Museum Entrance Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Reports Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Reports
Index

Jammage Colliery Accident

Extracted from the Annual Mines Inspectors Report for 1876

Report of Thomas Wynne (page 32)

Explosions of Fire-damp.

The first occurred on the 5th January at Jammage Colliery, causing the death of five men. The ignition of the gas was pretty clearly traced to the surreptitious firing of a shot by one of the deceased, but I think the following account of the proceedings at the adjourned inquest will best explain the matter.

FIRE-DAMP EXPLOSION AT JAMMAGE COLLIERY NEAR NEWCASTLE, STAFFORDSHIRE.

Adjourned Inquest held 19th January 1876.

The adjourned inquiry as to the deaths of the five men killed at the explosion at the Jammage Pit, on Wednesday the 5th instant, was held at the Crown Inn, Red Street,, on Wednesday, before Mr. J. Booth, Coroner for North Staffordshire. There were present: Mr. T. Wynne, Government Inspector of Mines; Mr. S. B. Gilroy, Assistant Inspector; Mr. Superintendent Baker; Mr. R. N. Wood, one of the proprietors of the colliery; and the Rev. W. M. McHutchin. Mr. Ackrill watched the proceedings on behalf of the representatives of the late John Wedgwood, Esq., the proprietors of the colliery.

Michael Wood, butty collier at the Jammage Pits, was re-called, and repeated the evidence he gave at the opening inquiry. In reply to Mr. Wynne, witness said he had never heard of a shot being fired by any one not a butty or fireman. The day before the explosion witness fired one in Macphearson's place. The last shot he fired was at ten minutes past seven on the morning of the explosion. He believed that since he fired the shot there had been another one fired. Sharples was on duty, and if fired by any one the shot should have been fired by him. Bury was on duty between seven o'clock and two o'clock, and he might have fired a shot. — In reply to Mr. Ackrill, witness said that when he went down in the morning everything appeared to be going on all right, and witness saw no gas. Supposing a shot to be fired by Darlington, the fireman Sharples should have been sent tor. Sharples would have been there between seven and ten. The strict ordere of witness to the men were that they should not fire shots themselves, but that they should adhere to the rules. Darlington should have sent for the fireman. Supposing any gas to be lodged, the fireman should have cleared it before the shot had been fired. The accident would not have occurred if the shot had been properly fired. — In reply to Mr. Gilroy: Witness said he was not aware that it was strictly forbidden to take the top of the lamp off. Witness had known shots to be fired with the top off. No one was allowed to carry a key except the firemen and the butties. Witness, however, knew that two of the men had keys. — The Coroner observed that three keys had been found. — In reply to Mr. Ackrill: That was strictly against orders. If a shot were fired with the lamp top off it would be by proper persons' after proper examination. — By the Coroner: Witness made no entries of his examinations in the book, but he reported all that he found. Thomas generally worked in the 7-feet. He was not there at the time of the explosion. — In reply to a juryman, witness said it was his opinion that Darlington fired the shot without orders. The Coroner said that at present there was no evidence of the shot being fired.

The next witness called was John Thompson, butty collier, living at Chesterton, and working in partnership with Wood. He said he went down the pit at half-past five in the morning. Edward Jones, the night fireman, went down when witness went down. In reply to an inquiry by witness, Jones said that all the places were right. Bury was examining the pit lamps along with Jones. Witness went along the north part of the workings between eight and nine o'clock to fire a shot in Daniel Proctor's place. He examined the whole of the workings on the north side, and found them all safe. There was no trace of gas. There were no other shots fired, except by Wood and witness. No complaint was made to witness as to the state of the ventilation. The powder was taken down in cartridges and in tin canisters. The duty of the fireman was to see that the hole was properly charged, and it was the fireman's duty to fire the shot. Witness had never known the rule to be broken ; he had never known a man to fire his own shot. Before a shot was fired, it would be the fireman's duty, of course, to examine the workings. The north side had been opened about eight or nine months. Witness had never found any gas upon the north side. — In reply to Mr. Wynne, witness said he had never known any man to fire a shot without permission. When witness was through the workings at about nine o'clock, he went up to No. 2 thirling from the far end. When he got there, the slack was going into the level. There was plenty of room for three men to go in abreast. The height from the slack to the roof was a yard, and the width would be about six feet across. Witness was sure of that. The next thirling was open — quite open. — In reply to Mr. Gilroy: When the fireman had examined the place, permission might be given to the men to fire the shot, but this was only on the supposition that the shot was fired soon. — In reply to Mr. Ackrill: The men were ordered by the rules to give up matches, keys, and pipes before they went down the pit. Between eight and nine o'clock, when witness fired the shots, the air current was going on perfectly right; everything was clear of gas.

