Renishaw Park Colliery Disaster
Extracted from the Annual Mines Inspectors Report for 1871
Report of Thomas Evans (page 76)
Accident No. 4 in the Schedule
was an explosion of gas, and took place in the "Blackshale" workings at Renishaw
Park Colliery, belonging to Messrs. J. and G. Wells, on Tuesday, January 10th.
On the evening of this day, some men were engaged in the main intake airway,
No. 1 pit, blasting down the roof to make sufficient height for the horses to go
into the workings. Other men were at different parts of the pits (No. 1 and
No. 2) repairing the roads, and a few also were getting coal. There are two shafts
sunk to the Blackshale coal, one on the low level, which is the downcast, and the
other about 600 yards to the rise, which is the upcast. The air is split at the
bottom of the downcast, one portion going north and the other south. The latter
passes along the level, where the explosion occurred, to the boundary, up an incline
to the working faces, along the faces to the north side of the upcast into the low
level of No. 2 pit, along the low level southward again to the boundary, up the
farthest gate road to the face, back along these faces to a point opposite the upcast
where it meets the north return and thence to the upcast. If the ventilation of
this colliery had been properly distributed a large proportion of the 26 lives lost
would have been spared even if the explosion had taken place, but it is quite probable
that it would not have occurred at all under those circumstances. No. 2 pit should
have had a distinct split of air taken straight from the bottom of the downcast and this
should have been split again on reaching No. 2 pit workings. Had this been the case
the explosion in No. 1 could not have affected the men in No. 2, whereas, as it was,
many of them were suffocated. The most simple principles of ventilation appear not to
have been understood or, if understood, were not carried out. With reference to the
former ventilation of this colliery, I beg respectfully to refer you to my Report for the
year 1865 in which, while commenting on a small explosion in that year, I said that I
had frequently pointed out the necessity of an alteration in the system of ventilation, and
had also complained of the want of discipline underground.
I append to this report a copy of the most important evidence taken at the inquest,
and a copy of the plan of the colliery, and would here remark that the manager admitted
in his examination that he seldom went into the mines, but left the distribution of the
air and the safety of those employed to the care and judgment of the underviewer,
Samuel Hardwick, a respectable working man, who, however, in his evidence told the
jury, "I manage the distribution of the air. I have not full control to drive airways
or do all that is necessary for the ventilation of the colliery."
Hardwick is assisted by his brother, a deputy, who keeps a public house not far from
the works. The furnace man, William Barker, stated in his evidence that he did not go
to his work that night, alleging that he was not well enough, but he admitted that he
had been at the deputy's house (the Rose and Crown) drinking beer.
The following is the principal part of the evidence taken before C. S. B. Busby, Esq.,
one of the coroners for the county of Derby :—
Mr. Joseph Wells said : "I live at Eckington, and am one of the proprietors of the
colliery where the accident happened. They are called No. 1 and No. 2 Silkstone pits —
Renishaw Park Colliery, in the parish of Eckington. The plan on the wall shows that
part of the workings where the men were found. The rules produced are those of the
colliery. They were not fiery pits. They are under the rules of fiery pits. They are
wholly worked with lamps. Samuel Hardwick is the underground steward who superintends
the colliery. Francis Clarke, who is dead, was deputy in the night time, and
Thomas Hardwick was deputy in the day time, of the part of No. 1 pit affected by the
accident. Thomas Hutchby was night deputy on the north side of No. 2 pit, and John
Hardwick on the south side. About 400 worked in the two pits in the day time. There
were 77 in that night. I can't say exactly when I was last in the pit. I don't go through
the pits regularly. That is Samuel Hardwick's department. I think it was in November
when I was in No. 1 pit. I can't recollect when I was in No. 2 pit."
By Mr. Evans : "The lamps are locked. We have one lamp-man for the night and
another for the day, William Keeton and John Brunt. They take their duties
alternately. Brunt is not the regular lamp-man. He was only engaged temporarily. Keeton
was on duty on the night of the explosion. It is his duty to lock the lamps before they
go into the pit. The men who blow have each two lamps, a glass lamp and a Davy
lamp, all the other men have only one lamp each. We have 'Georgy' lamps and Davy
lamps. The shot-firers have Davy lamps. The men have principally the 'clanny'
lamp (a glass lamp). Joseph Hardwick and Francis Clarke have each a key. If men's
lamps go out they have to go to the deputies who light them at the bottom of the shaft.
