongs to Messrs. Jeffcock, Dunn, and Company. It is an old colliery, but I only came to it on the first of January last. The Silkstone seam of coal is worked in it. The underground viewer is William Walker; the deputies connected with that part of the pit where the explosion occurred are Joseph Murfin, William Clayton, and Thomas Ward; the two latter are also fire-triers. The "fault" to which reference has been made was found before I came to the colliery, and the coal proved beyond it. We began about the end of February to drive on in the coal at the top of the fault, which is 24 feet up. We drove in the level 96 yards from the fault on the top side of it, and it was completed that distance on the 3rd June ; we intended to proceed with it no further. While driving it, and when about half-way along, a slight feeder of gas was met with. The coroner: You had better tell the jury now what are the duties of the fire-triers. The witness: We work one shift of eight hours, and the workings are examined twice in every 24 hours by the fire-triers. One deputy reports in the daytime, and one deputy at night, so there are two reports every 24 hours. It was the duty of William Clayton to go to the mine on Sunday night at nine o'clock to examine the engine plane, at the bottom of which the explosion occurred, and the works on the north-east side of it, and to report in the report book the state in which he found the workings. (The book was produced, and Clayton's entry was "Ventilation and general state good; roadways safe.") He should have gone off duty at six o'clock on Monday morning, and Joseph Murfin would succeed him. I was going to the pit at 7.20 a.m. when I was informed there had been an explosion. I went into the pit, and when I had proceeded within 70 yards of the fault I found the after-damp was coming up the engine plane very strong. I dropped on my hands and knees, and in going along I came to the body of Thomas Marples, sen., then to that of his nephew, then to Edward Saville, Woodward, and Cooper. Kelley had got out of the engine plane and had perished. I found the brattice at the end of the intake had been blown away. I have not heard of any gas been found in that part of the pit since the "feeder" referred to, and that was on the 7th April. I have heard of gas being found up in the Birley Wood district, from 1,200 to 1,400 yards away from where the explosion happened. It was found in a dirt hole, and it was soon cleared away. The circumstance was duly reported in the book. That was in May, and in February some gas was found in a goaf in the same district, but there was no explosion. There has been no other gas reported at, the colliery since I have been there. The coroner : Was there not an explosion there on Friday ? The witness: No ; that was in the north pit, which had no connexion with this one in the matter of ventilation. It is only connected by a water-course. Both pits are the property of the same company. Proceeding, witness said, I saw Clayton about eight o clock on Monday night, and I said to him "Well, Clayton, how did you find the place at the top of the 'staple' on Sunday night?" and he replied, "I found it all clean and sweet, master." I said, "Are you quite sure that it did not touch your lamp ?" and he said, "I'm sure it did not." Previous to this conversation being given, the coroner gave instructions for Clayton to be called into the room that he might hear the evidence. The witness then said that on Saturday a new opening was made near to the fault shaft, whereby the ventilation would be materially improved. In March last a board was placed about ten yards from the fault, on which was written "No naked light allowed beyond this point" I believe the board was there up to the time of the explosion, and I saw it on the ground afterwards. I ordered it to be put there, but I had not noticed it for some time before Monday. On Saturday, about half- past one, a conversation took place between me and William Walker, the under-viewer. I asked him if he had any safety lamps to spare, as I wanted some for another place. He replied, "We have got the connexion through at the little pit on the top of the fault and a good air is passing, and I think we might now use naked lights." I said, "Well, if you are perfectly sure it is clear and safe you may do so." I have not been able to ascertain whether they did use naked lights there or not, but there would be no work there after that time on Saturday, as the pit had stopped. The coroner: Do you know whether, when you had this conversation, Walker had been in the place ? — The witness: Yes; I asked him. If he had been there that day ? — Yes. What did he say ? — "Yes." Did he say what time he had been there ? — About half-past ten, he said. Mr. Evans : To what point did you expect he had been ? — The witness: I expected he had been into the place right away from the top of the staple. The coroner: Whose duty would it be to examine this place on Monday morning before the colliers went down ? — The witness: It was William Clayton's duty. What time would he go down ? — About nine o'clock on Sunday night, and he would go out at six on Monday morning. And Murfin would succeed him? — Yes. What time would