Brynn Hall Colliery Accident
Extracted from the Annual Mines Inspectors Report for 1873
Report of Thomas Bell (page 267)
Explosions of Fire-damp.
Accident No. 40 on Schedule.
This explosion took place in the "Wigan 9 ft. seam" at the Brynn Hall Colliery,
near Wigan, belonging to Wm. Crippin, Esq., on the night of the 30th May last,
causing the deaths of five men employed as "shot lighters," and one furnaceman. The
mine lies 178 yards below the surface, and gives off a large quantity of gas. There is
one downcast pit 11' 3" diameter, and one upcast 12 feet diameter; the system of
ventilation is rarefaction by furnace, which was fed with fresh air direct from the downcast
pit. The colliery is worked on the "pillar and stall" system, generally adopted in the
Wigan District, and as the coal is of a very hard nature, powder has to be used in large
quantities, consequent on a system lately introduced into the district of blowing the coal
after being holed on the top without side cutting, as many as three shots being required
in each place of 10 feet in width.
It has been the practice at this colliery for the last three years to fire shots only
during the night when the men ordinarily employed are absent from the mine, and by a
staff of men organised for that purpose with instructions to carefully examine the places
before each shot is fired, yet, notwithstanding this precaution, a serious explosion took
place causing the deaths of every person in the mine at that time, and doing fearful
damage to the workings and machinery. Exploring parties were organised as soon as
possible, but their progress was materially interrupted by the discovery of different parts
of the workings being on fire, causing very great danger of another explosion, and it was
not until late the following day that the workings had been examined, and the bodies
recovered.
It transpired at the inquiry that there had been a violation of the 8th General Rule
of the Coal Mines Regulation Act, 1872, by these workmen having more than 4 lbs.
of powder in their possession in the mine at one time; there were six men regularly
employed to discharge the duties of "shot lighters" (one being absent on the night of
the accident), and they must necessarily have more than 4 lbs. of powder each to charge
and fire over 170 holes during the shift; the work they had to perform requiring about
20 lbs. for each man, but instead of taking it down in 4 lb. canisters, and opening only one
of them at a time, they took it down in tins containing about 25 lbs. each.
I now beg leave to append the evidence of the principal witnesses given at the Inquest
held on the bodies, at which Mr. Dickinson, H.M. Inspector for the Manchester District,
attended; also, Mr. Ellis, of Wigan, appeared on behalf of Mr. Crippin, and Mr. Pickard
represented the Miners' Association.
Mr. Josh. Dickinson, Inspector of Mines, said "On the 11th instant, accompanied by
Mr. F. Crippin and others, I made an inspection of the workings in which the explosion
occurred in the Nine Feet Mine. The conclusion at which I arrived was that the
explosion had been a general one. There has been fire at the far ends of the north levels,
and down the workings on the dip on the same side, and there has been a general blast
out backwards towards the pit from those extremities. That has probably been one
explosion. On the south side the extremities in the left hand workings show similar
traces of fire, and also those places in the extremities on the right hand workings, in
most of the places which have been bratticed : and the explosion on the south side has
probably been distinct from that on the north. Round these workings there are scarcely
two lengths of working tramway left in their places. We also saw three or four 25 lbs.
powder cans, all of which were empty. You will find that having 25 lbs. cans is contrary
to the Act of Parliament, one of the regulations being that powder shall not be taken
into the mine except in a case or canister not containing more than 4 lbs. There is
not to be more than one of these in use at one time by one man. A workman is not
prohibited from having two or three canisters, but he must not have more than one in
use at one time. The practice in this mine is to make the cartridges at the place where
the shot is being fired instead of taking the powder into the mine in cartridges. The
powder only formed a very trifling part of the explosive matter in this mine. It had
been chiefly fire-damp. The shot lighters had apparently been firing the shots in the
best way. It was a point to be ascertained whether two or three shots had been fired
together in one place. They must consider what time the shot lighters would have
to charge each shot singly, fire it, and then return again to see whether gas had been
given off by the shot, and then to prepare second and third shots under similar circumstances
in rotation. Perhaps the most important point that should be cleared up was,
how with a mine giving off so much gas as this, so many working places were opened at
once which were dependent on brattice, that they ran too great risk, and were at any
time exposed to an explosion. It was to the great number of workings and brattice
places that I consider the explosion was chiefly due. Both Mr. Higson, junior, and
Mr. F. Crippin, manager, must have taken very great care to carry on the mine to the
extent they had done without this setting in sooner.