(Witness then proceeded to describe the ventilation.) The air in down-cast shaft No. 1
is divided into two courses, part going to the south and part to the north. The north
side was in no way affected by the explosion. The air goes round the north and up
No. 2, which is an upcast shaft. The air on the south side ventilates the dip headings,
travels on the two south levels to the end of the level, and then goes up the jenny-gate
(or incline). There are two air-doors at the top of the incline to direct the air into the
working faces of the coal on the extreme south of the mine. The air is then brought down
a dip-gate and returns by the face of the workings. It travels the whole of working
'benk' faces, and goes to a heading which communicates with No. 2 pit level. Then
the air goes along the deep level of No. 2 pit to the extremity of the workings on the
south side of No. 2. It then returns on the 'benk' faces to No. 1 gate, down which
it goes to the cupola. It travels about 2,000 yards from the starting point to the cupola.
The coal is three feet thick along the working faces. The gobbing is eight feet from the
face on the average. Supposing the working faces to be clear, there would be 29 feet
area of airway. Eight inches of floor is taken up nearly all the way along. Practically
there is 29 feet of airway all along. If there was any coal down it would interfere with
the area of the airway. The air that goes through No. 1 is the only air that supplies
the south side of No. 2. The bodies of Martin, Wood, Hall, Lowe, and Briggs were
found at the bottom of No. 4 gate of No. 1 pit ; Alcock and Clarke at the bottom of
No. 5 gate. Savage, Layking, and Watson at the bottom of No. 7 gate, within it ;
John Bolsover at the end of the south level ; Potas, 300 yards up the incline road or
jenny gate ; Billam was found at the back of the drum in the jenny-gate ; Mark Barber,
Rhodes, and Richardson were found on the level leading south from the top of the jenny
gate ; David Wainwright was found at the bottom of the dip gate ; George Webster,
Arthur Ellis, and Cutley were found in the benk. Thomas Goodwin, who died yesterday,
was found at the bottom of No. 4 gate in No. 1 pit. All the above were in No. 1
pit. On the level in No. 2, Goldsworthy was found suffocated. In No. 8 gate Thomas
Lloyd was brought out of the pit alive, but afterwards died from suffocation. In No. 3
gate were found Breeze, John Thorpe, and Webster, all dead from suffocation. In No. 1
gate Pearce was found dead. These six were found in No. 2 pit. Lowe, Briggs, Martin,
Wood, Hall, Alcock, Clarke (fireman), Bolsover, and Goodwin were the only men burnt.
All the rest were suffocated. All those burnt were in the main level. Six of them lay
within 15 yards of each other, Lowe, Briggs, Wood, Martin, Hall, and Goodwin ;
Alcock and Clarke were 80 yards off ; Bolsover was 280 from them. They were all on
the same level. The conditions of an explosion would have been the same to all men on
that level. Lowe, Briggs, and Alcock should have been working up a gate, but they
were found on the level. The fire would certainly be in a much less degree in the
gateways. The ventilation was affected by the explosion, which blew the doors down
wards with one exception. For the time there would be no ventilation. I was down in
the pit after the explosion. I was warned of it between 12 and 1."
Samuel Hardwick said : "I live at Renishaw Park Colliery, of which I am underviewer.
I look after both No. 1 and No. 2 pits. I was in both pits on Saturday, the
7th of January. I was in the north side and part of the south side of No. 1 pit. About
a fortnight ago I was in the level of the south side. I went in at the dip slip, and came
out at the far end of the jenny gate. I could not give you the exact measurement of the
area."
The Coroner : "It appears to be one of your chief duties to do so."
Examination continued : "I don't treat the south level as the main airway. My duties
are to see that all works are kept in a proper going state ; I manage the distribution of
the air in the pit. I have not full control to drive airways, or do anything necessary for
the ventilation of the colliery."
Mr. Evans : "How can you manage the distribution of air if you are not at liberty to
drive airways ? — I have not that permission. Who is responsible for driving the airways?
— Mr. Joseph Wells. He directs which way the ventilation is going to be, and I carry it
out. There is no book kept at the colliery office where the daily state of the pit is
entered. There may be a book at the general pay office, but I haven't seen it. I have
a copy of the rules. I know rule 95 which says that the daily condition of the mine must
be entered in a book at the colliery office. I have not obeyed it. There are two firetriers,
who examine the workings in No. 1 pit. Francis Clarke was the night fireman.