John Sharples, Talke, said he had been a fireman at the colliery for about five months. He went down the pit at two o'clock on the day of the explosion. He saw Edward Bury at the pit bottom. Bury said that all was right, and that witness had to go to the 8-feet seam. At the top head they wanted pipes starting to go along. Witness went to the 8-feet, but did not go to the north side of the 7-feet; he was laat in the 7-feet on the day previous to the explosion. He fired no shots on the day of the explosion, nor did he know any were going to be fired. If a man in the pit wanted a shot fired, and witness was in the 7-feet, it would be in the man's duty to send for witness. Witness never gave a man permission to fire a shot, and never knew one to be so fired. On the 4th instant witness went in all the places on the north side, and found that all was going on safely. The No. 3 thirling was closed up. There was a sort of temporary stopping for driving the air round to the far end. When that was removed, the far end would be ventilated. The men were in the habit of opening this thirling to let down the stuff from Darlington and Macpherson's place. The stuff from these places would have to go through the No. 3 thirling. If they failed to close it after letting out the stun, they would stop the whole of the ventilation. The air must come up there, because it was the shortest cut It was not much trouble to open it. It could be done in five minutes. Sometimes it would not be opened for three or four days. During the whole of his examinations of the mine on the north side of the 7-feet, witness had not found any gas. — In reply to Mr. Wynne: Witness had known shots fired without his consent. — Witness; He had never caught any man doing it. — In reply to Mr. Ackrill: During the shifts of witness, he had never known of shots being fired without his consent.

Mr. Wynne: Have you ever used words to me of this effect: "It's no use denying it, for the men have been in the habit of firing shots without my knowledge ?" — Witness: I never have.

In reply to Mr. Gilroy, witness said that all the shots fired in his shift were fired by himself. Witness had not had occasion to find fault with Rowley and Odam. There was a rule that matches should not be taken down the pit, yet he knew that one match had been found. — By Mr. Ackrill: The men had no right with lamp keys. Witness had always found the ventilation good in the workings of the north side. If witness had known that the brattice was misplaced in No. 3 thirling, he would have had it put right. If Darlington had wanted a shot fired, he could easily have found witness. — In reply to Mr. Gilroy: At the time of the explosion, witness heard two reports — the first one he could not understand the cause of, and the second one took his cap off and knocked him down. — By Mr. Ackrill: The explosion must have knocked down a great deal of stack. All the lamps had since been fonnd, and all were locked ; none had ever been found unlocked.

