Swaithe Main Disaster
Extracted from the Annual Mines Inspectors Report for 1875
Report of Frank N. Wardell (page 281)
On Monday 6th December the country was startled by the report that a fearful explosion
had occurred at the Swaithe Main Colliery near Barnsley. The report proved only too correct,
and it becomes my painful duty to state that no less than 143 lives were lost by this calamity.
For a period of nine years, or since the explosion at the Oaks Colliery, no accident involving
such disastrous results has occurred in this district, and the hope was growing that with
increased watchfulness and care, added to the various modes of more efficient ventilation
introduced by science from time to time, and a strict attention to the provisions of the recent
Acts of Parliament, whereby life is protected to a great extent, misfortunes like this were
things of the past. The accident in question rudely dispelled any such illusion, and prominently
brought before us the stern fact that when a single joint in the machinery gets out of
gear we are still liable to the most appalling consequences.
The explosion occurred, as I have stated, at the Swaithe Main Colliery, the property of
Messrs. Mitchell and Co. This colliery is contiguous to and indeed connected with the
Edmunds Main Colliery, belonging to the same owners, where an explosion occurred in 1862,
involving serious loss of life.
I have already, according to your instructions, made a special report to you on this accident,
and it will be best now to lay before you a plan of the workings in that portion of the mine
affected by the explosion, and the chief points of evidence produced at the inquest. I also
add the remarks made by myself, my colleagues, and the coroner, and append thereto
the verdict, which, after a prolonged and patient investigation, was returned by the jury.
Richard Forster, of Swaithe, said he was an articled pupil to Mr. John Mitchell, mining engineer.
He had known the Swaithe Main Colliery for three years and a half. Mr. Mitchell had been
the certificated manager of the colliery during the whole time witness had been there. Witness
had attended to no other pit except the Edmunds Main under the same company. He had been
employed in preparing a plan of the workings of the colliery. [The plan was affixed to the wall
of the court, so as to be within the sight of the jury.] The plan represented the dip workings
of the Swaithe Colliery. He had travelled all the roads marked on the plan, and he could certify
from his personal knowledge that the plan was a correct one. The diameter of the drawing shaft
was 13 feet 6 inches, and the depth 230 yards. The diameter of the up-cast shaft was 12 feet 9
inches, and the depth 225 yards. The distance between the two shafts was 68 yards. The pit was
ventilated by the down-cast shaft by means of the furnace which was at the bottom of the up-cast
shaft. The air divided immediately at the bottom of the down-cast shaft. One current goes down
the engine plane, and splits first at the north dip level ; then it splits at the third board of the
second north dip level; and there joining another current the joint currents go up the slant drift,
along the drift level to the end of the workings. The third split was at the "double three level,"
and the air proceeded up the first rise board, and along the old No. 5 level. Then it commenced
to return round the straight level, and separated at the bottom of No. 4 drift. The witness gave
further explanations of the arrangements for ventilating the pit.
Joseph Bennett, Calker Lane, Worsborough Dale, said he was a deputy viewer in Swaithe Main
Colliery, and on the sixth of the present month he was on the day shift. He went down the pit
at 5.25; and the first place he went to after leaving the pit bottom was the "box hole," or place
where the men met. When he got there he saw Henry Jacques, who was a day deputy. Before he
got to the "box hole," he saw the night deputies, Joseph Sheldon and William Midgley. They
were examining the lamps as the miners came down, before they went to work. Witness was
principal deputy at the pit, and had general overlooking of the districts of the pit. Sheldon in his
district had the dip workings, Briggs' siding, dip siding, and the shunt. Witness saw a deputy
named Allen along with several others when they met at the box hole; and then Sheldon reported
as to the state of the pit, and all was right and in working order. Allen was the under viewer, but
he gave witness no further information. In addition to himself there were Sheldon, Allen, Beavor,
George Beardsall, William Earnshaw, and Henry Jacques. Beardsall's district was on the right
side of the pit, No. 1. He escaped, and was living now. Jacques was dead. His district was
No. 2; William Earnshaw's was No. 3; Thomas Beavor's was No. 4. He met Jno. Waterworth,
a deputy, and one of the deceased in the box hole. He was a general day deputy and had no
district. All the deputies knew their own districts; and there was no fear of one party clashing
with another.