It is his duty to report the state of the workings to the day fireman, Thomas Hardwick,
who succeeds him. Clarke goes twice every night to places where men are working, and
to mark on the gateroad ends and all the places where men are at work. The day and
night firemen meet at the engine-road. They have no written communication, only
verbal. The day fireman then goes through all the workings and reports to me at night
if anything special wants to be done. He does not make a report if nothing is wanting. If
the night fireman reports a small quantity of gas to the day fireman, or vice versa, I don't
always hear of it. I believe there is a rule which makes it necessary that all the parts of
the colliery shall be inspected at certain times. It is rule 16. I could not say that
anyone travelled through the south level a week before the accident. My brother told
me he had been through. The air that ventilates No. 2 shaft has had to pass through
the side of No. 1 pit. There is a 12 to 14 feet area of airway along the bank faces
which ventilates both pits. It is about 600 yards long. Rather more than half the men
are at work on the south side of the two pits — perhaps 300. There are 15 horses in
No. 1 pit, and 14 in No. 2 pit. The men in No. 2 pit were all suffocated. The men at
the bottom of No. 5 were burnt. Bolsover also was burnt. I have been in the pit since
the explosion, and examined the place where it took place. I think it occurred about
20 yards beyond the bottom of No. 4 gate — the place where the shot was fired. That
was in the main level. The results of the explosion show plainly along the level that the
explosion took place at that place where there is most destruction of corves and timber
and the falls of roof are most prominent. The damage extends about 108 yards towards
No. 3 gate, and about 670 yards the other way. I think the gas which exploded was
four yards from where the shot was fired. It had probably accumulated behind some
timber in the roof which was covered with slabs. There was a vacuum about 18 inches
or 2 feet high by about 6 feet wide. I think the gas was there, and the shot having
disturbed the timber, the powder fired the gas, and caused the explosion. There was
an overcharge of powder."
Mr. Evans : "There must have been two explosions according to your theory ? — Yes,
but no man's ear could have distinguished them. There was little or no damage to the
timber in the roof at the place where the vacuum was. The airway in the main level is
6 feet by 5 feet 6 inches., Near the place the airway is 5 feet 2 or 4 inches by 5 feet.
I don't think the narrow place would offer great resistance. There is a great weight on
the timber, and they are very firm. No gas was reported to me the day before the
explosion. There are no signs of fire on the timbers. There are great marks of violence
both on the bottom and tops of the incline or jig-brow. The point of the incline is
about 608 yards from where the shot was fired. There is no more violence along the
incline than there is back along the level. The lower main level terminates a little
beyond the jenny gate, where it is blocked up. I am at a loss to account for there being
more damage in the jenny gate than in the level. I can't say what Portas was doing
there."
William Keeton said : "I live at Marsden Moor, and am a lamp-cleaner at No. 1 pit.
I was there on the night of the explosion. I gave the lamps between 7 and 8 o'clock.
I can't say exactly how many — about 70. All were locked, clean, and in good condition,
to the best of my knowledge. The lamps of the firemen were not locked. They had
keys. I gave out Clanny and Davy lamps. As near as I can remember I gave out
about a dozen Davy lamps. The rest were Clanny."
By Mr. Evans : "I think the whole of the 70 lamps have not been returned. All that
came in while I was there were locked, except one which was rather loose. Some of the
lamps were very much damaged — some of them cut in two."
By the Coroner : "I have not taken any account in a book of the lamps which were
given to each man. I don't know whether it is the practice elsewhere. The lamps are
not numbered."
Henry Cutis said : "I live at Eckington, and am a coal miner. I went into No. 1 pit
on Thursday morning, the 12th of January. I went into the horse level to search for
Bolsover. I found him at the far end of the horse level. He was covered over with a
few stones and small dirt. He was a little burnt, and quite dead. I found his lamp
about a yard from where he lay. It is broken into two pieces. I did not examine it to
see whether it was locked or not. It was a glass lamp. He was lying on his side, with
his head against an old wall, part of which had fallen on him."
Thomas Scott said : "I live at Mosbro'. I am a collier. I was employed as a contractor
for riping the roof in No. 1 pit — ripping means blowing down to make height for
the ponies. We blow down about one yard and a quarter. We blow with blasting
powder. Some we wedge down. I was in No. 1 pit on the night of the accident."