Murfin probably get to the place where the explosion occurred? — Very probably it might be nine o'clock before he got to that particular place. Mr. Evans: Where does Clayton meet Murfin? — The witness: At the lamp office, at the bottom of the pit. Should anybody go into the colliery before Clayton returns to that point? — No. I may add that it is Clayton's duty on Sunday night only to examine that place. Thomas Ward examines it all the other five nights in the week. I let them have three deputies on Sunday night instead of two, as there is generally a little extra work then. But whichever foreman or deputy examines the colliery he must return to the lamp cabin before the day men go in? — Yes, those are my instructions. Mr. Evans: Would it be impossible for a man to examine the workings in and past the fault by simply going to the bottom of the staple? — The witness: No, sir. There might have been gas in the heading from the top inward, and yet not be found unless the man had gone into it? — Just so. Do you know whether anybody had been appointed to go to work in that place on Monday morning? — No, sir, I do not. Have you ever been in that place yourself? — Yes. Do you think the two pipes, 11 in. by 9 in., are sufficient to ventilate that heading? — It was always very clean and sweet. The coroner : That is not an answer to the question. Mr. Evans: In your opinion do you say those pipes are sufficient in area? — The witness: Yes, I thought so. You did not give instructions to anyone to increase the size of the pipes? — No, I did not. The colliery is ventilated by means of a fan, is it not? — It is. What is the quantity of air going into the workings? — From 30,000 to 35,000 cubic feet per minute. How many persons are there employed in the pit? — When in full work about 400. And how many horses? — Eighteen. What quantity of air would go down to the point where the explosion occurred? — I don't suppose more than 700 or 800 feet per minute would go up the pipes over the top of the fault. You said the colliery was ventilated by a fan; does that fan work regularly? — Pretty moderately. We have had slight accidents with it, but not often. When did it break down last ? — It did not break down. There was a slight stoppage on Sunday last. How long did it stop on Sunday? — It stopped at 10.20 and it started again at 12.20. From that time until the men went down to work did it go regularly? — Yes; and at six o'clock on Monday morning it was making 80 revolutions per minute. When did it break down before that? — It would be three weeks ago, when we had, perhaps, an hour's stoppage. What was the matter then ? — One of the vanes had caught against the side. Was that during working hours? — Yes, and we ran rather slower that day ; it was about two o'clock in the afternoon. What effect had that upon the mine? — It made very little perceptible difference. We ran 10 strokes less per minute, that was all. Was there time after these break downs to get the men out before there was any danger ? — Yes; we have never seen the slightest sign of any danger. Have you power, as the certificated manager of the colliery, to lay out any headings you like, and to adopt other measures which you think are necessary for the safety of the people employed? — Yes; I have never been opposed in anything I have thought necessary. Mr. Binney: Before you came to this colliery were you ten years manager at the Thorncliffe Collieries belonging to Messrs. Chambers and Co.? — The witness : Yes. Have you ever gone over these rules with your deputies and fire-triers? — Yes, in March last I read every rule over and gave my opinion on it to every man in charge, with a view of their understanding it. I particularly enforced upon them the necessity of keeping the rules. Mr. Parker Rhodes: With regard to your rules, so far as you know, have the deputies always carried them out ? — The witness : Well, I have had some — I am speaking now more particularly of the deputy Murfin ? — I have had no room to find fault with Murfin. A juryman: Is it not the practice for some of the workmen to go into the workings before the fire-trier comee out ? — The witness: I do not know of any such practice. The coroner: Has it been the practice to your knowledge that men have gone to work before the deputy has come back from his round and reported? — The witness : I do not know of any such case. If it has been so, it has been contrary to my distinct orders. The juryman: It is a drift, and the men can walk in if there is no one to prevent them. The coroner: Do you carry out the rule that no man shall go into the pit before the deputy comes out? — The witness : I had heard of irregularities, and that was why I called the deputies together in March, and I gave positive instructions that no man should pass the station board before the pit had been examined. Mr. Evans: It is perfectly clear that no man has a right to go in before the deputy returns in the morning? — The witness: Those are my instructions, and a board is up at the place with the word "station" on it. In answer to further questions the witness said he considered they really worked two shifts a day at the pit, including the men who went down to do repairs, and two