The mine was worked on what might be called the North of England system, a system
of which he did not approve for a fiery mine of this description. He thought the first
explosion had occurred at or about the extremity of No. 2 north level. That explosion
disarranged the dumb drift of the furnace, and so gave access for the return air from the
south workings to get to the dumb drift and hence the second explosion on the south
side. He believed there had been a steady discharge of gas from the working places,
but did not think there had been any peculiar outburst. The blowing out of one of the
shots could never account for the wide spread explosion extending all round the south
side, unless it was the centre shot in the place (John Hill's) in question, he did not
himself see any indications of a blown out shot throughout the workings. As was
testified by the colliery records, gas had been met with a little time before the explosion
in some of the south levels.
In answer to Mr. Pickard, witness said that it was scarcely likely that the first
explosion on the north side, would traverse the intake to the south side. He had no
doubt that the force of the blast on the north side would travel to the south and do
some damage, and believed it disabled the three men on the south side; did not think
that there was a single part of the pit that would not feel the effects of the first blast
on the north, it had been so serious ; did not think it safe to fire the shots either in the
night or day, under that quantity of brattice and the number of places.
James Hill said "he was principal fireman on the north side in the Nine Feet Mine.
Had been frequently through the whole of the north and part of the south workings
since he was last before the jury; could not tell where the chief explosion had been,
thought it seemed to have been all over the mine; in his judgment the second explosion
occurred about 12 minutes after the first; the second came up the upcast, but he saw
nothing from the downcast; having seen the damage done by the explosion, thought
it resulted from gas, but the powder tins might account for a portion of it. When he
went round in a morning he usually found three or four places giving off a little gas,
and reported them, and entries were made in the book produced. He reported one
on the main north level, in the last place where shots were fired on the morning of the
explosion. Found four places in all where gas was given off, all of which were bratticed.
Noticed the ventilation several times that day, and it seemed to be very good and
plentiful. When the gas is found blue it explodes in the lamp. The main north level
gives off a little gas generally. Has sometimes gone shot lighting himself, when he has
taken two cans of 20 lbs. each for two of them. Charged all the shots in a place and
then fired one at a time."
By Mr. Bell. "Had occasionally heard two or three going off together, but had never
reported it to the underlooker or manager. Never knew any one to take down brattice
in order to fire shots, but some might be knocked down by the firing; if that occurred
it was re-adjusted before the next shot was fired."
By the Coroner. Had known a shot to contain 1 lb. or 2 lbs. of powder, the quantity
varying according to the size of the coal and position of the place, and the shot holes to
vary from 3 feet 5 inches to 6 feet. They would require more strength if they could
only take 4 lbs. of powder down at once and that in cartridges.
Mr. Pickard said "as regards cartridges, I may say, that the Home Office asked for
my opinion, and I sent it down along with the opinion of 12 other competent men of the
Wigan District, saying it would be much better to allow the men to use loose powder
rather than cartridges. I believe more accidents will occur from the cartridges than
from loose powder." In answer to Mr. Pickard, witness said "he had found gas in his
brother John's place on the brow and the level pretty frequently ; had been a fireman
at Rose Bridge Colliery for 10 years ; considered that the shot holes in his brother's place
were planted right; had found that both the side shots had been fired, but did not think
the middle shot had been charged. The coal had been blown about 12 yards, and he
thought it had blown the brattice down ; that the higher and lower side shots had been
fired about the same time, and that the higher side shot had disarranged the brattice and
ignited the gas given off there. Gorton and Helden were as good men as he could wish
to travel with ; believed the explosion started in his brother's place, and extended to the
south."
Henry Hodson, Joseph Arkwright, and Henry Waterworth, gave similar evidence.
John Hill, collier, said "his place was an opening driving up-brow out of No. 2 level
on the north side of the workings ; left the place a little before 3 p.m. on the 30th ult.
ready for the shot lighters, three holes being drilled; was satisfied with them as being
right for blowing. On account of a slip tried the place that day for gas, but there was
no trace observable; had found gas given off at other slips in the place on some
previous occasions ; should be surprised to hear that the fire had begun in his place,
for he had never seen so much gas there at one time that would cause an explosion.
There was plenty of air, the brattice being about six feet back from the face when he
left, and in good order. The shot lighters had never left a hole uncharged or shot
unfired in his place. Was not aware that two shots had been fired at once in one
place."