By Mr. Evans : " There would be 28 or 29 men on the south side pit and 9 or 10 on
the north side of No. 1. Some were tramming, others were doing repairs, and others
ripping. I had men working in No. 9 south. The men working about No. 4 gate level
were not mine. I saw Francis Clarke just before the explosion. He was in No. 12 benk
just where I was — at the west end of No. 1 pit. He followed me to there and told me
he would go on to the far end of the south side — to the benk faces — to see the men who
were working there. I came down towards the pit bottom. There came a regular rush
of smoke as hot as fire — black smoke and dust. The men came rushing on out of the
deep workings, and I went down the south level to No. 3 gateway. I came back to the
bottom then and tried to shut the doors, but they were blown out. I went round all the
working on that side before the explosion. Francis Clarke and a boy were with me.
They were boring a hole near No. 4 gateway — Martin and others. I went on to the end
of the level. There was a shot fired between that time and the explosion. Clarke, the
boy, and myself got there about half-past six. The next time I got there was after
the explosion. I didn't hear the shot go, so I suppose the explosion of the powder
occurred at the same time or just before the explosion of the gas. I only heard one
shock. I should not have heard the explosion of powder if it had occurred when I was
at the extreme rise. I examined the pit that night in every place on the south side, but
found no gas. I mean every working place. I did not walk the lower level all the
way through. We tried it at both ends and in the middle. I was in the middle during
the whole of the time they were getting out the bodies. After the explosion the others
wanted to go, but I stopped them ringing any more up. After the explosion I went to
the north side — to the north jenny — the doors were blown open. I then came back to
the pit bottom, and went along the south level. After that I went to No. 3 passway and
came back again. There was a little bit of stuff down. I waited then for assistance.
Joseph Hardwick, John Smith, and another, went with me to No. 3 gate to prop the
doors up. We reared some doors up at the bottom of the gate to turn the ventilation
forward. We went a little further to No. 3 gate where we saw Thomas Goodwin lying
just on the top side of the level. I went to the bottom again to send some more help,
and left my two mates with Goodwin. Samuel and Thomas Hardwick then came down
to the shaft and I went with them on the south level again to the bottom of No. 7 gate.
Meanwhile, Goodwin had been removed to No. 1 pit-top. We could not get any further
for the after-damp. We came back to the bottom, and got some straw and clothes to
make a stoppage at the bottom of each gate-road, so that we could get on. We put
temporary stoppings, and Thomas Hardwick and I went to the end of the level and up
the jenny. We found Portas near the top of the jenny. We found Billam near the
drum ; Mark Barker and Rhodes on the south level ; David Wainwright on the side of a
benk face ; John Ellis, 'Irish Jack,' Webster and another man named 'Thomas,' a little
further on. We helped to get them out, and then came out of the pit. We found a
man who I believe to be George Webster a little before I saw Goodwin ; the latter was
alive, but the others were all dead. We found nine up the jenny ; one at the bottom ;
three in No. 7 gate ; and the rest were at bottom of No. 4 gate. I can't say how many.
When we saw they were dead, we left them for others to take out, and went on."
By the Jury : "I am not a deputy. Francis Clarke was deputy. It is not my
duty to go round the workings except where I had men at work. I did not send a son
of Samuel Hardwick to do work that I ought to have done. A shot might have been
fired, and I might not have heard it."
By Mr. Evans : "We found a great number of lamps."
By Mr. Wells : "If a shot had been fired in the pit I ought to have smelt the powder smoke."
By Mr. Evans : "The shot might have been fired without my knowing it. I might
have been in many places without hearing or smelling it."
By the Jury : "I never send anyone to do my work. It would take the men from
two or three hours to drill a hole in the roof. They should drill it a yard and an inch or
two. I take the work by contract."
By the Coroner : "The fire to fire the shot is got out of the Davy lamp by means of
a wire by the charge-man — the man who bores the hole. The wire gets red hot, and he
applies it to the fuse. Benjamin Martin was charge-man."
Samuel Hardwick, who, by the direction of the Coroner, had been to the pit to
measure the airways, said : "I have been this morning to the extreme end of the workings.