examinations were necessary. If there were men at work in the daytime a third examination was made. The inquiry waa then adjourned until Wednesday next, at the Vestry Hall, Woodhouse, where a majority of the jurymen live. The first witness called was William Walker, under-viewer at the Birley Vale Colliery, who said: The explosion took place in the south or plantation pit. I was at work on Saturday the 24th, and left the pit about halt-past one. There is no work in the pit on Saturday afternoons. I did not go in again before the explosion took place. I should have gone in at a quarter to eight on Monday morning. I went in at about half-past six. I did so because I heard there had been an explosion, I went down to the place. I assisted in getting to the bodies, when I found Woodward in the main road; he was lying on his back. He was burnt badly, mostly about his face and breast. He had no clothes on, except his trousers, so far as I could see. Edward Saville was lying on his left side, close to the wall. His head was upwards towards the way out. He was about 50 feet above Woodward. He was not burnt, but appeared to have been caught by the fire-damp. Thomas Marples, junior, was about seventeen feet away. He was lying on his face with his head up the hill. Marples, senior, was twenty-five feet above Marples, junior, lying on his face with his head down the hill. He was not burnt, but knocked on his face, badly bruised. The men, in my opinion, had not begun working at all when the explosion occurred. On Saturday Cooper, Woodward, Seville, and Marples, junior, worked, not in the bottom of the staple, but in a road between the staple and another spot. I have been to the place since the explosion, and formed a pretty good opinion as to where it actually occurred, and these men actually worked at the very place on Saturday. Two worked on the top, and two on the under side of the "staple" which they were driving through in order to get regular ventilation. They were driving through dirt and bind, and got through on Saturday. I went through it myself; that would be about half-past ten. The ventilation was very good then, and I stopped with them till a quarter past eleven, arranging with them about the work that was to be done. The ventilation, after the heading was through, went down the pipes and came back along the new drift. It had previously gone down the. "staple" shaft, but when we made the cutting through it did not go down the shaft, but went on through on that cutting. I went out of the pit at a quarter to twelve o'clock, and went into the office. Before I went out of the pit I had a consultation with Murfin at the staple pit, and with the others there. Murfin said to me, "We have been punished a long time with lamps; we hope we shall be able to do without them." The coroner: Did he say "We have been punished" ? Witness: "they have been punished," he said, "with lamps for a long time; we hope we shall be able to do without in future." Cooper said to Murfin, "Shall we go without lamps on Monday morning?" And Murfin said, "No; I cannot give you that leave. We cannot grant that until we have seen our manager." I then came out of the pit. The coroner: Did you give Woodward any instructions about Monday morning before you came out ? Witness : Yes; where he was to work I gave him instructions to begin work at a heading at the bottom of the staple. It was a heading to widen the intake. No one was to work with him. The air-road had to be widened to improve the ventilation, and Cooper was to begin driving at a new heading to make another communication through the fault at the end of the new drift. I did not give any instructions about candles or lamps. Safety lamps were exclusively used in the fault, but naked candles had been used in the return air-way about twelve yards from the place of explosion. When I went out of the pit on Saturday, in the office at the top I told Mr. Mosby we had got through this staple, and as far as I could judge we could do without safety lamps. The coroner: After the explosion did you go to the place? Yes. — Did you form any opinion as to where it took place ? As far as my judgment has been, it took place between the staple pit and the steep road we drove round. Had any report reached you of any gas being found in the place previously? It was about the 7th April when it was reported there was gas in the air-road, at a place where the roof fell. It was put on the report books. I don't know that ever we had any report of gas in that part of the pit where the explosion occurred. When you went down to search for these men did you lake a candle or a lamp with you? I took a lamp for about 1,400 yards from the top. I went down the main board to "about" 450 yards from the bottom. It was an oil lamp. It was not a safety lamp. It was a "flaming lamp." I put my lamp down, and went forward one hundred yards in the dark. Then I fell in with two men. They had a safety lamp, and we went forward. The deputies were coming down the drift when the explosion occurred. They had safety lamps, but I could not take one, as there was not a lamp left in the store. There were nine explorers, supplied with four safety lamps for the first hour. By Mr. Evans: How