Cam Hay Accident
Extracted from the Annual Mines Inspectors Report for 1859
Report of Henry Gordon Longridge (page 93)
No. 66. George Walker, John Walker, and William Haines, Cam Hay Colliery. This
was an explosion of firedamp causing the death of three men and injury to others. That
the want of proper ventilation was the cause of this accident cannot be doubted by the
evidence taken at the first coroner's inquest, and the ground bailiff, Mr. Samuel Green,
was committed for manslaughter: the second inquest returned a verdict of accidental
death. At the Stafford assizes the bill was ignored, and so this portion of the case rested :
there had however, been an explosion about five or six weeks previous to this, which
caused serious personal injury. Acting under the supposition, under Rule 9, that in such
a case notice should be sent to the inspector, I took proceedings against Messrs. Underhill
for not sending notice, and obtained a conviction at Wolverhampton court. A case was
applied for and granted, and the conviction quashed.
Extracts from Notes of Evidence given at Inquest held at Bloxwich, June 27th, 1859, before
A. A. Fletcher, Esq., Coroner, and in the presence of H. G. Longridge, Esq. (Her Majesty's
Inspector of Mines for South Staffordshire and East Worcestershire), on the bodies of
John Walton and George Walker.
William Buckles, examined by the coroner, deposed:— I live in Sneyd Lane, Bloxwich, and am
a miner, working for George Rowbottom, at Mr. Underhill's collieries, Sneyd Lane. I have worked
there one month. I have been a collier five years, during which time I have worked in several mines.
I was at work on Thursday, the 16th of June, in one of the pits of the Sneyd Lane Colliery when, at
about four o'clock in the afternoon, an explosion of gas took place, by which means John Walton and
George Walker were killed. The former died at half-past eight on Friday morning, and the latter at
half-past seven on Saturday night. The explosion was caused, in my opinion, by the firing of two
shots or blasts. The two shots were fired almost at the same moment, and instantly after the
last shot the explosion took place. About six weeks from the present time an explosion of gas took
place in the same pit, at which time also six or seven workmen were badly hurt, but none of them
were killed. At the last explosion six men were seriously injured and two have died. I consider the
cause of the explosion to have been the imperfect ventilation of the pit. The workmen employed in
the pit knew there was a collection of sulphur in the pit, and had complained to the butty of it, and
the butty complained of it to Mr. Green, the ground bailiff, but he would not allow the butty to adopt the
course which he considered necessary for proper ventilation of the pit, though the butty perfectly described
the course he considered necessary. Green objected to the course the butty considered necessary,
because by following it very little coal would be got ; he said he must have coals to supply the sale,
and therefore ordered another plan to be worked, by which no improvement in the ventilation would
take place. Mr. Rowbottom has several times requested Mr. Green to allow him to drive a head for the
purpose of ventilating the pit, and on these several occasions he represented to Mr. Green the
dangerous condition of the pit from the accumulation of sulphur. It is my opinion that had the butty's
advice been followed by Mr. Green, no explosion would have taken place. The unsafe condition of
the pit from the accumulation of sulphur was well known and was complained of. The distance of
the way end from the air was very short. The blind side is about 38 yards, and the men were about
three or four yards down the blind side when the explosion took place. The shots were fired about
four yards from the way end. The holes for the shots were punched by George Walker and John
Walton. They did not punch them in the dark, but had an open candle, not a safety lamp. It was
Walker's son who told me that they punched the holes. Walton fired his shot, and Walker the
other. I was working down below where they were, and in the blind side till breakfast time. I was
cogging about eight yards from the way end. There was a little sulphur then. I was working with
a naked candle, and did not leave the work because of sulphur. Eight yards from the way end it
was holed. The troughs were put down for air, and were pulled up as the workmen advanced. I
complained of the sulphur in the pit to John Walton. He said there was a little, but did not object to
go to work. I was working about 100 yards from where the explosion took place. There was no
sulphur where I was working. I can tell when there is sulphur in the pit by my candle. There
are safety lamps, but they do not use them. I never saw the doggy take the safety lamp into the pit.
I heard Rowbottom say, that the sulphur came out of the gob after it was broken down. I never
heard Green and Rowbottom have any conversation, but I have seen them going down the pit I
have only seen a safety lamp used once since I have worked at the pit. I have heard complaints
that it was not used. There are two pairs of doors in the pit, and about 100 yards from the pit
bottom. There is no one to watch the doors.
By Mr. Longridge:— I went down to work at six o'clock in the morning, going with the second
handful. He was in the works when I went down, and I did not see him with the safety-lamp.
He did not tell me the pit was safe. I did not notice the fire in the shaft as I went down, but I
know there was a fire in it I felt the heat as we went by it, but I cannot say what sort of a fire it
was; generally it was good. When I was at work in the morning I saw a tail on the top of my
candle, and I knew there was a deal of sulphur in the mine. We did not leave the place to seek the
doggy. I was not burnt; I was in the air-way a hundred yards from where the explosion occurred.
I cannot tell how the doors were standing. The air is forced in by pipes and air-troughs. The
butty was not in the pit that morning, though he is down most mornings.