There was not sufficient air to turn the anemometer, because the ventilation has not yet
been thoroughly restored. It requires 100 cubic feet per minute to turn the instrument.
I can't give the quantity that was going into the south level at the time of the accident.
On the south side 10,640, and on the north side 9,520 feet per minute, is an estimate of
the ventilation of Nos. 1 and 2 pits on Saturday."
By Mr. Potter : "The pit was perfectly safe a fortnight before the accident. We
never have found gas beyond No. 4."
By Mr. Evans : "No report was made of the furnace to me on Tuesday night. There
is some weight on account of the extent of the workings. There are a few slips, but no
faults."
By Mr. Busby : "There are no daily records kept. I only go in the mine occasionally.
There may be gas without my knowing anything about it."
The Coroner said that there appeared to have been an admitted neglect of one of the
principal rules of the colliery. Gas might have accumulated without the last witness
knowing it, and it appeared to him (the Coroner) that he (witness) was responsible.
Thomas Hardwick said : "I live at the Rose and Crown Inn, Eckington, and am under-deputy
at the Renishaw Park Colliery. I keep the public-house. I was in No. 1 pit at
six o'clock in the morning of the 10th inst., and stayed there till the far end of the
afternoon — about four o'clock. I went through the workings of No. 1 pit. To the
north first, and then through the south. The ventilation was "much as usual." I have
nothing to do with No. 2 pit. I went along the low level of the south side in the fore
noon. I came out in the dips. I left a mark in the low level to show that I had been
there. I made a mark at the entrance, in the middle, and in the end."
By the Jury : "I don't send anyone to go in my place. When I am out a man is put
in my place."
By Mr. Evans : "I have been away a couple of days during the last fortnight. I ask
my brother for permission to go away, so that he may get someone to do my work. I
can't say whether the furnace-man was drinking at my house on the night of the accident
or not. I know he ought to have been on duty."
William Barker, furnaceman, said : "I live at Eckington, and am furnaceman at the
cupola. I was at home poorly at night. I took a walk down the village. I went into
the Rose and Crown, and had one pint in the morning. I live opposite the Rose and
Crown. No beer was brought to our house that night. I didn't feel well enough to go
to work. I had no chance of sending."
Thomas Scott (recalled) said : "Benjamin Martin ought to have superintended the firing
of the shot. A man named Wood helped him. Martin would point out where the hole
was to be bored. It was a proper place for that purpose."
Samuel Hardwick (recalled) said : "I don't know that I have given any special orders
except what are given by rule." The Coroner then read the rule requiring permission of
the underviewer to be obtained before the shot was fired in places where safety lamps
were used (Rule 38). Witness : "I directed Francis Clarke to take the roof down.
Martin was acting under my general orders."
By Mr. Evans: "We have been taking down the low places for the last three months.
Scott, in answer to Inspector Hallam : "A powder bottle, which contained five or six
pounds of powder, was behind a puncheon, about 10 or 12 yards from the shot. I don't
know how much powder was used. Martin was a competent man."
By the Jury : "The quantity of powder depends on the stuff to be blown down."
By Mr. Evans : "I can't say whether the powder bottle was full or not when it went
down the pit."
John Tindall said : "I am a coalminer, and live at Eckington. I was in the dips in
No. pit on the night of the accident. I noticed a shock about 20 minutes to 11. It
was a stopping of the air. I heard nothing. I felt a drumming in the ear as though
I was turned deaf. I heard no noise of an explosion."
By Mr. Evans : "I knew the time, because we looked at a watch shortly afterwards.
I only felt one shock."
By the Jury : "I am sure it was before eleven o'clock. We stayed a little "while" the
bad air cleared. I left Scott in the pit when I left. I went out in about a quarter of an
hour after I got to the pit bottom."
The following witnesses, Messrs. Bainbridge, Appleby, and Cooper were called by the
owners to describe their Inspection and give their opinions as to the cause of the
accident :—
Mr. Emerson Bainbridge said : "I live at Sheffield, and am a mining engineer and coal
owner. I examined No. 1 pit on Thursday morning. Mr. Appleby, Thomas Hardwick,
and I went along to where the shot was fired. In passing along I examined the timber
and the corves. I also examined the broken doors in Nos. 4 and 5 gates. I passed from
there to the bottom of the jenny where Bolsover was found. I saw the broken corves
and the falls of stones there. I passed up the jenny, and noticed that the "rapper" wire
was broken. The jenny was about 350 yards long. I noticed three or four falls of stone.