Edward Bury, fireman, Red Street, said he went down the pit on the day of the explosion, at about 5.30 a.m. He saw Edward Jones and took him out. Jones said that all was right, except one place, and that smelled a little. He said that was up the top lift at Daniel's place. Witness got to it at a quarter to eight, and put some pipes in it. Witness did not go into Darlington's place. In the report witness made, he said all the places were tight with the exception of a little gas in one level. As for going round the whole of the workings, some days witness could not get round. It was an understood thing that if the men found gas they were to send for witness, because witness could not examine the whole of the workings. Witness only fired part of the shots. Three men named Challinor, William Baskerville, and William Grocott, were told off for the purpose of firing shots. — By Mr. Wynne: When witness got to Daniel's place, he found about six inches of gas extending over about five or six yards. The head had been driven about twelve yards. One half of that place had six inches of gas in it. At the top of the heading there was no gas at all. Witness found some gas there about a week before, but he removed it by putting some sheeting up. If there was any gas from the far end of the deep level, it would pass the end of Daniel's place. That was the first place for it to go in. Witness knew that Darlington's place was thirled on the morning of the 5th. He believed it was thirled after the discovery of the gas at Daniel's place. He was in the habit of saying the places were safe when he had not seen them. The others did it, and the reason was that they could not help it because of the work they had to do. Witness did not know that the men had fired any shot themselves. Wood took the authority of making the men mentioned into shot firers. — By Mr. Gilroy: Witness did not make it a point to examine the whole of the working places when he went down in the morning; he could not do it. — By Mr. Ackrill ; It was an understanding between Michael Wood and others that the men must first find the gas, and then send for the fireman to clear it out. Witness and the other firemen had been to their work every day, and reported that all was right, when they could not really do the whole of the work. Still the entries were made in the book. Witness had complained to Mr. Gater many a time. He had complained this month, perhaps a week before the accident happened. In December he could not tell how often he had complained ; perhaps he had complained three times. The fact was he could not get round it all on any day, and the others could not if they told the truth. Witness had told Mr. Gater that it was an understanding that the men should find the gas, and then send for the fireman to clear it out — Mr. Ackrill: You seem to wish to implicate everyone. — At this juncture, in consequence of the manner in which witness answered the questions of Mr. Ackrill, the Coroner found it necessary to reprimand the man. — In reply to the foreman, witness said he had felt uneasy in his mind many a time as to his being unable to go round the workings in consequence of the other work he had to do. — By a Juror: Witness had been a fireman for fifteen years.

Edwin Jones, fireman, said he examined the whole of workings on the night of the 4th instant. He went through them at two o'clock in the morning, and reported that he had examined the seven and eight feet levels, dips, and thirlings, and found all right. At the No. 1 level north side of the seven feet there was a little gas. The last time witness was near Darlington's place was about five o'clock. Witness had been fireman at the Jammage Pits about twelve months. He had found but very little gas, and had never seen any in Darlington's place. There was an understanding among the firemen to tell each other what places bad been left unexamined. — By Mr. Wynne : When witness had the day shift he could not examine the whole of the places; and he did not report that he had done so. On the day shifts the firemen were usually sent for to fire shots. Witness did not know who fired shots when he was not sent for. He considered that Challinor, Grocott, and others had a right to fire shots. When the gas was found in Daniel's place, witness entered the fact in the report book. He could not say where the gas came from, and he did not trouble to inquire.

John Griffiths, collier, said he was at the pit on the morning of the explosion. He worked in Daniel Darlington's place. He left work at twelve o'clock, and no one would be there until Darlington came on. When witness left in the morning, one shot had been fired on the side he had been working, and one at Macpherson's place, the latter being fired by Wood. Proctor came out when witness did, Macpherson being left in. Witness had worked there about two or three months. He had never found any gas in his working. It was clear of gas on the day of the explosion. — By Mr. Gilroy: It was an understanding that matches, keys, and pipes should be left on the pit bank. — By the Coroner: Witness had never seen any men smoking in the pit.

Mr. Enoch Gater, colliery underground manager, Red Street, said he was manager of the Jammage Pits. He was not down the pit on the 5th instant before the explosion, but went down shortly afterwards, and assisted in getting out the bodies. On the previous day he had been through all the workings, and found them all in a very good state. The ventilation was good. There was a little gas in one heading in the eight-feet seam, and that was all. No complaints were made to him by any one when he was in the pit that day. Witness had never had any complaints made to him by the firemen or others. Edward Bury had never complained, nor had any of the other firemen. The mine was usually free from gas. In the opinion of witness every necessary step was taken for making the ventilation good and perfect. With regard to the firing of shots, orders were given that none but the firemen Wood and Thompson should fire shots. It had never come to his knowledge that other persons had fired shots. Witness knew Challinor, Grocott, and Baskerville, and had given permission for them to fire shots. He had not given permission to any one else. — By Mr. Wynne: Witness thought he was justified in appointing these men to fire shots. Men had said that shots were not fired when they wanted them. The persons named were therefore nominated by the butties, and witness sanctioned their firing shots. According to this there were eight shot firers in the pit. The men appointed were old workmen, who were steady and trustworthy. — By Mr. Ackrill: Had never had any complaint from the firemen that they were unable to do all their work. So far as witness could remember, Bury had never made any such complaint.