John Heaton said "he was a brattice man at Brynn Hall Colliery, and his work was
chiefly in the north side of the south workings. He was working there until nearly
three o'clock on the afternoon of the day of the explosion. The only gas he met with
that day was a small "blower" on the second down brow, No. 5 lower level, on the
north side of the brow. When he got the brattice up the gas there disappeared. There
was always plenty of air, and more could be put on at any time. Had been through
all the workings since the explosion, and believed the beginning of the explosion was in
No. 2 level (John Hill's), in a cut through on the north side. The left hand shot seemed
to have been too much in the "fast," and the right hand shot had only cracked up the
coal. He could not say how the explosion had been brought about; had fired shots
in the mine for about eight months; had never fired two shots at once in a bratticed
place, but had done so in an open place, but even then the head shot-firer found fault
with them. When he was shot-firing they always made an examination three or four
yards from the face along the brattice, between each shot. A shot properly charged
would not blow out its ramming. Did not think the shot lighters had got into the
practice of firing two shots together. John Hill's cut through was not a place where
witness would fire two shots together. If he thought there was a hole on the "fast" he
used to leave it, and it was reported to the underlooker. It would take witness from
a quarter to half an hour to examine the place, charge, and fire three shots. Had only
63 shots to fire on the night of the explosion, and there had been as many as 123.
Witness used to keep the brattice about six feet from the face, but put it nearer if gas
was being made. He always found the furnace to have as good, if not a better fire
during the night as in the day time."
William Hermon, furnace tenter at Brynn Hall pit, said "he was on the day shift at
the time of the explosion. Isaac John Johns (killed in the explosion) being on the
night shift. Johns was sober and all right when witness left him, and the furnace was
perfectly safe. They fired the furnace very hard when the shots were being fired."
John Sixsmith, underlooker, said "he had charge of the operations for clearing up
and re-ventilating, and had been through all the workings from end to end. He thought
the explosion had commenced in John Hill's place on the north side, and took it for
granted that the gas had been ignited by one or more of the shots there. The bodies
of the shot lighters Hodson and Holden were found in the next opening along the level
on the lower side. They were the only shot lighters on that side, the other three being
in the south workings. He thought that where Hodson and Holden were found was
the most likely place for them to go to while the last shots were being fired. They had
locked lamps. The left hand hole in John Hill's place appeared to have been bored about
six inches into the solid, and it was now after firing left 12 inches deep. The middle
hole was 3 feet 8 inches deep. That hole and the right hand hole were cut out
together on Tuesday. The right hand hole had been fired and had cut along the side.
Its depth was about the same as that of the middle hole. Of the middle hole, the coal
behind for 2 feet 4 inches of its length was undisturbed, and 1 foot 4 inches to
the front was left not thrown off, but cracked considerably upwards and downwards,
there being no coal blown off with the exception of a little on the top. On examining
this hole I found immediately beneath it a small piece of cartridge paper. Had always
held the opinion that the hole had been fired, but not until Saturday did he find the
piece of cartridge. He believed the cracking about the middle hole had been from the
right hand shot and not from its own powder, it had been a clean blown out shot.
Witness concluded that the left hand shot had been fired first, then, if both the middle
and right hand shots had been charged, the middle one had been fired next, and not
doing its work they had fired the other one, and that also had failed to do its work. It
was a positive rule in the pit, understood by every shot lighter that two shots should
not be fired together in a bratticed place, and John Hill's place was one of the most
unlikely spots in the workings for the firing of two shots simultaneously. Witness said
he had been about three months at Brynn Hall, and had been an underlooker for 10
years previously. Has only seen gas in the working places twice, and then only after
being reported to him. Has had reports from the shot lighters and fireman about gas.
They were bound to report every thing they found."
By Mr. Dickinson. "If the reports had said nothing about gas I should have disputed
the firemen's word. We have not more than 40 places going daily.
Mr. John Higson, mining engineer, Manchester, and viewer at several collieries in the
Wigan District, said "he had been through the whole of the workings on both sides.