At the top of the jenny and on the drum I saw 12 empty corves, which had been
crushed against the drum and had displaced it a few inches. This was the last point at
which I saw any of the effects of the explosion. We went from there to the face of the
coal above the drum. There was no effect visible there. I thought the area of airway
against the face was at least 24 feet. Behind the face there are several packs of stone
supporting the roof, and it is only where the packs occur that the area is only 24 feet.
As far as I could judge, the fire of the explosion went half way up the jenny gate on the
south side and not further up than No. 3 gate on the north side. I gathered from this
and the amount of damage done that the explosion was very slight. I was surprised
that so many deaths could occur in No. 2 pit — a distance of 2,000 yards from the
place where the explosion is supposed to have occurred. I think the explosion was
caused simultaneously with the firing of the shot. I think it took place somewhere
between the place where the shot was fired and the spot where Bolsover was found.
I should think nearer the latter place. My first impression was that it occurred
near the timber where the shot was fired, but as that was neither damaged nor
singed, and as I don't think there could have been more than 150 cubic feet of gas
above the timber, I cannot understand how the explosion could have occurred there. On
the other hand, by far the strongest effects of the explosion are visible in the jenny
gate — at the bottom — along the road and at the top. I don't think the flame from the
shot fired the gas. As a general rule such a flame only extends 15 yards. The blast
caused by the expansion of the air at the time of the explosion of the shot, which has
apparently been too strong, was sufficient to fire the gas in a locked lamp. I think it
did do so, unless one of the lamps was unlocked, of which we have no evidence. As the
low level was examined that night, I can't imagine where the gas came from. My
knowledge of the pit is not sufficient to enable me to judge whether the arrangements in
the pit were satisfactory or otherwise."
By Mr. Evans : "Thomas Hardwick was with us. I should think Hardwick is better
capable of judging the extent of the airway, as he has walked all along the face and I
have not. As a mining engineer I do not consider it right that in collieries of this size
the air which has already gone through one colliery should be allowed to ventilate
another. Assuming the explosion to have taken place in the jenny gate, and a direct
current of air sent into No. 2 pit from the downcast shaft, I think there would be a
probability of the lives of some of the men being saved. The whole of the stone broken
down by the shot is broken into very small fragments, and an ordinary shot would not
have done that. If a manager of a colliery finds a certain system of ventilation to
answer the purposes of the colliery, he is justified, in my opinion, in continuing it."
Mr. Charles Edward Appleby said : "I am a coal owner, and live at Barlbro'.
I accompanied Mr. Bainbridge on Thursday morning. I examined the level where the accident
occurred. I went with him and Thomas Hardwick to the far end of the working level.
At the jenny as far as the face was worked, and for a certain distance along the face of
the work, at the entrance of a new level-gate. We returned and met Mr. Evans and
party, and then proceeded back with them again. The result of my inspection would be
the same as that given by Mr. Bainbridge. The force of the explosion in itself does not
appear to have been very great, because no props or other timber were removed. There
was loose material blown along the roads. Where it came against any resistance, and
only then, would it do damage. The greatest force was expended at the bottom of the
jenny-gate and at the top where the drum is fixed. Near the place where the shot was
fired the effect seemed considerably less. The fact of the men being burnt on the level
only seems to point out that the explosion occurred in the vicinity where the shot was
fired. I am rather inclined to the opinion that it occurred further along the level than
where the shot was fired, because the traces of it seemed to grow as we went along the
level, and to lessen in the direction of the shot. I feel certain it was the result of the
firing of the shot — that is the indirect. result of it. The explosion of the shot liberated
some gas, which it afterwards, though almost simultaneously, fired."
Mr. P. Cooper said : "I live at the Holmes, near Rotherham. I am a colliery viewer
and manager for the Rotherham, Masbro', and Holmes Coal Company. I examined the
south side of No. 1 pit on the day after the explosion. We passed along the south level
and found evidence of the effects of an explosion. The corves for the most part of that
level had been forced inwards. There was very little timber displaced. There was no
charring. One side was unusually covered with dust as if it had been forced against it.