Henry Gordon Longridge, Esq., deposed: I am Her Majesty's Inspector of coal mines for
South Staffordshire and Worcestershire. I received notice on the 18th of June of the explosion which
had occurred on the 16th, and I went down the colliery the same day. I found a considerable
accumulation of gas or sulphur on the blind side, and also on the air-way side, where a portion of the
top coal had fallen, and part of the robbins had come down with it. At both these places it fired in
my safety lamp. I again visited the colliery on the 23rd June, having called in the assistance of
Mr. Brough, the late inspector of the district, with the sanction of the Secretary of State. I may as
well state that I had stopped the working of the pit till such time as I had made another examination
of it, and it was stopped from the 18th to the 23rd by my orders. On the 23rd we still found these
large accumulations of sulphur. I also found that the air-pipes or troughs, which should have aired
this blind side up as far as the fault, were not carried farther than the main air-way, and hence the
whole of the blind side had no ventilation. Two shots or blasts had evidently been fired to bring
the coal down ; and in my opinion the firing of the sulphur took place from a naked candle being
taken in after the concussion of the powder explosion and fall of coals had mixed the sulphur with
the atmospheric air coming down from the other side of the work. Had an air heading been driven
through from the end of the blind side, as was proposed a sufficient ventilation might have been
obtained to have avoided an explosion. The air-doors of the pit are single, and the neglect of one
of those might occasion the mine to foul and become dangerous. The fire in the shaft for the
purpose of ventilation is too small, and in a dangerous position, because the coals might fall off it on
to the heads of the workmen ascending or descending the shaft.
By the Foreman : When I visited the colliery on the 18th I went through all the workings on the
blind side, as well as the side where the former explosion took place. I had never heard of that
explosion, or even of the colliery being in existence until my visit on the 18th. There was no air
whatever in the blind side; whereas, if they had driven the heading through they would have had a
sweeping current of air. The grate in the shaft was not the size of a good kitchen grate ; for a pit
like that it ought to have been not less than four feet frontage and two feet deep. The opinion I
gave as to the sulphur being fired by a naked candle was simply an opinion. It was natural that
after the blasts the men would go back to see how much they had brought down, and then the
sulphur brought down by the concussion would be fired by the candle. It had been said that the
"garman," or fuze, had been blown into the goaf, but from the position in which the shots were
placed it would have gone into the air-way rather than there. The troughs were laid through the
door, and within four feet of where they were getting the coal. I think they are opening the pit in a
proper manner, but I should have had the air-heading driven through before working the side.
Troughs are liable to be crushed by falling coal, but they might have been laid under the face as
they went along. It would be the doggy's duty to attend to the laying down of these troughs. It
was the duty of the ground bailiff to provide them; and there was a sufficient quantity of air-troughs
in the pit. It was the butty's duty to order them to be put in, or the doggy's to see that they were
put in. I make no charge against the bailiff for the want of air-troughs. It is the bailiff's duty to
provide the grate in the shaft. I did not stop the working of the pit longer than the 23rd; I told
them they might go on upon their own responsibility. They proposed to put in a larger furnace and
fresh air-pipes. I had no power to close it longer. Of course, if any other accident happens, they
will still be responsible. I do not know whether they have done the work they spoke of. The
ground bailiff went down with me on the 23rd, but the butty refused to go, though he went down
on the 18th.
The Coroner having informed the Jury that the butty was present, and that they might ask him
some questions if they pleased, although what he might say would not be evidence.
Mr. Longridge suggested, that if he were called in he should be cautioned that he was not
bound to say anything that might criminate himself.
The butty, George Rowbottom, was accordingly called in, and having been duly cautioned,
deposed as follows:—
By Mr. Longridge. — It is not my practice to go down the pit every morning; I leave it with the
doggy. There were no air-pipes or troughs in the blind side when the explosion happened. If we
had had an air-head driven from the fault to meet the other, this would have given a free air course.
That was not done, because the bailiff would not let me do it. On the Tuesday before the accident
I named it to Mr. Green. If what I recommended had been done, there would have been air all
round; I will not say that if it had been done the accident would not have happened. There is a
great deal of sulphur coming out, especially from the robbins. I asked the man if he saw any danger
when he fired the powder, and he said he did not. There was a lamp down the pit.
By a Juror. — I have told Mr. Green it was very dangerous for men to work there. When we
came upon this fault, three weeks to-day, we stopped a day or two until we saw Mr. Green, and then
he would not let us start in the head. He said that when we got a little coal off the air side we would
go to the blind side. In a week or nine days I went to Bilston and asked him to let me put troughs
in, but he denied me again. On the Tuesday before the explosion I for the third time asked him; he
said, "No, you must go on getting a bit of coal." It was his son who then said we must not start
the heading. The blind side is 38 yards long. It was driven with two sets of air-troughs. We
have had one holing off it at the far end. We wanted this trough driven through mostly for air,
though we did want to get on the face of the coal. I cannot tell why Mr. Green would not let me
drive the head. I think we could have agreed as to price. He said he should drive it all one way.
To drive it from the blind side against the fault would not be cheaper, as the one is up and the other
down. One side is as good as the other to drive it on. There would not be less expense on the
blind side. More coal would be got by leaving this headway than by driving it through. I told
him several times that I considered the pit very dangerous it the air-way was not driven through.
The doggy worked the pit under my directions, but I have left him to hole where he thought proper,
to measure all the work, and to work the pit as he thought proper, as I had full confidence in him. I
have had nothing to do with the lamp, but I know that it has been used. Now and then I have
heard of sulphur being in the wastes, but not such as to do much damage. The men never complained
and told me they would not work. The man who left shortly since did so because there was
never a place for him, not because there was too much sulphur. We are now driving down hill at
the head. There is now sulphur in the side.
By Mr. Longridge. — I think the grate in the shaft is not large enough to clear the sulphur away :
I was told there was a good fire in it just before the explosion took place. I asked the doggy if he
perceived anything before he fired the shot, and he said he did not, but as soon as the shot went then
the rush of sulphur came down. The door was open then. The men were not more than eight or
nine yards from where the shots were fired. The coals had been holed down the blind side the day
before.
After the Coroner had summed up, the Jury returned a verdict of manslaughter against Samuel
Green, the ground bailiff.