The Foreman: Can you give us any information about an accumulation of gas ?
The Coroner: We have not got to that yet.
Mr. Maule: We must take things in order, or we shall get confused.
The Coroner: What was the particular spot where he was working ?
Witness: I don't know whether you could have got in, it was such a small place; it was in No. 3
district, and was an abandoned place.
The Coroner: Was it continuously reported that there was gas ?
Witness: Yes, up to Saturday morning. It had been continually reported up to the 4th of
December.
Mr. Maule; It is reported in the colliery books up to the 4th, and then it seems to have disappeared.
Mr. Mellor: It appeared so from the ventilating record book, signed by the viewers.
The witness continuing, said he went into "double three" and from thence into Joshua Eyre's
working place in No. 4. Earnshaw was there, and was about to fire a shot. Eyre came out of his
working place before the shot was discharged. This was about nine o'clock in the morning.
The Coroner: Did you stay till the shot was fired? — Yes.
Was it fired in the face of the coal ? — Yes.
Were they working by candle or by lamp ? — By lamp.
Safety lamps they would be? — Yes.
Were they Davy or Stephenson ? — Stephenson.
You had one too, I suppose ? — Yes.
How did they fire it, now was the shot formed? The hole is bored, and then what do they do ?
Was there a fuse ? — Yes; they light the ends of the fuse.
What with ? — With a wire.
With a red hot wire ? — Yes.
Which you heat at the lamp ? — Yes ; we put it through the gauze.
Was it very thin wire ? — Yes.
Was the wire put under the glass and through the gauze of Earnshaw's lamp ? — Yes.
That is the regular way ? — Yes; that is the regular way.
The deputies in the district were allowed to do everything that the men are not allowed to do ?
— Yes.
In which direction did you go when you left Eyre's place? How far would it be? — Perhaps six
or seven yards.
Did you pass Earnshaw and Eyre again ? — Yes, I passed Eyre's place.
Were they there then ? — Yes.
What were they doing? — Eyre was filling coal into a corve.
That was the coal which had been blown down by the shot ? — Yes.
And where did you get to after that ? — I got into double three.
Who did you find there? — I found John Godfrey and Philip Stocks, and they had got the rope
under the corves.
What then? — When we had got the corves set going there was a regular rush of wind and dust
down the double three jinny.
Where were you then ? — I should be 20 or 30 yards from the top of the jinny.
Then the rush of air came up the jinny ? — Yes.
Did it put the lamps out ? — No.
Were you standing still or walking then ? — We were standing when it came.
What did you do? — When the air and the dust came up we made for the incline.
Did you go down or up ? — We tried to go up the incline but we could not get up.
Then you went down the jinny, and then came towards the engine plane, or inclined plane, and
you could not get up it ? — Yes.
But you got to it ? — Yes, but we had to turn back and try if we could get up the back travelling
road.
What was it that kept you, was it smoke ? — Yes.
Was it dense ? — Yes; very thick.
Had your lamps gone out then ? — No.
You turned up the jinny did you? — We came a few yards back on the level, and then we tried
again the inclined, or engine plane.
Mr. Rhodes: That is not the same as the back travelling road? — No.
The Coroner: What did you find there? — We found it still as it was. We could not get up; we
could not face it.
You could not get up at all? — No.
What did you do then ? — We stepped back in the level in the siding, and we stayed there a few
seconds, and then the men who were with me left me.
Who were they ? — Stocks and Godfrey.
Which way did they go? — When they left me I believe they tried the travelling road again.
What did you do ? — I stood still a little, until it came very thick and put out my lamp, and I
thought that was a sign that the gas was coming down very fast, and that it was getting to the top
side, where I was. So I thought I should perish certainly if I stopped there, and I could only perish
if I tried to get to the pit bottom; and I made an effort.