In the openings on the right all the evidence we could find indicated that the force of the
explosion proceeded upwards from the level and inwards into the mine. I was exceedingly
surprised to find these effects, as in explosions we generally find the force to come
out of the interior of the colliery ; and also because the explosion appears to have occurred
in one of the safest places in a mine — in one of the main airways. The tendency of an
explosion is to go against the air current. There were no indications to show that the
explosion had passed through the slits into the horse level out of the low level. The
evidence indicated that the explosion was not violent. The full corves were but little
moved. There was no question it was an explosion of firedamp, but it is most difficult to
account for its existence under such circumstances. I should think it the most unlikely
place in the colliery. I don't think it is an ordinary case. I think it is possible that
there might have been firedamp above the timber, but not sufficient to cause the explosion.
I think that the firedamp is passing off constantly. I don't think that it would always
be detected. I think in a colliery where gas is discharged that the ventilation is sufficient.
I think that the airways in No. 1 pit were sufficient to ventilate that pit. I cannot say
whether they are sufficient for No. 2 without examining. I think the second colliery is
placed at decided disadvantage as far as the ventilation is concerned. The upper pit
(No. 2) has been in work about 10 years, and the other about two years before. The
lower pit was formerly ventilated by a brattice. The system was altered in 1863."
Mr. Earl, surveyor and colliery agent, said: "I live at Chesterfield. I have just been
down to the colliery to measure the air which goes to the dip workings. I find in the
deep level about 12 square feet of area, and in that about 3,180 feet of air passing per
minute. At the bottom of the jenny gate and the slit from the deep level to the counter
level I measured. I find there an area of 16 feet 8 inches. There was not pressure of
air sufficient to turn the anemometer at that point, although there was air passing. The
cause was that the gates were not repaired. I didn't measure the place where some one
said they crawled through. I didn't measure the area on the benk faces."
Thomas Evans, Esq., was examined, and said : "I am one of Her Majesty's Inspectors
of Mines, and the Renishaw Park Colliery is in my district. I made an inspection of the
underground workings in company with Messrs. Appleby, Hardwick, and others on 12th
January. I found evident signs of an explosion of gas commencing at or near the entrance
to gate No. 3, continuing along the level, and exhibiting greater violence up the incline
or "jenny." From my inspection, and from the evidence I have heard here today, I
believe the explosion took place at the bottom of the inclined plane or "jenny ;" and for
this reason, that from this point the tubs, the signal wire, and other things appear to have
been blown up the hill, one of the tubs having been carried over the drum at the top of
the incline. There were a great many "falls of roof" along the level back from No. 8
towards No. 4, and I think there are as many indications of blowing outwards toward
the downcast as inwards. The quantity of air said to pass along the south level about
10 feet from the downcast was 10,600 per minute, and this had to ventilate the whole
of the south sides of Nos. 1 and 2 Pits. At each of the gate-roads in work there
would be some leakage of air, and this is necessary to keep them free from gas. At the
end of the level the quantity would be very much less than at the point where it was
measured. The lower level referred to is nearly closed up at places ; there would consequently
be very little air passing along it. I think it very likely that the shot which
you have evidence of displaced some gas in the lower level, and that it fired at the first
defective lamp or open light. I do not agree with Mr. Cooper when he says that this
point is the least likely place for an explosion to occur, and I feel satisfied the explosion
of the powder, or rather the flame from it, did not explode the gas. If it took place
where Hardwick says it did, there would have been some damage done to the timber used
at that point for supporting the roof, whereas the props here are as good as when they
were first put there. Bolsover was employed in cleaning the road, and while so engaged
his lamp would probably be standing on the floor. It is possible it might have been
damaged by a fall or otherwise, and the gas coming in contact with it would cause the
explosion."
"I consider the quantity of air was very much too small for the ventilation of these
extensive mines, and its distribution most imperfect."
"The south side of No. 1 pit ought to have had a separate split of air, which should
have had no connexion with the workings in No. 2 pit. Had this been so the bad effects
of the explosion would not have been felt in the rise workings. The discipline in the pit
was most lax ; gas might be given off, as you have heard in evidence, without the underviewer
knowing anything whatever about it. And the manager, Mr. Joseph Wells seldom
or never goes into the colliery."
"I agree with Mr. Cooper and the other gentlemen that there was not a very large
quantity of gas, but still it was a sharp explosion, and if the air had been split, as I
contend and distinctly state that it ought to have been, the unfortunate men in the upper
pit (some two thousand yards from the point of the explosion) would have been saved.