He found the direction of the explosion or explosions bad been on the north side in the
main upwards, and in the south side, downwards. In his opinion the commencing point
of the original explosion was John Hill's place. He believed that gas had accumulated
in that place, and had there been fired; that the blast had rushed towards the downcast,
and not finding sufficient exit had swept down the south side, breaking down the overcast
there, and unquestionably deranging the whole ventilation on that side. The gas in
this mine was in many cases contained in pockets or fissures, which could not be drained
until the holing or the shots penetrated them. With regard to the undamaged box or
tub which Mr. Greenwell spoke of, witness said his experience was that the point of
explosion was always the point where the least damage was done. He believed the
whole of the route which the expanding gas took to the downcast shaft was one mass of
flame, and that this in various parts of the north workings set fire to the brattice cloth,
some of which he extinguished himself. Witness believed that after the first explosion
John Hill's place fouled again to a point where there was some burning material, and
that the gas again ignited, and so the second explosion was caused. He did not think
that any explosion had commenced in the south district. From his experience of this
class of men he preferred to think that two shots had been lighted together, rather than
that they omitted to refix the brattice after the first shot was fired."
In reply to Mr. Ellis, witness said "he did not think the system of working the mine
had at all contributed to the explosion, though 60,000 feet of air per minute, was amply
sufficient for the mine." By Mr. Dickinson, witness "believed that everything that
discipline in management and skill in applying it could do, had been done in the
interests of the general safety of the mine." Witness knew of mines quite as fiery as
this one, where they had five or six times as much brattice as they had on the north side
in these workings.
Mr. George C. Greenwell, of Poynton, Cheshire, mining engineer, in charge of Lord Vernon's
collieries, said "he made an inspection of Brynn Hall Colliery on June 17th
by request of the proprietor. He found very little gas indeed. One place where he
found it was where a man named Sharrocks worked. He did not believe that the explosion
occurred in John Hill's place, if it had done, a tub which he found on the level then
undamaged, and which he was informed was there at the time of the explosion, would have
been smashed. The tub was merely lifted off the rails. Thought the explosion first
occurred in Sharrock's place, No. 2 level, because there was gas there now, and generally
from the force of the blast. He examined the dust on the roof in different places, it
having been pointed out to him as having been burned. His experience of explosions
was, that dust which had been subjected to the blast of an explosion, and not a mere
flame up to the root, had invariably become charred. From the general appearances he
came to the conclusion that there had been a heavy fire from a sharp explosive gas, a
small quantity sufficing to produce a heavy explosion. He arrived at a conclusion on
the spot that two shots had been fired together in Sharrock's place, that the first one
had liberated gas which had been exploded by the second. Witness assumed that Hill's
shots had been fired out of order. The explosion first occurring would itself in passing
be the means of exhausting gas from the coal. Witness also inspected the north side
workings of the south district. He examined nearly the whole of the faces and did not
find gas anywhere, but the brattice was at that time restored. He believed that the
force of the first explosion had proceeded past the pit, and for a distance down the south
workings, then recoiling up the pit and so producing a vacuum in the back south
workings, itself causing much of the effects shown, the destruction being without fire.
Witness did not think that too many working places under brattice had been carried on
in this pit, he had been at much more fiery pits in the north of England, where there
were more working places. With regard to shot lighting, the regulations appeared to
have been framed with the strictest regard to safety. In the getting of the coal in this
mine, almost wholly by powder, witness did not concur. He considered that the coal
ought to be cut, which was simply a matter of cost. He considered 60,000 feet of air
per minute ample ventilation for this mine.
Mr. Frederick Crippin, certificated manager at Brynn Hall Colliery, and son of the
proprietor said "he thought the seat of the first explosion was in John Hill's upbrow
place. Three shots had been prepared there and had been fired. He considered the
left hand side shot had been drilled too much into the "fast," and it resulted in a
partially blown out shot, a hole being left twelve inches deep, of which six inches was in
the "fast." The firing of the middle hole had done no work whatever, not even cracked
its own coal. The right hand shot had only blown part of the shot away. This shot
had been overtasked, owing to the failure of the middle shot previously. He thought
the brattice had been carelessly replaced, and though he brought the accusation against
the men deceased, he thought that the middle and lower side shots had been fired at the
same time. It was the men's distinct instructions and duty to examine the places both
above and below between each firing, notwithstanding anything stated by witnesses at
previous sittings as to the practice. The centre shot and one of the others would probably
explode simultaneously, and it was most likely that the gas was ignited by the latter
shots. Witness was of opinion that there might have been sufficient gas formed in the
upbrow place to account for the first explosion, and that the explosions were not
attributable to any defect in the arrangements for working the colliery, but was inclined
to think they arose entirely from oversight or neglect on the part of the men themselves.