P. S. Stanton said he examined the bodies of the men as they were brought out of the pit. On Darlington he found a tobacco pouch, knife, and lamp studs; on Macpherson, a knife and two lamp studs; on Cogan, a lamp-key, knife, and tobacco box; on Rowney, a box; on Daniels, a watch, knife, and touch paper.

Mr. Samuel Bertram Gilroy, Assistant Inspector of Mines, said he visited the colliery on the 7th and 18th instants. He found a quantity of slack where Daniel's body was found. The aperture was so small that witness could barely get through it. He found many strong traces of fire from this point to the face. It appeared to have shot up the last thirling, and gone on to the far top north, leading to which Darlington's place thirled. The tar on the air pipes had been blistered considerably, traces of fire gradually becoming fainter towards the face. Witness went through Darlington's thirling, and saw the marks of a shot having been fired. At Macpherson's place there were similar indications of a shot having been fired. The traces of fire in Darlington's dip were very severe. The deep sides of all the projections were charred. No further trace of fire was found in this direction. The fire seemed to have spent itself at the bottom of No. 2 dip. The effect of a cloth being lifted at the bottom of Darlington's dip would be to cut the air off from the north side. The accumulation of slack already referred to would tend in the same direction. As there was no evidence of professional examination of Darlington's place between seven o'clock and the time of the explosion, there was sufficient time for the accumulation of gas in this bottom level. If Daniels had stood where he was he would have lived; but going through the door he met the whole body of after-damp. From the indications he had seen, witness concluded that the cause of mischief was a shot being fired in Darlington's place. At the time of the shot being fired the gas which was gradually accumulating would be so small that Darlington would not notice it, except on close examination. The heaping of slack was a great evil in this district. Instead of a heading being left open a man was allowed to go working over a heap of slack.

Mr. T. Wynne, Inspector of Mines, said he was down the pit the next morning after the explosion, and from the examination he then made he was now clearly of opinion that the explosion took place in Darlington's working, indeed, he did not think there could be a doubt that it was so from the course which the explosion took. He feared that there was gas in the far end of the workings for some time before the explosion, he believed for 24 hours. His reason for thinking so was that it begun to tail off ; from the first symptoms of gas were seen in Daniel's place, which was the very place where the gas would go to if it were driven away from the far end. That was a pretty clear indication tlmt there was foulness at the far end. Passing that place, which was the highest place, it went into it. It appeared that Darlington's place had been lately cut through, and had it not been cut through, from the smallness of the place and working it, it was very likely that it would have been below firing point. Being cut through, and having this fresh air right straight up to it, made it so sharp as to produce the effect which they saw of perhaps not a very large quantity of gas. The evidence had not gone to show where this gas had accumulated, but he could go as far as to say very positively that the gas was fired in Darlington's place, and that it was fired by a shot. He could not but strongly object to the evidence of Mr. Gater as to the steep dips and small air-holes, and he hoped that there would be no more of them.

The Coroner briefly summed up the evidence, and after a deliberation lasting for more than an hour, the jury returned a verdict of "Accidental death, caused by the explosion of an accumulation of gas in the north end of the workings, such accumulation being occasioned by the opening of a stopping, and the gas being fired by a shot in Darlington's place. The jury are of opinion that where lamps are used gunpowder should be entirely prohibited. The jury are also of opinion that the discipline of the pit has been very lax in the working and management, and recommend that in future no one but duly appointed firemen be allowed to fire shots."

The inquiry then terminated, having lasted from 10.30 a.m. to 5 p.m.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page


mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z