Which way did you go ? — Up the engine plane, and I went on my hands and knees. I crawled
in this way to the top of Briggs' siding, and then went along to the pit bottom.
Who did you meet there ? — I was in the dark and so were those who were with me, and I had
been lying down beside two men, who proved to be Joseph Sacker and Samuel Gilbert. I heard a
voice, as it seemed to me, about 12 or 13 yards distant, and it proved to be that of Samuel Gilbert.
As you lay by the side of Joseph Sacker you say you heard a voice; how far distant do you say
it was? — It was 12 or 13 yards higher up the incline.
What was Gilbert doing? — He was lying down, and he called out, and then Sacker, who was
beside me, spoke, and then we asked one another who we were.
Had you any idea where you were? — I knew where I was; near to the mouth of the new drift
What was done when you heard the voices of each other ? — They asked who I was, and I told
them; and then they asked me what was the matter, and I said I could not tell them exactly, although
I thought I knew. They asked what was the right way to go, and I said straight forward. As I
lay beside Sacker he said to me "Oh, it is hot;" and I said, "It is hot lad," and I crawled a bit
further. Then Sacker did not seem willing to go, and I followed after Gilbert and overtook him.
Did Sacker come out then ? — He came out afterwards, but I cannot say when.
Did you stand up or crawl when you started to follow Gilbert ? — I crawled out on my hands
and knees.
How far did you get up to him ? — I believe I was aside of him when we were crossing the level
which runs straight across the incline, that is straight through Briggs' siding to the slant level.
A Juror: What is the name ? — The place is just as I have said. I saw a small fire burning.
The Coroner: Do you mean the coal on fire ? — No ; I think it was a small wood fire, but I
cannot say.
This was at the slant level ? — Between the two inclines.
Mr. Rhodes : Was it in the dip between the two sidings ? — I believe it was.
The Coroner : Then you went on ? — Yes.
How did you get help ? — I did not get help.
Then you went on to the bottom ? — Yes.
Were you able to get fresher air as you went on ? — Yes; it began to get better.
Where did it begin to get better ? Can you tell? — Yes.
Where? Had you any light? — No; but we could feel it.
It gradually got better as you went on ? — Yes.
Did you pass over anybody do you know? — No.
And you got out ? — Yes.
Is it the Barnsley bed which is being worked ? — Yes.
What is the thickness of the seam? — Nearly nine feet I should say.
Do you know the length of the engine plane ? — I do not know exactly, but I should say about
700 yards.
When you got to Earnshaw and Eyre were they ready for firing the shot ? — Earnshaw was the
man in charge.
When you got there was it finished ? — No, it was not finished.
Were they ramming it down or charging it? — Yes.
Who was charging it? — Eyre.
And Earnshaw was superintending it? — Yes.
He was filling the hole with gunpowder and ramming it, I suppose? — They had a cartridge.
They were putting it into the drill hole? — Yes.
Then they simply had to put the cartridge in ? — Yes.
Has the cartridge a fuse to it ? — Yes.
Does it require any ramming ? — Yes.
What do they ram with ? — With a copper rammer.
And after ramming it they put the fuse. How is it applied ? — They put the fuse to the cartridge.
It is there to begin with ? — Yes.
Do you know where the cartridges are made ? Are they bought ready made ? — They make them
at home.
You mean the men make them at their own houses ? — Yes.
Do they fill the cases at home as well as make them? — They make the cases at home, and I believe
they fill them too.
How is the fuse attached, and when ; before they bring them or at the pit ? — Before they come.
They are all filled, as far as you know, before they are brought into the pit? — Yes.
You have not any loose powder to blast with ? — I have seen the drifters use powder.
Mr. Maule : Did the men carry the cartridges in tin cans? — Yes.
Not simply in paper, under their arms ? — No; it is not my duty to superintend the firing of the
shots unless I have a district, and when I go round with a deputy as well.