The present system of shot firing had been in existence since the last explosion, now
nearly three years since. Believing that the new Act did not contemplate dealing with
such operations as those at this colliery. Witness consulted the viewer, Mr. Peter Higson, junr.,
and after that consultation witness considered he was justified in going on
with the powder, &c. in the way they were doing, leaving Mr. Higson to see the
inspectors on the subject.
Ninety-nine out of every hundred underlookers were not as competent for this work
as was Gorton, the head shot lighter. The number of shot lighters was ample. They
had 117 shots to fire on the night of the explosion, and witness considered that the
five deceased shot lighters could fire these shots and have time to spare. There was no
inducement for them to hurry at all, for the longer they were down the more they were
paid. Witness contended that there was not an extraordinary number of working places
under brattice, considering the area. There were 24 places containing 350 yards of
brattice on the north side; 14 places containing 266 yards of brattice on the north side
of the south brow ; 25 places containing 368 yards of brattice on the south side of the
south brow; total number of places 63, containing 984 yards of brattice." By Mr. Pickard.
"I have never heard a suggestion on the part of the men for the cutting of the openings
more frequently. I believe the supply of air has been abundant."
Mr. Peter Higson, junr., of Manchester, mining engineer said, "he was viewer at
Brynn Hall Colliery, having had charge for about nine months. The opening out of the
mine there generally, and the methods of getting the coal and blasting, were in accordance
with his advice. Just a week before the explosion, witness had his attention called by
the fireman, James Hill, to the fact that gas was giving off rather freely in John Hill's
place. Having carefully examined the pit three times, the only conclusion he could
come to was, that the explosion occurred in John Hill's place. The only inference he
could draw with regard to the three shots there, was that the fuses of the centre and
the right hand shot had been lit at once. He was of opinion that, without any great
disarrangement of brattice either above or below, if the middle shot were to explode
partially blown a minute or two before, it would create such a vacuum as to suck out
gas, and the second shot would set fire to the gas that might be lodging in the holing on
the top. The men had not acted wisely in firing the left hand shot, at all events from the
back of the hole, which they had done. It was very likely the men, after the first shot
failed to do its work thoroughly, might have been tempted to fire the other two shots
together, thinking to do thereby what the single shot had failed in. He was aware of
the manner in which the powder was taken down the mine, but not of the exact weight.
The present system was adopted after the previous explosion three years ago. It was
also thought it would prove a far safer method of working the mine, the powder being
only placed in skilful hands. Witness attention was called to the new Act with reference
to the practice by Mr. F. Crippin, on December 23rd last. He consulted Mr. Peter Higson,
senior, Inspector of the District. At that time the Act had not come into
operation, and Mr. Higson's opinion was that the provisions of the Act did not apply to
special instances, such as the present and some other mines in the district. On the day
following, December 24th, witness and Mr. Caldwell, of Low Hall Colliery, jointly
consulted Mr. Higson on this point, and they understood he was to write to the Home
Secretary, explaining the peculiar circumstances of Brynn Hall and similar pits. Witness
heard of no result officially, and no order has been given for the discontinuance of the
practice in question. The ventilation of the pit was all that he could wish for. To
conform with the Act of Parliament and carry out the 4 lbs. canister of powder rule, he
thought they should require some 30 men for the work, and that being the case, they
might almost as well carry out the shot firing in the day time. He found, with the
exception of John Hill's place, that all the shots fired that night had done their work."
By Mr. Bell. Witness said, "this colliery had shown a peculiarity, that the most gas
was always found in the works in the dip, not in the rise. He did not think that any
ignition of passing gases would have occurred by means of the furnace. In some cases
he considered powder in cartridges was not so safe or effective as the same quantity fired
loose. The firing of two shots together was distinctly contrary to directions he had
given himself.
Mr. Thomas Bell, of Worsley, near Manchester, said he was Assistant Inspector of
Mines for the district, and owing to the illness of Mr. Higson, senior, was at present in
principal charge. He had been through the workings of Brynn Hall Pit, and was of
opinion that the explosion had occurred in the first instance in John Hill's place. He
thought that the left hand shot being heavily charged, had disarranged the brattice in
Sharrock's (adjoining) place, as well as its own; that before firing the next shot or shots,
Sharrock's place had not been examined, and that there would be an accumulation of gas
which would be given off there. Probably, gas had been given off also in Hill's place by
the first shot, and he believed the two remaining shots had been fired together, the
middle shot having probably gone off first and released some gas, which would be
ignited by the third shot; and the gas in Sharrock's place being also communicated with,
that would account for the first explosion, the effects of which, he believed, killed all
the men, and disarranged the ventilation throughout the pit. The vacuum caused by
this explosion would draw off gas from all new surfaces, and the gas so accumulating
would form a magazine for the second explosion, and this perhaps in both districts. He
believed that there had been fire in every working place throughout both the north and
south sides. Of such fire, he found distinct proof in some of the extreme south places.