many safety lamps were used in the colliery up to the time of explosion ? Only two, besides those used by the deputies; the two lamps were used in the fault — Was there a danger signal near the bottom of the main? Yes; a board was hanging about eight yards from the last cutting. — Was it a danger board? Yes; it had the words on it, "No naked light allowed beyond this point." The board was hanging on a cloth on Saturday. — Did any men work in the drift on Saturday? Yes; they worked there with naked lights. — How did they get there; did they pass along the drift and past the fire board with naked lights? Yes; it appears they did so. — Did you carry a candle? — No; I had a flaming lamp, but left it about two yards on the top side of the danger board, and went forward with Murfin, who had a safety lamp. — Did you say anything to the men on Saturday about using a danger signal? Yes. By the coroner: I tried the new cutting and all the new works with a safety lamp. When I was trying them with a safety lamp my flaming light was still within two yards of the bratticing cloths, and the men were working with candles. By Mr. Evans: This road on the top of the fault is said to be about 95 yards long? Yes, it is 96. — And the ventilation passed through pipes ? Yes. — You said in your evidence you were there on Saturday, at the bottom of the "staple" shaft? Yes. — Did you go into the far end of that drift? No. — How could you possibly tell the condition of that drift without going into the far end of it? Well, by going a few yards into it we thought the air was quite clear and pure. — It is 96 yards long? Yes. — Did you, in consequence of the examination you made on Saturday, allow the men to go and work there on Monday with naked lights? No, sir, I did not allow them at all. — Did you know the fireman brought the lamps out ? It has been reported so. — Did you know of your own knowledge whether there was any examination made of this level after you were there on Saturday, and before the explosion ? I expect so. There is a report in the book, and somebody must have examined it. — Were the men withdrawn out of the pit on account of the fan breaking down ? No, not to my knowledge. — Was there any brattice cloth to be had at the pit? Yes, we had 12 yards at the pit top before the explosion. By Mr. Binney, solicitor: There were perhaps four dozen safety lamps in the office at the top. The coroner pointed out that this was a contradiction! as the witness had previously stated there were only four lamps. The witness explained that he meant that number to apply to the lamps in the pit. Re-examined by the coroner: They borrowed some lamps for the north pit. They did borrow some from the Manor pit, but he believed that was the day after the explosion. He did not know now it was they sent there. They had enough in the south colliery. In the latter they had not above nine at work, and there were above three dozens in the chamber. A good many of them had to be cleaned. They were fit to be used. The coroner: I have it in evidence that there was a barrier or brattice cloth in the slit leading up to the new cut. Although there was that brattice cloth, is it or not a fact that the air would pass those naked lights, that is, the air coming from the new drift? — Witness: It would. Before the cut was made, the return air from the long new drift and where the safety lamps were used, would all pass the naked lights. Joseph Murfin, the day deputy in the Birley Plantation Colliery, living at Hollinsend, said: On Saturday, the 24th June, I left the pit at half-past twelve in the afternoon. I reported the state of the pit, from twelve to half-past twelve, in the book as good and safe. The new cut through had not been completed when I left. The last time I was there would be about twenty past eleven. I left Ellis Cooper, James Woodward, and Edward Saville there; they were working there. Walker was with me. I had some conversation with him respecting the ventilation. Ellis Cooper asked me if they would be allowed to work with naked lights, and I told him I would not be able to answer that question. William Walker said they ought to have a little consideration for those who had to give a reply. There was no further conversation, excepting as to the arrangement of the air round the new cut through. On the Monday morning it was nearly seven o'clock when I heard of the explosion. It was about twenty minutes past six when I left the surface. I had my safety lamp in my hand. When I heard the news I went to the site of the explosion with William Walker and William Cutts to explore. I cannot tell who found Kelly. When I got to the place I did not see the danger board up. I had seen it on Saturday. It was on a piece of wood that went across to hang the cloth on. It was found after the explosion, about two yards off the place it had been hanging to the cloth. The blast had taken the cloth away. By Mr. Evans: I sometimes meet the night fireman at the top of the main drift, and sometimes at the bottom. He is sometimes past the lamp cabin. I did not meet the night deputy on the day of the explosion. William Clayton was the night fireman of that district on that occasion. There was no boy with the fireman. They