In the slant drift level were shots fired, do you know ? — When, sir ?
At any time you know ? — Oh, yes.
They blast it there by shot fire? — Yes, I have seen shots fired in that part of the mine.
The Coroner: How long since ? — It will be 12 months since. After the blower of gas in 1874, the
men have always been withdrawn from the workings before blasting.
Mr. Maule: Did the gas explode ? — No, I put it out.
Did it ignite? — Yes.
And I suppose that was a sort of warning that it would not do to be shot firing with the men in the
workings? — Our duty was always to deliver in our statements on returning, to James Allen, and he
told us what to do. I told him what had occurred, and then he told me to cease firing shots.
I think you have told us that there was no more shot firing whilst the men were in the workings? —
None in the slant drift level until the men were withdrawn.
Is there any particular time in the day for the men to be withdrawn before shot firing takes place ?
— No.
Before the shot firing took place in the slant drift level were the men withdrawn ? — Yes. I have
often waited at the top or bottom of the drift with Jacques until the men had got out, and then we
would charge the hole.
When this blower of gas was reported, it entirely altered the plan of shot firing, and after June it
only took place in the slant drift level when the men were withdrawn? — Yes; during the last six
months I do not know of any fired except in this way.
How do they work the coal then ? — By wedging it.
Then it has only been wedged for the last six months? — Yes.
The fact is that six months ago you won the coal by shot firing; when the men were out, of course?
— Yes, at one place.
No cartridges are used in the south drift level ? — None at all.
After a short adjournment the examination of the witness was continued, and he produced No. 72
deputy lamp, which had been used by Earnshaw to fire a shot on the morning of the explosion. In
cross-examination by Mr. Hopwood, he said it was practically impossible to heat a wire by pushing it
through the gauze of an ordinary miner's lamp, whilst it was quite possible, and was usually done,
with a deputy's lamp in firing a shot. If a man's lamp went out he could light it at a station for that
purpose, and there was one at the slant end. A boy was appointed to stand at the pit top with the
powder required, and the lampman had control of it. He had seen the men carry powder and
cartridges in tin canisters.
Mr. Hopwood : You could not see the powder in the cartridges? — No; nor in the canisters either.
(Laughter).
Mr. Hopwood: I am rather used to this sort of thing, you know.
Witness: Perhaps I shall get used to it before very long.
In answer to further questions witness said that the men sometimes carried one pound of powder in
their canisters, but never four or five.
Mr. Hopwood: Have you heard that since the explosion canisters containing five pounds of powder
have been found in the pit? — No.
By Mr. Mellor: Earnshaw was an experienced man, and had been an underviewer about four
years. Earnshaw went to the hole after the shot had been fired and found the air pure. He could
not tell how much powder was used by the drifters in blasting. The quantity was usually left to their
own judgment.
Mr. W. Rayne, a clerk at the colliery, produced the report books of the deputies; and Robert
Schofield, collier, Worsborough Dale, said that he had the charge of the air-ways and ventilation of
the mine, and inspected them on the Saturday preceding the explosion, when he found them all right.
On the afternoon of the following Monday, hearing of the explosion, he went down the mine in
company with other explorers. When he arrived at the bottom he helped to clear away some corves
which had become entangled with one of the cages in the drawing shaft. A man named Sheldon
accompanied witness down the engine plane. There they met Peter Jenkins, whom witness brought
back. Sheldon went on down the plane and returned with some men. They then came out of the
pit, but shortly afterwards descended again, along with Mr. Millor, of Strafford Main. They found
all the doors blown, and evidences everywhere of the force of the explosion. Yesterday (Wednesday)
he went down the pit, and a man named Bostock gave him some gunpowder in a tin canister, which
would contain about 2 lbs. This was at the bottom of the drawing shaft; and witness took the
powder to the magazine.
Mr. Mellor: Did Bostock tell you where he got the powder from? — Yes; he said from No. 8, fargate,
on the slant drift level.
The Court then, after sitting for 10 hours, adjourned at 8.40 to this morning.