Cwm Tillery Colliery Disaster
Extracted from the Annual Mines Inspectors Report for 1873
Report of Lionel Brough (page 81)
The lists and recapitulations are all so clear that it is not necessary that every
accident should undergo separate notice. But a few amongst them, both fatal and
non-fatal, must be commented on, in order that those who chance to read the Inspector's
Reports may, if they like, learn how to avoid a repetition of disaster. I will commence
with the leading and most conspicuous calamity of the year, although it is not the
earliest in its date, but then explosion of fire-damp always takes the lead. It occurred
on the 5th of April 1873 in a colliery in Cwm Tillery belonging to the "South Wales
Company, Limited."
I believe the abstract of evidence which now follows, given before the coroner and his
jury at Abertillery on the last day of sitting (the 14th of May), will be sufficient to
make it understood, for the case itself is clear enough, although it occupied six days in
its investigation.
"I am Her Majesty's Inspector of Mines of the south-western division of the
kingdom. On the 10th April I inspected the South Wales Colliery Company's pit at
Cwmtillery. Messrs. Wallace, Brown, and others were with me on that occasion.
It will be well before I proceed to give evidence, to state that nearly three years ago
Mr. Wallace and myself contrived a method of ventilation by means of a third pit to
greatly increase the quantity of air in this colliery, and this improvement was carried
out, so that it cannot be said that the safety of the workmen has been neglected by
any person now concerned in the investigation of the great disaster that took place on
the fifth day of the month of April of last year. In fact, the alteration I allude
to became a great success.
"When I effected my inspection shortly after the explosion (I then being ordered by
the Secretary of State to visit some copper mines in the west of England), I convinced
myself that it had occurred in consequence of certain sheets having been left down,
just, in fact, as if frame doors had been left wide open, for these canvas sheets were
just as much doors as if they had been constructed of wood and fitted with iron
hinges. If, when the deceased persons had resumed their labour after partaking of
their supper, or whatever meal the refreshment may be called, and had had their sleep,
they had discovered gas and had put up the sheets and so restored the ventilation
to its normal and proper state, it is inevitable that that very restoration would have
brought the fire-damp right on to them, and they at the time being at work with
naked lights, nothing could have prevented the explosion. But the more immediate
bringing about of the calamity in my opinion was that after their supper and their
sleep the men walked with their unprotected lights right into the explosive mixture,
not remembering that the sheets had been left down.
"My deliberate belief is that it is altogether impossible that this accumulation of gas
could have taken place if these canvas doors had been properly closed.
"If the coal excavated on the other side of the gob had been passed under the sheets
and afterwards lifted into the trams, there would have been but the merest shadow of
suspicion of the ventilation, because the temporary displacement of a superficial foot
or two of sheet could be no appreciable check. Imponderable as atmospheric air is
sometimes erroneously regarded, a travelling column of it is still a mass of matter
possessing weight and obeying all the physical laws which govern motion; it could
not bring itself into an entire state of rest by the momentary uplifting of the bottom
of the canvas doors, that is not to be thought of at all.
"Another mode might be considered, but I disbelieve in it altogether. It is this, a
sudden outburst of gas, but though I sought for evidence thereof I could not find a
trace of any such occurrence, indeed it is my firm belief that no "blower" had
suddenly come off any one of the faces of coal in that part of the pit. I repeat the
conviction in my mind, that the sheets were down for some considerable time and so
cut off the passages of air to the far end, and that this happened during the repose of
the men. During all that time the carburetted hydrogen had slowly and silently
eliminated itself from the fresh face, and by admixture with its atomic dose of
atmospheric air had become quite as dangerous a compound as a barrel of gunpowder,
or more so. The end in that very small bit of work, was death to all but a man and a
boy. As far as my knowledge goes there can be no other explanation of all this
lamentable loss of life than the one I now offer. If the doors had been closed there
was wind enough to sweep away and render harmless all the gas that could possibly
threaten the men then employed in this division of the colliery."
There was abundant air in this bit of work, which was entirely new, and canvas
sheets were temporarily used. However, they were quite as good and effective as deal
brattice boards, and if they had not been tampered with by the men themselves, in order
to spare their labour a little, this explosion would never have taken place. The only
thing that can be charged against the management was a want of discipline in not
putting a stop to the reprehensible practice of men sleeping during their shift, every one
of them retired together at the same time into a stall for that very purpose, where, in all
probability, they slept an hour and perhaps a good deal more.