The first shot in Hill's place had been badly planted, and ought not to have been charged
and fired from the back. He thought the second shot should not have been fired subsequently,
placed as it was, and the third shot could not be fired until after the second
with any effect. This might possibly have been the temptation to light both shots at
once. The laying out of the pit had been systematic, and witness had no reason to find
fault with the application of the system. The number of working places had been great
for the opening out of a fiery mine. He would have preferred driving out fewer levels,
but was met by the evidence that this particular mine could not be so drained. If so,
there was nothing for it but to drive forward as slowly as possible. The getting of the
coal by powder without cutting, was new to him in this district, in which he had only
been a short time. He thought it would be much better to side cut it. He was informed
of the difficulties in the way of adopting this plan. His opinion was that it might be
worked on the "long wall" system, which was in use in the district, but not in this
seam that he knew of. He had not inspected the mine previous to the explosion. Was
aware of the shot lighting at night and approved of it; he thought machinery might be
used to advantage in holing."
By Mr. Pickard, "witness scarcely thought it possible for a flame from the furnace
to reach into the shaft, a distance of from 50 to 60 yards. It was very undesirable to
charge three shots in a place together, notwithstanding the difficulty to be met with
in doing otherwise."
Mr. Christopher Fisher Clark, of Garswood, said "he was mining engineer to
Sir Robert Gerard, who was lessor of these mines. He had examined the mine on
three or four occasions since the explosion. Had a knowledge of this seam back to
the time of the previous explosion, and he came to the conclusion that, so long as the
present mode of getting coal was pursued, using large quantities of powder instead of
cutting it, they would be subject to explosions. He thought the coal should be cut
notwithstanding the extra expenditure it would involve, which he did not look upon
as an insurmountable difficulty. He believed that seven or eight explosions, those
at Haydock, Highbrooks, Moss Pits, and Low Hall among the number, had occurred
in this district from the same cause, heavy charges of gunpowder, invariably from blown
out shots. Probably the chief difficulty would be in inducing the men to do it at the
present time. The present mode of working was an innovation which had crept into the
district, and was contrary to the old and recognised mode of getting coal, and every
means ought to be taken to put a stop to it. He would substitute for it in this instance,
either the "long wall" system, or by driving a series of levels, and cutting them every
hundred yards into square blocks, and he thought this system would effectually drain off
the gas. That system would be applicable to this mine now worked so far as it was on
the other or narrow system. He would drive out the levels by holing and cutting, and
using small shots of ½lb. or less. He believed two shots had been lighted together
in John Hill's place, which he considered the seat of the explosion, that when the middle
(second) shot was blown out, gas would be given off from the sides and face almost like
steam from a boiler, and the gas would be ignited by a third shot. Gas was already
exuding in this place, with the pressure of the atmosphere against it, and on the removal
of that pressure, witness believed it would come out with a rush, and sufficient gas would
be at once found to account for the first explosion. The effects of a 2 lbs. blown out
shot would be 16 times that of a small ½lb blown out shot."
The coroner having summed up, the jury after three quarters of an hour's deliberation,
returned the following verdict. "That the deceased, Isaac John Johns, and five others,
were killed within the workings of a certain coal mine by an explosion of fire-damp in the
same, occurring on the night of May 30th 1873. That the explosion commenced in
John Hill's upbrow place, in which certain shots were found to have been fired, and that
they consider the shot lighters to have been remiss in their duty in connexion with the
firing of these shots; the said shot lighters being now deceased, and the jurors make
certain recommendations to be appended to their finding as above."
Recommendations.
The jury agree with the recommendation of Mr. Clark as to the mode of getting this
mine in future, if the owners can get the work so done. They recommend that there
should be more air-splittings so as to supply fresh air to the various districts, and to
reduce the number of doors in the mine. They think that two shot lighters should not
have charge of more than twelve working places, and that there should be a man
appointed for each of the two existing districts, whose sole duty should be, to examine
the air before and during the shot firing. That between the engine and the furnace there
should be two doors in place of the present brattice cloth. As well as that the returns
ought all to be taken into a dumb drift and so into the upcast pit above the furnace
drift.