went separately. It was the custom for them to wait until I arrived, but it had been neglected for some time on a Monday morning. I did not go into the lamp cabin, but made my way as quickly as possible to the scene of the explosion. The fire-trier marked the fault as having examined it. I noticed the marks day after day. On the day of the explosion I saw no marks made previously to it. I was in the heading about three days before the explosion. I was there four or five times from the 3rd June. By Mr. Clegg: It was part of my duty to see that there was no gas there. I did not think it was necessary to go there as often as in any other part. Gas would not accumulate there as much as anywhere else. Of course it mattered whether I went there or not I went for this reason, to see if the roof had ever given way or injured the air pipes that go down there. If the roof had given way and injured the air pipes it would have affected the ventilation. William Clayton, a night fire-trier, living at Intake, said : I left off working at the south pit on Friday, the 23rd ultimo, at twelve o'clock at night. I went on again on Sunday night at eight. My duty was to go round the district in the low side of the mine with a safety lamp. I did so. I got to the "staple" pit between nine and ten o'clock, and found all right. I made a mark dated the 26th on a piece of board and on the shovel, one at the bottom of the staple and the other at the bottom of the new cutting. I considered the pit safe, sweet, and good. I went out between two and three o'clock. I ought to have gone out at four. We were led astray by Thomas Ward's watch, which gained. Joseph Murfin was the fireman, who ought to have come on after me, at six o'clock. I do not know it was my duty to see him before I went away in the morning. When we went to Mr. Mosby to hear the rules read over, there was an agreement come to. Mr. Mosby said that I and Thomas Ward were to be down at eight on Sunday night to examine the gates in time for the repairers, who come in at twelve. Martin Wilson, a fire-trier, was to come on at ten o'clock. Then, at four o'clock in the morning, when we had found all right, we went home. This arrangement has not been going on ever since Mr. Mosby came. I knew it was in opposition, to the rules, as far as the two hours went I heard of the explosion on the Monday morning, between six and seven, when I was at home. I had marked up the date in the pit on the previous night, as it was the rule to do so. Before I left the pit I had got an entry made in the book stating that all was right. It is not a fact that I had found gas that morning. I have not told anybody that I did. It is quite true that I wrote "fire" on a shovel for a "preventity" to keep others out of the staple. William Walker, the steward, when he saw me on the Saturday, told me that we had got the other staple down, and all was safe, and that the place was not going to be worked again either with lamps or naked lights for awhile. I put the word "fire" on the shovel for the purpose of keeping everybody out of the place. I swear that it is a positive fact that I found no gas at all, but merely put up the word as a beacon to frighten people away. It was my duty to examine the new drift every day, and when "fire" is written it is a sign that no one should enter with a naked light. The proper way would be "fencing off," but it was not done. It was the duty of some of the datalers. They would not fence it off without being told, and it was Joseph Murfin's duty to tell them. It was Murfin's duty, because he is not running over so much ground as I am. Supposing I really had found fire gas where I marked it up, I would have had to report it in the book. We have not fenced off those places. We have not found fire very often. The last I saw was in the new long drift When I heard of the explosion I did not make use of the expression, "Its just what I expected would happen." I did not ask Walker to say nothing about my having seen fire. By the coroner: The gas might have been given off just before the explosion took place. By the foreman: The fire-triers and deputies were not entitled to come up two hours earlier than usual on Monday, although they went down at eight o'clock on Sunday night They did it without his knowledge. William Walker, recalled, was examined as to the alleged order he had given with respect to the long new drift. On the 3rd of June he told Cooper and Woodward that that place would not be worked any more, and they must bring their tools out They did so. He did not know that he told Clayton on Saturday that the cut through was not going to be used again. There was no more ripping to be done there. He did not tell Cooper and Woodward that they were not to do any work in the new slit With regard to the arrangement about going down at eight o'clock on Sunday nights, he only told the fire-triers that they must go down early enough to get the examination of the datalers' places before twelve o'clock When the rules were read over, Clayton and the others were told to remain until they saw the deputies succeeding them arrive. As to the statement in regard to the lamps, he told them that if they thought it safe they might bring them