I have frequently advised the owners to employ a competent mining engineer to advise
them, and to be responsible for the safety of the workmen."
The Coroner, in summing up, said, "The jury had very patiently listened to the evidence
in this lamentable case, which he (the Coroner) had heard very carefully for reasons
independent of the present inquiry. He had not in any way shortened it, as he was
desirous that they should have every detail before them which could throw any light on
the cause of the explosion — resulting as it did in the loss of so many lives. But really
the points for their consideration were very limited indeed, and he would simply direct
their attention to those facts which would materially influence their verdict. The main
features to be considered were the engineering and the discipline of the mine. No doubt
it was, and it might be, a very serious question under the regulations of the Mines'
Inspection Act whether the ventilation, the engineering, and the discipline of the mine
had been carried on in the most intelligent way as they ought to have been, and with a due
regard to the safety of the men. For proved negligence in these matters Government
had provided certain civil — and in some instances criminal — remedies, to ensure compliance
with the policy of the Acts ; and the question whether this mine was or was not
conducted on the best principles was a matter to be considered by them. Such inquiries
were useful in directing public attention to the manner in which any great colliery is
carried on, and in preventing a recurrence of those causes which brought about calamities
such as the one they were discussing. But unless they could show a criminal negligence
on the part of the colliery proprietors, such matters were scarcely for their consideration,
and would have no influence upon their verdict. So far as the death of these unfortunate
men had arisen from any laxity or breach of discipline on the part of the officials
of the colliery, who might or might not have neglected their duties — it was for the jury
to say whether or not such men were criminally responsible for their negligence ; and
however outside the question it might be, he was bound to remind them that there had
been admissions and suggestions of a breach of the rules of the colliery, although it did
not appear that such a neglect caused the death of the men, except so far as a want of
discipline either relatively or nearer might be said to do so. He was also bound to tell
them that when a man accepted a dangerous situation, he accepted it with all the risks
and dangers attendant upon it, and he was bound to see that the rules were enforced for
his own safety, and to take care that he did not enter into any contract dangerous to
himself. Even though a colliery be under bad discipline, and bad engineering, and
without sufficient intelligence on the part of its officials, unless it could be shown that the
death of the men had resulted from criminal negligence on the part of those officials,
it was no concern of theirs in arriving at a verdict. There was of course the civil remedy
for damages, but it was no part of his (the Coroner's) duty to point out any course in
that matter. The man who undertook a dangerous contract, took upon himself the loss
attendant upon such a contract, in the shape of its dangers, and appropriated all profits —
in the shape of wages — which might accrue on the other hand." — The Coroner then proceeded
carefully to review the leading points of the evidence which had been adduced,
remarking that "the cause of the escape of the gas was a matter which was not, and
probably could not ever be ascertained. It was, however, a material point in their
inquiry, whether the explosion was caused by the shot or not. It did not appear that the
man who fired the shot, or any of the 77 men working in the mine, were not in the performance
of other duties, when the explosion took place, resulting as it did, not entirely
but incidentally from the firing of the shot, whereby some men were burnt and others
were suffocated. The probable cause was far too remote to fix it upon any one in the
mine. It was for the jury to decide whether some of the officers of the mine, who had
admitted that they had not strictly performed their duties in obedience to the rules, were
guilty of negligence or not ; but the question whether the accident would have been
prevented if greater care had been used, was far too remote to enter into their consideration
at the present time. Their purpose was to see whether the men had come to
a violent death through the criminal negligence of any one, or otherwise. In his opinion,
there was not sufficient evidence to point to a criminal negligence on the part of anyone,
and on the other hand, it was no part of his duty to suggest that anyone was civilly
responsible. In conclusion, he observed that it remained with the jury to decide whether
the men met with their death through an accidental explosion of gas in a coal-mine,
or not."
After a retirement of about a quarter of an hour, the jury returned, and the foreman
(Mr. Rotherham) delivered the following verdict:— "It is our unanimous opinion that
the deaths were accidental ; but at the same time we recommend that a stricter supervision
should be exercised by the underviewers."
The Coroner : "I think it unfortunate that the deputy of a colliery should keep a public
house. It leads both him and the men into habits likely to create a laxity in the
discipline of the colliery, which ought to be as strict as military discipline. I feel bound
to take this opportunity of making such a remark."