out by five o'clock. He did not consider that they would both leave the pit then. He thought one would have remained in while the other came up specially. He thought the order he gave in that respect was contrary to the rule, which said they should remain in the pit until the next set of deputies arrived. He asked Clayton after the explosion if he had examined the place and found all right. He replied "that the gas just lighted in his lampDon't say a word to anybody about what I've said." When he asked Clayton if he had examined the place, he meant the place of the explosion. Clayton, on being asked by the coroner what he thought of this statement, said it was false. The coroner said this was all the evidence in the case, and if the jury thought fit to put any questions to Mr. Evans, Her Majesty's Inspector of Mines, they might do so. Mr. Evans said he would be glad to give them the result of his inspection, and to answer any questions they felt inclined to put to him. On Wednesday the 28th of June I made an inspection of the Birley Vale Colliery, with a view of ascertaining the cause of the explosion which took place on the 20th of June, and was attended with a loss of six lives. From the inspection I made of the mine, and from the evidence given at this inquiry, I am satisfied the explosion occurred in the "cut through" near the "fault," and probably it fired at the naked light of one of the deceased men whilst he was going to his work. There are marks of violence to be seen in the "exploring drift," in the "cut through," and the heading in close proximity to the fault The exploring drift was ventilated up to the 24th by means of wooden pipes passing up the "staple" and along the drift, the air returning down the shaft. On that day the "cut through" was made, and a consequent alteration made in the wind. Mr. Stokes, my assistant, made an examination of the workings in past the fault on the Tuesday, and found but a small quantity of air. The alteration which has been described, made on Saturday, would probably decrease the quantity of air passing through the pipes. The exploring drift rises from the face towards the top of the "cut through," and any gas given off would naturally ascend and pass along to the road some of the deceased had to travel. Wherever the gas came from, it is quite clear the heading was not sufficiently ventilated to meet the requirements of the 1st General Rule of the Mines Act; and you have it in evidence the places were not examined since Saturday the 25th. I consider Walker is very much to blame, and all the officials in charge of that district, and the manager trusted to Walker's examination, which was most unsatisfactory. The coroner, in summing up, said the case was full of contradictions, but probably the jury would be able to judge where the truth lay from the manner in which the witnesses had given their evidence. They had the best possible evidence of a breach of the 25th rule, because the man who had committed it had himself admitted it. He, however, swore that an arrangement had been made for the under-viewers or deputies to leave the pit at four o'clock on Monday mornings, but the balance of evidence was against any such arrangement having been made at all. As to the question of ventilation, he might be wrong, but he thought the Government inspectors ought to have the power — as they were best able to judge — to say what mines ought to be worked with safety lamps and what mines might be worked with candles. Mr. Evans, however, was of opinion that if that duty were thrown upon the Government it would take the responsibility entirely off the shoulders of the agents and certificated managers, and render them almost nonentities. He could not concur in that opinion, because in a large mine like this they had many other matters of quite sufficient importance to attend to. He could not help thinking that the person best able to judge whether safety lamps should or should not be used was the person appointed by Government to look into the working of mines. He then pointed out that if the jury thought any person was to blame for the present accident they must be satisfied that there was not only negligence, but culpable negligence, before returning a verdict of manslaughter. He was inclined to think that Mr. Mosby, the manager, could hardly be held responsible, for, although he was manager, and was responsible for the proper conduct of the pit, he could not possibly be everywhere. It was impossible for him to superintend every little transaction done by deputies, and under-viewers, and others. The very fact of having those men implied that some of his duties were taken off his shoulders. After summing up the evidence, he dwelt on the contradictions involved in Clayton's evidence, and said the jury would have to make up their minds as to his conduct in not examining the long drift, and in making statements which, probably because they incriminated himself, he had denied whilst giving evidence. The jury retired to consider their verdict, and they found the deaths had been consequent on the gross negligence of the "fire-trier" Clayton, and it amounted to manslaughter.
|
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||